Transconnector for coupling spinal rods

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6283967
  • Patent Number
    6,283,967
  • Date Filed
    Friday, December 17, 1999
    26 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, September 4, 2001
    24 years ago
Abstract
The present invention is directed to a transconnector for coupling first and second spinal fixation rods or other elongate fixation elements. The transconnector includes a male member, a female member, and a locking member. The male member has a body with a linking element (such as a hook) associated with the lateral end for receiving one of the fixation elements, and a projection on the medial end. The projection includes a recess defined by lateral and medial walls. The female member has a body with a linking element associated with the lateral end for receiving the other fixation element, and a cavity with an opening on the medial end for receiving a portion of the male member projection. The locking member secures the position and orientation of the male member projection portion in the cavity in order to accommodate different separation distances and orientations between the first and second fixation elements. The locking member cooperates with the medial wall of the recess of the projection to prevent uncoupling of the male and female members. The male member may be made as a two component assembly in which the two components can rotate relative to one another for accommodating rod convergence or divergence.
Description




FIELD OF THE INVENTION




The present invention relates to a device for spinal fixation, and in particular to a transconnector for coupling spinal rods, plates, or other elongate members.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




It is often necessary to surgically treat spinal disorders such as scoliosis. Numerous systems for use in spinal correction and fixation have been disclosed. These systems usually include a pair of elongate members, typically either rods or plates, placed along the vertebral column. For the sake of simplicity, the term “rod” is used throughout to refer to any elongate member. Each rod is attached to the spine with various attachment devices. These attachment devices may include, but are not limited to, pedicle screws, plates, transverse process hooks, sublaminar hooks, pedicle hooks, and other similar devices.




It is also well known that the strength and stability of the dual rod assembly can be increased by coupling the two rods with a cross-brace or transconnector which extends substantially horizontal to the longitudinal axes of the rods across the spine. The simplest situation in which a transconnector could be used occurs when the two rods are geometrically aligned. Specifically, the two rods are parallel to each other, i.e. there is no rod convergence or divergence in the medial-lateral direction; the two rods have the same orientation with respect to the coronal plane (viewed in the anterior-posterior direction), i.e. the rods are coplanar from a lateral view; and the two rods are located a uniform distance from each other.




Due to a wide variety of factors, the two rods are rarely three dimensionally geometrically aligned in clinical situations. There are several ways to address the variations of geometrical alignment. First, one or both of the rods can be bent to accommodate the transconnector. However, any bending in either of the rods can adversely affect the fixation to the spine and comprise clinical outcome. Furthermore, the bending can also adversely affect the mechanical properties of the rods. The transconnector can also be bent so that the disturbance to the rod positioning is minimized. As is the case with bending of the rods, the mechanical properties of the transconnector could be compromised.




Transconnectors with some adjustability have been designed to adapt for variations from geometrical alignment. However, most are multi-piece systems that can be difficult to assemble and use in the surgical environment. U.S. Pat. No. 5,980,523 discloses a muti-piece transverse connector for spinal rods that can accommodate converging or diverging rods. However, accidental disassembly of the connector by the surgeon is possible. Even those that are one-piece designs do not allow for adjustments to compensate for all three modes in which there may be variation from geometrical alignment: convergence or divergence, non-coplanar rods, and variability in rod separation distances. For example, U.S. Pat. No. 5,947,966 discloses a device for linking adjacent spinal rods. In one embodiment, the device includes two members that are movable with respect to one another to accommodate different rod separation distances. A pin on one member engages a groove on the other member to provisionally couple the two members, thereby preventing a surgeon from separating the two members. Because the pin is sized to exactly fit the groove, no movement of the pin transverse to the longitudinal axis of the groove is possible. As a result, the device disclosed in the '966 patent cannot accommodate non-coplanar rods or adjust for rod convergence or divergence.




Thus, there exists a need for an improved transconnector for coupling spinal rods.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention relates to a transconnector for coupling first and second elongate spinal fixation elements that have different three dimensional orientations. The transconnector includes a male member, a female member and a locking member and can be made of any suitable material such as titanium, a titanium alloy, or stainless steel. The male member comprises a body with lateral and medial ends, a linking element associated with the lateral end and being configured and dimensioned to receive one of the fixation elements, and a projection on the medial end. The projection includes a body with a recess defined by lateral and medial walls. The female member comprises a body with lateral and medial ends, a linking element associated with the lateral end and being configured and dimensioned to receive one of the fixation elements, and a cavity with an opening on the medial end which is configured and dimensioned to receive a portion of the male member projection. The locking member secures the position and orientation of the male member projection portion in the cavity in order to accommodate different separation distances and orientations between the first and second fixation elements. The locking member interacts with the medial wall of the recess to limit travel of the male member projection portion in the cavity, thereby preventing uncoupling of the male and female members.




Preferably, the locking member comprises a threaded hole in the body of the female member and a set screw threadably received in the threaded hole. The set screw has a first end for receiving a tool to turn the set screw and a second end contactable with the projection for pressing the projection against the cavity. The recess may have a width wider than a width of the second end of the set screw for the rotation of the projection in the cavity. In an exemplary embodiment, the projection has a substantially cylindrical shape with a first radius and the recess has a curved upper surface with a second radius. The first radius is larger than the second radius and the second end of the set screw extends into the recess to limit the rotation of the projection in the cavity. The set screw can be a threaded cylindrical body transitioning to a tip at the second end of the set screw.




The male member body may comprise a link terminal having a lateral end with the male member linking element, an intermediate link having a medial end with the projection of the male member and a lateral end engaging the medial end of the link terminal, and a locking element for securing the link terminal to the intermediate link. Preferably, the medial end of the link terminal includes a first textured surface and the lateral end of the intermediate link includes a second textured surface mating with the first textured surface. The first textured surface is rotatable with respect to the second textured surface for accommodating convergence or divergence between the first and second rods. An example of suitable first and second textured surfaces includes a radial or star-grind pattern.




The locking element preferably comprises a first hole through the medial end of the link terminal, a second hole through the lateral end of the intermediate link aligned with the first hole, and a cap screw insertable in the first and second holes. The cap screw may have a second end with a retaining ring for preventing removal of the cap screw from the second hole. The retaining ring may include a resilient member which flexes inward upon insertion of the cap screw through the second hole and flexes outward once the resilient member is past a collar in the second hole. Preferably, the resilient member includes an end of the cap screw with a lip and a plurality of slits.




If rods are used for the elongate fixation elements, then the male member linking element preferably comprises a hook and the female member linking element preferably comprises a hook. The lateral ends of the male and female members each may include a threaded hole and a clamping screw threadably received in the respective threaded hole for securing the fixation elements to the respective hook. The fixation elements are preferably clamped between a conical second body portion of the respective clamping screw and a region near the tip portion of the respective hook when the transconnector is secured to the fixation elements.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




Preferred features of the present invention are disclosed in the accompanying drawings, wherein similar reference characters denote similar elements throughout the several views, and wherein:





FIG. 1

shows a top perspective view of a transconnector according to the present invention with an elongate fixation element attached at each end;





FIG. 2

shows a bottom perspective view of the transconnector without the fixation elements;





FIG. 3

shows a cross-sectional view of the transconnector with one fixation element attached;





FIG. 4

shows a perspective view of a portion of one embodiment of the male member;





FIG. 5

shows a cross-section of the male member taken through line


5





5


of

FIG. 4

;





FIG. 6

shows a perspective view of the female member of the transconnector;





FIG. 7

shows a side view of the female member;





FIG. 8

shows a side view of a link terminal of the male member with a partial cross section;





FIG. 9

shows a cross-sectional view of an intermediate link of the male member; and





FIG. 10

shows a perspective view of a cap screw used to join the link terminal and intermediate link.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS





FIG. 1

shows a transconnector


10


according to the present invention for coupling a first elongate spinal fixation element


12


to a second elongate spinal fixation element


14


. Transconnector


10


can be made of any suitable material typically used in orthopaedic applications such as titanium, titanium alloy, or stainless steel. If transconnector


10


is made of a metallic material, preferably it is the same metallic material used for fixation elements


12


,


14


to avoid galvanic (mixed-metal) corrosion. First and second fixation elements


12


,


14


can be cylindrical rods, rectangular bars, plates, or any other device suitable for spinal fusion. In use, first fixation element


12


extends along one side of the vertebral column and second fixation element


14


extends along the other side of the vertebral column. A wide variety of attachment devices such as hooks, screws, and clamps, can be used to attach first and second fixation elements


12


,


14


to the spine.




Transconnector


10


includes a male member


16


, a female member


18


, and a locking member


20


. Male member


16


has a body with a linking element


22


on the lateral end for receiving first fixation element


12


and a projection


24


extending from the medial end of the body. Female member


18


has a body with a linking element


26


on the lateral end for receiving second fixation element


14


and a cavity


28


with an opening


30


(

FIGS. 6 and 7

) on the medial end of the body for receiving a portion of projection


24


. Locking member


20


secures the portion of projection


24


in cavity


28


. The portion of projection


24


received in cavity


28


is adjustable for accommodating different separation distances d between first and second fixation elements


12


,


14


. This feature allows transconnector


10


to be readily adjusted for different patient anatomies and used in different regions of the spine. For example, the lumbar vertebrae are typically larger than the thoracic vertebrae. As a result, the distance between fixation elements in the lumbar region would be greater than fixation elements in the thoracic region. Because the length of projection that slides into cavity


28


can be varied, transconnector can be adjusted for use in different spinal regions without the need to bend either fixation rods or transconnector


10


. In order to further increase the adjustability of transconnector


10


, female member


18


, cavity


28


, and projection


24


can be manufactured in different sizes.




Projection


24


is rotatable in cavity


28


for accommodating differences between the angular orientation of first fixation element


12


with respect to the coronal plane and the angular orientation of second fixation element


14


with respect to the coronal plane. Specifically, first fixation element


12


has a longitudinal axis L


1


which runs at an angle α


1


with respect to Line AP


1


, which is perpendicular to plane C, and second fixation element


14


has a longitudinal axis L


2


which runs at an angle α


2


with respect to Line AP


2


, which is also perpendicular to plane C, a plane which divides the body in half from front to back. Because projection


24


can rotate in cavity


28


, transconnector can be used in situations in which α


1


differs from α


2


without the need to bend either fixation element or transconnector


10


.




As seen best in

FIGS. 3

,


4


, and


5


, projection


24


has a substantially cylindrical-like shape and includes a recess


32


defined by lateral and medial walls


34


,


36


. As will be described in more detail below, medial wall


36


of recess


32


forms a stop against locking member


20


to limit travel of projection


24


in cavity


28


, thereby preventing uncoupling of male member


16


and female member


18


. Recess


32


can be formed having a number of different configurations (e.g. a flat planar surface) so long as medial wall


36


contacts locking member


20


before projection


24


is completely removed from cavity


28


and projection


24


can rotate within cavity


28


.

FIGS. 4

,


5


, and


9


show an exemplary embodiment of recess


32


. A portion of an upper surface of recess


32


, defined by angle β, has a reduced radius r


2


compared to the radius r


1


outside of the area defined by angle β. Arcuate surfaces


38


serve as a transition region from reduced radius r


2


to radius r


1


. Radius r


2


and arcuate surfaces


38


can be manufactured using a number of different techniques. For example, they can be machined out by cutting, ball milling, or other milling processes.




As previously noted, locking member


20


secures the portion of projection


24


in cavity


28


.

FIGS. 1

,


3


,


6


, and


7


show that locking member


20


includes a threaded hole


42


in female member


18


and a set screw


44


. Set screw


44


threads into threaded hole


42


and a second end


46


presses projection


24


to clamp it against the walls of cavity


28


. In an exemplary embodiment, set screw


44


comprises a threaded cylindrical body


47


that transitions to a tip at second end


46


. A first end


48


of set screw


44


has an appropriately shaped and sized hole


50


(or a slot) for receiving a surgical instrument like a screwdriver to turn set screw


44


.




As also previously noted, projection


24


can rotate in cavity


28


to accommodate different orientations of first and second fixations elements


12


,


14


. The degree of possible rotation is determined by the geometries of recess


32


and set screw


44


. Specifically, projection


24


can rotate within recess


32


until set screw


44


engages the edges of recess


32


. With respect to the embodiment shown in

FIGS. 4 and 5

, angle θ, which includes the area of angle β and arcuate surfaces


38


, defines the amount of rotation of projection


24


that is possible until second end


46


of set screw


44


engages the edges of recess


32


(that has the larger radius r


1


).




In summary, recess


32


and locking member


20


interact to permit accommodation of non-coplanar rods and variability in rod separation distances. When locking member


20


includes set screw


44


, set screw


44


can be in two basic positions. In the clamped position, set screw


44


is threaded into threaded hole


42


so that second end


46


presses against recess


32


to clamp projection


24


against the walls of cavity


28


. In the un-clamped position, movement of projection


24


within cavity


28


is permitted. The range of movement is limited by contact between set screw


44


and the boundaries of recess


32


. In one embodiment, set screw


44


can be completely removed from threaded hole


42


, thereby allowing projection


24


. to completely leave cavity


28


and complete uncoupling of male and female members


16


,


18


. In another embodiment, set screw


44


is “staked” so that set screw


44


can not come out of threaded hole


42


without an increase in torque. One way to achieve this is by mechanically deforming the first threads of threaded hole


42


so that set screw


44


cannot be unscrewed past the damaged threads. It should also be noted that depending on the relative geometries of the set screw


44


and medial wall


36


, uncoupling of male and female members


16


,


18


may still be possible even without complete removal of set screw


44


from threaded hole


42


regardless of whether set screw


44


is staked.





FIGS. 1

,


8


, and


9


show an exemplary embodiment of the body of male member


16


as a two piece assembly which includes a link terminal


52


, an intermediate link


54


, and a locking element


56


to secure the two together. A lateral end of link terminal


52


has male member linking element


22


and intermediate link


54


has a medial end with projection


24


and a lateral end


58


which engages a medial end


60


of link terminal


52


. Medial end


60


of link terminal


52


includes a first textured surface


62


which mates with a second textured surface


64


of lateral end


58


of intermediate link


54


in such a fashion that first textured surface


62


is rotatable with respect to second textured surface


64


to accommodate for any convergence or divergence between first and second fixation elements


12


,


14


. First and second textured surfaces


62


,


64


are provided with a plurality of teeth, such as a radial or star-grind pattern, in order to help maintain link terminal


52


at the desired angular orientation. Locking element


56


includes a first hole


66


through medial end


60


of link terminal


52


and a second hole


68


through lateral end


58


. First and second holes


66


,


68


align so that a cap screw


70


can be inserted therethrough.




Referring to

FIGS. 8-10

, cap screw


70


has a first end


72


with a slot


74


for receiving a tool to turn cap screw


70


and a second end


76


with a retaining ring


78


for preventing removal of cap screw


70


from first and second holes


66


,


68


. Retaining ring


78


has slits


80


which allow retaining ring to flex inward to be inserted through a collar


82


in second hole


68


. Once retaining ring


78


is inserted past collar


82


, retaining ring


78


flexes back outward so that cap screw


70


can not be completely screwed out of first and second holes


66


,


68


. A body


84


of cap screw


70


is provided with threads


86


which engage threads


88


on the walls of second hole


68


.




The structure of linking elements


22


,


26


will depend on the structure of fixation elements


12


,


14


. For example, if fixation rods


12


,


14


are elongate plates, then linking elements


22


,


26


are configured and dimensioned to receive elongate plates. Such configurations and configurations for other types of fixation elements are well known in the art. If fixation elements


12


,


14


are cylindrical rods as shown in the drawings, then linking elements


22


,


26


each comprises a hook


90


. The lateral ends of male and female members


16


,


18


each includes a threaded hole


92


and a clamping screw


94


threadably received in threaded hole


92


for securing first and second fixation elements


12


,


14


to hook


90


.




As seen best in

FIGS. 2 and 3

, each clamping screw


94


has a first end


96


with a slot


98


for receiving a tool to turn clamping screw


94


, a threaded cylindrical first body portion


100


, and a conical second body portion


102


. Each hook


90


comprises a tip portion


104


and a curved portion


106


. Curved portion


106


has a radius of curvature larger than the radius r of fixation elements


12


,


14


. As a result, the only contact between hooks


90


and fixation elements


12


,


14


is at a region near tip portion


104


. Furthermore, the only contact between clamping screws


94


and fixation elements


12


,


14


is on conical second body portion


102


. Thus, fixation elements


12


,


14


is clamped between conical second body portion


102


and the region near tip portion


104


.




While various descriptions of the present invention are described above, it should be understood that the various features can be used singly or in any combination thereof. Therefore, this invention is not to be limited to only the specifically preferred embodiments depicted herein.




Further, it should be understood that variations and modifications within the spirit and scope of the invention may occur to those skilled in the art to which the invention pertains. Accordingly, all expedient modifications readily attainable by one versed in the art from the disclosure set forth herein that are within the scope and spirit of the present invention are to be included as further embodiments of the present invention. The scope of the present invention is accordingly defined as set forth in the appended claims.



Claims
  • 1. A transconnector for coupling first and second elongate spinal fixation elements that have different orientations, the transconnector comprising:a male member comprising a body with lateral and medial ends, a linking element associated with the lateral end and being configured and dimensioned to receive one of the fixation elements, and a projection at the medial end, the projection including a body with an elongated recess defined by lateral and medial walls and edges; a female member comprising a body with lateral and medial ends and having a threaded hole, a linking element associated with the lateral end and being configured and dimensioned to receive one of the fixation elements, and a cavity with an opening on the medial end which is configured and dimensioned to receive a portion of the male member projection; and a locking member for securing position and orientation of the male member projection portion in the cavity in order to accommodate different separation distances and orientations between the first and second fixation elements, the locking member threadably received in the threaded hole and having a first end for receiving a tool to turn the locking member and a second end contactable with the projection for pressing the projection against the cavity, wherein interaction of the locking member with the medial wall of the recess limits travel of the male member projection portion in the cavity to thereby prevent uncoupling of the male and female members and wherein interaction of the locking member with the edges of the recess limits the rotation of the projection in the cavity.
  • 2. The transconnector of claim 1 wherein the locking member comprises:a set screw.
  • 3. The transconnector of claim 2 wherein the recess has a width wider than a width of the second end of the set screw to permit the rotation of the projection in the cavity.
  • 4. The transconnector of claim 2 wherein the set screw comprises a threaded cylindrical body transitioning to a tip at the second end of the set screw.
  • 5. The transconnector of claim 1 wherein the male member body comprises:a link terminal having a lateral end with the male member linking element and a medial end; an intermediate link having a medial end with the projection of the male member and a lateral end engaging the medial end of the link terminal; and a locking element for securing the link terminal to the intermediate link.
  • 6. The transconnector of claim 5 whereinthe medial end of the link terminal includes a first textured surface; the lateral end of the intermediate link includes a second textured surface mating with the first textured surface; and the first textured surface is rotatable with respect to the second textured surface for accommodating convergence or divergence between the first and second fixation elements.
  • 7. The transconnector of claim 6 wherein the first and second textured surfaces include a star-grind pattern.
  • 8. The transconnector of claim 6 wherein the locking element comprises:a first hole through the medial end of the link terminal; a second hole through the lateral end of the intermediate link aligned with the first hole; and a cap screw insertable in the first and second holes.
  • 9. The transconnector of claim 8 wherein the cap screw has a first end for receiving a tool to turn the cap screw and a second end with a retaining ring for preventing removal of the cap screw from the second hole.
  • 10. The transconnector of claim 9 wherein the cap screw has a body with threads and the second hole is threaded for threadably receiving the cap screw.
  • 11. The transconnector of claim 9 wherein the second hole includes a collar and the retaining ring includes a resilient member, the resilient member flexing inward upon insertion of the cap screw through the second hole and flexing outward once the resilient member is past the collar for preventing removal of the cap screw.
  • 12. The transconnector of claim 11 wherein the resilient member includes an end of the cap screw with a lip and a plurality of slits.
  • 13. The transconnector of claim 1 wherein the male member linking element comprises a hook and the female member linking element comprises a hook.
  • 14. The transconnector of claim 13 wherein the lateral end of the male member and the lateral end of the female member each includes a threaded hole and a clamping screw threadably received in the respective threaded hole for securing fixation elements to the respective hooks of the male and female members.
  • 15. The transconnector of claim 14 wherein each clamping screw has a first end for receiving a tool to turn the clamping screw, a threaded cylindrical first body portion, and a conical second body portion.
  • 16. The transconnector of claim 15 wherein the hook of the male member and the hook of the female member each comprises a tip portion and a curved portion having a radius of curvature larger than that of fixation elements.
  • 17. The transconnector of claim 16 further comprising fixation elements clamped between the conical second body portion of each clamping screw and a region near the tip portion of the respective hook.
  • 18. The transconnector of claim 1 wherein the transconnector is made of titanium, a titanium alloy, or stainless steel.
  • 19. A transconnector for coupling first and second elongate spinal fixation elements that have different orientations, the transconnector comprising:a male member comprising a body with lateral and medial ends, a linking element associated with the lateral end and being configured and dimensioned to receive one of the fixation elements, and a projection at the medial end, the projection including a body with a recess, defined by lateral and medial walls, a female member comprising a body with lateral and medial ends, a linking element associated with the lateral end and being configured and dimensioned to receive one of the fixation elements, and a cavity with an opening on the medial end which is configured and dimensioned to receive a portion of the male member projection; a locking member for securing position and orientation of the male member projection portion in the cavity in order to accommodate different separation distances and orientations between the first and second fixation elements, wherein: interaction of the locking member with the medial wall of the recess limits travel of the male member projection portion in the cavity to thereby prevent uncoupling of the male and female members; the locking member comprises a threaded hole in the body of the female member and a set screw threadably received in the threaded hole and having a first end for receiving a tool to turn the set screw and a second end contactable with the projection for pressing the projection against the cavity; the recess has a width wider than a width of the second end of the set screw to permit rotation of the projection in the cavity; the projection has a substantially cylindrical shape with a first radius and the recess has a curved upper surface with a smaller second radius; and the second end of the set screw extends into the recess to limit the rotation of the projection in the cavity.
US Referenced Citations (69)
Number Name Date Kind
D. 353003 Dinello Nov 1994
2201087 Hallowell May 1940
4085744 Lewis et al. Apr 1978
4257409 Bacal et al. Mar 1981
4269178 Keene May 1981
4361141 Tanner Nov 1982
4369770 Bacal et al. Jan 1983
4404967 Bacal et al. Sep 1983
4422451 Kalamchi Dec 1983
4433676 Bobechko Feb 1984
4641636 Cotrel Feb 1987
4764068 Crispell Aug 1988
4773402 Asher et al. Sep 1988
5005562 Cotrel Apr 1991
5010879 Moriya et al. Apr 1991
5053034 Olerud Oct 1991
5084049 Asher et al. Jan 1992
5102412 Rogozinski Apr 1992
5129388 Vignaud et al. Jul 1992
5176679 Lin Jan 1993
5196014 Lin Mar 1993
5246442 Ashman et al. Sep 1993
5254118 Mirkovic Oct 1993
5261907 Vignaud et al. Nov 1993
5261909 Sutterlin et al. Nov 1993
5275600 Allard et al. Jan 1994
5312405 Korotko et al. May 1994
5330472 Metz-Stavenhagen Jul 1994
5334203 Wagner Aug 1994
5360431 Puno et al. Nov 1994
5395370 Müller et al. Mar 1995
5397363 Gelbard Mar 1995
5437670 Sherman et al. Aug 1995
5439463 Lin Aug 1995
5454812 Lin Oct 1995
5487742 Cotrel Jan 1996
5498262 Bryan Mar 1996
5498263 DiNello et al. Mar 1996
5522816 Dinello et al. Jun 1996
5540689 Sanders et al. Jul 1996
5549607 Olson et al. Aug 1996
5569246 Ojima et al. Oct 1996
5611800 Davis et al. Mar 1997
5624442 Mellinger et al. Apr 1997
5630816 Kambin May 1997
5643260 Doherty Jul 1997
5643262 Metz-Stavenhagen et al. Jul 1997
5643263 Simonson Jul 1997
5662651 Tornier et al. Sep 1997
5667507 Corin et al. Sep 1997
5681312 Yuan et al. Oct 1997
5683393 Ralph Nov 1997
5688272 Montague et al. Nov 1997
5693053 Estes Dec 1997
5697929 Mellinger Dec 1997
5702452 Argenson et al. Dec 1997
5707372 Errico et al. Jan 1998
5709684 Errico et al. Jan 1998
5709685 Dombrowski et al. Jan 1998
5743911 Cotrel Apr 1998
5752955 Errico May 1998
5776198 Rabbe et al. Jul 1998
5800433 Benzel et al. Sep 1998
5928231 Klein et al. Jul 1999
5947966 Drewry et al. Sep 1999
5980523 Jackson Nov 1999
6066142 Serbousek et al. May 2000
6083226 Fiz Jul 2000
6110173 Thomas, Jr. Aug 2000
Foreign Referenced Citations (17)
Number Date Country
0 878 170 A2 Nov 1988 EP
0 446 092 A1 Feb 1991 EP
0 514 303 A1 Nov 1992 EP
0 565 149 A2 Mar 1993 EP
0 676 177 A2 Feb 1995 EP
0 689 799 A1 Jan 1996 EP
0 726 064 A2 Aug 1996 EP
0 737 448 A1 Oct 1996 EP
0 811 357 A1 Dec 1997 EP
0 813 845 A1 Dec 1997 EP
0 836 836 A2 Apr 1998 EP
2 645 427 Apr 1989 FR
2 704 137 Apr 1993 FR
2 740 673 Nov 1995 FR
WO 9408530 Apr 1994 WO
WO 9525473 Sep 1995 WO
WO 9738640 Oct 1997 WO