This application is based upon and claims the benefit of priority from the prior Japanese Patent Application No. 2013-064938 filed on Mar. 26, 2013, the entire contents of which are incorporated herein by reference.
The embodiment discussed herein is related to a transmission apparatus, a transmission system, and a method of controlling average optical input power.
In a wavelength division multiplexing (WDM) optical transmission system, reconfigurable optical add-drop multiplexer (ROADM) apparatuses, each having a function for adding/dropping wavelengths, are connected in multiple stages to achieve long-distance transmission. In order to reduce variations (for example, tilts) among optical power levels for respective wavelengths which are monitored by the ROADM apparatus at a receiving side, a wavelength selective switch (WSS) in the ROADM apparatus at a transmitting side controls the optical power levels for the respective wavelengths to thereby ensure favorable transmission characteristics. Such control is called “pre-emphasis control”.
The ROADM apparatuses are expensive since they include high-cost elements, such as WSSs, in order to implement the add/drop functions. Accordingly, a relay apparatus (an in-line amplifier (ILA)) having only functions for amplifying signals and transmitting the signals is installed in place of a ROADM apparatus at a place where no wavelength add/drop is involved, to thereby construct a network at low cost (see, for example, Japanese Laid-open Patent Publication No. 2000-332686).
However, when an ILA is installed in place of a ROADM apparatus, an optical fiber length between the ROADM apparatuses increases and the span loss also increases. As the span loss increases, a tilt resulting from wavelength dependent loss (WDL) increases. When the magnitude of the tilt exceeds the amount of pre-emphasis control that can be performed by a WSS, it is difficult to install an ILA.
According to an aspect of the embodiments, a transmission apparatus includes: an amplifier controller configured to determine a target value for an average optical input power of a transmitting amplifier in a transmitting-side apparatus, based on an index based on a quality of transmission from an output of the transmitting amplifier to an output of a receiving amplifier in a receiving-side apparatus; and a pre-emphasis controller configured to determine amounts of adjustment of transmission optical powers for respective wavelengths, based on the target value and per-wavelength reception optical powers at the output of the receiving amplifier.
The object and advantages of the invention will be realized and attained by means of the elements and combinations particularly pointed out in the claims.
It is to be understood that both the foregoing general description and the following detailed description are exemplary and explanatory and are not restrictive of the invention, as claimed.
An illustrative network configuration to which an embodiment of the present disclosure is applicable will be described with reference to
The ROADM apparatuses B, C, E, and F illustrated in
In
In this case, the amounts of tilts that occur in the respective sections increase in proportion to span losses depending on the optical fiber lengths in the sections. Thus, when the optical fiber lengths between the adjacent apparatuses are assumed to be the same, the amounts of tilts that occur between the ROADM apparatuses A and D and between the ROADM apparatuses D and G in the configuration in
Even in such a case, application of the embodiment of the present disclosure allows the ILAs to be installed in place of the ROADM apparatuses and also allows a network to be constructed at low cost.
Pre-emphasis control between ROADM apparatuses will now be described with reference to
In
In order to perform the pre-emphasis control, first, the ROADM apparatus C monitors reception optical powers for respective wavelengths (which may hereinafter be referred to as “per-wavelength reception optical powers” and reports them to the ROADM apparatus A. Next, based on the per-wavelength reception optical powers reported from the ROADM apparatus C, the ROADM apparatus A adjusts transmission optical powers for the respective wavelengths. For example, when per-wavelength reception optical powers as illustrated in
For wavelengths at which the reception optical powers at the receiving-side ROADM apparatus C are high, the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus A reduces the corresponding transmission optical powers. This can avoid waveform deterioration due to a nonlinear effect of optical fibers. For wavelengths at which the reception optical powers at the receiving-side ROADM apparatus C are low, the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus A increases the corresponding transmission optical powers, thereby making it possible to minimize deterioration of an optical signal-to-noise ratio (OSNR).
Since the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus A adjusts the transmission optical powers for the respective wavelengths in the manner described above, the reception optical powers monitored by the receiving-side ROADM apparatus C have small variations between the wavelengths, as illustrated in
In this case, transmission optical powers are adjusted for the respective wavelengths in order to equalize the variations in the waveforms of the output powers of the receiving amplifier in the ROADM apparatus C. Thus, the average input power of the transmitting amplifier in the ROADM apparatus A in
As described above, in the pre-emphasis control, a transmitting-side ROADM apparatus adjusts the amounts of attenuation for the respective wavelengths to thereby compensate for the amount of tilt (Δt) detected by a receiving-side ROADM apparatus. Thus, when a maximum variable amount of attenuation of the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus is represented by an amount of pre-emphasis control (ΔPE), it is desired that ΔPE≧Δt be satisfied in order to realize the pre-emphasis control.
Next, a description will be given of how the above-described pre-emphasis control is executed in a ROADM apparatus.
The upper side in
Optical signals received by the ROADM apparatus 301 are amplified by the PreAMP 302, the amplified optical signals are dropped by the SPL 303, the optical signals are added by the WSS 304 for respective wavelengths, the resulting optical signals are amplified by the PostAMP 305, and then the amplified optical signals are transmitted.
The OCM 306 monitors, for the respective wavelength, the powers of reception light output from the PreAMP 302, as described above with reference to
As described above with reference to
Based on the per-wavelength reception optical powers reported from the receiving-side ROADM apparatus 301 and the per-wavelength optical signal powers monitored by the OCM 307 (in the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus 301), the pre-emphasis controller 308 determines, for the respective wavelengths, amounts of attenuation to be applied to optical signals by the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus 301.
In accordance with the amounts of attenuations for the respective wavelengths, the amounts being determined by the pre-emphasis controller 308, the WSS 304 attenuates transmission optical powers for the respective wavelengths. The amount of pre-emphasis control (ΔPE) described above with reference to
Changes in the average optical power in the ROADM apparatus having such a configuration will now be described with reference to graph 310 at the lower side in
The average optical power of optical signals received by the ROADM apparatus 301 first increases by an amount corresponding to a gain of the PreAMP 302 (in 311).
The average optical power is slightly attenuated by propagation when the optical signal is output from the PreAMP 302 and is input to the SPL 303, and is further reduced by an amount corresponding to the amount of loss in the SPL portion by passing through the SPL 303 (in 312).
In the WSS 304, in addition to fixed loss in the WSS portion (in 313), the average optical power is further attenuated by an amount corresponding to attenuation (ATT) loss due to the WSS portion, that is, by the amount of per-wavelength attenuation determined by the pre-emphasis controller 308 (in 314).
Lastly, the average optical power is amplified by the PostAMP 305 and is thus increased by an amount corresponding to a gain of the PostAMP 305 (in 315).
In graph 310 illustrated in
Conversely, in order for the receiving side ROADM apparatus to increase the per-wavelength reception optical powers, the amounts of attenuation due to the WSS 304 are reduced. In this case, the average input power of the PostAMP 305 increases as indicated by arrow 321.
The average input power of the PostAMP is typically set to have a large value in order to increase (improve) the OSNR of the PostAMP 305. Also, the fixed loss in the WSS 304 generally has an invariable value according to a minimum amount of attenuation of the WSS 304. Thus, even when the ATT loss in the WSS portion is set to 0, it is difficult to increase the input power value of the PostAMP 305 to an input power value resulting from addition of the fixed loss in the WSS portion. Thus, since the value of the average input power of the PostAMP 305 is defined by the ATT loss in the WSS portion, an amount by which the amount of attenuation due to the WSS 304 can be reduced is limited. The amount by which the WSS 304 can reduce the amount of attenuation is only a range indicated by arrow 321 in the case in
In the embodiment of the present disclosure, a reduction in the average input power of the PostAMP 305 described above with reference to
The upper side in
The pre-emphasis controller 408 is different from the pre-emphasis controller 308 in
Graph 410 at the lower side in
Similarly to
Similarly to
Accordingly, since the range of the variable amount of attenuation due to the WSS 404 can be increased, the amount of pre-emphasis control ΔPE can also be increased. Since the amount of tilt that can be compensated for is increased as the amount of pre-emphasis control ΔPE increases, the ROADM apparatus 401 may be replaced with an ILA apparatus to increase the transmission distance between ROADM apparatuses. This makes it possible to construct a network at low cost.
As described above, a reduction in the average input power of the PostAMP causes the amount of pre-emphasis control ΔPE to increase. However, since the OSNR of the PostAMP decreases, it is generally difficult to reduce the average input power of the PostAMP.
In the embodiment of the present disclosure, attention is given of the fact that, when the span loss between ROADM apparatuses is large, the influence that a reduction in the average input power of the PostAMP has on the OSNR between the ROADM apparatuses is small.
The OSNR in each section will be described below with reference to
The OSNR of the PostAMP in the ROADM apparatus A is denoted by an OSNR(A), and the OSNR of the PreAMP in the ROADM apparatus G is denoted by an OSNR(G). The OSNR in a section from an output of the PostAMP in the ROADM apparatus A to an output of the ILA b through the optical fibers is represented by an OSNR(b). Similarly, OSNRs in sections including the optical fibers and the ILAs are represented by OSNR(c) to OSNR(f), respectively. An OSNR between the ROADM apparatuses A and G is referred to as an “OSNR in a ROADM section” and is represented by an OSNR(A-G).
The OSNR(A) is invariable since it is determined by the average input power of the PostAMP in the ROADM apparatus A, as given by:
OSNR(A)=Ppost−NF+C (1)
In this case, Ppost indicates the average input power [dBm] of the PostAMP, NF indicates a noise figure [dB] of the PostAMP, and C indicates an invariable value determined by a wavelength band of an optical signal that propagates through the optical fiber.
An OSNR(b-G) represents an OSNR in an ILA section and may be calculated by:
OSNR(b-G)=1/(1/OSNR(b)+1/OSNR(c)+1/OSNR(d)+1/OSNR(e)+1/OSNR(f)+1/OSNR(G)) (2)
The OSNR(A-G) is given by:
OSNR(A-G)=1/(1/OSNR(A)+1/OSNR(b-G)) (3)
Curves 601, 602, and 603 correspond to the OSNR(A), the OSNR(b-G), and the OSNR(A-G), respectively, in
As indicated by curve 602, the OSNR(b-G) decreases as the total span loss in the ILA section increases. When the OSNR(b-G) becomes smaller than the OSNR(A) by a certain amount, for example, becomes smaller by 10 dB as denoted by an up and down arrow, the influence that the OSNR(A) has on the OSNR(A-G) is significantly reduced.
Thus, in such a case, even if the average input power of the PostAMP is reduced, the influence on the quality of transmission in the ROADM section is at an ignorable level. Thus, it is possible to control the average input power of the PostAMP to increase the amount of pre-emphasis control ΔPE, while maintaining the quality of transmission between the ROADM apparatuses in a favorable state.
When the OSNR in the ROADM section in
OSNR(A)=10*log [{OSNR(A-G)−Δd}−1−OSNR(b-G)−1] (4)
Although the OSNR(A) calculation in
Curve 701 illustrated in
In
It can be understood that, in particular, in the range of the ILA-section total span loss where the OSNR in the ILA section is smaller than the OSNR of the PostAMP by a certain amount, the influence that the deterioration of the OSNR of the PostAMP has on the OSNR in the ROADM section is small.
The average input power of the PostAMP may be obtained from the PostAMP OSNR calculated as described above.
Curve 801 in
Although straight line 802 is depicted in
Up and down arrows 803 to 807 indicate differences between the initial value and the target values (lower-limit values) for the average input power of the PostAMP. The average input power of the PostAMP can be greatly reduced from the initial value (straight line 802), as the OSNR in the ILA section decreases (deteriorates). On the other hand, when the OSNR in the ILA section is large (favorable), the amount by which the average input power of the PostAMP can be reduced is small.
Thus, by controlling the average input power of the PostAMP in accordance with the OSNR in the ILA section, as indicated by curve 801 in
In
The configuration of a ROADM apparatus will now be described with reference to
The ROADM apparatus 900 further includes a photodetector (PD) 905. The PD 905 monitors the total input power of WDM signals received by the ROADM apparatus 900 and optical power of spontaneous emission noise (amplified spontaneous emission: ASE) and passes the monitored total input power and optical power to an ASE calculator 911.
The ROADM apparatus 900 further includes a pre-emphasis controller 908, a PostAMP controller 909, an OSNR calculator 910, the ASE calculator 911, a span-loss calculator 912, and an interface 913.
The pre-emphasis controller 908 calculates an amount of attenuation for each wavelength in accordance with the amount of tilt Δt and the target value for the average input power of the PostAMP 904, the amount of tilt Δt and the target value being supplied from the PostAMP controller 909. The pre-emphasis controller 908 then reports the calculated amount of attenuation for each wavelength to the WSS 903.
The PostAMP controller 909 determines an amount of tilt Δt in accordance with the per-wavelength reception optical powers received from the ROADM apparatus at an opposite end. Next, the PostAMP controller 909 compares the amount of pre-emphasis control ΔPE, based on the current average input power of the PostAMP, with the amount of tilt Δt. For ΔPE<Δt, the PostAMP controller 909 refers to
As an alternative, the PostAMP controller 909 may obtain the lower-limit value of the average input power of the PostAMP 904 by using a total span loss supplied from the span-loss calculator 912, instead of the OSNR in the ILA section.
The OSNR calculator 910 collects OSNRs from all apparatuses that exist in the ILA section between the ROADM apparatus 900 and a receiving-side ROADM apparatus and calculates an OSNR [dB] in the ILA section in accordance with equation (2) noted above. Although equation (2) is based on the network configuration illustrated in
As an alternative, the OSNR calculator 910 may receive a cumulative ASE from the ASE calculator 911 and may calculate an OSNR [dB] in the ILA section in accordance with:
(OSNR in ILA Section)=−(Cumulative ASE) (5)
The OSNR calculator 910 reports the calculated ILA-section OSNR to the PostAMP controller 909.
The ASE calculator 911 collects ASEs from all of the apparatuses that exist in the ILA section between the ROADM apparatus 900 and the receiving-side ROADM apparatus and calculates a cumulative ASE. The ASE calculator 911 reports the calculated cumulative ASE to the OSNR calculator 910.
The ASE calculator 911 further calculates, when used as a receiving-side ROADM apparatus, an ASE in the section from the immediately preceding upstream apparatus to the local ROADM apparatus 900, based on the total input power of the received WDM signals which is supplied from the PD 905 and the optical power of the ASE. The ASE calculator 911 adds the calculated ASE to the ASE transferred from the immediately preceding upstream apparatus and feeds back the resulting ASE to a transmitting-side ROADM apparatus.
The span-loss calculator 912 collects span losses from all of the apparatuses that exist in the ILA section between the ROADM apparatus 900 and the receiving-side ROADM apparatus and calculates a total span loss. The span-loss calculator 912 reports the calculated total span loss to the PostAMP controller 909.
The interface 913 enables communication among the elements in the ROADM apparatus 900 and communication with another apparatus connected to the ROADM apparatus 900 through optical fibers or the like.
The configuration of an ILA will be described with reference to
The AMP 1001 amplifies an optical signal received by the ILA 1000 and transmits the amplified optical signal to another apparatus through optical fibers.
The PD 1002 monitors the total input power of WDM signals received by the ILA 1000 and the optical power of the ASE and passes the reception-WDM-signal total input power and the ASE optical power to the ASE calculator 1003.
Based on the reception-WDM-signal total input power and the ASE optical power supplied from the PD 1002, the ASE calculator 1003 calculates an ASE. The ASE calculator 1003 transmits the calculated ASE to an upstream or downstream apparatus, a ROADM apparatus, or a network monitoring system.
The span-loss calculator 1004 calculates a span loss by calculating a difference between the transmission optical power of the immediately preceding upstream apparatus and the reception optical power of the ILA 1000. Alternatively, the span-loss calculator 1004 may calculate a span loss, based on the ASE and OSC light obtained from the ASE calculator 1003. A method of calculating the span loss is not limited to the above-described method and may be selected from various known methods. The span-loss calculator 1004 transmits the calculated span loss to a transmitting-side ROADM apparatus.
The interface 1005 enables communication among the elements in the ILA 1000 and communication with another apparatus connected to the ILA 1000 through an optical fiber or the like.
In order to perform pre-emphasis control, it is important for a transmitting-side ROADM apparatus to know per-wavelength reception optical powers in a receiving-side ROADM apparatus. A method in which a ROADM apparatus at a receiving side (the right side in
The receiving-side ROADM apparatus 900 uses the OCM 906 to monitor outputs from the PreAMP 901 with respect to respective wavelengths λ1, . . . , λk included in received light and feeds back per-wavelength reception optical powers P (λ1), . . . , P (λk) to the immediately preceding upstream apparatus via the interface 913. The per-wavelength reception optical powers P (λ1), . . . , P (λk) are relayed by the ILA 1000 and are transmitted to the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus 900.
In the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus 900, the per-wavelength reception optical powers P (λ1), . . . , P (λk) received via the interface 913 and are reported to the PostAMP controller 909 and the pre-emphasis controller 908. The PostAMP controller 909 and the pre-emphasis controller 908 operate as described above.
The above-described reception-optical-power transmission is performed through OSC lines.
As described above, in order to determine a target value for the average input power of the PostAMP 904 during the pre-emphasis control, the OSNR in the ILA section is determined. A method of calculating a target value for the average input power of the PostAMP 904 by using a cumulative ASE will be described below with reference to
In the ILA 1000, the PD 1002 monitors optical signal power, input to the AMP 1001, to obtain an ASE. The ASE calculator 1003 adds an ASE1 representing the amount of the ASE, obtained by the PD 1002, to the ASE transferred from the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus 900 and transfers, as ASE=ASE0+ASE1, the resulting ASE to a downstream apparatus via the interface 1005. Thereafter, each time an optical signal passes through the AMP 1001, an ASE is added and the resulting ASE is transferred to the downstream apparatus.
In the receiving-side ROADM apparatus 900 (the right side in
In the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus 900, the OSNR calculator 910 receives the cumulative ASE from the ASE calculator 911 and calculates an OSNR in the ILA section in accordance with equation (5) noted above.
In
The ILA 1000 adds an ASE calculated thereby to the ASE received from a downstream apparatus and further transfers the resulting ASE to an upstream apparatus as ASE=ASEN+ASEN-1. Thereafter, each time an optical signal passes through the AMP 1001, an ASE is added and the resulting ASE is transferred to the upstream apparatus.
The transmitting-side ROADM apparatus 900 obtains a cumulative ASE by adding an ASE0 obtained thereby to the ASE (=ASE1+, . . . , +ASEN) transferred from the downstream ILA 1000. By using the cumulative ASE, the OSNR calculator 910 in the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus 900 calculates an OSNR in the ILA section.
In
The OSNR calculator 1402 in the NMS 1401 calculates a cumulative ASE by adding the ASE0, ASE1, . . . , and ASEN reported from the ROADM apparatuses 900 and the ILA 1000 and reports the cumulative ASE to the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus 900.
By using the cumulative ASE reported from the NMS 1401, the OSNR calculator 910 in the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus 900 calculates an OSNR in the ILA section.
The PostAMP controller 909 in the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus 900 determines a target value for the average input power of the PostAMP 904 in accordance with
The above-described ASE transfer is performed via OSC lines.
In order to determine a target value for the average input power of the PostAMP 904 during the pre-emphasis control, a span loss may also be used instead of the OSNR. A method of calculating a target value for the average input power of the PostAMP 904 by using a span loss will be described below with reference to
In
The ILA 1000 adds a span loss LN-1 calculated thereby to the span loss LN received from a downstream apparatus and further transfers the resulting span loss L to the upstream apparatus as L=LN+LN-1. Thereafter, each time an optical signal passes through the apparatus, the span loss is added and the resulting span loss is transferred to the upstream apparatus.
The span-loss calculator 912 in the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus 900 adds a span loss L0 calculated by the local ROAD apparatus 900 to the span loss transferred from the downstream ILA 1000 to obtain a total span loss L=LN+LN-1+, . . . , +L0. The span-loss calculator 912 reports the total span loss L to the PostAMP controller 909.
As the total span loss increases, the PostAMP controller 909 sets a small value for the target value for the average input power of the PostAMP 904. As an alternative, when the total span loss is larger than or equal to a given value, the PostAMP controller 909 may set the target value for the average input power of the PostAMP 904 to the given value.
A method of controlling the average input power of the PostAMP 904 will be described below with reference to
In S1 operation, this method is started.
In S2 operation, the PostAMP controller 909 sets an initial value of the average input power of the PostAMP 904 as a target value for the average input power of the PostAMP 904. The initial value is a value at which the OSNR in the ILA section is large (favorable) and may be, for example, −20 dBm.
In S3 operation, the ROADM apparatus 900 monitors a WDM-signal-line alarm transmitted to or received from another ROADM apparatus 900. In the presence of the alarm, the ROADM apparatus 900 continues the monitoring until no alarm is detected. In the absence of the alarm, the process proceeds to S4 operation.
In S4 operation, the ROADM apparatus 900 determines whether or not establishment of a signal line between the ROADM apparatuses 900 is completed. In this case, upon confirming that transmission/reception to/from the ROADM apparatus 900 at a distal end through the OSC line is properly performed, the ROADM apparatus 900 determines that the establishment of the signal line is completed. When the establishment of the signal line is not completed, the process returns to S3 operation in which the ROADM apparatus 900 monitors the alarm. When the establishment of the signal line is completed, the process proceeds to S5 operation.
In S5 operation, the PostAMP controller 909 calculates an amount of tilt Δt and an amount of pre-emphasis control ΔPE.
In S6 operation, the PostAMP controller 909 compares the amount of pre-emphasis control ΔPE with the amount of tilt Δt. For ΔPE<Δt, the process proceeds to S7 operation. Otherwise, the process proceeds to S8 operation.
In S7 operation, by using a total span loss or an OSNR calculated from the cumulative ASE or in the manner described above, the PostAMP controller 909 determines a target value for the average input power of the PostAMP 904.
In S8 operation, the pre-emphasis controller 908 executes pre-emphasis control, based on the current average input power of the PostAMP 904 or based on the target value for the average input power of the PostAMP 904, the target value being determined in S7 operation.
In S9 operation, the ROADM apparatus 900 again monitors the WDM-signal-line alarm transmitted to or received from another ROADM apparatus 900. In the absence of the alarm, the process returns to S5 operation in which an amount of tilt Δt and an amount of pre-emphasis control ΔPE are determined, and then the subsequent processing is performed again. In the presence of the alarm, the process proceeds to S10 operation.
In S10 operation, the process returns to S1 operation, the average input power of the PostAMP 904 is re-set to the initial value, and the processing is performed again.
The processing for calculating an amount of pre-emphasis control and an amount of tilt will now be described with reference to
The processing starts in S11 operation.
In S12 operation, the transmitting-side ROADM apparatus 900 receives per-wavelength reception optical powers from the receiving-side ROADM apparatus 900 in the manner described above with reference to
In S13 operation, the PostAMP controller 909 calculates a difference between the maximum value and the minimum value of the per-wavelength reception optical powers received in S12 operation, to thereby calculate an amount of tilt Δt.
In S14 operation, the PostAMP controller 909 calculates an amount of pre-emphasis control ΔPE, based on the current average input power of the PostAMP 904.
In S15 operation, the processing ends.
The processing for determining a target value for the average input power of the PostAMP 904 will now be described with reference to
The processing starts in S21 operation.
In S22 operation, the OSNR calculator 910 calculates a cumulative ASE by adding ASEs of all apparatuses that exist on a path through which a WDM signal passes, as described above with reference to
In S23 operation, by using the cumulative ASE calculated in S22 operation, the OSNR calculator 910 calculates an OSNR in the ILA section in accordance with equation (5) noted above, as described above with reference to
In S24 operation, in accordance with
In S25 operation, the PostAMP controller 909 sets the PostAMP average input power, determined in S24 operation, as the target value and reports the target value to the pre-emphasis controller 908.
In S26 operation, the processing ends.
Although the OSNR is determined from the cumulative ASE in
The processing for executing the pre-emphasis control will now be described with reference to
The processing starts in S31 operation.
In S32 operation, based on the target value set in S25 operation in
In S33 operation, based on the amounts of attenuation (ATT) for the respective wavelengths, the amounts being determined in S32 operation, the pre-emphasis controller 908 controls the WSS 903 to adjust the amounts of attenuation to be applied to the respective wavelengths.
The processing ends in S34 operation.
All examples and conditional language recited herein are intended for pedagogical purposes to aid the reader in understanding the invention and the concepts contributed by the inventor to furthering the art, and are to be construed as being without limitation to such specifically recited examples and conditions, nor does the organization of such examples in the specification relate to a showing of the superiority and inferiority of the invention. Although the embodiment of the present invention has been described in detail, it should be understood that the various changes, substitutions, and alterations could be made hereto without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2013-064938 | Mar 2013 | JP | national |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
6654561 | Terahara | Nov 2003 | B1 |
8693874 | Suzuki | Apr 2014 | B2 |
20040213566 | Takanashi | Oct 2004 | A1 |
20070206955 | Uda | Sep 2007 | A1 |
20090279888 | Butler | Nov 2009 | A1 |
20100158532 | Goto et al. | Jun 2010 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
2000-332686 | Nov 2000 | JP |
2010-154104 | Jul 2010 | JP |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20140294378 A1 | Oct 2014 | US |