Turbine driven centrifugal filter

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6210311
  • Patent Number
    6,210,311
  • Date Filed
    Wednesday, October 21, 1998
    26 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, April 3, 2001
    23 years ago
Abstract
A centrifugal filter assembly for filtering particulates from a fluid includes a rotating filter disposed within a housing and rotatable relative to the housing about an axis of rotation. A turbine is attached to the filter and includes a plurality of turbine blades extending generally radially relative to the axis of rotation. A nozzle having an outlet is aligned relative to the turbine, whereby a pressurized fluid which is jetted from the nozzle impinges upon the turbine and causes the filter to rotate about the axis of rotation.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




1. Field of the Invention




The present invention relates to centrifugal filters for filtering particulates from a liquid using centrifugal force.




2. Description of the Related Art




Many types of fluids contain particulates which need to be filtered out for subsequent use of the fluid. Examples of such fluids include medical and biological fluids, machining and cutting fluids, and lubricating oils. With particular reference to an internal combustion engine, a lubricating oil such as engine oil may contain particulates which are filtered out to prevent mechanical or corrosive wear of the engine.




Diesel engine mechanical wear, especially that relating to boundary lubricated wear, is a direct function of the amount of particulates in the lubricating oil. A particulate which is extremely detrimental to engine wear is soot, formed during the combustion process, and deposited into the crankcase through combustion gas blow-by and piston rings scraping of the cylinder walls. Soot is a carbonaceous polycyclic hydrocarbon which has extremely high surface area whereby it interacts chemically with adsorptive association with other lubricant species. Particle sizes of most diesel engine lubricant soot is between 100 Angstroms and 3 microns. Ranges of concentration are between 0 and 10 percent by weight depending on many factors. Because engine wear will dramatically increase with the soot level in the lubricating oil, engine manufacturers specify a certain engine drain oil interval to protect the engine from this type of mechanical wear. Current sieve type filters do not remove sufficient amounts of soot to provide soot related wear protection to the engine.




Centrifugal filters for lubricant filtration are generally known. Current production centrifugal lubricant oil filters are powered by hero turbines, which are part of the oil filter canister, or through direct mechanical propulsion. Hero turbine powered filters are limited by the supplied oil pressure from the engine, and only can be operated up to maximum speeds around 4000 revolutions per minute (RPM) with oil pressures nominally at less than 40 psi. In addition, hero turbine powered filters pass oil through the filter canister as it migrates toward the attached hero turbine jets. Therefore, the lubricant mean residence time is less than a few minutes. None of the currently available centrifugal filters which operate on the basis of a hero turbine provide satisfactory soot removal rates. Soot removal from engine lubricating oil requires greater G forces and longer residence times than is demonstrated with currently commercially available hero turbine powered filters.




Is also known to drive a centrifugal filter using a mechanical linkage from a turbine. The turbine receives a flow of engine exhaust air and drives a mechanical output shaft which nozzle impinges upon the turbine and causes the filter to rotate about the axis of rotation.




An advantage of the present invention is that the turbine is directly driven by a pressurized fluid to rotate the filter at a speed which is sufficient to effect centrifugal separation.




Another advantage is that the turbine is impacted upon by the pressurized fluid substantially orthogonal to the axis of rotation of the filter, thereby improving efficiency by substantially eliminating force vectors on the turbine parallel to the axis of rotation.




Yet another advantage is that the turbine may be configured as rigidly attached to, removably attached to or integral with the filter.




Still another advantage is that the nozzle may be disposed either radially within or outside of the turbine.




A further advantage is that the nozzle may be adjustably positioned relative to a fixed or variable geometry turbine.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




The above-mentioned and other features and advantages of this invention, and the manner of attaining them, will become more apparent and the invention will be better understood by reference to the following description of embodiments of the invention taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, wherein:





FIG. 1

is a perspective, sectional view of an embodiment of a centrifugal filter assembly of the present invention; in turn is coupled with a filter inside a centrifugal filter assembly. The rotational speed of the filter is sufficient to separate particulates within the engine oil. An example of such a filter is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 5,779,618 (Onodera, et al.).




All of the units described above and others commercially available fall generally in groups of hero turbine design or direct mechanical actuation. While direct mechanically driven systems are capable of reaching the necessary G forces to provide soot removal, this type of linkage is generally very expensive and requires extensive modification of engines to adapt. While hero turbines do not suffer from this problem, insufficient G forces limit these filters from removing soot.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention provides a centrifugal filter for filtering particulates from a liquid, wherein a turbine attached to a rotatable filter is driven with a pressurized fluid at a speed which is sufficient to separate the particulates from the liquid via centrifugal force.




The invention comprises, in one form thereof, a centrifugal filter assembly for filtering particulates from a fluid. A rotating filter is disposed within a housing and rotatable relative to the housing about an axis of rotation. A turbine is connected to the filter and includes a plurality of turbine blades extending generally radially relative to the axis of rotation. A nozzle having an outlet is aligned relative to the turbine, whereby a pressurized fluid which is jetted from the





FIG. 2

is a side, sectional view of another embodiment of a centrifugal filter assembly of the present invention;





FIG. 3

is a sectional view taken along line


3





3


in

FIG. 2

;





FIG. 4

is a fragmentary, side view of still another embodiment of a centrifugal filter assembly of the present invention;





FIG. 5

is a fragmentary, side view of another embodiment of a centrifugal filter assembly of the present invention;





FIG. 6

is a perspective view of an embodiment of a filter of the present invention;





FIG. 7

is a simplified, side view of still another embodiment of a centrifugal filter assembly of the present invention;





FIG. 8

is a perspective view of an embodiment of a turbine for use with the centrifugal filter assembly of the present invention;





FIG. 9

is a perspective view of another embodiment of a turbine for use with the centrifugal filter assembly of the present invention;





FIG. 10

is a perspective view of yet another embodiment of a turbine for use with the centrifugal filter assembly of the present invention;





FIG. 11

is a perspective view of still another embodiment of a turbine for use with the centrifugal filter assembly of the present invention;





FIG. 12

is a perspective view of a further embodiment of a variable geometry turbine for use with the centrifugal filter assembly of the present invention; and





FIG. 13

is a perspective view of yet another embodiment of a turbine for use with the centrifugal filter assembly of the present invention.











Corresponding reference characters indicate corresponding parts throughout the several views. The exemplifications set out herein illustrate one preferred embodiment of the invention, in one form, and such exemplifications are not to be construed as limiting the scope of the invention in any manner.




DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION




Referring now to the drawings, and more particularly to

FIG. 1

, there is shown an embodiment of a centrifugal filter assembly


10


of the present invention for filtering particulates from a fluid. For example, centrifugal filter assembly


10


may be used to filter soot from engine oil in a diesel engine, and will be described accordingly. Centrifugal filter assembly


10


may be used for other applications, such as medical applications for separating particulates from a bodily or medical fluid, or machining and cutting applications for separating metallic particles from a hydraulic fluid or lubricating oil.




Centrifugal filter assembly


10


generally includes a housing


12


, rotating filter


14


and turbine


16


. Housing


12


contains filter


14


and defines a generally fluid-tight vessel. For example, housing


12


may be used as part of a bypass filter assembly for use with an internal combustion engine. When configured as such, a central supply tube


18


disposed in communication with a sump


28


extends outwardly from the engine. Housing


12


includes a hub


20


which is rigidly attached therewith. Hub


20


includes an internal threaded portion


22


which threadingly engages external threads on supply tube


18


. Screwing hub


20


onto supply tube


18


causes housing


12


to axially seal against the engine. An annular seal


24


on an axial end face of housing


12


effects a fluid tight seal with the engine. Hub


20


includes external threads


26


allowing attachment with suitable fluid conduits (not shown) for recirculating oil transported through filter assembly


10


back to sump


28


.




Filter


14


is disposed within and rotatable relative to housing


12


about an axis of rotation


30


defined by supply tube


18


. Filter


14


may be rotatably carried using a pair of reduced friction bearings


32


and


34


disposed at each axial end thereof. Bearings


32


and


34


may be, e.g., roller bearings, ball bearings or another type of reduced friction bearing supports such as a bushing. Filter


14


may include a suitable medium therein (not shown) allowing filtration of the fluid which is transported through filter


14


. For example, the medium disposed within filter


14


may be in the form of a spiral wrapped and embossed sheet of metal or plastic material, as will be described in greater detail hereinafter.




Turbine


16


is connected to filter


14


at an axial end thereof. In the embodiment shown, turbine


16


is attached to a bottom wall


36


of filter


14


via welding, a suitable adhesive or the like. The interconnection between turbine


16


and filter


14


causes rotation of turbine


16


to in turn rotate filter


14


about axis of rotation


30


.




Turbine


16


includes a plurality of blades


38


which extend generally radially relative to axis of rotation


30


. Blades


38


may extend substantially through axis of rotation


30


, or may be positioned at an angle offset from axis of rotation


30


. Moreover, blades


38


may be configured with a particular shape which is curved, straight, segmented, a combination of the same, etc., to provide a desired rotational speed of filter


14


during operation.




Hub


20


of housing


12


includes at least one fluid port


40


defining a nozzle through which a pressurized fluid is jetted to impact upon turbine blades


38


. In the embodiment shown, hub


20


includes a single fluid port


40


defining a nozzle, although a greater number of fluid ports may also be provided. A wall


42


disposed within hub


20


defines a pressure chamber


44


in communication with each of an internal bore of supply tube


18


and fluid port


40


. The pressurized fluid is transported through supply tube


18


into pressure chamber


44


and is jetted from fluid port


40


. The pressurized fluid which is jetted from fluid port


40


sequentially impinges upon blades


38


of turbine


16


. The pressurized fluid is jetted from fluid port


40


in a direction which is substantially perpendicular to axis of rotation


30


, thereby eliminating force vectors in a direction parallel to axis of rotation


30


and maximizing the force imparted on each blade


38


. The curvature and/or positioning of each blade


38


causes a rotational moment to be exerted on turbine


16


, which in turn causes turbine


16


and filter


14


to rotate about axis of rotation


30


.




A splash shield


46


is attached to housing


12


and is disposed radially around turbine


16


above blades


38


. Pressurized fluid which is jetted radially outwardly from fluid port


40


against turbine blades


38


falls to a bottom of housing


12


and exits through drain holes


48


in hub


20


. Splash shield


46


prevents an appreciable amount of pressurized fluid from spraying against a side wall of housing


12


and impacting against filter


14


. Impact of the pressurized fluid would provide aerodynamic drag on filter


14


and slow the rotational speed thereof. A relatively small radial clearance is provided between turbine


16


and splash shield


46


to minimize the amount of pressurized fluid which flows past splash shield


46


to an area adjacent filter


14


.




Filter


14


fills with oil to be filtered during operation. One or more exit holes


50


are provided in the bottom side of filter


14


. The size and number of holes


50


, as well as the fluid input rate into filter


14


is a function of the desired throughput rate through filter


14


and residence time of the fluid within filter


14


. Engine oil which drains through holes


50


in the bottom of filter


14


flows down the top of splash shield


46


, through one or more holes


52


in splash shield


46


, and out through drain holes


48


in hub


20


.




During use, a pressurized fluid is transported from sump


28


to supply tube


18


. When used with an internal combustion engine, the pressurized fluid may be in the form of engine oil which is pressurized using an oil pump to a pressure of between 30 and 70 pound per square inch (psi), and more particularly approximately 45 psi. Approximately 90 percent (which actual percentage may vary) of the circulated engine oil is transported through supply tube


18


to pressure chamber


44


for discharging in a generally radially outward direction relative to axis of rotation


30


against turbine blades


38


of turbine


16


. The pressurized engine oil causes turbine


16


to rotate at a speed of between approximately 5,000 and 20,000 revolutions per minute (RPM), more preferably between approximately 10,000 and 20,000 RPM. The remaining 10 percent of the engine oil is transported into filter


14


for centrifugal filtration. The high rotational speed of filter


14


creates a G force which is high enough to cause centrifugal separation of particulates carried within the engine oil. The particulates migrate radially outwardly within filter


14


and are contained within filter


14


. Periodic changing of filter


14


allows the trapped particulates within filter


14


to be merely discarded along with filter


14


.




Referring now to

FIGS. 2 and 3

, there is shown another embodiment of a centrifugal filter assembly


60


of the present invention. For purposes of illustration, centrifugal filter assembly


60


will be described for use with an internal combustion engine, but it is to be understood that filter assembly


60


may be utilized for other applications.




Housing


62


is attached to an engine (not shown) utilizing flanges


64


and bolts


66


. A bottom cover


68


is threadingly engaged with housing


62


and is sealed with housing


62


using an annular O-ring


70


. Bottom cover


68


may be removed from housing


62


to allow replacement of filter


72


, as will be described in greater detail hereinafter.




Turbine


74


is rotatably carried by housing


62


using one or more reduced friction bearings, such as ball bearing assemblies


76


and


78


. Turbine


74


includes a plurality of blades


80


disposed around the periphery thereof. Blades


80


extend generally radially relative to an axis of rotation


82


, and have a selected shape to provide a desired rotational speed of turbine


74


. The shape of blades


80


and the distance from axis of rotation


82


both have an effect on the rotational speed and are determined for a particular application (e.g., empirically).




A top cover


84


is fastened to housing


62


using, e.g., bolts


86


. Seals such as O-rings


88


provide a fluid tight seal between top cover


84


and housing


62


. Top cover


84


includes suitable porting


90


and


92


to be fluidly connected with a source of pressurized fluid and the fluid to be filtered, respectively. In the embodiment shown, porting


90


and


92


are each connected with a source of pressurized engine oil which provides both the source of pressurized fluid for rotating turbine


74


and the fluid to be filtered.




Nozzles


94


are attached to and carried by top cover


84


, and direct a source of pressurized fluid at selected locations against blades


80


of turbine


74


. As viewed in

FIG. 2

, the left hand nozzle


94


is disposed behind central supply tube


96


and the right hand nozzle


94


is disposed in front of supply tube


96


. Nozzles


94


thus both jet a pressurized fluid which impinges upon blades


80


of turbine


74


on opposite sides of turbine


74


. Because nozzles


94


are carried by top cover


84


and directed generally inwardly relative to axis of rotation


82


, the specific impingement angle of the pressurized fluid on blades


80


can easily be adjusted for a specific application. The angle of impingement, flow velocity of the pressurized fluid, shape of blades


80


and impingement location relative to axis of rotation


82


may be configured to provide a desired rotational speed of turbine


74


.




Drive nut


98


includes internal threads which are threadingly engaged with external threads of turbine


74


. Drive nut


98


includes an upper, angled surface


100


defining a fluid port for providing lubricating oil to bearings


76


and


78


. Drive nut


98


includes a lower drive portion


102


with a cross sectional shape which is other than circular (e.g., hexagonal). The shape of lower drive portion


102


allows turbine


74


to interconnect with filter


72


and rotatably drive filter


72


during use. A flange


104


extends from drive portion


102


and seals with filter


72


around the outer periphery thereof with a slight compression fit.




Splash shield


106


is attached with housing


62


and directs oil away from filter


72


which is used to drive turbine


74


. Splash shield


106


is press fit into housing


62


in the embodiment shown. Pressurized fluid in the form of oil which is used to drive turbine


74


falls via gravitational force and flows through holes


108


and into a trough


110


defined by splash shield


106


. The trough


110


is connected with an exit port (not shown) in housing


62


for recirculating the fluid to the sump of the engine.




Filter


72


generally includes a body


112


, end cap


114


and impingement media


116


. Body


112


includes a top opening


118


which surrounds and frictionally engages flange


104


of drive nut


98


. The press fit between flange


104


and top opening


118


is sufficient to prevent fluid leakage therebetween. Body


112


also includes a plurality of exit holes, such as the two exit holes


120


in the top thereof. Exit holes


120


allow filtered oil to flow therethrough and into trough


110


during operation after filter


72


is full of the oil to be filtered.




End cap


114


is attached with body


112


in a suitable manner. In the embodiment shown, end cap


114


and body


112


are each formed from plastic and are ultrasonically welded together. However, it is also possible to attach end cap


114


with body


112


in a different manner, such as through a threaded or snap lock engagement. End cap


114


includes an upwardly projecting stud


122


with an angled distal face which acts to radially distribute oil to be filtered which is ejected from central supply tube


96


.




Impingement media


116


, shown in more detail in

FIG. 3

, is in the form of a long, continuous sheet


124


of material which is wrapped in a spiral manner about supply tube


96


and stud


122


. Sheet


124


is formed with a plurality of randomly located dimples


126


which are approximately {fraction (3/16)} inch diameter and 0.070 inch deep. Each dimple


126


defines a generally concave surface facing toward axis of rotation


82


. Sheet


124


is approximately 0.020 inch thick and includes a plurality of holes


128


between dimples


126


which have a diameter of approximately 0.060 inch. Holes


128


are also substantially randomly placed on sheet


124


at locations between dimples


126


at a ratio of approximately one hole pre every three dimples. In the embodiment shown, dimples


126


have a center-to-center distance which varies, but with a mean center-to-center distance of approximately ⅝ inch. Of course, it will be appreciated that the specific geometry and number of dimples


126


and/or holes


128


within sheet


124


may vary depending upon the specific application.




Impingement media


116


in the form of a spiral wrapped sheet with dimples


126


and holes


128


provides effective centrifugal separation of particulates within the oil, and also regulates the residence time of the oil within filter


72


. As filter


72


rotates at a desired rotational speed during use, the oil to be filtered is biased radially outwardly against an adjacent portion of sheet


124


. Particulates within the oil settle into the concave surfaces defined by dimples


126


and the filtered oil migrates toward a hole


128


to pass therethrough in a radial direction and impinge upon the next radially outward portion of sheet


124


. The radially outward flow of the oil through holes


128


in sheet


124


and trapping of particulates within dimples


126


continues until the filtered oil lies against the inside diameter of body


112


. An annular cap


130


at the end of spiral wrapped sheet


124


prevents the oil from prematurely exiting in an axial direction toward the end of filter


72


. The filtered oil flows in an upward direction along the inside diameter of body


112


and through exit holes


120


into trough


110


to be transported back to the sump of the engine.





FIG. 4

illustrates yet another embodiment of a centrifugal filter assembly


140


of the present invention. Filter assembly


140


includes a housing


142


with a filter


144


rotatably disposed therein. Housing


142


includes an integral fluid channel


146


which terminates at a nozzle


148


. Nozzle


148


directs pressurized fluid against turbine blades


150


of turbine


152


.




Filter


144


includes turbine


152


as an integral part thereof. That is, turbine


152


is monolithically formed with filter


144


. In the embodiment shown, filter


144


and turbine


152


are each formed at the same time using a plastic injection molding process.




Referring now to

FIG. 5

, another embodiment of a centrifugal filter assembly


160


is shown, including a housing


142


and filter


162


. Filter


162


includes a turbine


164


with a plurality of turbine blades


168


. Turbine


164


includes a deflector shield


170


attached to an axial end thereof which maximizes the efficiency of the pressurized fluid jetted from nozzle


148


by confining sideways deflection of the fluid impinging on blades


168


.





FIG. 6

illustrates another embodiment of a filter


174


which may be utilized with the centrifugal filter assembly of the present invention. Filter


174


includes a turbine


176


with a plurality of variable pitch turbine blades


180


. A nozzle


182


which is attached with and pivotable relative to a housing (not shown) about a pivot point


184


is adjustable during use to change the impingement angle on blades


180


and the distance from the axis of rotation. The composite curved shape of each blade


180


coacts with the variable impingement angle from nozzle


182


to vary the rotational speed of and/or torque applied to turbine


176


.





FIG. 7

illustrates yet another embodiment of a centrifugal filter assembly


190


of the present invention. Filter assembly


190


generally includes a housing


192


, filter


194


and turbine


196


. Filter


194


and turbine


196


are each disposed within housing


192


and are carried by suitable support structure (not shown) allowing rotation around respective axes of rotation


198


and


201


. A nozzle


200


defined by housing


192


jets a flow of pressurized fluid onto turbine


196


to cause rotation thereof about axis of rotation


201


. Rotation of turbine


196


in turn rotates pulley


202


which is connected via drive belt


204


with a pulley


206


rigidly attached to filter


194


. Thus, rotation of turbine


196


causes rotation of filter


194


about axis of rotation


198


. Using an elongate force transmission element, such as drive belt


204


, allows the rotational speed of filter


194


to not only be adjusted by changing the physical configuration of turbine


196


, but also by changing the diameters of the drive pulley


202


and driven pulley


206


. For example, providing drive pulley


202


with a diameter which is the same as turbine


196


but twice as large as driven pulley


206


provides filter


194


with a rotational speed which is twice that of turbine


196


.





FIGS. 8-12

illustrate perspective views of alternative embodiments of turbines which may be used in a centrifugal filter assembly of the present invention. The turbines shown in

FIGS. 8-11

are fixed blade designs for use with a stationary nozzle, while the turbine shown in

FIG. 12

is a variable geometry design for use with an adjustable nozzle. Turbine


218


(

FIG. 8

) includes a plurality of turbine blades


220


extending radially from a hub


222


. Turbine


224


(

FIG. 9

) includes a plurality of turbine blades


226


extending radially from a hub


228


. Turbine


230


(

FIG. 10

) includes a plurality of turbine blades


232


extending radially from a hub


234


. Turbine


224


(

FIG. 11

) includes a plurality of turbine blades


238


extending radially from a hub


240


. Lastly, Turbine


242


(

FIG. 12

) includes a plurality of turbine blades


224


extending radially from a hub


246


.





FIG. 13

is a perspective view of yet another embodiment of a turbine


210


which may be utilized with a centrifugal filter assembly of the present invention. Turbine


210


includes a plurality of turbine blades


212


extending radially from a hub


214


. A deflector shield


216


surrounds the periphery of turbine


210


and contacts blades


212


. For example, deflector shield


216


may be press fit onto turbine


210


around the periphery of blades


212


. Deflector shield


216


maximizes the efficiency of the pressurized fluid which is jetted from a nozzle


148


by confining radial deflections of the fluid impinging on blades


212


.




While this invention has been described as having a preferred design, the present invention can be further modified within the spirit and scope of this disclosure. This application is therefore intended to cover any variations, uses, or adaptations of the invention using its general principles. Further, this application is intended to cover such departures from the present disclosure as come within known or customary practice in the art to which this invention pertains and which fall within the limits of the appended claims.



Claims
  • 1. A centrifugal filter assembly for filtering particulates from a fluid, comprising:a housing; a rotating filter disposed within said housing and rotatable relative to said housing about an axis of rotation, said filter being configured for containing the fluid therein and entrapping the particulates from the fluid, said filter including at least one impingement medium disposed therein, said impingement medium impinging a radially outward flow of the pressurized fluid to be filtered in a radial direction during rotation of the filter, said at least one impingement medium comprising a substantially continuous sheet of material wrapped in a spiral manner about said axis of rotation; a turbine directly attached to said filter, said turbine including a plurality of turbine blades extending generally radially relative to said axis of rotation; and a nozzle having an outlet and being aligned relative to said turbine, whereby a pressurized fluid which is jetted from said nozzle impinges upon said turbine and causes said filter to rotate about said axis of rotation, thereby exerting a centrifugal force on the fluid contained within the filter, said centrifugal force biasing the particulates of the fluid against the filter.
  • 2. The centrifugal filter assembly of claim 1, wherein said sheet of material includes a plurality of through holes.
  • 3. A centrifugal filter assembly for filtering particulates from a fluid, comprising:a housing; a rotating filter disposed within said housing and rotatable relative to said housing about an axis of rotation, said filter including a sheet of material disposed therein and wrapped in a spiral manner about said axis of rotation, said sheet of material impinging a flow of the pressurized fluid to be filtered in a radial direction during rotation of the filter, said sheet of material including a plurality of dimples and a plurality of through holes; a turbine connected to said filter, said turbine including a plurality of turbine blades extending generally radially relative to said axis of rotation; and a nozzle having an outlet and being aligned relative to said turbine, whereby a pressurized fluid which is jetted from said nozzle impinges upon said turbine and causes said filter to rotate about said axis of rotation.
  • 4. The centrifugal filter assembly of claim 3, wherein each said dimple defines a generally concave surface facing toward said axis of rotation.
CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This is a non-provisional patent application based upon provisional patent application serial No. 60/101,804, entitled “AUXILIARY POWERED CENTRIFUGAL FILTER”, filed Sep. 25, 1998.

US Referenced Citations (22)
Number Name Date Kind
2053856 Weidenbacker Sep 1936
2321144 Jones Jun 1943
2335420 Jones Nov 1943
2485390 Langmuir Oct 1949
3273324 Jennings Sep 1966
3335946 Putterlik Aug 1967
3430853 Kirk et al. Mar 1969
3791576 Bazil Feb 1974
3879294 Ellis et al. Apr 1975
4106689 Kozulla Aug 1978
4142671 Ivin et al. Mar 1979
4150580 Silkebakken et al. Apr 1979
4165032 Klingenberg Aug 1979
4221323 Courtot Sep 1980
4492631 Martin Jan 1985
4557831 Lindsay et al. Dec 1985
5085783 Feke et al. Feb 1992
5637217 Herman et al. Jun 1997
5707519 Miller et al. Jan 1998
5779618 Onodera et al. Jul 1998
5785849 Mules Jul 1998
6017300 Herman Jan 2000
Foreign Referenced Citations (5)
Number Date Country
1089355 Nov 1967 GB
362643 Dec 1972 SU
564884 Jul 1977 SU
869822 Oct 1981 SU
8302406 Jul 1983 WO
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
60/101804 Sep 1998 US