This application claims priority to PCT Application No. PCT/EP2015/062158, having a filing date of Jun. 1, 2015, the entire contents of which are hereby incorporated by reference.
The following describes an inspection apparatus for a spherical body, and a method of inspecting a spherical body.
Ultrasonic testing (UT) is a widely used non-destructive testing technique to perform quality checks on various materials in order to detect internal flaws or to perform quality control. Typically, a UT probe is a transducer that emits an ultrasonic pulse into the object under inspection, and detects a reflected pulse. In the absence of a defect in the path of the pulse, the pulse will be reflected from the far boundary of the object, and will have a characteristic amplitude. A defect in the path of the pulse will result in a pulse reflected by the defect. The reflected pulse returns to the probe where it is detected.
UT inspection works very well for an object with relatively flat surfaces. Not all objects are suited to this type of inspection, for example it is more difficult to achieve a high level of accuracy when inspecting objects that have rounded surfaces.
However, it can be necessary to ensure the quality of a spherical object such as a steel bearing ball. A ball bearing can only function properly when the surfaces of the race and the surfaces of each bearing ball are smooth and free of defects. Small bearing balls can be manufactured relatively easily to a high standard. Larger bearing balls are more difficult to manufacture to the required standards since their larger dimensions increase the likelihood of surface defects. Therefore, much effort is invested in the inspection of such bearing balls, and an inspection procedure with a high probability of detection (PoD) rate is necessary to ensure that a flawed bearing ball does not make it through quality control. A visual inspection is slow and limited to the detection of evident defects such as pits or cracks in the outer surface. Such bearing balls would be discarded. However, a disadvantage of visual inspection is that a potentially problematic internal defect may escape detection. An internal defect located close to the surface of a bearing ball may later open up. An open defect can subsequently lead to seizure of the bearing and failure of the machine. In the case of large machine such as a wind turbine generator weighing several tons, failure of the ball bearing and subsequent repair can be very costly. Therefore, inspection of the components of such a large ball bearing may involve other techniques such as eddy current testing or UT inspection. However, when the known techniques of UT inspection are applied to a spherical body, the behavior of the pulses in the spherical body makes it difficult to interpret the reflections, so that a reliable inspection is not possible. Furthermore, the known techniques are not suited to detecting defects or flaws at or near the surface of a sphere.
An aspect relates to providing an improved way of inspecting such a spherical body.
According to embodiments of the invention, the spherical body inspection apparatus comprises a support arrangement realized to support a spherical body during an inspection procedure; a probe arrangement comprising a plurality of UT probes arranged about the spherical body such that the UT probes target a common test point at the surface of the spherical body; and a displacement means or displacer for effecting at least a rotational displacement of the spherical body relative to the probe arrangement.
In the context of embodiments of the invention, a UT probe is a probe of the type generally used for UT inspection. A UT probe generally has a working surface with a piezo-electric transducer for emitting and detecting ultrasonic waves. An ultrasonic wave generally a high frequency pulsed wave will diverge slightly as it travels through the object under test. In the context of embodiments of the invention, therefore, the “test point” targeted by a UT probe is to be understood as the area or region, at the object boundary, that is covered by the ultrasonic wave.
An advantage of the inspection apparatus according to embodiments of the invention is that a test point at the surface of the spherical body is targeted simultaneously by at least two UT probes. This significantly increases the sensitivity of the testing, and increases the accuracy of the inspection by increasing the likelihood of detecting a flaw, defect or anomaly at or close to the surface of the spherical body. Furthermore, test coverage can be favourably high owing to the relative rotational displacement of the spherical body and the probe arrangement.
According to embodiments of the invention, the method of inspecting a spherical body comprises the steps of arranging a plurality of UT probes relative to the spherical body to target a common test point at the surface of the spherical body; and then actuating the UT probes to each emit an ultrasonic pulse into the spherical body while effecting at least one relative rotation of the spherical body relative to the probe arrangement.
An advantage of the method according to embodiments of the invention is that it can quickly perform a thorough inspection of the spherical body, with a high probability of detection of any defect at the surface of the spherical body. The method is therefore particularly suited to the inspection of spherical bodies that must be manufactured to a high degree of quality.
Particularly advantageous embodiments and features of the invention are given, as revealed in the following description. Features of different categories may be combined as appropriate to give further embodiments not described herein.
In the following, without restricting embodiments of the invention in any way, it may be assumed that the spherical body under inspection is a solid body such as a steel ball for a large ball bearing, and the terms “spherical body”, “sphere”, bearing ball” and “ball” may therefore be used interchangeably. The terms “anomaly”, “flaw”, “defect” and “indication” as used in embodiments of the invention are synonymous and refer to an imperfection, close to or at the surface of the spherical body, that could lead to problems if not detected.
Preferably, the inspection apparatus according to embodiments of the invention is realized for use in an immersion tank. The tank may be filled with any suitable couplant such as water and an amount of anti-corrosive chemical.
In a preferred embodiment of the invention, the displacement means or displacer comprises two distinct arrangements for effecting a relative rotation between the spherical body and the probe arrangement. Preferably, a relative rotation is performed about a central axis of the spherical body. In a particularly preferred embodiment of the invention, the displacement means or displacer comprises a rotation means or rotator realized to rotate the spherical body about a first axis of the spherical body and/or a probe displacement means or displacer realized to displace the probe arrangement relative to the spherical body. In a particularly preferred embodiment of the invention, both a rotation means or rotator and a probe displacement means or displacer are used and simultaneously operated so that the spherical body is rotated about one central axis, while the probe arrangement is being rotated about another central axis of the spherical body.
The relative rotation of the spherical body about the first axis ensures that the succession of test points describes a path over the surface of the spherical body. In a preferred embodiment of the invention, the probe displacement means or probe displacer is realized to simultaneously rotate the probe arrangement about another, different axis of the spherical body. This additional displacement ensures that the path followed by the succession of test points covers more of the surface of the spherical body. The greater coverage of the inspection surface of the spherical body leads to the favorably high PoD for the inventive technique.
In a particularly preferred embodiment of the invention, the first axis and the second axis are orthogonal axes passing through the center of the bearing ball, i.e. the first and second axis are axes of a 3D Cartesian space with its origin at the center of the bearing ball. As a result, a path comprising a series of test points describes a loxodrome on the spherical body. A loxodrome is a spherical spiral path over the surface of the spherical body, from one pole to the diametrically opposite pole.
In a preferred embodiment of the invention, the inspection apparatus comprises a controller realized to control the rates of rotation of the rotating means or rotator and the probe displacement means or displacer. By choosing an appropriate rate of rotation of the bearing ball and an appropriate rate of displacement of the probe arrangement, the path followed by the targeted test points can be made favorably “dense”. For example, by moving the probe arrangement relatively slowly compared to the rotation of the bearing ball, neighboring sections of the spherical spiral path or loxodrome will be close together, giving good inspection coverage. Therefore, the rates of rotation/displacement are preferably set by the controller to achieve a favorably long pole-to-pole length of the loxodrome path traveled by the targeted test points. In one preferred embodiment of the invention, the probe arrangement is moved through 0.5° for every complete revolution of the spherical body about the first axis. A complete loxodrome can be traced by the targeted test points by spinning the bearing ball about the first axis and rotating the probe arrangement about the second orthogonal axis through a space containing one hemisphere of the bearing ball.
The rate of rotation of the spherical body and the rate of displacement of the probe arrangement are chosen to achieve an essentially complete coverage of the surface of the spherical body by a path described by the test points on the surface of the spherical body. A favorably uniform coverage can be ensured by adjusting the rate of rotation of the bearing ball according to the momentary position of the probe arrangement. For example, when the probe arrangement is targeting a test point near a pole of the loxodrome, the bearing ball can be rotated at a relatively fast rate; and when the probe arrangement is targeting a test point near the “equator” of the loxodrome, the bearing ball can be rotated at a relatively slow rate. By adjusting the rotation rate in this way, the rate of travel of the test point can remain essentially constant. These and other aspects will be explained in detail with the aid of the diagrams.
Preferably, the probe arrangement of the inspection apparatus according to embodiments of the invention comprising UT probes that are arranged to achieve specific pulse behaviors. Preferably, the probe arrangement comprises a first UT probe arranged to emit a pulse along a diameter of the spherical body, and at least one second UT probe arranged to emit a pulse along a chord of the spherical body. Preferably, the first UT probe is held to effectively point at the center of sphere such that the pulse emitted by that UT probe enters the bearing ball at the targeted test point, travels on to the far side of the bearing ball as a longitudinal wave, and is reflected back as a longitudinal wave through the test point to the first UT probe. This first UT probe will be referred to as a “longitudinal UT probe” in the following.
In a particularly preferred embodiment of the invention, one or more second UT probes are arranged relative to the longitudinal UT probe such that a pulse emitted by a second UT probe is refracted upon entry into the spherical body to travel as a transverse wave along a chord to the targeted test point on the far side of the bearing ball, and is reflected back as a transverse wave from the test point to the point of entry, and undergoes conversion once again to a longitudinal wave on its path back to the working surface of the UT probe. Such a second UT probe will be referred to as a “transverse UT probe” in the following. Preferably, two transverse UT probes are used in conjunction with a longitudinal UT probe. The probe arrangement in this preferred embodiment preferably comprises a symmetrical arrangement, with the longitudinal UT probe in the center, flanked on each side by a transverse UT probe. All three probes target the same test point on the inspection surface. The use of two transverse UT probes favorably raises the probability of detection of targets that are angled, i.e. directionally sensitive. This preferred probe arrangement can view all angles of a defect or indication, so that the indication will always be at a maximum reflected angle with respect to at least one of the probes during an inspection.
A UT probe initially generates an ultrasonic wave as a longitudinal wave (also referred to as a pressure wave), i.e. the ultrasonic wave leaves the working surface and passes through the couplant as a longitudinal wave. When the UT probe is arranged along a normal to the surface of the object under inspection, the pulse will continue as a longitudinal wave through the object. Embodiments of the invention make use of the refraction that occurs when a longitudinal ultrasonic wave enters the body at an angle to the normal. By arranging a longitudinal UT probe to emit a longitudinal wave through a test point along a diameter of the spherical body, and aligning a further transverse UT probe such that its path of travel (along a chord) intersects the path of travel of the pulse emitted by the longitudinal UT probe at the test point, more detailed data can be collected for the targeted test point.
According to embodiments of the invention, the targeted test point is the point of reflection of a pulse from a transverse UT probe, as well as being the point of entry/exit of a pulse from the longitudinal UT probe. By arranging the longitudinal UT probe and one or more transverse UT probes in this manner, the inspection sensitivity can be significantly increased, since several UT probes are simultaneously collecting information from a single targeted test point.
Preferably, the inspection apparatus according to embodiments of the invention comprises an acquisition unit for recording the reflected ultrasonic signals detected by the UT probes. The acquired data can be analyzed in real-time and/or can be stored for analysis at a later point. Preferably, the inspection apparatus according to embodiments of the invention comprises an analysis unit for analyzing the recorded ultrasonic signals to determine the presence of an anomaly in the spherical body. Alternatively or in addition, the recorded ultrasonic signals can be rendered by an appropriate module of a graphical user interface to allow a visual interpretation of the information.
There are a number of ways of defining a probe position so that its longitudinal wave is converted to a transverse wave (also referred to as a shear wave) upon entry. In a preferred embodiment of the invention, the probe arrangement can be realized to hold a transverse UT probe such that a long axis of that UT probe is parallel to a central axis or diameter of the bearing ball, and offset by a predetermined distance from that central axis. For example, a 14 mm offset has been observed to result in a 45° shear wave through a 60 mm steel bearing ball.
However, in a particularly preferred embodiment of the invention, the probe arrangement can be realized to hold a transverse UT probe such that a long axis of that UT probe subtends a predetermined angle relative to a central axis of the spherical body. This predetermined angle is the angle of incidence associated with the desired angle of refraction, according to Snell's law, and may apply to a steel ball of any diameter. For example, an angle of 18.8° subtended between a central axis and the transverse UT probe has been observed to result in a favourable 45° shear wave through a steel bearing ball.
The offset or subtended angle is preferably determined on the basis of a desired refraction angle of the transverse wave. Other parameters may determine the offset or subtended angle, for example the density of the bearing ball.
In a particularly preferred embodiment of the inspection apparatus according to embodiments of the invention, a UT probe comprises a focused UT probe having a focal length, and the probe arrangement is realised to hold that UT probe at a distance from the spherical body corresponding essentially to the focal length. For example, a 10 MHz 50 mm focused UT probe can be used. The longitudinal UT probe and the transverse UT probe(s) can be of the same type, e.g. each can be a 10 MHz 50 mm focused probe. Alternatively, the longitudinal UT probe and the transverse UT probe(s) can be of different types. For example, a transverse UT probe can have a different frequency and/or a different focal length from the longitudinal UT probe. When two or more transverse UT probes are used, their frequencies and/or focal lengths can be the same, or can be different. However, in a particularly preferred embodiment of the invention, the probe arrangement comprises a set of identical or matched UT probes. This maximizes the inspection sensitivity and results in a favourably high PoD. The frequency of a probe determines the size of a defect that can be detected by that probe. For example, a probe with a certain frequency can detect a 1 mm defect when used as a longitudinal probe in the context of embodiments of the invention. When used as a transverse probe, that frequency allows detection of a 0.5 mm target on account of the altered velocity of the ultrasonic wave after refraction. Preferably, the frequency of the UT probes is chosen on the basis of the minimum defect size to be detected.
The UT probes can be held by the probe arrangement in any suitable configuration that allows a conjunction of the entry/exit point of the longitudinal UT probe and the internal reflection point(s) of the transverse UT probe(s) as described above. In a preferred embodiment of the invention, the UT probes are held in a symmetrical arrangement, for example with the longitudinal UT probe in a plane defined by the first and third axes of the 3D Cartesian space, and with each transverse UT probe held at one angle relative to the longitudinal UT probe, and held at another angle relative to the plane containing the longitudinal UT probe.
The effects of the various parameters for an inspection setup can be modelled using appropriate modelling software to determine a suitable probe arrangement.
Some of the embodiments will be described in detail, with reference to the following figures, wherein like designations denote like members, wherein:
In the diagrams, like numbers refer to like objects throughout. Objects in the diagrams are not necessarily drawn to scale.
The inspection apparatus 1 comprises a ball rotator 100, 101, which causes the ball 2 to rotate about a first axis X passing through the center of the ball 2. A probe displacement means or displacer 110 causes the wing 11 to rotate about a second axis Y that is orthogonal to the first axis X and also passes through the center of the ball 2.
These elements of the inspection apparatus can be placed in an immersion tank 15, as indicated in
In this exemplary arrangement, a transverse probe 11A is held such that the initially longitudinal ultrasonic wave WL subtends an angle of incidence θ1 to a normal N to the surface of the ball 2. This results in an angle of refraction θ2 of the ultrasonic wave on account of the difference in density at the boundary between the couplant and the bearing ball 2. An angle of refraction θ2 of 45° has been observed during tests to result in an optimum shear wave amplitude at the far boundary, i.e. at the targeted test point P. The shear wave WT is reflected at the test point P and travels back to the entry point, where it undergoes refraction once again and conversion to a longitudinal wave, and is subsequently detected at the working surface of the transverse probe 11A. Any flaw or anomaly in the vicinity of the targeted test point P will appear in the detected signal as a departure from the expected pulse arrival time and amplitude. During the inspection procedure, the ball 2 is rotated about an axis above while the probe arrangement is moved about the rotating ball 2. The arrow in the diagram indicates the rotational displacement of this probe 11A relative to the bearing ball 2.
The diagram also shows an initial position and a final position of the transverse probe 11A (dotted lines) for targeted test points at initial and final poles P1, P2 of a spherical spiral or loxodrome traced by the test points during the inspection procedure. The angle of incidence θ1 of the transverse probe 11A remains the same throughout the inspection procedure. For the sake of clarity, the diagram does not show the longitudinal probe 11C and the other transverse probe 11B, since these do not lie in the plane of the page, and it may be assumed that pulses emitted by these other probes 11B, 11C meet at the targeted test point P. The other transverse probe 11B is also held at the desired angle of incidence θ1 as described above.
A portion of a loxodrome L already traced by the targeted test points P (under rotation of the ball and probe arrangement) commencing at an initial pole P1 is indicated as a projection in the lower part of the diagram. The density of the loxodrome L is determined by the rotational speed of the ball and/or the displacement speed of the probe arrangement.
In an alternative approach, the desired refraction angle could be achieved by holding a transverse probe 11A such that its long axis is parallel to a central axis K of the bearing ball 2, but offset from that axis K by a predefined distance Koffset as indicated in the diagram. The angle of refraction will increase as the offset increases. For an offset of 0 mm, no refraction occurs. For a steel bearing ball 2 with a diameter D of 60 mm, an offset of 14 mm has been found to result in the favorable angle of refraction θ2 of 45°.
Furthermore, the sensitivity of the single longitudinal probe 50 on its own is so low that only relatively large flaws can reliably be detected, and smaller but significant flaws of the type described in
Although the present invention has been disclosed in the form of preferred embodiments and variations thereon, it will be understood that numerous additional modifications and variations could be made thereto without departing from the scope of the invention.
For the sake of clarity, it is to be understood that the use of “a” or “an” throughout this application does not exclude a plurality, and “comprising” does not exclude other steps or elements. The mention of a “unit” or a “module” does not preclude the use of more than one unit or module.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/EP2015/062158 | 6/1/2015 | WO | 00 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2016/192770 | 12/8/2016 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3803904 | Diem | Apr 1974 | A |
4281548 | Kober | Aug 1981 | A |
4387596 | Fenkner et al. | Jun 1983 | A |
4801020 | Rogne | Jan 1989 | A |
4969361 | Kawasaki | Nov 1990 | A |
5195372 | Fushimi et al. | Mar 1993 | A |
5398551 | Kawasaki | Mar 1995 | A |
20090019937 | Deemer | Jan 2009 | A1 |
20090282924 | Gotz | Nov 2009 | A1 |
20140318251 | Chatellier | Oct 2014 | A1 |
20150198565 | Chatellier | Jul 2015 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
102003951 | Apr 2011 | CN |
102003951 | Apr 2011 | CN |
07244028 | Sep 1995 | JP |
H07 244 028 | Sep 1995 | JP |
WO-0043769 | Jul 2000 | WO |
Entry |
---|
Machine Translation JPH07244028 (Year: 2019). |
International Search Report and Written Opinion for PCT Application No. PCT/EP2015/062158, dated Feb. 19, 2016. |
Non-English Chinese Office Action for Application No. 201580080602.5, dated Oct. 21, 2019. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20180149620 A1 | May 2018 | US |