Ultrasonic instrument using langevin type transducers to create transverse motion

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 8303613
  • Patent Number
    8,303,613
  • Date Filed
    Friday, December 5, 2008
    16 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, November 6, 2012
    12 years ago
Abstract
A Langevin transducer horn uses split electroding or selective electroding of transducer elements and phase relationships of the voltages applied thereto to determine the relative longitudinal and flexural/transverse motion induced in the tip of the horn.
Description
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

1. The Field of the Invention


The present invention relates to inducing transverse motion at the end of a needle attached to a Langevin transducer horn. More specifically, the present invention relates to an improved Langevin transducer that induces transverse motion along with longitudinal motion.


2. State of the Art


Cataracts are the leading cause of blindness in the world. It is estimated that in the United States, age-related lenticular changes have been reported in 42% of those between 52 and 64, 60% of people between 65 and 74 and 91% of people between 75 and 85. A cataract is an opacity or cloudiness in the lens of the eye.


To address these issues, it has been common for a number of years to remove the lens of the eye. Initially this was done by making a large incision to facilitate removal of the lens and in some cases, replacing the lens with an implant.


In modern cataract surgery, phacoemulsification is a common procedure to facilitate removal of the damaged lens. Phacoemulsification involves using an ultrasonic handpiece to emulsify the cataract in the eye while the eye is irrigated with a balanced salt solution. The emulsified lens is aspirated and a prosthetic intraocular lens implant is inserted where the original lens was. This procedure has substantially reduced the size of the incision necessary in the eye and has significantly reduced recuperation time for patients.


In a conventional phacoemulsification handpiece, a hollow, resonating horn and a hollow needle attached thereto are disposed in communication with an aspirating line which suctions emulsified material through the center of the horn. The horn is disposed in a housing which typically includes an irrigation portion for introducing fluid around the horn and into the patient's eye.


A number of piezoelectric elements (often ceramic piezoelectric elements), typically referred to as a stack, are disposed adjacent each other about the horn. When the piezoelectric stack is subjected to an oscillating voltage, the ceramic piezoelectric elements expand and contract, thereby causing rapid longitudinal movement (i.e. longitudinal vibration at ultrasonic frequencies) in the horn and thereby in a needle which is attached at a distal end of the horn. The longitudinal vibration is used to emulsify the cataractous lens, allowing the cataract to be removed.


It is believed that transverse motion of the hand piece tip aids in phacoemulsification. There have been numerous attempts to create transverse motion during tissue removal. See e.g. U.S. Pat. No. 6,402,769 (Boukhny et al); U.S. Pat. No. 5,722,945 (Anis et al.); U.S. Pat. No. 5,222,959 (Anis et al); U.S. Pat. No. 4,504,264 (Kelman); and U.S. Patent Pub. 2006/0041220. In order to achieve out-of-plane motion in the horn, other inventors have created torsional motion in the horn and converted the torsional motion to transverse motion via a special bent needle. This torsional motion may be created through a separate ceramic stack, a configuration creating torsional motion with the stack or through slits made in the horn which change the geometry of the transducer. These methods introduce mechanical loss through conversion of torsional motion to transverse motion and appear to increase costs, and require the use of a bent needle to convert the torsional motion to a transverse motion. Furthermore, each requires changes to conventional handpiece design.


Thus, there is a need for a method for producing transverse movement in the horn and/or a needle attached to a horn. Preferably, such a method should be relatively low cost, not require major changes to existing handpiece design, and work with existing needles.


SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

It is an object of the present invention to provide an improved Langevin transducer that induces transverse motion along with longitudinal motion.


According to one aspect of the invention, transverse motion is induced in the tip of a Langevin horn by split electrodes on the face of ceramic elements. More specifically, out of phase voltage signals are applied to the split electrodes, inducing out of phase strain in the material. This out of phase strain creates flexural motion in the horn. More specifically, when the voltage signals applied to the split electrodes are 180 degrees out of phase, one side of the transducer expands while the opposing side contracts. This induces flexural motion in the horn, creating transverse (lateral) motion at the end of the needle. When the applied voltage signals are in phase, longitudinal motion is induced in the horn. Thus, a Langevin transducer can provide both longitudinal and transverse motion without changing the geometry of the transducer stack and without adding a dedicated transducer for creating flexural or other transverse motion.


According to another aspect of the invention, transverse motion and longitudinal motion are induced at the tip of the Langevin horn by selectively applying voltage to selected opposing sides of transducers along the stack. By regulating the application of voltage to the various crystals, both longitudinal and transverse motion can be controlled.


According to another aspect of the invention, the amount of flexural motion (and thus transverse motion at the end of the needle) versus longitudinal motion is adjustable according to the voltage phase between the voltage signals applied to the crystals.


According to another aspect of the invention, the ceramic electrodes may be segmented into 3 or more isolated conductors. By regulating the phase of the drive signal to the conductors various different types of motion may be induced in the horn, and thus in the tip of the needle attached to the horn.


These and other aspects of the present invention are realized in an improved Langevin transducer that induces transverse motion due to flexural mode of the handpiece along with longitudinal motion as shown and described in the following figures and related description.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

Various embodiments of the present invention are shown and described in reference to the numbered drawings wherein:



FIG. 1 shows a cross-section of a phacoemulsification horn with Langevin transducers and indicates a coordinate frame of reference;



FIG. 2 shows a perspective view of a Langevin transducer element in accordance with the invention;



FIG. 3 shows a side view of a plurality of transducer elements configured in accordance with one aspect of the present invention;



FIG. 4 shows a side view of a plurality of transducer elements configured in accordance with another aspect of the present invention; and



FIG. 5 shows a Langevin transducer assembly formed in accordance with the present invention and disposed inside of a phacoemulsification handpiece.





It will be appreciated that the drawings are illustrative and not limiting of the scope of the invention which is defined by the appended claims. The embodiments shown accomplish various aspects and objects of the invention. It is appreciated that it may not be possible to clearly show each element and aspect of the invention in a single figure, and as such, multiple figures are presented to separately illustrate the various details of the invention in greater clarity. Similarly, not every embodiment need accomplish all advantages of the present invention.


DETAILED DESCRIPTION

The invention and accompanying drawings will now be discussed in reference to the numerals provided therein so as to enable one skilled in the art to practice the present invention. The drawings and descriptions are exemplary of various aspects of the invention and are not intended to narrow the scope of the appended claims.


Turning now to FIG. 1, a cross section of a phacoemulsification horn 5 is shown. In normal use, the horn 5 would be disposed inside of a handpiece and would thus have a housing disposed about it for grasping by a surgeon. A needle would be attached at the right end of the horn 5, and an aspiration tube would be attached at the opposing end. The use of such phacoemulsification handpieces is well known and is therefore not specifically shown in FIG. 1.


Disposed about the horn 5 are a number of transducer elements 10 disposed in a stack 50. As discussed herein, the transducer elements are typically, though not necessarily, a flat, annular, piece of piezoelectric ceramic, and an oscillating voltage potential is applied to the opposing faces of the ceramic element in order to cause oscillating expansion and contraction of the ceramic element. In a conventional stack of transducer elements 10, the transducer elements would be subject to an oscillating voltage 10. This would cause expansion and contraction of the transducer elements 10 and cause longitudinal movement of the horn 5 along the X axis as designated by the reference coordinates indicated at 40.


According to the present invention, it has been found that the same basic stack geometry can be used to create transverse (lateral) motion of the tip of a phacoemulsification needle, i.e. transverse oscillating motion in the Y axis—designated at 30—due to the formation of flexural motion of the horn. Unlike prior art attempts, special stack geometries and/or slits to promote torsional motion are not required. Thus a conventional horn, a conventional handpiece and a conventional needle can still be used while producing a lateral oscillation of the needle tip by using a transducer stack as shown in the present invention.


According to the present invention, a transducer stack 50 is provided which allows for both longitudinal and lateral motion of the needle tip by selecting the manner in which electricity is applied to the transducer stack. The phase relationship of the oscillating voltage applied to different portions of the transducer stack 50 allows for a choice of flexural (transverse) and/or longitudinal oscillation of the needle tip. According to a preferred stack configuration, if in phase oscillating voltages are applied to the transducer stack 50, the tip 20 of the horn 5 will oscillate longitudinally in the X direction while if 180 degrees out of phase oscillating voltages are applied to opposing sides of the transducer elements 10, one side of the transducer elements will expand while the other side contracts. The uneven expansion and contraction causes the tip 20 of the horn 10 to oscillate transversely as shown at 30, thereby creating transverse motion.


Should out of phase oscillating voltages be applied that are out of phase by an angle other than 180 degrees, the tip 20 can be made to oscillate both longitudinally and transversely 30. The phase relationship determines the amount of relative flexural/transverse and longitudinal oscillation. Phase relationships closer to 0 will oscillate more in the longitudinal direction, while phase relationships closer to 180 will oscillate more in the flexural direction.


Turning to FIG. 2, a perspective view of a single piezoelectric transducer element 10 is shown in accordance with the invention. The transducer element 10 is typically a flat annular shape, the horn passing through the hole 210 in the transducer element. Typically, the two flat opposed sides of the ceramic disc are coated with a metal such as silver to thereby form electrodes, i.e. electrical contacts, on the two sides of the ceramic element. The electrical potential between the two sides of the ceramic material causes the physical expansion of the material. According to one aspect of the present invention, the two halves of the transducer element 10 are electrically insulated from one another. Each transducer element portion 10a, 10b has one or more electrodes 240a, 240b and corresponding electrical leads 230a, 230b attached thereto, through which a different voltage 210a, 210b may be applied. Dividing the piezoelectric element into separate regions allows a different (oscillating) voltage potential to be applied to each region to thereby alter the motion of the needle tip. For example, a larger voltage potential may be applied to one side 10a of the piezoelectric element 10 than is applied to the other side 10b, causing side 10a to expand more than side 10b. Alternatively, the voltages may be applied out of phase to the sides of the piezoelectric element 10, such as applying the opposite voltage polarity to side 10b as compared to side 10a (an oscillating voltage which is 180 degrees out of phase) such that side 10a expands while side 10b contracts and vice versa.


The transducer element 10 may also be divided into more than two electrically isolated portions, as indicated by dashed lines 220. Typically, the transducer element 10 would be divided radially into symmetrical active regions (such as pie shaped wedges). Thus, the transducer element could be divided into 3, 4, or more active regions, each having separate electrodes 240 and electrical leads 230. Having 3 or 4 different active regions may allow for other types of motion to be produced at the phacoemulsification needle, depending on how the transducer element regions are driven. Although FIG. 2 shows a unitary piece of ceramic with electrically isolated electrodes 240, the ceramic may also be divided into separate pieces for each electrically isolated portion of the transducer element 10.


According to a preferred method of driving the piezoelectric elements 10, a wave form voltage potential (such as a sinusoidal or a square wave) is applied to the ceramic elements, and the wave form may be phase shifted between different halves of one or more ceramic elements to cause differing expansion of the ceramic element. When the plurality of oscillating voltages 210 are in phase between the two halves, the corresponding portions of the transducer 10 expand and contract in phase, producing longitudinal oscillations. When the plurality of oscillating voltages are out of phase, the corresponding portions 10a and 10b of the transducer expand and contract out of phase, causing out of phase movement of the portions 10a and 10b of the transducer and inducing a bending of the horn. The bending of the horn provides flexural oscillation.


It will be appreciated that, by controlling the phase, the relative longitudinal motion to transverse motion can be controlled. Thus, a surgeon could, in real time, adjust the ratio of longitudinal and transverse motion being produced in the horn to better accommodate the particularities or the surgery or the simple preferences of the surgeon. Additionally, such control is accomplished without requiring special transducer configurations or stacks dedicated to creating torsional motion.


As an alternative to the transducer element shown in FIG. 2, a transducer element may be made of two discrete halves 10a and 10b rather than one piece of ceramic with electrically separated electrodes 240. Additionally, one half 10a may be an active ceramic element and the other half (such as 10b) may be a non piezoelectric ceramic such as alumina.


Turning now to FIG. 3, there is shown a slightly exploded side view of a transducer stack 50 formed in accordance with the principles of the present invention. The transducer elements 10 have been formed so as to have electrically isolated portions 10a and 10b. A plurality of electrodes 240a, 240b, and electrical leads 230a, 230b are used to independently apply electricity to the portions 10a and 10b of the transducer elements 10. By electrically stimulating portions of the transducer elements out of phase with other portions, flexural motion can be induced in a horn (as shown in FIG. 1) which is connected to the stack. Thus, for example, all of the portions 10a could have a voltage applied which caused these portions of the transducer elements to expand, while all of the portions 10b simultaneously have the opposite polarity of voltage applied so as to cause those portions of the transducer elements to contract. This would cause expansion on the left side of the stack and contraction on the right. The expansion and contraction would cause the horn to bend to the right of the axis A-A, thereby providing flexural and transverse motion. By selectively expanding some of the portions and contracting others, the horn can be driven in both longitudinal and flexural motions. This can be achieved, for example, by expanding the first two portions 10a and the last two portions 10b. By adjusting the ratios and how out of phase the portions expand and contract, the flexural and longitudinal oscillations can be controlled.


It will be appreciated that, depending on the level of control over the motion of the transducer horn and needle, all of the transducer element halves 10a, 10b may be independently driven, or some or all of the transducer element halves 10a, 10b, may be wired together and driven together. Thus, some or all of element halves 10a may be wired together and some or all of element halves 10b may be wired together.


Turning to FIG. 4, an alternate configuration of the stack is shown. Rather than electrically isolating portions of the transducer element electrodes 240 as is shown in FIG. 3, the electrodes 240 are disposed on opposing sides of only a portion of transducer element and not on the remainder of the transducer element. Thus, as shown in FIG. 4, the electrodes 240a, 240b are disposed on the left side of the top two transducer elements 10a and on the right side of the lower two transducer elements 10b. Applying a voltage to the top two transducer elements 10b will cause expansion on the left side, while applying voltage to the bottom two transducer elements 10a will cause expansion on the right side (or contraction on those sides with the opposite voltage polarity being applied). The uneven expansion of the transducer elements may be used to create transverse motion in addition to longitudinal motion. By controlling the extent to which the expansion and contraction is out of phase between the different transducer element groups, control is provided to either enhance or minimize longitudinal and flexural motion.


Additionally, the stack may be constructed as is shown in FIG. 3 but driven as is shown in FIG. 4, where only a portion of the transducer element sections 10a, 10b are driven. These transducer sections are selected based upon the type of motion which is to be produced in the needle tip.



FIG. 5 shows a cross-sectional view of an ultrasonic hand piece 250. The handpiece includes a body 254 and a horn 20 as are commonly available. The body 254 includes an irrigation channel 258 for irrigating the eye during phacoemulsification. The liquid and emulsified cataract are drawn through the lumen 100 in the needle 104 and on through the channel 108 in the horn 20.


The transducer elements 10 can be configured in either manner discussed with respect to FIGS. 2 through 4. They are driven to create both longitudinal and flexural motion in the horn 20 as is desired. Because they can be formed in substantially the same configuration as a conventional stack of transducer elements, the transducer elements 10 can be used without significant modification to a conventional hand piece 250 or horn 20. Thus, longitudinal and flexural motion can be provided by simply replacing a conventional stack with a stack formed in accordance with the principles of the present invention.


A typical prior art phacoemulsification transducer stack is driven by applying an oscillating voltage to the transducer stack. The transducer elements may all be driven together from the same voltage waveform. According to the present invention, the different segments of the transducer elements may be driven separately to alter the type of motion which is produced by the needle. Thus, control circuitry for a phacoemulsification handpiece of the present invention may include two waveform generators and a control circuit to vary the phase delay between the two produced waveforms. In driving the transducer elements, it will often be the case that different frequencies of wave form will be required to optimally drive the transducer elements in the longitudinal vibration and lateral vibration modes of operation. It is typically desirable to drive the transducer elements at a frequency which is sympathetic to the harmonis frequencies of the horn and needle, and these may have different harmonic frequencies for longitudinal versus lateral vibration. Thus, a simplified control circuit could be made which either drives the transducer elements in phase with each other to produce longitudinal vibration and a first frequency or drives the transducer elements out of phase as discussed to produce lateral vibration using a second different frequency.


Alternatively, the control circuit could have a single waveform generator and a control circuit to separate the waveform signal into two signals and to delay one of the signals relative to the other signal. Thus, according to one embodiment of the invention, one of the resultant waveforms is applied to transducer element portions 10a (via electrical leads 230a and electrodes 240a) and the other resultant waveform is applied to transducer element portion 10b. It will be appreciated that some of the above methods of operation, such as a variable phase delay or the same frequency for in phase versus out of phase use, may result in a less efficient driving of the transducer elements. As these modes of operation may result in other advantages, they may still be employed.


Where the ceramic electrodes are segmented into 3 or more isolated conductors, various types of motion may be induced in the needle tip by regulating the phase of the drive signal to the 3 conductors. Various different types of motion other than longitudinal motion may be created, as well as combinations of these motions. The use of multiple isolated electrode segments allows for the creation of different types of motion, as well as the direction and speed the motion. The 3 conductors may be driven at a different frequencies, or with a non-oscillating signals superimposed on the oscillating common mode signal which produces longitudinal motion.


While it has been primarily discussed above that the isolated portions of the transducer elements 10 are driven by out of phase voltage waveforms to create lateral oscillation of the needle tip, these same portions of the transducer element could also be driven by in phase voltage waveforms of differing magnitude to produce lateral vibration of the needle tip. Out of phase waveforms typically produce the maximum amount of lateral vibration in the needle tip and in phase waveforms of differing magnitudes typically produce a mixture of longitudinal and lateral vibration. Thus, a mixture of longitudinal and lateral vibration may be created by driving the transducer element portions with an in phase waveform with a different maximum voltage, and the relative amounts of longitudinal and lateral motion may be controlled by varying the difference in the voltages (amplitudes) of the waveforms applied to the transducer element sections. Thus, different types and combinations of longitudinal and transverse needle motions can be created by using combinations of waveform amplitude, frequency, and phasing and by selectively applying these waveform signals to the individual portions of the ceramic transducer elements.


The person using the phacoemulsification handpiece can adjust the phase angle between the two waveforms via the control circuit. If the phase angle is 0 degrees, the waveforms are aligned in time and the polarity of the voltages applied to the transducer portions 10a, 10b is the same, resulting in longitudinal movement of the needle tip. If the phase angle is 180 degrees, the two waveforms are completely out of phase such that the voltage polarity applied to transducer elements 10a is opposite that applied to transducer elements 10b, resulting largely in lateral motion of the needle tip. If the phase angle is between 0 and 180 degrees, a combination of longitudinal and lateral motion is produced.


There is thus disclosed an improved Langevin type transducer that induces flexural/transverse motion along with longitudinal motion, and allows a user to select the type of motion produced at the tip of a phacoemulsification handpiece. It will be appreciated that numerous changes may be made to the present invention without departing from the scope of the claims. The appended claims are intended to cover such modifications.

Claims
  • 1. An ultrasonic surgical instrument comprising: a horn body having a working member attached to an end thereof;a piezoelectric transducer element attached to the horn body such that excitation of the piezoelectric element causes vibration of the working member;a first pair of electrodes attached to top and bottom sides of a first portion of the transducer element such that the electrodes form an active area on the transducer element which covers the first portion of the transducer element and which does not cover a second portion of the transducer element such that when voltage is applied to said first pair of electrodes said first portion expands differently than said second portion; anda second pair of electrodes attached to the second portion of the transducer element, wherein the first portion and the second portion are electrically isolated from each other.
  • 2. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 1, further comprising a control circuit connected to the first portion and the second portion of the transducer element, the control circuit being configured for applying a first voltage waveform to the first portion and a second voltage waveform different from the first voltage waveform to the second portion such that the first portion expands differently than the second portion.
  • 3. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 2, wherein the first voltage waveform and second voltage waveform are opposite polarity.
  • 4. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 2, wherein the first voltage waveform and second voltage waveform have different voltage magnitudes.
  • 5. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 2, wherein the control circuit allows a user to vary the phase angle between the first voltage waveform and the second voltage waveform.
  • 6. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 2, wherein the first voltage waveform and the second voltage waveform are out of phase with one another.
  • 7. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 2, wherein the control circuit is selectable between a first mode of operation where the first voltage waveform and the second voltage waveform are out of phase and a second mode of operation where the first voltage waveform and the second voltage waveform are in phase.
  • 8. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 7, wherein, in the first mode of operation the first and second waveforms are at a first frequency and in the second mode of operation the first and second waveforms are at a second frequency different than the first frequency.
  • 9. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 1, wherein the first portion and the second portion of the transducer element are disposed on generally opposing halves of the transducer element such that applying out of phase voltages to the first and second portions of the transducer element causes uneven expansion or contraction between the halves of the transducer element.
  • 10. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 1 wherein the instrument comprises a plurality of transducer elements disposed in a series along the horn.
  • 11. The surgical ultrasonic instrument of claim 1, wherein the second portion has a second pair of electrodes attached to top and bottom sides thereof which are electrically insulated from the pair of electrodes attached to the first portion.
  • 12. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 1, wherein the ultrasonic instrument is a phacoemulsification handpiece.
  • 13. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 1, wherein the horn has a needle is attached to one end of the horn and an aspiration tube is attached to an opposing end of the horn.
  • 14. An ultrasonic surgical instrument comprising: a body;a horn at least partially disposed in the body;a piezoelectric transducer disposed adjacent the horn; anda first pair of electrodes attached to the top and bottom of a first part of the piezoelectric transducer so as to form a first active portion,a second pair of electrodes attached to the top and bottom of a second part of the piezoelectric transducer so as to form a second active portion; and whereinthe first and second active portions are electrically isolated from one another and electrical signals may be applied thereto independent of one another.
  • 15. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 14, further comprising a control circuit for supplying out of phase voltages to the first and second active portions.
  • 16. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 14, further comprising a second piezoelectric transducer which has first and second electrically isolated active portions defined by first and second electrode pairs attached to top and bottom surfaces of the respective first and second active portions.
  • 17. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 14, wherein the first active portion comprises a first half of the piezoelectric transducer and the second active portion comprises a second half of the piezoelectric transducer.
  • 18. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 14, wherein the piezoelectric transducer comprises a plurality of active regions which are positioned radially about the horn.
  • 19. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 14, wherein out of phase voltages are applied to the first active portion and the second active portion so as to cause uneven expansion in the first and second active portions.
  • 20. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 19, further comprising a control circuit which provides a first voltage waveform to the first active portion and a second different voltage waveform to the second active portion.
  • 21. The ultrasonic surgical instrument of claim 19, wherein the control circuit allows a user to vary the phase angle between the first and second wave voltages.
RELATED APPLICATIONS

The present application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 61/012,239, filed Dec. 7, 2007, which is expressly incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.

US Referenced Citations (148)
Number Name Date Kind
2704333 Calosi et al. Mar 1955 A
2974296 Rosen Mar 1961 A
3090222 Akaboshi et al. May 1963 A
3450476 Rando Jun 1969 A
3588859 Petree Jun 1971 A
3689783 Williams Sep 1972 A
3694675 Loveday Sep 1972 A
3805787 Banko Apr 1974 A
3939360 Jackson Feb 1976 A
3974681 Namery Aug 1976 A
3987674 Baumoel Oct 1976 A
4002996 Kebanoff et al. Jan 1977 A
4032803 Durr et al. Jun 1977 A
4083038 Kebanoff Apr 1978 A
4144517 Baumoel Mar 1979 A
4169984 Parisi et al. Oct 1979 A
4183007 Baird Jan 1980 A
4193004 Lobdell et al. Mar 1980 A
4280126 White Jul 1981 A
4312341 Zissimopoulos et al. Jan 1982 A
4316465 Dotson Feb 1982 A
4559454 Kramer Dec 1985 A
4577629 Martinez Mar 1986 A
4580448 Skrgatic Apr 1986 A
4631529 Zeitz Dec 1986 A
4663965 Metcalf et al. May 1987 A
4749988 Berman et al. Jun 1988 A
4753234 Martinez Jun 1988 A
4804364 Dieras Feb 1989 A
4821558 Pastrone et al. Apr 1989 A
4829448 Balding et al. May 1989 A
4833918 Jean et al. May 1989 A
4838853 Parisi Jun 1989 A
4861332 Parsi Aug 1989 A
4870953 DonMicheal et al. Oct 1989 A
4881487 Moore Nov 1989 A
4884065 Crouse et al. Nov 1989 A
4896099 Suzuki Jan 1990 A
4897079 Zaleski et al. Jan 1990 A
4908676 Bedell et al. Mar 1990 A
4920336 Meijer Apr 1990 A
4931047 Broadwin Jun 1990 A
4979952 Kubota et al. Dec 1990 A
4983901 Lehmer Jan 1991 A
4998022 Tregay Mar 1991 A
5011471 Miyazaki et al. Apr 1991 A
5015227 Broadwin May 1991 A
5026387 Thomas Jun 1991 A
5037386 Marcus et al. Aug 1991 A
5053747 Slate et al. Oct 1991 A
5074659 Suzuki et al. Dec 1991 A
5098387 Wiest et al. Mar 1992 A
5112300 Ureche May 1992 A
5116759 Klainer et al. May 1992 A
5121628 Merkl et al. Jun 1992 A
5123903 Quaid et al. Jun 1992 A
5160317 Costin Nov 1992 A
5178605 Imonti Jan 1993 A
5180363 Idemoto et al. Jan 1993 A
5182947 Fidelak et al. Feb 1993 A
5190517 Zieve et al. Mar 1993 A
5236414 Takasu Aug 1993 A
5260665 Goldberg et al. Nov 1993 A
5261883 Hood et al. Nov 1993 A
5268624 Zanger Dec 1993 A
5278471 Uehara et al. Jan 1994 A
5295120 McShane Mar 1994 A
5303585 Lichte Apr 1994 A
5305237 Dalrymple et al. Apr 1994 A
5331951 Kepley Jul 1994 A
5344420 Hilal et al. Sep 1994 A
5370602 Kepley Dec 1994 A
5388569 Kepley Feb 1995 A
5413556 Whittingham et al. May 1995 A
5417672 Nita et al. May 1995 A
5438868 Holden et al. Aug 1995 A
5442495 Saito et al. Aug 1995 A
5449370 Vaitekunas Sep 1995 A
5453087 Malinowski Sep 1995 A
5456887 Calvo et al. Oct 1995 A
5472447 Abrams et al. Dec 1995 A
5499077 Endo et al. Mar 1996 A
5514087 Jones May 1996 A
5514102 Winterer et al. May 1996 A
5534708 Ellinger et al. Jul 1996 A
5554894 Sepielli Sep 1996 A
5557368 Endo et al. Sep 1996 A
5562610 Brumbach Oct 1996 A
5649935 Kremer et al. Jul 1997 A
5672887 Shaw et al. Sep 1997 A
5680111 Danby et al. Oct 1997 A
5728130 Ishikawa et al. Mar 1998 A
5746756 Bromfield et al. May 1998 A
5764356 Iwase et al. Jun 1998 A
5798050 Gaynes et al. Aug 1998 A
5814922 Uchino et al. Sep 1998 A
5843109 Mehta et al. Dec 1998 A
5844587 Ando et al. Dec 1998 A
5879364 Bromfield et al. Mar 1999 A
5921999 Dileo Jul 1999 A
5983749 Holtorf Nov 1999 A
6064577 Moskowitz et al. May 2000 A
6068612 Bowman et al. May 2000 A
6069433 Lazarus et al. May 2000 A
6142008 Cole et al. Nov 2000 A
6150623 Chen Nov 2000 A
6179829 Bisch Jan 2001 B1
6251113 Appelbaum et al. Jun 2001 B1
6260434 Holtorf Jul 2001 B1
6346764 Boyd Feb 2002 B1
6360630 Holtorf Mar 2002 B2
6452123 Chen Sep 2002 B1
6478766 Chon Nov 2002 B1
6531708 Malmstrom et al. Mar 2003 B1
6543885 Bahl et al. Apr 2003 B2
6602193 Chon Aug 2003 B2
6674030 Chen et al. Jan 2004 B2
6709392 Salgo et al. Mar 2004 B1
6740058 Lal et al. May 2004 B2
6750468 Malmstrom et al. Jun 2004 B2
6852092 Kadziauskas et al. Feb 2005 B2
6921385 Clements et al. Jul 2005 B2
6932114 Sparks Aug 2005 B2
7012203 Hanson et al. Mar 2006 B2
7152482 Ueno et al. Dec 2006 B2
7169123 Kadziauskas et al. Jan 2007 B2
7470277 Finlay et al. Dec 2008 B2
20020138080 Chon Sep 2002 A1
20020161326 Sussman Oct 2002 A1
20020192111 Divino, Jr. et al. Dec 2002 A1
20020193817 Lal et al. Dec 2002 A1
20030055375 Holst et al. Mar 2003 A1
20030073980 Finlay et al. Apr 2003 A1
20040019318 Wilson et al. Jan 2004 A1
20040024412 Clements Feb 2004 A1
20040092922 Kadziauskas et al. May 2004 A1
20040197223 Olsen et al. Oct 2004 A1
20050228423 Khashayar et al. Oct 2005 A1
20050228424 Khashayar et al. Oct 2005 A1
20050234407 Spohn et al. Oct 2005 A1
20060036180 Boukhny et al. Feb 2006 A1
20060145540 Mezhinsky Jul 2006 A1
20060219049 Horvath et al. Oct 2006 A1
20080281253 Injev et al. Nov 2008 A1
20080294087 Steen et al. Nov 2008 A1
20090005712 Raney Jan 2009 A1
20100069825 Raney Mar 2010 A1
20100069828 Steen et al. Mar 2010 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (10)
Number Date Country
3241033 May 1984 DE
1 704 839 Sep 2006 EP
2249419 May 1992 GB
61 3012 Jan 1986 JP
61-3012 Jan 1986 JP
1388002 Apr 1988 SU
WO 2008060859 May 2008 WO
WO 2008147771 Dec 2008 WO
WO 2010014937 Feb 2010 WO
WO 2010014942 Feb 2010 WO
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20090149801 A1 Jun 2009 US
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
61012239 Dec 2007 US