Patent Application
20200332205
The present invention relates in general to the field of feedstock disposal including sewage sludge treatment (SST), municipal solid waste (MSW) management, wood waste (WW) processing, refuse derived fuels (RDF) treatment, Automotive Shredder Residue (ASR) and non-recyclable plastics disposal (NRP). Target markets for the present invention include municipalities, landfill operators that clean up and rehabilitate land, waste generators, wastewater treatment facilities, agricultural waste generators, private waste service companies and entrepreneurs invested in renewable energy.
Currently the combination of a fluidized bed or bubbling bed gasifier include a feeder system for biosolids that are designed for a single specific feedstock. It is a common practice in the industry that these gasification systems have similar feeder devices but require specialized design features to accommodate specific feedstock related to their respective handling requirements. These are often cumbersome, complex and expensive. What's needed is a standardized device and method of feeding diverse feedstock into the reactor chambers of any gasifier.
The invention is a standardized feeder system designed for a gasifier system to enable different feedstock materials to be fed to existing gasification reactors without having to custom design the feed system or integrate the feeder into the reactor. The present invention is a universal feeder system that combines with a fluidized bed gasification reactor for the treatment of multiple or mixed feedstocks including but not limited to sewage sludge, municipal solid waste, wood waste, refuse derived fuels, automotive shredder residue and non-recyclable plastics. The invention thereby also illustrates a method of gasification for multiple and/or diverse feedstocks using a universal feeder system.
The feeder system consists of one or more feed vessels attached to a live bottom dual screw feeder. In one embodiment, the feed vessel is rectangular shaped having three vertical sides and an angled side of no less than 60 degrees from the horizontal to facilitate proper flow of bio-feedstock materials that have different and/or variable flow properties. The vessel also provides for aeration mechanisms such as provided by inserting removable bridge breakers to safeguard flows. The biosolids are transferred from the live bottom dual screw feeder through a chute and into a secondary transfer screw feeder that conveys the material to a feed nozzle operably connected to a gasifier reactor. The secondary transfer screw is equipped with a coolant jacket to maintain a feed temperature between 60° F.-200° F. further expanding the types of feedstock that can be conveyed into a gasifier reactor.
This invention allows for standardizing equipment design and commoditization in the gasification industry by providing a path for simpler gasifier design with fewer equipment components. The universal feeder system may be used in open air, under ambient pressure and low temperature conditions. Where odor control is required, the systems can be fitted with a removable standard containment panel. In the case of biosolids, this design of the system may be a closed system from the feed bin into the gasifier to address odor control. Explosion panels are also optional for explosible dusts.
The invention is used for receiving and conveying bio-feedstock materials into any bioreactor. The feeder system is specifically suitable for categories of waste currently being landfilled, that could be incinerated if permitting new incinerations were possible or that have restricted recycling options to safely and fully dispose of these waste materials. The present invention can be used by municipalities, landfill operators that clean up and rehabilitate land, waste generators, wastewater treatment facilities, agricultural waste generators, private waste service companies and entrepreneurs invested in renewable energy. It could also be used in analogous non-gasification processes to convey metered solids to storage tanks, for desegregation in recycling of waste.
Currently there is no prior art of a single universal feeder/gasifier system capable of processing a broad range of feedstocks. Prior art dictates providing for custom designed feedstock-specific feeder systems to handle a specific type of feedstock. This in turn leads to modification and redesign of the gasifier. The present invention solves this problem and in addition, the present design can switch between different bio-feedstocks during operations.
The foregoing and other objects, features, and advantages of the invention will be apparent from the following more particular description of preferred embodiments as illustrated in the accompanying drawings, in which reference characters refer to the same parts throughout the various views. The drawings are not necessarily to scale, emphasis instead being placed upon illustrating principles of the invention. Reference will now be made in detail to the various exemplary embodiments of the present invention, which are illustrated in the accompanying drawings.
Screw feeder 102 also called screw conveyors and are used to control the flow rate of both free and non-free flowing, bulk material from a bin, silo or hopper. Live bottom feeders are specifically designed to convey and meter large quantities of materials in a very efficient manner. During operation the inlet section of the screw trough 102A is designed to be flooded with a selected material. The screw under the inlet can be modified to convey a metered amount of material per revolution of the screw. Modifications include but are not limited to in the flighting diameter, pitch, pipe diameter, trough shape. Screws with uniform diameter and pitch will convey material from the rear of the inlet opening to the front. The drives on screw feeders attached to the rear end, are usually variable speed, so that the discharge from a bin, hopper or feed vessel 101 that falls onto the screw feeder 102 and trough 102A can be adjusted, as required, to stay within a prescribed range. Depending on the number of screws across the bottom of the bin, hopper or feed vessel 101, there may be one drive for all the screws, several drives with the screws driven in-groups or individual drives for each screw. In one embodiment, the dual live bottom screw feeder 102 is configured to convey the material from the feed vessel 101 in two different directions to one of two secondary transfer screw feeders 103 as shown in
The biosolids are transferred by gravity from the live bottom dual screw feeder 102 through an open bottom chute 111 and onto a secondary transfer screw feeder 103 that conveys the material to a feed nozzle 106 operably connected such as by a flange to flange connection to a fuel feed inlet 201 located on the gasifier reactor vessel 299. In one embodiment, the secondary transfer screw 103 is configured perpendicular to the live bottom dual screw feeder 102 as shown in
In one embodiment, the live bottom dual screw feeder 102 can operate to direct the flow of feedstock in a single direction. In another embodiment, the dual screw feeder 102 can operate to direct flow of feedstock in two different directions. The feedstock can be fed into a gasifier reactor vessel 299 from more than one feed vessel 101 through multiple fuel feed inlets 201 located on the gasifier reactor vessel 299. A live bottom dual screw feeder 102 may therefore feed two separate transfer screw feeders 103; but the transfer screw feeder 103 may also connect and feed another secondary or even tertiary transfer screw feeder 103 as shown in
The feed vessels 101 may also be sized such that appropriately distributed volumes of feedstock are maintained entering the gasifier through multiple feed ports. The fuel feed inlets 201, also called feed ports, may be placed all around the gasifier vessel reactor 299 to ensure a continuous feed of fuel into the gasifier system 200. The feed vessel 101 inventory may be controlled through load cells or level sensors 105 (shown on
In one embodiment, the feeder system 100 is capable of receiving and processing multiple feedstocks prepared to a size up to one inch with an optimal range between 1/16 and ¼ inches. A key requirement of this embodiment is prepping the feedstock to a uniform size, moisture content and quality which is achieved through conventional processes. Prepared feedstock is then introduced into the vessel feed port 109 of the universal feeder vessel 101 and ultimately the gasification reactor vessel 299 for gasification.
In continued refence to
The reactor fluidized bed section 204 of a fluidized bubbling bed gasifier 200 is filled with a fluidizing media 204A that may be a sand (e.g., quartz or olivine), or any other suitable fluidizing media known in the industry. Feedstock such as, but not limited to dried biosolids, is supplied to the reactor bed section 204 through fuel feed inlets 201 at 40-250° F. In one embodiment, the feedstock is supplied to the reactor bed section 204 through fuel feed inlets 201 at 215° F.; with the gas inlet 203 in the bubbling bed receiving an oxidant-based fluidization gas such as but not limited to e.g., air. In one embodiment, the air could be enriched air, or a mix of air and recycled flue gas, etc. The air is not pre-heated, it is fed at ambient conditions. The bed is heated up with natural gas and air combustion from a start-up burner and when the bed reaches its ignition temperature for gasification the reactions takes off and is self-sustaining so long as feed carbon and oxygen continue to react. The fluidization gas is fed to the bubbling bed via a gas distributor, such as shown in
In one embodiment, a freeboard section 205 is provided between the fluidized bed section 204 and the producer gas outlet 210 of the gasifier reactor vessel 299. As the biosolids thermally decompose and transform in the fluidized bed media section (or sand zone) into producer gas and then rise through the reactor vessel 299, the fluidizing medium 204A in the fluidized bed section 204 is disentrained from the producer gas in the freeboard section 205 which is also known as and called a particle disengaging zone. A cyclone separator 207 may be provided to separate material exhausted from the fluidized bed reactor 299 resulting in clean producer gas for recovery with ash exiting the bottom of the cyclone separator 207 alternatively for use or disposal.
An ash grate 211 may be fitted below the gasifier vessel for bottom ash removal. The ash grate 211 may be used as a sifting device to remove any large inert, agglomerated or heavy particles so that the fluidizing media and unreacted char can be reintroduced into the gasifier for continued utilization. In one embodiment, a valve such as but not limited to slide valve 213 which is operated by a mechanism to open the slide valve 214 is located beneath the ash grate 211 to collect the ash. In one embodiment, a second valve 213 and operating mechanism 214 (no shown) are also located below the cyclone separator 207 for the same purpose. That is as a sifting device to remove any large inert, agglomerated or heavy particles so that the fluidizing media and unreacted char can be reintroduced into the gasifier for continued utilization. In one embodiment, the ash grate 211 may be a generic solids removal device known to those of ordinary skill in the art. In another embodiment, the ash grate 211 may be replaced by or combined with the use of an overflow nozzle.
A producer gas control 208 monitors oxygen and carbon monoxide levels in the producer gas and controls the process accordingly. In one embodiment a gasifier feed system 100 feeds the gasifier reactor 299 through the fluidized fuel inlets 201. In one embodiment, the gasifier unit 200 is of the bubbling fluidized bed type with a custom fluidizing gas delivery system and multiple instrument control. The gasifier reactor 299 provides the ability to continuously operate, discharge ash and recycle flue gas for optimum operation. The gasifier reactor 299 can be designed to provide optimum control of feed rate, temperature, reaction rate and conversion of varying feedstock into producer gas.
A number of thermocouple probes (not shown) are placed in the gasifier reactor 299 to monitor the temperature profile throughout the gasifier. Some of the thermal probes are placed in the fluidized bed section 204 of the gasifier rector 299, while others are placed in the freeboard section 205 of the gasifier. The thermal probes placed in the fluidized bed section 204 are used not only to monitor the bed temperature but are also control points that are coupled to the gasifier air system via port 202 in order to maintain a certain temperature profile in the bed of fluidizing media. There are also a number of additional control instruments and sensors that may be placed in the gasifier system 200 to monitor the pressure differential across the bed section 204 and the operating pressure of the gasifier in the freeboard section 205. These additional instruments are used to monitor the conditions within the gasifier as well to as control other ancillary equipment and processes to maintain the desired operating conditions within the gasifier. Examples of such ancillary equipment and processes include but are not limited to the cyclone, thermal oxidizer and recirculating flue gas system and air delivery systems. These control instruments and sensors are well known in the industry and therefore not illustrated.
The following provides a non-limiting example illustrating computation of the best dimensions for a bubbling fluidized bed gasification reactor in accordance with an embodiment of the invention. The gasifier, in this example, is sized to accommodate two specific operating conditions: The current maximum dried biosolids output generated from the dryer with respect to the average solids content of the dewatered sludge supplied to the dryer from the existing dewatering unit; and the future maximum dried biosolids feed rate that the dryer will have to deliver to the gasifier if the overall biosolids processing system has to operate without consumption of external energy, e.g., natural gas, during steady state operation with 25% solids content dewatered sludge being dried and 5400 lb/hr of water being evaporated from the sludge.
The first operating condition corresponds to the maximum output of dried sewage sludge from the dryer if, e.g., 16% solids content sludge is entering the dryer, and 5400 lb/hr of water is evaporating off the sludge. This corresponds to a biosolids feed rate in the small-scale gasifier of 1,168 lbs/hr of thermally dried biosolids at 10% moisture content entering the gasifier. In one embodiment, a solids content of 16-18% represents the estimated extent of dewatering that is required to make the drying load equal to the amount of thermal energy which can be recovered from the flue gas and used to operate the dryer. If sludge below 16% solids content are processed in the dryer, an external heat source can supplement the drying process. The second operating condition corresponds to the maximum amount of dried biosolids (dried to 10% moisture content) that the drier can produce if 25% solids content dewatered biosolids is fed into the drier. The second condition corresponds to the gasifier needing to process 2,000 lb/hr of 10% moisture content biosolids. In other words, there will be excess heat from feeding biosolids to the gasifier if greater than 20% content of biosolids in the sludge is used.
Another factor in determining gasifier sizing is the freeboard section internal diameter. The freeboard region of the gasifier allows for particles to drop out under the force of gravity. The diameter of the freeboard is selected with respect to the superficial velocity of the gas mixture that is created from different operating temperatures and fuel feed rates. The gas superficial velocity must be great enough to entrain the small ash particles, but not so great that the media particles are entrained in the gas stream. The extent of fresh fuel entrainment should also be minimized from correct freeboard section sizing. This is a phenomenon to carefully consider in the case of biosolids gasification where the fuel typically has a very fine particle size. Introducing the fuel into the side of the fluidized bed below the fluidizing media's surface is one method to minimize fresh fuel entrainment. This is based on the principle that the fuel has to migrate up to the bed's surface before it can be entrained out of the gasifier, and this provides time for the gasification reactions to occur.
In one non-limiting example shown in
A further factor in determining gasifier sizing is the media bed depth and bed section height. In general, the higher the ratio of media to fuel in the bed, the more isothermic the bed temperatures are likely to be. Typically, fluidized beds have a fuel-to-media mass ratio of about 1-3%. The amount of electrical energy consumed to fluidize the media bed typically imparts a practical limit on the desirable depth of the media. Deeper beds have a higher gas pressure drop across them and more energy is consumed by the blower to overcome this resistance to gas flow. A fluidizing media depth of 3 feet is chosen in this example shown in
Another factor in determining gasifier sizing is the height of the freeboard section 205. The freeboard section 205 is designed to drop out particles and return it to the bed, under the force of gravity and a reduction of superficial velocity as a result of the larger diameter in the free board section. As one moves up in elevation from the bed's surface, the particle size and density decreases, until at a certain elevation, a level known as the Transport Disengaging Height (TDH) is reached. Above the TDH, the particle density entrained up the reactor is constant. Extending the reactor above the TDH adds no further benefit to particle removal. For practical purposes 10 feet is selected for the height of the freeboard section 205 in this non-limiting example shown in
The reactor fluidized bed section 704 of a fluidized bubbling bed gasifier 700 is filled with a fluidizing media 704A that may be a sand (e.g., quartz or olivine), or any other suitable fluidizing media known in the industry. Feedstock such, as but not limited to sludge, is supplied to the reactor bed section 704 through fuel feed inlets 701 at 40-250° F. In one embodiment, the feedstock is supplied to the reactor bed section 704 through fuel feed inlets 701 at 215° F.; with the gas inlet 703 in the bubbling bed receiving an oxidant-based fluidization gas such as but not limited to e.g., gas, flue gas, recycled flue gas, air, enriched air and any combination thereof (hereafter referred to generically as “gas” or “air”). In one embodiment, the air i s at about 600° F. The type and temperature of the air is determined by the gasification fluidization and temperature control requirements for a particular feedstock. The fluidization gas is fed to the bubbling bed via a gas distributor, such as shown in
In one embodiment, a freeboard section 705 is provided between the fluidized bed section 704 and the producer gas outlet 710 of the gasifier reactor vessel 799. As the biosolids thermally decompose and transform in the fluidized bed media section (or sand zone) into producer gas and then rise through the reactor vessel 799, the fluidizing medium 704A in the fluidized bed section 704 is disentrained from the producer gas in the freeboard section 705 which is also known as and called a particle disengaging zone. A cyclone separator 707 may be provided to separate material exhausted from the fluidized bed reactor 799 resulting in clean producer gas for recovery with ash exiting the bottom of the cyclone separator 707 alternatively for use or disposal.
An ash grate 711 may be fitted below the gasifier vessel for bottom ash removal. The ash grate 711 may be used as a sifting device to remove any large inert, agglomerated or heavy particles so that the fluidizing media and unreacted char can be reintroduced into the gasifier for continued utilization. In one embodiment, a valve such as but not limited to slide valve 713 which is operated by a mechanism to open the slide valve 714 is located beneath the ash grate 711 to collect the ash. In one embodiment, a second valve 713 and operating mechanism 714 (no shown) are also located below the cyclone separator 207 for the same purpose. That is as a sifting device to remove any large inert, agglomerated or heavy particles so that the fluidizing media and unreacted char can be reintroduced into the gasifier for continued utilization. In one embodiment the ash grate 711 may be a generic solids removal device known to those of ordinary skill in the art. In another embodiment, the ash grate 711 may be replaced by or combined with the use of an overflow nozzle.
A producer gas control 708 monitors oxygen and carbon monoxide levels in the producer gas and controls the process accordingly. In one embodiment. a gasifier feed system (shown in
A number of thermocouple probes (not shown) are placed in the gasifier reactor 799 to monitor the temperature profile throughout the gasifier. Some of the thermal probes are placed in the fluidized bed section 704 of the gasifier rector 799, while others are placed in the freeboard section 705 of the gasifier. The thermal probes placed in the fluidized bed section 704 are used not only to monitor the bed temperature but are also control points that are coupled to the gasifier air system via port 702 in order to maintain a certain temperature profile in the bed of fluidizing media. There are also a number of additional control instruments and sensors that may be placed in the gasifier system 700 to monitor the pressure differential across the bed section 704 and the operating pressure of the gasifier in the freeboard section 205. These additional instruments are used to monitor the conditions within the gasifier as well to as control other ancillary equipment and processes to maintain the desired operating conditions within the gasifier. Examples of such ancillary equipment and processes include but are not limited to the cyclone, thermal oxidizer and recirculating flue gas system and air delivery systems. These control instruments and sensors are well known in the industry and therefore not illustrated.
With reference to FIG.7, an optional ash grate 711 may be fitted below the gasifier vessel for bottom ash removal. The ash grate 711 may be used as a sifting device to remove any agglomerated particles so that the fluidizing media and unreacted char can be reintroduced into the gasifier for continued utilization. In one embodiment, a slide valve 713 operated by a mechanism to open the slide valve 714 is located beneath the ash grate 711 to collect the ash. In one embodiment, a second slide valve 713 and operating mechanism 714 are located below the cyclone separator 707.
As with the small format fluidized bed gasifier, some unreacted carbon is carried into the cyclone separator 707 with particle sizes ranging from 10 to 300 microns. When the solids are removed from the bottom of the cyclone, the ash and unreacted carbon can be separated and much of the unreacted carbon recycled back into the gasifier, thus increasing the overall fuel conversion to at least 95%. Ash accumulation in the bed of fluidizing media may be alleviated through adjusting the superficial velocity of the gases rising inside the reactor. Alternatively, bed media and ash could be slowly drained out of the gasifier base and screened over an ash grate 711 before being reintroduced back into the gasifier. This process can be used to remove small agglomerated particles should they form in the bed of fluidizing media and can also be used to control the ash-to-media ratio within the fluidized bed.
With continued reference to
The upper portion of the main air inlet 801A is aligned with and an opening in a center trunk line 806, said trunk line 806 having at least 10 lateral air branches 805 that are open on one end to the center trunk line and closed on the other end. In one embodiment the lateral air branches 805 are symmetrically spaced on either side of the center trunk line 806. In one embodiment, the lateral air branches 805 are of varying length to fit symmetrically within the diameter of the bottom of the reactor bed 204. In one embodiment, each of the lateral air branches 805 comprise downward pointing gas and air distribution nozzles 810 which are also called, gas and air distribution ports 810. The air distribution nozzles 810 are pointed downward so the air entering from the main air inlet 801 is injected in a downward motion into the cone-shaped bottom of the gasifier reactor 799. In one embodiment the distribution nozzles 810 point downward at an angle such as but not limited to a 45-degree angle. The configuration and general locations of nozzles and components differ from the tuyere design for the smaller reactor vessel in that fewer gas/air distribution nozzles are required in a tuyere design to meet the fluidization requirements and good mixing requirements but still enough to enable the full volume of the fluidizing media material to fluidize when slumped in the bottom cone section of the reactor. This is also an essential part of the reactor.
The length of the live bottoms dual screw 102 and transfer screw 103 may vary and depend in the space available to locate the vessel 101 and distance to the gasifier 200. The transfer screw 103 may be equipped with a cooling jacket 104 shown in
The location of the aeration ports 107 can be variable in size and location and on any side of the vessel. The number of ports 107 can also be increased or decreased depending on the type and number of bridge breaking features and size of the feed vessel 101. Adjustable aeration features that uses either air or an inert gas, assists with avoiding bridging and maintaining flow to the transfer screws 103. The feed vessel 101 terminates in an open bottom chute 111 and a live bottoms dual screw feeder design 102 is located below the chute 111. The screw feeder 102 conveys the feedstock to another open bottom chute 111 that drops the feedstock by gravity directly onto the transfer screw 103. The screw feeder 103 conveys the feedstock either to another transfer screw feeder 103 by the same gravity/chute mechanism or conveys the feedstock to a gasifier reactor 299 via a fluidized fuel feed inlet 201. The connection of the transfer screw 103 to the feed inlet 201 is mechanical such as by a flange 116 to flange 116 connection.
The present invention makes processing large volumes of feedstock in either a single- or multi-gasifier system and building large industrial facilities feasible and cost effective; replacing the current and commonly practiced use of multiple smaller units. More specifically, the present invention is universal feeder system that combines with a fluidized bed gasification reactor for the treatment of multiple diverse feedstocks including sewage sludge, municipal solid waste, wood waste, refuse derived fuels, automotive shredder residue and non-recyclable plastics. The invention thereby also illustrates a method of gasification for multiple and diverse feedstocks using a universal feeder system. The feeder system comprises one or more feed vessels and at least one live bottom dual screw feeder.
The feed vessel is rectangular shaped having three vertical sides and an angled side of no less than 60 degrees from the horizontal to facilitate proper flow of feedstock material that have different and/or variable flow properties. The feedstocks are transferred through an open bottom chute to a live bottom dual screw feeder and through another open bottom chute to a transfer screw feeder that conveys feedstock to the fuel feed inlets of a gasifier. The invention is designed for the biomass waste processing industry—standardizes the capacity scale to a single design from 10-24 tpd day to more than 40 tpd and an average of over 100 tpd of feedstock that can be used at a single facility and retain the economies of scale. It also cooperatively can work with other standard large-scale supporting equipment such as driers, pollution control equipment and thermal handling equipment. This allows for standardized system and equipment design and commoditization.
While various embodiments of the present invention have been described above, it should be understood that they have been presented by way of example only, and not of limitation. Likewise, the various diagrams may depict an example architectural or other configuration for the invention, which is provided to aid in understanding the features and functionality that can be included in the invention. The invention is not restricted to the illustrated example architectures or configurations, but the desired features can be implemented using a variety of alternative architectures and configurations.
Indeed, it will be apparent to one of skill in the art how alternative functional configurations can be implemented to implement the desired features of the present invention. Additionally, with regard to operational descriptions and method claims, the order in which the steps are presented herein shall not mandate that various embodiments be implemented to perform the recited functionality in the same order unless the context dictates otherwise.
Although the invention is described above in terms of various exemplary embodiments and implementations, it should be understood that the various features, aspects and functionality described in one or more of the individual embodiments are not limited in their applicability to the particular embodiment with which they are described, but instead can be applied, alone or in various combinations, to one or more of the other embodiments of the invention, whether or not such embodiments are described and whether or not such features are presented as being a part of a described embodiment. Thus, the breadth and scope of the present invention should not be limited by any of the above-described exemplary embodiments.
This Application is a Continuation of U.S. application Ser. No. 16/801,834 filed Feb. 26, 2020, which is a Continuation-in-part Application of U.S. application Ser. No. 16/723,538 filed Dec. 20, 2019 (now U.S. Pat. No. 10,696,913 issued Jun. 30, 2020), which is a Continuation-in-part Application of U.S. application Ser. No. 16/445,118 filed Jun. 18, 2019 (now U.S. Pat. No. 10,611,973 issued Apr. 7, 2020), which is a Continuation of U.S. application Ser. No. 15/725,637 filed Oct. 5, 2017, which is a Continuation-in-part of U.S. application Ser. No. 14/967,973 filed Dec. 14, 2015 (now U.S. Pat. No. 9,809,769 issued Nov. 7, 2017), which is a Divisional Application of U.S. application Ser. No. 13/361,582 filed Jan. 30, 2012 (now U.S. Pat. No. 9,242,219 issued Jan. 26, 2016), all of which are incorporated herein in their entirety.
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 13361582 | Jan 2012 | US |
| Child | 14967973 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 16801834 | Feb 2020 | US |
| Child | 16922824 | US | |
| Parent | 15725637 | Oct 2017 | US |
| Child | 16445118 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 16723538 | Dec 2019 | US |
| Child | 16801834 | US | |
| Parent | 16445118 | Jun 2019 | US |
| Child | 16723538 | US | |
| Parent | 14967973 | Dec 2015 | US |
| Child | 15725637 | US |
