The present invention relates generally to board games and specifically to a vaccine development board game. Vaccination is a simple, safe, and effective way of protecting you against harmful diseases before you come into contact with them. It uses your body's natural defenses to build resistance to specific infections and makes your immune system stronger. Vaccines train your immune system to produce antibodies, just as it does when it is exposed to a disease. However, because vaccines contain only killed or weakened forms of germs like viruses or bacteria, they do not cause the disease or put you at risk of its complications. Vaccines reduce risks of getting a disease by working with the body's natural defenses to build protection. When a person gets a vaccine, his (her) immune system responds by recognizing the foreign compounds derived from viruses or bacteria (also called antigens), as it was the viruses or bacteria themselves, and produces antibodies.
Antibodies are proteins produced naturally by the immune system to fight disease; and remembering the disease and how to fight it. If a person is exposed to the germ in the future, their immune system can quickly destroy it before you become unwell. The vaccine is therefore a safe and clever way to produce an immune response in the body, without causing illness. The human immune system is designed to remember. Once exposed to one or more doses of a vaccine, it typically remains protected against a disease for years, decades or even a lifetime. This is what makes vaccines so effective. Rather than treating a disease after it occurs, vaccines prevent us in the first instance from getting sick.
The development of a vaccine represents a specific and complex stepwise process to ensure the most favorable benefit-risk balance before the vaccine commercialization and distribution phases that result in the immunization of the at-risk populations. Depending on the vaccine design, vaccines can protect against a single disease or against several diseases at the same time (combination or “combo” vaccines). The efficacy of a vaccine can also be impacted when the targeted virus or bacteria mutate. The infectious agents undergo a natural antigenic evolution through antigenic drift and shift in their antigens. The changing nature and specificities of diseases require adapted strategies to develop best-in-class vaccines.
Vaccinology is the science of vaccines and deals with scientific concepts that may not be fully understandable by non-experts. With the Covid-19 pandemic, people have become aware of the importance of developing potent vaccines to quickly protect vulnerable populations. More students are contemplating the pursuit of a career in the medical or allied health professions. They will be required to take courses in vaccinology. It is crucial to make science understandable to everyone through innovative learning methods including educative games (e.g., board games and digital apps). Games designed by scientific experts can help raise health consciousness by making scientific concepts accessible to all age groups in a simple and funny way.
Modern and realistic games dealing with actual health issues represent a powerful and universal communication tool to equip the current and future generations with the knowledge required to take on the biggest public health challenges, such as the COVID19 pandemic. The space would benefit from a teaching tool that addresses vaccine hesitancy issues. Such a solution can arguably trigger discussions between teachers and their students, as well as parents and their children, to help everyone make informed decisions about their health.
The descriptions of the various embodiments of the instant have been presented for purposes of illustration but are not intended to be exhaustive or limited to the embodiments disclosed. Many modifications and variations will be apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art without departing from the scope and spirit of the described embodiments. The terminology used herein was chosen to best explain the principles of the embodiments, the practical application or technical improvement over technologies found in the marketplace, or to enable others of ordinary skill in the art to understand the embodiments disclosed herein.
Certain terminology may be employed in the following description for convenience rather than for any limiting purpose. For example, the terms “forward” and “rearward,” “front” and “rear,” “right” and “left,” “upper” and “lower,” and “top” and “bottom” designate directions in the drawings to which reference is made, with the terms “inward,” “inner,” “interior,” or “inboard” and “outward,” “outer,” “exterior,” or “outboard” referring, respectively, to directions toward and away from the center of the referenced element, the terms “radial” or “horizontal” and “axial” or “vertical” referring, respectively, to directions or planes which are perpendicular, in the case of radial or horizontal, or parallel, in the case of axial or vertical, to the longitudinal central axis of the referenced element, the terms “proximate” and “distal” referring, respectively, to positions or locations that are close or away from a point of reference, and the terms “downstream” and “upstream” referring, respectively, to directions in and opposite that of fluid flow. Terminology of similar import other than the words specifically mentioned above likewise is to be considered as being used for purposes of convenience rather than in any limiting sense.
In the figures, elements having an alphanumeric designation may be referenced herein collectively or in the alternative, as will be apparent from context, by the numeric portion of the designation only. Further, the constituent parts of various elements in the figures may be designated with separate reference numerals which shall be understood to refer to that constituent part of the element and not the element as a whole. General references, along with references to spaces, surfaces, dimensions, and extents, may be designated with arrows. Angles may be designated as “included” as measured relative to surfaces or axes of an element and as defining a space bounded internally within such element therebetween, or otherwise without such designation as being measured relative to surfaces or axes of an element and as defining a space bounded externally by or outside of such element therebetween. Generally, the measures of the angles stated are as determined relative to a common axis, which axis may be transposed in the figures for purposes of convenience in projecting the vertex of an angle defined between the axis and a surface which otherwise does not extend to the axis. The term “axis” may refer to a line or to a transverse plane through such line as will be apparent from context. The terms “a” and “an” refer to “at least one” or “one or more” of that which it precedes. The term “card” refers to a flat (planar), usually geometrically shaped piece of substantially stiff paper, cardboard, composite or polymeric material. The term “board” refers to a flat (planar), usually geometrically shaped piece of paper, cardboard, composite or polymeric material that, in some embodiments, can be rolled or folded.
Vaccination is a simple, safe, and effective way of protecting you against harmful diseases before you come into contact with them. The United States Center for Disease Control defines immunization as a process by which a person becomes protected against a disease through vaccination. The immunization process leverages your body's natural defenses to build resistance to specific infections and makes your immune system stronger. Vaccines train your immune system to produce antibodies, just as it does when it is exposed to a disease. However, because vaccines contain only killed or weakened forms of germs like viruses or bacteria, they do not cause the disease or put you at risk of its complications.
The present invention seeks to provide a teaching tool for players to learn about vaccines. It is proposed that at least one useful incentive for using the game in a classroom setting may be for example to receive credit points for playing the game and completing related hands-on workshop activities. The space would benefit from a teaching tool that describes how vaccines are produced.
Embodiments of the present invention seek to provide a board game for explaining how vaccines are developed. Other aspects of the present invention seek to a board game that can be played by one or more players. Additional aspects of the instant disclosure seek to a board game that creates an entertaining playing and learning environment pertaining to the development of vaccines. The instant board game seeks to provide a game board, game pieces for each player that are advanced around the board, dice that are rolled to trigger specific actions during the game play, currency in the form of pay coins, various learning elements including information cards, all working together to create a fun and learning environment.
The vaccine development board game theme revolves around addressing threatening diseases and fast-spreading, outbreaks, There each player leads a pharmaceutical company that develops vaccines that attempt to immunize against the aforementioned diseases. The goal of each player is to protect the most at risk population against infectious diseases. Each player is challenged to develop effective vaccines by discovering the best antigenic formulations, launch clinical trials, manage production capacity to address the needs, and define an appropriate pricing strategy. The vaccine development board game can be played in four modes, “Competitive Mode,” “Quick Competitive Mode,” “Cooperative Mode,” and “Solo Mode,” are described in the instant disclosure.
The vaccine development board game also includes several game expansion modes: “Outbreak” to teach players about to the viral variants and antigenic drift, “Last Mile” to teach players about vaccine stability and delivery, and “Patents” to teach players about scientific patenting and licensing. In certain embodiments, the vaccine development board game includes are “Open Innovation” expansion mode that allows the players to collaborate with research institutes or small biotech companies that have already developed some vaccines available for licensing. In some ways, this expansion mode gives access to pre-designed vaccines that can be acquired to accelerate the development of the players' vaccine portfolios.
In the “Competitive Mode,” the goal is for each player to develop and manage a portfolio of vaccines. The player that immunizes the most people and has the most Victory Points by the end of the last turn wins the game.
In the “Quick Competitive Mode”, the players start the game play with pre-assigned T&E cards that define the profiles of their companies. The T&E cards can be randomly distributed to each player or the players can take turns selecting their cards one by one from the marketplace. Once the profiles of each company are defined, the goal is for each player to develop and manage their portfolio of vaccines. The player that immunizes the most people and has the most Victory Points by the end of the last turn wins the game.
In the “Cooperative Mode”, the players openly develop their vaccines together to eradicate the diseases. The immunization points are not counted as the goal is to cooperatively eradicate all the diseases before the end of the last turn. The Cooperative Mode has the particularity to allow the players to sell vaccines that target the same disease without competing for the sales. In other words, the principle of “best-in-class” vaccines and the vaccine comparison rules do not apply in this Mode.
In the “Solo Mode”, the player develops a vaccine portfolio to eradicate all the diseases before the end of the last turn. Some T&E cards can be randomly pre-assigned at the beginning of the game play while the rest of the T&E cards are drawn by the player to be strategically used during the game play.
The Figures (hereinafter “FIGS.”) of the instant disclosure are presented herein to describe the various components and game steps of the vaccine development board game (“board game”). The instant board game includes a plurality of components that allow one or more players to learn about vaccine development. As depicted in
Although the game board 100 is preferably a rigid playing surface, the component can alternatively be a surface that can be rolled up and/or folded for storage. The scoring track 105 includes a first sequentially numbered track 110. The scoring track 105 is used to display the number of people immunized based on the number of vaccines distributed by a company (or a player). Here, a single immunization equals one vaccine need addressed by the sale of one vaccine production unit. The turn counting track 115 includes a second sequentially number track 120. The first sequentially numbered track 110 and the second sequentially number track 120 are preferably linear, but they can also be circular in other embodiments. A starting position 111 is positioned on the scoring track 105. Each player token 112 is preferably associated with one or more players.
Similar to the game board 100, the game board 200 is for playing a “quick” version of the vaccine development game board that includes two or more scoring tracks 205 that each include a first sequentially numbered track 210 and a starting position 211 (depicted in
The vaccine needs value 405 describes the number of vaccines that are needed to treat or prevent the associated disease. The vaccine needs value 405 is determined by rolling a six-sided vaccine needs dice (depicted in
The ten-sided antigen dice 700 includes randomly positioned consecutive numerical values that consist of 0-9 on its sides (i.e., non-repeating numerical values).
The base vaccine price value 415 reflects the recommended price of any vaccine a player or company produces to treat or prevent the disease of the disease board 400. The base vaccine price value 415 is determined by rolling a six-sided vaccine price dice 1000 (depicted in
The combo incompatibility value 420 is preferably determined by rolling a six-sided incompatibility dice 900 (depicted in
The board game also includes a plurality (e.g., twenty-one) of technology and expertise (hereinafter “T&E”) cards 1200 (reflected in
A fifth T&E card 1200 that provides the holder with two production units and expands his production capacity to six extra units. A sixth T&E card 1200 that grants a reroll of the clinical study dice 600 when a vaccine study fails (i.e., a phase I/II study or a phase III study). A seventh T&E card 1200 that reduces preclinical study cost by a predetermined study cost percentage (e.g., fifty percent or other percentage). An eighth T&E card 1200 that provides an additional public opinion point during each turn. For example, the eighth T&E card 1200 can reflect a company's commitment to support immunization campaigns in developing countries.
A ninth T&E card 1200 that increases vaccine efficacy by a predetermined efficacy percentage (e.g., five percent or other percentage). A tenth T&E card 1200 that launches a vaccine and does not count as an action. For example, the tenth T&E card 1200 can reflect a company's mastery of the regulatory steps required to launch new vaccines. An eleventh T&E card 1200 that grants a reroll of the Toxicology dice 800 to select the highest result as the Toxicology value (“TV”) 1420. A twelfth T&E card 1200 that gives to its holder an exclusive access to a new research reagent with a value of 3. The following T&E cards 1200 allow players to develop antigenic formulas and can be used in combination to improve vaccine efficacy.
A thirteenth T&E card 1200 that develops antigenic formulas by adding research reagent values and is preferably available by default. A fourteenth T&E card 1200 that develops antigenic formulas by multiplying research reagent values. A fifteenth T&E card 1200 that develops antigenic formulas by subtracting research reagent values. A sixteenth T&E card 1200 that develops antigenic formulas by dividing research reagent values.
As part of the “Patent” expansion, a seventeenth T&E card 1200 that files a patent or withdraws a patent without counting it as an action. For example, the seventeenth T&E card 1200 can reflect a company's mastery of the intellectual property management steps required to file and manage patent applications. An eighteenth T&E card 1200 that provides its holder the ability to file more than one patent. The player owning this T&E card 1200 receives at least one additional patent board. As part of the “last mile” expansion, a nineteenth T&E card 1200 that increases vaccine stability by a predetermined value (e.g., 2 degrees Celsius or other value) for all the vaccines developed by a player. A twentieth T&E card 1200 that reduces by at least one day the accessibility of each region. For example, the twentieth T&E card 1200 can reflect a company's mastery of the vaccine distribution steps required to deliver vaccines around the world. The player owning this T&E card 1200 can draw at least one vaccine distribution card fewer during the vaccine distribution phase. A twenty-first T&E card 1200 that reduces the cost of the vaccine stability cards by a predetermined cost percentage (e.g., fifty percent or other percentage).
To perform a toxicology study, a six-sided toxicology dice 800 (depicted in
Hence, rotating the public opinion dial 1600 simultaneously advances or decreases the public opinion point count and the sales impact values. The sales impact values are negative when the public opinion point count is less than a threshold amount (e.g., 5). For example, public opinion point count can be 1-10 and sales impact values can reflect −20%, −50%, and −80% for public opinion levels 4 or 3, 2, and 1, respectively. To be sure, the vaccine production unit value is reduced by negative sales impact values. During play, the public opinion point count increases by at least one when the player's vaccine price value is less than the base vaccine price value. The public opinion count also increases when a player performs a Tox study with an in vitro model or when a player launches a vaccine against the outbreak disease. In some embodiments, the public opinion and the production capacity parameters are managed via a dual-layered board with small cubes or markers to indicate the public opinion score and production capacity level.
To play the vaccine board game each player receives three vaccine cards, one of the T&E cards 1200 (e.g., the thirteenth T&E card 1200), a player token 112, a production capacity dial 1650, a public opinion dial 1600, a predetermined amount of pay coins (e.g., 3000 pts), and a dividing board 300. Subsequent to shuffling, four T&E cards 1200 are positioned face-up where everyone can reach them and represent the T&E marketplace. The remaining cards are placed face down in a stack. Every time that a player purchases a T&E card 1200, a new card is drawn from the stack to replace the empty space. Research reagent token are separated per type and placed in four stacks (one reagent type per stack). The four types of research reagent token include a plurality of numerical values (e.g., 2, 10, 50, and 80). The study cards 1300 are placed in four stacks (one study type per stack). All dice are placed to be accessible to each player. The pay coins are organized to represent the bank.
The method steps illustrated in
At each turn, Steps 1720-1740 occur sequentially. At Step 1720, each player initiates an action phase by executing three actions randomly selected from a group consisting of purchasing research reagents, acquiring a technology or expertise, performing a tox study, performing a clinical study, increasing production capacity, launching a new vaccine into the market and removing a vaccine from the market. At Step 1725, each player initiates a vaccine production phase that includes recording vaccine production unit values 1425 and player's vaccine price values 1410 on the vaccine cards 1400 to thereby generate a plurality of marketable vaccines.
At Step 1730, each player initiates a vaccine sales phase that includes identifying a best-in-class vaccine for each disease board 400. For example, the best-in-class vaccine is the marketable vaccine that comprises a highest vaccine efficacy value 1415 against a disease of the disease board 400. At Step 1735, for each best-in-class vaccine, the associated player token 112 is advanced along the scoring track 105 according to the vaccine production unit value 1425 of the vaccine development card 1400. At Step 1740, the turn token 121 is sequentially advanced on the turn counting track 115.
At Step 1805, the six-sided toxicology dice 800 is rolled to determine the toxicology value and the toxicology value is recorded to the associated vaccine development card 1400. After completion of the toxicology study, a player may finance a Phase I/II study and a Phase III study using their pay coins. To perform a clinical study, three six-sided clinical study dice 600 are rolled, unless the number of dice is modified by the toxicology value 1420 as described above. As reflected in
The sub-steps discussed in Step 1720 (
The vaccine efficacy value 1415 is 100 minus an antigenic difference, which is the positive difference of the target antigen value 410 of a disease and a vaccine antigen value. The vaccine antigen value is determined via an antigenic formula 1430 that is derived from the purchased research reagents arranged as described in the owned T&E cards 1200. Recording the vaccine production unit value 1425 for a marketable vaccine includes determining a vaccine production unit value that equals at least a portion of a sum of production units 1655 available to the player as determined on the production capacity dial 1670. Recording the player's vaccine price value 1410 for a marketable vaccine includes determining the vaccine price value to be a multiple of 10 and at least equal to 100 when only one marketable vaccine is launched by the player; and determining the player's vaccine price value 1410 to be a multiple of 10 and at least equal to 20, where a summation of the player's vaccine price values is at least 100 when more than one marketable vaccine is launched by the player.
Identifying the best-in-class vaccine preferably includes comparing the vaccine efficacy values 1415 of marketable vaccines for one of the disease boards 400 and identifying the highest vaccine efficacy value 1415 thereof. If the vaccine efficacy values 1415 are equal, the player's vaccine price value 1410 that has the lowest price determines the best-in-class vaccine. If the vaccine efficacy values 1415 and associated player's vaccine price values 1410 are equal, then the player with the greatest public opinion summation 1605 determines the best-in-class vaccine. If the vaccine efficacy values, associated player's vaccine price values, and public opinion scores are all equal, then the greatest toxicology value 1420 determines the best-in-class vaccine. In case of a tie, the toxicology dice 800 is rolled and the highest result determines the best-in-class vaccine. A public opinion point is taken away (defined as an “inaction penalty”) from any player that fails to launch a vaccine during a turn.
The vaccine development phase can also include a combination of vaccines that uses one of the vaccine development cards 1400 to simultaneously target two disease boards 400. The combination vaccine (or “combo vaccine”) includes a combo base vaccine price that is chosen from the greatest base vaccine price value 415 of the two disease boards 400. The target antigen value to be considered for the development of the “combo vaccine” is chosen by the player from the two target antigen values 410 of the two disease boards. The “combo vaccine” also includes a combo vaccine production unit that equals twice the actual amount of the vaccine unit value 1425 defined on the vaccine development card 1400. In other words, during vaccine sales, one vaccine unit of a combo vaccine is counted twice for the number of immunizations points. The vaccine needs values 405 of each targeted disease board 400 are then updated by subtracting the vaccine units sold.
The end point of the vaccine board game can be reached when one of the following occurs: when the vaccine need value 405 of each of the disease boards 400 equals zero; when the turn token 121 is advanced to the final turn position (e.g., position “15”) on the turn counting track 115; or when one of the player tokens 112 is advanced to a final scoring position (e.g., position “100”) on the scoring track 105. When the end point is reached, a victor is identified as the player that has amassed the greatest summation of victory points. For example, one victory point is achieved for each immunization point, five victory points are granted for each marketable vaccine, and two victory points are granted for each T&E card 1200 owned by a player at the end of the game play. Extra victory points (e.g., 5) are given to a player if his public opinion summation 1605 is equal or superior to a certain threshold (e.g., 9) at the end of the game play.
A “quick competitive” version of the vaccine board games is played using the game board 200. Here, each player is issued an equal amount of T&E cards 1200 and a lower budget compared to regular play.
An “outbreak” version of the vaccine board game brings a new disease board 400 into the standard game with the particularity that this viral disease evolves over time. In other words, the vaccine needs change every turn and the virus can mutate (i.e., change its target antigen value). This version also includes an outbreak mutation dice 1100 that includes two primary drift indicia 1105, a secondary drift indicium 1110, a shift indicium 1115, and two null value indicia 1120 randomly positioned in its sides. Here, the outbreak disease board 1500 (
The outbreak version adds an additional phase in the game turn and follows the vaccine sale phase.
When the outbreak vaccine needs dice 500 results in the nonnumerical value 505, the virus “mutates” as described in
At Step 2105, rolling the third antigen dice 700 (e.g., the antigen dice 700c) to update the ones place when the primary drift indicium 1105 results. At Step 2110, rolling the second antigen dice 700 (e.g., the antigen dice 700b) and the third antigen dice 700 (e.g., the antigen dice 700c) to update the tens place and the ones place, respectively, when the secondary drift indicium 1110 results. At Step 2115, rolling the first antigen dice 700 (e.g., the antigen dice 700a) to update the hundreds place when shift indicium 1115 results. Subsequent to updating the target antigen value 1510, the outbreak vaccine needs value 1505 is updated by rolling the six-sided outbreak vaccine needs dice 500 until 20, 30, or 40 results. Any marketable vaccines that target the outbreak disease has their vaccine efficacy 1415 potentially impacted by the mutation of the virus.
The vaccine development board game can include a “patent” component with the “patent” expansion version, that allows the players to protect their vaccine formulas with patents and to share their vaccine research with other players through patent licenses. This phase can be played in conjunction with the competitive mode. The patent phase typically includes a plurality of patent boards (e.g., 5 or other predetermined number), a patent end token for each patent board, and a six-sided dice from 1 to 6 (e.g., the toxicology study dice 800). Here, each player receives one of the patent boards and one of the patent end tokens.
The method steps of
In other words, paying the patent extension fee extends the life of the patent for two turns (or another predetermined number of turns). However, when the patent extension fee is not paid the patent terminates and the patent falls into the public domain where the other players can use the antigenic formula without the requirement of a license. To be sure, use of a portion of the antigenic formula of a patent does not require a license from the patent's owner.
The vaccine development board game can include a “vaccine stability” component with the “last mile” expansion version. For example, during the distribution process, vaccines are “exposed” to temperature excursions (i.e., fluctuations) that impact their efficacy. To limit this cold chain fluctuation impact, the players need to develop antigenic formulas that are sufficiently stable to be delivered. The vaccine stability component can be used with all the modes of the vaccine development board game. This game expansion includes accessibility tokens (that each define shipping times of two or more days), vaccine stability cards (that each define vaccine temperature stability range, such at least 2° C.), and vaccine delivery cards (that each define a temperature excursion of at least 2° C. on at least 2 production units). During play, the vaccine stability cards, and the vaccine delivery cards are shuffled separately to form two decks placed in the middle of the game play.
Each vaccine delivery card represents a potential temperature excursion that is then compared to the vaccine stability cards of the vaccine. For example,
The game is not limited to a set of boards, dice and cards, and may also be played on a computer, a tablet or a smartphone. A computer game embodiment of the invention can employ a multi-person game played over the internet, or can employ a computer, a tablet or a smartphone as a board game companion to assist the players during the game play.
Based on the foregoing, methods for a vaccine development board game have been disclosed in accordance with the instant disclosure. However, numerous modifications and substitutions can be made without deviating from the scope of the instant disclosure. Therefore, the instant disclosure has been disclosed by way of example and not limitation.
This application claims priority to U.S. Provisional Application No. 63/325,560 filed Mar. 30, 2022. This application is hereby incorporated herein by reference.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
63325560 | Mar 2022 | US |