Valve operating system for engine

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6170449
  • Patent Number
    6,170,449
  • Date Filed
    Monday, September 27, 1999
    25 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, January 9, 2001
    24 years ago
Abstract
A multi-valve internal combustion engine having a plurality of valves having skewed axes that are operated by cam lobes of a single cam shaft. The cam shaft operates the valves through rocker arms each of which are pivoted independently about axes that are skewed relative to the cam shaft axis so as to minimize bending stresses on the valve during its actuation. This also avoids scuffing between the rocker and the valve stem. At the same time, good contact is maintained between the cam lobe and the follower surface by machining the cam lobe so that it will have a slight concavity at least in its tip portion so as to ensure constant line contact with the follower.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




This invention relates to a valve operating system for an engine and more particularly to an improved camshaft and follower arrangement and method for forming the surfaces thereon for operating a plurality of valves from a single camshaft where the valves reciprocate about axes that are skewed to each other.




In order to provide an optimum combustion chamber configuration and large flow areas, it has been proposed to provide a cylinder head wherein at least two valves are operated by the same camshaft for a given cylinder and these valves reciprocate about axes that are not parallel to each other but rather are in a skewed relationship. By employing such an arrangement, it is possible to form a combustion chamber shape that is more like a segment of a sphere.




However, this gives rise to considerable difficulties in the actuation of the valve. That is with conventional camshaft operated valves, the valve reciprocates about an axis that lies in a plane that is perpendicular to the axis of the camshaft. The valve reciprocal axis may also intersect the camshaft axis, but this is not essential. If the valve reciprocal axis does not lie in a plane that is perpendicular to the camshaft axis, it is difficult if not impossible to operate it without scuffing between the valve and its actuating element.




A system has been proposed wherein each valve is operated by a pair of rocker arms. The first rocker arm is operated by a respective cam lobe on the camshaft. This first rocker arm operates the valve through the second rocker arm. The rocker arms are supported so that their pivotal axes are at an angular relationship to each other so as to minimize sliding or scuffing contact between the rocker arm that operates the valve and the tip of the valve stem.




Obviously, the use of such multiple rocker arms substantially complicates the engine construction and minimizes the available space for other components in the cylinder head arrangement.




Therefore, there has been proposed a system wherein the valve is operated by a single rocker arm that contacts a three-dimensional cam surface formed on the camshaft. With this type of arrangement, only one rocker arm need be employed for each valve. However, it is important that the contact between the cam surface and the rocker arm be maintained at a line contact rather than a point contact. If this is not done, there will be a substantial problem because the oil film will break down at the point of contact between the cam and its follower surface.




It is, therefore, a principal object of this invention to provide an improved cam and follower arrangement for operating a poppet valve through a three-dimensional cam surface of the camshaft.




It is a further object to configure the cam surface in such a way that it has a curvature that will be mated with a curved surface of the follower of the rocker arm so as to maintain a line contact during the opening and closing of the associated valve.




It is a further object of this invention to provide an improved method for forming a cam lobe that will achieve the results desired.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




This invention is adapted to be embodied in a valve actuating system for an internal combustion engine having a camshaft with a cam lobe formed thereon that has a three-dimensional configuration. A rocker arm has a follower surface that is engaged with this cam lobe for pivoting the rocker arm about a pivotal axis that is disposed at a skewed angle to the axis of rotation of the camshaft. The rocker arm has an actuating surface that is engaged with a poppet-type valve that reciprocates about an axis that is skewed relative to the camshaft axis and which lies in a plane that is generally perpendicular to the rocker arm pivot axis. The cam lobe is configured so as to have a slight concavity on its follower engaging surface so as to maintain a line contact with the curved follower surface of the rocker arm.




A further feature of the invention is adapted to be embodied in a method for forming a cam lobe having a configuration as described in the preceding paragraph. This method involves the mounting of a camshaft blank having a blank cam lobe for rotation about an axis that is coincident to the rotational axis of the camshaft in the engine. A grinding wheel having a curved grinding surface is mounted for rotation about an axis that is skewed to the axis of rotation about which the mounted camshaft rotates. This axis is also supported for translational movement relative to the camshaft axis for forming the desired camshaft lobe configuration. The camshaft is rotated slowly about the camshaft axis while the grinding wheel is rotated about its axis. This axis is translated relative to the camshaft axis so as to form the desired cam lobe configuration. The movement of the grinding wheel axis is done in a manner so that the grinding wheel will contact the cam lobe surface along a line that conforms to the line of contact of the cam lobe with the follower when mounted in the engine.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a cross-sectional view taken through a cylinder head of an internal combustion engine constructed in accordance with an embodiment of the invention and is taken generally along the line


1





1


of FIG.


2


.





FIG. 2

is a top, plan view of the cylinder head shown in

FIG. 1

but with the cam cover removed so as to more clearly show the valve operating construction and specifically the camshafts, rocker arms, and rocker arm supports.





FIG. 3

is an enlarged perspective view of the cylinder head area showing only the valves and the operating mechanism therefore.





FIG. 4

is a side elevational view of one of the valve actuating rocker arms looking in a direction perpendicular to its pivotal axis.





FIG. 5

is a top plan view of the rocker arm.





FIG. 6

is an end elevational view of the rocker arm looking at the follower end thereof.





FIG. 7

is an enlarged view looking in the same general direction as

FIGS. 1 and 4

showing the valve operating mechanism associated with one of the intake valves. The solid line view shows the position when the valve is fully opened and the phantom line shows the position when the valve is fully closed.





FIG. 8

is an enlarged perspective view of the follower surface of the rocker arm showing the line of contact of the cam surface with the rocker arm.





FIG. 9

is a perspective view showing the locus of the camshaft and the grinding wheel during the grinding phase by which the cam lobe is formed.





FIG. 10

is a view showing the locus of movement of the grinding wheel relative to the cam lobe during the grinding operation.





FIG. 11

is a view also showing the grinding operation and shows the position of the grinding wheel and the camshaft when the lobe portion is being ground in solid lines and when the heel portion is being ground in phantom lines.





FIG. 12

is an enlarged view taken perpendicularly to the axis of the camshaft and shows the grinding operation that forms the concavity of the lobe portion of the camshaft.





FIG. 13

is a top plan view showing the grinding apparatus and particularly the support and backup for the camshaft.





FIG. 14

is a cross-sectional view of this apparatus taken along the line


14





14


of FIG.


13


.





FIG. 15

is a further enlarged view, in part similar to

FIG. 11

, and shows the operation in grinding the lobe in accordance with another embodiment of the invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS OF THE INVENTION




Referring now in detail to the drawings and initially to

FIG. 1 and 2

, a cylinder head assembly, indicated generally by the reference numeral


21


, forms a portion of an internal combustion engine with which the invention is utilized. The cylinder head assembly


21


is depicted apart from the remaining components of the engine since the invention deals primarily with the valve and valve actuating mechanism associated with the cylinder head assembly


21


.




In the illustrated embodiment, only a single cylinder is depicted, but it will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art how the invention can be utilized in conjunction with engines having multiple cylinders and a wide variety of cylinder configurations such as V-type, opposed, etc.




The cylinder head assembly


21


includes a main cylinder head member


22


which is formed primarily as a casting from a light alloy such as aluminum or alloys thereof. The cylinder head member


22


has a lower surface


23


that is adapted to be brought into sealing engagement with the upper end of the associated cylinder block. This closes a cylinder bore, having a cylinder bore axis indicated by the phantom lines CB. The cylinder head member


22


is affixed to the cylinder block in any suitable known manner.




The cylinder head surface


23


is formed with a recess


24


in its lower surface which cooperates with the cylinder bore and the head of a piston that reciprocates in the cylinder bore to form the combustion chamber of the engine. Preferably, the configuration of the recess


24


is that of a segment of a sphere. This is made possible by means of the valve configuration, which will be described next.




The cylinder head assembly


21


forms an intake side and this is the left side appearing in

FIGS. 1 and 2

. A Siamese-type intake passage


25


extends from an inlet opening in an outer surface


26


at this side of the cylinder block and terminates in a pair of valve seats which comprise intake valve seats. A suitable induction system is affixed relative to the cylinder head surface


26


for supplying at least an air charge to the intake passage


25


.




The flow through the intake valve seats is controlled by the heads


27


of poppet type intake valves, indicated generally by the reference numeral


28


. These poppet valves


28


have stem portions


29


that are slidably supported within valve guides that are pressed or otherwise fixed in the cylinder head member


22


.




As best seen in

FIGS. 1 and 3

, the reciprocal axes of the valve stems


29


are inclined at an acute angle to a longitudinally-extending plane containing the cylinder bore axis CD when viewed in the direction of FIG.


1


. These valve reciprocal axes also lie at acute angles to a perpendicular plane also containing the cylinder bore axis CB and on opposite sides of this plane as best seen in

FIGS. 2 and 3

. Hence, the reciprocal axes of the intake valves


28


and specifically defined by their stem portions


29


are skewed to each other.




The intake valves


28


are urged to their closed positions by air spring assemblies, indicated generally by the reference numeral


29


. These air spring assemblies


29


are comprised of lower cup-shaped members


31


that are fixed to the cylinder block member


22


and upper housing members


32


that are slidably supported relative thereto. The members


31


and


32


are urged apart by means of air pressure contained within the chamber defined by these components.




The upper member


32


has a keyed relationship to an upper part


33


of the valve stem


29


for holding the valves


28


in their closed position.




The intake valves


28


are opened by means of a cam and follower mechanism which is comprised of an intake camshaft


34


. The intake camshaft has axially spaced bearing portions that are journaled in bearing surfaces formed in the cylinder head and bearing caps


35


affixed thereto by threaded fasteners


36


.




Cam lobes


37


are formed between the bearing portions of the camshaft


34


and are engaged with follower slippers


38


of rocker arms, indicated generally by the reference numeral


39


. The slipper portions


38


are interposed between the valve stem end parts


33


and the cam lobes


37


.




Each rocker arm


39


is supported for pivotal movement relative to the cylinder head by a respective rocker arm shaft or pin


41


. To this end, the rocker arms


39


have boss portions


42


that define bores which receive the rocker pins


41


. The attachment of the rocker pins


41


to the cylinder head assembly


21


and specifically the cylinder head member


22


will be described later.




On the side of the cylinder head member


22


opposite from the intake passages


25


, there are provided a pair of exhaust passages


43


each of which extends from a respective exhaust valve seat to an outlet opening formed in a surface


44


of the cylinder head member


22


. The engine exhaust products are discharged from the passages


43


to an exhaust manifold (not shown) that is affixed to the cylinder head surface


44


.




The exhaust valve seats are valved by the heads


45


of poppet-type exhaust valves


46


. These exhaust valves


46


have stem portions


47


that are also slidably supported within the cylinder head assembly


21


by valve guides which may be pressed or otherwise formed in the cylinder head member


22


. The reciprocal axes of the exhaust valves


44


lie in a common plane at an acute angle to the first plane containing the cylinder bore axis CB.




Like the intake valves


28


, the reciprocal axes of the exhaust valves


46


are also disposed at opposite acute angles to a second plane that contains the cylinder bore axis CB and which is perpendicular to the first plane as best seen in FIG.


2


. Hence, the axes of reciprocation of all of the valves


28


and


46


are skewed to each other.




Air spring assemblies, indicated generally by the reference numeral


48


cooperate with the exhaust valves


46


for urging the exhaust valves


46


to their closed positions. Like the intake valve air springs


29


, the exhaust valve springs


48


include first members


49


that are fixed to the cylinder head member


22


in any appropriate manner. Second members


51


reciprocate in the members


49


and define with them an air volume which is charged with air under pressure.




The air spring members


51


are fixed to tip portions


52


of the valve stems


48


by keeper assemblies so that the valves


46


will be held in their closed positions.




The exhaust valves


46


are opened by means of an exhaust camshaft, indicated generally by the reference numeral


52


and which like the intake camshaft


34


is journaled in the cylinder head assembly


21


. This journaling is provided by bearing surfaces formed integrally in the cylinder head member


22


and bearing caps


53


that are detachably connected thereto by threaded fasteners


54


.




The intake and exhaust camshafts


34


and


52


rotate about a parallel axes that extend perpendicularly to the first mentioned plane. At one end of the cylinder head member


22


, there is formed a timing case


55


in which a timing chain (not shown) is contained and which is driven by the engine crankshaft. This timing chain is associated with sprockets


56


and


57


fixed to the intake and exhaust camshaft


34


and


52


, respectively so as to drive these camshafts at one-half crankshaft speed in a manner well known in this art.




The exhaust valves


46


are opened by cam lobes


58


formed on the exhaust camshaft


52


and which like the intake cam lobes


37


have a three-dimensional profile. This profile is formed in accordance with the invention in a manner which will be described later.




Slipper follower portions


59


of exhaust rocker arms


61


are engaged with the cam lobes


56


and operate the valves


46


. The exhaust rocker arms


61


like the intake rocker arms


39


have boss portions


42


that are journaled on respective rocker shafts or pins


41


. Each rocker shaft


41


is fixed to the cylinder head assembly


21


as previously described and this mounting arrangement will now be described by primary reference to FIG.


2


.




First, however, it should be noted that the rocker arm shafts


41


are all mounted in skewed relationships to each other. The rocker arm shafts


41


are all disposed at a relatively small acute angle a (

FIG. 2

) to the axes of rotation of the respective camshaft


34


or


52


. Also, as best seen in

FIG. 1

, these rocker arm shafts


41


are also inclined to the horizontal plane defined by the cylinder head lower surface


23


so that they are inclined somewhat downwardly from the cylinder bore axis CB toward the ends of the cylinder head member


22


.




The cylinder head member


22


is formed with an upstanding boss


62


that has a plurality of bored openings


63


each of which receives one end of a respective rocker arm shaft


41


. This boss


62


lies on one side of each of the rocker arms


39


and


61


, respectively.




A pair of rocker arm support members


63


are fixed to the cylinder head member


22


outwardly of the rocker arms


39


and


61


by threaded fasteners


64


. Each of these rocker arm support members


63


has a pair of further bores


65


that receive the remaining ends of the rocker arm shafts


42


so as to complete the journaling thereof in the cylinder head member


22


. The threaded fasteners


64


retain the rocker arm pins


41


in the respective bores


63


and


65


of the cylinder head projection


62


and the mounting member


63


, respectively. Because of this angular relationship, scuffing action between the rocker arms and the cam lobes


37


and


58


and valve stem portions


33


and


52


is avoided.




Finally, the raised central portion


62


of the cylinder head is also formed with a central spark plug well so as to receive a spark plug, shown in phantom in FIG.


1


and identified by the reference numeral


66


for firing the charge within the combustion chamber. The gap of the spark plug


66


lies generally on the cylinder bore axis CB.




The specific construction of the cam surfaces


37


and


58


and rocker followers


39


and


61


will now be described in more detail by particular reference to FIGS.


4


-


8


with the method of formation being described subsequently by reference to FIGS.


9


-


14


. Since the method applied to each cam lobe


37


and


58


and each rocker follower assembly


39


and


61


is the same, only the construction associated with one of the intake cam lobes


37


and one of the rocker arm followers


39


associated therewith will be described by reference to these figures. It should be apparent to those skilled in the art that this description, applies equally as well to the construction and formation of the exhaust cam lobes


58


and the exhaust rocker arms


61


.




As has been noted, the rocker arms


39


have boss portions


42


that are journaled upon the rocker pins


41


. Bores


67


formed in the boss portions


42


provide this journaling. The opposite sides of the boss portions


42


are provided with outwardly projecting portions


68


that extend beyond the side surfaces


69


thereof. These extending portions


68


are slidably engaged with the cylinder head projection


62


and the rocker pin retainer


63


so as to restrict the transverse and tilting movement of the rocker arms


39


on the rocker pins


41


.




Extending from the boss portion


42


is an arm-like part


71


upon which the slipper members


38


are formed. The slipper members


38


are disposed above actuating portions


72


which have a curved surface and which engage the valve tips


33


for their actuation.




As best seen in

FIG. 1

, the point of contact between the actuating portions


72


and the valve stems


73


lies at a distance RI from the pivot axis of the rocker arm


39


. This distance R


1


is greater than the distance R


2


between the line of contact between the cam lobe


37


and a slipper surface


73


which is engaged by it. Hence, there is a mechanical advantage so that there will be a greater degree of lift for the valve


28


than the height of the cam lobe


37


. This permits a more compact assembly.




It should be seen that the slipper surface


73


has a curved arcuate shape as seen in side view (

FIG. 4

) while the surface


73


is generally planar from side to side as seen from the end view of FIG.


6


. The curved surface


73


of the slipper


38


is a quadratic surface that is convex on the camshaft side and which has a width that is greater than the width of the cam lobes


37


.




As may be seen in

FIG. 8

, this curved shape coupled with the three-dimensional shape of the cam lobes


37


, as will be described, provides a curved line of contact indicated by the line AB in this figure across the width of the slipper surface


73


so as to provide good lubrication and avoid point contact. The line of contact AB will shift transversely along the slipper surface


73


as the cam lobe


37


rotates and the rocker arm


39


pivots as seen in FIG.


7


.





FIG. 7

shows in solid lines the condition at nearly maximum lift of the valve and in phantom lines the condition when the valve is closed and the rocker follower surface


37


is engaged with the heel portion of the cam lobe


37


. As may be seen, the point of line contact AB moves away from and toward the rocker arm axis defined by the rocker pin


41


during this operation. However, at all times there is a line contact because of the configuration of the cam surface which is formed in the manner to be described shortly.




As may be seen in the

FIG. 7

, the cam lobe


37


has a tip portion


37




t


which provides the maximum lift of the associated valve. There is a steeply inclined ramp of the cam portion


37


that blends into the tip portion


37




t


but the tip portion


37




t


has a fairly large radius so as to minimize stress and improve wear characteristics.




Basically, the heel portion


37




h


of the cam lobe


37


is a constant radius curve but because of the three-dimensional configuration, this is a tapered curve.




Referring now to

FIG. 9

, this figure shows schematically the relationship of the camshaft , the parts of which are identified by the same reference numerals as those of the finished camshaft


39


and the associated grinding wheel, indicated generally by the reference numeral


74


. The grinding wheel


74


has a cylindrical outer surface


75


which basically has a radius that is generally equal to the radius of curvature of the slipper surface


73


.




The grinding wheel


74


has a rotational axis


76


which is disposed at an angle to the rotational axis of the camshaft


39


, which axis is indicated at


77


. The axes


76


and


77


are offset from each other in both a horizontal and vertical plane. The vertical offset is at an angle θ


1


which angle is equal to the corresponding angle of the rocker arm pin axis defined by the pin


41


and the rocker arm bore


67


. In a like manner, the horizontal offset θ


2


is also equal to that of the rocker pin axis to the axis of rotation of the camshaft


37


.




During the grinding operation to form the configuration of the finished cam lobe


37


, the grinding wheel


74


and the camshaft


39


are moved relative to each other so that the grinding wheel surface


75


contacts the cam surface along the same curved line as the follower surface


73


traces during the valve actuation. To achieve this, the camshaft


39


is rotated about its axis


77


at a relatively slow speed. During this rotation, the axis of the grinding wheel


76


is moved relative to the surface of the camshaft due to the rotation of the camshaft about its axis


77


.




Thus, during a single revolution, the grinding wheel effectively moves around the cam surface


37


as seen in the various locus illustrated in FIG.


10


. During this same operation, the grinding wheel axis


76


is moved translationally relative to the camshaft surface


77


to form the desired profile for the cam


37


. During the grinding operation, the axis


76


of the grinding wheel


75


is moved in a parallel direction toward and away from the camshaft axis


77


. This translational movement is done while maintaining the angles θ


1


and θ


2


between the axes


77


and


76


.




During the grinding of the heel portion of the cam


37


, the translational motion of the grinding wheel


75


relative to the camshaft


39


is only in the direction transverse to the rotational motion. However, as the grinding approaches the tip or nose portion


37




t


of the cam lobe, the grinding wheel is also translated in a direction parallel to its axis. This motion is done so as to provide a very slight concavity in the surface of the lobe as may be seen partially in FIG.


12


. That is, in the rounded portion of the cam lobe tip


37




t


, there is a slight concavity from side to side in addition to the curvature looking from the end. This ensures that there will be a complete line contact between the cam lobe


37


and the follower surface


73


.




The actual grinding apparatus is shown partially schematically in

FIGS. 13 and 14

. This includes a head stock


78


that has a chuck portion


79


that receives an end bearing


81


of the blank from which the camshaft


34


is formed. The camshaft


34


also has bearing surfaces


82


that are formed between the various cam lobes


37


formed thereon.




A backup member


83


is provided on the grinding apparatus between the head stock


78


and the grinding wheel


75


and the cam lobe


37


being machined. This backup member has an arcuate recess


84


that is complementary to the bearing surface


82


and engages more than one-half of its circumferential extent. As a result, the grinding operation will not cause any deflection of the camshaft


34


that could interfere with the formation of the desired surface for the cam lobe


37


.





FIG. 11

shows the relationship of the grinding wheel


75


to the camshaft


34


and illustrates the translational motion which occurs when creating the grinding of the wheel portion


37




h


and the tip portion


37




t


. The translational motion is indicated by the line Tm. As has been noted, in addition to this motion when the tip portion is being ground the wheel


75


is also moved axially along its axis so as to provide an area L where the cam lobe will be ground in a somewhat concave curvature. Because of this, the three-dimensional contact is maintained with the follower along a line so that point contact which could destroy the lubricant layer during engine operation is avoided. This is particularly desirable at the smallest radius portion of the cam tip


37




t


, where the wear problem could be the greatest.




In the embodiment as thus far described, the grinding wheel


75


had a radius that was substantially the same as the radius of the follower surface


73


.

FIG. 15

shows another embodiment wherein the grinding wheel, indicated here at


101


has a substantially smaller radius. In fact, this radius may be approximately one-half or less than that previously shown. Nevertheless, the same grinding technique is employed.




That is, the axis of the grinding wheel


101


is translated relative to the camshaft axis while the camshaft is rotated slowly about its axis during the grinding of the heel portion and some of the lift portion. However, as the tip portion


37




t


is ground, the grinding wheel is also moved in an axial direction along its axis so as to provide the relatively shallow curvature that provides the continued line contact between the cam lobe


37


and the follower surface


73


.




Thus, from the foregoing description it should be readily apparent that the described cam and follower arrangement and method for manufacturing it is effective in providing a three-dimensional cam surface that can operate the valve mechanism without using multiple rocker arms while at the same time avoiding stuffing action between the rocker arm and the valve tip and permitting the forces on the valve to be transmitted directly along their reciprocal axes so as to eliminate bending stresses. All of this is done while maintaining the line contact between the three-dimensional cam and the rocker which pivots about an axis that is inclined relative to the axis of rotation of the camshaft.




Of course, the foregoing description is that of a preferred embodiment of the invention and various changes and modifications may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention, as defined by the appended claims.



Claims
  • 1. A valve actuating system for an internal combustion engine having a camshaft with a cam lobe formed thereon, said cam lobe having a three-dimensional configuration, a rocker arm having a follower surface engaged with said cam lobe for pivoting said rocker arm about a pivotal axis that is disposed at a skewed angle to the axis of rotation of said camshaft, said rocker arm having an actuating surface engaged with a poppet-type valve that reciprocates about an axis that is skewed relative to said camshaft rotational axis and which lies in a plane that is generally perpendicular said rocker arm pivot axis, said cam lobe being configured with a slight concavity on its follower engaging surface so as to maintain a line contact with said follower surface of said rocker arm.
  • 2. A valve actuating system as set forth in claim 1, wherein the rocker arm follower surface is curved in a direction looking along its pivotal axis.
  • 3. A valve actuating system as set forth in claim 2, wherein the tip portion of the cam lobe is concave in a direction perpendicular to its rotational axis.
  • 4. A valve actuating system as set forth in claim 1, wherein the cam shaft has at least two cam lobes each of which actuates a respective valve through a respective rocker arm.
  • 5. A valve actuating system as set forth in claim 4, wherein each of the cam lobes is three dimensional and each rocker arm has a respective pivot axis, said pivot axes being non parallel.
  • 6. A valve actuating system as set forth in claim 5, wherein each rocker arm follower surface is curved in a direction looking along its respective pivotal axis.
  • 7. A valve actuating system as set forth in claim 6, wherein the tip portion of each cam lobe is concave in a direction perpendicular to its rotational axis.
Priority Claims (1)
Number Date Country Kind
10-278149 Sep 1998 JP
US Referenced Citations (5)
Number Name Date Kind
3618573 Allen et al. Nov 1971
4635592 Weichsler Jan 1987
5012783 Ferrazzi May 1991
5921210 Regueiro Jul 1999
5988128 Moriya et al. Nov 1999