Centrifugal compressors are commonly used for fluid compression in rotating machines such as, for example, a gas turbine engine. Gas turbine engines typically include at least a compressor section, a combustor section, and a turbine section. In general, during operation, air is pressurized in the compressor section then mixed with fuel and burned in the combustor section to generate hot combustion gases. The hot combustion gases flow through the turbine section, which extracts energy from the hot combustion gases to power the compressor section, other gas turbine engine loads, and to provide excess energy for either shaft power or thrust.
A centrifugal compressor is a device in which a rotating impeller delivers air at relatively high velocity through centrifugal force on the gas within the impeller. Such a compressor also includes a diffuser, which normally is an annular space surrounding the periphery of the impeller and which usually is provided with vanes to guide the gas flow in order to recover static pressure, and minimize turbulence and frictional losses in the diffuser. The air or other gas (which will be referred to hereafter as air) is delivered from the impeller with a substantial radial component of velocity and ordinarily a substantially greater tangential component. The function of the diffuser is to decelerate the air smoothly and to recover as static pressure (head) the total or stagnation pressure (dynamic head) of the air due to its velocity.
While centrifugal compressors operate over a variety of flow conditions and ranges, they are designed to operate most efficiently at one set of operating conditions, usually referred to as the design point. For example, a centrifugal compressor may be designed for maximum efficiency and minimum adequate surge margin when operating to supply maximum shaft horsepower. As a consequence of selecting these design conditions, when the compressor is operating off the design point, it operates at reduced efficiency and potentially reduced stall margin. It is therefore desirable to improve the compressor's efficiency and low flow stall margin when operating off the design point. One option for improving efficiency and/or stall margin can be to vary the diffuser area as the operating point of the compressor changes.
According to some aspects of the present disclosure, a variable diffuser comprises a passage defined between opposing faces of a hub and a tip, at least two vanes within the passage, and at least two rotatable pennies. Each of the vanes comprises a body having a leading edge and a trailing edge, and the body extends between the hub face and the tip face. Each of the pennies is coupled to a respective vane body and an actuator. Each penny is coupled to a respective vane body near an edge of the penny. Rotation of at least one penny changes an orientation of the respective vane relative to the hub face.
In some embodiments each penny is rotatable a minimum of 90 degrees. In some embodiments each vane body defines a slot and each penny is coupled to a respective body via a pin extending from the penny and into the respective slot. In some embodiments each penny comprises a forked pin extending from a face of the penny, and each penny is coupled to a respective body such that the body is disposed within a fork of the forked pin. In some embodiments each penny defines a recess configured to receive a respective pin, and each body is coupled to the respective penny by a respective pin extending from the body into the recess. In some embodiments the hub face defines a slot respective to each body and each body is further coupled to the hub face via a pin extending from the body into the respective slot. In some embodiments the recess is elongated allowing the respective pin to translate.
In some embodiments each penny is configured to rotate in unison with the other pennies. In some embodiments the actuator comprises an actuating ring, each penny has a drive shaft extending from a first face of the penny, and the actuating ring is coupled to each penny drive shaft via a respective coupling member. The first face is opposite a second face of the penny proximate the respective vane body. In some embodiments the coupling member is a pinion gear. In some embodiments the coupling member is an arm linkage.
In some embodiments the orientation of each vane body is continuously variable between a first position and a second position. In some embodiments the first position results in a passage that is more open than the second position. In some embodiments each penny is housed in the hub face. In some embodiments each vane body is coupled to the tip face via a freewheeling penny.
According to further aspects of the present disclosure, a centrifugal compressor comprises an impeller having a high pressure outlet; a scroll; and a variable diffuser between the impeller and the scroll. High pressure gas flows from the high pressure outlet through the variable diffuser to the scroll. The variable diffuser comprises a passage defined between opposing faces of a hub and a tip, at least two vanes within the passage, and at least two rotatable pennies. Each of the vanes comprises a body having a leading edge and a trailing edge, and the body extends between the hub face and the tip face. Each of the pennies is coupled to a respective vane body and an actuator. Each penny is coupled to a respective vane body near an edge of the penny. Rotation of at least one penny changes an orientation of the respective vane relative to the hub face.
In some embodiments each penny is configured to rotate in unison with the other pennies. In some embodiments the actuator comprises an actuating ring, with each penny having a drive shaft extending from a first face of the penny, and the actuating ring is coupled to each penny drive shaft via a respective coupling member. The first face is opposite a second face of the penny proximate the respective vane body. In some embodiments the coupling member is a pinion gear. In some embodiments the coupling member is an arm linkage.
In some embodiments the orientation of each vane body is continuously variable between a first position and a second position. In some embodiments the first position results in a passage that is more open than the second position. In some embodiments each penny is housed in the hub face. In some embodiments each vane body is coupled to the tip face via a freewheeling penny.
According to further aspects of the present disclosure, a method is presented of varying fluid flow exiting a centrifugal compressor. The method comprises defining a diffuser passage between a pair of axially displaced and opposing disk faces; fixing a plurality of vanes in the diffuser passage, each vane extending between the opposing disk faces and coupled to a respective penny housed in a first of the disk faces; and transitioning each of the plurality of vanes from a first orientation relative to the diffuser passage to a second orientation relative to the diffuser passage by rotating each respective penny in unison.
In some embodiments each respective penny is coupled to an actuator and the step of transitioning each of the plurality of vanes from a first orientation relative to the diffuser passage to a second orientation relative to the diffuser passage by rotating each respective penny in unison is performed by actuating the actuator. In some embodiments each respective penny is rotatable through a minimum of 90 degrees of rotation.
According to further aspects of the present disclosure, a variable diffuser comprises a passage defined between opposing faces of a hub and a tip, at least one vane within the passage, and at least one rotatable penny. The vane comprises a body having a leading edge and a trailing edge, and the body extends between the hub face and the tip face. The at least one rotatable penny is coupled to the body and an actuator. The penny is coupled to the body near an edge of the penny. The hub face defines a slot and the body is coupled to the hub face via a pin extending from the body and into the slot, the pin movable within the slot. Rotation of at least one penny changes an orientation of the at least one vane relative to the hub face.
In some embodiments the slot can be oriented radially with respect to a center axis. In some embodiments the slot can be oriented circumferentially with respect to a center axis. In some embodiments the tip face defines a second slot opposite the slot in the hub face, and the body is coupled to the tip face via a second pin extending from the body to the second slot.
In some embodiments the penny is configured to rotate in unison with other pennies. In some embodiments the actuator comprises an actuating ring, and the penny has a drive shaft extending from a first face of the penny, and the actuating ring is coupled to each penny drive shaft via a respective coupling member. The first face opposite a second face of the penny proximate the respective vane body. In some embodiments the coupling member is a pinion gear. In some embodiments the coupling member is an arm linkage.
In some embodiments the orientation of the vane is continuously variable between a first position and a second position. In some embodiments the first position results in a passage that is more open than the second position. In some embodiments the penny is housed in the hub face. In some embodiments the vane body is coupled to the second disk via a freewheeling penny.
According to further aspects of the present disclosure, a variable diffuser comprises a passage defined between opposing faces of a hub and a tip, a vane within the passage, and a rotatable penny. The vane comprises a leading edge segment and a trailing edge segment. Each segment extends between the hub face and the tip face. The rotatable penny is coupled to the leading edge segment and an actuator. The penny is coupled to the leading edge segment near an edge of the penny. The hub face defines a slot and the leading edge segment is coupled to the hub face via a pin extending from the leading edge segment into the slot, the pin movable within the slot. The trailing edge segment is coupled to the hub face via a pin extending from the trailing edge segment to the hub face. Rotation of the penny changes an orientation of the leading edge segment relative to the hub face, and changes in the orientation of the leading edge segment causes changes an orientation of the trailing edge segment relative to the hub face.
In some embodiments the leading edge segment is coupled to the penny near an aft end. In some embodiments a forward end of the trailing edge segment rests on an aft end of the leading edge segment. In some embodiments the slot can be oriented radially with respect to a center axis. In some embodiments the slot can be oriented circumferentially with respect to a center axis. In some embodiments the tip defines a second slot opposite the slot in the hub, and the body is coupled to the tip via a second pin extending from the body to the second slot.
According to further aspects of the present disclosure, a method of varying fluid flow exiting a centrifugal compressor is presented. The method comprises: defining a diffuser passage between a pair of axially displaced and opposing disk faces; defining a plurality of slots within the first disk face; fixing a plurality of vanes in the diffuser passage, each vane extending between the opposing disk faces, coupled to a respective penny housed in a first of the disk faces and coupled to a respective pin extending from the vane into the respective slot; and transitioning each of the plurality of vanes from a first orientation relative to the diffuser passage to a second orientation relative to the diffuser passage by rotating each respective penny in unison and allowing each respective pin to translate within each respective slot.
In some embodiments each respective penny is coupled to an actuator and the step of transitioning each of the plurality of vanes from a first orientation relative to the diffuser passage to a second orientation relative to the diffuser passage by rotating each respective penny in unison is performed by actuating the actuator. In some embodiments each respective penny is rotatable through a minimum of 90 degrees of rotation. In some embodiments each respective vane comprises a leading edge segment coupled to an trailing edge segment, wherein the step of transitioning each of the plurality of vanes from a first orientation relative to the diffuser passage to a second orientation relative to the diffuser passage by rotating each respective penny in unison transitions each respective trailing edge segment from a first orientation relative to the leading edge segment to a second orientation relative to the leading edge segment.
The following will be apparent from elements of the figures, which are provided for illustrative purposes.
While the present disclosure is susceptible to various modifications and alternative forms, specific embodiments have been shown by way of example in the drawings and will be described in detail herein. It should be understood, however, that the present disclosure is not intended to be limited to the particular forms disclosed. Rather, the present disclosure is to cover all modifications, equivalents, and alternatives falling within the spirit and scope of the disclosure as defined by the appended claims.
For the purposes of promoting an understanding of the principles of the disclosure, reference will now be made to a number of illustrative embodiments in the drawings and specific language will be used to describe the same.
A typical centrifugal compressor 100 is presented in
Diffuser 119 comprises a hub surface 120, a tip surface 122, and a plurality of vanes 118 extending between the hub surface 120 and tip surface 122. As illustrated, hub surface 120 and tip surface 122 may be opposing faces, and may be referred to as hub face and tip face. Alternatively, hub surface 120 and tip surface 122 may be referred to as first disk face and second disk face. Vanes 118 may be fixed or variable. The hub surface 120 of hub 121 and tip surface 122 of tip 123 define a passage 116. In some embodiments, the passage extends from the outlet 126 to a swirl chamber 112 defined by the volute casing 114. Swirl chamber 112 may be a scroll. High pressure gas exiting the impeller region at outlet 126 will flow though diffuser 119 to swirl chamber 112.
As discussed above, a typical centrifugal compressor will have low stall margins during low flow conditions. Variable diffusers may be used to increase stall margins for low flow conditions. A typical variable diffuser comprises a plurality of cantilevered variable vanes extending into a passage at the outlet of the centrifugal compressor. The cantilevered vanes are coupled to a unison ring that pivots the vanes through a small angular range, typically less than 10°, although not so limited. Unfortunately, the use of a typical unison ring and cantilevered variable vanes does not afford the type of precise and accurate angular placement of the vane required to substantially improve stall margin during low flow conditions. It is therefore desirable to improve the accuracy of angular disposition of a variable vane, allowing an operator to finely tune the operation of a centrifugal compressor to improve margin to stall during low flow conditions.
With this basic description of a centrifugal compressor 100 in mind, attention is now given to the specific embodiments of the present disclosure.
The variable diffuser 200 comprises a plurality of variable vanes 201 and a plurality of rotatable pennies 203, with each of the plurality of variable vanes 201 coupled to a respective one of the plurality of pennies 203. The plurality of vanes 201 may be disposed in a passage 116 defined between a hub surface 120 and a tip surface 122. As illustrated, hub 121 has a central axis A. The central axis A may be the same as the axis of rotation of the centrifugal compressor, or may be offset from the axis of rotation.
Each of the variable vanes comprises a body 209 having a leading edge 210 disposed closest to the outlet 126 of the centrifugal compressor impeller 102 and a trailing edge 212 disposed furthest from the outlet 126 of the centrifugal compressor impeller 102. A high pressure surface 216 extends between the leading edge 210 and trailing edge 212 and substantially faces the outlet 126, while a low pressure surface 214 extends between the leading edge 210 and trailing edge 212 opposite the high pressure surface 216.
In the embodiment of
Second, a drive penny 203 is disposed in or housed by an aperture 221 in the hub surface 120, and the vane 201 is coupled to the penny 203 via a second pin 223 extending from vane body 209 and disposed in a recess 225. The penny 203 is rotatable within aperture 221. The recess 225 may be located proximate an edge of the penny 203. The aperture 221 may be located partially or entirely radially outward from a radial midpoint in the hub surface 120. In some embodiments recess 225 may be elongated, allowing second pin 223 to translate within the recess 225.
The drive penny 203 may be positioned relative to the vane 201 at an outer chord location. The penny 203 may be positioned relative to the vane 201 on the trailing edge 212 side of a midpoint between the trailing edge 212 and leading edge 210.
Vane 201 may be coupled to tip 123. For example, tip 123 may define a slot, and the slot may be opposite slot 207. Vane 201 may comprise a pin extending from the vane 201 and disposed in the slot of the tip 123 to thereby couple vane 201 to tip 123. Additional details of embodiments that couple a vane between both hub 121 and tip 123 are provided below with reference to
As described with reference to later
It will be appreciated from
In some embodiments, one or more of the plurality of vanes 201 may be coupled to tip surface 122. A vane 201 may be coupled to the tip surface 122, for example, via a dummy penny that is housed in the tip surface 122 and rotates freely such that control of the orientation of a vane 201 remains with the position of penny 203. A freely rotating dummy penny may be referred to as a freewheeling penny.
The embodiment of
In contrast to cantilevered vanes of the prior art, the vanes 201 of variable diffuser 200 have two points of interface with hub surface 120 (pin 218 with slot 207, and pin 223 with recess 225) instead of one, which provide greater structural stability, lowered vane stresses, and greater accuracy in vane alignment.
In some embodiments, the vane 201 may be coupled to the penny 203 via a slotted-vane-and-pin architecture such as that shown in
At the leading edge 210 the vane 201 may be coupled to hub surface 120 by a vertex penny 501 that rotates along with the rotation of the vane 201. Vertex penny 501 may be a pin extending from the vane 201 into a corresponding recess in the hub surface 120 to allow the vane 201 to pivot.
The rotation of vane 201 is driven by the rotation of penny 203, with rotation of the penny 203 translating into motion of the vane 201 via the vane slot 504 and penny pin 506 coupling. Rotation of penny 203 may cause the penny pin 506 to slide within the vane slot 504 to be closer or further from trailing edge 212, and will cause a pivoting motion of vane 201. The vane 201 may be continuously variable between a first, more open position 511 and a second, more closed position 513 (shown in dashed lines in
In some embodiments, the vane slot 504 may be disposed proximate the leading edge 210 and the vertex penny 501 may be coupled to the vane 201 at the trailing edge 212.
To accommodate the slot-and-pin design, the vane 201 of the embodiment shown in
In some embodiments, the vane 201 may be coupled to the penny 203 via a forked pin architecture such as that shown in
At the leading edge 210 the vane 201 may be coupled to hub surface 120 by a vertex penny 501 that rotates along with the rotation of the vane 201. Vertex penny 501 may be a pin extending from the vane 201 into a corresponding recess in the hub surface 120 to allow the vane 201 to pivot.
The rotation of vane 201 is driven by the rotation of penny 203, with rotation of the penny 203 translating into motion of the vane 201 via the forked pin 602. Rotation of penny 203 may cause the forked pin 602 to slide along vane 201 to be closer or further from trailing edge 212, and will cause a pivoting motion of vane 201. The vane 201 may be continuously variable between a first, more open position 511 and a second, more closed position 513 (shown in dashed lines in
In some embodiments, the forked pin 602 may be disposed proximate the leading edge 210 and the vertex penny 501 may be coupled to the vane 201 at the trailing edge 212.
There are numerous advantages associated with the slot-and-pin design, including that the vane 201 may be thinner than in the embodiment shown in
In still further embodiments, a vane assembly 700 of a variable diffuser may comprise a split vane 702 and penny 203. Split vane 702 has a leading edge 704 and trailing edge 706. A pin proximate the leading edge 704 extends from the split vane 702 and is disposed in a slot 708 of hub surface 120, thus coupling the split vane 702 to the hub surface 120. Slot 708 may be oriented radially, circumferentially, or at an angle with respect to a central axis of hub 121 or an axis of rotation of the centrifugal compressor.
A pivot pin 710 proximate the trailing edge 706 extends from the split vane 702 and is disposed in a corresponding recess of hub surface 120, thus coupling the split vane 702 to the hub surface 120. Alternatively, a pivot pin may extend from hub surface 120 and be disposed in a corresponding aperture of the split vane 702 to couple the split vane 702 to hub surface 120.
Split vane 702 may be coupled to penny 203 proximate a midpoint between the leading edge 704 and trailing edge 706. In some embodiments, a pin 712 may extend substantially perpendicular from penny 203 and be disposed in a corresponding aperture 714 defined by the split vane 702 to thus couple the penny 203 and split vane 702.
Split vane 702 may comprise two segments, a leading edge segment 716 and a trailing edge segment 718. The leading edge segment 716 may extend between the leading edge 704 and a portion of the split vane 702 proximate the penny 203, while the trailing edge segment 718 may extend between the trailing edge 706 and a portion of the split vane 702 proximate the penny 203. Leading edge segment 716 terminates opposite the leading edge 704 in an aft end 730. Trailing edge segment 718 terminates opposite the trailing edge 706 in a forward end 732.
In the illustrated embodiment, the leading edge segment 716 defines aperture 714, and the trailing edge segment 718 comprises the pivot pin 710 or may define the aperture associated with coupling the trailing edge segment 718 to hub surface 120. Leading edge segment 716 may be coupled to penny 203 near the aft end 730. Leading edge segment 716 and trailing edge segment 718 may be coupled by an slidable and overlapping joint 720. Forward end 732 of trailing edge segment 718 may rest on the aft end 730 of leading edge segment 716.
Split vane 702 may be coupled to tip 123. For example, tip 123 may define a slot, and the slot may be opposite slot 708. Split vane 702 may comprise a pin extending from the vane 702 and disposed in the slot of the tip 123 to thereby couple the split vane 702 to tip 123.
In operation, penny 203 is coupled to an actuator such as described below with reference to
The embodiment presented in
As discussed above, in some embodiments each of the plurality of pennies 203 may be coupled to one or more actuators via a coupling member. In the embodiment of
Rotation of actuating ring 951 will translate through arm linkages 953 and drive shafts 801 to effect rotation of each of the plurality of pennies 203. In some embodiments, the pennies 203 are rotated in unison by the actuator such as actuating ring 951. As discussed in the various embodiments above, rotation of each of the plurality of pennies 203 results in rotation, pivoting, repositioning, and/or reorienting of a respective vane of the variable diffuser.
In the embodiment of
Rotation of gear ring 1061 will translate through pinion gear 1065 and drive shafts 801 to effect rotation of each of the plurality of pennies 203. In some embodiments, the pennies 203 are rotated in unison by the actuator such as gear ring 1061. As discussed in the various embodiments above, rotation of each of the plurality of pennies 203 results in rotation, pivoting, repositioning, and/or reorienting of a respective vane of the variable diffuser.
In some embodiments the vanes discussed above are coupled to the hub 121 at two locations and extend outward from the hub surface 120 into passage 116 but do not couple with tip 123. In other embodiments, the vanes discussed above may be coupled to the hub 121 at two locations, extend outward from the hub surface 120 into passage 116, and also be coupled to tip 123.
Penny 203 is coupled to vane 201 and housed in hub 121. A pin 223 extends from vane 201 and into a recess 225 defined by the penny 203 to effect coupling between the vane 201 and penny 203.
A drive shaft 801 extends from the penny 203 and through hub 121, protruding from hub 121 in order to be coupled to an actuator. A seal 1105 may be provided between the drive shaft 801 and hub 121 in order to prevent leakage through hub 121. The seal 1105 may also be placed between the penny 203 and hub 121.
Vane 201 may be coupled to a dummy penny 1107 housed in tip 123. Dummy penny 1107 may define a recess 1108, and a pin 1109 may extend from vane 201 into the recess 1108 to couple the vane 201 to the dummy penny 1107. Dummy penny 1107 may be configured to rotate freely, such that motion of vane 201 is entirely driven by an actuator via drive shaft 801 and penny 203. In some embodiments, dummy penny 1107 may also be coupled to an actuator that is either the same or different from the actuator coupled to drive shaft 801.
In addition to the systems, apparatuses, and structures described above, the present disclosure presents methods for varying fluid flow in a centrifugal compressor. These methods may be used to improve stall margin during low flow conditions.
Method 1300 begins at Block 1301 and proceeds to Block 1303 where a diffuser passage is defined. The diffuser passage may be defined between a hub surface 120 and tip surface 122. The diffuser passage may be defined between the opposing faces 120, 122 of a hub 121 and tip 123.
At Block 1305, a plurality of vanes are fixed in the diffuser passage. The vanes may be of the type of variable vane 201 or split vane 702 described above. The vanes may each extend between hub 121 and tip 123.
Each of the plurality of vanes are coupled to a respective one of a plurality of pennies 203 at Block 1307. The pennies 203 may be housed in hub 121 or tip 123. Vanes and pennies 203 may be coupled via a vane pin and penny recess, a slotted vane and penny pin, vane aperture and penny pin, and a forked penny pin architecture such as those described above. The pennies 203 may each be rotatable through at least 90°. Block 1307 and 1405 may be performed in any order; in other words, the vanes may be fixed in the diffuser passage and then coupled to pennies 203, or the vanes may be coupled to pennies 203 and then fixed in the diffuser passage. The plurality of pennies 203 may be coupled to one or more actuators.
At Block 1309 the pennies are rotated to transition each vane from a first orientation to a second orientation. The first orientation may be more open or more closed than the first orientation. The vanes may be continuously variable between a most open orientation and a most closed orientation. The pennies may be rotated in unison or individually. The pennies may be rotated by the actuation of an actuator coupled to the pennies.
Method 1300 ends at Block 1311.
Method 1400 begins at Block 1402 and proceeds to Block 1404 where a diffuser passage is defined. The diffuser passage may be defined between a hub surface 120 and tip surface 122. The diffuser passage may be defined between the opposing faces 120, 122 of a hub 121 and tip 123.
A plurality of slots, such as slot 207, may be defined in one or both of hub surface 120 and tip surface 122 at Block 1406. The slots may be oriented radially, circumferentially, or at an angle with respect to a central axis of either hub 121 or tip 123, or with respect to an axis of rotation of the centrifugal compressor.
At Block 1408, a plurality of vanes are fixed in the diffuser passage. The vanes may be of the type of variable vane 201 or split vane 702 described above. The vanes may each extend between hub 121 and tip 123.
Each of the plurality of vanes are coupled to a respective one of a plurality of pennies 203 at Block 1410. The pennies 203 may be housed in hub 121 or tip 123. Vanes and pennies 203 may be coupled via a vane pin and penny recess, a slotted vane and penny pin, vane aperture and penny pin, and a forked penny pin architecture such as those described above. The pennies 203 may each be rotatable through at least 90°. Blocks 1408 and 1410 may be performed in any order; in other words, the vanes may be fixed in the diffuser passage and then coupled to pennies 203, or the vanes may be coupled to pennies 203 and then fixed in the diffuser passage. The plurality of pennies 203 may be coupled to one or more actuators.
At Block 1412 each vane is coupled to a respective one of the plurality of slots via a pin. The pin is configured to translate or move within the slot.
At Block 1414 the pennies are rotated to transition each vane from a first orientation to a second orientation. Each pin is allowed to translate within a respective slot. The first orientation may be more open or more closed than the first orientation. The vanes may be continuously variable between a most open orientation and a most closed orientation. The pennies may be rotated in unison or individually. The pennies may be rotated by the actuation of an actuator coupled to the pennies.
Method 1400 ends at Block 1416.
Although examples are illustrated and described herein, embodiments are nevertheless not limited to the details shown, since various modifications and structural changes may be made therein by those of ordinary skill within the scope and range of equivalents of the claims.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3799694 | Duzan | Mar 1974 | A |
3992128 | Lunsford et al. | Nov 1976 | A |
4737071 | Horn, Jr. | Apr 1988 | A |
5207559 | Clevenger et al. | May 1993 | A |
6547520 | Zinsmeyer | Apr 2003 | B2 |
8147186 | Ibaraki et al. | Apr 2012 | B2 |
20050123397 | McArdle | Jun 2005 | A1 |
20090302152 | Knight | Dec 2009 | A1 |
20100080694 | Chapman | Apr 2010 | A1 |
20160341215 | Knight et al. | Nov 2016 | A1 |
20170233080 | Knight et al. | Aug 2017 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
0058533 | Jul 1985 | EP |
2626573 | Aug 2013 | EP |
02095237 | Nov 2002 | WO |
Entry |
---|
European Search Report, dated Oct. 23, 2019, in EP Application No. 19168565.0. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20190345839 A1 | Nov 2019 | US |