Not applicable
Not applicable
Not applicable
1. Field of the Invention
This invention relates generally to the field of vascular access procedures and more particularly to a suture tensioning concept for quickly arresting blood flow from a vascular access site.
2. Description of Related Art
Vascular access site closure has a long history of inventive strategies. The standard of care has always been simultaneous direct pressure on the vessel and the insertion site. This typically involves firm pressure over the access site at the skin surface and the vascular site at the surface of the artery or vein. Pressure is held for 10 to 30 minutes based on the blood chemistry and the blood's propensity to clot. During this time the patient typically experiences severe discomfort from the intense pressure.
More recently, pluralities of closure devices have been invented to prevent bleeding at the vascular access site. Some deposit a dose of collagen inside the vascular vessel to prevent bleeding; some leave a mechanical device on the distal side of the access site; others implant a dissolvable “tampon-like” device into the tract between the insertion site and the access site which, upon swelling with blood, physically prevents bleeding from the access site. All of these closure devices can be characterized as having a direct effect on the access site.
A composition for arresting the flow of blood or another protein containing blood fluids flowing from an open wound has been patented by Patterson et al. in U.S. Pat. No. 6,187,347 teaching a substantially anhydrous compound of a salt ferrate which will hydrate in the presence of blood and body fluid to produce Fe+++ promotes clotting when applied directly over a wound and forming a protective scab attached to the wound to enhance healing thereof. Oxygen is also produced during the reaction.
One aspect of the present invention utilizes the heretofore unrealized virtues of the '347 compound in conjunction with the installation of a catheter and other types of vascular access procedures both at the time of catheter insertion and at the time of removal of the catheter from the vein or artery and skin area of the patient.
More recently, BIOSEAL ADVANCED hemostatic powder by Biolife, L.L.C. of Florida also called (the “powder” hereinafter), a combination of potassium ferrate and acidic cation exchange resin, has been used to form a seal of multi-valent cation-coagulated protein over the access site. This reduced the holding time, for example on arterial sites to 4 minutes, to achieve hemostasis. BIOSEAL ADVANCED is a bone-dry powder that absorbs blood liquid and rejects blood solids. The blood liquids dissolve the potassium ferrate and release a small amount of soluble Fe3+. The soluble iron coagulates the accumulating and rejected proteins to create a natural seal over the insertion site, independent of platelet count. The seal is semi-permeable and the powder continues to absorb blood liquids and reject solids. Eventually, the “filter cake” on the proximal side of the seal gets so thick that fluid flow ceases and bleeding stops. When bleeding has ceased, there are no flow events to disrupt the natural clotting at the vascular access site. The blood vessel clots as quickly as the patient's blood chemistry allows. The absorbed cations are replaced with protons from the acidic resin, lowering the pH at the skin/powder interface.
BIOSEAL ADVANCED hemostatic agent significantly reduces the holding time for hemostasis but has no clinically proven effect on the TTA. Importantly, BIOSEAL ADVANCED seals over the insertion site by coagulating blood proteins in situ and then covering the site with a powder at pH 2. The seal acts as a microbial barrier, physically blocking colonizing microbes from infecting the host; the acidic environment adjacent to the seal inhibits microbial growth and kills most pathogens; the patient does not get infected. In a recently published retrospective study of BIOSEAL on PICC lines, the infection rate was reduced 40%.
Once closure has been achieved with any of these devices, the patient has to rest until the physician is confident that he can get up and walk 100 feet. This time is called time to ambulation or TTA. A typical TTA for closure devices is 2-4 hours; for manual pressure, it is 4-6 hours.
The U.S. vascular access industry is huge with more than 6 million arterial accesses per year (2008) splintered across many different service providers. The most common is a catheter lab or an IR lab in a hospital. Recently stand-alone clinics have become a lower cost alternative for routine vascular access procedures. In the U.S., these are regulated by POS11 (Point of Service 11). The gist of this regulation is that no more than 3 patients can be non-ambulatory at any one time. The practical result of POS11 is that procedures are initiated for the first 4 hours of a working day; the latter 4 hours are reserved for TTA and discharge. If the TTA could be reduced to 1 hour, then procedures could be scheduled for 6 hours of a working day, a 50% increase in revenue-generating potential. Thus there is a large economic incentive to reduce TTA.
This driving force has led to the development of internal closure devices. There are, however, several problems with internal closure devices:
There is a real need for a low-cost protocol to shorten TTA to 1 hour and not leave anything in the patient's body while simultaneously preventing external-sourced infections, hematomas and other complications.
Sutures and staples are well known closure means to proximate two sides of a wound. Normal procedure is to make the stitch and pull it tight and then stitch again until the wound is closed. Many inventors have improved on the basic stitch by adding various tensioning means, such as Alghamdi, 20090281569 hereafter '569, Weiss, U.S. Pat. No. 6,471,715 and Cosmetto et al U.S. Pat. No. 5,127,412. '569 teaches a loop through the skin with a slipknot that is then pulled tight to provide tension. '569 teaches this is particularly critical because excess tension can cause cosmetically unacceptable scaring. The key teaching of '569 is direct tension on a suture to close a wound. Weiss and Cosmetto teach mechanical means to provide tension on a suture. One of them teaches a rotary device that converts circular motion into a linear force in-line with the suture.
Shad et al, 2009/0082790, teaches a twist means to facilitate post-operative sternum closure. The suture is placed in a holding device and twisted to bring the internal sides together.
Davis, U.S. Pat. No. 4,773,421, teaches a controlled linear tensioning device because excess tension of the suture can damage underlying skin. This is particularly important for sutures that remain in place for days. Davis points out that his device allows for tension adjustment as the healing process proceeds because frequent cleaning and inspection of the wound is required. Davis also teaches that the angle of the suture to the skin as the suture emerges from tissue is as close to a right angle to avoid the suture cutting into the skin.
Taheri, U.S. Pat. No. 5,919,207, teaches a method of closing an artery by twisting wires in the artery to close the hole, then stapling the site together. The twisted wire is then removed and the artery heals. As an aside, Taheri teaches that the skin opening is approximated with a standard staple. With Taheri, there are two staples on the artery itself and at least one staple on the skin.
Tiefenbrun, U.S. Pat. No. 6,331,182, teaches twisted sutures to close internal tissue. Lafontaine et al, U.S. Pat. No. 5,964,782, teaches that the time to complete the suturing function can result in significant blood loss, particularly on arterial interventions. He goes on to teach about other closure devices that may support clot formation and thrombosis. He goes on to teach that twisting the suture is an effective countermeasure. Like other inventors of closure devices, Lafontaine is dismissive of ways to achieve hemostasis at the access site.
Gao et al, U.S. Pat. No. 6,752,810, teaches that adding tension to a suture is a successful way to approximate two sides of a wound. His device uses an external twister to generate linear tension.
Sancoff et al, U.S. Pat. No. 7,081,124, teaches a suture at an arterial insertion site and then approximating the sides using a twist.
Torque is different than tension. Tension is a linear force aligned with the suture. Torque (or twist) is the force at an angle to tension. Tension and torque together represent the in-line vector and the right-angle vector respectively with respect to the centerline of the suture.
When torque is combined with sutured skin, the skin twists like an Archimedes Screw. Put a finger on the back of your other hand and then rotate 30° to see the Archimedes Screw effect on your skin. When the sutures and sutured skin are rotated clockwise (or counterclockwise) (looking down at the wound site), the lower skin is pulled up towards the torque-inducer. When a vein or artery (artery is used herein to mean either vein or artery) is embedded in the skin adjacent to the “screwed” skin, the arteriotomy is approximated. This is illustrated in Lafontaine '782, FIG. 6c, in which a Y-shaped insertion pattern is twisted into a closed half-spiral. Thus twisting soft tissue to close it is well known.
Doctors work hard to prevent over-tightening sutures because it increases scarring and the potential for skin damage, so that excess tension and especially excess tension and torque is not used in clinical practice. In addition, over-tightening elongates the hole and tends to prevent approximation at the distal end of the insertion site. An enlarged hole is a vector for infection, oozing and complications.
Current best practices for extra-luminal closing of an arteriotomy involve manual pressure. With manual pressure, the nurse or doctor presses a finger on the artery upstream of the arteriotomy while simultaneously pressing on the insertion site. The best practitioners use semi-occlusive pressure such that the radius of the artery at the arteriotomy is little changed. Less skilled practitioners will use heavy pressure at the insertion site that transmits to the arteriotomy and changes the radius of the arteriotomy. Heavy pressure has a large complication rate compared to semi-occlusive pressure including intense pain for the patient.
The prior art teaches:
An ideal solution would deliver the single step simplicity of external manual pressure, the short time to hemostasis and TTA of an internal closure device and the low complication rate of using a haemostatic powder plus manual pressure.
The foregoing examples of the related art and limitations related therewith are intended to be illustrative and not exclusive. Other limitations of the related art will become apparent to those skilled in the art upon a reading of the specification and a study of the drawings.
This invention is directed to a wound sealing system and method for closing a vascular access site. The method invisions suturing a single continuous Z-stitch into a skin area around a wound and wound tract such that the submerged suture is perpendicular to the wound tract while the catheter remains within the vessel; covering the wound and suture holes with a hemostatic powder; tightening and knotting the ends of the suture together in an X configuration, applying finger pressure against the hemostatic powder as the catheter is removed; and twisting the suture ends together to tension the Z-stitch, pulling the skin area into inversion. The wound sealing system includes a powder containment device (PCD) which surrounds wound and catheter and a suture twisting member configured with the PCD to tension the Z-stitch closing the wound and arresting blood flow. The hole in the PCD holds a quantity of the hemostatic agent sufficient to cover the wound and suture holes.
It is an object of the invention to eliminate the need for manual pressure, reduce TTA, reduce scarring and reduce complications. It is also an object of the invention to increase patient satisfaction. It is a further object that the closure means is an extra-luminal strategy with nothing left in the patient at discharge. It is a further object to lower cost.
It is a further object to secure bodily tissue with a Z-stitch encompassing the area defined by the catheter insertion site, and the vascular access site distal to the blood vessel. The ends of the sutures are tied together to form an X. Twisting the external ends to create torque and excessive tension on the stitch further enhances the X. The tissue perpendicular to the subcutaneous stitch indents downward towards the tract and arterial access site and provides low-level continuous pressure on the wound.
It is still a further object to seal the elongated suture holes to prevent oozing, bleeding and microbial colonization.
The following embodiments and aspects thereof are described and illustrated in conjunction with systems, tools and methods which are meant to be exemplary and illustrative and not limiting in scope. In various embodiments one or more of the above-described problems have been reduced or eliminated while other embodiments are directed to other improvements. In addition to the exemplary aspects and embodiments described above, further aspects and embodiments will become apparent by reference to the drawings and by study of the following descriptions.
Exemplary embodiments are illustrated in reference figures of the drawings. It is intended that the embodiments and figures disclosed herein are to be considered to be illustrative rather than limiting.
A protocol has been developed for implementing the method of the present invention utilizing an anhydrous ferrate and cationic exchange resin composition (the powder) taught in U.S. Pat. No. 6,187,347, the entire teaching of which is incorporated herein by reference.
Referring now to the drawings, and firstly to
Referring now to
In
In
In
In
In another embodiment, there is an encircling plastic “washer” through which the free ends of the suture are threaded and then the washer is placed over the insertion site. The washer has a detent to bind the windlass means in place after torque has been applied. The barrel can be of any rotatable shape and any material with sufficient strength to withstand the torque.
In a preferred embodiment, the
According to MacKay-Wiggan et al in Suturing Techniques, May 1, 2009 (Web MD): “The choice of suture technique depends on the type and anatomic location of the wound, the thickness of the skin, the degree of tension, and the desired cosmetic result. The proper placement of sutures enhances the precise approximation of the wound edges which helps minimize and redistribute skin tension. Wound eversion is essential to maximize the likelihood of good epidermal approximation. Eversion is desirable to minimize the risk of scar depression secondary to tissue contraction during healing. Usually, inversion is not desirable and probably does not decrease the risk of hypertrophic scarring in an individual with a propensity for hypertrophic scars.”
The inversion-induced force is on the insertion site, the wound tract and the wound or insertion site. The induced pressure is gentle but consistent and hemostasis is achieved along the entire wound. The barrel 42 is left in place one hour to allow clotting to go to completion. Prior art teaches that right angle tension is undesirable, and it is for extended time, but not for one hour. However, the induced force over the entire site is detrimental to the suture entry sites as they are elongated as seen in
After the hour, the stitches are removed as shown in
Other embodiments of the PCD facilitate this same methodology. In
In
In
Referring now to
The suture tensioner 94 also includes an upright finger turning blade 112 connected to a top surface therefore which facilitates the tensioning of the suture 12. The suture ends 12a and 12c are fed from knot 40 into locking notches 104 and 106, respectively, as the suture twister 94 is lowered into tooth engagement with the PCD 92. Thereafter, one of the suture ends 12a is fed through a central locking notch 118 and then through one of the side locking notches 114 or 116 formed through blade 112, while the other suture end 12c is fed firstly through the central locking notch 118 and then through the alternate side-locking notch 116 or 114. Once the suture ends 12a and 12c are lockingly engaged as described and shown, rotation by manual grasping of the finger blade 112 is effected in the direction of arrow G to properly tension the suture 12 as previously described.
Referring to
The suture tensioner 124 has downwardly facing teeth 134 which matably engage into teeth 128 of the PCD 122 when the suture tensioner 124 is downwardly positioned into the U-shaped channel 132. The suture tensioner 124 further includes V-shaped notches 138 and 142 having locking ends 140 which secure the suture ends as previously described in
A surface adhering device may also be used to pull the skin from around the access site together while pushing down in the center to create an inversion in the skin and tissue therebeneath. This inversion puts pressure over the hole in the vessel to stop the bleeding from that vessel. This device can be used with or without the hemostatic powder. The device an attach by means of a surface adhesive, mechanical hooks, or the like. The hooks can be designed to barely penetrate the surface of the skin or to penetrate into the tissue beneath. Depth of penetration may be used to control the degree of inversion of the tissue beneath. The device can also be turned, twisting the skin and tissue beneath creating a tortuous track to reduce oozing from said tract.
In the
The FIG. 16/17 wound sealing system 160 works this way:
Device 160 is the preferred embodiment because it eliminates any time lag between pulling the catheter (or sheath) and creating skin inversion. This tensioner 160 also simplifies the procedure because there is only one knot, not two and eliminates any messiness potential with the powder 36a as the powder 36a is held in place magnetically.
The suture tensioner 160 includes a PCD 162 and a suture tensioner 164 which are preassembled together so, to the practioner, it is a one piece device, not two. The suture tensioner 164 pulls the sutures through a central slot 176/178 and holds tension on the sutures for the entire length of patient recovery. This can be accomplished by wrapping the suture around a cylindrical surface 170 of the PCD 162 after the suture ends have been locked into locking notches 192, followed by manual rotation of the suture tensioner 164 by finger blades 186.
The PCD 162 is formed having upwardly facing teeth 168 which lockingly mesh with the downwardly facing teeth 184 formed on the suture tensioner 164. An access notch 174 is formed radially inwardly from the perimeter of the body 166 of the PCD 162 for providing access around the in-place catheter. A clearance notch 188 in the perimeter of body 180. By making the powder 36a magnetic by the addition of magnetized powder such as Magnetite, and by providing a magnet 196 positioned at the top of cavity 172 covered by a compressible foam layer 194, all of the magnetic hemostatic powder 36a is held within the cavity 172 as the device 160 is positioned over the in-place sutures around the wound and wound tract as previously described.
The device 160 holds constant pressure over the wound in the vessel while in use with no outside assistance from a clinician. The pressure is created by gathering the tissue from the area around the insertion site, pulling it together while maintaining or creating a force over the skin to create an inversion in the tissue. This inversion in the tissue pushes down on the vessel stopping the bleeding. The sutures penetrate the skin on either side of the wound in the vessel, pulling the sides of the vessel upwards and inwards, creating a deep inversion that pushes down over the wound in the vessel as previously described.
Referring now to
The PCD 202 includes a cylindrical body 206 having a catheter clearance notch 208 formed radially inwardly from the perimeter to the center of the body 206 and also has a suture clearance hole 214 centrally therethrough. Upwardly facing teeth 210 of the PCD 202 interlock with the downwardly facing teeth 222 of the linear tract 220 of the suture tensioner 204. The suture ends upwardly extend from the central aperture 214 and lockingly engage within locking grooves 226a and 228a of locking members 226 and 228, respectively. Thereafter, linear movement of the suture tensioner 204 in the direction of the arrow applies tension in linear response to that movement to tension the Z-stitch positioned beneath the hemostatic powder cavity 216 in a fashion previously described.
Clinical trials were conducted on randomly selected patients' legs, comparing the methodology of this disclosure to subcombinations thereof:
The results for the three conditions tested were:
Pressure only:
Pressure+BIOSEAL:
Suture Twist+BIOSEAL:
In a second experiment, the windlass was used without the haemostatic powder. Closure was achieved without manual pressure and the TTA was 1.5 hours; there was a 1% complication rate from infection; bandage changes were required to soak up oozing.
The clinical trial also collected economic data and analyzed the economic impact of the three legs both as to cost and also as to revenue. The revenue analysis continued after the test period. The Twist+BIOSEAL significantly reduced the overall cost of the procedure.
The one-hour TTA was independent of the platelet count of the patient. Closure devices previously were used on about 30% of the cases; this skews by doctor. Some doctors used a closure device frequently (33% of all arterial accesses use closure devices), particularly when the patient had a low platelet count or other clotting compromise. Most doctors used closure devices infrequently. The most significant economic difference was the ability to schedule one additional case per day without overtime, a revenue increase of $2,000 per day per clinic. The increase in cost was $50/day for the suture twist kit 10.
While a number of exemplary aspects and embodiments have been discussed above, those of skill in the art will recognize certain modifications, permeations and additions and subcombinations thereof. It is therefore intended that the following appended claims and claims hereinafter introduced are interpreted to include all such modifications, permeations, additions and subcombinations that are within their true spirit and scope.