Patent Application
20240059426
This application claims the benefit of European Patent Application EP 22191442.7, filed on Aug. 22, 2022, the contents of which is incorporated by reference in its entirety.
This disclosure relates to a safety device to detect and make visible hydrogen fires in transport vehicle and aviation applications where hydrogen is used or stored on an aircraft, associated ground vehicles or similar transport applications.
To create new environmentally friendly ways to power vehicles like aircraft, the use of new fuels such as hydrogen are being promoted. Hydrogen however brings some new safety issues that are different from traditional aircraft safety cases which must be addressed before acceptance and certification of this fuel type for regular commercial aviation use will be achieved. One key issue is that of hydrogen fires, as hydrogen burns with a near non-visible clear flame, which is hard to detect by human eye both in daylight and nighttime conditions. This issue is equally problematic for road and water borne transport applications.
This clear burning flame means if a hydrogen fire occurs around the aircraft, particularly as part of a safety event with minimally trained passengers present, the possibility exists of persons walking, running or driving directly into a burning fire as it cannot be easily seen by the naked human eye. The potential risks of this non-visible fire affects passengers and crew of the aircraft, the refuelling crew, and aircraft crash safety crew alike.
Most industrial uses of hydrogen typically use infrared and ultra-violet sensors combined with computer imaging technology and some form of electronic display to visualise hydrogen fires for safety purposes. There is a large body of literature and patents for such types of technology. Whilst these devices can be remarkably accurate, they require specific equipment which would be impractical to outfit and train for its operation all the passengers on a hydrogen fuelled aircraft. Indeed, if an operator of such device has to alternate between a visual view of their surroundings and a screen view, there is also a high risk of disorientation creating an additional safety risk. Such devices may also be difficult to orientate towards and give sufficient breadth of coverage to observe any fire occurrence prior to opening the emergency exits of an aircraft after an emergency event. This would increase the risk to the passengers and crew if a door or emergency exit was incorrectly opened adjacent to a fire.
Hydrogen fires burn quickly if the fuel is fully exposed to the atmosphere, as the fuel both burns and evaporates. Current aircraft cabin evacuation rules also require all passengers and crew to evacuate the aircraft within a period of 90 seconds after the instruction to evacuate is given. This means the first minutes of any aircraft crash when passengers are normally expected to evacuate are most critical to identify and avoid any flames until the fire is burnt out. Therefore, any hydrogen fire detection system must be easy to use and quick to operate.
The present inventors judge that what is required is a hydrogen fire detection device that can make a hydrogen fire visible to all actors in an emergency event, and not a single operator with specialised equipment, nor a device that has a specific training requirement or reliance on a secondary display. Such a device should be able to be carried on an aircraft safely, without constituting or creating its own safety risk due to its carriage. It should also be able to be operated prior to the opening of the aircraft cabin doors and emergency exits to avoid inadvertent opening of the aircraft exits adjacent to a fire whilst flames are still burning in proximity to the door. Similarly, versions of the device should be able to triggered or operated by refuelling crews or emergency crews if a hydrogen fire was suspected, including wider transport applications such as for road accidents or shipping incidents. Such a device would ideally be operated systematically in approach to treating a hydrogen aircraft (or other transport vehicle) after serious damage to an aircraft to ensure any hydrogen fires would be easily identified by all persons coming into proximity of the aircraft, hydrogen refueller or airport hydrogen infrastructure.
The invention can be executed in several forms for aviation and wider transport applications. For example, it is considered appropriate for use on an aircraft, on a refuelling vehicle, on a crash vehicle and for use in person portable forms.
The invention is configured to disperse, suitably following fluidisation, a flame colourant, such as a flame colourant powder or flame colourant liquid, that displays a colour in the presence of a hydrogen flame. That is, activation of the device when the dispersed colourant encounters a hydrogen flame it will change the colour of the flame to a colour that is in the visible spectrum. In the case of a hydrogen flame this will change it from a non-visible form to a visible form.
A first aspect of the invention provides a fire detection device configured to increase visibility of a hydrogen flame, the device including: a container containing a flame colourant for displaying a colour in the presence of a hydrogen flame; and a disperser for dispersing the colourant.
The flame colourant may be of any suitable type leading to an emission of visible light in the visible spectrum in the presence of a hydrogen flame.
The term, “displaying a colour” as used herein can refer to any emission in the visible spectrum. Suitably, the visible spectrum may be defined as wavelengths from about 380 to about 750 nanometres.
In various embodiments, the flame colourant may lead to an emission of violet (380-450 nm), blue (450-485 nm), cyan (485-500 nm), green (500-565 nm), yellow (565-590 nm), orange (590-625 nm), red (625-750 nm), or combinations thereof. The displayed colour may suitably refer to any of these, or combinations thereof.
Unless context requires otherwise, the term “hydrogen flame” is used herein to refer to a flame produced by burning hydrogen in air, or at least in the presence of some oxygen. Such a flame may already emit some light in the visible spectrum, though detection and visibility is a challenge. The flame colourant may suitably enhance the emission of visible light and/or vary its wavelength. Advantageously, the flame can thus become more detectable.
The flame colourant may comprise or consist of one or more flame colourant elements or compounds and optionally one or more carriers, solvents or auxiliary elements or compounds.
The flame colourant or one or more of its constituent ions/atoms may have an emission spectrum so as to emit visible light in the presence of a hydrogen flame.
Suitable flame colourant elements or compounds may be identified by reference to known emission spectra or for example using flame emission spectroscopy.
Elements with suitable spectra include Al, As, B, Ba, Be, Bi, C, Ca, Cd, Ce, Co, Cr, Cs, Cu, Ge, Fe, Hf, Hg, In, K, Li, Mg, Mn, Mo, Na, Nb, Ni, P, Pb, Ra, Rb, Sb, Sc, Se, Sn, Sr, Ta, Te, Ti, Tl, V, W, Y, Zn, Zr. Thus, in principle, the flame colourant may comprise or consist of one or more of these elements or their compounds.
However, advantageously, the flame colourant may be chosen to mitigate or avoid potentially adverse secondary effects. For example, preferably, a flame colourant element or compound, or indeed the flame colourant as a whole may be selected not to react exothermically, for example by oxidisation, in the presence of a hydrogen flame. Additional heat would be potentially harmful in some applications.
On the contrary, advantageously, a flame colourant element or compound, or indeed the flame colourant as a whole, may be capable of absorbing energy or undergoing an endothermic process in the presence of a hydrogen flame.
Toxicity, availability, or ease of dispersion may also be a consideration in choosing the flame colourant. However, where appropriate, mitigation or avoidance of potentially adverse secondary effects may be balanced with the desire for particular emission levels or spectra.
In various embodiments, the flame colourant may comprise or consist of one or more of the following elements or their compounds (e.g. salts): Al, Be, Bi, C, Ca, Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Ge, Fe, In, K, Li, Mg, Mn, Mo, Na, Nb, Ni, P, Pb, Rb, Sb, Sc, Se, Sn, Sr, Te, Ti, Tl, V, W, Y, Zn, Zr.
Advantageously, a flame colourant may comprise one or more metals, metal elements or metal compounds. Suitably, the flame colourant may comprise metal ions. Conveniently, the flame colourant may comprise one or more metal salts. Examples of suitable counter-ions include halide, nitrate, or sulphate.
Advantageously, the flame colourant may comprise or consist of one or more of the following elements or their compounds (e.g. salts): Al, Be, Ca, Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Fe, K, Li, Mg, Mn, Ni, Pb, Sb, Sc, Sn, Sr, V, W, Y, Zn, Zr.
Suitable metals include, for example, alkali or alkali earth metals, or transition metals. Transition metals include any element in the d-block of the periodic table, which includes groups 3 to 12 on the periodic table.
Preferred alkali metals include (Li), sodium (Na), and potassium (K). Preferred alkali earth metals include magnesium (Mg), calcium (Ca), and strontium (Sr). Preferred transition metals include Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu and Zn. In some embodiments, a flame colourant compound may comprise Cu(I), Cu(II), Fe (II), or Fe (III). For example, suitable metal salts include sodium chloride, potassium chloride, strontium chloride, lithium chloride, copper sulphate, or copper chloride. Preferably, the flame colourant comprises a flame colourant powder comprising particles of a metal salt.
In preferred embodiments the flame colourant can comprise or consist of sodium chloride (yellow, orange or yellow-orange flame) or potassium chloride (lilac or purple flame) as both these salts will create a change in the colour of the flame and are non-toxic to persons.
Such salts, or other suitable flame colourant powders in particle form, are however hygroscopic so embodiments of the invention may involve measures to avoid the uptake of water that may compromise the free flow of the powder, particularly after a period of storage. This can be by sealing the powder, ideally in a vacuum, the use of dehumidifying agents, or even a light wax coating of the particles themselves can be possible embodiments to ensure the effective long-term storage of the powder.
Other flame colourant possibilities for use with the invention include; strontium chloride (intense red flame), but this may have harmful health side effects on unprotected persons and can be corrosive affecting other parts of the vehicle; lithium chloride (pink flame), but this is very hygroscopic making storage more difficult; copper sulphate (green flame), but this is an irritant and can be toxic to persons; copper chloride (blue flame), but this is corrosive and may also be toxic to people.
In preferred embodiments the flame colourant comprises a flame colourant powder comprising particles configured to display a colour in the presence of a hydrogen flame. This arrangement is understood to provide a higher concentration of metal salts than liquid alternatives, and is considered easy to store.
In other embodiments the flame colourant may comprise a liquid. For example, a metal salt dissolved in a solvent. The skilled person will be able to readily identify a suitable solvent for a particular metal salt. Possible example solvents may include alcohol, water, or acid such as hydrochloric acid.
In embodiments in which the flame colourant comprises a flame colourant powder, the powder is preferably stored in an appropriate container, to ensure that water absorption into the powder does not take place, nor will the container allow the powder to escape in a way where it could cause corrosion in other parts of the vehicle. Thus, the container may be sealed to prevent ingress of moisture. The container may be sealed to provide a vacuum or near-vacuum.
The disperser preferably includes a means for fluidizing the flame colourant powder in the container. As the skilled person will be aware, fluidization is a process whereby a bed of solid particles is transformed into a fluid-like state. When fluidized, the flame colourant powder can flow much like a fluid.
For example, the disperser may include a cannister containing a compressed gas, and an intake configured to deliver gas from the cannister to a base of the container to thereby fluidize the flame colourant powder. Suitable gases include carbon dioxide, nitrogen or air.
The disperser may further include a gas-porous fluidizing base within the container supporting the flame colourant powder, and a plenum chamber beneath the fluidizing base, and the intake may be configured to deliver gas from the cannister to the plenum chamber. The disperser preferably further includes an outlet nozzle and an outlet conduit configured to deliver flame colourant powder from above the fluidizing base to the outlet nozzle. Such an arrangement provides a particularly simple and efficient way to achieve fluidization of the flame colourant powder.
Alternatively, the intake may include a fluidizer nozzle configured to eject the compressed gas into the flame colourant powder to thereby fluidize the powder.
The skilled person will understand that other arrangements suitable for fluidizing the flame colourant powder may be substituted for those described herein.
The container preferably forms part of the fluidiser for the powder, with a suitable plenum or entry port extending into the powder to introduce a compressed gas, and one or more exit ports to eject the fluidised powder through one or more appropriately orientated nozzles to cover the desired area with the fluidised powder. The compressed gas that is the means to fluidise and propel the powder out of the nozzles, can be carbon dioxide, nitrogen or air in preferred embodiments.
The device preferably includes a trigger device configured to activate the disperser. Thus, the fire detection device can be operated at an appropriate time or location.
In some embodiments the trigger device includes a manually activated switch configured to activate the disperser. Such an arrangement may be particularly advantageous for portable applications of the fire detection device.
The fire detection device may include a sensor configured to detect a hydrogen flame and the trigger device may be configured to activate the disperser in response to detection by the sensor of a hydrogen flame. Such an arrangement may be particularly advantageous for applications of the fire detection device where passive operation is beneficial. For example, the sensor may be configured to detect heat and/or light emitted by a flame. Optionally, the sensor comprises an infrared or ultraviolet sensor configured to detect infrared or ultraviolet electromagnetic radiation, respectively.
Alternatively, the trigger device may include a heat-activated component configured to activate in the presence of excess heat to thereby activate the disperser. For example, the component may be normally closed to prevent ingress of a compressed gas into the container, and configured to open in the presence of excess heat to permit ingress of a compressed gas into the container. Again, such an arrangement may be particularly advantageous for applications of the fire detection device where passive operation is beneficial. The heat-activated component may comprise, e.g. thermo-mechanical fuse, thermo-mechanical valve, or other component configured to open or otherwise change configuration to permit ingress of a compressed gas into the container when exposed to excess heat. Excess heat may comprise heat from a flame such as a flame from a hydrogen fire.
The compressed gas can be stored in one or more cannisters that are activated (or opened) by a mechanical action. This could be a one-shot breaking of the sealing of the cannister for a single-use system, or a fused connection, for instance that is activated by the pulling of an emergency cord. Alternatively for applications where multiple use is needed the cannister may comprise a valve that can be both opened and closed to selectively activate the device as required. In alternate embodiments where passive activation is desirable or required, for instance to activate when a fire was not anticipated or suspected, then the rupture of the seal of the cannister may be triggered by heat causing the breakage, such as a heat activated fuse. Alternatively, the trigger may come from a connected digital imaging sensor (using technology like infrared or ultraviolet sensing) that electronically detects and triggers the unsealing of the cannister. Consequentially any of these activations and release of the compressed gas would result in the fluidisation and ejection of the flame colourant powder to cover any flames and make them visible to the naked eye.
In embodiments in which the flame colourant comprises a liquid, the disperser may comprise an aerosol spray device configured to generate an aerosol mist of liquid particles. For example, the disperser may comprise a container housing the flame colourant liquid and a propellant, and a valve having open and closed positions. The propellant is held at a pressure higher than an atmospheric pressure such that movement of the valve to the open position causes the flame colourant liquid to be expelled via the valve as an aerosol, or mist. A suitable propellant will be non-flammable. Tetrafluoropropene is considered a suitable propellant in some embodiments.
Suitable applications for such passively operated embodiments may include refuelling vehicles, fuel transport vehicles or fixed installations where a fire would not normally be expected, and thus ‘automatically’ making flames visible to operators and personal if a fire is present will increase the safety of the personal. For emergency vehicles, such as common-use fire trucks or specialised aircraft crash vehicles, the application of the invention will in preferred embodiments be a multiple use system that can be switched on and off on demand if a hydrogen fire is suspected, potentially as a standard practice in approaching a hydrogen fuelled vehicle to ensure the safety of approach. For such emergency applications a handheld portable variation of the invention can also be employed, of either single or multi-use type, which can be carried and aimed and directed by an emergency worker at any potential hydrogen fire locations.
For emergency use on a vehicle, which may be an aircraft, whilst a handheld portable system may be useful for a fully trained crew member, to anticipate use by passengers with limited training (typically restricted to the pre-flight briefing) a fixed dispersion single-use system may be employed at one or more cabin exit positions. In this case the dispersion pattern of the device nozzles shall be such that they fully cover the potential egress directions of passengers and crew, and the flame colourant contents of the container(s) and the compressed gas in the propellant cannister(s) shall be sufficient to last until any potential fire has burnt out and/or the occupants have sufficient time to observe the area free of fire and evacuate the aircraft. Such a fixed dispersion system in preferred embodiments may be activated by a mechanical activation by a cord, although both valve types and digital flame sensor activation systems embodiments may optionally be employed.
In some applications, the fire detection device may comprise a portable housing containing the container and the means for dispersing the flame colourant, the portable housing being configured to be held and directed by a user. Such portable user-operated devices may be particularly useful in some applications by trained users, as described above.
A second aspect of the invention provides an emergency exit door defining an escape route, and a fire detection device according to the first aspect. Optionally the disperser is configured to disperse the flame colourant at or towards the escape route.
A third aspect of the invention provides a vehicle comprising a fire detection device according to the first aspect or an emergency exit door according to the second aspect.
A fourth aspect of the invention provides a method of detecting a hydrogen flame, the method comprising activating a fire detection device according to the first aspect, and detecting the presence of a hydrogen flame if particles in the dispersed flame colourant display a colour. The method may further include operating the trigger device to activate the disperser.
Further aspects of the invention are defined in the following numbered clauses.
1. The application of a fluidised flame colouring powder or flame colouring fluid ejected into the presence of a detected or suspected non-visible hydrogen flames to change the flame colour to be visible to the naked eye as a means to ensure the safety of passengers, crew, ground staff and emergency staff in the proximity of hydrogen powered vehicles such as a hydrogen fuelled aircraft.
2. In relation to Clause 1 the use of sodium chloride, Potassium chloride, Strontium chloride, Lithium chloride, Copper sulphate, or Copper chloride in the form of a fine powder or dissolved in an appropriate fluid to change the colour of a near non-visible hydrogen flame into a coloured flame to make it visible to the naked eye as an aid to safety.
3. In relation to Clause 1 any form of fluidiser device consisting of a compressed gas cannister, compressed gas, a valve or fuse to selectively release the compressed gas, a container to hold the flame colourant powder with a plenum or a intake, and one or more output nozzles from the container for the purpose of fluidising and ejecting a flame colourant powder to be suspended temporarily in the air.
4. In relation to Clauses 1 to 3, such a device that is person portable and can be directed by the operator at a suspected fire by orientating the whole device, or through the orientation of a flexible ejection nozzle that forms part of the device.
5. In relation to Clauses 1 to 3, such a system where the activation of the system is manual via the operation of a valve or the breaking of a fuse.
6. In relation to Clauses 1 to 3, such a system that is connected to an appropriate sensor that is able to detect near non-visible flames, including the use of digital imaging, to create an electrical trigger that enables the automatic activation of the valve or fuse to activate the system when a hydrogen flame is detected.
7. In relation to Clauses 1 to 3 where the fuse or valve is thermo-mechanically coupled and heat from a flame would cause the fuse or valve to activate and the system to eject fluidised flame colouring powder.
8. In relation to Clauses 1 to 3 and Clauses 5 to 7 where such a system was integrated or connected to the emergency exit of an aircraft or similar vehicle that was powered by hydrogen or had stored hydrogen onboard.
9. In relations to Clauses 1 to 3 and Clauses 6 and 7 where one or more such protection systems were a fixed to a refuelling vehicle or transport vehicle to cause fluidised flame colouring powder to be ejected automatically in the presence of a flame and in a dispersion pattern of the flame colourant powder that would cover all possible orientations of hydrogen flames surrounding the vehicle.
10. In relations to Clauses 1 to 3 and Clauses 5 to 7 where one or more such systems were a fixed to an emergency vehicle to be used in conjunction with possible hydrogen fires, to allow both the automatic and manual ejection of fluidised flame colouring powder in one discharge or multiple discharges.
Throughout the description and claims of this specification, the words “comprise” and “contain” and variations of the words, for example “comprising” and “comprises”, mean “including but not limited to”, and do not exclude other components, integers or steps. Moreover, the singular encompasses the plural unless the context otherwise requires: in particular, where the indefinite article is used, the specification is to be understood as contemplating plurality as well as singularity, unless the context requires otherwise.
Preferred features of each aspect of the invention may be as described in connection with any of the other aspects. Within the scope of this application it is expressly intended that the various aspects, embodiments, examples and alternatives set out in the preceding paragraphs, in the claims and/or in the following description and drawings, and in particular the individual features thereof, may be taken independently or in any combination. That is, all embodiments and/or features of any embodiment can be combined in any way and/or combination, unless such features are incompatible.
One or more embodiments of the invention will now be described, by way of example only, with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
The flame colourant powder 10 is fluidised and ejected by a compressed propellant gas 12 stored in a cannister 13, which on activation of a fuse or valve 14 by the actuation of an emergency cord or lever 15, will release the compressed propellant gas 12 into the flame colourant powder 10 to thereby fluidize the flame colourant powder 10. This is achieved by, for example, ejecting the propellant gas 12 through either a plenum and fluidizing base (as illustrated in
If the powder discharge 18 is dispersed in an area in which there is a hydrogen flame, then the reaction of the flame colourant powder 10 with the flame will cause the flame to change colour, and will make a near non-visible hydrogen flame visible. That is, the flame colourant powder 10 will emit visible light in the presence of the flame so that a colour is displayed. Suitable substances for the flame colourant powder 10 include metal salts, such as sodium chloride or potassium chloride. In such preferred embodiments the near non-visible flame will appear orange if sodium chloride is used, or purple if potassium chloride is used. This will make the nearly invisible hydrogen flame fully visible to the naked eye of any persons in proximity to the flame. Alternative embodiments may use other powders for the flame colourant powder 10, such as Strontium chloride (intense red flame), Lithium chloride (pink flame), Copper sulphate (green flame), Copper chloride (blue flame), or others, but these powders often have negative effects such as toxicity that make their use less desirable.
To activate the fluidization the compressed propellant gas 12, which is stored in an appropriate cannister 13, can be manually released via the intake 101 by opening the valve 14. The valve 14 may optionally be replaced with a single-use mechanical fuse in some embodiments. For example, a suitable single-use mechanical fuse may be normally closed, but be configured to permanently open in the presence of heat indicative of a fire. The container 11 is sealed, and when the valve 14 is opened the compressed propellant gas 12 will be forced into the plenum 102 via the intake 101, from where it rises through the porous membrane 103 and into the powder causing it to aerate and fluidize. The fluidized powder 105 is then forced in a loose state suspended in the compressed propellant gas 12 through the pickup tube and nozzle(s) 104. This fluidized powder 105 is then ejected from the pickup tube and nozzle(s) 104, and if there is a flame 106 present the reaction of the flame 106 with the colourant powder 10 will change the flame from largely invisible to the colour determined by the choice of flame colourant powder 10.
Optionally there may be one or more than one pickup tube and nozzle(s) 104 to allow several orientations to be covered with the dispersed fluidized powder 105. The pickup tube and nozzle 104 may optionally be flexible and able to be directed by the operator in a chosen direction, or the pickup tube and nozzle(s) 104 may be fixed in a predetermined orientation applicable to the application, such as the siting of an aircraft emergency exit. For emergency operator use in person portable applications the operator may be able to direct the whole device at a potential fire location if the configuration of the device is small enough, or through the use of a flexible nozzle 104.
If a particular application requires that the device be able to be activated multiple times, then the cannister 13 shall have a sufficiently large volume to ensure that enough compressed propellant gas 12 will be available. Similarly, the volume of the container 11 should allow for sufficient additional flame colourant powder 10 if multiple activations are required.
In this embodiment if a hydrogen flame 106 is present and detected by an appropriate sensor(s) 201, such as an infra-red or ultra-violet sensor(s), this will trigger a signal that will be used to activate the electric or electro-mechanical servo 202 that will open the valve 14 (or break the mechanical fuse, in variations of this embodiment), thereby releasing the compressed propellant gas 12 via the intake. This will operate the system in a similar way to that described above in relation to
Once the occupants have observed that no flames 106 are present visually thanks to the ejected fluidized powder 105, then
Given that the operator of a refueller vehicle 501 is normally working alone and has other duties such that they are unlikely to suspect the presence of a fire, preferred embodiments of the invention as a safety device 500 would be passively activated using an appropriate sensor(s) 201, such as an infra-red or ultra-violet sensor(s). Such a system could trigger the one or more hydrogen fire detection systems 502 individually or collectively as required, thereby enhancing the safety of the refueller operator and any other personal working in close proximity that could be endangered by a near non-visible hydrogen flame.
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 22191442.7 | Aug 2022 | EP | regional |
