Applicant claims priority under 35 U.S.C. § 119 of European Application No. 18207118.3 filed Nov. 19, 2018, the disclosure of which is incorporated by reference.
The invention relates to a method for monitoring an oil-injected screw compressor, in which oil from an oil separator tank is returned to a compression chamber of a compressor block, following an unintentional cold run in which condensation occurs due to a too low compression discharge temperature.
With oil-injected screw compressors, ambient air is compressed to a higher pressure. The compression process takes place inside the screw compressor block. This generates compression heat. Oil is injected into the screw compressor block to prevent the temperature of the compressed air from rising too high. The oil absorbs part of the compression heat and heats up in the process. The temperature at the end of the compression process can therefore be regulated by changing the temperature and/or quantity of the oil. This temperature is called the compression discharge temperature.
The compressed air flows over the oil separator tank 11′ and is fed to an application via aftercooler 16′. The temperature of the outflowing air is measured with the sensor 43′.
The aspirated atmospheric air contains water vapor. The change in pressure and temperature of the air changes the mass of water, which at most can be present as vaporous. If there is more water in the air in the block and oil separator tank than there can be water vapor, condensation occurs. This can lead to damage.
The compression discharge temperature is normally regulated to a value which is usually in a range between 60° C. and 100° C. To set the compression discharge temperature, the oil circuit includes an oil cooler, the cooling capacity of which can often be influenced by a fan, the speed of which can also optionally be adjusted. If less cooling capacity is required, a partial flow of the hot oil is guided past the oil cooler via a bypass, so that the oil is finally injected into the screw compressor at a predetermined desired temperature and the actual compression discharge temperature is approximated to a target compression discharge temperature. In normal operation, the compression discharge temperature is set to a lower temperature to avoid excessive damage to the oil. On the other hand, the compression discharge temperature must not be so low that condensate forms and water accumulates in the oil circuit. In this respect, the compression discharge temperature is usually set to a value at which condensate formation is definitely avoided. If there is more water in the air in the screw compressor and in the oil separator tank than there can be water vapor, condensation or condensate formation occurs. This can lead to damage. For example, corrosion can occur in the screw compressor.
In contrast to this, it is the object of the present invention to propose a method to monitor an oil-injected screw compressor, in which oil from an oil separator tank is returned to a compression chamber, for condensate formation in the oil circuit.
This object is solved by a method for monitoring an oil-injected screw compressor according to the features of the invention. Advantageous further developments are indicated below.
A core idea of the present invention is that for a point in time t a water inlet mass flow {dot over (m)}ein(t) and a water outlet mass flow {dot over (m)}aus(t) are calculated or determined and from the formation of a difference a generated condensate flow Δ{dot over (m)}w(t)={dot over (m)}ein(t)−{dot over (m)}aus(t) is calculated or determined.
The water inlet mass flow {dot over (m)}ein concerns the mass flow of vapor contained in the aspirated air.
The water outlet mass flow {dot over (m)}aus concerns the mass flow of vapor contained in the air leaving the oil separator tank.
The generated condensate flow Δ{dot over (m)}w concerns the change in the condensate mass contained in the oil circuit per time for a time period t.
Although it is theoretically conceivable to determine the water inlet mass flow that was actually aspirated with knowledge of the absolute or relative humidity; in the present case, however, it is regarded as a particularly favorable procedure to assume a worst-case scenario, under the assumption of certain values for the relative humidity, in particular a relative humidity of 100%, and therefore to assume a water inlet mass flow {dot over (m)}ein based on this scenario. By differential formation with the water outlet mass flow a generated condensate flow Δ{dot over (m)}w is calculated and thus a kind of virtual sensor for the condensate flow Δ{dot over (m)}w is defined.
Although there are approaches in the prior art to consider limit temperatures or dew point temperatures, the fact that a limit temperature or a dew point temperature is undershot alone does not provide any indication of the maximum condensate mass that could actually have occurred. Rather, the respective water inlet mass flow must be included in the consideration, in terms of the variables such as the delivery capacity of the screw compressor and the respective intake temperature TAns. Air at 30° C. has a much higher absolute humidity at 100% humidity than air at 12° C. and 100% relative humidity. In this respect, a mere comparison of temperatures with a dew point temperature is not sufficient.
In general, for humid air, the maximum water mass mw, which can be present as water vapor per air mass ma, results from the vapor pressure of the water at the current temperature psat,w(T) and the pressure p.
with Rw, Ra: gas constants of water or air
An increase in pressure therefore causes a reduction in the maximum water mass per air mass. An increase in temperature and thus in vapor pressure leads to an increase in this water mass.
If the aspirated mass of water per air mass is greater than the maximum mass that can be present as vapor in the compressed air after oil separation, liquid water (condensate) forms in the oil circuit (compressor block, oil separator tank and connections with interconnected components).
The minimum temperature at which no condensate can precipitate can be calculated on the basis of the properties of the ambient air (pressure, temperature, humidity) and the operating pressure. The target value for the compression discharge temperature should therefore be determined on the basis of this minimum temperature. This is described in the specification WO 200246617. This specification describes a regulation of the cooling via the speed of a valve fan. Another actuating variable could be a regulating valve that allows some of the oil flow past the oil cooler to the compressor block.
In practice, however, the target value for the compression discharge temperature is not always reached. For example, when starting a screw compressor which has cooled down in a standstill phase, a certain operating time is required until the screw compressor has been sufficiently heated and a sufficiently high outlet temperature can be achieved.
During operating times when the outlet temperature is too low, condensate accumulates in the oil separator tank. In unfavorable cases, too much condensate may accumulate in the oil despite a correct default target value for the temperature regulation, resulting in damage. Such unfavorable cases could be too short load running times, which are always terminated when the target value for the compression discharge temperature has not yet been reached or very low ambient conditions, possibly also a defect in regulating components.
From pressure, temperature and relative humidity of the aspirated air, as well as the conveyed air mass flow, the mass flow of the aspirated water vapor {dot over (m)}W,ein can be calculated.
The maximum possible mass flow of water vapor {dot over (m)}W,aus,max can be calculated from the pressure and temperature in the oil separator tank as well as the air mass flow conveyed, assuming a relative humidity of 100%. If condensate is present, i.e. if the mass of the condensate mK is greater than zero or if more water vapor enters the screw compressor than can escape at most, the escaping water vapor flow it {dot over (m)}W,aus is given by the maximum possible flow {dot over (m)}W,aus,max. If no condensate is present and less water vapor enters the compressor than can escape at most, the escaping water vapor flow is equal to the flow entering the compressor:
If the difference between the two mass flows
Δ{dot over (m)}w={dot over (m)}w,ein−{dot over (m)}w,aus
is positive, more water is introduced into the screw compressor than is discharged. If Δ{dot over (m)}w is negative, more water can be discharged from the screw compressor than can be introduced. In the latter case, water that has already condensed would evaporate again.
In this respect, a further development of the present invention calculates a total generated condensate mass mK from a summation of the condensate flows generated over a given period of time.
Although different methods are conceivable for summing up the condensate flows occurring over a given period of time, different methods, especially numerical methods, can be used which are easy to handle in terms of calculation technology. Preferably, a numerical integration of the condensate mass change rate Δ{dot over (m)}w(t) or an analog quantity over time is performed.
For example, a calculation is performed as follows: mK(t)=mK(t−dt)+Δ{dot over (m)}w*dt with dt=1 s. The respective condensate mass is therefore balanced at each point in time of a scanning structured by given time intervals, wherein the incremental increase or decrease results from a difference between the water inlet mass flow {dot over (m)}ein and the water outlet mass flow {dot over (m)}aus. Based on the calculated condensate mass, it can be assessed whether there is a risk of condensate damage during current operation.
Preferably, the total generated condensate mass mK(t) is calculated from a known initial value of the condensate mass mK(t0) by numerical integration of the condensate flow Δ{dot over (m)}w over time.
In concrete terms, starting from a known initial value for the condensate mass mK(t0), e.g. 0 g during start-up or oil change, condensate mass can be calculated by integration of the mass flow difference Δ{dot over (m)}w over the time t:
mK(t)=mK(t0)+∫t
This integration can be performed numerically by the control unit during compressor operation. For example, the value for Δ{dot over (m)}w can be calculated in regular time intervals Δt and the new value for the condensate mass mK(t) can be calculated in each case from the value of the condensate mass of the previous point in time mK(t−Δt):
mK(t)=mK(t−Δt)+Δ{dot over (m)}w(t)Δt
It is understood that other numerical integration methods could also be applied, e.g. using a variable step size and/or using the mass flow difference of more than one point in time in a time step.
The method according to the invention may thus provide in a preferred embodiment that a condensate mass mK is calculated from a summation of condensate mass changes that have occurred between two points in time, wherein the condensate mass change is calculated from the condensate flows at one or more points in time. In an alternative, preferred embodiment of the method, a change in a generated condensate mass mK for a specified time interval is calculated by numerical integration of the condensate flow Δ{dot over (m)}w(t) over time.
In a specifically possible embodiment of the invention, the total condensate mass mK(t) generated at a point in time t is compared with a limit value mK,max1, so that if the value mK,max1 is exceeded, it is possible to intervene in the control of the screw compressor. In concrete terms, for example, a higher partial flow can be guided past the oil cooler in the oil circuit, so that the oil heats up overall. Also, the additional cooling power generated by a fan could be turned off or limited by turning off or shutting down the fan. In such a case, the target default value for the compression discharge temperature can be increased in a very concrete embodiment or an extension of the load running interval of the screw compressor can be provided, if this is technically possible. With regard to a target temperature of the compression discharge temperature (VET), an increase by a predetermined amount can also be provided, for example by a predetermined temperature value, in particular by 5K, so that VETSoll,neu=VETSoll,alt+5K then applies.
In another preferred embodiment, the total condensate mass mK(t) generated at a point in time t is compared with a limit value mK,max2 and a warning or error message is issued if the value mK,max2 is exceeded.
In a concrete preferred embodiment, the water inlet mass flow {dot over (m)}ein(t) is calculated from the inlet air mass flow {dot over (m)}Luft(t) with the assumption of a relative humidity of 100%. This assumption makes the method according to the invention particularly easy to carry out and the virtual sensor defined in this way is comparatively simply designed.
However, it is also possible to calculate the water inlet mass flow {dot over (m)}ein(t) from the inlet air mass flow {dot over (m)}Luft(t) with the assumption of a relative humidity with a fixed value F, with 70%≤F<100%, i.e. a fixed value for example of 90%, 80% or 70%, or to calculate a relative humidity dependent on the intake temperature TAns.
Finally, it would also be possible to determine the water inlet mass flow {dot over (m)}ein(t) from the inlet air mass flow on the basis of a certain value of a relative humidity <100%, wherein the value of the relative humidity could, for example, be recorded via a hardware sensor, estimated or otherwise used as a basis for determining the water inlet mass flow. For example, data from an external weather station can also be taken into account.
In a particularly preferred embodiment, at least the following parameters are used to determine the inlet air mass flow:
In a particularly preferred embodiment, at least the following parameters are used to determine the water inlet mass flow {dot over (m)}ein(t):
In a particularly preferred embodiment, at least the following parameters are used to determine the water outlet mass flow {dot over (m)}aus(t):
In general, a water vapor mass flow {dot over (m)}w can be calculated as a function of temperature T, pressure p, inlet air mass flow {dot over (m)}Luft and relative humidity of air φ as follows:
Ra is the gas constant of air, RW is the gas constant of water vapor and Psat,W(T) is the vapor pressure of water at temperature T. The vapor pressure can be taken from water vapor tables or calculated using an approximation function, e.g. the Antoine equation:
The above-mentioned object is also solved in particular by an oil-injected screw compressor comprising a control unit, in particular a central one, which is adapted to carry out the method according to the invention.
Other objects and features of the invention will become apparent from the following detailed description considered in connection with the accompanying drawings. It is to be understood, however, that the drawings are designed as an illustration only and not as a definition of the limits of the invention.
In the drawings,
The oil separated in the oil separator tank 11 is returned via a return line 18 to the screw compressor 10 where it is injected into the compression chamber 12 for cooling, sealing and lubrication. The return line is divided into a first partial line 20 and a second partial line 21 at a branching point 19. The first partial line 20 and the second partial line 21 will be reunited in a unification point 22.
An oil cooler 23 is provided in the first partial line 20, which cooler extracts heat from the recirculated oil and for this purpose is cooled with an air stream generated by a fan 24 for better heat dissipation. The second partial line 21 forms a bypass through which oil can be guided past the oil cooler 23. With an electrically controllable, infinitely adjustable regulating valve 25, the ratio between the oil guided through the oil cooler 23 and the oil guided past the oil cooler 23 can be infinitely adjusted. This allows the temperature of the oil injected into compression chamber 12 to be set to a desired value.
During normal operation, the oil temperature of the oil injected back into compression chamber 12 is set to such a temperature value that the compression discharge temperature (VET) at an outlet 26 of the screw compressor 10 is at such a temperature level that condensate accumulation in the oil separator tank 11 is avoided. At the same time, a minimum compression discharge temperature of e.g. 60° C. is targeted. Also, a maximum compression discharge temperature must not be exceeded, let alone due to legal requirements. In this respect, a compression discharge temperature of no higher than 95° C. is the target for most screw compressors.
During normal operation, the compression discharge temperature should be set as low as possible in the aforementioned areas in order to avoid unnecessary stress of the oil; on the other hand, as already mentioned, condensate formation should be prevented with certainty.
The screw compressor 10 further has a central control unit 40 or interacts with such a central control unit 40. The central control unit 40 can receive data from various sensors in a preferred embodiment, namely from a first temperature sensor which is designed and arranged to detect the intake temperature TAns, a second temperature sensor 42 which is arranged to detect the compression discharge temperature at an outlet of the compressor block 30 and a third temperature sensor 43 which is designed and arranged to detect the temperature T2 after the oil separator 11. The central control unit 40 also receives data from two pressure sensors, namely a first pressure sensor 44 which is arranged and provided for the detection of a pressure Pakt in the oil separator tank 11 and a second pressure sensor 45 which is intended for the detection of a network pressure PN after the aftercooler. A further third pressure sensor (not shown) may be located on the central control unit to detect and transmit an ambient pressure Pamb. However, the ambient pressure can also be taken into account as an assumed value or received externally, for example via a data network, for example from a weather station. In addition, a fixed assumed temperature value can be used instead of the temperature TAns, which is recorded by the temperature sensor 42, for example. A fixed temperature value of 25° C. or 30° C. may optionally also be used, for example, depending on the installation location. Instead of a pressure PAkt in the oil separator tank 11, it is also possible to recalculate the pressure in the oil separator tank PAkt from the data supplied by the pressure sensor 45, i.e. from the network pressure PN, or the pressure in the oil separator tank PAkt can be estimated from the network pressure PN. Furthermore, a fixed value for the pressure in the oil separator tank PAkt can also be assumed, for example the maximum value which is preset on the operating side for the screw compressor or a maximum value which is preset by an operator at the control unit of the screw compressor.
According to the present invention, a method or a virtual sensor is proposed to monitor or determine the correct functioning of the above-mentioned regulation if condensate accumulation appears to be inadvertently possible. For this purpose, water mass flows are compared with each other at respectively predetermined sampling times and a currently generated condensate flow is determined from this. From an addition of the value of the currently generated condensate flow, which can assume different signs, and the condensate mass already present from previous calculations, a currently existing condensate mass is calculated.
Since a worst-case scenario can be assumed when determining the water inlet mass flow, for example that the ambient air has a 100% relative humidity, certain values, such as condensate flow or condensate mass, are always to be understood as “currently possible generated condensate flow or currently possible condensate mass”, i.e. also as a worst-case scenario. With the water outlet mass flow, on the other hand, it is assumed that there is 100% saturation anyway if condensate is to be discharged, so that here the maximum possible water outlet mass flow should at least approximately coincide with the actually discharged water outlet mass flow.
On the basis of the flowchart according to
{dot over (m)}Luft(t)={dot over (m)}L(pamb,paktn,TAns . . . ) (1)
The calculation of the possible air mass flow includes a system-specific delivery characteristic, which depends on the current speed n for screw compressors regulated by frequency converters, the pressure pakt in the oil separator tank 11, the ambient pressure pamb, and the intake temperature TAns after the oil separator tank 11.
In a step 103, a water inlet mass flow is calculated from the possible air mass flow according to the following formula (2):
{dot over (m)}ein(t)={dot over (m)}w(TAns,pamb, {dot over (m)}Luft,φ=100%) (2)
This calculation or determination is based on a worst case scenario, i.e. it is assumed that the aspirated ambient air has a relative humidity of 100%.
In a step 104, the current water outlet mass flow is calculated with the following formula (3)
{dot over (m)}aus(t)={dot over (m)}w(T2,pakt,{dot over (m)}Luft,φ=100%) (3)
in which the temperature T2 after the oil separator tank 11, the pressure in the oil separator tank pakt, the inlet air mass flow {dot over (m)}Luft and a relative humidity of 100% are included in this calculation. It should be clear to the person skilled in the art that steps 103 and 104 can also take place in reverse order or at the same time.
From the water inlet mass flow determined in step 103 and the water outlet mass flow determined in step 104, a current water mass change rate, i.e. a currently generated condensate mass, is calculated in step 105 according to equation (4) as follows:
Δ{dot over (m)}w(t)={dot over (m)}ein(t)−maus(t) (4).
If the currently generated water mass change rate or the currently generated condensate mass is positive, condensate is actually produced and an existing condensate mass is increased. If, on the other hand, the value of the currently generated water mass change rate or the currently generated condensate mass is negative, condensate is discharged, i.e. a current condensate mass is reduced.
The currently present condensate mass mK is calculated according to equation (5) in step 106, so that the currently given condensate mass is updated taking into account the current water mass change rate calculated in step 105.
The method could theoretically start again from scratch at this point if the determination of the currently given condensate mass mK is only to take place in the sense of a virtual sensor.
However, other measures may also be considered. For this purpose, step 107 checks whether the currently given condensate mass mK≤0. In this case, the currently given condensate mass is set to zero in one step 108 and the process is started from the beginning. If the currently given condensate mass mK is positive, on the other hand, the process is restarted in a step 109 with the currently given condensate mass mK, and on the other hand in a step 110 it is checked whether the currently given condensate mass mK is above a limit value mK,max1, i.e. above a certain amount of condensate. If this is the case, in a further step 111 the target value of the compression discharge temperature is increased by 5K until the currently given condensate mass has reached the value 0 again. However, it is also taken into account that the compression discharge temperature does not exceed a maximum value of 95° C. However, if it is determined in step 110 that the currently present condensate mass has not exceeded the specified limit value of mK,max1, the target value of the compression discharge temperature is not affected.
Although above a mass flow or a mass change rate was represented as a quantity characterizing the water flow or the condensate accumulation, a volume flow at a suitable reference condition or also a mass flow can be used instead. Alternatively, it would also be possible to calculate a quantity characterizing the condensate mass change approximately by the product of a quantity characterizing the air mass flow (e.g. mass, volume, quantity) and the difference of the water vapor pressures of inlet and outlet each converted to a common reference pressure.
Although only a few embodiments of the present invention have been shown and described, it is to be understood that many changes and modifications may be made thereunto without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
18207118 | Nov 2018 | EP | regional |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
7722333 | DeRosa | May 2010 | B2 |
20160245273 | Wagner | Aug 2016 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
43 13 573 | Oct 1994 | DE |
1 475 586 | Nov 2004 | EP |
2 277 462 | Nov 1994 | GB |
0246617 | Jun 2002 | WO |
WO-0246617 | Jun 2002 | WO |
2015103678 | Jul 2015 | WO |
Entry |
---|
European Search Report dated Jan. 28, 2019 in European Application No. 18207118.3 with English translation of the relevant parts. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20200158112 A1 | May 2020 | US |