Apparatus for holding workpiece

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6290583
  • Patent Number
    6,290,583
  • Date Filed
    Thursday, September 10, 1998
    26 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, September 18, 2001
    23 years ago
Abstract
An apparatus for holding a workpiece is incorporated in a polishing apparatus which polishes the workpiece to a flat mirror finish. The workpiece holding apparatus has a top ring holding a workpiece and a top ring drive shaft for rotating the top ring and pressing the top ring holding the workpiece against a turntable. A rotary joint is removably provided on the top ring drive shaft for allowing fluid to pass therethrough to thereby communicate with an external fluid source. A passage provided in the top ring drive shaft allows the rotary joint to communicate with through-holes formed in the top ring.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




1. Field of the Invention




The present invention relates to an apparatus for holding a workpiece, and more particularly to an apparatus for holding a workpiece such as a semiconductor wafer for use in a polishing apparatus which polishes the workpiece to a flat mirror finish.




2. Description of the Related Art




Recent rapid progress in semiconductor device integration demands smaller and smaller wiring patterns or interconnections and also narrower spaces between interconnections which connect active areas. One of the processes available for forming such interconnections is photolithography. Though the photolithographic process can form interconnections that are at most 0.5 μm wide, it requires that surfaces on which pattern images are to be focused by a stepper be as flat as possible because the depth of focus of the optical system is relatively small.




It is therefore necessary to make the surfaces of semiconductor wafers flat for photolithography. One customary way of flattening the surfaces of semiconductor wafers is to polish them with a polishing apparatus.




Conventionally, a polishing apparatus comprises a turntable having a polishing cloth thereon, a top ring for holding a workpiece such as a semiconductor wafer, a pressing device for pressing the workpiece held by the top ring against the polishing cloth on the turntable, and a driving device for rotating the top ring about its own axis. The top ring is coupled to the pressing device and the driving device through a top ring drive shaft. When the workpiece is transferred to the top ring, it is held by the lower surface of the top ring under vacuum developed in the top ring. When the workpiece is polished, a pressurized fluid such as compressed air is supplied from the top ring to the backside surface of the workpiece, thereby pressing a surface of the workpiece to be polished against a polishing surface comprising the polishing cloth on the turntable. Therefore, the top ring drive shaft coupled to the upper portion of the top ring is provided at its upper part with a rotary joint by which the top ring communicates with an external vacuum source or an external fluid source.




In the conventional polishing apparatus, the rotary joint is integrally formed with the top ring drive shaft. To be more specific, a lateral hole communicating with a vertical hole formed in the top ring drive shaft is formed in the upper part of the top ring drive shaft. By fixing the rotary joint incorporating the sealing portion therein to the top ring drive shaft, the lateral hole is caused to communicate with the connecting portion of the rotary joint which is connected to the external fluid source. Therefore, the conventional rotary-joint structure is problematic in that making the ring drive shaft is complicated and the replacement of the rotary joint is extremely troublesome when the sealing portion is damaged or worn.




Further, in the conventional rotary joint, the contacting surface between a stationary ring and a rotating ring serves as a sealing surface, and it is necessary to seal against a vacuum, pressurized air and pressurized liquid. In the case where the top ring communicates with the vacuum source through the rotary joint, a slurry-like abrasive liquid containing abrasive particles (or grains) is occasionally sucked up which then reaches, the sealing surface of the rotary joint. In this case, the abrasive liquid enters the sealing surface between the stationary ring and the rotating ring to thereby wear the sealing surface, and hence the sealing surface becomes irregular to cause fluid to leak therefrom.




Further, in the conventional rotary joint, fluid is prevented from leaking by a high contact pressure produced by making a spring force pressing the rotating ring and the stationary ring against each other larger. Therefore, the wear of the sealing surface progresses and the temperature rises in the sealing surface occurs, which causes thermal-stress cracking in either the stationary ring or the rotating ring.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




It is therefore an object of the present invention to provide an apparatus for holding a workpiece in which a rotary joint can be attached to a top ring drive shaft without requiring a specific manufacturing operation for the top ring drive shaft, and can be easily replaced if the rotary joint is damaged or worn, by making the rotary joint a discrete unit.




Another object of the present invention is to provide an apparatus for holding a workpiece in which slurry can be prevented from entering a sealing surface of the rotary joint, and a temperature rise in the sealing surface can also be prevented from occurring to thereby avoid thermal-stress cracking in either a stationary ring or a rotating ring.




According to an aspect of the present invention, there is provided an apparatus for holding a workpiece comprising a top ring holding a workpiece, a top ring drive shaft for rotating the top ring and pressing the top ring holding the workpiece against a turntable, a rotary joint removably provided on the top ring drive shaft for allowing fluid to pass therethrough to thereby communicate with an external fluid source, and a passage provided in the top ring drive shaft for allowing the rotary joint to communicate with through-holes formed in the top ring.




According to the present invention, since the rotary joint is removably provided on the top ring drive shaft, it can be easily replaced with a new one if it is damaged or worn. Further, since the rotary joint is constructed as a discrete unit removable from the top ring drive shaft, a specific manufacturing operation for the top ring drive shaft, such as boring, is not required, thus reducing the manufacturing cost of the top ring drive shaft.




The rotary joint comprises a body, a stationary ring fixed to the body, a rotating ring housed in the body and rotated integrally with the top ring drive shaft, and a liquid supply hole formed in the body for supplying liquid to an outer circumferential portion of a contacting surface between the stationary ring and the rotating ring.




With the above structure, by supplying liquid such as pure water to the outer circumferential portion of the contacting surface between the stationary ring and the rotating ring, a sealing film of liquid is formed between the stationary ring and the rotating ring when a vacuum is developed. This sealing liquid prevents slurry such as an abrasive liquid from entering the contacting surface between the stationary ring and the rotating ring. Further, by supplying liquid to the contacting surface between the stationary ring a and the rotating ring, temperature rise generated by relative sliding movement of the stationary ring and the rotating ring can be suppressed to thus prevent thermal-stress cracking in either the rotating ring or the stationary ring.




The above and other objects, features, and advantages of the present invention will become apparent from the following description when taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings which illustrate a preferred embodiment of the present invention by way of example.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a vertical cross-sectional view showing an apparatus for holding a workpiece in a polishing apparatus according to an embodiment of the present invention;





FIG. 2

is an enlarged fragmentary vertical cross-sectional view showing essential parts of the apparatus for holding the workpiece shown in

FIG. 1

;





FIG. 3

is a vertical cross-sectional view of a rotary joint in the apparatus for holding the workpiece shown in

FIG. 1

; and





FIG. 4

is a cross-sectional view showing the whole structure of the polishing apparatus according to an embodiment of the present invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS




An apparatus for holding a workpiece according to an embodiment of the present invention will be described below with reference to

FIGS. 1 through 3

.




As shown in

FIGS. 1 and 2

, an apparatus for holding a workpiece (hereinafter referred to as workpiece holding apparatus


1


) comprises a substantially disk-like top ring


10


, a top ring drive shaft


12


for supporting the top ring


10


and transmitting a rotating force and a pressing force to the top ring


10


, and a universal joint unit


14


for coupling the top ring drive shaft


12


and the top ring


10


in such a manner that the top ring drive shaft


12


and the top ring


10


tilt relative to each other.




The top ring


10


comprises a substantially disk-like holding plate


16


for holding a semiconductor wafer (workpiece) to be polished at a lower surface thereof, a substantially disk-like cover plate


18


fixed to the holding plate


16


so as to define a gap S between the holding plate


16


and the cover plate


18


, and an annular plate


20


for covering the holding plate


16


and the cover plate


18


. A guide ring


22


is attached to the lower circumferential portion of the holding plate


16


for retaining a circumferential edge of the workpiece. An elastic pad


15


is attached to the lower surface of the holding plate


16


.




The holding plate


16


has a recess


24


at an upper central part thereof, and a step


26


around the recess


24


. The cover plate


18


has at its lower surface a projecting portion


28


which is fitted in the recess


24


of the holding plate


16


. Further, the cover plate


18


has a flange


30


, around the projecting portion


28


, which is fixed to the step


26


of the holding plate


16


by bolts. The cover plate


18


has at its upper surface a recess


32


and an annular shoulder


34


around the recess


32


, and a step outwardly of the shoulder


34


for attachment of the annular plate


20


. The depth of the recess


24


of the holding plate


16


is larger than the height of the projecting portion


28


of the cover plate


18


. Thus, the certain gap S is defined between the recess


24


and the projecting portion


28


. The holding plate


16


has a number of through holes


38


which communicate with holes


40


formed in the annular plate


20


through the gap S between the cover plate


18


and the holding plate


16


.




Further, the gap S communicates with the backside surface of the workpiece held by the lower surface of the holding plate


16


through the through holes


38


. In the gap S, negative pressure or positive pressure is developed by allowing the gap S to communicate with a vacuum source or a pressurized fluid source. To be more specific, if the gap S communicates with the vacuum source, an attracting force is applied to the backside surface of the workpiece, and if the gap S communicates with the pressurized fluid source, a pressing force is applied to the backside surface of the workpiece.




The top ring drive shaft


12


is rotatably and vertically movably supported by a top ring head


42


which is supported by a frame of the polishing apparatus. That is, the top ring drive shaft


12


is coupled to an output shaft of a driving source (comprising a motor with reduction gears) provided on the top ring head


42


through a pully-belt mechanism


44


so as to be rotatable.




Further, the top ring drive shaft


12


is vertically movable by a top ring cylinder


48


provided between the top ring head


42


and a drive shaft holder


46


. The top ring cylinder


48


is actuated by supplying air there to and discharging air there from. The body of the top ring cylinder


48


is fixed to the shoulder of the drive shaft holder


46


, and the forward end of the rod


48




a


is fixed to the upper surface of the top ring head


42


.




The top ring drive shaft


12


is a hollow cylindrical member, and has at its central part a vertical hole


50


which communicates with an external fluid source


54


through a rotary joint


70


. In the vertical hole


50


, there is provided a tube


56


made of synthetic resin having corrosion resistance such as Teflon (the trade name of polytetrafluoroethylene) or polypropylene. The upper end of the tube


56


is connected to the rotary joint


70


, and the lower end of the tube


56


is branched into two tubes


56




a,




56




b


through a branch connection


57


. The tubes


56




a,




56




b


communicate with the holes


40


of the annular plate


20


.




The rotary joint


70


has at its lower end a screw


70




a


which is threaded into a thread


63




a


of a member


63


fixed to the upper end of the top ring drive shaft


12


. That is, the rotary joint


70


is fixed to the top ring drive shaft


12


by the screw engagement, and hence mounting or dismounting of the rotary joint


70


can be easily performed, and the replacement of the rotary joint


70


can be easily performed if it is damaged or worn. Further, since the rotary joint


70


is a discrete unit which is separable from the top ring drive shaft


12


, a lateral hole communicating with the vertical hole


50


is not required to be formed in the top ring drive shaft


12


and the manufacture of the top ring drive shaft


12


can be easily conducted.




The external fluid source


54


comprises a vacuum source


58


, a pressurized air source


60


and a pure water supply source


62


which can selectably communicate with the through holes


38


of the holding plate


16


through selective control valves


64




a


through


64




c,


the rotary joint


70


, the tube


56


, and the tubes


56




a,




56




b.







FIG. 3

is a front view partly in section showing the detailed structure of the rotary joint


70


. As shown in

FIG. 3

, the rotary joint


70


comprises a lower body


71


, an upper body


72


fixed to the lower body


71


, a hollow rotating shaft


74


supported by ball bearings


73


,


73


provided in the lower body


71


, and a hollow stationary shaft


75


fixed to the upper body


72


. The upper body


72


has a part


72




a


through which fluid is supplied to the rotary joint


70


or discharged from the rotary joint


70


.




A rotating ring


76


made of ceramics such as silicon carbide (SiC) is fixed to the upper end of the rotating shaft


74


. The rotating shaft


74


has at its lower end the screw


70




a


which is threaded into the top ring drive shaft


12


. A stationary ring


77


made of ceramics such silicon carbide (SiC) is fixed to the lower end of the stationary shaft


75


. The stationary ring


77


is brought into sliding contact with the rotating ring


76


. The stationary ring


77


is pressed against the rotating ring


76


by a compression coil spring


79


to cause the stationary ring


77


to normally contact the rotary ring


76


. That is, the rotating ring


76


and the stationary ring


77


allow fluid to pass therethrough to thereby supply fluid between the rotating part and the stationary part and constitute a sealing surface which prevents fluid from leaking externally.




An oil seal


80


is provided around the upper circumferential portion of the rotating shaft


74


, and pure water is supplied to a space


81


defined above the oil seal


80


through a pure water supply hole


71




a


formed in the lower body


71


. Therefore, it is possible to supply pure water to the outer circumferential portion of the sealing surface between the rotating ring


76


and the stationary ring


77


. A water expulsion mechanism


82


comprising upper and lower rings is provided between the oil seal


80


and the ball bearing


73


to prevent liquid such as pure water from entering the ball bearing


73


. That is, the water expulsion mechanism


82


constitutes a leakage-prevention section which prevents liquid from entering the ball bearing


73


. The reference numeral


83


represents a drain hole which serves to discharge leakage liquid from the oil seal


80


to the exterior of the rotary joint


72


.




As shown in

FIGS. 1 and 2

, a driving plate


68


having a flange


66


extending outwardly is fixed to the lower end of the top ring drive shaft


12


. The universal joint unit


14


is provided between the driving plate


68


and the cover plate


18


of the top ring


10


so that the top ring


10


is tiltably supported by the top ring drive shaft


12


and the pressing force is transmitted from the top ring drive shaft


12


to the top ring


10


. The universal joint unit


14


comprises a spherical bearing mechanism


170


and a rotation transmission mechanism


172


for transmitting the rotation of the top ring drive shaft


12


to the top ring


10


.




The spherical bearing mechanism


170


comprises a central spherical concave surface


100


formed in the lower end of the projecting portion


176


of the driving plate


68


, a central spherical concave surface


102


formed in the upper end of the cover plate


18


, and a ball


78


made of high hardness material such as ceramics interposed between the spherical concave surfaces


100


and


102


. A plurality of pins


84


and


86


(six in this embodiment) that extend upwardly are provided at equal angular intervals on the shoulder


34


of the cover plate


18


, and these pins


84


and


86


are inserted into holes


88


and


90


formed in the flange


66


of the driving plate


68


. The pins


84


serve to lift the top ring


10


and these pins


86


serve to transmit rotation of the top ring drive shaft


12


to the top ring


10


. The pin


84


projects from the upper surface of the driving plate


68


, and a compression coil spring


94


is provided between a stopper


92


of the pin


84


and the driving plate


68


to support a part of weight of the top ring


10


by the resilient force of the spring


94


. Two parallel pins


98


extending horizontally are provided in the flange


66


so as to sandwich the pin


86


. In this case, even if the holding plate


16


is inclined, since the driven pin


86


and the driving pins


98


are relatively vertically movable, the torque of the top ring drive shaft


12


can be reliably transmitted to the holding plate


16


with movement of the contacting point of the pins


86


and


98


.





FIG. 4

shows the polishing apparatus which incorporates the workpiece holding apparatus


1


shown in

FIGS. 1 through 3

. As shown in

FIG. 4

, a turntable


90


is supported on a central shaft


90




a


and is rotatable about the axis of the shaft


90




a.


A polishing cloth


91


is attached to the upper surface of the turntable


90


. The workpiece holding apparatus


1


holding a semiconductor wafer


2


is disposed above the turntable


90


. An abrasive liquid supply nozzle


92


is disposed above the turntable


90


so that an abrasive liquid Q containing abrasive material can be supplied to the polishing cloth


91


on the turntable


90


.




Next, the operation of the polishing apparatus incorporating the workpiece holding apparatus


1


shown in

FIGS. 1 through 4

will be described.




The tube


56


in the top ring drive shaft


12


communicates with the vacuum source


58


of the external fluid source


54


through the rotary joint


70


, and hence the semiconductor wafer


2


is held by the lower surface of the holding plate


16


under vacuum developed in the through holes


38


of the holding plate


16


. The driving source is energized, and the top ring drive shaft


12


is rotated to thus rotate the holding plate


16


. In this case, the tube


56


made of Teflon or polypropylene has a strength such that it is hardly deformed when it communicates with the vacuum source


58


.




The semiconductor wafer


2


is held by the top ring


10


, and pressed against the polishing cloth


91


on the turntable


90


by the top ring cylinder


48


. At this time, the turntable


90


is being rotated, and the top ring


10


is also being rotated to thus produce the relative motion between the semiconductor wafer


2


and the polishing cloth


91


. Further, the abrasive liquid Q is supplied from the abrasive liquid supply nozzle


92


onto the polishing cloth


91


. The supplied abrasive liquid Q is retained on the polishing cloth


91


, and the semiconductor wafer


2


is polished in contact with the polishing cloth


91


. During polishing, by allowing the tube


56


in the top ring drive shaft


12


to communicate with the pressurized air source


60


of the fluid source


54


through the rotary joint


70


, the pressurized air is supplied to the backside surface of the semiconductor wafer


2


through the through holes


38


, whereby the semiconductor wafer


2


is pressed against the polishing cloth


91


.




In this case, the pressing force of the top ring drive shaft


12


is transmitted to the top ring


10


through the spherical bearing mechanism


170


. When the upper surface of the turntable


90


is slightly tilted during polishing of the semiconductor wafer, the holding plate


16


is tilted about the ball


78


with respect to the top ring drive shaft


12


to thereby bring the en-tire surface of the semiconductor wafer


2


in close contact with the polishing surface of the turntable


90


.




After completing polishing of the semiconductor wafer, the top ring drive shaft


12


is lifted to raise the top ring


10


, and then the top ring


10


is moved away from the turntable


90


and positioned above a transfer device for transferring the semiconductor wafer from or to the top ring


10


. At this time, the semiconductor wafer


2


is held by the lower surface of the holding plate


16


under vacuum by causing the tube


56


in the top ring drive shaft


12


to communicate with the vacuum source


58


through the rotary joint


70


. Thereafter, the communication between the tube


56


and the vacuum source


58


is stopped, and the tube


56


communicates with the pure water supply source


62


through the rotary joint


70


. Thus, the semiconductor wafer


2


is easily removed from the holding plate


16


because the pure water supplied through the tube


56


, the gap S and the through holes


38


of the holding plate


16


pushes the backside surface of the semiconductor wafer


2


.




According to the embodiment of the present invention, the rotary joint


70


is constructed as a discrete unit removable from the top ring drive shaft


12


, and is fixed to the upper end of the top ring drive shaft


12


through the screw engagement. Therefore, the mounting or dismounting of the rotary joint


70


can be easily performed, and the rotary joint


70


can be easily replaced with a new one if it is damaged or worn. Further, the rotary joint


70


can be mounted or dismounted in an axial direction of the top ring drive shaft


12


, thereby facilitating the replacement work. Further, it is unnecessary to form a lateral hole which communicates with the vertical hole


50


in the top ring drive shaft


12


, and hence the work of the top ring drive shaft


12


is extremely simple.




Further, according to the embodiment of the present invention, by supplying pure water to the outer circumferential portion of the sealing surface of the rotary joint


70


, i.e., the outer circumferential portion of the rotating ring


76


and the stationary ring


77


, a sealing film is formed between the rotating ring


76


and the stationary ring


77


when a vacuum is developed in the sealing surface of the both rings


76


and


77


. This sealing film of pure water prevents a slurry such as an abrasive liquid from entering the sealing surface of the rotary joint


70


. Further, by supplying pure water to the outer circumferential portion of the sealing surface, a temperature rise caused by frictional heat between the rotating ring


76


and the stationary ring


77


can be suppressed to thus prevent thermal-stress cracking in either the rotating ring


76


or the stationary ring


77


. By providing the water expulsion mechanism


82


above the ball bearing


73


, liquid leaking from the sealing surface is prevented from entering the interior of the ball bearing


73


to thus prevent the bearing


73


from being damaged.




Further, according to the embodiment of the present invention, by suitably arranging the outer diameters of the rotating ring


76


and the stationary ring


77


, depending on the property or pressure of fluid, the sealing surface of the rotary joint


70


can have an optimum pressure balancing diameter, and hence an excessive pressure is not applied by the spring


79


to the sealing surface of the rotary joint


70


. Therefore, the wear of the sealing surface can be reduced to a minimum, and the temperature rise of the sealing surface can also be prevented. Since the tube


56


connected to the rotary joint


70


is made of a corrosion-resistant material, even if air and water are allowed to pass therethrough alternately, the generation of rust is prevented in the tube


56


. Thus, fluid is not contaminated by rust, and hence the polishing performance and quality of the polished semiconductor wafer are improved.




Although certain preferred embodiments of the present invention have been shown and described in detail, it should be understood that various changes and modifications may be made therein without departing from the scope of the appended claims.



Claims
  • 1. An apparatus for holding a workpiece comprising:a top ring holding a workpiece; a top ring drive shaft for rotating said top ring; a rotary joint provided on said top ring drive shaft for allowing fluid to pass therethrough to thereby communicate with an external fluid source; and a passage provided in said top ring drive shaft to allow said rotary joint to communicate with said top ring; wherein said rotary joint comprises a body, a stationary part provided in said body, a rotating part housed in said body, being rotated with said top ring drive shaft, and being in sliding contact with said stationary part such that there is a contacting surface between said stationary part and said rotating part, and a liquid supply hole formed in said body for supplying liquid to an outer circumferential portion of said contacting surface.
  • 2. An apparatus according to claim 1, wherein said rotary joint is mounted on said top ring drive shaft by a screw engagement.
  • 3. An apparatus according to claim 1, wherein said passage comprises a tube made of corrosion-resistant material.
  • 4. An apparatus according to claim 1, wherein said external fluid source comprises at least one of a vacuum source, a pressurized air source and a liquid supply source.
  • 5. An apparatus for holding a workpiece comprising:top ring holding a workpiece; a top ring drive shaft for rotating said top ring; a rotary joint provided on said top ring drive shaft for allowing fluid to pass therethrough to thereby communicate with an external fluid source; and a passage provided in said top ring drive shaft to allow said rotary joint to communicate with said top ring; wherein said rotary joint comprises a body, a stationary part provided in said body, a rotating part housed in said body, being rotated with said top ring drive shaft, and being in sliding contact with said stationary part, a bearing for rotatably supporting said rotating part, a sealing section between said rotating part and said body, and a leakage-prevention section between said sealing section and said bearing for preventing liquid from entering said bearing.
  • 6. A polishing apparatus for polishing a surface of a workpiece comprising:a turntable having a polishing surface thereon; a top ring holding a workpiece; a top ring drive shaft for rotating said top ring; a rotary joint provided on said top ring drive shaft for allowing fluid to pass therethrough to thereby communicate with an external fluid source; and a passage provided in said top ring drive shaft to allow said rotary joint to communicate with said top ring; wherein said rotary joint comprises a body, a stationary part provided in said body, a rotating part housed in said body, being rotated with said top ring drive shaft, and being in sliding contact with said stationary part such that there is a contacting surface between said stationary part and said rotating part, and a liquid supply hole formed in said body for supplying liquid to an outer circumferential portion of said contacting surface.
  • 7. A polishing apparatus for polishing a surface of a workpiece comprising:a turntable having a polishing surface thereon; a top ring holding a workpiece; a top ring drive shaft for rotating said top ring; a rotary joint provided on said top ring drive shaft for allowing fluid to pass therethrough to thereby communicate with an external fluid source; and a passage provided in said top ring drive shaft to allow said rotary joint to communicate with said top ring; wherein said rotary joint comprises a body, a stationary part provided in said body, a rotating part housed in said body, being rotated with said top ring drive shaft, and being in sliding contact with said stationary part, a bearing for rotatably supporting said rotating part, a sealing section between said rotating part and said body, and a leakage-prevention section between said sealing section and said bearing for preventing liquid from entering said bearing.
Priority Claims (1)
Number Date Country Kind
9-262796 Sep 1997 JP
US Referenced Citations (22)
Number Name Date Kind
3571978 Day et al. Mar 1971
3838718 Flory et al. Oct 1974
3889983 Freize et al. Jun 1975
4254972 Wiedenbeck Mar 1981
4339108 Daniluk Jul 1982
4360186 Tinsley et al. Nov 1982
4632431 McCracken Dec 1986
4647077 Ethridge et al. Mar 1987
5058927 Miwa Oct 1991
5110162 Peter et al. May 1992
5185959 Ikola et al. Feb 1993
5209526 Beccia et al. May 1993
5303959 Medsker Apr 1994
5443416 Volodarsky et al. Aug 1995
5643053 Shendon Jul 1997
5653476 Su et al. Aug 1997
5670011 Togawa et al. Sep 1997
5738574 Tolles et al. Apr 1998
5747386 Moore May 1998
5820448 Shamouilian et al. Oct 1998
5839947 Kimura et al. Nov 1998
6024633 Kimura et al. Feb 2000
Foreign Referenced Citations (3)
Number Date Country
58-22657 Feb 1983 JP
4-201174 Jul 1992 JP
404203581 Jul 1992 JP