Apparatus for manufacturing photographic emulsions

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6443611
  • Patent Number
    6,443,611
  • Date Filed
    Friday, December 15, 2000
    23 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, September 3, 2002
    22 years ago
Abstract
An apparatus and method for mixing at least two reactants is taught wherein a first reactant is delivered to a reaction zone through a first annular flow path and a second reactant is delivered to the reaction zone through a second annular flow path. The first and second annular flow paths are concentric with one another and the two reactants intermix with one another in the reaction zone. There is a rotating disc having a surface, defining one boundary of the reaction zone. The flow of the first and second reactants across the rotating disc and through the reaction zone is generally radial and has a residence time in the reaction zone of not more than about 100 msec, and preferably not more than about 50 msec. The reaction zone resides in a main reactor vessel and there is a driven agitator residing in the main reactor vessel to stir the contents thereof.
Description




FIELD OF THE INVENTION




This invention relates to mixing apparatus for intermixing two or more reactants and, more particularly, to mixing apparatus for manufacturing photographic emulsions.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




Most state-of-the-art manufacturing processes used in the photographic industry expose emulsion grains to local high concentrations of silver nitrate in the vicinity of the silver nitrate reagent introduction pipes. (See for example U.S. Pat. Nos. 3,415,650, 3,692,283, 4,289,733, 4,666,669, 5,096,690, 5,238,805). Such exposure is undesirable because of the uncontrolled amount of reduced silver centers that may be created on the grain surface. The variable amount of reduced silver centers lead to variability in photographic sensitivity of the emulsions, which is undesirable.




In processes where an additional mixing vessel is used to mix silver nitrate with alkali halide prior to introducing them as fine silver halide grains into the reaction vessel (see for example U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,145,768 and 5,334,359), such an exposure is avoided but, additional complexities are created related to the additional mixing vessel and transport of material from that additional mixing vessel to the reaction vessel. When the mixing vessel is separate from and positioned externally to the main reaction vessel, problems arise due to the growth of fine grains during the solution delivery from the mixing vessel to the main reaction vessel. Such a process usually does not meet the requirement of grain formation in a time period as short as realized in the conventional method. When the mixing vessel is immersed in the reaction vessel, the above problem is apparently solved only when a separate heavy duty mechanical stirrer is provided near the discharge slit of the mixing vessel for immediate uniform mixing of the discharged solution with the reaction mixture. It is, however, well known that a well stirred mixing vessel has an exponential distribution of residence times (cf. O. Levenspiel, Chemical Reaction Engineering, 2nd Edition, Chapter 9). Therefore, a small fraction of discharge fluid bypasses the mixing process inside the mixing vessel and microscopic pockets of high concentration silver nitrate solution are expected to be discharged into the reaction vessel. Furthermore, when the discharge fluid meets the reaction mixture in the space between the two heavy duty mechanical stirrers, the mixing intensity is lower than that near the stirrer blades, so the pockets of high concentration silver nitrate solution are not immediately eliminated. Also, the discharge slit of the mixing vessel has to be provided with a back flow preventing valve to prevent reaction mixture from flowing into the mixing vessel, providing yet another operational complexity in a manufacturing environment.




U.S. Pat. No. 5,690,428 to Bryan et al. teaches a mixing device that includes concentric tubes for supplying solutions to a mixing rotor. The mixing rotor in combination with the supply tubes creates a non-planar, annular reaction zone that includes step changes in diameter thereof, and therefore, multiple turns in the flow path through the reaction zone.




There is continuing need for manufacturing high sensitivity photographic emulsions with tightly controlled sensitivities. Since prior art mixing apparatus subject emulsion grains to variable high concentrations of silver nitrate in the reaction vessel, tight control of sensitivity of the emulsion being manufactured is difficult. In prior art processes where the emulsion grains are not exposed to high concentrations of silver nitrate, the problem is either that of longer grain formation time than the conventional process, or that of increased operational complexity of the manufacturing process, resulting from the placement of at least two separate heavy duty mechanical stirrers in close proximity of each other.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




It is therefore an object of the present invention to provide an apparatus for mixing two or more reactants which provides a very short residence time in the apparatus.




It is a further object of the present invention to provide an apparatus for mixing two or more reactants which obviates any back flow in the apparatus.




Yet another object of the present invention is to provide an apparatus for mixing two or more reactants which prevents the formation of short-circuiting flow paths therethrough.




Still another object of the present invention is to provide an apparatus for mixing two or more reactants which prevents the formation of dead flow pockets therein.




Briefly stated, the foregoing and numerous other features, objects and advantages of the present invention will become readily apparent upon a review of the detailed description, claims and drawings set forth herein. These features, objects and advantages are accomplished by forming a mixing apparatus that includes a generally planar reaction zone inside the main reaction vessel such that the reaction mixture contained in the main reaction vessel never backflows into the planar reaction zone. The invention accomplishes efficient mixing inside the reaction zone, as well as efficient mixing of the reaction products produced in the reaction zone with the reaction mixture in the main reaction vessel. Within the planar reaction zone, the two reactants are mixed and reacted. The reaction products exit the reaction zone directly into the reaction mixture contained in the main reaction vessel. There is no connecting or intermediate flow path. In other words, there is a direct interface between the reaction zone and the reaction mixture contained in the main reaction vessel. In the production of photographic emulsions, silver nitrate and alkali halide solutions are mixed and reacted such that they are converted into the fine silver halide grains by the time they leave the generally planar reaction zone and mix with the reaction mixture. The generally planar reaction zone includes a rotating disc which defines one surface or boundary of the generally planar reaction zone. The two reactants are directed in separate and concentric annular flow paths at the substantially planar surface of a rotating disc. In the production of photographic emulsions, silver nitrate and alkali halide solutions are directed in separate and concentric annular flow paths at the planar surface of a rotating disc. The rotating disc aids in the mixing of the silver nitrate and alkali halide solutions. Further, the rotating disc may act, at least partially, as a pump impeller accelerating the reacting silver nitrate and alkali halide solutions toward the perimeter of the rotating disc in a generally radial or spiral flow path through the generally planar reaction zone. The rotating disc should provide enough pumping to at least overcome head losses resulting from the flow of the liquid through the reaction zone. This, in combination with the flow rates and pressures of the two reactants, and the generally planar reaction zone, ensures that there is no back flow of the silver nitrate and alkali halide solutions in the generally planar reaction zone. In other words, the rotating disc, the flow rates and pressures of the two reactants, and the geometry of the reaction zone obviate the formation of stagnant pockets in the planar reaction zone. As the reacted silver nitrate and alkali halide solutions exit the reaction zone, they immediately mix with the reaction mixture in the main reaction vessel. Through the control of the pressure and flow rates of the silver nitrate and alkali halide solutions into and through the reaction zone, and disc rotation, backward mixing of the reaction mixture from the main reaction vessel into the planar reaction zone is prevented. The residence time of the fluid in the reaction chamber is so small that the fine grains that are generated are ejected into the main reaction vessel very quickly after the formation thereof. Thus the present invention avoids exposure of emulsion grains in the main reaction vessel to high concentrations of silver nitrate without introducing complexities of the prior art where two stirrers have to be placed in close proximity. In general, the planar reaction zone is advantageous because it produces a more uniform distribution of fine grains, which can be used to produce a narrower distribution of silver halide emulsion grains. The uniformity of flow field also improves the scalability of the precipitation process. Thus, the present invention solves the problems encountered with the prior art processes and apparatus and enables manufacturing of high sensitivity photographic emulsions with tightly controlled sensitivities.




The present invention is being described herein with specific relationship to the mixing into the main reaction vessel of reacted silver nitrate and alkali halide solutions to form radiation-sensitive emulsions, specifically, silver halide emulsion grains. However, those skilled in the art will recognize that this invention may be applicable to any precipitation process that produces particles of sparingly soluble materials. For example, the apparatus of the present invention may be used for gold or silver chalcogenides.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a schematic of the reactor and mixing apparatus of the present invention.





FIG. 2

is a cross-sectional view of an exemplary reactor manifold and disc of the reactor and mixing apparatus of the present invention.





FIG. 3

is an enlarged cross-sectional view of disc and the lower portion of reactor manifold of FIG.


2


.





FIG. 4

is a schematic diagram illustrating critical parameters for residence time calculation in the reaction zone.





FIG. 5

is a Scanning Electron Microscope image of a silver halide emulsion made with the preferred embodiment of the present invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION




Turning first to

FIG. 1

, the mixing apparatus


10


of the present invention is schematically illustrated. Such mixing apparatus


10


is particularly suited for making silver halide grains. The apparatus


10


includes the reaction vessel


12


. Extending down into the reaction vessel


12


is a reactor support


14


. Supported from reactor support


14


are reactor manifold


15


and reactor


16


. Rotatably residing within reactor support


14


is shaft


18


, rotation of which is driven by motor


20


. A separate mechanical mixing device is used to stirrer contents of the reaction vessel


12


. A shaft


22


of the mechanical mixing device has an agitating blade


24


attached to an end thereof, such that the agitating blade


24


resides below the liquid level


26


in reaction vessel


12


. The mixing apparatus


10


of the present invention, when used for producing silver halide emulsions, has at least water and a dispersion medium contained in the main reaction vessel


12


. The dispersion medium may include pre-made silver halide grains. A pair of conduits


28


,


30


provide for separate flow of the two reactants to the reactor manifold


15


and a reactor


16


. In the production of silver halide grains, an aqueous silver salt solution and an aqueous halide salt solution (either or both solutions may contain a peptizer) are delivered to the reactor manifold


15


through conduits


28


,


30


. The silver nitrate or alkali halide solutions may contain dissolved gelatin for specific photographic emulsions when necessary.




Looking next at

FIG. 2

, there is depicted a cross-sectional view of an exemplary reactor manifold


15


and reactor


16


. Rector manifold


15


includes a cylindrical opening


32


therein. Residing within cylindrical opening


32


is journal box


34


which houses journal bearings


36


. Conduits


28


,


30


connect to reactor manifold


15


at couplings


38


,


40


, respectively. There is a bore


42


through reactor manifold


15


providing a flow path between coupling


38


and annular channel


44


. There is a bore


46


through reactor manifold


15


which extends from coupling


40


to align with bore


48


. Bore


48


extends generally radially through journal box


34


such that a flow path from coupling


40


is provided through bore


46


and bore


48


to annular channel


50


. Extending down from journal box


34


and formed integrally therewith is lower shaft housing


52


which is cylindrical. The inside surface of annular channel


50


is defined by the outside surface of shaft


18


. The inside surface of annular channel


44


is defined by the outside cylindrical surface of lower shaft housing


52


. A first annular flow path


54


extends from annular channel


50


down to the reactor


16


. A second annular flow path


56


extends from annular channel


44


down to the reactor


16


. First annular flow path


54


is defined by the outside surface of shaft


18


and the interior surface of lower shaft housing


52


. Second annular flow path


56


is defined by the outside surface of lower shaft housing


52


in the inside surface of lower portion of a reactor manifold


15


. There is a disc


60


connected to shaft


18


by means of machine bolt


62


such that disc


60


rotates with the rotation of shaft


18


. A spacer


58


may reside between disc


60


and the lower end of shaft


18


.




Looking next at

FIG. 3

, there is shown a detailed cross-sectional view of disc


60


and the lower portion of reactor manifold


15


. The reactant traveling down annular flow path


54


intercepts the top surface of disc


60


to thereby form a generally radial 360° flow in the gap


63


formed between the top surface of disc


60


and the bottom surface


64


of lower shaft housing


52


. The top surface of disc


60


is “substantially planar.” Although not preferred, the top surface of disc


60


may have a pattern of fine grooves therein to aid in the mixing and/or pumping functions of rotating disc


60


. The groove(s) may be, for example, arranged as a single spiral line, as a pattern of a plurality of equally spaced, radially directed straight lines, or as a pattern of a plurality of equally spaced, arcuate segments. In addition, the top surface of disc


60


may be textured such that it has a rough surface in order to create turbulence and enhance mixing. The term “substantially planar” as used herein with regard to the top surface of disc


60


is intended to include smooth or non-grooved surfaces, textured or rough surfaces, and finely grooved surfaces. The reactant traveling down annular flow path


56


also intercepts the top surface of disc


60


to thereby form a generally radial 360° flow in the gap


65


formed between the top surface of disc


60


and the bottom surface


66


of reactor manifold


15


. The reaction zone may be generally defined as gap


65


noting, however, that the reaction zone begins at that 360° interface where annular channel


56


and gap


63


converge such that the two reactants begin mixing with one another. Thus, geometrically, the reaction zone may be more accurately described as an annular volume. Use of a spacer


58


will aid in setting the thickness of that annular volume, that is, the thickness of gap


65


. The reaction zone is characterized herein as “generally planar” to indicate that gap


65


is very narrow and that the top surface of disc


60


and the bottom surface


66


of reactor manifold


15


are parallel to one another. Also, the flow through the reaction zone is characterized as a “plug flow” and hence, the distribution of residence times for fluid elements is expected to be very narrow. It should be understood that due to the rotation of disc


60


, the generally radial 360° flow of the two reactants begins to take a spiral path as opposed to truly radial. Thus, the term “generally radial” as used herein is intended to include both radial and spiraled or arcuate flow paths.




Disc


60


is depicted as having substantially the same outside diameter as the lower portion of reactor manifold


15


. It should be understood that the diameter of disc


60


can be greater than the outside diameter of lower portion of reactor


15


. However, the reaction zone would still end at the outside diameter of lower portion of reactor


15


. Similarly, the reactor manifold


15


could be configured such that the lower portion thereof a larger diameter than disc


60


. In such case, the reaction zone would end at the diameter of lower portion of reactor manifold


15


. The outer edge of the reaction zone is that area where the reaction products begin to intermix with the contents of the main reactor vessel


12


. Although not a preferred embodiment, when disc


60


has a larger diameter than the diameter of lower portion of reactor manifold


15


, agitator blades can be attached to disc


60


such that through rotation of disc


60


the agitator blades attached thereto simultaneously mix the contents of the main reactor vessel


12


.




The gap


65


between the bottom surface


66


and the top surface of disc


60


is kept to a dimension such that flow in the reaction zone has no recirculation zones when the disc


60


is rotated at a speed which for any particular device and reaction may be determined empirically. Similarly, the dimensions of the annular flow paths


54


,


56


are chosen such that the backflow of material into the annular flow paths


54


,


56


is prevented. The gap


63


between the bottom surface


64


of lower shaft housing


52


and the top surface of disc


60


is also of a dimension such that there are no recirculation zones therein and backflow from the reaction zone into gap


63


is prevented. The rotating disc


60


preferably extends beyond the reaction zone radially so that the effluent of the reaction zone mixes efficiently with the dispersion medium contained in the reaction vessel


12


.




Although both annular flow paths


54


,


56


are depicted as being substantially at right angles to the top surface of disc


60


, it should be understood that the both annular flow paths


54


,


56


, and most particularly the outer annular flow path


56


, may flare outwardly shortly before intercepting gaps


63


,


65


. This would be accomplished by providing the outer surface of lower shaft housing


52


proximate bottom surface


64


with a cone shape. The interior surface of reactor manifold


15


would also have a cone shape proximate to the bottom surface


66


thereof. A similar modification can also be made between the interior surface of lower shaft housing


52


proximate bottom surface


64


and the adjacent exterior surface of


18


. Such a flared flow path between conar surfaces may be described as conar annulus. In this manner, one or both of the annular flow paths


54


,


56


may be formed such that liquid exiting therefrom impinges on disc


60


at an angle from vertical (e.g. 30° ). Flow would still be radially outward across the top surface of disc


60


and further, the liquid exiting such flared flow paths would already include a horizontal velocity component directed radially outward even before the liquid entered the gaps


63


,


65


.




An important parameter in the operation of the present invention is the residence time, that being the time during which the silver and salt streams come into contact in the reaction zone before exiting into the reaction medium contained in the main reaction vessel


12


. Assuming a plug flow velocity profile, the residence time, τ, of the reacting fluid in the reaction zone is calculated via the mass balance equations below and stated with reference to

FIG. 4

, which is a schematic diagram of the reaction zone described with reference to FIG.


3


:






τ
=



2





π

q










r
1


r
2




h





r



r














or






τ
=



h





π

q



[


r
2
2

-

r
1
2


]












where π is about 3.1412, q is the total combined flow rate of silver (q


0


) and halide (q


1


) salt containing streams flowing from annular flow paths


54


,


56


, that is, q=q


0


+q


1


, h is the dimension of gap


65


, r


1


, is the radial distance from the centerline of shaft


18


to the outer surface of the lower portion of reactor manifold


15


, and r


2


is the radial distance from the centerline of shaft


18


to the outer edge of the reaction zone as defined herein. In addition to the definition provided above and as used herein to describe the reaction zone, the term “generally planar” may also be defined by the equations above. That is, if for the geometry of the device (r


1


, r


2


, and h) and the combined flow rate q, the equations above may be solved for the residence time τ such that τ≦100 msec, then that reaction zone is “generally planar”.




EXAMPLE




To a stirred vessel at 68° C., containing 82 liters of distilled water, 43 g of sodium chloride, and 4500 g of bone gelatin, was added 0.729 moles of a fine grained AgCl emulsion where the mean cubic edge length of the fine grains was about 0.14 μm. The vessel was stirred by a slanted marine propeller. A reactor as described with reference to

FIG. 3

, was employed to provide a reaction zone and intermix the reactants and subsequently deliver the reactants to the main stirred vessel shown in FIG.


1


. The disk


60


was rotated at a rate of 5000 rpm. Next, a sodium chloride solution was added to the vessel to adjust its pCl to 1.05. Then 17 g of 1,8-dihydroxy-3,6-dithiaoctane was added approximately 10 seconds before commencing the introduction of growth salt solutions. The growth salt solutions, 3.7 M silver nitrate and 3.8 M sodium chloride, were added to the reaction vessel through the reactor as six controlled double-jet pulses while maintaining pCl of the reaction mixture at 1.05. The sodium chloride solution also contained 2.6 wt % bone gelatin. The pulsed addition rate for silver nitrate solution was about 2 liters/min and the pulses were separated by hold periods. The residence time, τ, in the reaction zone was 0.7 msec. During each hold period, the feed conduits were flushed with distilled water for 5 seconds. The six pulse-hold sequence had the following durations respectively: 0.75 min., 5 min., 0.75 min., 3 min., 3 min., 3 min., 3 min., 3 min., 3 min., 2 min., 1.5 min., 2 min. The resultant emulsion had a cubic edge length of 0.61 μm. A representative Scanning Electron Micrograph of the emulsion grains is shown in FIG.


5


. For the apparatus used for this example, the height of gap


65


was 0.15 mm, the diameter of disc


60


was 60 mm and r


1


=10 mm and r


2


=28.5 mm.




From the foregoing, it will be seen that this invention is one well adapted to obtain all of the ends and objects hereinabove set forth together with other advantages which are apparent and which are inherent to the apparatus.




It will be understood that certain features and subcombinations are of utility and may be employed with reference to other features and subcombinations. This is contemplated by and is within the scope of the claims.




As many possible embodiments may be made of the invention without departing from the scope thereof, it is to be understood that all matter herein set forth and shown in the accompanying drawings is to be interpreted as illustrative and not in an illuminating sense.




PARTS LIST






10


mixing apparatus






12


reaction vessel






14


reactor support






15


reactor manifold






16


reactor






18


shaft






20


motor






22


shaft






24


agitating blade






26


liquid level






28


conduits






30


conduits






32


cylindrical opening






34


journal box






36


journal bearing






38


coupling






40


coupling






42


bore






44


annular channel






46


bore






48


bore






50


annular channel






52


lower shaft housing






54


first annular flow path






56


second annular flow path






58


spacer






60


disc






62


machine bolt






63


gap






64


bottom surface






65


gap






66


bottom surface



Claims
  • 1. A process for mixing at least two reactants comprising:(a) delivering a first reactant to a reaction zone through a first annular flow path, the reaction zone having an annular volume; (b) delivering a second reactant to the reaction zone through a second annular flow path, the first annular flow path being inside of and concentric to the second annular flow path, the first and second reactants intermixing in the reaction zone; and (c) rotating a substantially planar surface positioned to define one boundary of the reaction zone, the flow of the first and second reactants through the reaction zone being generally radial and having a residence time in the reaction zone of not more than about 100 msec, the first and second reactants exiting the reaction zone directly into a main reaction vessel.
  • 2. A process as recited in claim 1 further comprising the steps of:(a) introducing to the main reactor vessel a reaction mixture containing at least a dispersion medium and water, the reaction zone residing in the main reaction vessel; and (b) mixing the intermixed first and second reactants exiting the reaction zone directly with the reaction mixture.
  • 3. A process as recited in claim 2 herein:the mixing step is performed with an agitator blade residing in the main reaction vessel.
  • 4. A process as recited in claim 1 wherein:the annular volume of the reaction zone defined at a top and a bottom thereof by a gap between the rotating substantially planar surface and a stationary surface.
  • 5. A process as recited in claim 4 further comprising the step of:deflecting flow of the first reactant from the first annular flow path to create a first 360° generally radially outward flowpath.
  • 6. A process as recited in claim 5 further comprising the step of:deflecting flow of the second reactant from the second annular flow path to create a second 360° generally radially outward flowpath, the first 360° generally radially outward flowpath being substantially coplanar with the second 360° generally radially outward flowpath.
  • 7. A process as recited in claim 6 wherein:the annular volume of the reaction zone is further defined by a circle of intersection of the first 360° generally radially outward flowpath with the second annular flow path.
  • 8. A process as recited in claim 6 wherein:the substantially planar surface is part of a disc that is rotated at a speed sufficient to at least overcome head losses to the flow of the first and second reactants through the reaction zone.
  • 9. A process as recited in claim 6 wherein:the first and second reactants are a silver salt solution and a halide salt solution.
  • 10. A process as recited in claim 9 wherein:one or both of the silver salt solution and the halide salt solution contains a peptizer.
  • 11. A process as recited in claim 9 wherein:the residence time in the reaction zone of not more than about 50 msec.
  • 12. A process for manufacturing radiation-sensitive emulsions comprised of:(a) delivering a silver salt solution to a reaction zone that is annular in shape through a first annular flow path; (b) delivering a halide salt solution to a reaction zone through a second annular flow path, the first annular flow path being concentric to the second annular flow path, the first and second reactants intermixing in the reaction zone, the silver salt solution and the halide salt solution intermixing in the reaction zone, the reaction zone residing in a main reaction vessel containing a reaction mixture including at least a dispersion medium and water; (c) flowing the silver salt solution and the halide salt solution exiting the first and second annular flow against a substantially planar surface positioned to define one boundary of the reaction zone; and (d) rotating the substantially planar surface, the flow of the silver salt solution and the halide salt solution through the reaction zone being generally radial and having a residence time in the reaction zone of not more than about 100 msec, the intermixed silver salt solution and halide salt solutions forming a reaction solution, the reaction solution exiting the reaction zone directly into the reaction mixture while avoiding backflow of the reaction mixture into the reaction zone.
  • 13. A process as recited in claim 12 wherein:the residence time is less than 50 msec.
  • 14. A process as recited in claim 12 wherein:the silver salt solution contains a peptizer.
  • 15. A process as recited in claim 12 wherein:the halide salt solution contains a peptizer.
  • 16. A process as recited in claim 12 wherein:both the silver salt solution and the halide salt solution contain a peptizer.
  • 17. A process as recited in claim 12 wherein:the dispersion medium contains pre-made silver halide grains.
US Referenced Citations (47)
Number Name Date Kind
2641453 Teale Jun 1953 A
3318580 Simonetti May 1967 A
3415650 Frame et al. Dec 1968 A
3628959 Theilemann Dec 1971 A
3692283 Sauer et al. Sep 1972 A
3744763 Schnoring et al. Jul 1973 A
3801326 Claes Apr 1974 A
4046586 Uhlmann et al. Sep 1977 A
4147551 Finnicum et al. Apr 1979 A
4171224 Verhille et al. Oct 1979 A
4289733 Saito et al. Sep 1981 A
4309501 Huguenard et al. Jan 1982 A
4334012 Mignot Jun 1982 A
4335199 Michewich et al. Jun 1982 A
4386156 Mignot May 1983 A
4399215 Wey Aug 1983 A
4539290 Mumaw Sep 1985 A
4666669 Mumaw May 1987 A
4999131 Shimizu et al. Mar 1991 A
5018871 Brazelton et al. May 1991 A
5035991 Ichikawa et al. Jul 1991 A
5035992 Houle et al. Jul 1991 A
5096690 Saito Mar 1992 A
5104785 Ichikawa et al. Apr 1992 A
5145768 Ichikawa et al. Sep 1992 A
5169750 Vacca Dec 1992 A
5202226 Saitou Apr 1993 A
5213772 Ichikawa et al. May 1993 A
5219720 Black et al. Jun 1993 A
5223388 Saitou Jun 1993 A
5238805 Saitou Aug 1993 A
5334359 Masutomi et al. Aug 1994 A
5378598 Bagchi et al. Jan 1995 A
5437971 Loiacono et al. Aug 1995 A
5478718 Verbeeck et al. Dec 1995 A
5484697 Mignot et al. Jan 1996 A
5503972 Lewis et al. Apr 1996 A
5541051 Verbeeck et al. Jul 1996 A
5549879 Chow Aug 1996 A
5690428 Bryan et al. Nov 1997 A
5709990 Jezequel et al. Jan 1998 A
5723279 Jezequel Mar 1998 A
5813758 Delcourt et al. Sep 1998 A
6048683 Mehta et al. Apr 2000 A
6150080 Ando Nov 2000 A
6265145 Mehta et al. Jul 2001 B1
6319659 Taima Nov 2001 B1
Foreign Referenced Citations (3)
Number Date Country
0 137 398 May 1990 EP
0 532 842 Jan 1991 EP
WO 9221061 Nov 1992 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (1)
Entry
O. Levenspiel, “Chemical Reaction Engineering,” 2nd Edition, Chapter 9, pp. 257-260.