The process and the device for diagnosing the quality of compression of an ultrashort pulse, consist in performing an approximation of the Strehl ratio without going through a step for determining the phase of the pulse characterized by: —the first step allowing a decomposition (S) of the aforementioned ultrashort light pulse (I) into two pulses, respectively known as the initial pulse (Ii) and the secondary initial pulse (Iis), of different polarization or propagation direction and whose phase characteristics are essentially identical to said ultrashort light pulse (I), —a second step allowing the measurement of the spatio-spectral image or images (ISS1) of the initial ultrashort light pulse (Ii) using one or more imaging spectrometers in a parallel manner; —a third step allowing interaction of the aforementioned pulse with a nonlinear optical material (DMNL), the aforementioned interaction generating, by a nonlinear optical mechanism of an n order, a secondary pulse (Is) having an intensity proportional to the temporal intensity of the aforementioned ultrashort light pulse (Iis) raised to the power n; —a fourth step allowing the measurement of the spatio-spectral image or images (ISS2) of the second pulse (Is), using one or more imaging spectrometers in a parallel manner; —a fifth step allowing the calculation of the spatio-spectral intensity (ISS3) which would be obtained from the simulation of the nonlinear effect using the spatio-spectral intensity (ISS1) with a phase plate; —a sixth step allows the calculation of the spatio-spectral intensity (ISS4) which would be obtained from the simulation of the nonlinear effect using the spatio-spectral intensity (ISS1) with a very large quadratic phase, stretching the pulse temporally and spatially by at least a factor of 3 relative to the undistorted pulse; a seventh step allowing the estimation of the distortions of the pulse done through comparing the different spectra obtained and translated into the Strehl ratio R, of the pulse using a standard formula:
RI=f(ISS1, ISS2,ISS3,ISS4), where f is a function which provides an estimate of the Strehl ratio from the spatial-spectral intensities provided, for example:
where the ratio Z is the ratio of the width of the spectrum obtained by space-spectral intensity integration (ISS2) according to the spatial dimension over the width of the spectrum obtained by space-spectral intensity integration (ISS1) according to the spatial dimension, the ratio Z0 is the ratio of the width of the spectrum obtained by integration of the spatio-spectral intensity (ISS3) according to the spatial dimension over the width of the spectrum obtained by integration of the spatio-spectral intensity (ISS1) according to the spatial dimension and the ratio Z∞ is the ratio of the width of the spectrum obtained by space-intensity spectral integration (ISS4) according to the spatial dimension over the width of the spectrum obtained by space-intensity-spectral integration (ISS1) according to the spatial dimension, the widths considered here, for instance, are the standard deviations.
The present invention concerns a process and a device for measuring the spatial and temporal compression quality of ultrashort light pulses.
It mainly concerns the relative intensity measurements at the focus, that is, the intensity variations due to the spectral, spatial, and spectro-spatial phase distortions of these pulses. It deals with the effects of the spectral, spatial, and spatio-spectral components of the phase, that is, the variations in intensity due to these effects.
It is generally known that the characterization of the compression quality of ultrashort light pulses having a duration between a few femtoseconds and a few picoseconds presents many difficulties. It can be estimated using the Strehl ratio, which is defined as the ratio of the maximum illuminations with and without phase distortions. Therefore, this ratio is between 0 and 1.
Several state-of-the-art measurement methods are described in the following document: Dorrer, C., IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quantum Electron. (2019) [nplcit1].
When an ultrashort pulse is available, measuring its spatial and temporal compression quality requires different measurements according to the spatial, temporal, and spatio-temporal dimensions. These measurements may require several successive recordings. Temporal measurement, in particular, includes several so-called self-referenced methods. It is compulsory for these methods to use at least one optical element having a nonlinear response. This is notably recalled in the following document: Ian A. Walmsley and Victor Wong, “Characterization of the electric field of ultrashort optical pulses,” J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 13, 2453-2463 (1996) [nplcit2].
Among the self-referenced methods, we can cite the FROG method (Frequency Resolved Optical Gating) and the SPIDER method (Spectral Phase Interferometry for Direct Electric-field Reconstruction). These two methods are described respectively in the following documents: R. Trebino and D. J. Kane: “Using phase retrieval to measure the intensity and phase of ultrashort pulses: Frequency Resolved Optical Gating”, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A11, p. 2429-2437, 1993, regarding the FROG method [nplcit3], C. Iaconis and I. A. Walmsley: “Spectral Phase Interferometry for Direct Electric-field Reconstruction of ultrashort optical pulses”, Opt. Lett, 23, p. 729-794, 1998, regarding the SPIDER method [nplci4].
In all cases, multiple copies of the initial pulse, modified or unmodified in the spectral domain, are mixed nonlinearly in order to obtain the useful signal. The methods differ according to whether they require a single measurement (one-shot measurement) or multiple measurements corresponding to successive light pulses. In the previous case, these successive pulses must be essentially identical. The methods also differ as to whether the phase can be derived from the measurement using a direct algorithm, or whether they use an otherwise fitting procedure aiming at minimizing the difference between the calculation of the expected measurement for a test spectral phase and the phase measurement itself. For example, the FROG method uses a successive adjustment technique, while the SPIDER method uses a direct algorithm. The direct algorithm is generally preferred given possible uncertainties about the convergence of successive fits.
In addition, the methods differ in their ability to perform spatial, and particularly spatio-temporal measurements, as discussed above. The FROG method does not allow this unambiguous combined measurement between the temporal and the spatial. A spatio-temporal measurement, derived from a single-shot SPIDER method, was achieved at the cost of much greater complexity in the optical setup and to the detriment of instrument sensitivity. It is described in the following document: C. Dorrer, E. M. Kosik, I. A. Walmsley: “Spatio-temporal characterization of the electric field of ultrashort optical pulses using two-dimensional shearing interferometry”, App. Phys. B, 74, p. 209-217, 2002 [nplcit5].
In particular, the purpose of the invention is to eliminate the disadvantages of the aforementioned methods by exploiting the fundamental advantages of the proposed method, which are, among others, simplicity, sensitivity, single-shot measurement, obtaining an approximation of the Strehl ratio through direct algorithm, and the possibility of space-time-combined measurements of the entire ultrashort pulse. The principle consists of comparing the spatio-spectral images of the initial pulse with those obtained by an interaction of the pulse to be measured with a nonlinear environment.
Relative intensity measurements at focus, that is, intensity variations due to spectral, spatial, and spectro-spatial phase distortions of these pulses, are difficult to perform and are essential for determining the maximum power of the laser, which is the critical parameter for very high-power systems. The intensity is affected by the effects of the spectral, spatial, and spatio-spectral components of the phase, that is, the intensity variations due to these effects. The low repetition rate of very high-power lasers essentially requires single-shot measurements, that is, no parameter needs to be sampled between successive measurements.
It is generally known that the characterization of the compression quality of ultrashort light pulses having a duration between a few femtoseconds and a few picoseconds presents many difficulties. It can be estimated using the Strehl ratio, which is defined as the ratio of the maximum illuminations with and without phase distortions. Therefore, this ratio is between 0 and 1. A device for measuring or estimating this ratio would make it possible to directly obtain an estimate of the peak power.
In particular, the purpose of the invention is to eliminate the disadvantages of the aforementioned methods by exploiting the fundamental advantages of the proposed method, which are, among others, simplicity, sensitivity, single-shot measurement, obtaining an approximation of the Strehl ratio through direct algorithm, and the possibility of space-time-combined measurements of the entire ultrashort pulse. The principle consists of comparing the spatio-spectral images of the initial pulse with those obtained by an interaction of the pulse to be measured with a nonlinear environment.
Thus, the method according to the invention may include the following steps:
where the Z-ratio is the ratio of the width of the spectrum obtained by the spatial-spectral intensity integration (ISS2) according to the spatial dimension over the width of the spectrum obtained by the integration of the space-spectral intensity (ISS1) according to the spatial dimension, the ratio Z0 is the ratio of the width of the spectrum obtained by the integration of the space-spectral intensity (ISS3) according to the spatial dimension over the width of the spectrum obtained by the integration of the spatio-spectral intensity (ISS1) according to the spatial dimension and the ratio Z∞ is the ratio of the width of the spectrum obtained by the integration of the spatio-spectral intensity spectral (ISS4) according to the spatial dimension over the width of the spectrum obtained by the integration of the spatio-spectral intensity (ISS1) according to the spatial dimension, the widths considered here are, for instance, the standard deviations.
Eventually, this method can also include several parallel measurements of the ultrashort light pulse according to different spatio-spectral dimensions, which finally allows the characterization of the compression of this pulse according to all its dimensions thanks to the combined results of these measurements.
This principle will be better understood in the following description of an embodiment of the invention.
Previously, the reasons why such a method would differ from existing methods will be discussed.
No existing method in the literature can measure the entire compression quality of an ultrashort pulse in a single pulse. Several Spatio-temporal characterization methods have been patented and proposed in literature recently:
However, no current method allows diagnosing the compression quality in a single laser shot. Most devices and methods offer complex measurements. In fact, in order to measure the ultrashort pulse, it is necessary to estimate both the amplitude and the phase according to the transverse and temporal-spatial dimensions. Several devices can be used in parallel to characterize on one hand the temporal or spectral dimension and according to the transverse spatial dimensions on the other. But then, the spatio-temporal variations of the pulse are still to be estimated. The techniques described as state-of-the-art in DORRER19 are either complex and difficult to implement, or they require several successive measurements. They all have in common the desire to perform measurements to reconstruct the intensity profile of the ultrashort pulse according to the transverse spatial dimensions to the focal and temporal.
The originality of the invention is to directly estimate the Strehl ratio without trying to reconstruct the intensity profile of the pulse and by including Spatio-temporal distortions in a measurement that can be done in a single acquisition from a single pulse.
A mode of implementation of the method according to the invention will be described below, by way of a non-limiting example, referencing to the appended drawings in which:
a.
b.
c. 3a, 3b represent the spatio-spectral images of the initial pulse and the second pulse in the case of a pulse without distortion called Fourier transform-limited, and for that of a pulse with space-time distortion;
d.
e.
f.
g.
In the example shown in
In the schematic representation of
The spatio-spectral intensity characteristics of the secondary pulse at the output of the DMNL device are examined below based on the phase distortions present in the initial pulse. If one initially assumes that the phase of the pulse to be measured is constant, the nonlinear interaction, having a third order for example, leads to the superimposition of spectral contributions from frequency triplets. If all the frequencies of the spectrum have the same delay and contribute equally, it has been shown in the aforementioned publication, that in the case of a Gaussian spectrum, the resulting spectral band is equal to the incident spectral band multiplied by the square root of 3. In general, for sufficiently small phase variations, the spectral band will be increased. Indeed, the output frequency corresponds to contributions from multiple triplets of frequencies having close delays. In this case, an averaging effect reduces the phase variations concerning the incident phase variations. This effect is proven in theoretical calculations performed in Thomas Oksenhendler's publication “Self-Referenced Spectral Interferometry Theory”, Arxiv:1204.4949 (2012). This paper also presents the results of spectral band expansion for all initial pulse spectral shapes and as a function of the different spectral phase contributions.
Different DMNL and SPEC devices can be produced and combined, particularly according to the spatial dimensions focused on the DMNL device and integrated into the SPEC device. In the example of [
for SPEC3:Signal=A I0(x,∫y,λ), a.
and for SPEC4:Signal=B INL(x,∫y,λ), b.
where x is the transverse spatial dimension to the beam and in the diagram plan, y is the transverse spatial dimension perpendicular, X the optical wavelength, A and B are constants, and I0 represents the spatio-temporal intensity of the initial pulse at the level of the DMNL device, INL that of the intensity of the secondary pulse obtained by the nonlinear effect of the DMNL device. In the geometry considered in [
In the example of [
for SPEC5:Signal=A I0(∫x,y,λ), a.
and for SPEC6:Signal=B INL(∫x,∫y,λ), b.
In the example of [
for SPEC7:Signal=A I0(∫x,∫y,λ), a.
and for SPEC8:Signal=B INL(∫x,∫y,λ), b.
In the example of
In the example of
Curves 31 and 32 represent the values of the central positions, in the sense of the barycenters. On a beam with no spatio-spectral coupling, these curves are straight and perpendicular (one is horizontal, and the other is vertical). The effect is considered to be a pure phase effect, it is not visible on image 30 and curves 31 and 32. After the nonlinear effect, the image obtained (40) on the SPEC4 device no longer shows enlargement in both dimensions. The curves of the central positions and pulsations 41 and 42 are respectively straight and perpendicular (one is horizontal, and the other is vertical). From the enlargements obtained weighted by the windowing linked to the value of the initial signal concerning the measurement noise, we will estimate the Strehl ratio of the pulse. Broadening is defined as the ratio between the width considered (along x,y or ω) obtained for the pulse having undergone the nonlinear effect on the width considered (along x,y or ω) obtained on the initial pulse. For the device of
where Zxx(ω) is the spatial enlargement calculated by taking the ratio of the widths of the profiles obtained for each pulse u for images 40 and 30, Zx0(ω) is the spatial enlargement according to x obtained for the pulse ω for the pulse without phase distortion and where Zx∞(ω) is the spatial widening along x obtained for the pulse ω for the pulse with infinite quadratic phase distortion along x (highly divergent beam). We find that this ratio is equal to 1 if the pulse is perfectly focused, and decreases to zero if it is infinitely spatially stretched.
According to the dimension ω, this Strehl ratio is expressed by a formula of the type:
where Zωω2(x) is the square of the spectral broadening calculated by taking the ratio of the widths of the spectra obtained for each position x for images 40 and 30, Zω02(x) is the square of the broadening spectral according to ω obtained for position x for the pulse without phase distortion and where Zω∞2(x) is the square of the spectral broadening according to ω obtained for position x for the pulse with an infinite quadratic phase distortion according to ω (highly divergent beam). We find that this ratio is equal to 1 if the pulse is perfectly compressed, and decreases to zero if it is infinitely in temporarily stretching. The study of these two curves makes it possible to determine whether the pulse is qualitatively distorted according to the dimensions x and ω.
By integrating the image obtained along one dimension (x or ω), we obtain the integrated ratio along one dimension. For an integration according to x of the intensity of images 30 and 40, we obtain the ratio according to ω:
where Zω2 is the square of the broadening calculated by taking the ratio of the widths of the profiles obtained for images 40 and 30, Z0ω2 is the square of the spectral broadening according to ω obtained for the pulse without phase distortion and where Z∞ω2 is the square of the spectral broadening according to ω obtained for the pulse with an infinite quadratic phase distortion according to ω (highly stretched pulse). We find that this ratio is equal to 1 if the pulse is perfectly compressed, and decreases to zero if it is infinitely temporarily stretched. And for integration according to ω of the intensity of images 30 and 40, we obtain the ratio according to x:
where Zx2, where is the square of the widening calculated by taking the ratio of the widths of the profiles obtained for images 40 and 30 by integrating according to ω, Z0x2 is the square of the spatial broadening along x obtained for the pulse without phase distortion and where Z∞x2 is the square of the spatial broadening along x obtained for the pulse with infinite quadratic phase distortion along x (highly divergent beam). We find that this ratio is equal to 1 if the pulse is perfectly focused, and decreases to zero if it is infinitely spatially stretched.
These two ratios correspond to the Strehl ratios of the pulse, taking into account only the phase distortions affecting this dimension. For example, a quadratic phase purely along x will only affect RIx. Respectively, a phase-only according to ω will only affect RIω. On the other hand, a phase of spatio-temporal type affecting both according to x and ω will affect both ratios. The global Strehl ratio of the pulse for the dimensions x and ω is obtained as the product of the different previous ratios:
R
I
=R
Ix
R
Iω.
In the example of
where Zω2 is the square of the broadening calculated by taking the ratio of the widths of the profiles obtained for images 50 and 30 by integrating along x, Z0ω2 is the square of the spectral broadening along w obtained for the pulse without phase distortion and where Z∞ω2 is the square of the spectral broadening according to ω obtained for the pulse with infinite quadratic phase distortion according to ω. We find that this ratio is equal to 1 if the pulse is perfectly compressed, and decreases to zero if it is infinitely temporarily stretched. And for integration according to ω of the intensity of images 30 and 50, we obtain the ratio according to x:
where Zx2 is the square of the widening calculated by taking the ratio of the widths of the profiles obtained for images 50 and 30 by integrating according to ω, Z0x2 is the square of the spatial enlargement according to x obtained for the pulse without phase distortion and where Z∞x2 is the square of the spatial enlargement according to x obtained for the pulse with an infinite quadratic phase distortion according to x (highly divergent beam). We find that this ratio is equal to 1 if the pulse is perfectly focused, and decreases to zero if it is infinitely spatially stretched.
In the case of the wave front inclination along only x and ω, the two ratios RIω and RIx are reduced by the distortion, and we find the effect on the ratio of Strehl global of the pulse for the dimensions x and ω by the product of the various previous ratios: RI=RIxRIω.
The effect of an inclination of the pulse front according to the dimensions y and ω alone is not quite visible by the assembly of
In the example of
where Z2 is the square of the spectral broadening calculated by taking the ratio of the widths of the obtained spectra 71 and 70, Z02 is the square of the spectral broadening obtained for the pulse without phase distortion from spectrum 70 and where Z∞2 is the square of the spectral broadening obtained for the pulse with infinite quadratic phase distortion from spectrum 70. We find that this ratio is equal to 1 if the pulse is perfectly focused and compressed, and decreases to zero if it is infinitely stretched. As a reminder for Gaussian profiles,
The resulting ratio RI is a good measure of Strehl's ratio and is always greater than or equal to the actual ratio. It, therefore, constitutes an excellent quantitative diagnosis for the quality of pulsed lasers, but without being able to distinguish the origin of these distortions or to determine the temporal intensity profile or the spectral phase.
In the example of
Simultaneously, on the same pulse, the SPEC10 spectrometer measures the integrated spectral intensity over the x and y transverse spatial dimensions of the secondary pulse: Signal=A10 INL (∫x, ∫y, λ), where ∫λ represents the fact that the transverse spatial dimension to the beam and in the diagram plan is integrated to obtain the signal, likewise ∫y for the perpendicular transverse spatial dimension, λ the optical wavelength, A10 is a constant, and INL represents the intensity of the secondary pulse obtained by the nonlinear effect of the DMNL device
The IMAG10 camera measures the integrated spatial intensity on the spectral dimension λ according to the two transverse spatial dimensions x and y: Signal=B10 INL (x, y, ∫λ), where ∫λ x represents the fact that the spectral dimension of the beam is integrated to obtain the signal, B10 is a constant, and INL represents the intensity of the secondary pulse obtained by the nonlinear effect of the DMNL device.
This device makes it possible to obtain from the signals of SPEC9 and SPEC10 the curves 70 and 71 of
where Z2 is the square of the spectral broadening calculated by taking the ratio of the widths of the obtained spectra 71 and 70, Z02 is the square of the spectral broadening obtained for the pulse without phase distortion from spectrum 70 and where Z∞2 is the square of the spectral broadening obtained for the pulse with infinite quadratic phase distortion from spectrum 70. We find that this ratio is equal to 1 if the pulse is perfectly focused and compressed, and decreases to zero if it is infinitely stretched. And from the signals of the IMAG9 and IMAG10 cameras, we can estimate the contributions to the Strehl ratio of the spatial dimensions x and y. For an integration, according to y of the intensity of the images, we obtain the ratio according to x:
where Zx2 is the square of the spatial widening along x calculated by taking the ratio of the widths of the profiles obtained for the integrated images along y, Z0x2 is the square of the spatial widening along x obtained for the pulse without phase distortion and where Z∞x2 is the square of the spatial widening along x obtained for the pulse with an infinite quadratic phase distortion along x (highly divergent beam). For an integration, according to x of the intensity of the images, we obtain the ratio according to y:
where Zy2 is the square of the spatial widening along y calculated by taking the ratio of the widths of the profiles obtained for the integrated images along x, Z0y2 is the square of the spatial widening along y obtained for the pulse without phase distortion and where Z∞y2 is the square of the spatial widening along y obtained for the pulse with an infinite quadratic phase distortion along y (highly divergent beam). The global Strehl ratio of the impulse integrating the contributions according to all the dimensions (x, y, and ω) is obtained by the product of the previously calculated ratios: R1=RixRIyRk.
This example is the first single-shot measurement of the Strehl ratio of an ultrashort pulse including contributions from all types of spectral, spatial, and spatio-temporal phase distortions.
In the example of
for SPEC30:Signal=A Ikx0(x,∫y,λ), a.
for SPEC40:Signal=B IkxNL(x,∫y,λ), b.
for SPEC50:Signal=C Iky0(∫x,y,λ), c.
for SPEC60:Signal=D IkyNL(∫x,y,λ) d.
for SPEC70:Signal=E Ikxky0(∫x,∫y,λ), e.
and for SPEC80:Signal=F IkxkyNL(∫x,∫y,λ) f.
Similarly to the device in
The set of curves and images obtained makes it possible to determine the origin of the phase distortions, whether they are spectral, spatial according to x or y, or spatio-temporal according to (x-ω) or (y-ω) according to the deformations of the curves. This is the first single-shot method of measuring the Strehl ratio of an ultrashort pulse including contributions from all types of spectral, spatial, and spatio-temporal phase distortions.
The third-order nonlinear effect producing cross-polarization (collinear polarization rotation) is not the only one that can be used in the invention. One can use any nonlinear order of order n greater than or equal to 2 called instantaneous, the result of which is that the pulse obtained has a temporal intensity and according to the spatial dimensions at the level of the nonlinear environment such that it is directly proportional to the power of n of the temporal intensity of the initial pulse at the level of the nonlinear medium. The degenerate third-order nonlinear effect considered above is only one example among the usable nonlinear orders. On the other hand, the combination of two or more stages of nonlinear effects can also be used.
Instantaneous nonlinear effects that are particularly interesting in our case are the effects obtained at the level of the experiments directly such as the generation of harmonic 2 or 3 on the surface or in gases. The measurement can thus be carried out directly at the level of the experiment.
In the embodiment of the invention above, the spatio-spectral images can be processed directly at the level of the calculator to give an evaluation of the Strehl ratio. They can also be used to diagnose the origin of distortions. If the pulse is significantly distorted, then its Strehl ratio is significantly lower than 1 (for example, 0.2). The observation of the image is curved, which can be associated with it such that the central positions and the enlargements are characteristic of the defects. There may remain an ambiguity, for example between a pulse comprising a combination of spectral dispersion and spatial dispersion, with a pulse comprising exclusively an inclination of the pulse front. The spatio-spectral images are identical. But by adding a spectral or spatial dispersion, then the images become different and then reveal a signature of the origin of the distortion.
The invention can be used to optimize the output's characteristics of laser systems. The laser then comprises one or more shaping devices whose characteristics will be modified in a feedback loop in order to obtain the characteristics sought by the user. In many cases, the desired characteristic is the cancellation of phase distortions.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2000958 | Jan 2020 | FR | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/EP2021/052226 | 1/30/2021 | WO |