Electronic battery tester

Abstract
An electronic battery tester includes a calibration interface. A microprocessor is configured to calibrate the battery tester by coupling to a calibrator through the calibration interface.
Description




The present invention relates to testing of storage batteries. More specifically, the present invention relates to electronic battery testers of the type used to test the condition of storage batteries.




Storage batteries, such as lead acid storage batteries of the type used in the automotive industry, have existed for many years. However, understanding the nature of such storage batteries, how such storage batteries operate and how to accurately test such batteries has been an ongoing endeavor and has proved quite difficult. Storage batteries consist of a plurality of individual storage cells electrically connected in series. Typically each cell has a voltage potential of about 2.1 volts. By connecting the cells in series, the voltages of the individual cells are added in a cumulative manner. For example, in a typical automotive storage battery, six storage cells are used to provide a total voltage when the battery is fully charged of 12.6 volts.




There has been a long history of attempts to accurately test the condition of storage batteries. A simple test is to measure the voltage of the battery. If the voltage is below a certain threshold, the battery is determined to be bad. However, this test is inconvenient because it requires the battery to be charged prior to performing the test. If the battery is discharged, the voltage will be low and a good battery may be incorrectly tested as bad. Furthermore, such a test does not give any indication of how much energy is stored in the battery. Another technique for testing a battery is referred as a load test. In a load test, the battery is discharged using a known load. As the battery is discharged, the voltage across the battery is monitored and used to determine the condition of the battery. This technique requires that the battery be sufficiently charged in order that it can supply current to the load.




More recently, a technique has been pioneered by Dr. Keith S. Champlin and Midtronics, Inc. of Burr Ridge, Ill. for testing storage batteries by measuring the conductance of the batteries. This technique is described in a number of United States patents obtained by Dr. Champlin and Midtronics, Inc, for example, U.S. Pat. No. 3,873,911, issued Mar. 25, 1975, to Champlin, entitled ELECTRONIC BATTERY TESTING DEVICE; U.S. Pat. No. 3,909,708, issued Sep. 30, 1975, to Champlin, entitled ELECTRONIC BATTERY TESTING DEVICE; U.S. Pat. No. 4,816,768, issued Mar. 28, 1989, to Champlin, entitled ELECTRONIC BATTERY TESTING DEVICE; U.S. Pat. No. 4,825,170, issued Apr. 25, 1989, to Champlin, entitled ELECTRONIC BATTERY TESTING DEVICE WITH AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE SCALING; U.S. Pat. No. 4,881,038, issued Nov. 14, 1989, to Champlin, entitled ELECTRONIC BATTERY TESTING DEVICE WITH AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE SCALING TO DETERMINE DYNAMIC CONDUCTANCE; U.S. Pat. No. 4,912,416, issued Mar. 27, 1990, to Champlin, entitled ELECTRONIC BATTERY TESTING DEVICE WITH STATE-OF-CHARGE COMPENSATION; U.S. Pat. No. 5,140,269, issued Aug. 18, 1992, to Champlin, entitled ELECTRONIC TESTER FOR ASSESSING BATTERY/CELL CAPACITY; U.S. Pat. No. 5,343,380, issued Aug. 30, 1994, entitled METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR SUPPRESSING TIME VARYING SIGNALS IN BATTERIES UNDERGOING CHARGING OR DISCHARGING; U.S. Pat. No. 5,572,136, issued Nov. 5, 1996, entitled ELECTRONIC BATTERY TESTER WITH AUTOMATIC COMPENSATION FOR LOW STATE-OF-CHARGE; U.S. Pat. No. 5,574,355, issued Nov. 12, 1996, entitled METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR DETECTION AND CONTROL OF THERMAL RUNAWAY IN A BATTERY UNDER CHARGE; U.S. Pat. No. 5,585,728, issued Dec. 17, 1996, entitled ELECTRONIC BATTERY TESTER WITH AUTOMATIC COMPENSATION FOR LOW STATE-OF-CHARGE; U.S. Pat. No. 5,592,093, issued Jan. 7, 1997, entitled ELECTRONIC BATTERY TESTING DEVICE LOOSE TERMINAL CONNECTION DETECTION VIA A COMPARISON CIRCUIT; U.S. Pat. No. 5,598,098, issued Jan. 28, 1997, entitled ELECTRONIC BATTERY TESTER WITH VERY HIGH NOISE IMMUNITY; U.S. Pat. No. 5,757,192, issued May 26, 1998, entitled METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR DETECTING A BAD CELL IN A STORAGE BATTERY; U.S. Pat. No. 5,821,756, issued Oct. 13, 1998, entitled ELECTRONIC BATTERY TESTER WITH TAILORED COMPENSATION FOR LOW STATE-OF-CHARGE; U.S. Pat. No. 5,831,435, issued Nov. 3, 1998, entitled BATTERY TESTER FOR JIS STANDARD; U.S. Pat. No. 5,914,605, issued Jun. 22, 1999, entitled ELECTRONIC BATTERY TESTER; U.S. Pat. No. 5,945,829, issued Aug. 31, 1999, entitled MIDPOINT BATTERY MONITORING; and U.S. Pat. No. 6,002,238, issued Dec. 14, 1999, entitled METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR MEASURING COMPLEX IMPEDANCE OF CELLS AND BATTERIES.




Most accurate electronic battery testers have required very accurate and relatively expensive test and interface circuitry. The circuitry must be able to be accurately calibrated to a standard, and maintain that calibration in the harsh environment often associate with automotive battery testing. The user interface associated with such devices has also been relatively complex and expensive. Such devices have required a significant capital investment and, because of this investment, have often not been attractive to individual consumers. Further, the expense associated with such battery testers has reduced the number of testers which are typically available in commercial settings.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




An electronic battery tester includes a calibration interface. A microprocessor is configured to calibrate the battery tester by coupling to a calibrator through the calibration interface.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a simplified schematic diagram showing an electronic battery tester in accordance with the present invention.





FIG. 2

is a simplified block diagram of a test fixture in accordance with one aspect of the invention for use with the battery tester of FIG.


1


.





FIG. 3

is a simplified electrical schematic diagram of an amplifier in the tester of FIG.


1


.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS




The present invention provides an inexpensive electronic battery tester which delivers accurate results and is easy to use. Aspects of the invention will be apparent in the following disclosure.





FIG. 1

is a simplified block diagram of electronic battery tester circuitry


16


in accordance with the present invention. Apparatus


16


is shown coupled to battery


12


which includes a positive battery terminal


22


and a negative battery terminal


24


. Battery


12


is a storage battery having a plurality of individual cells, typically six, and a voltage of 12.6 volts.




Circuitry


16


operates in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention and determines the conductance (G


BAT


) of battery


12


and the voltage potential (V


BAT


) between terminals


22


and


24


of battery


12


. Circuitry


16


includes current source


50


, differential amplifier


52


, analog-to-digital converter


54


and microprocessor


56


. Amplifier


52


is capacitively coupled to battery


12


through capacitors C


1


and C


2


. Amplifier


52


has an output connected to an input of analog-to-digital converter


54


. Microprocessor


56


is connected to system clock


58


, memory


60


, visual output


62


and analog-to-digital converter


54


. Microprocessor


56


is also capable of receiving an input from input device


66


. Further, an input/output (I/O) port


67


is provided.




In operation, current source


50


is controlled by microprocessor


56


and provides a current in the direction shown by the arrow in FIG.


1


. In one embodiment, this is a square wave or a pulse. Differential amplifier


52


is connected to terminals


22


and


24


of battery


12


through capacitors C


1


and C


2


, respectively, and provides an output related to the voltage potential difference between terminals


22


and


24


. In a preferred embodiment, amplifier


52


has a high input impedance. Circuitry


16


includes differential amplifier


70


having inverting and noninverting inputs connected to terminals


24


and


22


, respectively. Amplifier


70


is connected to measure the open circuit potential voltage (V


BAT


) of battery


12


between terminals


22


and


24


. The output of amplifier


70


is provided to analog-to-digital converter


54


such that the voltage across terminals


22


and


24


can be measured by microprocessor


56


.




Circuitry


16


is connected to battery


12


through a four-point connection technique known as a Kelvin connection. This Kelvin connection allows current I to be injected into battery


12


through a first pair of terminals while the voltage V across the terminals


22


and


24


is measured by a second pair of connections. Because very little current flows through amplifier


52


, the voltage drop across the inputs to amplifier


52


is substantially identical to the voltage drop across terminals


22


and


24


of battery


12


. The output of differential amplifier


52


is converted to a digital format and is provided to microprocessor


56


. Microprocessor


56


operates at a frequency determined by system clock


58


and in accordance with programming instructions stored in memory


60


.




Microprocessor


56


determines the conductance of battery


12


by applying a current pulse I using current source


50


. The microprocessor determines the change in battery voltage due to the current pulse I using amplifier


52


and analog-to-digital converter


54


. The value of current I generated by current source


50


is known and is stored in memory


60


. In one embodiment, current I is obtained by applying a load to battery


12


. Microprocessor


56


calculates the dynamic conductance of battery


12


using the following equation:









Conductance
=


G
BAT

=


Δ





I


Δ





V







Equation





1













where ΔI is the change in current flowing through battery


12


due to current source


50


and ΔV is the change in battery voltage due to applied current ΔI. This can then be converted in to cold cranking amps (CCA) and/or compared to a rating of battery


12


stored in memory


60


.




One aspect of the present invention includes the reduction in the number of expensive components which are used in the battery tester


16


. For example, some prior art battery testers have required a user input through which an operator enters a rating or reference for the particular battery being tested. However, in one embodiment, the present invention uses a fixed reference which is chosen to approximate the capacity of most batteries being tested. For example, a value of approximately 500 CCA may be used as an approximation and stored in memory


60


. Although this reduces accuracy of the tester, the tester is still capable of providing satisfactory results for many applications. For example, if a battery is measured as being marginal, the operator can proceed with a battery test using a tester having a separate input. The particular general reference standard which is used in the present invention can be selected for a specific use for the tester. For example, if the tester is intended for use with automotive batteries one standard may be used and if the tester is intended for use with golf carts, for example, another standard may be stored in memory


60


during manufacture. In another embodiment, the rating is entered through input


66


by an operator.




In another aspect of the present invention, indicator


62


comprises two LEDs


62


A and


62


B. For example, LED


62


A can be a red LED and LED


62


B can be a green LED. If microprocessor


56


turns both LEDs


62


A and


62


B on, this indicator that the testing process is under way. A single green LED


62


B indicates a good battery while a single red LED


62


A indicates a bad battery. A flashing green LED


62


B indicates a good battery with a low charge. Flashing red and green LEDs


62


A,B indicate the battery should be recharged and retested. In another aspect, the tester


16


can be used as a charging tester by measuring the voltage across the battery


12


during operation of the engine of the vehicle which contains the battery. The tester can be switched between a battery test mode and a charging test mode through user input


66


which comprises a switch, for example. In this aspect of the invention, a green light indicates a normal charging voltage, a red light indicates a low charging voltage and a flashing red light indicates a high charging voltage. Of course, other combinations of light colors, sequences or flashing rates can be used to convey information.




In one aspect, memory


60


includes a non-volatile memory such as a flash memory which can store information when circuitry


16


is not receiving power. In performing a battery test, microprocessor can compare a measured value of a dynamic parameter of the battery, such as conductance, to a rated value to obtain a relative value. The rated value can be stored in memory


60


. The units of the rating such as CCA, DIN, SAE, JIS or others, can be selected by a user and semi-permanently stored in the flash memory. Any type of non-volatile memory which can be written to and can be used. A rating can be selected through user input


66


. For example, a first button can be used to increment a rating displayed on indicator


62


and a second button can be used to decrement the rating. The value of the increments and decrements can be stored in the flash memory. Programming of the flash memory can be through a special operating mode. For example, if a certain sequence of inputs are provided or pressed on input


66


during operation or during power up of the device, microprocessor


56


can enter a flash memory programming mode. In such a mode, the rating standard or the increment/decrement value can be entered and stored into the flash memory. Typically, circuitry


16


is powered using power derived from battery


12


. In such an embodiment, values in the flash memory will be maintained even when the device is disconnected from battery


12


.




Microprocessor


56


can also capture and store voltages measured by amplifier


70


. For example, microprocessor


56


can take a number of samples using the analog to digital converter


54


and store a high sample value and a low sample value. These values can subsequently be retrieved using input


66


and displayed through indicator


62


. This information is particularly useful to diagnose problems associated with the starter motor of the vehicle. For example, a relatively low voltage value can indicate a impending failure. Similarly, a high value during which the starter motor is not operating can indicate that the starter motor is burned out is failing to receive power.




In one aspect, indicator


62


includes an LED array configured to provide a numerical output. Such an output can provide, for example, a voltage measurement. Further, in one embodiment, an operator is able to enter the rating of a battery, such as a CCA rating, by pushing buttons in user input


66


which allow the operator to scroll through a series of CCA ratings which are displayed on the LED array of indicator


62


. CCA can be stored in increments of 5 or 10, for example, and the operator can scroll through the increments until the battery rating is reached. A test can then be initiated by pressing another button in input


66


.




The battery tester


16


of the present invention is also capable of performing an automated calibration. Typically, this calibration is performed during manufacture, during which time the tester


16


is coupled to a calibrated test fixture.

FIG. 2

is a simplified diagram of a test fixture or calibrator


100


for use with tester


16


of FIG.


1


. In the simplified schematic diagram illustrated in

FIG. 2

, calibrator


100


includes a calibration resistance or shunt


102


and a calibration voltage generated by zener diode


104


of 10.00 volts. A switch


106


is connected as shown in FIG.


2


and coupled to tester I/O


67


. During operation, microprocessor


56


and tester


16


controls switch


106


to switch between a conductance (CCA) calibration mode and a voltage calibration mode. To calibrate conductance, switch


106


is moved into position to couple to resistance


102


. Tester


16


performs a test upon this calibration resistance


102


. The difference between the measured value and the actual value is stored in memory


60


and is used to offset subsequent tests. Similarly, to perform a voltage calibration switch


106


is connected to voltage source


104


such that all test connections to tester


16


are connected across voltage source


104


. Again, the measured value is compared to the actual value of source


104


and the offset is stored in memory


60


and used to correct subsequent calibrations. In a third position, switch


106


couples to the other terminal to allow measurement of the voltage source. After the calibration sequence, a second calibration sequence is performed. If errors still exist, or if the errors are outside of an acceptable window, the tester is rejected. Further I/O


67


can couple to a computer (not shown) whereby microprocessor


56


in tester can provide detailed diagnostic information such as specific calibration values or measurement errors for use in performing diagnostics on tester


16


.




Calibrator


200


can have other configurations and the embodiment of

FIG. 2

is simply one example. The switch can be formed by a relay transistor or other selectable switch and can comprise multiple switches to achieve the desired functionality. The calibrator can also include a microprocessor to perform more complex calibration steps.





FIG. 3

illustrates a simplified amplifier


120


in accordance with another aspect of the invention. Amplifier


120


includes differential amplifier


52


coupled with resistors


122


,


124


,


126


and


128


as shown. Further, current source


50


is illustrated in

FIG. 3

including a measured voltage V


I




130


across a load resistance


132


which is switched by transistor


134


. The amplifier is configured to have a gain of 100 and the transistor


134


switches at a frequency of 100 Hz. Thus, the CCA of the battery


12


is proportional to the conductance of the battery (G


BATT


) which equals V


I


/V


DIFF


, where V


I


is the voltage across load resistance


132


and V


DIFF


is the differential voltage output from amplifier


52


. In one preferred embodiment, amplifier


52


comprises a LM324 operational amplifier (OPAMP).




The present invention may be implemented using any appropriate technique. For simplicity, a single technique has been illustrated herein. However, other techniques may be used including implementation in all analog circuitry. Additionally, by using appropriate techniques, the battery resistance and a reference resistance (the reciprocal of conductance) may be employed in the invention. Various reference values may be stored in memory and be selected for various testing criteria such as based upon a measured temperature or the measured battery voltage. Although circuitry


16


has been illustrated in which source


50


is a current source and amplifier


52


measures a voltage signal, those skilled in the art will recognize that the circuitry may be modified by using a voltage signal source and detecting the result in current flowing through the battery. A value related to this current level is digitized and provided to the microprocessor. Battery conductance and relative conductance are calculated as appropriate. Further, the voltage or current signals may be pulsed, square waves, sign waves or any other appropriate signal controlled by microprocessor


56


or by an oscillator such as clock


58


. The terms “inject” or “apply” is used herein to describe the applying of voltage or current either with active circuitry or by applying a load to the battery. Further, “time varying” includes step signal inputs, pulse signals, periodic signals, etc.




Although the present invention has been described with reference to preferred embodiments, workers skilled in the art will recognize that changes may be made in form and detail without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.



Claims
  • 1. An electronic battery tester for testing a storage battery, comprising:a first pair of connectors configured to couple to a positive terminal of the battery; a second pair of connectors configured to couple to a negative terminal of the battery, the first and second pairs of connectors forming a Kelvin connection with the battery; a memory; a calibration interface configured to provide a calibrator control output to a calibrator; a microprocessor configured to test the battery through the Kelvin connection based upon a calibration value stored in the memory, the microprocessor further configured to communicate with the calibrator through the calibration interface to initiate a self calibration, measure a calibrated value of the calibrator through the Kelvin connection and store the measured calibrator value in memory as the calibration value.
  • 2. The electronic battery tester of claim 1 wherein the calibration interface is configured to provide a first calibrator control output to initiate a resistance calibration and a second calibrator control output to initiate a voltage calibration.
  • 3. The electronic battery tester of claim 1 including a visual output configured to display a result of the battery test, the visual output including a LED and wherein a first test result is indicated with the LED on and a second test result is indicated with the LED off.
  • 4. The electronic battery tester of claim 1 wherein the battery test is further a function of a fixed reference value stored in the memory.
  • 5. The electronic battery tester of claim 1 wherein the battery test is further a function of a selectable reference value.
  • 6. The electronic battery tester of claim 5 wherein the reference value is selected by scrolling through a plurality of reference values.
  • 7. The electronic battery tester of claim 5 wherein the reference value is selected in accordance with an increment value stored in the memory.
  • 8. The electronic battery tester of claim 7 wherein the memory comprises a non-volatile memory.
  • 9. The electronic battery tester of claim 8 wherein the increment value is selectively stored in the non-volatile memory.
  • 10. The electronic battery tester of claim 9 wherein the increment value is stored by placing the microprocessor in a programming mode.
  • 11. The electronic battery tester of claim 11 wherein a programming mode is entered during power-up of the microprocessor.
  • 12. The electronic battery tester of claim 5 wherein the reference value is in accordance with a selectable standard.
  • 13. The electronic battery tester of claim 12 wherein the standard is stored in memory.
  • 14. The electronic battery tester of claim 13 wherein the memory comprises a non-volatile memory.
  • 15. The electronic battery tester of claim 13 wherein the standard is stored by placing the microprocessor in a programming mode.
  • 16. The electronic battery tester of claim 15 wherein the programming mode is entered during power-up of the microprocessor.
  • 17. The electronic battery tester of claim 1 wherein the calibration output is configured to drive a switch in the calibrator.
  • 18. The electronic battery tester of claim 2 wherein the microprocessor calibration values from resistance and voltage measurements are stored in the memory.
  • 19. An electronic battery tester for testing a storage battery, comprising:a first pair of connectors configured to couple to a positive terminal of the battery; a second pair of connectors configured to couple to a negative terminal of the battery, the first and second pairs of connectors forming a Kelvin connection with the battery; a memory; a microprocessor configured to test the battery through the Kelvin connection based upon an industry standard battery rating; and a user input configured to select an industry standard rating system for the battery rating and store the selected rating system in the memory.
  • 20. The electronic battery tester of claim 19 including a calibration interface configured to couple to a calibrator to initiate measurement of a calibrated value of the calibrator through the Kelvin connection.
  • 21. The electronic battery tester of claim 19 including a visual output configured to display a result of the battery test, the visual output including a LED and wherein a first test result is indicated with the LED on and a second test result is indicated with the LED off.
  • 22. The electronic battery tester of claim 19 wherein the battery test is a function of a fixed reference value stored in the memory.
  • 23. The electronic battery tester of claim 19 wherein the battery test is further a function of a selectable reference value.
  • 24. The electronic battery tester of claim 23 wherein the reference value is selected by scrolling through a plurality of reference values.
  • 25. The electronic battery tester of claim 24 wherein the reference value is selected in accordance with an increment value stored in a non-volatile memory.
  • 26. The electronic battery tester of claim 19 wherein the memory comprises a non-volatile memory.
  • 27. The electronic battery tester of claim 26 wherein the standard rating system is stored by placing the microprocessor in a programming mode.
  • 28. The electronic battery tester of claim 14 wherein the programming mode is entered during power-up of the microprocessor.
  • 29. An electronic battery tester for testing a storage battery, comprising:a first pair of connectors configured to couple to a positive terminal of the battery; a second pair of connectors configured to couple to a negative terminal of the battery, the first and second pairs of connectors forming a Kelvin connection with the battery; a memory; a microprocessor configured to test the battery through the Kelvin connection based upon a battery rating; and a user input configured to select an increment or decrement value for use in entering the battery rating and store the value in the memory.
  • 30. The electronic battery tester of claim 29 includes a calibration interface to couple to a calibrator.
  • 31. The electronic battery tester of claim 29 including a visual output configured to display a result of the battery test, the visual output including a LED and wherein a first test result is indicated with the LED on and a second test result is indicated with the LED off.
  • 32. The electronic battery tester of claim 29 wherein the battery rating is selected by scrolling through a plurality of reference values.
  • 33. The electronic battery tester of claim 29 wherein the reference value is selected in accordance with an increment value stored in the memory.
  • 34. The electronic battery tester of claim 29 wherein the memory comprises a non-volatile memory.
  • 35. The electronic battery tester of claim 29 wherein the increment or decrement value is stored in memory by placing the microprocessor in a programming mode.
  • 36. The electronic battery tester of claim 35 wherein the programming mode is entered during power-up of the microprocessor.
  • 37. The electronic battery tester of claim 29 wherein the battery rating is in accordance with a selectable standard.
  • 38. The electronic battery tester of claim 37 wherein the standard is stored in memory.
  • 39. The electronic battery tester of claim 38 wherein the standard is stored by placing the microprocessor in a programming mode.
  • 40. A battery tester calibrator, comprising:a control input configured to receive a control input from an electronic battery tester; a Kelvin connection coupling configured to couple to a Kelvin connection of the battery tester; a voltage reference; a resistance reference; at least one switch configured to selectively couple the voltage and resistance references to the Kelvin connection coupling in respective first and second relay positions in response to the control input.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

The present invention claims priority to Provisional Application Serial No. 60/128,366, filed Apr. 8, 1999 and entitled ELECTRONIC BATTERY TESTER.

US Referenced Citations (196)
Number Name Date Kind
2514745 Dalzell Jul 1950
3356936 Smith Dec 1967
3562634 Latner Feb 1971
3593099 Scholl Jul 1971
3607673 Seyl Sep 1971
3676770 Sharaf et al. Jul 1972
3729989 Little May 1973
3753094 Furuishi et al. Aug 1973
3808522 Sharaf Apr 1974
3811089 Strezelewicz May 1974
3873911 Champlin Mar 1975
3876931 Godshalk Apr 1975
3886443 Miyakawa et al. May 1975
3889248 Ritter Jun 1975
3906329 Bader Sep 1975
3909709 Champlin Sep 1975
3936744 Perlmutter Feb 1976
3946299 Christianson et al. Mar 1976
3947757 Grube et al. Mar 1976
3969667 McWilliams Jul 1976
3979664 Harris Sep 1976
3984762 Dowgiallo, Jr. Oct 1976
3984768 Staples Oct 1976
3989544 Santo Nov 1976
4008619 Alcaide et al. Feb 1977
4053824 Dupuis et al. Oct 1977
4070624 Taylor Jan 1978
4086531 Bernier Apr 1978
4112351 Back et al. Sep 1978
4114083 Benham et al. Sep 1978
4126874 Suzuki et al. Nov 1978
4178546 Hulls et al. Dec 1979
4193025 Frailing et al. Mar 1980
4207611 Gordon Jun 1980
4217645 Barry et al. Aug 1980
4315204 Sievers et al. Feb 1982
4316185 Watrous et al. Feb 1982
4322685 Frailing et al. Mar 1982
4363407 Barkler et al. Dec 1982
4369407 Korbell Jan 1983
4379990 Sievers et al. Apr 1983
4390828 Converse et al. Jun 1983
4392101 Saar et al. Jul 1983
4396880 Windebank Aug 1983
4408157 Beaubien Oct 1983
4412169 Dell'Orto Oct 1983
4423378 Marino et al. Dec 1983
4423379 Jacobs et al. Dec 1983
4424491 Bobbett et al. Jan 1984
4459548 Lentz et al. Jul 1984
4514694 Finger Apr 1985
4520353 McAuliffe May 1985
4633418 Bishop Dec 1986
4659977 Kissel et al. Apr 1987
4667279 Maier May 1987
4678998 Muramatsu Jul 1987
4679000 Clark Jul 1987
4697134 Burkum et al. Sep 1987
4707795 Alber et al. Nov 1987
4709202 Koenck et al. Nov 1987
4710861 Kanner Dec 1987
4719428 Liebermann Jan 1988
4743855 Randin et al. May 1988
4745349 Palanisamy et al. May 1988
4816768 Champlin Mar 1989
4820966 Fridman Apr 1989
4825170 Champlin Apr 1989
4849700 Morioka et al. Jul 1989
4876495 Palanisamy et al. Oct 1989
4881038 Champlin Nov 1989
4912416 Champlin Mar 1990
4913116 Katogi et al. Apr 1990
4929931 McCuen May 1990
4931738 MacIntyre et al. Jun 1990
4937528 Palanisamy Jun 1990
4947124 Hauser Aug 1990
4956597 Heavvvvey et al. Sep 1990
4968941 Rogers Nov 1990
4968942 Palanisamy Nov 1990
5004979 Marino et al. Apr 1991
5032825 Xuznicki Jul 1991
5047722 Wurst et al. Sep 1991
5087881 Peacock Feb 1992
5126675 Yang Jun 1992
5140269 Champlin Aug 1992
5144218 Bosscha Sep 1992
5144248 Alexandres et al. Sep 1992
5160881 Schramm et al. Nov 1992
5170124 Blair et al. Dec 1992
5179335 Nor Jan 1993
5204611 Nor et al. Apr 1993
5214370 Harm et al. May 1993
5214385 Gabriel et al. May 1993
5241275 Fang Aug 1993
5254952 Salley et al. Oct 1993
5266880 Newland Nov 1993
5281919 Palanisamy Jan 1994
5281920 Wurst Jan 1994
5295078 Stich et al. Mar 1994
5298797 Redl Mar 1994
5300874 Shimamoto et al. Apr 1994
5302902 Groehl Apr 1994
5315287 Sol May 1994
5321626 Palladino Jun 1994
5331268 Patino et al. Jul 1994
5336993 Thomas et al. Aug 1994
5338515 Dalla Betta et al. Aug 1994
5339018 Brokaw Aug 1994
5343380 Champlin Aug 1994
5347163 Yoshimura Sep 1994
5352968 Reni et al. Oct 1994
5365160 Leppo et al. Nov 1994
5365453 Startup et al. Nov 1994
5381096 Hirzel Jan 1995
5412323 Kato et al. May 1995
5426371 Salley et al. Jun 1995
5426416 Jefferies et al. Jun 1995
5432426 Yoshida Jul 1995
5434495 Toko Jul 1995
5442274 Tamai Aug 1995
5449996 Matsumoto et al. Sep 1995
5449997 Gilmore et al. Sep 1995
5451881 Finger Sep 1995
5457377 Jonsson Oct 1995
5469043 Cherng et al. Nov 1995
5485090 Stephens Jan 1996
5488300 Jamieson Jan 1996
5519383 De La Rosa May 1996
5528148 Rogers Jun 1996
5537967 Tashiro et al. Jul 1996
5546317 Andrieu Aug 1996
5548273 Nicol et al. Aug 1996
5550485 Falk Aug 1996
5561380 Sway-Tin et al. Oct 1996
5562501 Kinoshita et al. Oct 1996
5572136 Champlin Nov 1996
5574355 McShane et al. Nov 1996
5583416 Klang Dec 1996
5585728 Champlin Dec 1996
5589757 Klang Dec 1996
5592093 Klingbiel Jan 1997
5596260 Moravec et al. Jan 1997
5598098 Champlin Jan 1997
5602462 Stich et al. Feb 1997
5606242 Hull et al. Feb 1997
5621298 Harvey Apr 1997
5642031 Brotto Jun 1997
5650937 Bounaga Jul 1997
5652501 McClure et al. Jul 1997
5656920 Cherng et al. Aug 1997
5675234 Greene Oct 1997
5677077 Faulk Oct 1997
5699050 Kanazawa Dec 1997
5701089 Perkins Dec 1997
5705929 Caravello et al. Jan 1998
5710503 Sideris et al. Jan 1998
5717336 Basell et al. Feb 1998
5717937 Fritz Feb 1998
5747909 Syverson et al. May 1998
5757192 McShane et al. May 1998
5760587 Harvey Jun 1998
5773978 Becker Jun 1998
5789899 van Phuoc et al. Aug 1998
5793359 Ushikubo Aug 1998
5808469 Kopera Sep 1998
5821756 McShane et al. Oct 1998
5825174 Parker Oct 1998
5831435 Troy Nov 1998
5862515 Kobayashi et al. Jan 1999
5872443 Williamson Feb 1999
5895440 Proctor et al. Apr 1999
5914605 Bertness Jun 1999
5929609 Joy et al. Jul 1999
5939855 Proctor et al. Aug 1999
5939861 Joko et al. Aug 1999
5945829 Bertness Aug 1999
5969625 Russo Oct 1999
6002238 Champlin Dec 1999
6008652 Theofanopoulos et al. Dec 1999
6009369 Boisvert et al. Dec 1999
6031354 Wiley et al. Feb 2000
6037751 Klang Mar 2000
6037777 Champlin Mar 2000
6051976 Bertness Apr 2000
6072299 Kurie et al. Jun 2000
6072300 Tsuji Jun 2000
6081098 Bertness et al. Jun 2000
6091245 Bertness Jul 2000
6094033 Ding et al. Jul 2000
6104167 Bertness et al. Aug 2000
6114834 Parise Sep 2000
6137269 Champlin Oct 2000
6150793 Lesesky et al. Nov 2000
6163156 Bertness Dec 2000
6172483 Champlin Jan 2001
6172505 Bertness Jan 2001
Foreign Referenced Citations (23)
Number Date Country
29 26 716 B1 Jan 1981 DE
0 022 450 A1 Jan 1981 EP
0 637 754 A1 Feb 1995 EP
0 772 056 A1 May 1997 EP
2 749 397 Dec 1997 FR
2 088 159 A Jun 1982 GB
59-17894 Jan 1984 JP
59-17893 Jan 1984 JP
59017894 Jan 1984 JP
59-17892 Jan 1984 JP
59215674 Dec 1984 JP
60225078 Nov 1985 JP
62-180284 Aug 1987 JP
63027776 Feb 1988 JP
03274479 Dec 1991 JP
03282276 Dec 1991 JP
4-8636 Jan 1992 JP
04131779 May 1992 JP
04372536 Dec 1992 JP
5216550 Aug 1993 JP
7-128414 May 1995 JP
WO 9322666 Nov 1993 WO
WO 9858270 Dec 1998 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (14)
Entry
“Electrochemical Impedence Spectroscopy in Battery Development and Testing”, Batteries International, Apr. 1997, pp. 59 and 62-63.
“Battery Impedence”, by E. Willihnganz et al., Electrical Engineering, Sep. 1959, pp. 922-925.
“Determining The End of Battery Life”, by S. DeBardelaben, IEEE, 1986, pp. 365-368.
“A Look at the Impedence of a Cell”, by S. Debardelaben, IEEE, 1988, pp. 394-397.
“The Impedence of Electrical Storage Cells”, by N.A. Hampson et al., Journal of Applied Electrochemistry, 1980, pp. 3-11.
“A Package for Impedance/Admittance Data Analysis”, by B. Boukamp, Solid State Ionics, 1986, pp. 136-140.
“Precision of Impedence Spectroscopy Estimates of Bulk, Reaction Rate, and Diffusion Parameters”, by J. Macdonald et al., J. Electroanal, Chem., 1991, pp. 1-11.
Internal Resistance: Harbinger of Capacity Loss in Starved Electrolyte Sealed Lead Acid Batteries, by Vaccaro, F. J. et al., AT&T Bell Laboratories, 1987 IEEE, Ch. 2477, pp. 128,131.
IEEE Recommended Practice For Maintenance, Testings, and Replacement of Large Lead Storage Batteries for Generating Stations and Substations, The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc., ANSI/IEEE Std. 450-1987, Mar. 9, 1987, pp. 7-15.
“Field and Laboratory Studies to Assess the State of Health of Valve-Regulated Lead Acid Batteries: Part I Conductors/Capacity Correlation Studies”, by D. Feder et al., IEEE, Aug. 1992, pp. 218-233.
“Battery Impedance”, by E. Willihnganz et al., Electrical Engineering, Sep. 1959, pp. 922-925.
“JIS Japanese Industrial Standard-Lead Acid Batteries for Automobiles”, Japanese Standards Association UDC, 621.355.2:629.113.006, Nov. 1995.
“Performance of Dry Cells”, by C. Hambuechen, Preprint of Am. Electrochem. Soc., Apr. 18-20, 1912, paper No. 19, pp. 1-5.
“A Bridge for Measuring Storage Battery Resistance”, by E. Willihncanz, The Electrochemical Society, preprint 79-20, Apr. 1941, pp. 253-258.
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
60/128366 Apr 1999 US