Patent Application
20190025186
This disclosure relates to flow cytometry evaluation of biological material for unassociated particles of virus size of a viral type of adenovirus.
Adenovirus and adeno-associated virus are nonenveloped viruses that have been particularly difficult to accurately quantify by flow cytometry. By quantity or quantification it is meant counting and determining a concentration of individual virus particles.
Adenovirus are a family of non-enveloped virus about 90 to 100 nanometers in size with an icosahedral nucleocapsid containing a double stranded DNA genome ranging from 26 to 48 kbp in size. Adenovirus is infective of a number of vertebrate hosts, including many distinct serotypes that infect humans. Adenovirus is an important virus for use in a number of virotherapy applications, including for oncolytic, gene therapy and immunotherapy applications. Adenovirus is one of the primary vehicles for delivering genetic payloads to specific cell types, especially neoplastic cells. Adenovirus have high potential toxicity, and careful and accurate monitoring and quantification of adenovirus is important throughout various stages of manufacture and for accurate dosing in virotherapeutic formulations. For example, adenovirus is known to cause respiratory disease in humans, primarily in children, and it is essential that key viral genes are replaced with the required therapeutic gene or genes. To avoid this issue, as well as the likelihood of a host immune response to the vector, non-human strains of adenovirus are also being investigated. This point, especially as it relates to quantification, has been specifically called-out by the FDA: “Given the potential toxicity of the adenoviral particles themselves, CBER recommends that patient dosing be based on particle number.” (Guidance for Human Somatic Cell Therapy & Gene Therapy, FDA Centers for Biologics Evaluation and Research, 1998.)
Adeno-associated virus (AAV) are a family of small, nonenveloped viruses on the order of 20 nanometers in size and a 4.7 kb single stranded DNA genome. AAV has many serotypes that can infect both dividing and quiescent cells in human hosts. Adeno-associated virus are important virus for use in a number of virotherapy applications, including as gene therapy vector. Because of the extremely small size, adeno-associated virus is difficult to detect and accurately quantify, for example in manufacture operations for making recombinant adeno-associated virus and for dosing control.
Adeno-associated virus (AAV) is generally non-replicating, with replication generally requiring the presence of an additional factor. For example, AAV may be replicated in the presence of adenovirus using certain proteins of adenovirus genes. Some advantages of using AAV as a viral vector are the absence of pathogenicity, low host immune response and long-term expression. Accurate quantification of AAV during manufacture and formulation operations is important to monitor performance of manufacturing constructs and track product yields and to provide accurate dosing. Even though not pathogenic, excessive dosing with an infectious viral agent such as adeno-associated virus can cause serious problems to patients.
One of the most problematic steps is in the quantification of adenovirus or AAV viral vectors during growth, harvest, purification and release. Methods such as quantitative PCR and absorbance readings at 260 nm and 280 nm are highly variable, resulting in over- or under-estimation of particles present at any given step. The ramifications for manufacturing are lost product, delays and cost overruns, which are serious, yet minor in comparison to the risks associated with administering too little (no therapeutic effect) or too much (adverse immune response) product to patients. Clearly, there is a critical requirement for a rapid, more precise means of quantifying AAV viral particles used for vector-mediated gene therapy.
Some other traditional approaches to virus quantification include, transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and single radial immunodiffusion (SRID) assay. These traditional approaches tend to have one or more of the following limitations: time-consuming, expensive, highly technical, high variability in results and subjective. Some newer approaches that have been proposed generally for virus quantification include field flow fractionation and multi-angle light scattering (FFF-MALS), tunable resistive pulse sensing (TRPS) and nanoparticle tracking analysis (NTS). All of these newer approaches may in some instances have some advantages relative to traditional quantification methods, but also have limitations, including typically providing limited virus data. In the case of AAV, plaque titer assay, commonly used as a quantification measure for many viruses, is generally not a useful technique for AAV, because of the non-replicating nature of AAV. Also, plaque titer assay, commonly used as a quantification measure for many viruses, is generally not a useful technique for adeno-associated virus, because of the non-replicating nature of AAV.
A very common method for quantifying AAV is quantitative PCR, however the technique is generally considered as at best providing an indirect readout of particle number, and results for the same sample can vary by as much as 3× when performed on the same instrument and even more (up to 10×) when the sample is analyzed on different hardware and/or by different laboratory personnel. The ability to use qPCR is also often confounded by the aberrant packaging of constructs in excess of the normal 4.7 kb genome size. Since qPCR typically underreports the copy number (and by inference, underreports the particle count), concerns around injecting higher than necessary amounts of AAV particles are well-founded.
Carefully controlled flow cytometry using a combination of protein and nucleic acid fluorescent stains has also been used for quantification of a variety of viruses. Flow cytometry is an analytical technique in which physical and/or chemical properties of particles are measured as they flow in a fluid sample through an investigation cuvette, commonly referred to as a flow cell. Although the fluid sample may be investigated by subjecting the fluid sample to a variety of stimuli, light is one common stimulus technique. Devices containing a flow cell, and associated fluid flow, light delivery and light detection components, are typically referred to as flow cytometers.
The Virus Counter® flow cytometers (ViroCyt, Inc.) have been used to detect the presence of free, unassociated virus particles (sometimes referred to as virions) of a variety of viruses through a combination of very low and precisely controlled sample flow rate through the flow cell and use of two fluorogenic fluorescent stains having different fluorescent emission signatures, with one stain having an affinity for labeling nucleic acid and the other having affinity for labeling proteins. The stains are non-specific as to virus type, but identification of simultaneous detection events for the two different fluorescent emissions of the two fluorescent stains may be indicative of passage of such an unassociated virus particle through the flow cell. Contrary to such techniques as field flow fractionation and multi-angle light scattering (FFF-MALS), tunable resistive pulse sensing (TRPS) and nanoparticle tracking analysis (NTS) that measure only the presence of particles, virions or other particles, the Virus Counter® flow cytometers provide more biologically relevant information given the nature of the dyes used for enumeration.
Non-specific protein and nucleic acid stains of the types as noted above are fluorogenic. The stain molecules have only a very weak fluorescent response in a free, unbound state, but the magnitude of fluorescent response increases significantly when the molecule orientation becomes fixed when bound to a particle. This increase in fluorescent response from the free, unbound state to the bound state may be an order of magnitude increase or more. This permits the strong fluorescent signals of the bound stain molecules to be identified over background fluorescence from unbound stain molecules, because of the relatively much weaker fluorescent response from the unbound stain molecules.
There are some situations, however, when such flow cytometry techniques have limitations. One limitation is that the technique is not optimal for evaluation of non-enveloped viruses, such as adenovirus or adeno-associated virus. The absence of readily accessible envelope proteins on adenovirus or adeno-associated virus can significantly limit the accuracy of the technique for adenovirus or adeno-associated virus quantification.
Given the importance of adenovirus or adeno-associated virus as virotherapy agents and the potential risks involved with use of such an infectious material, fast, inexpensive and reliable quantification techniques would be desirable.
Flow cytometry as a useful technique for quantitatively evaluating virus particles is relatively new. Most flow cytometry evaluations of biological material have involved detection and investigation of properties of particles that are of a size on the order of cells from multi-cellular organisms or larger. Such particles may be individual cells or microspheres (typically made of a material such as latex or polystyrene) functionalized with an affinity to bind smaller biological units of interest. Such microspheres are also sometimes referred to as beads or microbeads. The presence of cell or microsphere particles is typically identified during flow cytometry through detecting and analyzing scattered light exiting from the flow cell. Various fluorescent stain techniques have also been used to provide additional information about some specific biological properties of such particles, for example particular biological attributes of detected cells or of biological material bound to microspheres. Cell or microsphere particle detection through light scatter is supplemented by detecting also for the specific fluorescent emission from the fluorescent stain. Some fluorescent stains include a fluorescent molecule bound to an antibody with binding capability for a particular epitope of interest for evaluation. These stains, however, tend to be fluorophores that exhibit a high level of fluorescent response whether or not bound to a particle. Effective quantification of a virus-size particles in a fluid sample by flow cytometry requires counting individual unassociated particles of a virus size, measuring sample flow and calculating the virus-size particle concentration from the measured particle count and measured sample flow. Unlike fluorogenic stains, the presence of background signals from unbound fluorophore stains is a significant concern. Some techniques may be utilized to ensure that a detected fluorescent signal is associated with the cell or microsphere of interest, rather than coming from stained debris or from free, unbound fluorescent stain molecules that may remain in solution. After staining the particles with the desired fluorescent stain, the particles may be separated from liquid that contains residual fluorescent stain molecules in solution, such as by filtration or by accelerated sedimentation, such as by centrifugation, and decantation. The separated cells or microsphere particles may then be re-suspended in fresh suspension liquid that is free of unbound fluorescent stain. Also, a time correlation analysis may be performed to identify occurrence of simultaneous events of light scatter detection indicative of presence of a cell or microsphere particle and fluorescent emission detection indicative of the presence of the fluorescent stain, which helps to ensure that a detected fluorescent signal is in fact associated with properties of biological material of the cells or microspheres.
It has been found, however, that flow cytometry quantification of adenovirus or adeno-associated virus particles may be performed using fluorescent antibody stain, and without particle identification by light scatter detection, without separating stained adenovirus or adeno-associated virus particles from liquid with residual unbound antibody stain following virus-particle staining, and without requiring simultaneous detection of non-specific protein and nucleic acid stains or light scatter detection. This facilitates practical use of fluorophore antibody stains for detection and quantification of the particles adenovirus or adeno-associated virus viral type, and without complications of identifying particles of virus-size through light scatter detection or simultaneous detection of nucleic acid and protein fluorogenic stains and without removal of stained particles from residual unbound antibody stain fluorophores in the fluid sample following staining. This is especially remarkable given the extremely small size of such particles, and AAV particles in particular.
An aspect of this disclosure is a method for evaluating a biological material sample for unassociated virus-size particles having a particular epitope, i.e., particular antibody-binding capability, indicative of adenovirus or adeno-associated virus viral type, for example of a virus or virus-like particle. The method includes subjecting to flow cytometry a fluid sample comprising at least a portion of a biological material sample to be evaluated, wherein the fluid sample comprises a fluorescent antibody stain capable of binding, directly or indirectly, with the particular epitope. The flow cytometry may include flowing the fluid sample through a flow cell of a flow cytometer; subjecting the fluid sample flowing through the flow cell to excitation radiation capable of causing a fluorescent emission response from the fluorescent antibody stain; and detecting radiation from the flow cell within a wavelength range of the fluorescent emission and evaluating the detected radiation to identify detection events indicative of passage through the flow cell of unassociated labeled particles of virus size including a said virus-size particle having the epitope and the fluorescent antibody stain. Each such detection event corresponds with a single such unassociated labeled particle.
A number of feature refinements and additional features are applicable to this and other aspects of this disclosure. These feature refinements and additional features may be used individually or in any combination within the subject matter of this aspect or any other aspect of this disclosure. As such, each of the following features may, but are not required to be, used with any other feature or a combination of features of this aspect or any other aspect of this disclosure.
The method may include preparing a fluid sample that includes the biological material to be evaluated for presence of the unassociated particles of virus size and at least one fluorescent antibody stain that is capable of binding, directly or indirectly, with the unassociated virus-size particles through the epitope to form unassociated labeled particles of virus size that may be detected during flow cytometry. Preparing the fluid sample may include mixing the biological material or a portion thereof to be evaluated with the fluorescent antibody stain. Subjecting the fluid sample to flow cytometry may include flowing the fluid sample through a flow cell of a flow cytometer under flow conditions for passage of virus-size particles individually through the flow cell.
The unassociated particles of virus size targeted for detection may be any particles of virus size including an epitope of interest. Such particles may have multiple epitopes, at least one of which is of interest for particle evaluation. Multiple epitopes may be of interest on the same particle of virus size of interest, and may be targeted using a corresponding number of different fluorescent antibody stains. Examples of some unassociated particles of virus size that may be targeted for detection include viral particles (including viruses and particles such as virus-like particles with virus attributes). The discussion provided herein is exemplified primarily by reference to viral particles, but the principles discussed apply also to other particles of virus size (e.g., exosomes and other nanoparticles) having a particular epitope that may be targeted for detection.
A significant advantage of the method is that residual, unbound fluorescent antibody stain in solution need not be removed from the fluid sample prior to flow cytometry. Separation of remaining unbound fluorescent antibody stain from the fluorescently labeled particles of virus size of interest for evaluation would require cumbersome and time consuming processing, such as ultracentrifugation. This is significantly different than separating antibody stain from larger labeled particles such as cells or immunoassay beads in prior applications, and separating the fluorescent antibody stain from particles of virus size is significantly more complicated, time consuming and expensive than in such larger-particle contexts. In preferred implementations, preparing a fluid sample includes, after the mixing, not removing unbound fluorescent antibody stain, that is fluorescent antibody stain not bound in the unassociated labeled particles (e.g., free in solution), from the fluid sample prior to flow cytometry. In other words, residual unbound fluorescent antibody stain from the mixing may be retained in the fluid sample to remain in the fluid sample when the fluid sample is subjected to flow cytometry. Such unbound fluorescent antibody stain may represent a majority or even most of the fluorescent antibody stain that is mixed with the biological material during the noted mixing step. However, an important consideration for flow cytometry performance is control of concentration of such residual, unbound fluorescent antibody stain molecules in solution so that fluorescent emission signals from such unbound fluorescent antibody stain molecules do not overwhelm or dominate over fluorescent emission signals from the unassociated labeled particles of virus size and prevent differentiation of the emission signals from the unassociated labeled particles. In some preferred implementations, the fluid sample as fed to the flow cytometer may have a concentration of such unbound fluorescent antibody stain, not bound in unassociated labeled particles, in a range having a lower limit of 0.25 microgram per milliliter, 0.5 microgram per milliliter, 0.7 microgram per milliliter, 1 microgram per milliliter, 2 micrograms per milliliter, 3 micrograms per milliliter or 5 micrograms per milliliter and an upper limit of 10 micrograms per milliliter, 8 micrograms per milliliter, 7 micrograms per milliliter, 6 micrograms per milliliter, 5 micrograms per milliliter, 4 micrograms per milliliter, 3 micrograms per milliliter, 2.5 micrograms per milliliter or 2 micrograms per milliliter, with the upper limit being larger than the lower limit. When a fluid sample includes multiple different types of fluorescent antibody stains, such a concentration of residual, unbound fluorescent antibody stain may be applied to a concentration of each separate fluorescent antibody stain type and/or to a combined concentration of some or all of the fluorescent antibody stains. Such a concentration of residual, unbound fluorescent antibody stain of about 2, about 2.5 or about 3 micrograms per milliliter or within a relatively narrow range (e.g., within 0.5 microgram per milliliter) above or below 2, 2.5 or 3 micrograms per milliliter may be preferred for many implementations. In some preferred implementations, the fluid sample as fed to the flow cytometer may have a total concentration of a fluorescent antibody stain, including residual, unbound fluorescent antibody stain and fluorescent antibody stain bound in unassociated labeled particles in a range having a lower limit of 0.25 microgram per milliliter, 0.5 microgram per milliliter, 0.7 microgram per milliliter, 1 microgram per milliliter, 2 micrograms per milliliter, 3 micrograms per milliliter or 5 micrograms per milliliter and an upper limit of 10 micrograms per milliliter, 8 micrograms per milliliter, 7 micrograms per milliliter, 6 micrograms per milliliter, 5 micrograms per milliliter, 4 micrograms per milliliter, 3 micrograms per milliliter, 2.5 micrograms per milliliter or 2 micrograms per milliliter, with the upper limit being larger than the lower limit. Such a total concentration of fluorescent antibody stain of about 2, 2.5 or 3 micrograms per milliliter or within a relatively narrow range (e.g., within 0.5 microgram per milliliter) above or below 2, 2.5 or 3 micrograms per milliliter may be preferred for many implementations. When a fluid sample includes multiple different types of fluorescent antibody stains, such a total concentration of fluorescent antibody stain may be applied to a total concentration of each separate fluorescent antibody type and/or to a total combined concentration for some or all of the fluorescent antibody stains. Such a concentration of about 2, 2.5 or 3 micrograms per milliliter or within a relatively narrow range (e.g., within 0.5 microgram per milliliter) above or below 2, 2.5 or 3 micrograms per milliliter may be preferred for many implementations. As will be appreciated, an optimal concentration for such a total concentration of fluorescent antibody stain or for such a concentration of residual, unassociated antibody stain may vary somewhat between particular applications, but the specified ranges may be generally applicable across many applications. Optimal concentration for a particular application may depend upon such variables as concentration of the targeted unassociated particles of virus size, the amount of the epitope (number of binding sites for the fluorescent antibody stain) on such unassociated particles and affinity of the fluorescent antibody stain for binding with the epitope on the unassociated particles. In some preferred implementations, the fluid sample as fed to the flow cytometer may have a concentration of the unassociated labeled particles in a range having a lower limit of 1×105, 1×106 or 1×107 particles per milliliter and an upper limit of 1×109, 1×108 or 1×107 particles per milliliter, provided that the upper limit is larger than the lower limit. When a fluid sample includes multiple different types of particles having different epitopes to be detected with different types of fluorescent antibody stains, such a concentration of unassociated labeled particles may be applied to a concentration of the unassociated labeled particles of each particle type and/or to a combined concentration for some or all of the unassociated labeled particles of all of the particle types to be detected. In some preferred implementations, essentially all of the particles of a type to be detected are in unassociated labeled particles of virus size when the fluid sample is fed to the flow cytometer. In some preferred implementations, when detection events occur during the flow cytometry that are indicative of unassociated labeled particles of virus size during the flow cytometry there are a number of such detection events per minute that are in a range having a lower limit of 300, 1,000 or 10,000 of such detection events per minute and an upper limit of 325,000 or 100,000 of such detection events per minute. As will be appreciated, sample fluid may need to be run at a variety of different dilutions to obtain desired concentrations of unassociated labeled particles and fluorescent stains (associated and unassociated with unassociated labeled particles) and appropriate counts per minute of detection events.
Another advantage of the processing disclosed herein is that particles of virus size of specific type (e.g., as indicated by having particular antigen-binding capability) may be identified using flow cytometry without detecting for light scatter to identify the presence of particles, as has been the case for example when identifying virus type in a host cell or attached to a microsphere. In preferred implementations, the flow cytometry does not include (is in the absence of) detecting light scatter, and may include only detecting for fluorescent emissions from fluorescent stains or only detecting for fluorescent emissions of one or more fluorescent antibody stains.
A fluorescent antibody stain may include a fluorescent component or components attached to an antibody molecule that is specific to binding to an epitope of a targeted particle of adenovirus or adeno-associated virus viral type. Such fluorescent component(s) may be any component(s) with fluorescent activity to function as a fluorescent label as attached to the antibody molecules. The attachment of a fluorescent component to the antibody molecule may be direct or indirect. The attachment may be through a chemical bond or other adherence mechanism. Some examples of fluorescent components that may be included in the fluorescent antibody stain include fluorophores (fluorescent chemical compounds), fluorescent conductive nanocrystals (quantum dots), fluorescent polymers, fluorescent phycobilins, and recombinant fluorescent proteins. The description herein is exemplified primarily with reference to the use of fluorophores, but the description applies also to other fluorescent components that could be attached to the antibody molecule. In the case of a fluorophore, the fluorescent antibody stain may preferably include an average number of attached fluorophore groups (dye molecules) per antibody molecule of the fluorescent antibody stain (F/P ratio) in a range having a lower limit of 3, 4 or 5 and an upper limit of 10, 9, 8 or 7, with a range of from 5 to 7 being preferred for many applications. The antibody molecules of a fluorescent antibody stain may be monoclonal or polyclonal. Monoclonal antibodies may be preferred for targeting detection in many situations. However, a polyclonal antibody may be preferred for some applications targeted to evaluation for various virus serotypes, for example when a monoclonal antibody does not bind with the full range of targeted serotypes. The epitope target of a fluorescent antibody stain may be on a constituent protein of a target virus-size particle or may be a conformational epitope that is present in an assembled capsid of a viral particle but not present in individual constituent proteins. For adeno-associated virus in particular some preferred antibodies for fluorescent antibody stains bind with conformational epitopes of assembled capsids of adeno-associated virus. Especially with the extremely small size of adeno-associated virus, targeting a conformational epitope helps to distinguish in-tact virus structure from fragments that may contain individual proteins.
At least one viral type targeted for evaluation is adenovirus viral type or adeno-associated virus viral type. Some other example viral types that may be targeted for identification include baculovirus, adenovirus, influenza virus, enterovirus, adeno-associated virus or norovirus, for example in applications involving the evaluation for the presence of two different targeted viral types in a fluid sample. Viral type refers to the particular category of viral attribute that is targeted for detection and discrimination, and which may be at a family, subfamily, specie or serotype level, or any identifiable subset of the foregoing. As some examples, a targeted viral type may include a single specific serotype of a virus or may include multiple serotypes of a virus that share a common antigenic attribute for interaction with a fluorescent antibody stain (e.g., multiple serotypes that include a common epitope binding with the same monoclonal fluorescent antibody stain). Different viral types targeted for identification may represent for example different families, subfamilies, genera, species or serotypes. Another such example may be evaluation for different species of virus as the different viral types.
Adeno-associated virus and adenovirus in particular each includes many identified serotypes, and a fluorescent antibody stain may target a single serotype or two or more different serotypes of an adenovirus or adeno-associated virus viral type. For example a fluorescent antibody stain may be monoclonal and target a particular epitope associated with only one serotype or may target a particular epitope that is common to two or more different serotypes. As another example, a fluorescent antibody stain may by polyclonal and capable of binding with different epitopes of different serotypes.
In some applications, virus-size particles of a viral type of one of adenovirus or adeno-associated virus may be targeted as a first viral type and virus-size particles of the other viral type may be targeted as a second viral type.
In some applications, virus-size particles of a baculovirus viral type may be targeted as a second viral type, for example in applications involving virus-like particles of an adenovirus viral type or an adeno-associated virus viral type made using a baculovirus gene expression system.
Baculovirus are a family of rod-shaped viruses up to 300 nm long, and which are particularly useful to produce recombinant proteins. Baculovirus normally infect and replicate in insect cells, and recombinant protein expression in insect cell systems using a genetically modified Baculovirus expression vector is a well-known technique. Baculovirus can also be genetically modified to include mammalian promoters to drive recombinant protein expression in mammalian cells. Modified baculovirus systems including mammalian promoters that are useful for transfer of inserted genetic material by transduction to mammalian cells are often referred to as the “BacMam” system for Baculovirus gene transfer into Mammalian cells.
Baculovirus is also very useful in the production of virus-like particles, which may include a variety of viral proteins. Example viral types that may be expressed in such virus-like particles include an adenovirus viral type or an adeno-associated virus viral type. Depending upon the particular process or processing stage within a process, baculovirus may be a desirable product or an undesirable contaminant. In either case, accurate monitoring and quantification of baculovirus at various points in a production operation are important for process and product control. The presence of fetal bovine serum (FBS) in some baculovirus protein expression systems (e.g., the BacMam system) may significantly complicate differentiation of fluorescent signals from stained protein in viral particles of interest from a high level of background fluorescent signals from stained serum protein when using the prior technique of using a combination of nonspecific, fluorogenic protein and nucleic acid stains.
The fluorescent antibody stain may bind with the viral particle directly or indirectly through an epitope. By directly binding through an epitope it is meant that a site on the antibody portion of the fluorescent antibody stain binds with the epitope. By indirectly binding through an epitope, it is meant that there is an intermediate binding unit between the epitopes and the fluorescent antibody stain. For example, the intermediate binding unit may be a different antibody (different than the antibody of the fluorescent antibody stain) that binds directly with the epitopes and the fluorescent antibody stain is bound to that antibody, thereby binding the fluorescent antibody stain in the unassociated labeled particle.
The fluorescent antibody stain may include a fluorescent component, for example a fluorophore, that is excited by any convenient excitation radiation and with an appropriate Stokes shift between the absorption spectrum of the excitation radiation and the emission spectrum of the fluorescent emission. The fluorophore may be provided by a fluorescent dye molecule linked, or conjugated, with another molecule in a form in which the dye is in a fixed, highly fluorescent state. A fluorescent dye may be conjugated directly with an antibody or may be conjugated with another component that is then attached to the antibody (e.g. biotinylated fluorescent antibody stain, discussed below).
The excitation radiation for a fluorescent antibody stain, or for other fluorescent stains that may also be used, may be in any suitable wavelength range or ranges for the fluorescent stain or stains being used. When multiple fluorescent stains are used, it is preferred that the emission spectra of the different fluorescent stains do not overlap or only minimally overlap so that individual detection is facilitated. Excitation radiation may often be in the visible or near-visible spectrum (e.g., ultraviolet through near infrared). Some example sources for excitation radiation include LED's and lasers providing a narrow light spectrum. A variety of small lasers are available for use as an excitation radiation source. Some example lasers are green light lasers, for example green He—Ne or Nd:YAG lasers. Other possible lasers to provide excitation radiation are discussed, for example, in: Methods in Molecular Biology, Vol. 263, Flow Cytometry Protocols, 2d. ed., Edited by Hawley, Teresa S. and Haley Robert G., Humana Press, 2004, Chapter 23 “Small Lasers in Flow Cytometry”, by Telford, William G., pages 399-418; Methods in Cell Biology, Vol. 102, Recent Advances in Cytometry, Part A: Instrumentation, Methods, Edited by Darzynkiewicz, Zbigniew et al., Elsevier, 2011, Chapter 15 “Lasers in Flow Cytometry”, by Telford, William G., pages 375-407; and Telford, William G. et al., Supercontinuum white light lasers for flow cytometry, Cytometry A. 2009 May, 75(5): 450-459. doi:10.1002/cyto.a.20687.
In some preferred implementations when two or more different fluorescent stains are utilized for a single fluid sample, for example to evaluate for different biological material components, which may be different viral types (e.g., adenovirus as one viral type and adeno-associated virus as a second viral type, or vice versa; or one of adenovirus or adeno-associated virus as one viral type and a second viral type being other than an adenovirus or adeno-associated virus viral type; or two viral types being different adeno-associated virus serotypes or being different adenovirus serotypes), the multiple fluorescent stains may preferably be excited by the same narrow-spectrum excitation radiation, although in other implementations multiple excitation radiation sources or a single source (e.g., tunable white light source) providing multiple excitation radiation spectra may be used provided that the fluorescent emission responses of the different fluorescent stains are distinguishable from such different excitation radiation spectra. Some example excitation radiation for many applications may be narrow spectra including one of the following wavelengths: 350 nanometers, 405 nanometers, 488 nanometers, 532 nanometers, 543 nanometers, 561 nanometers, and 635 nanometers. The fluorescent emission spectra may include any narrow spectra, typically in the visible and near-visible spectrum. It is often preferable that a fluorescent emission spectrum of a fluorescent stain, including a fluorescent antibody stain, has a significant Stokes shift in peak wavelength relative to the peak excitation spectrum wavelength for that fluorescent stain. The Stokes shift in wavelength may be at least 5 nanometers, at least 10 nanometers, at least 20 nanometers or more. Many fluorescent stains have a Stokes shift in a range of 10 to 50 nanometers, although some may have much larger Stokes shifts.
Some example antibodies for use in fluorescent antibody stains for some viral types are shown in Table 1.
An antibody of a fluorescent antibody stain may be a pan-serotype antibody (binding with multiple serotypes). The polyclonal M149 product from Takara is an anti-human influenza A, B rabbit polyclonal antibody that is pan-serotype across various influenza virus serotypes, including Type B influenza virus and various serotypes of Type A influenza virus. Monoclonal antibody of fluorescent antibody stain may be serotype specific or may be pan-serotype to some degree. For example, ADK8/9 listed in Table 1 is pan-serotype for AAV-8 and AAV-9 serotypes. As another example, for adenovirus an antibody in a fluorescent antibody stain for example binds to a capsid protein that is present across multiple serotypes. This is the case, for example, for 8C4 listed in Table 1, which binds with hexon protein that is present across multiple adenovirus serotypes.
A wide variety of fluorophores may be used in the fluorescent antibody stains. A fluorophore may be attached directly to the antibody or through a linking group. Such a linking group may be a biotin-derived linking group on a biotinylated antibody through which a fluorophore conjugated streptavidin may be bound to the antibody. For convenience of reference, such fluorescent antibody stains having a fluorophore attached to a biotinylated antibody may be referred to herein as a biotinylated fluorescent antibody stain. Table 2 shows some example fluorescent dye products in the Alexa Fluor product line (Life Technologies, Thermo Fisher Scientific) that may be used in conjugated form as fluorophores and peak excitation (absorption) wavelength and emission wavelength for conjugates of the dye molecules. The Stokes shift of the conjugate is the difference between these wavelengths:
Some example dyes for use as fluorophores in a conjugate form with a green laser excitation light source, useful with a variety of antibodies to make a fluorescent antibody stain, are shown in Table 3.
Any of the example dyes listed in Tables 2 and 3, or other dyes, may be used in a fluorescent antibody stain with any of the example antibodies listed in Table 1.
The fluid sample may include only a single fluorescent stain, which would be a fluorescent antibody stain. In alternative implementations, the fluid sample may include multiple fluorescent stains (i.e., two or more than two different fluorescent stains), at least one of which is a fluorescent antibody stain. When multiple fluorescent stains are used, two or more than two of the fluorescent stains may be fluorescent antibody stains and/or one or more than one may be a fluorescent stain other than a fluorescent antibody stain, for example a non-specific fluorogenic stain. One example of such a non-specific fluorogenic stain is a stain for labeling nucleic acid. By non-specific fluorescent stain it is meant a fluorescent stain that is not specific as to viral type. An example of one non-specific fluorogenic stain for nucleic acid that is excitable by a green laser light source is POPO-3 from Life Technologies (Thermo Fisher Scientific). When using multiple different fluorescent antibody stains, the different fluorescent antibody stains may be directed toward identifying different viral types of viral particles, in which case each of the different fluorescent antibody stains will be capable of binding with different viral particles of different viral types to form different unassociated labeled particles. As one example, a first fluorescent antibody stain may bind with adeno-associated virus while a second fluorescent antibody stain may bind with adenovirus, or vice versa. Multiple different fluorescent antibody stains may also be used to bind with multiple different virus serotypes. As one example, a first fluorescent antibody stain may bind with a first adeno-associated virus serotype and a second fluorescent antibody stain may bind with a second adeno-associated virus serotype. As another example, a first fluorescent antibody stain may bind with a first adenovirus serotype and a second fluorescent antibody stain may bind with a second adenovirus serotype. The flow cytometry may include detecting radiation from the flow cell within different wavelength ranges of the different fluorescent antibody stains to identify detection events indicative of passage of the different unassociated labeled particle types through the flow cell, which are indicative of the presence of the different viral types.
The mixing of biological material for evaluation with the fluorescent antibody stain may be performed in a liquid medium, for example in a buffered aqueous liquid. During the mixing, the fluorescent antibody stain may be provided in a form in which the fluorophore is already attached to the antibody or the fluorescent antibody stain may form in situ during the mixing from precursor components provided to the mixing. The fluorescent antibody stain may form in solution from such precursors during the mixing and then attach to unassociated particles and/or may form on the unassociated particles to form unassociated labeled particles. For example, in the case of a biotinylated fluorescent antibody stain, the biotinylated antibody stain may be pre-prepared and provided to the mixing in the pre-prepared state, such as dispersed in a buffered solution, or precursors for the biotinylated antibody stain may be provided separately to the mixing and may first be contacted during the mixing to form the biotinylated antibody in situ. As one example, a pre-prepared biotinylated antibody and a pre-prepared fluorophore:streptavidin conjugate may be separately supplied to the mixing, for example in separate buffered solution formulations. The pre-prepared biotinylated antibody and pre-prepared fluorophore:streptavidin conjugate may then react to form the biotinylated fluorescent antibody stain. Such reaction may occur prior to binding of the antibody to an unassociated particle and/or such reaction may occur after a biotinylated fluorescent antibody has already become bound to an unassociated particle, in which case the biotinylated fluorescent antibody stain may form directly on the unassociated particle, thereby forming an unassociated labeled particle with the formation of the biotinylated fluorescent antibody stain. When providing such precursors separately to the mixing, the precursors may be added in appropriate proportions to provide a desired concentration of the resulting fluorescent antibody stain and preferably without a lot of residual, unassociated fluorophore:streptavidin conjugate that would add significant additional background fluorescence.
The virus-size particles targeted for detection may be viral particles. By viral particles it is meant individual particles of virus (e.g., virions) or virus-like particles and viral type refers to the particular type of virus or virus-like particles associated with that type of virus. As will be appreciated virus-like particles are particles that are similar to a virus, but that are not infectious because they are lacking in a complete virus make-up, such as viral genetic material. The virus-size particles targeted for detection may be exosomes or other nanoparticles that have an epitope for binding with an antibody.
By virus-size particle or particle of a virus size, it is meant a particle of a size on the order of individual, free virus particles, or virions, which are typically in a range of from tens of nanometers to hundreds of nanometers. In some implementations, virus-size particles may have a size in a range having a lower limit of 10 nanometers, 20 nanometers, 40 nanometers, 60 nanometers, 80 nanometers and an upper limit of 2 microns, 1 micron, 600 nanometers, 300 nanometers, 200 nanometers, 100 nanometers, 75 nanometers or 50 nanometers provided the upper limit is larger than the lower limit. In some implementations virus-size particles may have any one or more of length dimension, diameter dimension or maximum cross dimension within such a range. By a particle being unassociated, it is meant that the particle is not part of a larger particle structure that is larger than virus size, for example the unassociated particle is not within a host cell or bound to a microsphere or part of an agglomerate that is larger than virus size. Adenovirus has a generally icosahedral shape of about 90 to 100 nanometers in diameter. Adeno-associated virus has an icosahedral shape on the order of about 20 nanometers in size (diameter). An unassociated labeled particle will be somewhat larger due to the presence of attached antibody stains relative to the unlabeled virus-size particle (e.g., unlabeled virion or virus-like particle). Even with the bound fluorescent antibody stain, the unassociated labeled particles are of virus size, and may often have a maximum cross dimension that is larger than the maximum cross-dimension of unlabeled virus-size particle that is in a range having a lower limit of 10 nanometers, 20 nanometers or 30 nanometers and an upper limit of 200 nanometers, 150 nanometers, 100 nanometers, 50 nanometers or 25 nanometers, with the upper limit being larger than the lower limit. For example, it is common for individual antibody molecules to be of a size on the order of about 5 to 10 nanometers may increase the maximum cross-dimension of the labeled particle by twice that amount, or by about 10 to 20 nanometers, relative to the unlabeled virus-size particles. As will be appreciated, indirectly bound antibody stain may increase the maximum cross dimension by a larger amount as a result of intermediate binding groups. With the extremely small size of adeno-associated virus, the unassociated labeled particle including n adeno-associated virus particle with bound fluorescent antibody stain may, for example, often have a maximum cross-dimension (e.g., diameter) on the order of 2 to 4 times as large as the adeno-associated virus particle to which the fluorescent antibody stain is bound.
The biological material to be evaluated may be obtained from any source. Some example sources include manufacturing operations in which virus are cultured, genetically modified viral particles are produced (e.g., virus-like particles) such as for alternative forms of vaccines, in which genetically modified viruses are produced for expression of recombinant proteins, or for delivery of genetic material for virotherapy, or in which batches of purified virus-size particles are prepared to test exclusion limits in biological fluids manufacturing. The method may be performed in association with or as part of such a manufacturing operation. The biological material may be the result of prior processing of an initial biological material, which may be a crude material that has been purified or otherwise processed to prepare a more suitable sample for flow cytometry evaluation. The biological material may be provided for mixing with the fluorescent antibody stain in any convenient form, including in an aqueous buffered solution, for example a phosphate buffered solution, which may include one or more additives or other reagents useful for processing. Likewise, the fluorescent antibody stain may be provided in any convenient form, including in a buffered solution, for example a phosphate buffered solution or other buffered solution. The biological material may be provided in a purified form such as may result from purification processing. Such purification processing may be as disclosed in International Patent Publication WO2014/210370A1, the entire contents of which are incorporated herein by reference. The biological material may be provided for mixing with the fluorescent antibody stain in a Tris-HCl buffer solution as disclosed for use in flow cytometry in WO2014/210370A1, or a different buffered solution. The flow cytometer may, for example, be a Virus Counter® 2100 flow cytometer or preferably a Virus Counter® 3100 flow cytometer (ViroCyt, Inc.). Such flow cytometers are specifically designed to operate at very low sample flow rates to evaluate fluid samples for the presence of virus-size particles. Other flow cytometers, although less preferred, may also be used that provide adequate focusing of virus-size particles in the center of a flow of fluid sample for investigation in the flow cell. Some examples of other flow cytometers equipped with a green light laser source for excitation radiation are Attune® NxT (Thermo Fisher Scientific), CyFlow® Space (Sysmex) and S1000EXi (Stradedigm). Some examples of other flow cytometers that may include an excitation radiation source other than a green light laser are ACSCalibur™ (Becton Dickinson), BD LSRFortessa™ (Becton Dickinson), BD FACSCanto™ (Becton Dickinson), FACSVerse (Becton Dickinson), Gallios™ (Beckman Coulter), CyAn™ ADP (Beckman Coulter), SE520EXi (Stratedigm) and SP6800 (SONY). As noted above, the biological material in the fluid sample may be in a purified form for enhanced flow cytometry evaluation, and which may be the result of purification of a crude sample of biological material according to processing disclosed in WO2014/210370A1.
Preparing a fluid sample may include, prior to the mixing of biological material for evaluation with the fluorescent antibody stain, purifying a crude sample of biological material to prepare the biological material for the fluid sample as subjected to the flow cytometry. The purifying may include filtering out particles of larger-size impurities of the crude sample. Such larger-size impurities may include particles larger than virus size. Such larger-size impurities may include for example, cell debris, bacteria, mycobacteria protein aggregates, lipids, lipid assemblies, lipid-protein assemblies, lecithins, lipid-protein aggregates, liposomes, ribosomes, vesicles, protein-nucleic acid complexes or other materials. The filtering may include filtration with a filter separation size, or filtration size, that is not larger than 2 microns, not larger than 1.5 microns, not larger than 1.3 microns, not larger than 1 micron, not larger than 0.9 micron, not larger than 0.8 micron or not larger than 0.75 micron. The separation size may often be at least 0.05 micron, at least 0.1 micron, at least 0.3 micron, at least 0.4 micron, at least 0.5 micron, at least 0.6 micron or at least 0.7 micron. The purifying may include chromatographic removal of at least a portion of smaller-size impurities that may be smaller than virus size. Such smaller-size impurities may include, for example proteins and/or nucleic acids, and material derived from viruses, such as fragments or debris from viruses. The chromatographic removal may include spin chromatography in a centrifuge. The spin chromatography may include centrifuging the sample to be purified, which may be in a buffer solution, in the presence of chromatographic media that captures smaller-size impurities. Supernatant including remaining biological material may be further processed, such as by the filtering, or provided directly to be mixed with a fluorescent antibody stain.
In other implementations, the fluid sample may include a sample of biological material in a crude form that that has not been purified or has not been purified to a significant degree. Even using such a crude sample of biological material, specificity of the fluorescent antibody stain peak signals of labeled virus-size particles may be distinguishable from background readings.
In some preferred implementations the flow cytometry may include flowing the fluid sample through the flow cytometer flow cell at a very low fluid sample flow rate. Such a sample fluid flow rate may be in a range of from 250 to 3000 nanoliters per minute. As noted above, flow cytometers with larger flow rates may also be used that are capable of focusing virus-size particles in the center of a flow of fluid sample for investigation in the flow cell. Such flow cytometers may, for example, have fluid sample flows of up to 1 milliliter per minute. In preferred implementations, the flow cytometry may include hydrodynamically focusing flow of the fluid sample with a sheath fluid and flowing the fluid sample and the sheath fluid through the flow cell. Moreover, in some more preferred implementations, the flow cytometry or a flow cytometer used for such flow cytometry (e.g., Virus Counter® 3100 flow cytometer) may employ evaluation of particle attributes from fluorescent emission signals as described in international patent application no. PCT/US2015/033907 (published as WO2015/187783) entitled FLOW CYTOMETER PEAK SIGNAL IDENTIFICATION EMPLOYING DYNAMIC THRESHOLDING, the entire contents of which is incorporated herein by reference. Such, evaluation uses a dynamic threshold determination for identifying peak signal threshold for particle counting, and which is particularly advantageous for use with the methods disclosed herein for quantitatively evaluating the labeled unassociated particles of virus size. The Virus Counter® 3100 flow cytometer has been found to have advantageous capabilities for differentiating fluorescent response signals from unassociated labeled particles of virus size from background signals of residual unbound fluorescent antibody stain, identifying fluorescent response detection events indicative of passage of an unassociated labeled particle of virus size through the flow cell of the flow cytometer, counting such unassociated labeled particles in the fluid sample based on such detection events, and calculating and displaying concentration of the unassociated labeled particles in the flow sample in real time relative to passage of the fluid sample through the flow cell. The Virus Counter® 3100 flow cytometer monitors, measures and carefully controls fluid sample flow rate to the flow cell, and unlike other flow cytometers uses integrated measured flow rate data over time to determine sample fluid volume passing through the flow cell for concentration calculation purposes. Additional information is provided in WO2010/132053, the contents of which are incorporated herein by reference.
In some implementations the flow cytometry may include counting the detection events as occurrences of individual ones of the unassociated labeled particles passing through the flow cell to determine a count for unassociated labeled particles in a volume of the fluid sample passing through the flow cell; determining the volume of fluid sample passing through the flow cell that corresponds with the count; and determining a concentration of the unassociated labeled particles in the volume of the fluid sample passing through the flow cell using the count of unassociated labeled particles. Such counting may be performed in real time relative to the detecting of the radiation corresponding with the detection event, and determining of the concentration may also be performed in real time relative to passage of the volume of the fluid sample through the flow cell. Determining the volume of fluid sample passing through the flow cell may include measuring in real time with a flow sensor the flow rate of the fluid sample to the flow cell and integrating resulting measured flow rate data over time. Identification of detection events indicative of passage through the flow cell of the unassociated labeled particles may be determined in the absence of correlating with light scatter detection information. Flow cytometry operation control and data acquisition and analysis (e.g., identifying detection events, counting, determining volume, determining concentration, measuring flow rate data, integrating measured flow rate data) may be performed by an electronic controller, for example using a Virus Counter® 3100 flow cytometer.
The fluid sample may include multiple fluorescent stains (two or more fluorescent stains), at least one of which is a fluorescent antibody stain. In some implementations a fluorescent stain may be a first fluorescent stain having a first fluorescent emission and the fluid sample may include a different second fluorescent stain (and possibly also a different third or even more different fluorescent stains) that has a different second fluorescent emission. The first and second fluorescent emissions may be separately detected. First detection events for the first fluorescent emission may be indicative of a first particle property (e.g., presence of an epitope) and second detection events for the second fluorescent emission may be indicative of a second particle property (e.g., presence of a different epitope or some other property). The different properties of the first and second detection events may be in relation to both properties being present on a single virus-size particle (in which case first and second detection events will temporally coincide with the passage of a single particle through the flow cell) or may be in relation to each of the properties being present on different particles (in which case the first and second detection events will not temporally coincide). Such first and second fluorescent stains may or may not be excited by the same wavelengths of excitation radiation, although for simplicity of operation it is convenient to have both fluorescent stains excited by the same narrow spectra of excitation radiation.
In some implementations, a first fluorescent stain may be a fluorescent antibody stain and the second fluorescent stain may be a stain for nucleic acid, which may be a non-specific fluorogenic stain. Detection events for the second fluorescent emission may be indicative of passage of particles of virus size containing nucleic acid stained with the fluorescent nucleic acid stain. Results of the separate detecting of the first and second fluorescent stains may be compared for identification of occurrences of a said first detection event that temporally coincides with a said second detection event, which may be a further indication of passage through the flow cell of an unassociated labeled particle including both the epitope and the nucleic acid properties, for example which may be indicative of an in-tact virus particle. The comparison of the first and second detection events alternatively or additionally may include identification of occurrences of a first detection event that does not temporally coincide with a second detection event, which may for example be indicative of a virus-like particle or an exosome (or other nanoparticle) having the epitope property but not the nucleic acid property, because of the absence of genetic material. The comparison of the first and second detection events may alternatively or additionally include identification of occurrences of a second detection event that does not temporally coincide with a first detection event, for example which may be indicative of an exosome (or other nanoparticle) including the nucleic acid property but not the epitope property.
When using multiple fluorescent stains, there may be multiple fluorescent antibody stains. For example a first fluorescent antibody stain with a first fluorescent emission may be capable of binding with a first epitope and a different second fluorescent antibody stain with a second fluorescent emission may be capable of finding with a different second epitope. A third or more additional fluorescent antibody stains and/or one or more non-specific stains (e.g., non-specific nucleic acid stain) may also be used, although the flow cytometer used will need to be provided with capability to discriminate all of the different fluorescent emission spectra. The first and second fluorescent emissions may each be separately detected. The first detection events of radiation of the first florescent emission may be indicative of passage of unassociated labeled particles of virus size including particles of virus size including the first epitope and second detection events of radiation of the second fluorescent emission may be indicative of passage of unassociated labeled particles of virus size including particles of virus size including the second epitope. In the case when a virus-size particle has both the first and second epitopes, first and second detection events will temporally coincide, whereas when there are two different kinds of virus-size particles with one kind having the first epitope and the other kind having the second epitope, the first and second detection events will not temporally coincide. For example, a first epitope may be indicative of particles of a first viral type and the second epitope may be indicative of particles of a different second viral type. Alternatively, the first and second epitopes may both be indicative of the same viral type, for example when a viral particle includes both the first and second epitopes. For example, a first viral type may be an adeno-associated virus viral type and the second viral type may be for a different virus (e.g., adenovirus or baculovirus). Or, for example, a first viral type may be an adenovirus and the second viral type may be for a different virus (e.g., adeno-associated virus or baculovirus). As another example, the first and second viral types may be different adeno-associated virus serotypes or the first and second viral types may be different adenovirus serotypes.
In order to obtain even more specificity in relation to contents of a biological material sample under evaluation, different portions of the sample may be separately evaluated by flow cytometry with different fluorescent antibody stains used in each of the different fluid samples subjected to the different flow cytometry evaluations. In this way, a plurality of portions of a biological material sample may be processed to make a matrix of different fluid samples for flow cytometry with different combinations of fluorescent stains to test for different combinations of particle properties in the biological material sample. Each of the different fluid samples may, for example include different combinations of fluorescent antibody stain with a non-specific fluorogenic stain (e.g., nucleic acid stain) and/or with multiple fluorescent antibody stains. Such matrix-type evaluation may, for example, be used to prepare and test by flow cytometry one or more than one differently labeled fluid samples to evaluate for presence of a desired virus-size product particle and/or to evaluate for presence of undesired contaminant particles of virus size.
The method of evaluation including flow cytometry may be part of, or may be performed in connection with, a method for manufacturing a product comprising virus-size particles. Such manufacturing may include: generating the virus-size particles in a biological production operation; harvesting from the biological production operation crude product comprising the virus-size particles; and purifying at least a portion of material of the crude product to prepare a purified product including the virus-size particles. Such a purified product may be a final product or may be an intermediate product that may be subjected to further processing. Flow cytometry evaluation performed as part of or in connection with the manufacturing may include collecting a biological material sample from a stage of the production processing during which virus particles would be expected to be present in the biological material and evaluating the sample for presence of particles of virus size having a particular epitope, including subjecting at least a portion of the sample to flow cytometry. Such evaluation including flow cytometry may for example include any of the features or any combination of the features noted above. Such manufacturing may include performing the collecting multiple times to collect different said biological material samples to be evaluated from multiple different stages of the manufacturing and performing an evaluation including flow cytometry on each such collected biological material sample to be evaluated. In this way, product yield and quality may be verified through the various stages of manufacture processing and processing problems may be quickly identified, analyzed and corrective action taken. For example, the collecting may be performed at a first stage during the generating or harvesting and at a second stage during or after the purifying.
The method of evaluation including flow cytometry may be performed in an environment that is not a part of or in connection with such manufacturing. For example, the method may be performed in connection with research or diagnostic activities.
One application for the method disclosed herein is evaluating a biological material sample for virus-like particles when the biological material sample is suspected of including virus-like particles. This may be the case for example during or in connection with manufacture operations to make virus-like particles or products including virus-like particles, for example for use in vaccines or as a carrier (vector).
One application for the method disclosed herein is evaluating a biological material for in-tact virus particles. Such virus detection may be to evaluate for virus contaminants and/or to evaluate for presence of desired virus products. In one variation, the virus may be a virus programmed for virotherapy. Such a virus may be for example, an anticancer oncolytic virus, a viral vector for gene therapy or immunotherapy.
Another aspect of this disclosure is a composition in the form of a fluid formulation, such as for a fluid sample in preparation for flow cytometry evaluation. The fluid formulation comprises:
an aqueous liquid medium;
unassociated labeled particles of virus size in the aqueous liquid medium at a concentration of from 1×105 to 15×109 of the unassociated labeled particles per milliliter, wherein the unassociated labeled particles each includes a virus-size particle having a particular epitope indicative of an adenovirus viral type or an adeno-associated virus viral type and a fluorescent antibody stain specific for binding, directly or indirectly with the epitope; and
a concentration of the fluorescent antibody stain that is in an unassociated state in the aqueous liquid medium not bound in the unassociated labeled particles in a range of from 0.25 (or more) microgram per milliliter to 10 (or less) micrograms per milliliter.
A number of feature refinements and additional features are applicable to this and other aspects of this disclosure. These feature refinements and additional features may be used individually or in any combination within the subject matter of this aspect or any other aspect of this disclosure. As such, each of the following features may, but are not required to be, used with any other feature or a combination of features of this aspect or any other aspect of this disclosure.
Such a fluid formulation may be or have any feature or features described with respect to the fluid sample of the method aspect. Any of the aqueous liquid medium, unassociated labeled particles and concentration and components thereof, virus-size particle, epitope, fluorescent antibody stain and concentration of unassociated concentration of fluorescent antibody stain may be or have any feature or features described in relation to the fluid sample of the method aspect.
Other features of this and other aspects will be further understood with reference to the drawings and in view of the discussion provided below, to example implementations described below and to the claims.
The fluid sample 104 of
In the examples below, flow cytometry tests are performed on a Virus Counter® 3100 flow cytometer (ViroCyt, Inc.). Plots in the Figures referred to in these examples that plot virus particle concentration versus dilution factor are log-log plots. Flow cytometry tests using fluorescent antibody stain are performed without washing stained virus samples following staining and without detection of light scatter to assist with particle detection. Except as otherwise stated below, fluorescent antibody stains in these examples generally include an average number of attached dye molecules (fluorophores) per antibody molecule in the fluorescent antibody stain (F/P ratio) of 3 to 7. Concentrations of fluorescent antibody stains provided in these examples are total concentrations in the samples. As will be appreciated, some of this fluorescent antibody stain attaches to and stains virus particles in the samples, but most of fluorescent antibody stain in the samples will typically be in an unbound state when the samples are subjected to flow cytometry. All sample fluids in these examples are prepared to a pH within a range of pH 7 to pH8 with buffered solution.
In Examples 1 and 2 below flow cytometry tests are performed for evaluation of adeno-associated virus serotype 2 (AAV-2) using a fluorescent antibody stain including anti-AAV-2 monoclonal antibody A20 (PROGEN Biotechnik) conjugated with Alexa Fluor 532 dye (identified below as CF-A20 antibody stain). A20 is an antibody for a conformational epitope of assembled capsid of AAV-2 and AAV-3.
Comparative flow cytometry tests are performed on AAV-2 test formulations using the fluorescent antibody stain CF-A20 relative to controls of AAV-5 and AAV-9 which are not antigenic for the A20 antibody. Two different AAV-2 test formulations are prepared using AAV-2 obtained from different commercial sources. For all tests, the total concentration of the CF-A20 antibody stain (both bound and unbound to AAV-2) in the test solutions is about 2.5 micrograms per milliliter. Five test solutions are prepared at different dilutions of stock virus solution for each for each dilution series, to provide five different virus concentrations for testing in buffered solution. For a specificity control, the fluorescent antibody stain was tested against the AAV-5 and AAV-9 serotypes, as well as buffered solution including CF-A20 but absent virus of any type.
Results are summarized in
Flow cytometry dilution series using a variety of antibody stain concentrations are performed against a titration of AAV-2 solution containing about 1×105 to 1×108 AAV-2 particles per milliliter. Each dilution series includes flow cytometry of 200 microliter samples prepared at different dilutions of the stock AAV-2 solution, with all samples in each dilution series containing the same concentration of the fluorescent antibody stain. Three dilution series are run at antibody stain concentrations of about 0.91, 1.82 and 2.73 micrograms of CF-A20 antibody stain per milliliter of sample. Flow cytometry tests are performed to detect and evaluate for fluorescent emissions from stained AAV-2. Results of the flow cytometry tests for each dilution series are summarized in
In Examples 3 and 4 below flow cytometry tests are performed to evaluate for multiple adenovirus serotypes using as the fluorescent antibody stain an 8C4 monoclonal antibody-CF 532 conjugate (identified below CF-8C4). The 8C4 antibody is specific for the hexon protein of adenovirus, and is effective across different adenovirus serotypes (tested against at least serotypes 2 through 6).
Comparative flow cytometry tests are performed on adenovirus test formulations using the fluorescent antibody stain CF-8C4 on two different test formulations containing different adenovirus serotypes. One test formulation included adenovirus serotype 4 and the other test formulation included adenovirus serotype 5. For all tests, the total concentration of the CF-8C4 antibody stain (both bound and unbound to adenovirus) in the test solutions is about 2.5 micrograms per milliliter. For each test formulation four test solutions are prepared at different dilutions of stock adenovirus solution for each for the dilution series, to provide four different virus concentrations for testing in buffered solution for each test formulation.
Results are summarized in
Comparative flow cytometry tests are performed on adenovirus test formulations using the same fluorescent antibody stain as used in Example 1 (CF-8C4) relative to controls of an influenza virus and lentivirus, which are not antigenic for the 8C4 antibody. The adenovirus used in the test formulations is serotype 4. For all tests, the total concentration of the CF-8C4 antibody stain (both bound and unbound to adenovirus) in the test solutions is about 2.5 micrograms per milliliter. Six test solutions are prepared at different dilutions of stock adenovirus solution for each for the dilution series, to provide six different virus concentrations for testing in buffered solution. For a specificity control, the fluorescent antibody stain was tested against unrelated viruses of influenza and lentivirus types.
Results are summarized in
Some example implementation combinations, and for various types of implementation applications, which may be the subject of claims with or without additional features as disclosed above, are summarized as follows:
1. A method for evaluating a biological material sample for unassociated virus-size particles having a particular epitope of a viral type selected from the group consisting of an adenovirus viral type or an adeno-associated virus viral type, the method comprising:
subjecting to flow cytometry a fluid sample comprising at least a portion of the biological material sample, wherein the fluid sample comprises a fluorescent antibody stain capable of binding, directly or indirectly, with the particular epitope, the flow cytometry comprising:
2. A method according to example implementation combination 1, wherein the biological material sample is suspected of including virus-like particles.
3. A method according to example implementation combination 2, wherein the virus-size particles are the virus-like particles.
4. A method according to example implementation combination 3, wherein the biological material comprises virus particles of a different viral type than the virus-like particles.
5. A method according to example implementation combination 4, wherein:
the fluorescent antibody stain is a first fluorescent antibody stain, the epitope is a first epitope, the unassociated labeled particles are first unassociated labeled particles, the fluorescent emission is a first fluorescent emission, the detecting is first detecting, the detection event is a first detection event and the virus particles have a second epitope that is different than the first epitope;
the fluid sample includes a second fluorescent antibody stain different than the first fluorescent antibody stain and capable of binding, directly or indirectly, with the second epitope, the second fluorescent antibody stain having a second fluorescent emission response to the excitation radiation that is different than the first fluorescent emission response; and
the flow cytometry comprises second detecting for second radiation from the flow cell within a wavelength range of the second fluorescent emission and evaluating the detected second radiation for detection events indicative of passage through the flow cell of second unassociated labeled particles of virus size including a said virus particle and the second fluorescent antibody stain.
6. A method according to either one of example implementation combination 4 or implementation combination 5, wherein the virus particles are of a baculovirus viral type.
7. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 4-6, wherein the epitope is a first epitope, the flow cytometry is first flow cytometry, the fluid sample is a first fluid sample including a first portion of the of the biological material sample, the unassociated labeled particles are first unassociated labeled particles and the excitation radiation is first excitation radiation, and the method comprises:
subjecting to flow cytometry a second fluid sample comprising a second portion of the biological material sample, wherein the fluid sample comprises a second fluorescent antibody stain that is different than the first antibody stain and is capable of binding, directly or indirectly, with a second epitope that is different than the first epitope, the second flow cytometry comprising:
8. A method according to example implementation combination 7, wherein:
the first and second fluid samples each includes at least two different fluorescent antibody stains for binding, directly or indirectly, with two different epitopes; and
the first and second fluid samples each includes at least one fluorescent antibody stain that is not in the other said fluid sample.
9. A method according to example implementation combination 8, wherein the at least two fluorescent antibody stains of each said fluid sample are targeted to detecting at least two different types of particles of virus size in the said fluid sample and at least one said type of particle is different between the first sample fluid and the second sample fluid.
10. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 4-9, wherein the biological material sample is a sample collected from a stage of a production operation for producing the virus-like particles during which the virus-like particles are expected to be present in the biological material.
11. A method for manufacturing a product comprising virus-like particles, the method comprising:
production processing to prepare a purified product including the virus-like particles, the production processing including:
collecting a biological material sample from a stage of the production processing during which virus-like particles would be expected to be present in the biological material;
evaluating the sample for presence of particles of virus size having a particular epitope, the evaluating comprising performing the method according to any one of example implementation combinations 4-10.
12. A method according to example implementation combination 11, comprising performing the collecting multiple times to collect different said biological material samples to be evaluated from multiple different said stages and performing a said evaluating on each said collected biological material sample to be evaluated.
13. A method according to example implementation combination 12, wherein the multiple different said stages include at least a first stage during the generating or the harvesting and a second stage during or after the purifying.
14. A method according to example implementation combination 1, wherein the virus-size particles are virus particles of adenovirus or adeno-associated virus.
15. A method according to example implementation combination 14, wherein:
the fluorescent antibody stain is a first fluorescent stain, the fluorescent emission is a first fluorescent emission, the detecting is first detecting and the detection event is a first detection event;
the fluid sample includes a second fluorescent stain for nucleic acid, the second fluorescent stain having a second fluorescent emission response, different than the first fluorescent emission response, to the excitation radiation when attached to nucleic acid; and
the flow cytometry comprises second detecting for second radiation from the flow cell within a wavelength range of the second fluorescent emission and evaluating the detected second radiation for detection events indicative of passage of particles of virus size containing nucleic acid stained with the second fluorescent stain; and
comparing results for the first detecting and the second detecting for identification of occurrences of a said first detection event that temporally coincides with a said second detection event that is further indicative of passage through the flow cell of a said unassociated labeled particle including a said virus particle.
16. A method according to example implementation combination 15, wherein:
the fluorescent antibody stain is a first fluorescent antibody stain, the viral type is a first viral type, the epitope is a first epitope, the fluorescent emission is a first fluorescent emission, the detecting is first detecting and the detection event is a first detection event;
the fluid sample includes a second fluorescent antibody stain different than the first fluorescent antibody stain and capable of binding, directly or indirectly, with a second epitope different than the first epitope, the second fluorescent antibody stain having a second fluorescent emission response to the excitation radiation that is different than the first fluorescent emission response; and
the flow cytometry comprises second detecting for second radiation from the flow cell within a wavelength range of the second fluorescent emission and evaluating the detected second radiation for detection events indicative of passage through the flow cell of unassociated labeled particles of virus size including a particle of virus size with the second epitope and the second fluorescent antibody stain.
17. A method according to example implementation combination 16, wherein the first and the second epitope is indicative of a second viral type other than the first viral type.
18. A method according to example implementation combination 17, wherein the first viral type is an adeno-associated virus viral type and the second viral type is an adenovirus viral type.
19. A method according to example implementation combination 17, wherein the first viral type is the adenovirus viral type and the second viral type is an adeno-associated virus viral type.
20. A method according to example implementation combination 17, wherein the first epitope is indicative of a first adeno-associated virus serotype and the second epitope is indicative of a second, different adeno-associated virus serotype.
21. A method according to example implementation combination 17, wherein the first epitope is indicative of a first adenovirus serotype and the second epitope is indicative of a second, different adenovirus serotype.
22. A method according to example implementation combination 14, wherein the epitope is a first epitope, the flow cytometry is first flow cytometry, the fluid sample is a first fluid sample including a first portion of the of the biological material sample, the unassociated labeled particles are first unassociated labeled particles and the excitation radiation is first excitation radiation, and the method comprises:
subjecting to flow cytometry a second fluid sample comprising a second portion of the biological material sample, wherein the fluid sample comprises a second fluorescent antibody stain that is different than the first antibody stain and is capable of binding, directly or indirectly, with a second epitope that is different than the first epitope, the second flow cytometry comprising:
23. A method according to example implementation combination 22, wherein:
the first and second fluid samples each includes at least two different fluorescent antibody stains for binding, directly or indirectly, with two different epitopes; and
the first and second fluid samples each includes at least one fluorescent antibody stain that is not in the other said fluid sample.
24. A method according to example implementation combination 23, wherein the at least two fluorescent antibody stains of each said fluid sample are targeted to detecting at least two different types of particles of virus size in the said fluid sample and at least one said type of particle is different between the first sample fluid and the second sample fluid.
25. A method according to example implementation combination 24, wherein at least one of the fluorescent antibody stains in the first fluid sample is targeted to detecting an epitope of a first viral type of the adenovirus viral type or the adeno-associated virus viral type and at least one of the fluorescent antibody stains in the second fluid sample is targeted to detecting an epitope of a second viral type that is different than the first viral type.
26. A method according to example implementation combination 24, wherein either:
at least one of the fluorescent antibody stains in the first fluid sample is targeted to detecting an epitope of an adeno-associated virus serotype and at least one of the fluorescent antibody stains in the second fluid sample is targeted to detecting a different adeno-associated virus serotype; or
at least one of the fluorescent antibody stains in the first fluid sample is targeted to detecting an epitope of an adenovirus serotype and at least one of the fluorescent antibody stains in the second fluid sample is targeted to detecting a different adenovirus serotype.
27. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 14-26, wherein the biological material sample is a sample collected from a stage of a production operation for producing the virus particles during which the virus particles are expected to be present in the biological material.
28. A method for manufacturing a product comprising virus particles of adenovirus adeno-associated virus, the method comprising:
production processing to prepare a purified product including the virus particles, the production processing including:
collecting a biological material sample from a stage of the production processing during which the virus particles would be expected to be present in the biological material;
evaluating the sample for presence of particles of virus size having a particular epitope, the evaluating comprising performing the method according to any one of example implementation combinations 14-28.
29. A method according to example implementation combination 28, comprising performing the collecting multiple times to collect different said biological material samples to be evaluated from multiple different said stages and performing a said evaluating on each said collected biological material sample to be evaluated.
30. A method according to example implementation combination 29, wherein the multiple different said stages include at least a first stage during the generating or the harvesting and a second stage during or after the purifying.
31. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 28-29, wherein the adenovirus or adeno-associated virus of the virus particles has been modified to express recombinant protein.
32. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1-31, wherein the biological material in a said fluid sample is purified biological material with larger-size components removed to a filtration size of not larger than 2 microns, and the fluid sample comprises a concentration of fluorescent antibody stain not bound in the unassociated labeled particles in a range of from 0.25 microgram per milliliter to 10 micrograms per milliliter of the fluid sample.
33. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1-32, wherein a said fluid sample as fed to the flow cytometer includes a total concentration of the fluorescent antibody stain in a range of from 0.25 microgram per milliliter to 10 micrograms per milliliter.
34. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1-33, wherein the virus-size particles are of the adeno-associated virus viral type and the unassociated labeled particles have a maximum cross dimension in a range of from 10 nanometers to 100 nanometers.
35. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1-33, wherein the virus-size particles are of the adenovirus viral type and the unassociated labeled particles have a maximum cross dimension in a range of from 80 nanometers to 200 nanometers.
36. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1-35, wherein the excitation radiation includes radiation within a wavelength range of from 520 nanometers to 550 nanometers.
37. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1-36, wherein the fluorescent emission has a Stokes shift in wavelength of at least 10 nanometers.
38. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1-37, wherein a said fluid sample as fed to the flow cytometer comprises a concentration of the fluorescent antibody stain not bound in the unassociated labeled particles in a range of from 0.25 microgram per milliliter to 10 micrograms per milliliter.
39. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1-38, wherein a said fluid sample as fed to the flow cytometer has a concentration of the unassociated labeled particles in a range of from 1×105 to 1×109 particles per milliliter.
40. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1-39, wherein a said fluorescent antibody stain comprises a fluorophore attached to an antibody molecule.
41. A method according to example implementation combination 40, wherein a said fluorescent antibody stain comprises an average of from 3 to 8 of the fluorophores attached per antibody molecule of the fluorescent antibody stain.
42. A flow method according to either one of example implementation combination 40 or example implementation combination 41, wherein the antibody molecules are monoclonal.
43. A method according to either one of example implementation combination 40 or example implementation combination 41, wherein the antibody molecules are polyclonal.
44. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1-43, wherein the flow cytometry comprises flowing a said fluid sample through the flow cell at a fluid sample flow rate in a range of from 250 to 3000 nanoliters per minute.
45. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1-44, wherein the viral type is an adenovirus viral type.
46. A method according to example implementation combination 45, wherein a said fluorescent antibody stain comprises 8C4 monoclonal antibody.
47. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1-46, wherein the viral type is the adeno-associated virus viral type.
48. A method according to example combination 47, wherein a said fluorescent antibody stain includes one or more than one monoclonal antibody selected from the group consisting of anti-AAV-1 antibody (optionally ADK1a), antiAAV-2 antibody (optionally A20), anti-AAV-3 antibody (optionally A20), anti-AAV-4 antibody (optionally ADK4), anti-AAV-5 antibody (optionally ADK5a and/or ADK5b), anti-AAV-6 antibody (optionally ADK6), anti-AAV-8 antibody (optionally ADK8 and/or ADK8/9), anti-AAV-9 antibody (optionally ADK9 and/or ADK 8/9), and combinations thereof.
1A. A flow cytometry method for evaluating biological material for the presence of unassociated particles of a virus size having a particular epitope indicative of a virus type selected from the group consisting of an adenovirus viral type or an adeno-associated virus viral type, the method comprising:
preparing a fluid sample, comprising mixing biological material to be evaluated for presence of the unassociated particles with a fluorescent antibody stain, the fluorescent antibody stain being capable of binding, directly or indirectly, with the unassociated particles through the epitope to form unassociated labeled particles of virus size;
subjecting the fluid sample to flow cytometry, comprising:
2A. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 1A, wherein the preparing a fluid sample comprises, prior to the mixing, purifying a crude sample of biological material to prepare the biological material for the fluid sample as subjected to the flow cytometry, the purifying comprising filtering out particles of the crude sample at a filtration size of not larger than 2 microns and chromatographic removal of at least a portion of impurities smaller than virus size.
3A. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 2A, wherein the chromatographic removal comprises spin chromatography in a centrifuge.
4A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-3A, wherein the preparing a fluid sample comprises, after the mixing, not removing fluorescent antibody not bound in the unassociated labeled particles from the fluid sample prior to flow cytometry.
5A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combination 1A-4A, wherein the fluorescent antibody stain comprises a biotinylated antibody and a fluorophore conjugated streptavidin.
6A. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 5A, wherein the fluorophore conjugated streptavidin is attached to the biotinylated antibody when provided to the mixing.
7A. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 6A, wherein the fluorophore conjugated streptavidin and the biotinylated antibody are provided in separate formulations to the mixing and the fluorophore conjugated streptavidin attaches to the biotinylated antibody in solution during the mixing.
8A. A flow cytometry method for evaluating biological material for the presence of unassociated particles of a virus size having a particular epitope indicative of a viral type selected from the group consisting of an adenovirus viral type and an adeno-associated virus viral type, the method comprising:
subjecting a fluid sample comprising biological material to be evaluated and a fluorescent antibody stain to flow cytometry, fluorescent antibody stain being capable of binding, directly or indirectly, with the unassociated particles through the epitope to form unassociated labeled particles of virus size, the flow cytometry comprising:
detecting radiation from the flow cell within a wavelength range of a fluorescent emission of the fluorescent antibody stain and evaluating the detected radiation to identify detection events indicative of passage of said unassociated labeled particles through the flow cell;
wherein the biological material in the fluid sample is purified biological material with larger-size components removed to a filtration size of not larger than 2 microns, and the fluid sample comprises a concentration of fluorescent antibody stain not bound in the unassociated labeled particles in a range of from 0.25 microgram per milliliter to 10 micrograms per milliliter of the fluid sample.
9A. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-8A, wherein the flow cytometry is in the absence of detecting for light scatter.
10A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-9A, wherein the fluid sample as fed to the flow cytometer includes a total concentration of the fluorescent antibody stain in a range of from 0.25 microgram per milliliter to 10 micrograms per milliliter.
11A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-10A, wherein the fluid sample as fed to the flow cytometer comprises a concentration of the fluorescent antibody stain not bound in the unassociated labeled particles in a range of from 0.25 microgram per milliliter to 10 micrograms per milliliter.
12A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-11A, wherein the fluid sample as fed to the flow cytometer has a concentration of the unassociated labeled particles in a range of from 1×105 to 1×109 particles per milliliter.
13A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-12A, wherein the excitation radiation includes radiation within a wavelength range of from 520 nanometers to 550 nanometers.
14A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-13A, wherein the fluorescent emission has a Stokes shift in wavelength of at least 10 nanometers.
15A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-14A, wherein the fluorescent antibody stain comprises a fluorophore attached to an antibody molecule.
16A. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 15A, wherein the fluorescent antibody stain comprises an average of from 3 to 8 of the fluorophores attached per antibody molecule of the fluorescent antibody stain.
17A. A flow cytometry method according to either one of example implementation combination 15A or example implementation combination 16A, wherein the antibody molecules are monoclonal.
18A. A flow cytometry method according to either one of example implementation combination 15A or example implementation combination 16A, wherein the antibody molecules are polyclonal.
19A. A flow cytometry method according any one of example implementation combinations 1A-18A, wherein the fluorescent antibody stain is a first fluorescent stain and the fluid sample comprises a second fluorescent stain having a second fluorescent emission response, different than the first fluorescent emission response of the first fluorescent stain, caused by the excitation radiation.
20A. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 19A, wherein the second fluorescent stain comprises a fluorescent nucleic acid stain not specific to particle type.
21A. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 19A, wherein:
the unassociated particles are first unassociated particles, the epitope is a first epitope, the unassociated particles are of a first particle type and the unassociated labeled particles are first unassociated labeled particles;
the second fluorescent stain is a second fluorescent antibody stain that is different than the first fluorescent antibody stain and is capable of binding with second unassociated particles of virus size having a second epitope indicative of a second particle type that is different than the first particle type to form second unassociated labeled particles of virus size; and
the method comprises detecting radiation from the flow cell within a wavelength range of the second fluorescent emission and evaluating the detected radiation to identify detection events indicative of passage of the second unassociated labeled particles through the flow cell.
22A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 19A-21A, wherein the second fluorescent emission has a peak wavelength at least 20 nanometers different than a peak wavelength of the first fluorescent emission nanometers.
23A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-22A, wherein each said fluorescent antibody stain is capable of binding directly with a corresponding said unassociated particle to form the corresponding said unassociated labeled particle.
24A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-23A, wherein the unassociated labeled particles have a maximum cross dimension in a range of from 10 nanometers to 200 nanometers.
25A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-24A, wherein the flow cytometry comprises flowing the fluid sample through the flow cell at a fluid sample flow rate in a range of from 250 to 3000 nanoliters per minute.
26A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-25A, wherein the flow cytometry comprises hydrodynamically focusing flow of the fluid sample with a sheath fluid and flowing the fluid sample and the sheath fluid through the flow cell.
27A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-26A, wherein the flow cytometry comprises separately detecting for at least two different fluorescent emissions and not detecting for light scatter.
28A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-27A, wherein the viral type is the adeno-associated virus viral type.
29A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-27A, wherein the viral type is the adenovirus viral type.
30A. A flow cytometry method according to either one of example implementation combination 28A or example implementation combination 29A, wherein the viral particles comprise a member selected from the group consisting of virus particles of the viral type, virus-like particles of the viral type and combinations thereof.
31A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-30A, wherein the viral type is the adeno-associated virus viral type and the unassociated labeled particles have a maximum cross-dimension in a range of from 10 nanometers to 100 nanometers.
32A. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1A-30A, wherein the viral type is the adenovirus viral type and the unassociated labeled particles have a maximum cross-dimension in a range of from 80 nanometers to 200 nanometers.
33A. A fluid formulation comprising;
an aqueous liquid medium;
unassociated labeled particles of virus size in the aqueous liquid medium at a concentration of from 1×105 to 1×109 of the unassociated labeled particles per milliliter, wherein the unassociated labeled particles each includes a virus-size particle having a particular epitope indicative of a viral type selected from the group consisting of an adenovirus viral type and an adeno-associated virus viral type and a fluorescent antibody stain specific for binding, directly or indirectly with the epitope; and
a concentration of the unbound fluorescent antibody stain in the aqueous liquid medium, not bound in the unassociated labeled particles, is in a range of from 0.25 microgram per milliliter to 10 micrograms per milliliter.
34A. A fluid formulation according to example implementation combination 33A, wherein the unassociated labeled particles are unassociated labeled particles of any one of example implementation combinations 1-48 and 1A-33A.
1B. A flow cytometry method for evaluating a biological material sample for unassociated virus-size particles of a viral type selected from the group consisting of an adenovirus viral type and an adeno-associated virus viral type and having a particular epitope indicative of the viral type, the method comprising:
subjecting to flow cytometry a fluid sample comprising at least a portion of the biological material sample, wherein the fluid sample comprises a fluorescent antibody stain capable of binding, directly or indirectly, with the particular epitope, the flow cytometry comprising:
2B. A method according to example implementation combination 1B, wherein the fluid sample as fed to the flow cytometer comprises a concentration of the fluorescent antibody stain not bound in the unassociated labeled particles in a range of from 0.25 micrograms per milliliter to 10 micrograms per milliliter.
3B. A flow cytometry method according to either one of example implementation combination 1B or 2B, wherein the fluid sample as fed to the flow cytometer includes a total concentration of the fluorescent antibody stain in a range of from 0.25 microgram per milliliter to 10 micrograms per milliliter.
4B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-3B, wherein the epitope is a conformational epitope of assembled capsid of an adeno-associated virus serotype and the fluorescent antibody stain comprises a monoclonal antibody for the conformational epitope.
5B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-4B, wherein the virus-size particles comprise adeno-associated virus particles.
6B. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 5B, wherein the adeno-associated virus particles express recombinant protein.
7B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-3B, wherein the epitope is an adenovirus hexon protein.
8B A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 7B, wherein the fluorescent antibody stain comprises 8C4 monoclonal antibody.
9B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-4B, 7B and 8B, wherein the virus-size particles comprise adenovirus particles.
10B. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 9B, wherein the adenovirus particles express recombinant protein.
11B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-10B, wherein:
the fluorescent antibody stain is a first fluorescent stain, the fluorescent emission is a first fluorescent emission, the detecting is first detecting and the detection event is a first detection event;
the fluid sample includes a second fluorescent stain for nucleic acid, the second fluorescent stain having a second fluorescent emission response, different than the first fluorescent emission response, to the excitation radiation when attached to nucleic acid; and
the flow cytometry comprises second detecting for second radiation from the flow cell within a wavelength range of the second fluorescent emission and evaluating the detected second radiation for detection events indicative of passage of particles of virus size containing nucleic acid stained with the second fluorescent stain; and
comparing results for the first detecting and the second detecting for identification of occurrences of a said first detection event that temporally coincides with a said second detection event that is further indicative of passage through the flow cell of a said unassociated labeled particle including a said virus-size particle of the viral type.
12B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-10B, wherein:
the fluorescent antibody stain is a first fluorescent antibody stain, the epitope is a first epitope, the fluorescent emission is a first fluorescent emission, the detecting is first detecting, the viral type is a first viral type, the unassociated labeled particles are first unassociated labeled particles of virus size and the detection event is a first detection event;
the fluid sample includes a second fluorescent antibody stain different than the first fluorescent antibody stain and capable of binding, directly or indirectly, with a second epitope different than the first epitope, the second epitope being indicative of a second viral type that is other than the first viral type and the second fluorescent antibody stain having a second fluorescent emission response to the excitation radiation that is different than the first fluorescent emission response; and
the flow cytometry comprises second detecting for second radiation from the flow cell within a wavelength range of the second fluorescent emission and evaluating the detected second radiation for detection events indicative of passage through the flow cell of the second unassociated labeled particles of virus size including a particle of virus size with the second epitope and the second fluorescent antibody stain.
13B. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 12B, wherein the particles of virus size with the first epitope comprise virus-like particles.
14B. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 13B, wherein the second viral type is a baculovirus viral type.
15B. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 12B, wherein the first viral type is an adeno-associated virus serotype and the second viral type is a different adeno-associated virus serotype.
16B. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 12B, wherein the first viral type is the adeno-associated virus viral type and the second viral type is an adenovirus viral type.
17B. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 12B, wherein the first viral type is the adenovirus viral type and the second viral type is an adeno-associated virus viral type.
18B. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 12B, wherein the first viral type is an adenovirus serotype and the second viral type is a different adenovirus serotype.
19B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-10B, wherein the epitope is a first epitope, the viral type is a first viral type, the flow cytometry is first flow cytometry, the fluid sample is a first fluid sample including a first portion of the of the biological material sample, the unassociated labeled particles are first unassociated labeled particles and the excitation radiation is first excitation radiation, and the method comprises:
subjecting to flow cytometry a second fluid sample comprising a second portion of the biological material sample, wherein the fluid sample comprises a second fluorescent antibody stain that is different than the first fluorescent antibody stain and is capable of binding, directly or indirectly, with a second epitope that is different than the first epitope, the second epitope being indicative of a second viral type other than the first viral type and the second flow cytometry comprising:
20B. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 19B, wherein:
the first and second fluid samples each includes at least two different fluorescent antibody stains for binding, directly or indirectly, with two different epitopes; and
the first and second fluid samples each includes at least one fluorescent antibody stain that is not in the other said fluid sample.
21B. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 20B, wherein the at least two fluorescent antibody stains of each said fluid sample are targeted to detecting at least two different types of particles of virus size in the said fluid sample and at least one said type of particle is different between the first sample fluid and the second sample fluid.
22B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-21B, wherein the biological material sample is a sample collected from a stage of a production operation for producing virus particles during which the virus-size particles of viral type are expected to be present in the biological material.
23B. A flow cytometry method for manufacturing a product comprising virus-size particles of a viral type selected from the group consisting of an adenovirus viral type and adeno-associated virus viral type, the method comprising:
production processing to prepare a purified product including the virus-size particles of the viral type, the production processing including:
collecting a biological material sample from a stage of the production processing during which the virus-size particles would be expected to be present in the biological material;
evaluating the sample for presence of particles of virus size having a particular epitope indicative of the viral type, the evaluating comprising performing the method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-21B.
24B. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 23B, comprising performing the collecting multiple times to collect different said biological material samples to be evaluated from multiple different said stages and performing a said evaluating on each said collected biological material sample to be evaluated.
25B. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 24B, wherein the multiple different said stages include at least a first stage during the generating or the harvesting and a second stage during or after the purifying.
26B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-25B, wherein the biological material in the fluid sample is purified biological material with larger-size components removed to a filtration size of not larger than 2 microns.
27B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-26B, wherein a said fluid sample as fed to the flow cytometer has a concentration of the unassociated labeled particles in a range of from 1×105 to 1×109 particles per milliliter.
28B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-27B, wherein a said fluorescent antibody stain comprises fluorophore attached to antibody molecules and the fluorescent antibody stain in the fluid sample comprises an average of from 3 to 8 of the fluorophores attached per said antibody molecule of the fluorescent antibody stain.
29B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-28B, wherein antibody of the fluorescent antibody stain is monoclonal.
30B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-29B, wherein the flow cytometry comprises flowing a said fluid sample through the flow cell at a fluid sample flow rate in a range of from 250 to 3000 nanoliters per minute.
31B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-30B comprising:
preparing the fluid sample, comprising mixing biological material to be evaluated for presence of the unassociated virus-size particles with the fluorescent antibody stain.
32B. A flow method according to example implementation combination 31B, wherein the preparing the fluid sample comprises, prior to the mixing, purifying a crude sample of biological material to prepare the biological material for the fluid sample as subjected to the flow cytometry, the purifying comprising filtering out particles of the crude sample at a filtration size of not larger than 2 microns and comprising spin chromatography in a centrifuge to remove at least a portion of impurities smaller than virus size.
33B. A flow cytometry method according to either one of example implementation combination 31B or example implementation combination 32B, wherein the preparing a fluid sample comprises, after the mixing, not removing fluorescent antibody stain not bound in the unassociated labeled particles from the fluid sample prior to the flow cytometry.
34B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 31B-33B, wherein the fluorescent antibody stain comprises a biotinylated antibody and a fluorophore conjugated streptavidin.
35B. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 34B, wherein the fluorophore conjugated streptavidin is attached to the biotinylated antibody when provided to the mixing.
36B. A flow cytometry method according to example implementation combination 35B, wherein the fluorophore conjugated streptavidin and the biotinylated antibody are provided in separate formulations to the mixing and the fluorophore conjugated streptavidin attaches to the biotinylated antibody in solution during the mixing.
37B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-36B, wherein the flow cytometry is in the absence of detecting for light scatter.
38B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-37B, wherein the fluorescent antibody stain is a first fluorescent stain and the fluid sample comprises a second fluorescent stain having a second fluorescent emission response, different than the first fluorescent emission response of the first fluorescent stain, caused by the excitation radiation.
39B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-38B wherein the viral type is an adeno-associated virus viral type and the epitope is a conformational epitope of assembled capsid of an adeno-associated virus serotype and the fluorescent antibody stain comprises a monoclonal antibody for the conformational epitope, and the method comprises any one or more of the following:
(i) a said serotype is AAV-1 and a said monoclonal antibody is ADK1a;
(ii) a said serotype is AAV-2 and a said monoclonal antibody is A20;
(iii) a said serotype is AAV-3 and a said monoclonal antibody is A20;
(iv) a said serotype is AAV-4 and a said monoclonal antibody is ADK4;
(v) a said serotype is AAV-5 and a said monoclonal antibody is selected from the group consisting of ADK5a, ADK5b and combination thereof;
(vi) a said serotype is AAV-6 and a said monoclonal antibody is ADK6;
(vii) a said serotype is AAV-8 and a said monoclonal antibody is selected from the group consisting of ADK8, ADK8/9 and combinations thereof; and
(viii) a said serotype is AAV-9 and a said monoclonal antibody is selected from the group consisting of ADK9, ADK8/9 and combinations thereof.
40B. A flow cytometry method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1B-38B wherein the viral type is an adenovirus viral type and the epitope is an adenovirus hexon protein and the fluorescent antibody stain comprises 8C4 monoclonal antibody.
41B. A fluid sample for feed to a flow cytometer for flow cytometry evaluation, comprising;
an aqueous liquid medium;
unassociated labeled particles of virus size in the aqueous liquid medium at a concentration of from 1×105 to 1×109 of the unassociated labeled particles per milliliter, wherein the unassociated labeled particles each includes;
a concentration of the unbound fluorescent antibody stain in the aqueous liquid medium, not bound in the unassociated labeled particles, in a range of from 0.25 microgram per milliliter to 10 micrograms per milliliter.
42B. A fluid sample according to example implementation combination 41B, wherein the fluid sample includes a total concentration of the fluorescent antibody stain in a range of from 0.25 microgram per milliliter to 10 micrograms per milliliter.
43B. A fluid sample according to either one of example implementation combination 41B or example implementation combination 42B, wherein the biological material in the fluid sample is purified biological material with larger-size components removed to a filtration size of not larger than 2 microns.
44B. A fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 41B-43B, wherein the unassociated labeled particles have a maximum cross dimension of not larger than 100 nanometers.
45B. A fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 41B-44B, wherein the fluorescent antibody stain comprises fluorophore attached to antibody molecules and the fluorescent antibody stain in the fluid sample comprises an average of 3 to 8 of the fluorophores attached per antibody molecule of the fluorescent antibody stain.
45B. A fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 41B-45B, wherein antibody of the antibody stain is monoclonal.
46B. A fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 41B-45B, wherein the virus-size particles comprise adeno-associated virus modified to express recombinant protein.
47B. A fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 41B-46B, wherein the virus-size particles comprise adenovirus modified to express recombinant protein.
48B. A fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 41B-45B, wherein the viral type is an adeno-associated virus viral type and the epitope is a conformational epitope of assembled capsid.
49B. A fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 41B-45B, wherein the viral type is an adenovirus viral type and the epitope is a hexon protein.
50B. A fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 41B-49B, wherein the fluorescent antibody stain comprises a biotinylated antibody and a fluorophore conjugated streptavidin.
51B. A fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 41B-50B, wherein:
the fluorescent antibody stain is a first fluorescent stain having a first fluorescent emission; and
the fluid sample includes a second fluorescent stain for nucleic acid, the second fluorescent stain having a second fluorescent emission, different than the first fluorescent emission.
52B. A fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 41B-50B, wherein:
the fluorescent antibody stain is a first fluorescent antibody stain, the epitope is a first epitope, the fluorescent emission is a first fluorescent emission, the viral type is a first viral type and the unassociated labeled particles are first unassociated labeled particles of virus size;
the fluid sample includes a second fluorescent antibody stain different than the first fluorescent antibody stain and capable of binding, directly or indirectly, with a second epitope different than the first epitope, the second epitope being indicative of a second viral type that is other than the first viral type and the second fluorescent antibody stain having a second fluorescent emission response that is different than the first fluorescent emission response.
53B. A fluid sample according to example implementation combination 52B, wherein the particle of virus size with the first epitope is a virus-like particle.
54B. A fluid sample according to example implementation combination 52B, wherein the particle of virus size with the second epitope is a virus-like particle.
55B. A fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 52B-54B, wherein the first viral type is an adenovirus viral type and the second viral type is an adeno-associated virus viral type.
56B. A fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 52B-54B, wherein the first viral type is an adeno-associated viral type and the second viral type is an adenovirus viral type.
57B. A fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 52B-54B, wherein the first epitope is indicative of a first adeno-associated virus serotype and the second epitope is indicative of a second, different adeno-associated virus serotype.
58B. A fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 52B-54B, wherein the first epitope is indicative of a first adenovirus serotype and the second epitope is indicative of a second, different adenovirus serotype.
59B. A fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 41B-58B, wherein the unassociated labeled particles are unassociated labeled particles of any one of example implementation combinations 1-48, 1A-32A and 1B-40B.
60B. A method or fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 1-48, 1A-34A and 1B-59B, wherein the viral type is the adenovirus viral type.
61B. A method or fluid sample according to any one of example implementation combinations 1-48, 1A-34A and 1B-59B, wherein the viral type is an adeno-associated virus viral type.
1C. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1-48, 1A-32A, 1B-40B and 60B-61B, wherein the flow cytometry comprises:
counting the detection events as occurrences of individual ones of the unassociated labeled particles passing through the flow cell to determine a count for unassociated labeled particles in a volume of the fluid sample passing through the flow cell;
determining the volume of fluid sample passing through the flow cell that corresponds with the count; and
determining a concentration of the unassociated labeled particles in the volume of the fluid sample passing through the flow cell using the count of unassociated labeled particles.
2C. A method according to example implementation combination 1C, wherein the flow cytometry comprises:
performing the counting of a said unassociated labeled particle in real time relative to the detecting of the radiation corresponding with the detection event; and
determining the concentration in real time relative to passage of the volume of the fluid sample through the flow cell.
3C. A method according to either one of example implementation combination 1C or example implementation combination 2C, wherein the determining the volume of fluid sample passing through the flow cell comprises measuring in real time with a flow sensor the flow rate of the fluid sample to the flow cell and integrating resulting measured flow rate data over time.
4C. A method according to any one of example implementation combinations 1C-3C, wherein the identification of detection events indicative of passage through the flow cell of the unassociated labeled particles is determined in the absence of correlating with light scatter detection information.
The foregoing discussion of the invention and different aspects thereof has been presented for purposes of illustration and description. The foregoing is not intended to limit the invention to only the form or forms specifically disclosed herein. Consequently, variations and modifications commensurate with the above teachings, and the skill or knowledge of the relevant art, are within the scope of the present invention. The embodiments described hereinabove are further intended to explain best modes known for practicing the invention and to enable others skilled in the art to utilize the invention in such, or other, embodiments and with various modifications required by the particular applications or uses of the present invention. It is intended that the appended claims be construed to include alternative embodiments to the extent permitted by the prior art. Although the description of the invention has included description of one or more possible embodiments and certain variations and modifications, other variations and modifications are within the scope of the invention, e.g., as may be within the skill and knowledge of those in the art after understanding the present disclosure. It is intended to obtain rights which include alternative embodiments to the extent permitted, including alternate, interchangeable and/or equivalent structures, functions, ranges or steps to those claimed, whether or not such alternate, interchangeable and/or equivalent structures, functions, ranges or steps are disclosed herein, and without intending to publicly dedicate any patentable subject matter. Furthermore, any feature described or claimed with respect to any disclosed variation may be combined in any combination with one or more of any other features of any other variation or variations, to the extent that the features are not necessarily technically compatible, and all such combinations are within the scope of the present invention. The description of a feature or features in a particular combination do not exclude the inclusion of an additional feature or features. Processing steps and sequencing are for illustration only, and such illustrations do not exclude inclusion of other steps or other sequencing of steps. Additional steps may be included between illustrated processing steps or before or after any illustrated processing step.
The terms “comprising”, “containing”, “including” and “having”, and grammatical variations of those terms, are intended to be inclusive and nonlimiting in that the use of such terms indicates the presence of some condition or feature, but not to the exclusion of the presence also of any other condition or feature. The use of the terms “comprising”, “containing”, “including” and “having”, and grammatical variations of those terms in referring to the presence of one or more components, subcomponents or materials, also include and is intended to disclose the more specific embodiments in which the term “comprising”, “containing”, “including” or “having” (or the variation of such term) as the case may be, is replaced by any of the narrower terms “consisting essentially of” or “consisting of” or “consisting of only” (or the appropriate grammatical variation of such narrower terms). For example, a statement that something “comprises” a stated element or elements is also intended to include and disclose the more specific narrower embodiments of the thing “consisting essentially of” the stated element or elements, and the thing “consisting of” the stated element or elements. Examples of various features have been provided for purposes of illustration, and the terms “example”, “for example” and the like indicate illustrative examples that are not limiting and are not to be construed or interpreted as limiting a feature or features to any particular example. The term “at least” followed by a number (e.g., “at least one”) means that number or more than that number. The term at “at least a portion” means all or a portion that is less than all. The term “at least a part” means all or a part that is less than all.
A “portion” or a material, e.g., of a biological material sample, refers to some component or components of such material and includes both equal composition aliquots of a material and processed portions of the material that no longer have the same composition but that have one or more components from the material and which may be mixed with other components (e.g., buffer solution, reagents) not from the material. For example, a fluid sample including biological material that is to be subjected to flow cytometry includes a portion of a collected crude biological material sample even if the fluid sample includes only some purified biological components separated from the crude sample. As another example, if a batch of fluid sample is prepared including some biological material for evaluation is divided into separate aliquots for separate flow cytometry runs of the individual aliquots, each such aliquot includes both a portion of the biological material of the batch and includes a portion of the biological material that originated from a crude sample of biological material that may have been subjected to purification.
This application is a divisional of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 15/713,154 entitled “EVALUATING BIOLOGICAL MATERIAL FOR UNASSOCIATED VIRUS-SIZE PARTICLES WITH ADENO-ASSOCIATED VIRUS EPITOPE” filed Sep. 22, 2017 further identified as attorney docket no. 50911-00055, which is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 15/123,544 entitled “EVALUATING BIOLOGICAL MATERIAL FOR UNASSOCIATED VIRUS-SIZE PARTICLES HAVING AN ADENOVIRUS HEXON PROTEIN EPITOPE” (now U.S. Pat. No. 9,816,912) having a 371(c) date of Sep. 2, 2016 further identified as attorney docket no. 50911-00046, which is a U.S. national stage filing under the Patent Cooperation Treaty of international patent application no. PCT/US2016/023742 filed Mar. 23, 2016 further identified as attorney docket no. 50911-00042, which claims the benefit of each and every one of the following U.S. provisional patent application Ser. No. 62/280,079 entitled FLOW CYTOMETRY METHOD FOR EVALUATING BIOLOGICAL MATERIAL FOR UNASSOCIATED PARTICLES OF VIRUS SIZE filed Jan. 18, 2016 and further identified as attorney docket no. 50911-00035; Ser. No. 62/280,029 entitled EVALUATING BIOLOGICAL MATERIAL FOR UNASSOCIATED VIRUS-SIZE PARTICLES OF BACULOVIRUS VIRAL TYPE filed Jan. 18, 2016 and further identified as attorney docket no. 50911-00036; Ser. No. 62/280,042 entitled EVALUATING BIOLOGICAL MATERIAL FOR UNASSOCIATED VIRUS-SIZE PARTICLES OF ADENOVIRUS VIRAL TYPE filed Jan. 18, 2016 and further identified as attorney docket no. 50911-00037; Ser. No. 62/280,048 entitled EVALUATING BIOLOGICAL MATERIAL FOR UNASSOCIATED VIRUS-SIZE PARTICLES OF ADENO-ASSOCIATED VIRUS VIRAL TYPE filed Jan. 18, 2016 and further identified as attorney docket no. 50911-00041; Ser. No. 62/273,874 entitled FLOW CYTOMETRY METHOD FOR EVALUATING BIOLOGICAL MATERIAL FOR UNASSOCIATED PARTICLES OF VIRUS SIZE filed Dec. 31, 2015 and further identified as attorney docket no. 50911-00040; and Ser. No. 62/137,102 entitled FLOW CYTOMETRY METHOD FOR EVALUATING BIOLOGICAL MATERIAL FOR UNASSOCIATED PARTICLES OF VIRUS SIZE filed Mar. 23, 2015 and further identified as attorney docket number 50911-00027. Each and every one of the foregoing identified patent applications, and each and every portion of the contents thereof, are incorporated herein by reference, for all purposes.
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 62280042 | Jan 2016 | US | |
| 62280079 | Jan 2016 | US | |
| 62280029 | Jan 2016 | US | |
| 62280048 | Jan 2016 | US | |
| 62273874 | Dec 2015 | US | |
| 62137102 | Mar 2015 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 15713154 | Sep 2017 | US |
| Child | 16138407 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 15123544 | Sep 2016 | US |
| Child | 15713154 | US |
