The invention is generally related to defining quantitative trait loci (QTLs) that contribute to body composition. More specifically, the invention relates to SNP sequences derived from a region immediately adjacent upstream to the AKT1 gene that are associated with anthropomorphic variables, volumetric and cross-sectional MRI (muscle, mass and strength, subcutaneous fat, and cortical bone), and the use of these SNPs for both diagnostic and clinical intervention methods.
The incidence of obesity, metabolic syndrome, and type II diabetes is an epidemic in most industrialized populations (1). Obesity, as defined by body mass index (BMI)>30 has risen in the USA from ˜10% of women in 1990, to ˜20% of women in 2002, with three states reporting >25% obesity rates (2). African-American and Hispanic populations are at significantly higher risk, and it has been calculated that a Hispanic child born in 2000 will have about a 50% risk of developing type II diabetes in his or her lifetime, with an associated loss of 18-22 quality-adjusted life years (3).
Type II diabetes is characterized by persistent hyperglycemia in the face of adequate amounts of circulating insulin and a functional pancreas, hence, is also referred to as insulin-independent diabetes. Because it generally occurs in individuals over the age of 40, it also has been referred to as late-onset diabetes. The dramatic rise in obesity in the United States has lead to an equally alarming increase in the percentage of the population who suffer from the metabolic syndrome. “Metabolic syndrome” is a clustering of athersclerotic cardiovascular disease risk factors, such as hypertension, dydlipidemia, insulin resistance, low levels of HDL and a systemic proinflammatory state, impaired fibrinolysis, procoagulation and, most telling, central obesity. Indeed many experts contend that insulin resistance is the primary cause of Type II diabetes and that it is closely correlated to visceral adiposity (obesity). It should be pointed out that obesity alone does not always lead to insulin resistance, and vice versa. Such observations point to the added role of genetics in the acquisition of Type II diabetes.
It should also be borne in mind that muscle cells are a primary insulin target tissue and the primary storage depot for glycogen. Hence, insulin resistance may also be expected to play a role in the utilization of circulating glucose by muscle cells.
There are three primary and inter-related causes of the rapid increase in obesity and metabolic syndrome; inactivity, easy access to inexpensive high caloric food, and genetics (4). Of these three, genetics plays a dominant role, in that there are genetic propensities to become obese and insulin resistant, independent of ethnicity, extent of inactivity and food intake. This genetic predisposition extends through all populations, with body mass index (BMI) as one harbinger of obesity and metabolic syndrome thought to show 75% heretibility (5). The inter-individual variation in energy balance “set point” is thought to be the purposeful balance of risk of starvation (promotion of fat storage), and the risk of predation (strength and leanness) within recent human evolution (6). Despite the acknowledged importance of genetic factors in an individual's set point for energy balance, the specific genetic risk factors are poorly understood. The genetics of energy balance, adiposity, and insulin resistance are undoubtedly complicated, with genetic factors responsible for baseline values (e.g. baseline adiposity or muscle mass), and genetic determinants of response to environment (e.g. energy balance, response to hyperglycemia). Moreover, one cannot isolate a particular organ easily; fat tissue, muscle, liver, pancreas, and brain function are all intimately intertwined via endocrine functions of each.
It would be extremely useful to identify genetic loci that are diagnostic and prognostic for body compositions, muscle size and strength, bone size and adiposity. Such genetic loci have been discovered, and are described below.
We have Identified and isolated eight single nucleotide polymorphic (“SNP”) polynucleotides derived from a 12 kb region immediately upstream of the AKT1 gene in human males, seven of which are highly conserved among all races and animal species tested, constituting a group of SNPs consisting of SEQ ID Nos. 1 through 8, or complementary strands of SEQ ID Nos. 1 through 8. These SNPs exhibit strong association with certain aspects of body composition in human males, with these aspects consisting essentially of the states of bone cortical area and volume, subcutaneous fat area and volume, muscle area, volume and strength, and Body Mass Index that is strongly correlated with the potential for Type II diabetes.
The alleles of SEQ ID Nos. 1 through 8 are, respectively, -GI71T, -C8541T, -C12293A, -A8665G, -G738A, -G143A, -C3349G, and -G8371T. [009] In one embodiment, SEQ ID Nos. 1, 2, 3 and 4 are members of a 4-allele haplotye (“Haplotype 2”) that is associated with increased baseline muscle strength, decreased subcutaneous fat, and larger bones, and a potentially decreased potential for Type II diabetes.
In still another embodiment, SEQ ID NO. 5 constitutes Haplotype 4 that is associated with increased muscle cross section area and volume, but with no effect on subcutaneous fat or strength.
In yet another embodiment, SEQ ID NO, 8 constitutes Haplotype 1 that is associated with increased amounts of subcutaneous fat, an increased Body Mass Index, and an increased potential for Type II diabetes.
Additional embodiments constitute methods for analyzing a subject's genomic DNA for the presence of one or more of SEQ ID Nos 1 through 8, or complementary strands thereof, in order to predict presymptomatically the likelihood that a human male will have a genetic propensity for a particular quality involving one or more of bone size, muscle size and strength, amount of subcutaneous fat, the Body Mass Index (“BMI”) and the potential for Type II diabetes.
In another embodiment, the method of the invention is used to determine the presence of the alleles of Haplotype 2 (SEQ ID Nos. 1-4) in order to determine whether the human male will have a genetic propensity for larger bones, stronger muscles, lower subcutaneous fat and BMI, and a decreased potential for Type II diabetes.
In another embodiment, the method of the invention is used to determine the presence of the allele of Haplotype 1 (Seq ID NO. 8) in order to determine whether the subject will have a genetic propensity for excessive subcutaneous fat and obesity, and increased BMI and an increased potential for Type II diabetes.
In another embodiment, the method of the invention is used to determine the presence of the allele of Haplotype 4 (SEQ ID NO. 6) in order to determine whether a human male will have a genetic propensity for increased muscle cross sectional area and volume, no effect on subcutaneous fat or muscle strength, and a decreased potential for Type II diabetes.
In another embodiment, the method of the invention is used to test for the presence of the allele of SEQ ID NO. 1 which, if present, indicates that the human male has a genetic propensity for increased bone cross sectional area and volume and decreased subcutaneous fat.
In still another embodiment of the invention, the method of the invention is used to test for the presence of the allele of SEQ ID NO. 1 or 6, which are protein expression enhancers of the AKT1 gene in muscle.
Another embodiment constitutes detection reagents comprising one or more polynucleotides of the group consisting of SEQ ID No. 1 through 8, or complentary strands thereof, that is suitable for predicting the efficacy of clinical interventions designed to improve body compositions related to muscle strength, subcutaneous fat, bone size, and a potential for avoidance of Type II diabetes.
It is also within the scope of this invention to prepare commercial kits that contain the inventive detection reagents
We have identified and isolated eight single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in the 12 kb region immediately upstream of the AKT1 gene in human males, seven of which are highly conserved among humans, all races and various animal species, that are closely associated with different muscle, adipose tissue and bone physiotypes, and that are diagnostic and prognostic for body composition and muscle strength. The eight SNPs can be localized to one or more of four haplotypes that are differently predictive of bone cortical area, subcutaneous fat area and volume, muscle area, volume and strength, BMI and by inference insulin resistant Type II diabetes. The availability of these SNPs as novel detection reagents provides genetic detection methods that predict the success or failure of clinical interventions designed to influence body composition and strength and, possibly, also Type II diabetes. These detection reagents can be constituted in commercial kits for laboratory diagnostic purposes.
We have also discovered that two of these SNPs, SEQ ID Nos. 1 and 6, enhance protein expression of the AKT1 gene in muscle myotubules in the presence of a promoter and appropriate factors. This provides yet another physiological function for the inventive SNPs.
The data from the experiments described below demonstrate how the eight SNPs were discovered and isolated, and their diagnostic and prognostic uses.
We have recently reported the design of the study (7). Briefly, 945 volunteers (18-40 yrs; mean 24±6 yrs; Table 1), were enrolled by one of seven exercise physiology and kinesiology sites. Anthropomorphic data was obtained at study entry, and blood taken for genetic studies. Quantified phenotypes included muscle strength by maximum voluntary contraction (MVC) and one repetition maximum (1 RM), and muscle, bone and fat size by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) (8). Cross-sectional area (CSA) of the biceps was done using analysis of images at the center of the muscle. In addition, position-corrected semi-automated CSA and volumetric measurements of cortical bone, subcutaneous fat, and entire arm muscle were done for a subset of participants (9).
Fifty (50) single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in candidate genes were selected for analyses of genotype associations with age-, weight- and height-adjusted quantitative phenotypes. Candidate genes were selected from our mRNA expression profiling studies in human volunteers and rats (10,11,12,13), previous genetic association studies (14) (Table 2), and biochemical pathway information (15). SNP discovery was done for 25 of these genes by denaturing high pressure liquid chromatography (DHPLC) of all exons, exon/intron boundaries, and selected 5′ and 3′ UTR and promoter sequences in 96 ethnically diverse individuals (Supplemental Table 1) (16). Any identified polymorphism that showed an allele frequency of >10% in the screening panel was used for genetic association studies in the FAMuSS cohort (Supplemental Table 2) (17).
QTLs for ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) and muscle strength, angiotensinogen converting enzyme (ACE) and change in muscle strength and baseline body mass, PPARG and body weight, interleukin 6 (IL6) with change in cortical bone cross sectional area following training, and insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF1) with body weight were validated (Table 2). An alpha-actinin 3 (ACTN3) polymorphism that results in complete loss of the protein has been associated with elite power athletes, and we recently reported an association with muscle baseline strength in females (18). However, we were able to validate the previous findings for only men or women, and only rarely both (Table 2). In most instances, the previously identified QTL explained only a relatively small amount of the total variation seen, the exception being the IL6 polymorphism and bone remodeling, where 12.6% of variation in training-induced bone remodeling could be attributed to this polymorphism, similar to the dramatic effects of this polymorphism seen in Danish military recruits (Table 2).
Forty four (44) candidate gene SNPs drawn from emerging biochemical pathway data on muscle atrophy and hypertrophy, as well as genes that we have found strongly regulated by aerobic or resistance activity of muscle were tested (Supplemental Table 2). The most significant associations in our study were initially seen with a novel SNP near the AKT1 gene with baseline muscle strength in males (Table 2). AKT1 was considered a strong functional candidate, due to its central role as a signaling molecule in the regulation of muscle remodeling during both atrophic and hypertrophic stimuli (19,20). The SNP was mapped within the 5′ UTR of the AKT1 gene in the 2002 construct of the human genome; however, the 2003 updates of the genome sequence data placed this SNP 12 kb upstream of the first exon. The -C12,273A AKT1 polymorphism showed a relatively high allele frequency in all populations tested (allele: Caucasians 29%; Asians 15%; African-Americans 34%; Hispanics 23%) (Supplemental Table 4). Male subjects showed a quantitative effect of genotype, with the strength of CC<CT<TT (
To further interrogate the association with AKT1 polymorphisms with body composition, we conducted a thorough SNP discovery of the AKT1 gene and upstream promoter region sequence. We identified 12 polymorphisms in and upstream of AKT1 covering a 35 kb region (
We re-tested the FAMuSS muscle strength and size variables against seven of the 12 AKT1 polymorphisms, and found that both the -171 and -12,273 rare alleles showed association with baseline strength in males, consistent with their placement in the same haplotype (Supplemental Table 1; Table 3). The -738 locus showed association with baseline biceps cross sectional area by MRI, with the rare allele showing a quantitative increase in size (GG<GT<TT) (Supplemental Table 1; Table 2). No significant associations were found with any of the four polymorphisms within the AKT1 transcript unit itself.
To extend our studies of the AKT1 locus, 51 males were selected for semi-automated cross-sectional and volumetric MRI analyses of whole arm muscle, subcutaneous fat, and cortical bone (Supplemental Table 6). This analysis showed that the two distinct haplotypes upstream of the AKT1 gene were associated with different phenotypes. The haplotype marked by the -171T allele showed strong association with increased bone cortical cross-sectional area and volume, and decreased subcutaneous fat in males (
We studied the variability due to genotype effect for both haplotypes in males, and found that about 25% of all variation in cortical bone volume could be explained by the -171T haplotype, as well as 12% of variation in subcutaneous fat volume and 9% of muscle strength. The -738T genotype explains about 10% of variation in muscle size (volume) in males. The variability associated with AKT1 polymorphisms is considerably larger than other QTLs for muscle strength and body composition identified to date (Table 2).
Body mass index (BMI) is often used as a measure of body type and fat content. BMI is based on height and weight only, without any quantitative measures of the relative contribution of muscle, fat and bone to the overall weight. We tested the -G171T locus against BMI in the 945 subject cohort, and found that BMI tracked with genotype in males, as expected, with BMI GG>GT>TT (
The present data demonstrate that haplotypes upstream of the AKT1 gene are a major determinant of body composition and muscle strength in males. AKT1 (also called PKB) has emerged as a key signaling molecule, with many membrane-associated and intracellular signaling pathways converging on AKT1, and AKT1 then controlling diverse cellular growth and cell response pathways through phosphorylation of other proteins (15). AKT1 is an important factor for phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase signaling initiated by numerous growth factors and hormones, including those involved in protein synthesis and controlling rates of gene transcription (24). AKT also phosphorylates several proteins involved in cell development and death pathways, providing a negative regulator of apoptosis (10).
We defined the possible consequences of the base changes on AKT1 structure or function. We first tested each of the 12 polymorphisms for conservation through evolution. We found that four of the 12 polymorphisms were in blocks of high conservation (-C12273A; -A8665G; -C8541T; -G171T), and three of these were in the same Haplotype 2 (
A Haplotype 2 was defined as a QTL for muscle, bone and fat phenotypes in our cohort, we further studied the three conserved loci that comprise this haplotype (-171, -8541, -12,273) (
The -8541 allele removes a potential p53 binding site, while adding a nuclear hormone receptor TR4 binding site (30, 31). TR4, like Pax5, is highly expressed in bone, and may positively regulate bone development and homeostasis, with potentiation by increased AKT1 expression in Haplotype 2 (32). With regards to p53, pre-adipocytes are protected from apoptosis by Wnt signaling via AKT1 (33), and induction of AKT1 in pre-adipocytes would be expected to increase the amount of fat cells. Importantly, p53 has recently been shown to be part of a negative feedback loop that senses the fed state, and down-regulates lipogenesis in adipocytes (34). Thus, we hypothesize that the normal induction of p53 in adipocytes by a meal in obese subjects results in the increased expression of AKT1 in subjects with haplotype 1, leading to increased numbers and/or sizes of fat cells. Again, this is what we observed in our association studies, with haplotype 1 associated with increased subcutaneous fat and BMI, and haplotype 2 with decreased fat and BMI. p53 has also been found to be important in bone remodeling. Normally, limb immobilization leads to concomitant loss of muscle and bone. Muscle loss is dependent on the AKT1/Foxo/atrogin1 ubiquitin ligase pathway (35), while bone loss appears dependent on p53 (36). Mice deficient in p53 no longer show any loss in bone following limb immobilization.
The -C12,273A allele removes a potential myogenin/nuclear factor 1 binding site (36); myogenin is a key co-activator of MyoD, and is responsible for driving muscle differentiation (
AKT1 has been shown to be important for muscle, bone, and fat tissues, both in development and homeostasis. The phenotype AKT1 mice is primarily that of growth retardation and increased apoptosis (38), but AKT2 is expressed in most tissues and is thought to be partially functionally redundant with AKT1 (39). AKT2 null mice are insulin resistant, but double knockouts for AKT1/AKT2 show abnormalities of muscle, bone development, and impeded adipogenesis (39). These are the same tissues that we have shown to be influenced by QTLs upstream of AKT1 in the human genetic association data reported in this current study. AKT1 is also increasingly recognized for its role in metabolism and insulin signaling. Although AKT2 is more highly expressed in insulin-sensitive tissues, both AKT1 and AKT2 are downstream of the key phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase pathway (PI3k). The P13k pathway is critical for a cell's response to leptin, regulation of the insulin receptor, response to IGF-1, and many other signaling pathways (40,41). AKTI is involved in intramuscular insulin signaling and has also been linked to muscle hypertrophy and angiogenic growth factor synthesis (42,43,44).
The easy availability of relatively inexpensive, high calorie food, coupled with low physical activity levels are driving the rapid rise in obesity and type II diabetes. Indeed, poor diet and low physical activity are expected to overcome tobacco as the single most common cause of premature death (45,46). However, it is also clear that individuals show different propensities to become obese, with certain genetically derived “physiotypes” that help set lean body mass (muscle content), bone size, and fat deposits (47,48). An individual's genetically-determined tendency to become obese or remain lean seems conserved throughout primates. For example, in carefully controlled studies of rhesus monkey populations provided unlimited food only a subset of individuals become morbidly obese (49). These same studies have carefully studied the progression from obesity to type 11 diabetes, and have shown that muscle insulin resistance is one of the earlier stages of this process. Thus, fat tissue and muscle show endocrine actions that work together with the pancreatic beta cells and liver to regulate energy balance throughout the body, and each of these tissues contribute to a specific energy balance “set point” specific to each individual (genetically determined), yet influenced by environment. The identification of genetic risk factors for obesity-related physiotypes could be considered a key first step in developing personalized interventions to prevent obesity and the associated morbidity factors.
The present data demonstrates that transcriptional regulation of AKT1 is a major genetic determinant of physiotype in males. The four locus haplotype 2 is associated with larger bones, stronger muscles, and lower subcutaneous fat. The high degree of conservation of three of the four loci, and the establishment of this haplotype prior to ethnic divergence, suggests that there may be coordinate regulation of multiple promoter elements. This would allow a balancing of the muscle, fat, and bone in an environmentally-sensitive manner, leading to physiotypes adapted to distinct environmental conditions. The present data also suggests that the ancestral haplotype (Haplotype 1) results in a physiotype better equipped to survive food deprivation, while the second common haplotype in all world populations (Haplotype 2) imparts a larger boned and stronger build better able to ward off predators. This genetically determined physiotype is highly significant for males but not females, suggesting that the genetic loci responsible for physiotypes in the two sexes are likely different. Given the strong predictive correlations between BMI, subcutaneous fat, and risk for subsequent obesity, metabolic syndrome and type II diabetes, our data suggests that genetic testing for Haplotype 2 will identify individuals at lower risk for poor muscle strength, weak bones, obesity, metabolic syndrome and type II diabetes.
SEQ ID Nos. 1 and 6 SNPs were attached to pGL3 basic and promoter vectors and luciferase expression was examined in myoblasts and myotubules. Attachment to the basic vector actually inhibited expression both myoblasts and myotubules. However, attachment to the promoter vector did not change expression in myoblasts, but significantly activated expression in myotubules. Furthermore, -143AA activated expression more strongly than did -143GG (p<0.008-143GG vs p53L promoter vector only; p<0.005-143AA vs p53L promoter vector only; p<0.027-143AA vs-143GG). The same results were obtained with the -171 SNP. We conclude that these SNPs are expression enhancers in the presence of a promoter and appropriate factors, and that myotubules, but not myoblasts, are active in this regard.
In the method of the invention, a patient's genomic DNA can be extracted from blood or buccal cells using the PUREGENE DNA Purification System (Gentra Systems, Minneapolis, Minn.) according to the manufacturer's instructions. Briefly, for whole blood the extraction process is as follows: (1) Red blood cells are lysed and the contents of the red blood cells removed; (2) nucleated cells are lysed, thus exposing proteins and DNA; (3) proteins are precipitated and removed; (4) DNA is isolated by alcohol precipitation and placed in a DNA hydration solution. DNA is extracted from nucleated cells as follows: (1) cells are lysed, thereby liberating DNA and proteins; (2) proteins are precipitated and removed; and, (3) DNA is isolated using alcohol precipitation, and placed in a DNA hydration solution.
This DNA is analyzed for the presence of one or more of the 8 allelic nucleotides of SEQ ID Nos. 1 through 8, or their complementary strands by standard methods well known in this art. The pattern of alleles and haplotypes will thereby predict which clinical intervention is best suited for the patient in order to increase muscle strength and bone size and to decrease subcutaneous fat and thus the risk of Type II diabetes.
To the extent that the following references disclose methods used herein, they are incorporated by reference.
56 N Yang et al. Am J Hum Genet 73: 627 (2003).
-----------------