High speed imaging apparatus for CCD based scanners

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • RE37925
  • Patent Number
    RE37,925
  • Date Filed
    Thursday, September 28, 2000
    23 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, December 10, 2002
    21 years ago
  • US Classifications
    Field of Search
    • US
    • 235 455
    • 235 47201
    • 235 474
    • 235 46225
    • 250 223 R
    • 250 568
    • 250 205
  • International Classifications
    • G06K710
Abstract
A high speed imaging apparatus for CCD based scanners comprises a housing having separate compartments which complement modular assemblies installed therein. A decoder compartment houses components associated with locating and decoding an image. An optics compartment houses the mirrors and associated optics for reflecting the subject image onto the CCD detector. A lighting compartment includes high intensity lamps and the associated components for illuminating an object to be imaged. The lighting compartment includes a heat management system which removes the heat from the high intensity lamps and prevents heat from migrating to other compartments within the housing.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




1. Field of the Invention




The present invention generally relates to an apparatus for illuminating coded information symbols. More particularly, the present invention relates to a high speed imaging apparatus for CCD based scanners.




2. Description of Prior Art




There are many difficulties associated with imaging objects or bar code symbols and other machine readable symbologies on packaging. Erroneous imaging of a human or machine readable symbology may be the result of poor printing of the symbology on a label or extraneous markings or contaminants located on the label. However, erroneous imaging is often the results of poor lighting conditions. Proper illumination is one of the most important requirements for any machine imaging system.




The illumination of an object or a label is particularly critical for high speed scanning systems that employ CCD detectors. As is well known by those skilled in the art, the ability of CCD scanning systems to accurately detect an object depends upon the amount of light that is reflected from the region of interest onto the CCD detector. The amount of light detected by the CCD detector is a function of both the integration period and the intensity of illumination.




Many current imaging systems in the material handling field include variable speed conveyors, wherein the conveyor speed varies with the volume of packages handled by the system. If a low intensity illumination level is selected for low speed conveyor operation, the same illumination level may be insufficient for accurate imaging when the conveyor speed is increased. If a high intensity illumination level is selected, the light may saturate the CCD detector when the conveyor is operating at low speeds.




High intensity illumination sources have also been known to generate tremendous amounts of heat, thus creating “wave distortions” which may inhibit the ability of a CCD detector based system to accurately resolve the image. Additionally, the high intensity sources create an annoyance and even a safety hazard to nearby operators.




Accordingly, there exists a need for an illumination assembly which provides the desired illumination for operation of a conveyor at any speed.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention is a high speed imaging apparatus used for CCD based image acquisition systems. The apparatus comprises a housing having separate compartments which complement modular assemblies installed therein. A decoder compartment houses a CCD camera head unit and components associated with locating and detecting and decoding an image. An optics compartment houses the mirrors and associated optics for reflecting the image onto the CCD detector. A lighting compartment includes high intensity lamps and the associated components for illuminating the object to be imaged. The lighting compartment includes a heat management system which removes the heat from the high intensity lamps and prevents heat from migrating to other compartments within the housing.




Accordingly, it is an object of the invention to provide an illumination assembly which provides the optimum amount of illumination according to the demands placed upon the system.




It is a further object of the invention to provide a high speed imaging apparatus with an effective heat management system.




Other objects and advantages will become apparent to those skilled in the art after reading the detailed description of a presently preferred embodiment.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a perspective view of the high speed imaging apparatus of the present invention;





FIG. 2

is a perspective view of the modular illumination assembly of the present invention;





FIG. 3A

is a side view of the lighting assembly of

FIG. 2

;





FIG. 3B

is a perspective view of the lighting assembly of

FIG. 2

;





FIG. 4

is a perspective view of a plurality of modular illumination assemblies located in parallel;





FIG. 5

is a graphical representation of the illumination profile of a prior art lighting unit;





FIG. 6

is a plan view of the window of the lighting assembly including an aperture;





FIG. 7

is a graphical representation of the illumination profile of the lighting assembly of the present invention;





FIG. 8

is a block diagram of the illumination intensity control system of the present invention;





FIG. 9

is a perspective view of the present invention showing the resolution of the scanning system; and





FIG. 10

is the square wave output signal from the tachometer.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT




The preferred embodiment will be described with reference to the drawing figures where identical numerals represent the same element throughout. A high speed imaging apparatus


12


in accordance with the present invention is shown in FIG.


1


. The imaging apparatus


12


comprises a frame


14


which supports a main housing


16


above a conveyor


18


. As packages


20


travel along the conveyor


18


, they pass under the housing


16


. The packages


20


are illuminated to facilitate the detection of the packages


20


and any human or machine readable symbologies located thereon, such as a bar code


22


. For simplicity, the invention will be described with reference to the detection and decoding of bar codes. However, the present invention is applicable to any type of system for imaging objects or imaging human and machine readable symbologies.




There are many factors which can affect the ability of the apparatus


12


to accurately detect each bar code label


22


; including the speed of the conveyor


18


, the illumination intensity, and the ability of the apparatus


12


to accurately focus on the subject bar code label


22


. These factors are considered by the imaging apparatus


12


of the present invention in illuminating and detecting bar code symbols.




Referring to

FIG. 2

, the imaging apparatus


12


made in accordance with the teachings of the present invention is shown. The apparatus


12


includes a lighting assembly


40


and a main housing


42


. The main housing


42


comprises three separate compartments: 1) an optics compartment


44


; 2) a decoder compartment


46


; and, 3) a lighting compartment


43


. Access hatches


57


,


59


,


61


are also provided for easy access to components within each compartment


43


,


44


,


46


.




The optics compartment


44


houses the mirrors and associated optics for reflecting an image of the subject bar code label


22


onto a CCD detector. The decoder compartment


46


houses the components, such as a CCD camera head unit and the image processing architecture which is used for detecting and decoding the bar code image. The decoder compartment


46


may be configured to house different types of CCD detectors from any manufacturer.




The lighting compartment


43


compliments the lighting assembly


40


for securing the lighting assembly


40


to the main housing


42


. Referring to

FIG. 3A

, the lighting assembly


40


includes a combination reflector/heatsink


50


, a window


51


, a cross-flow blower


52


, lamp sockets


56


, lamps


58


and an electronics compartment


60


. The lamps


58


provide the source of illumination


62


for bar code detection. The lamp sockets


56


secure the lamps


58


in place and provide electrical power to the lamps


58


. Preferably, there are two lamps


58


and each lamp


58


is of the 400 watt high pressure sodium type.




In order to utilize as much of the output from the lamps


58


as possible, a combination reflector/heatsink


50


is utilized. The combination reflector/heatsink


50


is an aluminum extrusion which is polished to a reflective mirrored surface


70


on one side and includes heatsink fins


72


on the other side. The combination reflector/heatsink


50


provides a simple and inexpensive means for both light reflection and heat removal. With respect to light reflection, illumination emitted from the lamps


58


in a direction away from the conveyor


18


, will be redirected by the reflector/heatsink


50


through the window


51


and toward the conveyor


18


.




The plurality of heatsink fins


72


provide structural rigidity to the reflector/heatsink


50


. Thus, the reflector/heatsink


50


will not substantially deform even in harsh environmental conditions. This is a significant advantage over prior art reflectors which typically comprise thin reflective materials supported by a frame or other structure. These prior art reflector assemblies can be easily dented or deformed, thus permitting light to be misdirected.




With respect to heat removal, since the reflector


50


is also a heatsink


50


, heat removal is extremely efficient. Heat removal is further effected by a laminar air flow


75


across the heatsink fins


72


. The cross-flow blower


52


draws air through the cool air intake plenum


71


from underneath the lighting assembly


40


and across the heatsink fins


72


. The heated air is discharged out the back of the lighting assembly


40


through a warm air exhaust plenum


73


. The laminar air flow


75


cools the back and top of the reflector/heatsink


50


. The laminar air flow


75


also prevents the build-up of heat in the lighting assembly


40


which would eventually migrate to the optics compartment


44


and create optical distortions due to heatwaves or an “oasis effect”.




The cross-flow blower


52


is effective not only in cooling the combination reflector/heatsink


50


, but also in directing the hot air away from adjacent bar code scanners


61


,


63


. Accordingly, several lighting assemblies may be placed in parallel for a wide conveyor system


59


as shown in FIG.


4


.




Referring to

FIG. 3B

, the lighting assembly


40


is shown in greater detail. The laminar air flow


75


thermally isolates the reflector/heatsink


50


from other portions of the lighting assembly


40


. This effectively prevents thermal degradation of components in the electronics compartment


60


which are more susceptible to damage from heat related stress. A fan


54


removes any remaining heat from the electronics compartment


60


.




It should be appreciated by those of skill in the art that not all of the heat generated by the lamps


58


will be removed by the laminar air flow. Cooling of the reflector/heatsink


50


is further enhanced by direct suspension of the reflector/heatsink


50


at the side walls


78


of the lighting assembly


40


. This permits the remaining heat to be radiated out along the heat fins


72


and onto the side walls


78


.




In order to monitor the intensity of the lamps


58


, a light intensity feedback system


80


is employed. The system


80


comprises a light pipe


82


,


83


, for each lamp


58


which conducts a portion of the illumination from each lamp


58


to a photo sensitive device such as a photo resistor


65


,


67


which is located in the electronics compartment


60


of the lighting assembly


46


. The light pipes


82


,


83


are thermally conductive tubes which are selectively placed within the same laminar air flow


75


that cools the reflector/heatsink


50


. Each photo resistor


65


,


67


monitors the illumination transmitted by its respective light pipe


82


,


83


and provides an electrical output corresponding to the relative illumination intensity for that lamp


58


. This provides a feedback arrangement whereby the illumination of each lamp


58


may be individually monitored and controlled, as will be described in greater detail hereinafter. The use of the conductive light pipes


82


,


83


permits the photo resistors


65


,


67


to directly monitor the relative intensity of the lamps


58


while minimizing the undesired effects of heat related degradation which would be caused by locating the photo resistors


65


,


67


in close proximity to the lamps


58


.




The modular design of the present invention provides significant advantages over prior art systems. Since the main housing


42


provides three separate compartments, (the optics compartment


44


, the decoding compartment


46


and the lighting compartment


43


), components within each compartment


43


,


44


,


46


may be removed without disturbing components in other compartments. The modular design of the lighting assembly


40


provides for quick removal and replacement. Additionally, the compartmentalization of the main housing


42


provides distinct thermal separation between compartments


43


,


44


,


46


thus minimizing any adverse effects upon electrical components from heat generated by the lamps


58


.




One of the common problems associated with prior art lighting units is that the illumination emitted by these lighting units has an uneven profile as shown in FIG.


5


. The illumination intensity tends to be greater near the middle of the profile and tapers off at the ends of the profile, which typically coincides with the outer edges of the conveyor


18


.




Referring to

FIG. 6

the lighting assembly


40


of the present invention employs an aperture for equalizing the illumination intensity across the width of the illumination profile. The aperture


47


reduces the intensity of the illumination at the center of the illumination profile, but does not substantively affect the illumination at either end of the illumination profile. Accordingly, a more even illumination profile as shown in

FIG. 7

is achieved. An even illumination profile increases the performance of the imaging apparatus


12


by permitting the acquisition of higher quality, more uniform CCD images. As would be appreciated by those of skill in the art, the shape of the aperture


47


may be modified to achieve a different illumination profile, depending upon the profile desired for a specific application.




The ability to individually control the intensity of the lamps


58


is also critical in assuring proper operation of the CCD detector. Referring to

FIG. 8

, a microprocessor


100


is used to determine an intensity value based on certain operating conditions. Using a lookup table, the microprocessor


100


outputs an analog level corresponding to a digital word to a lamp driver


103


. The analog level represents the desired illumination intensity. The lamp driver


103


drives the lamps


58


accordingly. Preferably, each lamp


58


is individually monitored and adjusted to the desired intensity. This permits the lighting assembly


40


to account for fluctuations in the performance of each lamp


58


, which can vary greatly as the age of the lamps


58


increase.




The intensity of the lamps


58


may be controlled in response to several different parameters. In the present invention, the intensity of the lamps


58


is controlled in relation to: 1) the speed of the conveyor


18


; and 2) the height of each package being scanned. With respect to the speed of the conveyor


18


, with a fixed resolution CCD system, a line of data is acquired for a fixed distance of conveyor


18


travel. The time required to travel the distance varies with the speed of the conveyor


18


. Accordingly, the exposure time for a line of data is equal to the time required to travel the fixed distance. At slower conveyor


18


speeds, the exposure time is longer than at higher conveyor


18


speeds. Accordingly, a lower illumination intensity is required for longer exposure times.




A conveyor


18


tachometer


110


outputs a signal to the microprocessor


100


, which determines the desired intensity value for that particular conveyor speed. The microprocessor


100


outputs an analog level to the lamp driver


103


and the intensity of the lamps


58


is adjusted accordingly. At slower conveyor


18


speeds, a lower illumination level is desired. This results in lower power consumption and increased operator comfort level.




The intensity of the lamps


58


may also be controlled in relation to the height of each package being scanned. For packages which are shorter, and thus further away from the scanner, a higher illumination intensity is required to keep a constant signal-to-noise ratio in the CCD detected images. For taller packages which are closer to the scanner, a lower illumination intensity is required. The package height detector


111


may comprise a light curtain, as shown in

FIG. 1

, or any other type of conventional height detecting means. The height detector


111


determines the height of a package and forwards this information to the microprocessor


100


. The microprocessor


100


determines the desired intensity value for that particular package height. As would be appreciated by those skilled in the art, package height and conveyor speed may be simultaneously considered to calculate an optimum lighting intensity.




In another aspect of the invention, tachometer resealing is used to directly control the CCD line rate, (or resolution), of the imaging apparatus


12


along the direction of travel. As shown in

FIG. 9

, the resolution of the imaging apparatus


12


across the width of the conveyor


18


varies with the distance of an object from the imaging apparatus


12


. Imaging inaccuracies may result if this variation in the resolution is not taken into consideration by the imaging apparatus


12


while imaging a bar code located on the package. This is particularly critical in applications where time delayed integration (TDI) CCD detectors are used, since the shifting of the charge must be closely coupled with object motion to maintain accurate image resolution.




An example of the variation in scanning resolution is shown in FIG.


9


. The imaging apparatus


12


may scan packages at a plurality of heights


200


,


202


,


204


. The tachometer


110


produces an output signal which is proportional to the speed of the conveyor


18


. One pulse is generated for every 0.01 inches of conveyor travel, which is designated the “y” direction. Thus, the resolution of the imaging apparatus


12


is constant in the Y direction. At height


200


the field of view X


1


of CCD detector will be relatively small in the X direction. This results in high resolution in the X direction. At height


202


, the field of view X


2


is larger than the field of view X


1


at height


200


. However, since the same number of pixels on the CCD detector image the wider field of view X


2


, the resolution in the X direction has decreased. At this height


202


, the resolution in the X direction is equal to the resolution in the Y direction Y


2


. At height


204


the field of view X


3


has again increased, thereby decreasing the resolution in the X direction. Accordingly, the resolution in the X direction at height


204


will be less than the resolution in the Y direction. This variation of resolution in the X direction due to package height causes imaging anomalies and decoding inaccuracies.




Referring to

FIG. 10

, the signal that tachometer


110


produces is a 50% duty cycle square wave


120


which is output to the microprocessor


100


. The microprocessor


100


digitally samples the square wave


120


and a raw digital count corresponding to the time between rising edges


122


is obtained. Using a lookup table, the microprocessor


100


obtains a scaling factor, which is a function of the lens focal length and object distance. The microprocessor


100


applies this scaling factor to the raw digital count and generates a rescaled digital count. The rescaled digital count provides the CCD line clock signal, which is output to the CCD detector. Accordingly, the CCD line clock rate is modified to maintain a 1:1 magnification ratio in both the X and Y directions. For example, if a package is tall, and thus close to the imaging apparatus


12


, the CCD line clock rate must be increased. The microprocessor


100


obtains the raw digital count and accesses the lookup table for a scaling factor. At this height, the scaling factor may be on the order of ten per-cent. The raw digital count is multiplied by 1.1 to provide an increased CCD line clock signal. Implementation of the resealing method as described will provide greatly improved performance of TDI based CCD detectors in large depth of field applications.




Although the invention has been described in part by making detailed reference to the preferred embodiment, such detail is intended to be instructive rather than restrictive. It will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that many variations may be made in the structure and mode of operation without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention as disclosed in the teachings herein.



Claims
  • 1. An apparatus for imaging an object within a predetermined region comprising:means for illuminating the region comprising: means for producing light; reflector means for directing said light toward said region; and said reflector means including means integral with said reflector means for removing heat generated by said light producing means; detecting means for receiving reflected light from said object when disposed within the region; means for focusing reflected light onto said detecting means; and means for monitoring the intensity of said light producing means comprising a photo sensitive element and means for transmitting light from said light producing means to said element.
  • 2. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said transmitting means comprises a thermally conductive tube for thermally insulating said element from said light producing means.
  • 3. An apparatus for imaging an object within a predetermined region comprising:means for illuminating the region comprising: means for producing light; reflector means for directing said light toward said region, said reflector means including means integral with said reflector means for removing heat generated by said light producing means; detecting means for receiving reflected light from said object when disposed within the region, said light detecting means comprising a CCD camera head unit having a CCD detector and an image processor; and means for focusing reflected light onto said detecting means.
  • 4. The apparatus of claim 3 further comprising:a conveyor, for moving objects past said light detecting means; and means for rescaling the line clock of the CCD detector comprising: means for measuring the speed of said conveyor; means for determining the distance between the object and said light detecting means; and means for calculating a new line clock rate based upon said speed and said distance.
  • 5. An apparatus for imaging an object within a predetermined region comprising:means for illuminating the region comprising: means for producing light; reflector means for directing said light toward said region, said reflector means including means integral with said reflector means for removing heat generated by said light producing means; detecting means for receiving reflected light from said object when disposed within the region; means for focusing reflected light onto said detecting means; means for determining the distance between the object and said light detecting means; and means for modulating the intensity of said light producing means, said modulating means being responsive to said distance.
  • 6. The apparatus of claim 5 wherein said modulating means increases the intensity of said light producing means as said distance increases and decreases the intensity of said light producing means as said distance decreases.
  • 7. The apparatus of claim 6 further including means for determining the speed of the object relative to said light detecting means, said modulating means being further responsive to said speed.
  • 8. The apparatus of claim 7 wherein said modulating means increases the intensity of said light producing means as said speed increases and decreases the intensity of said light producing means as said speed decreases.
  • 9. An apparatus for imaging an object within a predetermined region comprising: means for illuminating the region comprising:means for producing light; reflector means for directing said light toward said region said reflector means including means integral with said reflector means for removing heat generated by said light producing means; detecting means for receiving reflected light from said object when disposed within the region; and means for focusing reflected light onto said detecting means; said heat removing means comprising a plurality of thermally conductive heatsink fans, and said illuminating means further comprising a blower for producing a flow of air across said heatsink fins to remove heat, said flow of air being transverse to said heatsink fins, said light producing means, said reflector means and said blower being housed in a compartment separate from other compartments of said imaging apparatus, thereby providing distinct thermal separation between said compartments.
  • 10. The apparatus of claim 9, further comprising an electronic compartment adjacent to said separate compartment, the flow of air across said fins isolating and preventing degradation of components in said electronics compartment by the heat from said light producing means.
  • 11. The apparatus of claim 10 comprising means for directing said flow of air so as to continue adjacent to said electronics compartment after passing across said fins.
  • 12. The apparatus of claim 11 further comprising a fan for removing heat from said electronics compartment.
  • 13. The apparatus of claim 9, wherein the ends of the fins of the reflector means are suspended directly at the sidewalls of the separate compartment whereby heat is radiated along the fins and onto the sidewalls.
  • 14. An apparatus for imaging an object within a predetermined region comprising:means for illuminating the region comprising: means for producing light; reflector means for directing said light toward said region; and said reflector means including means integral with said reflector means for removing heat generated by said light producing means; detecting means for receiving reflected light from said object when disposed within the region; and means for monitoring the intensity of said light producing means comprising a photo sensitive element and means for transmitting light from said light producing means to said element.
  • 15. An apparatus for imaging an object within a predetermined region comprising:means for illuminating the region comprising: means for producing light; reflector means for directing said light toward said region, said reflector means including means integral with said reflector means for removing heat generated by said light producing means; and detecting means for receiving reflected light from said object when disposed within the region, said light detecting means comprising a CCD camera head unit having a CCD detector.
  • 16. An apparatus for imaging an object within a predetermined region comprising:means for illuminating the region comprising: means for producing light; reflector means for directing said light toward said region said reflector means including means integral with said reflector means for removing heat generated by said light producing means; detecting means for receiving reflected light from said object when disposed within the region; said heat removing means comprising a plurality of thermally conductive heatsink fins, and said illuminating means further comprising a blower for producing a flow of air across said heatsink fins to remove heat, said flow of air being transverse to said heatsink fins, said light producing means, said reflector means and said blower being housed in a compartment separate from other compartments of said imaging apparatus, thereby providing distinct thermal separation between said compartments.
  • 17. An apparatus for imaging an object within a predetermined region comprising:means for illuminating the region comprising: means for producing light; reflector means for directing said light toward said region; and said reflector means including means integral with said reflector means for removing heat generated by said light producing means; detecting means for receiving reflected light from said object when disposed within the region; and means for focusing reflected light onto said detecting means; said illuminating means further comprising aperture mean which selectively blocks illumination from said light producing means to provide an even illumination intensity in said region.
  • 18. An apparatus for imaging moving objects comprising:means for producing an image of a moving object; means for measuring a speed of the moving object; means for determining a distance between the moving object and the image producing means; and means for rescaling along a dimension of the produced image based on in part the measured speed and the determined distance; and reflector means for directing light produced by a light producing means towards the moving object, the reflector means having means integral with the reflector for removing heat generated by the light producing means.
  • 19. The apparatus of claim 18 wherein the rescaled dimension is a dimension associated with a direction of movement of the moving object.
  • 20. The apparatus of claim 18 wherein the moving object is on a moving conveyor belt and the speed measuring means measures a speed of the moving conveyor belt to measure the speed of the moving object.
  • 21. The apparatus of claim 20 wherein the image producing means is a CCD detector and the rescaling is performed by rescaling a line clock rate of the CCD detector.
  • 22. The apparatus of claim 21 wherein the CCD detector is a time delay integration CCD detector.
  • 23. The apparatus of claim 20 wherein the speed measuring means comprises a tachometer which produces a pulse signal proportional to the conveyor belt speed.
  • 24. The apparatus of claim 20 wherein the speed measuring means comprises a tachometer which produces a 50% duty cycle square wave signal proportional to the conveyor belt speed.
  • 25. The apparatus of claim 18 wherein the dimension rescaling is based on in part the distance determination, the measured speed and a lens focal length of the image producing means.
  • 26. The apparatus of claim 25 wherein the dimension rescaling means comprises a microprocessor using a lookup table.
  • 27. An apparatus for imaging moving objects comprising:a CCD detector for producing an image of a moving object; a tachometer for measuring a speed of the moving object; a height detector for determining a height of the moving object; and a processor operatively coupled to the tachometer and height detector for rescaling a dimension of the produced image based on in part the measured speed and the determined height; and wherein the apparatus having reflector means for directing light produced by a light producing means towards the moving object, the reflector means having means integral with the reflector means for removing heat generated by the light producing means.
  • 28. An apparatus for imaging moving objects within a predetermined region, the apparatus having means for illuminating the region, detecting means for receiving reflected light from said object when disposed within the region, and means for focusing reflected light onto the detecting means, the illuminating means having means for producing light, reflector means including means integral with said reflector means for removing heat generated by said light producing means for directing the light toward the region, the apparatus comprising:means for producing an image of a moving object; means for measuring a speed of the moving object; means for determining a distance between the moving object and the image producing means; and means for rescaling a dimension of the produced image based on in part the measured speed and the determined distance.
  • 29. An apparatus for imaging moving objects in a predetermined region, the apparatus having a reflector means for directing light produced by a light producing means towards the region, the reflector means having means integral with the reflector means for removing heat generated by the light producing means, the apparatus comprising:means for producing an image of a moving object; means for measuring a speed of the moving object; means for determining a distance between the moving object and the image producing means; and means for rescaling along a dimension of the produced image based on in part the measured speed and the determined distance.
US Referenced Citations (21)
Number Name Date Kind
3663800 Meyer et al. May 1972 A
3977784 Hara Aug 1976 A
4248517 Nishikawa Feb 1981 A
4874936 Chandler et al. Oct 1989 A
4920255 Gabeler Apr 1990 A
4988852 Krishnan Jan 1991 A
5003189 Vala et al. Mar 1991 A
5059860 Sato et al. Oct 1991 A
5235167 Dvorkis et al. Aug 1993 A
5241164 Pavlidis et al. Aug 1993 A
5245172 Esslinger et al. Sep 1993 A
5291564 Shah et al. Mar 1994 A
5343296 Hellstrom Aug 1994 A
5343629 Rae Sep 1994 A
5384451 Smith et al. Jan 1995 A
5392100 Yoshida Feb 1995 A
5430282 Smith et al. Jul 1995 A
5581635 Zhu et al. Dec 1996 A
5633487 Schmutz et al. May 1997 A
5991470 Swithers et al. Nov 1999 A
6177999 Wurz et al. Jan 2001 B1
Foreign Referenced Citations (3)
Number Date Country
0331328 Sep 1989 EP
2201784 Sep 1988 GB
WO9301566 Jan 1993 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (1)
Entry
IBM Technical Disclosure Bulletin, vol. 27, No. 7A, Dec. 1984, Grant et al.
Divisions (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 08/606426 Feb 1996 US
Child 09/680406 US
Reissues (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 08/606426 Feb 1996 US
Child 09/680406 US