Hybrid LADAR with co-planar scanning and imaging field-of-view

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 12123950
  • Patent Number
    12,123,950
  • Date Filed
    Thursday, August 5, 2021
    3 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, October 22, 2024
    2 months ago
  • Inventors
  • Original Assignees
  • Examiners
    • Hellner; Mark
    Agents
    • O'Rourke; Thomas A.
    • Bongiorno; James
    • O'Rourke IPLaw, PLLC
Abstract
A laser radar includes: a laser, an optical transmission system, a 1-dimensional array of photo-detectors, an optical reception system, and an electronic control system. The laser emits a wavelength of light, and the optical transmission system shapes the light into a beam, and scans the beam along a fan of transmission light paths toward a target. The photo-detectors are capable of time-of-arrival measurements and are sensitive to the wavelength of light. The optical reception system collects the laser light reflected from the target along a fan of reception light paths. The electronic control system synchronizes the scan of the beam with a respective time-of-arrival measurement from each of the photo-detectors, and analyzes the time-of-arrival measurements. The system is configured for all of the transmission light paths and all of the reception light paths to lie in one plane, with all of the reception light paths intersecting with at least one of the transmission light paths.
Description
FIELD OF THE INVENTION

The present invention relates generally to the field of optical Time-of-Flight (ToF) measurement, and more specifically, to directionally-resolved ToF measurement technology, known as Laser Radar (LADAR).


BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

The need for early warning of an invading force dates back to the ancient world, which could involve scouts traveling on foot or by horse back, and eventually included use of telescopes and binoculars for an enhanced view of the enemy. In the modern era, beginning in World War II, radio detection and ranging (RADAR) systems were deployed, and which utilize reflected radio waves to identify the position of enemy aircraft. Sonar similarly uses sound waves to locate vessels within the oceans. Soon after the development of laser technologies, light/laser detection and ranging (LIDAR/LADAR) systems underwent development.


LADAR is generally based on emitting short pulses of light within certain Field-Of-View (FOV) at precisely-controlled moments, collecting the reflected light and determining its Time-of-Arrival, possibly, separately from different directions. Subtraction of the pulse emission time from ToA yields ToF, and that, in turns, allows one to determine the distance to the target the light was reflected from. LADAR is the most promising vision technology for autonomous vehicles of different kinds, as well as surveillance, security, industrial automation, and many other areas, where detailed information about the immediate surroundings is required. While lacking the range of radar, LADAR has a much higher resolution due to much shorter wavelengths that are used for sensing, and hence, comparatively relaxed diffractive limitations. It may be especially useful for moving vehicles, both manned, self-driving, and unmanned, if it could provide detailed 3D information in real-time, with the potential to revolutionize vehicles' sensing abilities and enable a variety of missions and applications.


However, until recently, LADARs have been prohibitively large and expensive for vehicular use. They were also lacking in desirable performance: to become a true real-time vision technology, LADAR must provide high-resolution imagery, at high frame rates, comparable with video cameras, in the range of 15-60 fps, and cover a substantial solid angle. Ideally, a LADAR with omnidirectional coverage of 360° azimuth and 180° elevation would be very beneficial. Collectively, these requirements may be called “real-time 3D vision”.


A variety of approaches has been suggested and tried, including mechanical scanning, non-mechanical scanning, and imaging time-of-flight (ToF) focal-plane arrays (FPA). There is also a variety of laser types, detectors, signal processing techniques, etc. that have been used to date, as shown by the following.


U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2012/0170029 by Azzazy teaches 2D focal plane array (FPA) in the form of a micro-channel plate, illuminated in its entirety by a short power pulse of light. This arrangement is generally known as flash LADAR.


U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2012/0261516 by Gilliland teaches another embodiment of flash LADAR, with a two dimensional array of avalanche photodiodes illuminated in its entirety as well.


U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2007/0035624 by Lubard teaches a similar arrangement with a 1D array of detectors, still illuminated together, while U.S. Pat. No. 6,882,409 to Evans further adds sensitivity to different wavelengths to flash LADAR. Another approach is the use a 2D scanner and only one detector receiving reflected light sequentially from every point in the FOV, as taught by US Patent Application Pub. No. 2012/0236379 by da Silva.


Additional improvements to this approach are offered by U.S. Pat. No. 9,383,753 to Templeton, teaching a synchronous scan of the FOV of a single receiver via an array of synchronized MEMS mirrors. This arrangement is known as retro-reflective.


Yet another approach is to combine multiple lasers and multiple detectors in a single scanned FOV, as taught by U.S. Pat. No. 8,767,190 to Hall.


However, presently, such a real-time 3D LADAR remains elusive.


OBJECTS OF THE INVENTION

The present invention is aimed at overcoming the limitations of both scanning and imaging approaches to LADAR by combining their advantages and alleviating their problems, namely to:

    • 1. Improve Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR);
    • 2. Lower the peak power of illumination sources, reduce their cost and improve efficiency;
    • 3. Reduce overall cost and power consumption; and
    • 4. Increase the resolution.


Further objects and advantages of the invention will become apparent from the following description and claims, and from the accompanying drawings.


SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

This Summary is provided to introduce a selection of concepts in a simplified form that are further described below in the Detailed Description. This Summary is not intended to identify key features or essential features of the claimed subject matter, nor is it intended to be used to limit the scope of the claimed subject matter.


In one embodiment, the above-noted objects of this invention may be achieved by combining a relatively large 1D array of time-sensitive detectors (preferably, hundreds of pixels), with a relatively fast 1D laser scanner (preferably, tens of kHz in frequency), in a co-planar configuration, that allows collection of one line of ToF data during each scan. Optionally, the planar FOV of both the scanner and the detector is also scanned in an orthogonal direction at a slower rate, thus providing a 2D FOV.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS


FIG. 1 illustrates a concept for a 1D scanning and imaging hybrid system.



FIG. 2A illustrates a 1D hybrid LADAR installed on a Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) to obtain 2D ToF data.



FIG. 2B illustrates a 1D hybrid LADAR coupled to an additional scanning mirror to obtain 2D ToF data.



FIG. 2C illustrates a 1D hybrid LADAR installed on a rotating platform to obtain 2D ToF data.



FIG. 3A illustrates tight focusing of the laser beam on the scanning mirror of a LADAR and subsequent re-collimation with a cylindrical lens.



FIG. 3B is a bottom view of the LADAR of FIG. 3A.



FIG. 3C is a side view of the LADAR of FIG. 3A.



FIG. 4 illustrates forming a scan line on the surface of a diffractive element and imaging the scan line onto the target.



FIG. 5A illustrates a laser spot scanning across virtual detector pixels on the target.



FIG. 5B illustrates permissible misalignment while the laser spot is scanning across tall virtual detector pixels on the target.



FIG. 5C illustrates splitting each of the pixels shown in FIG. 5B into two sub-pixels.



FIG. 5D illustrates positioning an array of micro-lenses in front of the detectors, and further illustrates how a relatively small pixel can be collecting light from a relatively large virtual pixel.



FIG. 6A illustrates the laser of the LADAR system being continuously ON.



FIG. 6B illustrates the laser being modulated with one short pulse per pixel.



FIG. 6C illustrates the laser being modulated with multiple short pulses per pixel.



FIG. 7 illustrates synchronizing the clock of an electronic control system with the scanning process, so that there is a constant integer number of clock pulses per scanning cycle.



FIG. 8 illustrates the electronic control system of FIG. 7.





DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

As used throughout this specification, the word “may” is used in a permissive sense (i.e., meaning having the potential to), rather than the mandatory sense (i.e., meaning must). Similarly, the words “include”, “including”, and “includes” mean including but not limited to.


The phrases “at least one”, “one or more”, and “and/or” are open-ended expressions that are both conjunctive and disjunctive in operation. For example, each of the expressions “at least one of A, B and C”, “one or more of A, B, and C”, and “A, B, and/or C” mean all of the following possible combinations: A alone; or B alone; or C alone; or A and B together; or A and C together; or B and C together; or A, B and C together.


The word “pixel” is used throughout this specification to denote an individual detector of a 1D detector array.


Also, all references (e.g., patents, published patent applications, and non-patent literature) that are cited within this document are incorporated herein in their entirety by reference.


Furthermore, the described features, advantages, and characteristics of any particular embodiment disclosed herein, may be combined in any suitable manner with any of the other embodiments disclosed herein.


In accordance with at least one embodiment of the hybrid LADAR system disclosed herein, a fast 1D scanner/imager hybrid can collect one line of high-resolution ToF data within tens of microseconds. If needed, that hybrid can also be coupled to a secondary, slow scanning stage, producing raster ToF frames of thousands of lines at high frame rates, with total pixel throughput of tens or even hundreds of megapixels per second.


The following description lists several embodiments of the present invention, which are merely exemplary of many variations and permutations of the subject matter disclosed.


Mention of one or more representative features of a given embodiment is likewise exemplary: an embodiment can exist with or without a given feature, and likewise, a given feature can be part of other embodiments.


A preferable embodiment of a 1D hybrid scanner/imager is illustrated in FIG. 1. It comprises a 1D array of photo-detectors 1, placed in a focal point of a receiving optical system 2, and a scanning mirror 3, its axis of rotation perpendicular to the direction of the detector array. A laser beam 5 generated by the laser 4 is directed onto the scanning mirror 3 through a collimating lens 6. The positions of the optical system 2 and the scanner 3 are adjusted in such way that the fan of imaginary rays 7 emanating from individual pixels of the array, and the fan of real laser rays 8 emanating from the scanning mirror 3 lay in the same plane. Respectively, the laser scan line on the target overlaps with the FOV of the detector array.


Preferably, the scanning mirror 3 is a resonant MEMS mirror. Such mirrors, having dimensions of the reflective area of the order of 1 sq. mm, the resonant frequencies of tens of kHz, and the scan amplitude of tens of degrees, are becoming commercially available. While generally this invention would benefit from the fastest rate of scanning, a general tendency in scanning mirrors is that the faster scanning rate typically leads to narrower scan angle and smaller mirror size, which in turn increases the divergence of the scanned laser beam, thus limiting the number and size of the detectors in the array, and the amount of light that can be collected onto the detectors, especially, at longer ranges.


This invention might further benefit from non-mechanical beam scanners (NMBS), that are undergoing development, although their specifications and commercial availability remain unclear. For example, U.S. Pat. No. 8,829,417 to Krill teaches a phase array scanner, and U.S. Pat. No. 9,366,938 to Anderson teaches an electro-optic beam deflector device. NMBS may allow scan rates, or beam cross-sections, exceeding those of mechanical scanners.


A photo-detector array should preferably consist of high-sensitivity detectors, as the number of photons arriving to each detector, especially from longer ranges, might be exceedingly small. Significant progress has been recently achieved in design and manufacturing of Avalanche Photo Diodes (APD), working in both a linear, and a Geiger mode, which is also known as a Single-Photon Avalanche Detector (SPAD). The former are reported to be able to detect a light pulse consisting of just a few photons, while the latter can actually be triggered by a single photon, and both types would be suitable for embodiments of the present invention. It should be noted, however, that the most advanced detectors are expensive to fabricate, therefore, the present invention that needs only one row of detectors would be very cost-efficient in comparison with flash LADAR, that would typically require a 2D array of the same resolution.


One of the problems typically encountered in ground-based and vehicular LADARs intended to be used in a populated area is the eye safety hazard presented by its powerful lasers. Therefore, a preferable embodiment of this invention would use a laser with longer infra-red (IR) wavelength, exceeding approximately 1400 nm. Such longer wavelengths are not well-absorbed by human eyes and therefore don't pose much danger. Respectively, much more powerful lasers might be used in this spectral range.


Depending on a particular task the hybrid LADAR is optimized for, one of the following configurations of the slow stage may be used for ground surveillance, vehicular navigation and collision avoidance, control of industrial robots, other applications, or alternatively there may not be any slow stage at all. As depicted on FIG. 2A, the hybrid 1D LADAR of FIG. 1 is attached to an aerial platform 15, with the scan direction perpendicular to direction of platform motion.



FIG. 2B illustrates using a scanning mirror 16, with its scanning direction being perpendicular to the scanning direction of the hybrid. Combined, they constitute a 2D LADAR preferably having comparable scan angles in both directions. Finally, FIG. 2C illustrates positioning the hybrid of FIG. 1 on a rotational stage 17, which gives the combined LADAR a 360 degree FOV in a horizontal plane.


If a scanning mirror is used for the slow stage, its area should be sufficiently large to reflect the entire fan of beams emanating from the fast scanner, as well as the entire fan of rays coming to the optical reception system. However, scanning mirrors with active area of square centimeters, frequencies of tens of Hz, and scan angles of tens of degrees are commercially available. Thus, an exemplary combination of a detector array with 300 pixels, a fast scanner of 30 kHz, and a slow scanner of 30 Hz would provide a point cloud of ˜18M points a second, assuming that both scanners utilize both scan directions, thus enabling real-time 3D vision with the resolution of approximately 1000×300 pixels at 60 frames a second. Rotation at 60 revolutions per second, or linear motion on board a vehicle would also provide comparable point acquisition rates, without the limitations of the reflective area of the scanning mirror.


Preferably, the optical system 2 is configured to form the FOV of each individual pixel 11 of the detector array to match the divergence angle of the laser beam, which is generally possible and usually not difficult to achieve. In an exemplary embodiment, a laser beam of near-infrared (NIR) light of approximately 1 mm in diameter will have a far-field divergence of approximately 1 milliradian (mrad). A photo-detector pixel 20 um in size will have similar FOV when placed in a focal plane of a lens with 20 mm focal length.


It might also be advantageous to use additional elements in an optical transmission system to shape the laser beam, such as, for example, a cylindrical lens 23, as depicted in FIG. 3A. In this case, the laser may still be nearly-collimated in the scanning direction, but may be tightly focused in the orthogonal direction, as illustrated by FIG. 3B, which shows the view from direction B in FIG. 3A. Cylindrical lens 23 subsequently re-collimates the beam in the orthogonal direction as illustrated on FIG. 3C, which shows the view from direction C in FIG. 3A. The advantage of such an arrangement lies in the possibility to reduce the dimension of the scanning mirror in the tightly-focused laser beam direction, as well as in reduced eye hazard presented by the laser beam expanded in at least one direction.


In another embodiment of the present invention, the laser beam can be tightly focused in both directions and be scanned across a diffractive element 21, as illustrated on FIG. 4, forming a thin scan line on its surface. That scan line is subsequently imaged onto the target by the lens 20. The lens 20 may be identical to the lens 2 in the optical reception system in front of the detector array, in which case the dimensions of the scan line on the surface of a diffractive element 21 should be similar to that of the detector array, thus insuring the equal divergence of both FOVs of the illuminating laser and the detector. Alternatively, the lenses 2 and 20 may have different magnification, and respectively, the scan line may have different dimensions from the detector array, however, the design should provide for a good overlap of both FOVs on the target, as further illustrated on FIG. 5A, where virtual pixels 31 denote the projections of the detector pixels 11 onto the target through the optical system 2, while the laser spot 25 scans the same target along the scan line 22, thus sequentially illuminating pixels 11 with light reflected from the target. As shown on the figure for clarity, at the moment when the laser spot assumes position 25a, it illuminates the detector pixel 11a. It should be noted that the desired shape of laser spot 25 may be achieved by a variety of optical methods, as illustrated on FIG. 3 and FIG. 4, or other methods, without limiting the scope of this invention.


Pixels 11 may have different shapes: for example, FIG. 5B illustrates pixels with their height exceeding the pitch of the array. For example, pixels of the array may be 20 micrometers wide and 60 micrometers toll. The advantage of such arrangement is that it may accommodate slight misalignment between the laser scan line 22 and the line of virtual pixels 31. Likewise, the laser spot may also be oblong, or have some other desirable shape. It might also be advantageous to split each of the pixels 11 into two or more sub-pixels 11b, 11c, as depicted on FIG. 5C. These sub-pixels would generate redundant information, as the scan spot 25 may cross either of virtual pixels 31b, or 31c, or both of them, at the same time, and the ToA measured by either sub-pixels or both would be treated as one data point. The advantage, however, may come from the fact that smaller sub-pixels would generally have lower noise level, therefore a laser spot of the same power is more likely to generate a response when illuminating a small sub-pixel, than a larger full pixel.


Some types of the high-sensitivity detectors, notably Geiger-mode APDs, are known to need considerable gaps between active pixels to eliminate cross-talk, thus limiting the fill factor of the arrays consisting of such detectors. To alleviate this problem, an array of micro-lenses 12 may be used in front of the detectors 11, as depicted on FIG. 5D, with the micro-lens 12a specifically illustrating how a relatively small pixel 11a can still be collecting light from a relatively large virtual pixel 31a.


It is also preferable to match the total extent of the array's FOV with the total scan angle, for example: 512 pixels, 20 um each, placed behind a 20-mm lens will subtend the angle of ˜29°. Respectively, the total scan angle should be the same or slightly greater to utilize every pixel of the array.


In a further embodiment of this invention, as the laser spot moves along the scan line, it is continuously energized, thus producing a time-domain response in the pixels it crosses, as illustrated on FIG. 6A, where the graph 10A represents the intensity (I) vs. time (t) response in the pixel 11a. The response starts when the laser beam in position 25b just touches the virtual pixel 31a, and ends when the laser beam moves to position 25c, just outside of the virtual pixel 31a. In such an embodiment, the laser power, and hence, the sensitivity is maximized, however, the precision of ToF measurement may suffer, due to the ambiguity of the Time of Arrival (ToA) of a relatively long light pulse.


To alleviate this problem, the laser can be electrically-modulated with shorter pulses, as illustrated by FIG. 6B. For example, the laser is turned on when the laser spot is in the position 26d, producing the response 10d in the pixel 11a. Since the pulse is narrower, its ToA can be determined with greater precision.


One problem with this modulation method might arise if the laser is energized while its spot falls in between two virtual pixels, therefore each of the real pixels is getting only a fraction of the reflected light. Due to some parallax between the laser scanner and the detector array, the precise overlap between the laser spot and virtual pixels is somewhat dependent on the distance to the target, and hence not entirely predictable. To alleviate this problem, the laser may be modulated with more than one pulse per pixel, as illustrated on FIG. 6B. In this case, at least one of the consecutive modulation pulses emitted with the laser spot in positions 25f, 25g, 25h, would fully overlap with the virtual pixel 31a, thus producing full response 10g in the pixel 11a. Responses from two other pulses 10f and 10h might be shared with adjacent pixels and hence be lower.


In any LIDAR system dependent on ToF measurements, it is important to accurately measure the ToA of a light pulse on the detector, as well as the time when the light pulse was emitted. In the present invention, additionally, it is important to precisely know the position of the scanned spot, as it determines which detector pixel will be illuminated. To achieve this, it is preferable to synchronize the clock of the electronic control system, denoted by pulses 50 on FIG. 7, with the scanning process, in such a way that there is a constant integer number of clock pulses per scanning cycle 51. The vertical axis (S) on FIG. 7 illustrates a scan angle, while the horizontal axis (t) illustrates time. Since many resonant scanners have unique, non-tunable resonant frequency, the system clock frequency may be changed instead to keep a integer number of clocks per period, preferably, by means of a Phase-Lock Loop (PLL) circuit. As long as this fixed relationship between the system clock and the scan angle is maintained, the system clock may be easily used for precise detector read-out timing, as well as for timing of the laser modulation pulses, if such modulation is used. Additionally, some types of detectors require quenching after they received a light pulse, and arming, to be able to receive the next pulse. Keeping pixels armed when they are not expected to be illuminated is undesirable, as it carries the risk of false positive due to internal noise. In most flash LADARs with such detectors, they are armed all at once, right before the illuminating laser pulse is emitted. In the present invention, it is preferable to arm detectors one-by-one, in the order they are illuminated by the scanning laser beam. As illustrated on FIG. 7, while the scanning beam proceeds from bottom to top, the pixel 11d would be armed by the system clock pulse 50d, while pixel 11e will be armed considerably later by the system clock pulse 50e.


A preferred embodiment of the electronic control system is illustrated by FIG. 8. The fast scanning mirror 3 is driven by the driver 63 at the frequency defined by the voltage-controlled oscillator (VCO) 67 through clock divider 65. Being resonant, mirror 3 tends to oscillate at maximum amplitude while driven at its own resonant frequency and in a specific phase with respect to the drive signal. The mirror phase feedback 71 carries the information about the mirror's phase to the phase-locked loop (PLL) 62, that compares it to the phase of the clock divider and adjusts the VCO to eliminate any phase error, thus maintaining mirror oscillations close to its resonant frequency.


System clock 68 is derived from the same VCO, thus insuring that all other timing blocks function in strict synchronization with the mirror motion. Specifically, the arming circuit 61 provides sequential pixel arming and the laser driver 64 generate laser pulses in specific relationship to the scanned laser spot, as discussed above. Likewise, the same system clock synchronizes the motion of the slow mirror 16 through the driver 66 in a fixed relationship with the motion of the fast mirror, for instance, one cycle of the slow mirror per 1024 cycles of the fast mirror. Read-out circuit 60 and signal processor 69 may use the same clock as well, although they, unlike other elements discussed above, don't have to be strictly synchronized with the mirror motion. They must, however, be fast enough to be able to read and process data from all pixels within one scan cycle of the fast mirror. 3D vision data 70 is generated based on the ToF measurement coming from the detector array 1 and then supplied to users, such as navigation system of autonomous vehicles or security surveillance system.


It should be noted that the present invention offers a considerable advantage in efficiency over other types of LADARs, especially flash LADARs, where short laser pulses are used to illuminate the entire scene at relatively long intervals. The advantage comes from the fact that in the present invention the laser is energized either continuously, or with a fairly high duty cycle: for example, a LADAR of the present invention using 10 ns pulses per pixel and generating 18M data points per second would have a duty cycle of approximately 35%. A flash LADAR using the same 10 ns pulses, and having the same frame rate of 60 fps, would have the laser duty cycle of only 0.00006%. Consequently, to generate the same average power and attain comparable range, the laser of that hypothetical flash LADAR would need instantaneous power almost 6 orders of magnitude greater. While pulsed lasers capable of producing very short powerful pulses do exist, they are known to have lower efficiency, larger size and higher cost than continuous lasers of the same average power. Aside from inability to deliver high average power, pulsed sources are typically less efficient, more complex, bulkier and costlier, than continuous or high-duty sources. The general physical explanation of lower efficiency is in the fact that the emitted power of photonic sources—lasers or LEDs—is typically proportional to the current, while parasitic losses on various ohmic resistances inside those sources are proportional to the square of the current.


Additionally, high-power pulsed laser sources are typically more dangerous in terms of eye safety.


It should be noted, that it is difficult (although not impossible) to place the scanner at the center of the optical system. At any other position, there will be some parallax between the FOVs of the optical transmission and the reception systems, hence the detailed mapping of the pixels onto a scan line will depend on the distance to the target. However, in a practical system such parallax can be kept to a minimum by placing the scanner in close proximity to the optical system.


The present invention as illustrated by the above-discussed embodiments, would provide serious advantages over other types of LADAR.


In a typical imaging LADAR, the light source emits a short pulse which illuminates all pixels at once. Respectively, each pixel receives only a small fraction of the total back-scattered signal. In the proposed hybrid, only one pixel receives all the back-scattered light emitted at a given moment. If we assumed that the illumination power is the same, then the signal strength on each pixel would be up by a factor comparable to the number of pixels, i.e. hundreds, if not thousands. In practice, pulsed sources generally have higher instantaneous power than continuous ones, but their average power is still considerably lower.


Conversely, in a typical scanning LADAR, at any given moment only a small portion of the photo-detector is receiving any signal, while the rest only generates noise and contributes to unwanted capacitance. The exception is so-called retro-reflective scanners, where a small detector FOV is directed through the same scanning system. However, this approach only works with large, slow scanners, where the mirrors are large enough to provide sufficient optical collection area for back-scattered light. Contrarily, high-speed scanners are usually tiny, just sufficient to fit the beam of the laser, and are usually of the order of 1 mm.


In either case, as illustrated above, a hybrid appears would have a considerable SNR advantage: higher signal than imaging-only, or lower noise than scanning-only device.


It is anticipated that a hybrid LADAR of the present invention will be able to use a regular laser diode as its illumination source—which is by far the cheapest and most efficient source among those suitable for LADARs.


Also, both cost and power consumption are roughly proportional to the total number of pixels fabricated by a given technology. So, substituting a 2D array by a 1D array is supposed to considerably reduce both cost and power consumption for the detector array, while the cost and power consumption of both fast and slow scan stages may be considerably lower, than that of the array of pixels or the illuminating laser.

Claims
  • 1. A laser radar (LADAR) comprising: a laser configured to emit a wavelength of light;an optical transmission system configured to shape the light emitted by said laser into a beam, and to scan said beam along sequential planes of transmission light paths toward a target, wherein each pixel of a plurality of pixels in each plane of transmission light paths is sequentially illuminated by said scanned beam of laser light;a 1-dimensional array of photo-detectors, each photo-detector of said 1-dimensional array of photodetectors being sensitive to said wavelength of light emitted by said laser;an optical reception system configured to collect said laser light reflected from the target along reception light paths within each sequential plane onto said photo-detectors of said array, and each photo-detector of said 1-dimensional array of photo-detectors configured to determine a time-of-arrival measurement for a respective one of said plurality of pixels illuminated by said scanned beam of light within each sequential plane;an electronic control system configured to synchronize said scan of said beam with a respective time-of-arrival measurement from each said photo-detector, and to analyze said time-of-arrival measurements;a system clock;wherein said transmission optical system comprises a mirror configured to produce said scan of said laser beam, where said mirror is a mechanical resonant mirror; andwherein said system clock is phase-locked to oscillations of said mechanical resonant mirror.
  • 2. The LADAR of claim 1, where an angle of a field of view (FOV) of each of said photo-detectors in the array in the direction of the array is the same as a divergence angle of said plane of transmission light paths in the same direction.
  • 3. The LADAR of claim 1, where an angle of a field of view (FOV) of each of said photo-detectors in the array in a direction perpendicular to the direction of the array is the same as a divergence angle of said plane of transmission light paths in the same direction.
  • 4. The LADAR of claim 1, where an angle of a field of view (FOV) of each of said photo-detectors in the direction of the array is the same as a total scan angle of said transmission system.
  • 5. The LADAR of claim 1, where the laser is continuously on while the transmission path of said scan of said beam intersects the reception paths from all the detectors in the array.
  • 6. The LADAR of claim 1, wherein said LADAR is placed on an aerial platform moving in the direction perpendicular to said plane containing the light paths of said transmission system.
  • 7. The LADAR of claim 1, with a scanning mirror positioned in an optical path of the scanned laser beam, with an axis of rotation parallel to said plane containing the light paths of said transmission system.
  • 8. The LADAR of claim 1 mounted on a rotational stage with an axis of rotation being parallel to said plane containing the light paths of said transmission system.
  • 9. The LADAR of claim 1 where the photodetectors are Avalanche Photo Diodes (APD).
  • 10. The LADAR of claim 9 where the photodetectors are Geiger-mode Avalanche Photo Diodes (APD).
  • 11. The LADAR of claim 1 wherein each of said photodetectors comprise a single photon avalanche detector with individual time counters configured to record a time of arrival of a first photon after a reset.
  • 12. The LADAR of claim 1; wherein said system clock is synchronized, whereby a frequency of pulses of said system clock are related to a frequency of said scan of said beam; andwherein said synchronization of said system clock is configured to provide a constant integer number of said clock pulses per said scan of said mirror, to permit accurate determination of a position of a scanned spot to determine a pixel to be illuminated.
  • 13. The LADAR of claim 1 where said optical transmission system comprises a non-mechanical beam scanner (NMBS) configured for said scan of said laser beam.
  • 14. The LADAR of claim 1, wherein said optical transmission system comprises: an optical element; anda diffractive element, said diffractive element comprising a plurality of ridges; andwherein said optical transmission system is configured to form a scan line on a surface of said diffractive element, and for said scan line to be imaged onto the target through said optical element.
  • 15. The LADAR of claim 1 wherein said optical system comprises: a mirror and a cylindrical lens; wherein said mirror is configured to produce said scan of said laser beam; and wherein said optical system is configured for the laser beam to be focused on the mirror in a direction parallel to a scan axis of the mirror, and to then be re-collimated by said cylindrical lens.
  • 16. The LADAR of claim 1 where a height of each pixel exceeds a pitch of each pixel.
  • 17. The LADAR of claim 1 wherein said optical reception system comprises: an array of micro-lenses, with one said micro-lens positioned in front of each of said photo-detectors.
  • 18. The LADAR of claim 1 where a frequency of said scan exceeds 10 kHz.
  • 19. The LADAR of claim 1 where a frequency of said scan exceeds 30 kHz.
  • 20. The LADAR of claim 1 where each individual photo-detector is illuminated for no more than 60 nanoseconds during each scan.
  • 21. The LADAR of claim 1 where each photo-detector is illuminated for no more than 20 nanoseconds during one scan.
  • 22. The LADAR of claim 1 where the laser is a diode laser.
  • 23. The LADAR of claim 1 where the laser emits eye-safe light with said wavelength exceeding 1400 nm.
  • 24. The LADAR of claim 1 wherein every said reception light path intersects with at least one of said transmission light paths.
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a continuation of U.S. application Ser. No. 15/432,105, which claims priority on U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 62/295,210, filed on Feb. 15, 2016, all disclosures of which are incorporated herein by reference.

US Referenced Citations (1043)
Number Name Date Kind
3636250 Haeff Jan 1972 A
4240746 Courtenay Dec 1980 A
4397549 Morgan Aug 1983 A
4627734 Rioux Dec 1986 A
4820914 Allen Apr 1989 A
4862257 Ulich Aug 1989 A
4941719 Hisada Jul 1990 A
4964721 Ulich Oct 1990 A
4967270 Ulich Oct 1990 A
5006721 Cameron Apr 1991 A
5013917 Ulich May 1991 A
5091778 Keeler Feb 1992 A
5096293 Cecchi Mar 1992 A
5157257 Geiger Oct 1992 A
5159225 Um Oct 1992 A
5164784 Waggoner Nov 1992 A
5164823 Keeler Nov 1992 A
5166507 Davis Nov 1992 A
5192978 Keeler Mar 1993 A
5198657 Trost Mar 1993 A
5200606 Krasutsky Apr 1993 A
5206698 Werner Apr 1993 A
5220164 Lieber Jun 1993 A
5221927 Palmer Jun 1993 A
5221956 Patterson Jun 1993 A
5231401 Kaman Jul 1993 A
5231480 Ulich Jul 1993 A
5233415 French Aug 1993 A
5239352 Bissonnette Aug 1993 A
5241314 Keeler Aug 1993 A
5243541 Ulich Sep 1993 A
5250810 Geiger Oct 1993 A
5255065 Schwemmer Oct 1993 A
5257085 Ulich Oct 1993 A
5270780 Moran Dec 1993 A
5270929 Paulson Dec 1993 A
5272351 Andressen Dec 1993 A
5303084 Pflibsen Apr 1994 A
5311272 Daniels May 1994 A
5335070 Pflibsen Aug 1994 A
5343284 Keeler Aug 1994 A
5353054 Geiger Oct 1994 A
5384589 Ulich Jan 1995 A
5442358 Keeler Aug 1995 A
5450125 Ulich Sep 1995 A
5457639 Ulich Oct 1995 A
5467122 Bowker Nov 1995 A
5534993 Ball Jul 1996 A
5546183 Fegley Aug 1996 A
5570224 Endo Oct 1996 A
5574553 McManamon Nov 1996 A
5608514 Stann Mar 1997 A
5644386 Jenkins Jul 1997 A
5667304 Gelbwachs Sep 1997 A
5670935 Schofield Sep 1997 A
5682225 DuBois Oct 1997 A
5724125 Ames Mar 1998 A
5767519 Gelbwachs Jun 1998 A
5778019 Churnside Jul 1998 A
5796471 Wilkerson Aug 1998 A
5822047 Contarino Oct 1998 A
5825464 Feichtner Oct 1998 A
5831719 Berg Nov 1998 A
5831724 Cordes Nov 1998 A
5835199 Phillips Nov 1998 A
5847815 Albouy Dec 1998 A
5847816 Zediker Dec 1998 A
5847817 Zediker Dec 1998 A
5870180 Wangler Feb 1999 A
5877851 Stann Mar 1999 A
5898483 Flowers Apr 1999 A
5914776 Streicher Jun 1999 A
5989087 Cordes Nov 1999 A
6042050 Sims Mar 2000 A
6084659 Tulet Jul 2000 A
6147747 Kavaya Nov 2000 A
6246468 Dimsdale Jun 2001 B1
6302355 Sallee Oct 2001 B1
6323941 Evans Nov 2001 B1
6371405 Sallee Apr 2002 B1
6381007 Fabre Apr 2002 B2
6388739 Rice May 2002 B1
6396397 Bos May 2002 B1
6396577 Ramstack May 2002 B1
6404494 Masonis Jun 2002 B1
6441889 Patterson Aug 2002 B1
6448572 Tennant Sep 2002 B1
6522396 Halmos Feb 2003 B1
6556282 Jamieson Apr 2003 B2
6559932 Halmos May 2003 B1
6577417 Khoury Jun 2003 B1
6593582 Lee Jul 2003 B2
6608669 Holton Aug 2003 B2
6608677 Ray Aug 2003 B1
6618125 Stann Sep 2003 B2
6619406 Kacyra Sep 2003 B1
6634600 Krawczyk Oct 2003 B2
6636300 Doemens Oct 2003 B2
6646725 Eichinger Nov 2003 B1
6664529 Pack Dec 2003 B2
6711475 Murphy Feb 2004 B2
6714286 Wheel Mar 2004 B1
6717655 Cheng Apr 2004 B2
6724470 Barenz Apr 2004 B2
6781683 Kacyra Aug 2004 B2
6836285 Lubard Dec 2004 B1
6844924 Ruff Jan 2005 B2
6873716 Bowker Mar 2005 B1
6875978 Halmos Apr 2005 B2
6882409 Evans Apr 2005 B1
6963354 Scheps Nov 2005 B1
7010339 Mullen Mar 2006 B2
7046358 Barker May 2006 B2
7064810 Anderson Jun 2006 B2
7064817 Schmitt Jun 2006 B1
7067812 Gelbwachs Jun 2006 B2
7104453 Zhu Sep 2006 B1
7130028 Pain Oct 2006 B2
7135672 Land Nov 2006 B2
7164468 Correia Da Silva Vilar Jan 2007 B2
7164787 Nevis Jan 2007 B1
7164788 Nevis Jan 2007 B1
7187452 Jupp Mar 2007 B2
7190854 Novotny Mar 2007 B1
7195163 Yoo Mar 2007 B2
7203339 Nevis Apr 2007 B1
7206062 Asbrock Apr 2007 B2
7215826 Nevis May 2007 B1
7227625 Kobayashi Jun 2007 B2
7242460 Hsu Jul 2007 B2
7248342 Degnan Jul 2007 B1
7248343 Cardero Jul 2007 B2
7260507 Kalayeh Aug 2007 B2
7274448 Babbin Sep 2007 B2
7281891 Smith Oct 2007 B2
7301608 Mendenhall Nov 2007 B1
7312855 Hintz Dec 2007 B1
7313506 Kacyra Dec 2007 B2
7333184 Kalayeh Feb 2008 B2
7336345 Krasutsky Feb 2008 B2
7339670 Carrig Mar 2008 B2
7345744 Halmos Mar 2008 B2
7359039 Kloza Apr 2008 B2
7361922 Kameyama Apr 2008 B2
7375804 Liebman May 2008 B2
7375877 Di Teodoro May 2008 B1
7397568 Bryce Jul 2008 B2
7400384 Evans Jul 2008 B1
7411196 Kalayeh Aug 2008 B2
7411662 Ruff Aug 2008 B1
7417717 Pack Aug 2008 B2
7428041 Kallio Sep 2008 B2
7436494 Kennedy Oct 2008 B1
7440084 Kane Oct 2008 B2
7463340 Krishnaswamy Dec 2008 B2
7463341 Halldorsson Dec 2008 B2
7474332 Byren Jan 2009 B2
7474964 Welty Jan 2009 B1
7485862 Danziger Feb 2009 B2
7495764 McMillan Feb 2009 B1
7505488 Halmos Mar 2009 B2
7532311 Henderson May 2009 B2
7561261 Hilde Jul 2009 B2
7570347 Ruff Aug 2009 B2
7571081 Faulkner Aug 2009 B2
7580127 Mayor Aug 2009 B1
7583364 Mayor Sep 2009 B1
7630062 Mori Dec 2009 B2
7649616 Michael Jan 2010 B2
7652752 Fetzer Jan 2010 B2
7656526 Spuler Feb 2010 B1
7675610 Redman Mar 2010 B2
7675619 Danehy Mar 2010 B2
7683928 Lubard Mar 2010 B2
7688348 Lubard Mar 2010 B2
7688374 Land Mar 2010 B2
7692775 Treado Apr 2010 B2
7697125 Swenson Apr 2010 B2
7697794 Dragic Apr 2010 B2
7701558 Walsh Apr 2010 B2
7720580 Higgins-Luthman May 2010 B2
7720605 Welty May 2010 B2
7739823 Shapira Jun 2010 B2
7741618 Lee Jun 2010 B2
7742151 Krasutsky Jun 2010 B2
7746450 Williner Jun 2010 B2
7755745 Urata Jul 2010 B2
7760334 Evans Jul 2010 B1
7800736 Pack Sep 2010 B2
7821619 Krikorian Oct 2010 B2
7827861 La White Nov 2010 B2
7830442 Griffis Nov 2010 B2
7847235 Krumpkin Dec 2010 B2
7894044 Sullivan Feb 2011 B1
7933002 Halldorsson Apr 2011 B2
7936448 Albuquerque May 2011 B2
7944547 Wang May 2011 B2
7948610 Hintz May 2011 B2
7961301 Earhart Jun 2011 B2
7969558 Hall Jun 2011 B2
7974813 Welty Jul 2011 B2
7983738 Goldman Jul 2011 B2
7986397 Tiemann Jul 2011 B1
8010300 Stearns Aug 2011 B1
8024135 Lee Sep 2011 B2
8054454 Treado Nov 2011 B2
8054464 Mathur Nov 2011 B2
8072581 Breiholz Dec 2011 B1
8072582 Meneely Dec 2011 B2
8072663 O'Neil Dec 2011 B2
8077294 Grund Dec 2011 B1
8081301 Stann Dec 2011 B2
8090153 Schofield Jan 2012 B2
8098889 Zhu Jan 2012 B2
8115622 Stolarczyk Feb 2012 B2
8115925 Mathur Feb 2012 B1
8120754 Kaehler Feb 2012 B2
8121798 Lippert Feb 2012 B2
8125367 Ludwig Feb 2012 B2
8125622 Gammenthaler Feb 2012 B2
8135513 Bauer Mar 2012 B2
8139863 Hsu Mar 2012 B1
8164742 Carrieri Apr 2012 B1
8179521 Valla May 2012 B2
8198576 Kennedy Jun 2012 B2
8224097 Matei Jul 2012 B2
8229663 Zeng Jul 2012 B2
8229679 Matthews Jul 2012 B1
8242428 Meyers Aug 2012 B2
8244026 Nahari Aug 2012 B2
8269950 Spinelli Sep 2012 B2
RE43722 Kennedy Oct 2012 E
8279420 Ludwig Oct 2012 B2
8284382 Krasutsky Oct 2012 B2
8294881 Hellickson Oct 2012 B2
8306273 Gravseth Nov 2012 B1
8306941 Ma Nov 2012 B2
8325328 Renard Dec 2012 B2
8332134 Zhang Dec 2012 B2
8344942 Jin Jan 2013 B2
8362889 Komori Jan 2013 B2
8386876 Khoshnevis Feb 2013 B2
8427649 Hays Apr 2013 B2
8441622 Gammenthaler May 2013 B2
8446571 Fiess May 2013 B2
8465478 Frey Jun 2013 B2
8478386 Goldman Jul 2013 B2
8493445 Degnan Jul 2013 B2
8494687 Vanek Jul 2013 B2
8508721 Cates Aug 2013 B2
8537337 Welty Sep 2013 B2
8537338 Medasani Sep 2013 B1
8538695 Welty Sep 2013 B2
8541744 Liu Sep 2013 B1
8558993 Newbury Oct 2013 B2
8577611 Ma Nov 2013 B2
8587637 Cryder Nov 2013 B1
8599365 Ma Dec 2013 B2
8599367 Canham Dec 2013 B2
8600589 Mendez-Rodriguez Dec 2013 B2
8605262 Campbell Dec 2013 B2
8610881 Gammenthaler Dec 2013 B2
8629975 Dierking Jan 2014 B1
8629977 Phillips Jan 2014 B2
8648702 Pala Feb 2014 B2
8655513 Vanek Feb 2014 B2
8659747 Goodman Feb 2014 B2
8659748 Fakin Feb 2014 B2
8670591 Mendez-Rodriguez Mar 2014 B2
8675181 Hall Mar 2014 B2
8675184 Schmitt Mar 2014 B2
8692980 Gilliland Apr 2014 B2
8692983 Chapman Apr 2014 B1
8712147 Rahmes Apr 2014 B2
8717545 Sebastian May 2014 B2
8724099 Asahara May 2014 B2
8736818 Weimer May 2014 B2
8767187 Coda Jul 2014 B2
8767190 Hall Jul 2014 B2
8775081 Welty Jul 2014 B2
8781790 Zhu Jul 2014 B2
8786835 Reardon Jul 2014 B1
8797512 Stettner Aug 2014 B2
8798372 Korchev Aug 2014 B1
8798841 Nickolaou Aug 2014 B1
8804101 Spagnolia Aug 2014 B2
8818124 Kia Aug 2014 B1
8818722 Elgersma Aug 2014 B2
8829417 Krill Sep 2014 B2
8836922 Pennecot Sep 2014 B1
8855848 Zeng Oct 2014 B2
8855849 Ferguson Oct 2014 B1
8885883 Goodman Nov 2014 B2
8891069 Pedersen Nov 2014 B2
8896818 Walsh Nov 2014 B2
8915709 Westergaard Dec 2014 B2
8938362 Ionov Jan 2015 B2
8939081 Smith Jan 2015 B1
8947644 Halmos Feb 2015 B2
8947647 Halmos Feb 2015 B2
8958057 Kane Feb 2015 B2
8976339 Phillips Mar 2015 B2
8976340 Gilliland Mar 2015 B2
8976342 Lacondemine Mar 2015 B2
9002511 Hickerson Apr 2015 B1
9007569 AmZajerdian Apr 2015 B2
9007570 Beyon Apr 2015 B1
9041915 Earhart May 2015 B2
9046600 James Jun 2015 B2
9056395 Ferguson Jun 2015 B1
9057605 Halmos Jun 2015 B2
9069059 Vogt Jun 2015 B2
9069061 Harwit Jun 2015 B1
9069080 Stettner Jun 2015 B2
9081090 Sebastian Jul 2015 B2
9086275 Weinberg Jul 2015 B2
9086486 Gilliland Jul 2015 B2
9098753 Zhu Aug 2015 B1
9103907 Sebastian Aug 2015 B2
9110154 Bates Aug 2015 B1
9110163 Rogan Aug 2015 B2
9110169 Stettner Aug 2015 B2
9111444 Kaganovich Aug 2015 B2
9128185 Zeng Sep 2015 B2
9128190 Ulrich Sep 2015 B1
9129211 Zeng Sep 2015 B2
9134402 Sebastian Sep 2015 B2
9146102 Pernstich Sep 2015 B2
9146316 Gammenthaler Sep 2015 B2
9165383 Mendez-Rodriguez Oct 2015 B1
9170096 Fowler Oct 2015 B2
9188674 Suzuki Nov 2015 B2
9188677 Bossert Nov 2015 B2
9201146 Beyon Dec 2015 B2
9215382 Hilde Dec 2015 B1
9223025 Debrunner Dec 2015 B2
9229108 Debrunner Jan 2016 B2
9229109 Stettner Jan 2016 B2
9244272 Schiltz Jan 2016 B2
9255989 Joshi Feb 2016 B2
9277204 Gilliland Mar 2016 B2
9285464 Pennecot Mar 2016 B2
9300321 Zalik Mar 2016 B2
9310471 Sayyah Apr 2016 B2
9310487 Sakimura Apr 2016 B2
9315192 Zhu Apr 2016 B1
9335414 Leyva May 2016 B2
9354317 Halmos May 2016 B2
9354825 Kozak May 2016 B2
9360554 Retterath Jun 2016 B2
9360555 Oh Jun 2016 B2
9361412 Hilde Jun 2016 B1
9366938 Anderson Jun 2016 B1
9369689 Tran Jun 2016 B1
9378463 Zeng Jun 2016 B2
9383447 Schmitt Jul 2016 B2
9383753 Templeton Jul 2016 B1
9407285 Kozak Aug 2016 B2
9420177 Pettegrew Aug 2016 B2
9420264 Gilliland Aug 2016 B2
9425654 Lenius Aug 2016 B2
9448110 Wong Sep 2016 B2
9453907 Zheleznyak Sep 2016 B2
9453914 Stettner Sep 2016 B2
9453941 Stainvas Olshansky Sep 2016 B2
9465112 Stettner Oct 2016 B2
9470520 Schwarz Oct 2016 B2
9476968 Anderson Oct 2016 B2
9476983 Zeng Oct 2016 B2
9489746 Sebastian Nov 2016 B2
9495466 Geringer Nov 2016 B2
9519979 Hilde Dec 2016 B1
9523772 Rogan Dec 2016 B2
9525863 Nawasara Dec 2016 B2
9529087 Stainvas Olshansky Dec 2016 B2
9530062 Nguyen Dec 2016 B2
9547074 Schulz Jan 2017 B2
9575162 Owechko Feb 2017 B2
9575164 Kim Feb 2017 B2
9575184 Gilliland Feb 2017 B2
9575341 Heck Feb 2017 B2
9588220 Rondeau Mar 2017 B2
9599468 Walsh Mar 2017 B2
9599714 Imaki Mar 2017 B2
9602224 McLaughlin Mar 2017 B1
9606236 Rojas Mar 2017 B2
9625580 Kotelnikov Apr 2017 B2
9625582 Gruver Apr 2017 B2
9651658 Pennecot May 2017 B2
9658322 Lewis May 2017 B2
9658337 Ray May 2017 B2
9678199 Hutson Jun 2017 B2
9702975 Brinkmeyer Jul 2017 B2
9710714 Chen Jul 2017 B2
9735885 Sayyah Aug 2017 B1
9753124 Hayes Sep 2017 B2
9753462 Gilliland Sep 2017 B2
9759809 Derenick Sep 2017 B2
9772399 Schwarz Sep 2017 B2
9778362 Rondeau Oct 2017 B2
9784840 Pedersen Oct 2017 B2
9790924 Bayon Oct 2017 B2
9791555 Zhu Oct 2017 B2
9791557 Wyrwas Oct 2017 B1
9797995 Gilliland Oct 2017 B2
9804264 Villeneuve Oct 2017 B2
9810775 Welford Nov 2017 B1
9810776 Sapir Nov 2017 B2
9810777 Williams Nov 2017 B2
9810786 Welford Nov 2017 B1
9812838 Villeneuve Nov 2017 B2
9823118 Doylend Nov 2017 B2
9823350 Fluckiger Nov 2017 B2
9823351 Haslim Nov 2017 B2
9823353 Eichenholz Nov 2017 B2
9830509 Zang Nov 2017 B2
9831630 Lipson Nov 2017 B2
9834209 Stettner Dec 2017 B2
9841495 Campbell Dec 2017 B2
9851433 Sebastian Dec 2017 B2
9851442 Lo Dec 2017 B1
RE46672 Hall Jan 2018 E
9857473 Kim Jan 2018 B2
9860770 McLaughlin Jan 2018 B1
9869753 Eldada Jan 2018 B2
9869754 Campbell Jan 2018 B1
9870512 Rogan Jan 2018 B2
9872010 Tran Jan 2018 B2
9874635 Eichenholz Jan 2018 B1
9877009 Tran Jan 2018 B2
9880263 Droz Jan 2018 B2
9880281 Gilliland Jan 2018 B2
9881220 Koravadi Jan 2018 B2
9882433 Lenius Jan 2018 B2
9885778 Dussan Feb 2018 B2
9891711 Lee Feb 2018 B1
9892567 Binion Feb 2018 B2
9897687 Campbell Feb 2018 B1
9897689 Dussan Feb 2018 B2
9904375 Donnelly Feb 2018 B1
9905032 Rogan Feb 2018 B2
9905987 Seo Feb 2018 B2
9905992 Welford Feb 2018 B1
9910136 Heo Mar 2018 B2
9910139 Pennecot Mar 2018 B2
9910155 Lundquist Mar 2018 B2
9915726 Bailey Mar 2018 B2
9921297 Jungwirth Mar 2018 B2
9921307 Schmalengurg Mar 2018 B2
9927524 Kaiser Mar 2018 B2
9933513 Dussan Apr 2018 B2
9933514 Gylys Apr 2018 B1
9945950 Newman Apr 2018 B2
9958545 Eichenholz May 2018 B2
9971024 Schwarz May 2018 B2
9971035 Imaki May 2018 B2
9983297 Hall May 2018 B2
9983590 Templeton May 2018 B2
9985071 Irish May 2018 B2
9989969 Eustice Jun 2018 B2
10000000 Marron Jun 2018 B2
10012474 Teetzel Jul 2018 B2
10012723 Lindskog Jul 2018 B2
10012732 Eichenholz Jul 2018 B2
10018711 Sebastian Jul 2018 B1
10018725 Liu Jul 2018 B2
10018726 Hall Jul 2018 B2
10019803 Venable Jul 2018 B2
10024964 Pierce Jul 2018 B2
10031214 Rosenweig Jul 2018 B2
10031231 Zermas Jul 2018 B2
10031232 Zohar Jul 2018 B2
10032369 Koravadi Jul 2018 B2
10036801 Reterrath Jul 2018 B2
10036803 Pacala Jul 2018 B2
D826746 Qiu Aug 2018 S
10042042 Miremadi Aug 2018 B2
10042043 Dussan Aug 2018 B2
10042159 Dussan Aug 2018 B2
10046187 Doten Aug 2018 B2
10048359 Zhelenyzak Aug 2018 B2
10048374 Hall Aug 2018 B2
10054841 Nomura Aug 2018 B2
10061019 Campbell Aug 2018 B1
10061020 Slobodyanyuk Aug 2018 B2
10061266 Christmas Sep 2018 B2
10067230 Smits Sep 2018 B2
10073166 Dussan Sep 2018 B2
10078133 Dussan Sep 2018 B2
10078137 Ludwig Sep 2018 B2
10088557 Yeun Oct 2018 B2
10088558 Dussan Oct 2018 B2
10094657 Kiss Oct 2018 B2
10094916 Droz Oct 2018 B1
10094925 LaChapelle Oct 2018 B1
10094928 Josset Oct 2018 B2
10107914 Kalscheur Oct 2018 B2
10107915 Rozenzweig Oct 2018 B2
10109208 Cherepinsky Oct 2018 B2
10114109 Gazit Oct 2018 B2
10114112 Slobodyanyuk Oct 2018 B2
10115024 Stein Oct 2018 B2
10120076 Scheim Nov 2018 B2
10121813 Eichenholz Nov 2018 B2
10126411 Gilliland Nov 2018 B2
10126412 Eldada Nov 2018 B2
10131446 Stambler Nov 2018 B1
10132928 Eldada Nov 2018 B2
10139478 Gaalema Nov 2018 B2
10142538 Hurd Nov 2018 B2
10145941 Lee Dec 2018 B2
10145944 Shchemelinin Dec 2018 B1
10145945 Harada Dec 2018 B2
10148060 Hong Dec 2018 B2
10151836 O'Keeffe Dec 2018 B2
10168423 Lombrozo Jan 2019 B2
10168429 Maleki Jan 2019 B2
10175344 Jungwirth Jan 2019 B2
10175361 Haines Jan 2019 B2
10180493 Eldada Jan 2019 B2
10185027 O'Keeffe Jan 2019 B2
10185028 Dussan Jan 2019 B2
10185033 Justice Jan 2019 B2
10191156 Steinberg Jan 2019 B2
10197669 Hall Feb 2019 B2
10197676 Slobodyyanyuk Feb 2019 B2
10197765 Schulz Feb 2019 B2
10203399 Retterath Feb 2019 B2
10203401 Sebastian Feb 2019 B2
10209349 Dussan Feb 2019 B2
10209359 Russell Feb 2019 B2
10209709 Peters Feb 2019 B2
10214299 Jackowski Feb 2019 B2
10215846 Carothers Feb 2019 B2
10215847 Scheim Feb 2019 B2
10215848 Dussan Feb 2019 B2
10215859 Steinberg Feb 2019 B2
10222474 Raring Mar 2019 B1
10222477 Keilaf Mar 2019 B2
10223806 Luo Mar 2019 B1
10223807 Luo Mar 2019 B1
10241196 Bailey Mar 2019 B2
10241198 LaChappelle Mar 2019 B2
10247811 Clifton Apr 2019 B2
10254402 Lane Apr 2019 B2
10254405 Campbell Apr 2019 B2
10261006 Ray Apr 2019 B2
10261187 Halmos Apr 2019 B2
10262234 Li Apr 2019 B2
10267898 Campbell Apr 2019 B2
10267918 LaChapelle Apr 2019 B2
10274377 Rabb Apr 2019 B1
10274599 Schmalenberg Apr 2019 B2
D849573 Haban May 2019 S
10281254 Ginsberg May 2019 B2
10281322 Doyland May 2019 B2
10281564 Low May 2019 B2
10281581 Lipson May 2019 B2
10281582 Elooz May 2019 B2
10288736 Lipson May 2019 B2
10288737 Mooney May 2019 B2
10295656 Li May 2019 B1
10295660 McMichael May 2019 B1
10295668 LaChapelle May 2019 B2
10295670 Stettner May 2019 B2
10295671 Grazit May 2019 B2
10295672 Abari May 2019 B2
10295673 Tucker May 2019 B1
10302746 O'Keeffee May 2019 B2
10302749 Droz May 2019 B2
D850306 Bainter Jun 2019 S
10310058 Campbell Jun 2019 B1
10310087 Laddha Jun 2019 B2
10317529 Shy Jun 2019 B2
10317533 Cherepinsky Jun 2019 B2
10324170 Enberg Jun 2019 B1
10324185 McWhirter Jun 2019 B2
10330777 Popovich Jun 2019 B2
10330778 Kaneda Jun 2019 B2
10330780 Hall Jun 2019 B2
10331956 Solar Jun 2019 B2
10353074 Justice Jun 2019 B2
10337996 Blagojevic Jul 2019 B2
10338201 Slobodyyanyuk Jul 2019 B2
10338202 Mashtare Jul 2019 B2
10338220 Raring Jul 2019 B1
10338224 Eken Jul 2019 B2
10338225 Boehmke Jul 2019 B2
10340651 Drummer Jul 2019 B1
10345446 Raring Jul 2019 B2
10345447 Hicks Jul 2019 B1
10346695 Clifford Jul 2019 B2
10351103 Yeo Jul 2019 B2
10353057 Suzuki Jul 2019 B2
10353075 Buskila Jul 2019 B2
10359507 Berger Jul 2019 B2
10366282 Lee Jul 2019 B2
10372138 Gilliland Aug 2019 B2
10377373 Stettner Aug 2019 B2
10379135 Maryfield Aug 2019 B2
10379205 Dussan Aug 2019 B2
10379220 Smits Aug 2019 B1
10379540 Droz Aug 2019 B2
10386464 Dussan Aug 2019 B2
10386465 Hall Aug 2019 B2
10386487 Wilton Aug 2019 B1
10386488 Ridderbusch Aug 2019 B2
10393863 Sun Aug 2019 B2
10393877 Hall Aug 2019 B2
10394345 Donnelly Aug 2019 B2
10401480 Gaalema Sep 2019 B1
10401484 Lee Sep 2019 B2
10401500 Yang Sep 2019 B2
10401866 Rust Sep 2019 B2
10408926 Slobodyyabnyuk Sep 2019 B2
10408936 Van Voorst Sep 2019 B2
10408939 Kim Sep 2019 B1
10408940 O'Keeffe Sep 2019 B2
10416292 de Mersseman Sep 2019 B2
10418776 Welford Sep 2019 B2
10422862 Gnecchi Sep 2019 B2
10422863 Choi Sep 2019 B2
10422865 Irish Sep 2019 B2
10386467 Dussan Oct 2019 B2
10429243 Yu Oct 2019 B2
10429495 Wang Oct 2019 B1
10429496 Weinberg Oct 2019 B2
10429507 Sebastian Oct 2019 B2
10429511 Bosetti Oct 2019 B2
10430970 Bier Oct 2019 B2
10436882 Meng Oct 2019 B2
10436904 Moss Oct 2019 B2
10436907 Murray Oct 2019 B1
10444330 Stann Oct 2019 B2
10444356 Wu Oct 2019 B2
10444362 Schaefer Oct 2019 B2
10444367 Lodden Oct 2019 B2
10445928 Nehmadi Oct 2019 B2
10447973 Droz Oct 2019 B2
10451716 Hughes Oct 2019 B2
10451740 Pei Oct 2019 B2
10451742 Christmas Oct 2019 B2
10458904 Batholomew Oct 2019 B2
10466342 Zhu Nov 2019 B1
10469753 Yang Nov 2019 B2
10473763 Schwarz Nov 2019 B2
10473767 Xiang Nov 2019 B2
10473768 Walsh Nov 2019 B2
10473770 Zhu Nov 2019 B1
10473784 Puglia Nov 2019 B2
10474160 Huang Nov 2019 B2
10474161 Huang Nov 2019 B2
10481267 Wang Nov 2019 B2
10481268 Vlaiko Nov 2019 B2
10482740 Fang Nov 2019 B2
10488495 Sebastian Nov 2019 B2
10488496 Campbell Nov 2019 B2
10488497 Cheong Nov 2019 B2
10491052 Lenius Nov 2019 B2
10491855 Gates Nov 2019 B2
10495757 Dussan Dec 2019 B2
10502813 Schultz Dec 2019 B2
10503174 Lim Dec 2019 B1
10503175 Agarwal Dec 2019 B2
10509111 Park Dec 2019 B2
10509112 Pan Dec 2019 B1
10509120 Bilik Dec 2019 B2
10509198 Zhou Dec 2019 B1
10514444 Donovan Dec 2019 B2
10514447 Schwarz Dec 2019 B2
10520591 Kotelnikov Dec 2019 B2
10520592 Droz Dec 2019 B2
10520602 Villeneuve Dec 2019 B2
10523880 Gassend Dec 2019 B2
10527726 Bartlett Jan 2020 B2
10531004 Wheeler Jan 2020 B2
10534074 Slobodyyanyuk Jan 2020 B2
10534079 Kim Jan 2020 B2
10539116 Davoust Jan 2020 B2
10539661 Hall Jan 2020 B2
10539663 Liu Jan 2020 B2
10545222 Hall Jan 2020 B2
10545238 Rezk Jan 2020 B1
10545240 Campbell Jan 2020 B2
10545289 Chriqui Jan 2020 B1
10552691 Li Feb 2020 B2
10556585 Berger Feb 2020 B1
10557923 Watnik Feb 2020 B2
10557924 Jang Feb 2020 B1
10557926 Gilliland Feb 2020 B2
10557927 Marron Feb 2020 B2
10557929 Kajiyama Feb 2020 B2
10557939 Campbell Feb 2020 B2
10557940 Eichenholz Feb 2020 B2
10557942 Belsey Feb 2020 B2
10564261 Huebner Feb 2020 B2
10564263 Efimov Feb 2020 B2
10564266 O'Keeffe Feb 2020 B2
10564285 Belsley Feb 2020 B2
10565457 Luo Feb 2020 B2
10571552 Gao Feb 2020 B1
10571567 Campbell Feb 2020 B2
10571570 Paulsen Feb 2020 B1
10571574 Yavid Feb 2020 B1
10571683 Low Feb 2020 B2
10576011 Krishnan Mar 2020 B1
10578717 Bucina Mar 2020 B2
10578719 O'Keeffe Mar 2020 B2
10578720 Hughes Mar 2020 B2
10578721 Jang Mar 2020 B2
10578724 Droz Mar 2020 B2
10578742 Guo Mar 2020 B2
10585174 Gnecchi Mar 2020 B2
10585175 Reterath Mar 2020 B2
10591598 Jeong Mar 2020 B2
10591599 O'keeffe Mar 2020 B2
10591600 Villeneuve Mar 2020 B2
10591601 Hicks Mar 2020 B2
10591604 Xu Mar 2020 B2
10591740 McMichael Mar 2020 B2
10598769 Rodrigo Mar 2020 B2
10598770 Singer Mar 2020 B2
10598788 Dussan Mar 2020 B1
10598791 Jain Mar 2020 B2
10598922 Low Mar 2020 B2
10600930 Suzuki Mar 2020 B2
10605899 Singer Mar 2020 B2
10605900 Spuler Mar 2020 B2
10605918 Wong Mar 2020 B2
10605924 Slutsky Mar 2020 B2
RE47942 Hall Apr 2020 E
D882430 Haban Apr 2020 S
10551501 LaChapelle Apr 2020 B1
10613200 Hallstig Apr 2020 B2
10613201 Pacala Apr 2020 B2
10613204 Warke Apr 2020 B2
10613224 Jeong Apr 2020 B2
10620301 Wilton Apr 2020 B2
10620302 Zhu Apr 2020 B2
10620315 Zellinger Apr 2020 B2
10620317 Chai Apr 2020 B1
10620318 Yi Apr 2020 B2
10627490 Hall Apr 2020 B2
10627491 Hall Apr 2020 B2
10627492 Shand Apr 2020 B2
10627495 Gaalema Apr 2020 B2
10627512 Hicks Apr 2020 B1
10627516 Eichenholz Apr 2020 B2
10629072 Felix Apr 2020 B2
10630913 Wei Apr 2020 B2
10634772 Eckstein Apr 2020 B2
10634793 Siao Apr 2020 B1
10641870 Magnani May 2020 B1
10641872 Dussan May 2020 B2
10641873 Dussan May 2020 B2
10641874 Campbell May 2020 B2
10641876 Field May 2020 B2
10641877 Lombrozo May 2020 B2
10641878 Yeo May 2020 B2
10641897 Dussan May 2020 B1
10641900 Dussan May 2020 B2
10642029 Dussan May 2020 B2
10649072 Bozchalooi May 2020 B2
10649086 Raring May 2020 B2
10650531 Lakshmi Narayanan May 2020 B2
10656252 Dussan May 2020 B1
10656272 Dussan May 2020 B1
10656277 Dussan May 2020 B1
10663584 Sakai May 2020 B2
10663587 Sandborn May 2020 B1
10663590 Rzeszutek May 2020 B2
10663596 Dussan May 2020 B2
RE48042 Pennecot Jun 2020 E
10670460 Waterbury Jun 2020 B1
10670702 Choi Jun 2020 B2
10670718 Dussan Jun 2020 B1
10670721 Efimov Jun 2020 B2
10670724 Moon Jun 2020 B2
10677897 LaChapelle Jun 2020 B2
10677925 Boehmke Jun 2020 B2
10684359 Axelsson Jun 2020 B2
10684360 Campbell Jun 2020 B2
10690754 Pei Jun 2020 B2
10690756 Warke Jun 2020 B2
10690772 Van Voorst Jun 2020 B2
10697582 Campbell Jun 2020 B2
10698088 Droz Jun 2020 B2
10698114 Keilaf Jun 2020 B2
10705189 Qiu Jul 2020 B2
10705190 Jang Jul 2020 B2
10712433 Carothers Jul 2020 B2
10712434 Hall Jul 2020 B2
10714889 Hong Jul 2020 B2
10725156 Halmos Jul 2020 B2
10725177 Smits Jul 2020 B2
10726567 Lee Jul 2020 B2
10726579 Huang Jul 2020 B1
10732264 Bailey Aug 2020 B2
10732266 Popovich Aug 2020 B2
10732279 Schlotterbeck Aug 2020 B2
10732281 LaChapelle Aug 2020 B2
10732287 Korsgard Jensen Aug 2020 B2
10739440 Shimizu Aug 2020 B2
10739441 Nabbe Aug 2020 B2
10739444 Hall Aug 2020 B2
10739459 Castorena Martinez Aug 2020 B2
10739461 Agarwal Aug 2020 B2
10746858 Bradley Aug 2020 B2
10754009 Sung Aug 2020 B2
10754012 Galloway Aug 2020 B2
10754033 Shand Aug 2020 B2
10754034 Chamberlain Aug 2020 B1
10761191 Qiu Sep 2020 B2
10761195 Donovan Sep 2020 B2
10761196 Dussan Sep 2020 B2
10762673 Luo Sep 2020 B2
10763290 Akselrod Sep 2020 B2
10768282 Crouch Sep 2020 B2
10768303 Xiong Sep 2020 B2
10775484 Jeong Sep 2020 B2
10775485 Shim Sep 2020 B2
10775488 Bradley Sep 2020 B2
10775507 Mandai Sep 2020 B2
10782393 Dussan Sep 2020 B2
10782399 Lee Sep 2020 B2
10782409 Wang Sep 2020 B2
10788574 Shim Sep 2020 B2
10732283 Gilliland Oct 2020 B2
10754015 Dussan Oct 2020 B2
10791884 Starkey Oct 2020 B2
10794998 Spuler Oct 2020 B2
10795000 Singer Oct 2020 B2
10796457 Beek Oct 2020 B2
10802119 Yoon Oct 2020 B2
10802120 LaChapelle Oct 2020 B1
10802122 Goldberg Oct 2020 B1
10802149 Stettner Oct 2020 B2
10809361 Vallespi-Gonzalez Oct 2020 B2
10809362 Fredericksen Oct 2020 B2
10809380 Pacala Oct 2020 B2
10816647 Xiang Oct 2020 B2
10816648 Pennecot Oct 2020 B2
10816649 Keyser Oct 2020 B1
10818091 Evans Oct 2020 B2
10819082 Josset Oct 2020 B2
10821942 Green Nov 2020 B2
10823855 Li Nov 2020 B2
10830877 Chawla Nov 2020 B1
10830878 McMichael Nov 2020 B2
10830880 Subasingha Nov 2020 B2
10830890 Keyser Nov 2020 B1
10837773 Yang Nov 2020 B2
10838042 Badoni Nov 2020 B2
10838045 Crouch Nov 2020 B2
10838046 Qui Nov 2020 B2
10838047 Chong Nov 2020 B2
10838048 Field Nov 2020 B2
10838049 Schwiesow Nov 2020 B1
10838062 de Mersseman Nov 2020 B2
10841496 Wheeler Nov 2020 B2
10844838 Schlipf Nov 2020 B2
10845464 Schwarz Nov 2020 B2
10845466 Pei Nov 2020 B2
10845468 Marron Nov 2020 B2
10845470 Verghese Nov 2020 B2
10845480 Shah Nov 2020 B1
10845482 Frederiksen Nov 2020 B2
10845587 Low Nov 2020 B2
10852397 Schwarz Dec 2020 B2
10852398 Yu Dec 2020 B2
10852426 Shan Dec 2020 B2
10852433 Chen Dec 2020 B2
10852437 Eken Dec 2020 B2
10852438 Hartman Dec 2020 B2
10859683 Lin Dec 2020 B2
10859684 Nabatchian Dec 2020 B1
10866312 Crouch Dec 2020 B2
10866319 Brinkmeyer Dec 2020 B2
10871554 Keyser Dec 2020 B1
10871779 Templeton Dec 2020 B2
10872269 Roy Chowdhury Dec 2020 B2
10877131 Singer Dec 2020 B2
10877134 Han Dec 2020 B2
10877154 Bronstein Dec 2020 B2
10878282 Mei Dec 2020 B2
10878580 Mei Dec 2020 B2
10879415 Kwon Dec 2020 B2
10884126 Shu Jan 2021 B2
10884129 Wu Jan 2021 B2
10884130 Viswanatha Jan 2021 B1
10884131 Allais Jan 2021 B1
10884411 Allais Jan 2021 B1
10890650 Droz Jan 2021 B2
10891744 Wyffels Jan 2021 B1
10897575 Wheeler Jan 2021 B2
10901074 Pan Jan 2021 B1
10901089 Zhang Jan 2021 B2
10901292 Jeong Jan 2021 B2
D909216 Vuletici Feb 2021 S
10908080 Salazar Feb 2021 B2
10908262 Dussan Feb 2021 B2
10908264 O'Keeffe Feb 2021 B2
10908265 Dussan Feb 2021 B2
10908267 Gagne Feb 2021 B1
10908268 Zhou Feb 2021 B2
10908282 Meyers Feb 2021 B2
10908287 Warke Feb 2021 B2
10908372 Moebius Feb 2021 B2
10908409 Zhou Feb 2021 B2
10914821 Patterson Feb 2021 B2
10914822 Kremer Feb 2021 B2
10914824 Meng Feb 2021 B2
10914825 Coda Feb 2021 B2
10914839 Hartmann Feb 2021 B2
10914841 Crouch Feb 2021 B2
10921431 Pei Feb 2021 B2
10921450 Dussan Feb 2021 B2
10921452 Crouch Feb 2021 B2
10921453 Dumais Feb 2021 B2
10922880 Scanlon Feb 2021 B2
10928485 Karadeniz Feb 2021 B1
10928486 Donovan Feb 2021 B2
10928487 O'Keeffe Feb 2021 B2
10928488 Sun Feb 2021 B2
10928490 Tatipamula Feb 2021 B2
10928519 Schaffner Feb 2021 B2
10929694 Zhang Feb 2021 B1
RE48490 Hall Mar 2021 E
RE48491 Hall Mar 2021 E
10935637 Cullumber Mar 2021 B2
10935640 Jackson Mar 2021 B2
10935658 Park Mar 2021 B2
10935659 Smits Mar 2021 B2
10939057 Gassend Mar 2021 B2
10942257 Bao Mar 2021 B2
10942260 Low Mar 2021 B2
10942272 Droz Mar 2021 B2
10942277 Angus Mar 2021 B1
10948598 Prabhakar Mar 2021 B1
10951864 Droz Mar 2021 B2
10955530 Pei Mar 2021 B2
10955532 Gilliland Mar 2021 B2
10955533 Konrad Mar 2021 B2
10955534 Halmos Mar 2021 B2
10955545 Hunt Mar 2021 B1
10955952 Gwon Mar 2021 B2
10962644 Kong Mar 2021 B1
10962647 Shin Mar 2021 B2
10965379 Brown Mar 2021 B2
RE48503 Hall Apr 2021 E
RE48504 Hall Apr 2021 E
10969474 O'keeffe Apr 2021 B2
10969475 Li Apr 2021 B2
10969489 Schmitt Apr 2021 B2
10969491 Krause Perin Apr 2021 B1
10976413 Han Apr 2021 B2
10976414 Sayyah Apr 2021 B2
10976417 LaChapelle Apr 2021 B2
10979644 Jamjoom Apr 2021 B2
10983197 Zhu Apr 2021 B1
10983201 Pimentel Apr 2021 B2
10983213 Eichenholz Apr 2021 B2
10983215 Li Apr 2021 B2
10983218 Hall Apr 2021 B2
10983219 Kotov Apr 2021 B2
10984540 Mei Apr 2021 B2
10989796 Liu Apr 2021 B2
10989914 Ramsey Apr 2021 B2
10996322 Buettner May 2021 B2
10996334 Datta May 2021 B2
10999511 Yang May 2021 B2
11002832 Sayyah May 2021 B2
11002834 Kaestner May 2021 B2
11002837 Barber May 2021 B2
11002839 Shi May 2021 B2
11002852 Cao May 2021 B2
11002853 McWhirter May 2021 B2
11002857 Dussan May 2021 B2
11003137 Christmas May 2021 B2
11009592 Wilton May 2021 B2
11009605 Li May 2021 B2
11016178 Donovan May 2021 B2
11016181 Schwarz May 2021 B2
11016183 Gill May 2021 B2
11016195 Balbas May 2021 B2
11016197 Barber May 2021 B1
11016496 Chen May 2021 B2
11022682 Konrad Jun 2021 B2
11022688 Eichenholz Jun 2021 B2
11022689 Villeneuve Jun 2021 B2
11022691 Frederiksen Jun 2021 B2
11022693 Allais Jun 2021 B1
11024669 Rezk Jun 2021 B2
11027726 Stettner Jun 2021 B2
11029393 Li Jun 2021 B2
11029394 Li Jun 2021 B2
11029395 Barber Jun 2021 B1
11029398 Hwang Jun 2021 B2
11029406 LaChapelle Jun 2021 B2
11035933 Demir Jun 2021 B2
11035957 Shotan Jun 2021 B2
11041942 Ruchatz Jun 2021 B2
11041944 Zhu Jun 2021 B2
11041954 Crouch Jun 2021 B2
11041956 Harris Jun 2021 B2
11041957 Uehara Jun 2021 B2
11043005 Wallin Jun 2021 B2
11047958 Choiniere Jun 2021 B1
11047963 Viswanatha Jun 2021 B1
11047983 Prabhakar Jun 2021 B1
11054505 Droz Jul 2021 B2
11054508 Li Jul 2021 B2
11054523 Buchter Jul 2021 B1
11054524 Rezk Jul 2021 B2
11061116 Gao Jul 2021 B2
11061140 Hosseini Jul 2021 B2
11063408 Jang Jul 2021 B2
11067670 Patterson Jul 2021 B2
11067671 Chong Jul 2021 B2
11067673 Wei Jul 2021 B2
11067676 Yang Jul 2021 B2
11067693 Walls Jul 2021 B2
11119218 Patterson Sep 2021 B2
11150349 Chen Oct 2021 B2
11156716 Yavid Oct 2021 B1
20020140294 Iwata Oct 2002 A1
20050173770 Linden et al. Aug 2005 A1
20070035624 Lubard Feb 2007 A1
20090273770 Bauhahn Nov 2009 A1
20100053715 O'Neil Mar 2010 A1
20100204974 Israelsen Aug 2010 A1
20120170024 Azzazy Jul 2012 A1
20120170029 Azzazy Jul 2012 A1
20120236379 da Silva Sep 2012 A1
20130120734 Ogata May 2013 A1
20130242283 Bailey Sep 2013 A1
20140168634 Kameyama Jun 2014 A1
20150192677 Yu Jul 2015 A1
20150301180 Stettner Oct 2015 A1
20150329111 Prokhorov Nov 2015 A1
20160162743 Chundrlik Jun 2016 A1
20170328990 Magee Nov 2017 A1
20200101890 Solar Apr 2020 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (181)
Number Date Country
1106534 Aug 1995 CN
1576123 Feb 2005 CN
2681085 Feb 2006 CN
2773714 Apr 2006 CN
103278808 Dec 2015 CN
104299244 Jul 2017 CN
206773192 Dec 2017 CN
106443699 Feb 2019 CN
106597471 May 2019 CN
208902906 May 2019 CN
109997057 Jul 2020 CN
930909 Jul 1955 DE
3134815 Mar 1983 DE
3216312 Nov 1983 DE
3216313 Nov 1983 DE
3701340 Jul 1988 DE
3741259 Jun 1989 DE
3808972 Oct 1989 DE
3821892 Feb 1990 DE
4040894 Apr 1992 DE
4115747 Nov 1992 DE
4124192 Jan 1993 DE
4127168 Feb 1993 DE
4137550 Mar 1993 DE
4215272 Nov 1993 DE
4243631 Jun 1994 DE
4340756 Jun 1994 DE
4411448 Oct 1995 DE
4412044 Oct 1995 DE
19512644 Oct 1996 DE
19512681 Oct 1996 DE
4345446 Jul 1998 DE
4345448 Jul 1998 DE
19727792 Feb 1999 DE
19741730 Apr 1999 DE
19741731 Apr 1999 DE
19752145 May 1999 DE
19717399 Jun 1999 DE
19757847 Jul 1999 DE
19757848 Jul 1999 DE
19757849 Jul 1999 DE
19757840 Sep 1999 DE
19815149 Oct 1999 DE
19828000 Jan 2000 DE
19902903 May 2000 DE
19911375 Sep 2000 DE
19919925 Nov 2000 DE
19927501 Nov 2000 DE
19936440 Mar 2001 DE
19953006 May 2001 DE
19953007 May 2001 DE
19953009 May 2001 DE
19953010 May 2001 DE
10025511 Dec 2001 DE
10110420 Sep 2002 DE
10114362 Oct 2002 DE
10127417 Dec 2002 DE
10128954 Dec 2002 DE
10141055 Mar 2003 DE
10143060 Mar 2003 DE
10146692 Apr 2003 DE
10148070 Apr 2003 DE
10151983 Apr 2003 DE
10162668 Jul 2003 DE
10217295 Nov 2003 DE
10222797 Dec 2003 DE
10229408 Jan 2004 DE
10244638 Apr 2004 DE
10244640 Apr 2004 DE
10244643 Apr 2004 DE
10258794 Jun 2004 DE
10303015 Aug 2004 DE
10331529 Jan 2005 DE
10341548 Mar 2005 DE
102004010197 Sep 2005 DE
102004014041 Oct 2005 DE
102005050824 May 2006 DE
102005003827 Jul 2006 DE
102005019233 Nov 2006 DE
102007013023 Sep 2008 DE
102007044536 Mar 2009 DE
202015009250 Jan 2017 DE
0185816 Jul 1986 EP
0361188 Apr 1990 EP
0396865 Nov 1990 EP
0412395 Feb 1991 EP
0412398 Feb 1991 EP
0412399 Feb 1991 EP
0412400 Feb 1991 EP
0468175 Jan 1992 EP
0486430 May 1992 EP
0653720 May 1995 EP
0656868 Jun 1995 EP
0897120 Feb 1999 EP
0913707 May 1999 EP
0937996 Aug 1999 EP
0967492 Dec 1999 EP
1046938 Oct 2000 EP
1055937 Nov 2000 EP
1148345 Oct 2001 EP
1160718 Dec 2001 EP
1174733 Jan 2002 EP
1267177 Dec 2002 EP
1267178 Dec 2002 EP
1286178 Feb 2003 EP
1286181 Feb 2003 EP
1288677 Mar 2003 EP
1291673 Mar 2003 EP
1291674 Mar 2003 EP
1298012 Apr 2003 EP
1298454 Apr 2003 EP
1298543 Apr 2003 EP
1300715 Apr 2003 EP
1302784 Apr 2003 EP
1304583 Apr 2003 EP
1306690 May 2003 EP
1308747 May 2003 EP
1355128 Oct 2003 EP
1403657 Mar 2004 EP
1408318 Apr 2004 EP
1418444 May 2004 EP
1460454 Sep 2004 EP
1475764 Nov 2004 EP
1515157 Mar 2005 EP
1531342 May 2005 EP
1531343 May 2005 EP
1548351 Jun 2005 EP
1557691 Jul 2005 EP
1557693 Jul 2005 EP
1557694 Jul 2005 EP
1557992 Jul 2005 EP
1700763 Sep 2006 EP
1914564 Apr 2008 EP
1927867 Jun 2008 EP
1939652 Jul 2008 EP
1947377 Jul 2008 EP
1965225 Sep 2008 EP
1983354 Oct 2008 EP
2003471 Dec 2008 EP
2177931 Apr 2010 EP
2503360 Sep 2012 EP
2631667 Aug 2013 EP
2994772 Mar 2016 EP
3029488 Jun 2016 EP
2122599 Nov 2019 EP
3671261 Jun 2020 EP
2041687 Sep 1980 GB
2251150 Jun 1992 GB
2463815 Mar 2010 GB
H36407 Jan 1991 JP
H05240940 Sep 1993 JP
H6288725 Oct 1994 JP
2011264871 Sep 1999 JP
2001216592 Aug 2001 JP
20012656576 Sep 2001 JP
2009086787 Apr 2009 JP
6039704 Dec 2016 JP
2017162204 Sep 2017 JP
2020521955 Jul 2020 JP
2480712 Apr 2013 RU
WO1999003080 Jan 1999 WO
WO2000025089 May 2000 WO
WO0131608 May 2001 WO
WO03019234 Mar 2003 WO
WO03040755 May 2003 WO
WO2004019293 Mar 2004 WO
WO2004036245 Apr 2004 WO
WO2008008970 Jan 2008 WO
WO2009120706 Oct 2009 WO
WO2010141631 Dec 2010 WO
WO2015079300 Jun 2015 WO
WO2015104572 Jul 2015 WO
WO2016162568 Oct 2016 WO
WO2017033419 Mar 2017 WO
WO2017089063 Jun 2017 WO
WO2017132703 Aug 2017 WO
WO2017164989 Sep 2017 WO
WO2017165316 Sep 2017 WO
WO2017193269 Nov 2017 WO
WO2018125823 Jul 2018 WO
WO2018196001 Nov 2018 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (1)
Entry
US 11,068,723 B1, 07/2021, Beijbom (withdrawn)
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20230143755 A1 May 2023 US
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
62295210 Feb 2016 US
Continuations (2)
Number Date Country
Parent 16744410 Jan 2020 US
Child 17394596 US
Parent 15432105 Feb 2017 US
Child 16744410 US