Patent Application
20140004137
The present invention relates to immune restricted peptides, and especially HLA-A2 restricted peptides. Further, the present invention relates to methods for providing the present immune restricted peptides and the use thereof in medicine and especially the use thereof in vaccines, immunosuppressive therapy, adoptive T cell therapy and diagnostics.
Existing and newly emerging diseases that threaten public health demand the development of new technologies combating, or preventing, these diseases. One approach to combat, or prevent, diseases is to use, or direct, the own defence system of a subject, i.e. the immune system, for example by vaccination, immunosuppressive therapy, or adoptive T cell therapy.
A vaccine is a biological preparation that stimulates, activates or improves the response of the immune system towards a particular disease or condition. Vaccines can be prophylactic, for example to prevent or ameliorate the effects of a future infection by a pathogen, or therapeutic, for example vaccines against cancer.
A classical vaccine typically contains an agent that mimics a disease-causing agent such as a microorganism, and is often made from weakened or killed forms of a pathogen.
Besides the above classical vaccines, considerable efforts have been made towards the development of subunit vaccines. Rather than introducing an inactivated or attenuated micro-organism in order to stimulate, activate or improve the immune system, a fragment, such as a peptide, is used.
Peptide vaccines are generally preparations comprising synthetic epitopes in the form of peptides, i.e. short strings of consecutive amino acid forming sequences up to 20, 30, 40 or 50 amino acids, representing one or more minimal immunogenic regions of a protein or antigen.
All nucleated cells present peptides that are derived, or originate, from intracellular proteins on their surface bound to MHC class I, whereas peptides derived, or originate, from extracellular proteins are mainly presented by MHC class II on specialised antigen-presenting cells, APCs, such as dendritic cells and macrophages.
In both cases, the T cell receptor or TCR on the surface of the cytolytic T lymphocyte, CTL, or TH cell forms a complex with the MHC I/peptide-epitope complex or the MHC II/peptide-epitope complex, respectively; these interactions are aided by the CD8 and CD4 co-receptors, respectively. The intricate interplay of these peptide-dependent recognition processes results in the initiation or propagation of immune responses controlling, for example, infections and cancer in a subject, such as a human subject.
Vaccines have been designed based on the use of short synthetic peptides which mimic the exact epitope recognised by cytolytic CD8+ T lymphocytes when associated with the restricting MHC complex. This limits the applicability of the vaccine to individuals of the appropriate MHC haplotype. Since HLA alleles are extremely polymorphic, the practical approach to this type of vaccination has focused the efforts on those peptides presented by the most frequent HLA alleles. HLA-A2, and to a lesser extent other alleles such as -A1, -A3, -B7, -B35, are alleles generally relevant for individuals of Caucasian origin.
Despite HLA allele restriction, peptide vaccines offer considerable advantages such as absence of infectious material capable of compromising live or attenuated vaccines. Furthermore, many pathogens can be difficult or impossible to culture by conventional methods. Peptide vaccine also offer the option to exclude deleterious sequences from full-length antigens, such as proteins, or other pathogen-derived molecules such as oncogenic compounds or compounds implicated in autoimmune diseases.
Peptides are easily characterised and analysed for purity using well-established analytical techniques such as liquid chromatography and mass spectrometry. This facilitates quality control and ultimately approval by the regulatory authorities.
The production of chemically defined peptides can be carried out economically on a large scale. Peptide preparations can be stored freeze-dried, which avoids the need to maintain a ‘cold-chain’ facility in storage, transport and distribution. There is no risk of reversion or formation of adverse reassortants that can lead to virulence, which is a potential problem associated with live attenuated vaccine preparations.
Peptide-based vaccines can be designed to include multiple determinants from several pathogens, or multiple epitopes from the same pathogen. The introduction of non-natural amino acids and peptide-like molecules into peptide-based vaccines allows the design of more drug-like compounds, which opens up avenues for vaccine delivery and rational drug design in vaccinology.
Despite the numerous advantages associated with the use of peptide vaccines, challenges in peptide vaccination strategies are, for example, the often low immunogenicity of the peptide, especially in the case of tumour antigens, the delivery of peptide epitopes to antigen presenting cells and premature peptide degradation by protease activity in the periphery or in APCs.
Modification of anchor amino acids by other naturally occurring amino acids may result in enhanced binding to the MHC and—together with peptides in which TCR binding is altered—such peptides are designated altered peptide ligands or APLs. Substitutions in the TCR interacting region by naturally occurring amino acid, or heteroclitic analogues, may cause hyperstimulation of the CTL thereby providing a more potent immune response compared with the native epitope. Alternatively heteroclitic analogues may antagonise autoreactive CTLs, leading to immunosuppression, which can be exploited for the treatment of autoimmune disease and prevention of organ rejection following allogeneic transplantation
Another strategy to improve the efficacy of peptide vaccines is the introduction into the peptide of non-naturally occurring amino acid residues, including incorporation of non-encoded alpha amino acids, photoreactive cross-linking of amino acids, beta-amino acids, backbone reduction, partial retro-inversion and incorporation of D-amino acids, N-terminal methylation and C-terminal amidation and pegylation. Synthetic engineering of peptide epitopes thus confers beneficial properties to the peptide vaccine such as improved MHC class I binding and TCR avidity, protease resistance, and oral bioavailability.
Immune restricted peptides, besides in vaccines, can also be used in immunosuppressive therapy and T cell antagonism. Currently, broad-spectrum drugs that generally suppress the immune system are used to reduce the risk of rejection after allogeneic organ transplantation (host versus graft reaction) or to lower the risk of Graft-versus-Host Disease after hematopoietic stem cell (bone marrow) transplantation.
CD8+ T cells have been implicated in mediating Graft-versus-Host Disease, but also early allograft rejection, indicating an important role for MHC class I. Also the treatment of autoimmune diseases is based on immunosuppression. The selective knock-down of autoimmune or rejective responses is desirable and hitherto research has been focused on the design of modified versions of the natural pathogenic viral or self-antigenic peptides.
These altered peptide ligands (APLs) are epitopes in which one or multiple of the naturally occurring amino acid residues are replaced by another amino acid residue. They either block the MHC peptide binding groove, inhibiting binding to the TCR, or they antagonise the TCR, i.e. interaction with the TCR does take place, but without the onset of signalling.
Optimisation of immunogenic peptides is valuable for the generation of MHC multimers, which are widely used for epitope restricted T cell detection and isolation for adoptive T cell therapy.
Typically, a substantial proportion of T cell defined tumour-derived antigenic peptides are suboptimal for binding to HLA, with consequent fast dissociation from MHC and weak immunogenicity. Non-natural amino acid substitutions increase peptide binding to MHC resulting in highly stable complexes. It has been observed that the half-life of MHC/peptide complexes is directly correlated to immunogenicity. MHC multimers containing optimised tumour derived antigens, i.e. immunogenic peptides, aid in the isolation and subsequent expansion of, for example, tumour infiltrating lymphocytes.
Considering the above, it is an object of the present invention, amongst other objects, to provide immunogenic peptides with improved efficiency in, for example, vaccines, immunosuppressive therapy, adoptive T cell therapy and diagnostics.
Specifically, the present invention enables a new vaccination technology based on stable peptides that have the ability to induce T cell activation at very low epitope concentrations and/or at late time points after epitope binding to antigen-presenting cells, as an initial prevention against major health threats such as pandemic influenza. In addition, high burden diseases including cancer, such as melanoma, can be targeted with the present peptides.
Further, the present peptides enable inactivation of T cells by blocking the MHC-TCR interaction or by antagonising the T cell receptor.
Furthermore, the present peptides contribute to enhancing MHC multimer technology which is fundamental technique in monitoring infection and cancer, determining vaccination efficiencies and evaluating and isolating T cells for adoptive T cell therapy.
The above objects, amongst other objects, are met by immune restricted peptides as defined in the appended claim 1.
The term “immune restricted peptides”, within the context of the present invention, designates modified peptides capable of eliciting, or modifying an immune response. The modification of the present peptides comprises the replacement, or substitution, of one or more amino acids in a peptide, i.e. a peptide representing one or more immunogenic epitopes, with non-naturally occurring amino acids. The present immune restricted peptides can provide an increased immunogenicity as compared the original peptide or are capable to provide immunogenicity to original non-immunogenic peptides.
The term “non-naturally occurring amino acids” within the context of the present invention denotes amino acids which are not found in naturally occurring compounds such as proteins and peptides. Specifically, non-naturally occurring amino acids according to the present invention are not the L-amino acids: alanine, cysteine, aspartic acid, glutamic acid, phenylalanine, glycine, histidine, isoleucine, lysine, leucine, methionine, asparagine, proline, glutamine, arginine, serine, threonine, valine, tryptophan and tyrosine.
Specifically, the above objects, amongst other objects, are met by immune restricted peptides, preferably HLA-A2 restricted peptides, according to the general formula (I):
wherein:
The present peptides are based on chemically enhanced and/or stabilised variants of immunogenic or non-immunogenic peptides also designated as ‘epitopes’. Chemical enhancement and stabilisation of epitopes comprises the incorporation of non-naturally occurring amino acids. The present chemical enhancement and stabilisation of epitopes, or peptides, results, for example, in an improved proteolytic stability and/or enhanced HLA affinity, providing an enhanced immunogenicity and/or T cell antagonism as compared to the original, or non-modified, peptide.
The present invention preferably relates to HLA-A2 restricted epitopes, or HLA-A2 immune restricted peptides, with enhanced affinity for HLA-A2 comprising 8- to 16-, preferably 8- to 13-, more preferably of 9- or 10-mer peptides, based on naturally occurring HLA-A2 restricted epitopes in which at least one amino acid has been replaced by a non-natural modification thereof.
To generate the present immunogenic epitopes, the modifications, as defined above, are introduced on P1 and can be introduced on amino acids P2 and/or P3 (counting from the N-terminus) and on the last (PC) and second before last (PC-2) amino acid. Amino acids between P3 and the before last amino acid residue (PC-2) are essential for T cell receptor activation.
PC-1 generally is any of the standard 20 naturally occurring side chains. Although substitution of this position provides improved binding to the HLA proteins, non-naturally occurring modifications on this position do not lead to activation of T cells. However, non-naturally occurring substitutions at PC-1 are beneficial for the development of T cell antagonists. Accordingly, an additional modification of the naturally occurring amino acid at this position by a non-naturally occurring amino acid is contemplated within the context of the present invention.
According to a preferred embodiment, the present invention relates to immune restricted peptides, preferably HLA-A2 Immune restricted peptides, wherein further at least one, preferably at least two, more preferably at least 3, most preferably 4 of P2, P3, P4, PC-2 and PC are a non-naturally occurring amino acid.
Specifically preferred combinations of P1, P2, P3, P4, PC 2 and PC are modification of P1 in combination with P2 and Pc, P1 in combination with P2, Pc-2 and Pc, P2 in combination with Pc-2 and Pc, P2 in combination with Pc, P2 in combination with Pc-2, P1 in combination with P2, P1 in combination with PC-2 and P2 in combination with PC-2.
Preferred examples of non-naturally occurring amino acid combinations at the indicated positions as defined herein are:
According to another preferred embodiment of the present invention:
is defined as the residues that make up the bulk part of the interaction site between peptide and TCR, and is preferably part of an HLA-A2 restricted immunogenic epitope. An immunogenic epitope according to the present invention is an amino acid sequence capable of T cell activation. Analogous, an HLA-A2 immunogenic epitope according to the present invention is an amino acid sequence capable of T cell activation through HLA-A2 presentation.
According to yet another preferred embodiment, the present invention relates to immune restricted peptides, preferably HLA-A2 immune restricted peptides, according to the general formula (II):
wherein:
According to the present invention, the present non-naturally occurring amino acid according to the present invention are preferably selected from the group consisting of TIC, CSME, OM-HS, NVA, NLE, BUTALA, PRG, PHG, SOME, 2-AOC, CpALA, ALG, am-phg, 3-PYRA, 3-THI, 3F-ABU, CSCF3 and 4-FPHE.
According to especially preferred embodiments of the present invention: PC-2 is 4-FPHE, P2 is selected from the group consisting of CpALA, NLE, BUTALA, NVA, 3F-ABU, (L) 3F-ABU and 2-AOC, P3 is NLE, P4 is an alpha-N-methylated amino acid residue containing a naturally occurring side-chain and/or Pc is selected from the group consisting of ALG, PRG, NLE, CSME and OM-HS and any combination of the indicated non-naturally occurring amino acids at the position PC-2, P2, P3, P4 and Pc.
The preferred immunogenic epitopes according to the present invention as represented by
are GFV, part of the HLA-A2 restricted influenza A matrix protein 1 (58-66) epitope, GIGI, part of the HLA-A2 restricted melanoma Mart-1 (26-35)epitope, or DFF, part of the HLA-A2 restricted melanoma TRP-2 (180-188) HLA-A2 epitope.
Considering the beneficial properties of the present immunogenic restricted, or modified, peptides according to the present invention, especially in the fields of vaccines, immunosuppressive therapy, adoptive T cell therapy and/or diagnostics, the present invention, according to another aspect, relates to a method for providing a immune restricted peptide, preferably an HLA-A2 restricted immunogenic peptide, comprising:
According to a preferred embodiment of the present method, the method comprises further comprising after step (a), but before step (b), analysing the amino acid sequence of the immunogenic peptide using a computer algorithm providing, preferably, a prediction of the at least one of the naturally occurring amino acids at positions P2, P3, P4, PC-2 and PC to be replaced by the non-naturally occurring amino acid and the identification of the replacement non-naturally occurring amino acid at positions P1, P2, P3, P4, PC-2 and/or PC.
According to another preferred embodiment of this aspect, the present invention relates to a method wherein step (b) comprises replacing at least two, preferably at least three, more preferably at least four naturally occurring amino acids at positions P2, P3, P4, PC-2 and PC.
Specifically preferred combinations of P1, P2, P3, PC-2 and PC are modification of P1 in combination with P2 and Pc, P1 in combination with P2, Pc-2 and Pc, P2 in combination with Pc-2 and Pc, P2 in combination with Pc, P2 in combination with Pc-2, P1 in combination with P2, P1 in combination with PC-2 and P2 in combination with PC-2.
Preferred examples of non-naturally occurring amino acid combinations at the indicated positions as defined herein are:
According to the present invention, the present non-naturally occurring amino acid substitutions at positions P1, P2, P3, PC 2 and PC are preferably selected from the group consisting of TIC, CSME, OM-HS, NVA, NLE, BUTALA, PRG, PHG, SOME, 2-AOC, CpALA, ALG, am-phg, 3-PYRA, 3-THI, 3F-ABU, CSCF3 and 4-FPHE.
According to an especially preferred embodiments of the present invention the replacement non-naturally occurring amino acid at position PC-2 is 4-FPHE, the replacement non-naturally occurring amino acid at position P2 is selected from the group consisting of CpALA, NLE, BUTALA, NVA, 3F-ABU, (L)3F-ABU, CSME and 2-AOC, the replacement non-naturally occurring amino acid at position P3 is NLE, the replacement non-naturally occurring amino acid at position P4 is an alpha N-methylated amino acid containing a naturally occurring side chain and/or the replacement non-naturally occurring amino acid at position PC is selected from the group consisting of ALG, PRG, NLE, and OM-HS or any combination of the indicated replacement non-naturally occurring amino acid at their respective positions.
The present variant or modified peptides provide beneficial properties especially in the fields of vaccines, immunosuppressive therapy, adoptive T cell therapy and diagnostics. Accordingly, according to another aspect, the present invention relates to the use of the present immune restricted peptides in medicine.
Preferably, the present immune restricted peptides are in vaccines, in immunosuppressive therapy or T cell antagonism, diagnostic and/or in adoptive T cell therapy.
The present invention will be further detailed in the examples below outlining especially preferred embodiments of the present immune restricted peptides. In the examples, reference is made to figures wherein:
In the examples below, optimisation of HLA A2 epitopes (
Both the IFNγ and MHC tetramer assays are monitored using flow cytometry, in which fluorescently labelled cells can be detected (
IFNγ production is visualised by intracellular staining using an APC conjugated anti-IFNγ antibody, whereas the CD8+ T cell is stained with a fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC)labelled anti-CD8 antibody. Both the percentage of IFNγ producing T cells and the amount of IFNγ produced per T cell (represented by the geometric mean) are taken into account.
In the examples below, T cell receptor exposed residues are left unchanged in order to maintain immunogenicity. The immunogenic activity of both high and low affinity epitopes has been enhanced with relative ease. An increase in HLA binding affinity up to a factor 1000 has been achieved. Epitopes enhanced by the invented technology presented here showed increased T cell stimulatory activity, as determined by IFNγ production, compared to native epitopes. The chemical structures of the non-naturally occurring amino acids used below are presented in
HLA binding affinity was determined by a fluorescence polarization (FP) assay based on UV mediated MHC peptide exchange. In short, purified soluble MHC class I molecules (HLA-A0201) loaded with a UV-labile peptide KILGFVFJV, in which J is photocleavable 3-amino-3-(2-nitrophenyl)propionic acid, (5.3 μM stock) are used for this assay. MHC molecules are diluted in phosphate buffer saline containing 0.5 mg/ml bovine gamma globulines (referred to as PBS/BGG) to a final concentration of 0.75 μM and pipetted into a 96 well microplate.
The HLA-A2 restricted hepatitis B virus epitope, FLPSDCFPSV, fluorescently labelled with tetramethylrhodamine (TAMRA) covalently bound to the cysteine residue, is used as the tracer. This tracer peptide is diluted in PBS/BGG to a concentration of 6 nM and manually pipetted into a 96 well microplate. The peptides of interest are diluted in DMSO to a concentration of 125 μM and pipetted into a 96 well microplate. A Hamilton high throughput liquid handling robot is then used combine the components from the three 96 well microplates into a black nonbinding surface 384 well microplate so that each peptide can be measured in triplicate for the fluorescence polarization assay. Once all the components are in the 384 well microplate (30 μl per well of 0.5 μM MHC, 1 nM tracer and 5 μM peptide), the plate is spun down to mix all the components and to remove any air bubbles.
Competition between the tracer peptide and the peptides of interest starts when the 384 well microplate is placed under a UV-lamp (>350 nm) for 30 minutes at 4° C. to cleave the UV-labile peptide.
All scores represent the percentage inhibition of the FP of the fluorescent tracer peptide. IC50 values are represented as fold increase towards the index peptide, which is set to an arbitrary value of 1.
Peptide/MHC (p/MHC) binding to the TCR was analysed by Fluorescence Assisted Cell Sorting (FACS) on a BD FACSCalibur machine, where 20,000 to 30,000 events were counted per sample. In short, enhanced and control peptides were pipetted in DMSO to a final concentration of 500 μM in a 96 well microplate. Biotinylated MHC monomers (2.45 mg/ml stock) were then diluted in PBS to 25 μg/ml and dispensed with non-binding surface pipette tips, 27 μl/per well in a 96 well microplate. 3 μl of the peptide plate was added to the MHC monomer plate and UV-irradiated for 30 minutes. The plates were then left at RT for another 30 minutes.
Subsequently, the plates were centrifuged for 5 minutes at 3300 RCF to remove disintegrated MHC molecules and 20 μl supernatant was transferred to a new 96 well microplate. 20 μl of PBS-diluted streptavidin-R-phycoerythrin conjugate (27 μg/ml) was added to the peptide-MHC plate in 4×15 minute intervals. The intervals are necessary to saturate the streptavidin molecules with the biotinylated MHC molecules so that the maximum amount of fully loaded tetramers is achieved.
In the same time, 100,000 T cells per well were plated out by a Thermo Scientific wellmate cell dispenser in a 384 well microplate. A Hamilton high throughput liquid handling robot was used to add 2 μl of p/MHC-tetramer in triplicate from the 96 well microplate into the cell-filled 384 well microplate. This plate was then incubated for 15 minutes at 37° C. Then 4 μl of allophycocyanin conjugated anti-CD8 antibody (8×diluted in PBS) was added to each well and incubated for 20 minutes on ice. Subsequently, after two wash steps with PBS, the wells were filled with PBS containing PI to distinguish between live and dead T cells in the FACS analysis. Data were analysed using FCS Express 2 by De Novo software and Microsoft Excel.
T cell activation assays (
T2 cells were used as antigen presenting platform and were cultured in RPMI medium containing 10% fetal bovine serum supplemented with penicillin and streptomycin. T cells were grown in RPMI/AIM-V medium (50:50), supplemented with 10% human serum, penicillin and streptomycin, interleukin-2 and glutamax. 50,000 T2 cells were plated out per well and peptides were added to a 1 μm final concentration. T2 cells and peptides were incubated at 37° C. for 1H after which 50,000 T cells in 50 μl medium were added to the T2 plate. 100 μl of RPMI medium containing 10% fetal bovine serum supplemented with penicillin and streptomycin was added to the wells and the plate was spun at 1500 rpm for 3 minutes. The supernatant was discarded and 100 μl of GolgiPlug (1 μl/ml) in RPMI medium containing 10% fetal bovine serum supplemented with penicillin and streptomycin was added to the cells. For the positive control, 2 μl of phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA) and 2 μl of ionomycin diluted in GolgiPlug medium was added to the positive control cells. The plate was spun at 700 rpm for 2 minutes and incubated for 4 hours at 37° C.
After incubation the plate was spun at 1300 rpm for 3 minutes and the supernatant was discarded. The cells were resuspended in 50 μl of FACS buffer with FITC labelled anti-CD8 antibody (20 μl/ml) and left to stain for 15 minutes in the dark at room temperature.
After staining the plate was spun at 1300 rpm for 3 minutes, and two wash steps were performed in which the cells are washed with 300 μl of FACS buffer. The cells were resuspended in 100 μl of Cytofix/Cytoperm solution and incubated on ice for 20 minutes. The plate was spun at 1300 rpm for 3 minutes and the supernatant was discarded and replaced by 250 μl of Permwash; this step was repeated. The cells were resuspended in 50 μl of Permwash with APC conjugated anti-IFNγ antibody. PermWash buffer was used for the dilution of the APC conjugated anti-IFNγ antibody, rather than a standard buffer, in order to maintain cells in a permeabilised state for the intracellular staining. The plate was incubated on ice for 30 minutes. The plate was spun at 1300 rpm for 3 minutes and the supernatant was discarded and replaced by 250 μl of Permwash; this step was repeated.
After the final wash step, the supernatant was discarded and the cells were resuspended in FACS buffer. Cells were then transferred from the plate into FACS-tubes and the samples were analysed by FACS. Data were analysed using FCS Express 2 by De Novo software and Microsoft Excel.
T cell activation results from table 7 were determined by measuring Interferon-y using an Enzyme-linked immunosorbant assay (ELISA) as described in Kuiper et al., Am J Ophthalmol, 2011. Biotinylated Interferon-γ antibodies were added to activated T cells, these were incubated with streptavidin R-phycoerythrin after which fluorescence was analyzed.
The Influenza A Matrix 1 epitope is a highly conserved epitope amongst Influenza A variants and binds strongly to HLA-A2.1. This epitope serves as a model for stringent selection of unnatural amino acid modifications. Modifications and evaluation of HLA binding and T cell reactivity are summarised in Table 1. Replacements found to enhance the HLA affinity of this epitope, were also found to be beneficial to HLA binding of other epitopes (see examples 2 and 3 below).
The columns listed under ‘Sequence’ numbering 1 to 9 indicate the amino acid residue present on the designated position in the epitope.
CD8+ T cells were obtained from Influenza A positive donors and were sorted using tetramers containing HLA A2.1::GILGFVFTL. The hepatitis B viral epitope FLPSDFFPSV (entry 12) was used as a negative control peptide in the TCR binding and IFNγ production assays. This natural epitope is known for its very high affinity for HLA-A2.1.
FP 4H and 24H represent percentage inhibition of tracer peptide binding by 5 μM competitor peptide at 4 hours and 24 hours incubation, respectively. High inhibition values maintained over 24 hours indicate a low off-rate of the peptide and consequently long lived p/MHC complexes.
IC50 values were determined using the MHC exchange FP assay and IC50 ratios represent IC50 values determined using the FP MHC exchange assay normalised to the native index peptide (entry 11).
% TCR shows the percentage of CD8+ T cells that are stained by the indicated p/MHC-tetramers. GeoTCR represents T cell staining efficiency.
The last two columns represent IFNγ production by stimulated T cells. % IFN indicates the percentage of T cells that are both CD8+ and produce IFNγ, whereas GeoIFN indicates the amount of IFNγ per T cell. 1.5 pg peptide was added per well to load antigen presenting cells and IFNγ production at time point 4H after adding T cells to the antigen presenting cells was measured.
In short, all substitutions introduced in Influenza A matrix 1 epitope (58-66) lead to enhanced HLA-A2 affinity, and similar or improved T cell activation efficiency (entries 2 to 10) compared to the native epitope.
The melanoma epitope EAAGIGILTV has low HLA affinity. When it became clear that defined anchor residues exist for all specific HLA types, replacement of alanine on P2 by a leucine was used to create an altered peptide ligand with greater MHC affinity, while maintaining T cell activation of lymphocytes that respond to native epitope EAAGIGILTV. The A to L mutation enhances MHC affinity, but not to the extent that is shown below by introduction of unnatural substitutions. Modifications and evaluation of HLA binding and T cell reactivity are summarised in Table 2.
In the columns listed under ‘Sequence’ numbering 1 to 10 indicates the amino acid present on the designated position in the epitope. HLA-A2::Mart-1(26-35) reactive T cells were obtained either by transduction of CD8+ T cells with a viral vector containing a monoclonal TCR for EAAGIGILTV or were isolated from melanoma patients and sorted using MHC tetramers containing HLA A2.1::ELAGIGLTV. FP 4H and 24H represent percentage inhibition of tracer peptide binding by 5 μM competitor peptide at 4 hours and 24 hours incubation, respectively. High inhibition values maintained over 24 hours indicate a low off rate of the peptide and consequently long lived p/MHC complexes.
IC50 values were determined using the MHC exchange FP assay and were normalised to the well known A2L altered peptide ligand (ELAGIGILTV), represented as IC50 ratios.
% TCR and GeoTCR are to be interpreted as in Table 1. The data shown were obtained using T cells transduced with a viral vector containing a monoclonal TCR for EAAGIGILTV.
% IFN and GeoIFN are to be interpreted as in Table 1. Peptide concentrations ranged from 100 pM to 0.005 pM.
The data shown were obtained using FACS-sorted T cells derived from a single patient, thus containing EAAGIGILTV reactive TCRs. The wild type epitope EAAGIGILTV was not included as a control because previous experiments indicated that at the concentrations used in this assay, this peptide did not induce measurable IFNγ expression.
The introduction of multiple nonnatural amino acid residues yielded peptides with up to a factor 24 higher HLA-A2 binding affinity (entry 5) according to the IC50 data compared to the reported A2L modification. Compared to the original wild type epitope a 300-400 fold increase in HLA affinity is observed.
TCR binding data show that most of the optimised peptides display similar or enhanced T cell staining efficiency as compared to native or A2L modified epitopes. It is also observed that [4-FPHE] on PC-2 increases HLA affinity but not T cell activation. Whereas in the Influenza epitope [4-FPHE] replaces a phenylalanine which it closely resembles, here it replaces a leucine on a site exposed to the TCR. Apparently, interaction between MHC loaded with this peptide analogue and the TCR is hampered. Consequently, the introduction of [4-FPHE] on PC-2 does not constitute a general improvement of immunogenicity, but is dependent on the particular epitope-TCR combination.
Titration of peptide analogues in the IFNγ assay revealed a tenfold higher T cell stimulatory activity of [CSME][2-AOC]AGIGILTV (entry 1) compared to control epitope ELAGIGILTV (entry 29).
After determination of optimal peptide concentrations in the titration assay, an experiment was set up in which interferon-y production by T cells upon stimulation by APC's (here T2 cells) displaying modified epitopes was monitored over time as is schematically shown in
The experiment involved the same modified peptides as used earlier in the titration assay and was carried out using peptide concentrations of 50 pM (Table 3)and 0.5 pM (Table 4), respectively.
The 0H time point represents basal IFNγ levels of T cells in a resting state. After 2 hour incubation with peptide-MHC presenting cells, IFNγ levels have risen considerably, reaching maximum levels, as measured here at 4 hours and gradually declining at longer time points. While up to 4 hours no significant differences between index and modified peptides are apparent, at time points 24 and 48H distinct differences are found. With the exception of entry 4 all modified peptides display the ability to activate T cell for a longer duration (up to the 48 h measured) than the index peptide.
Also incubation with 0.5 pM peptide shows that all modified peptides, with the exception of entry 4, are able to induce IFNγ production in responding T cells for a longer period of time than the index peptide. Moreover, as also seen with 50 pM peptide incubation, the duration of T cell activation by modified peptides is extended up to 48 hours. In contrast, at the 24 hour time point index peptide and entry 4 induce IFNγ production only just measurable above background level.
This epitope stems from tyrosinase-related protein 2 (TRP-2), an enzyme expressed in most melanoma cancers. It has a moderate affinity for HLA-A2.1 making it suitable for binding enhancement. Several modified epitopes were designed and binding data as well as T cell activation data on 19 of these are plotted in Table 5.
Also for this epitope, an IFNγ expression time-course experiment was performed. The two distinguishing time points 24H and 48H were taken along at peptide concentrations of 5·103 pM, 50 pM and 0.5 pM. The 5·103 pM concentration was included because this specific T cell receptor was found to require higher peptide levels to reach the dynamic measuring range than for example the EAAGIGILTV reactive TCR discussed in Example 2.
The results support the findings obtained for the Mart-1 ELAGIGILTV epitope. When enhanced by incorporating unnatural residues, the derivatives gain the ability to induce IFNγ expression for a longer period of time. Already at timepoint 24H a difference is observed at the 5·103 pM concentration when comparing the natural epitope to the better performing derivatives. Even more so this same effect is apparent after 48H.
At 50 pM and 24H the natural epitope induced IFNγ expression has fallen to background level, whereas the enhanced epitopes still show significant expression of this cytokine. At the same concentration but after 48H, only entries 1, 2 and 6 still show IFNγ expression significantly above background level. For the epitope-TCR combination studied here, incubation with 0.5 pM peptide does not lead to T cell activation in all cases.
HLA affinity is represented by percentage inhibition scores obtained using a fluorescence polarization assay as described in the materials and methods section. As shown in Table 6, HLA affinity of wild-type peptides GILGFVFTL and EAAGIGILTV can be improved, as indicated by the percentage of inhibition by [SOME] replacements at position P1 resulting in [SOME]ILGFVFTL and [SOME]AAGIGILTV.
HLA affinity is represented by percentage inhibition scores obtained using a fluorescence polarization assay as described in the materials and methods section. As shown in Table 7, wild-type peptide QLLNSVLTV was modified by [3-THI] replacement at position P1 resulting in [3-THI]LLNSVLTV, [3-THI]LLNSVLT[2-AOC], [3-THI][2-AOC]LNSVLT[NVA] and [3-THI][NLE]LNSVLT[NVA].
T cells specific for the epitope QLLNSVLTV were stimulated with several concentrations of this epitope, the modified peptide [3-THI]LLNSVLTV, or three similar 3-THI containing peptides. Interferon-γ production, indicative of T cell activation, was measured by an ELISA.
It is observed that the 3-THI residue has a positive effect on T cell activation, especially in combination with a leucine to valine replacement on position 9 of the peptide (entry 1). Entries 2, 3 and 4 show that the 3-THI residue is well tolerated on P1, even when combined with multiple other substitutions. The wild-type epitope was taken along three times (entries 5, 6 and 7).
HLA affinity is represented by percentage inhibition scores obtained using a fluorescence polarization assay as described in the materials and methods section. As shown in Table 8, the binding of wild-type peptides ELAGIGILTV and SVYDFFVWL to HLA A2 can be improved, as indicated by the percentage of inhibition, by [CSCF3] replacement at position P1 resulting in [CSCF3][2-AOC]AGIGILTV and [CSCF3][2-AOC]YDFFVWL.
The binding of both wild-type peptides to HLA A2 (entries 1 and 4 in the table) can be improved by replacement of P1 and P2 with [CSME][2-AOC] (entries 2 and 5). These can be further improved by a [CSME] to [CSCF3] replacement on P1 (entries 3 and 6).
HLA affinity is represented by percentage inhibition scores obtained using a fluorescence polarization assay as described in the materials and methods section. As shown in Table 9, the binding of wild-type peptide EAAGIGILTV to HLA A2 can be improved, as indicated by the percentage of inhibition, by [3F-ABU] replacement at position P2 resulting in E[3F-ABU]AGIGILTV.
Replacement of the alanine on P2 of the wild-type epitope with a racemic mixture of 3F-ABU residue increases binding at the 24H time point. It was further found that the enantiopure L-form of [3F-ABU] increased binding even further.
Three mouse vaccination studies were done using three different wild-type epitopes. In all cases, mice were vaccinated with the peptide supplemented with incomplete freunds ajuvant (IFA) and CpG. Analysis was done by analyzing blood samples with tetramers loaded with wild-type peptide in all cases.
Two groups of three mice were vaccinated with 5 μg of either ELAGIGILTV or [am-phg][NVA]AGIGILT[PRG]. At day 97, mice were administred a second dose (booster). At several timepoints blood was taken and tested for ELAGIGILTV-specific CD8+ T cells using tetramers loaded with ELAGIGILTV. This was done for both groups of mice. At all times, specific T cell numbers were higher for the [am-phg][NVA]AGIGILT[PRG] vaccinated mice. The results are summarised in
Two groups of four mice were vaccinated with with 100 μg of either LLFGLALIEV or [PHG][2-AOC]FGLALIEV. LLFGLALIEV is an immunogenic peptide derived from Melanoma-associated protein C2 (Mage-C2). At several timepoints blood was taken and tested for LLFGLALIEV-specific CD8+ T cells using tetramers loaded with LLFGLALIEV. This was done for both groups of mice. At all times after day one, specific T cell numbers were higher for the [PHG][2-AOC]FGLALIEV vaccinated mice. The results are summarised in
These peptides were also tested for HLA binding and T cell activation using an existing T cell line specific for LLFGLALIEV (Table 10). HLA binding is represented by percentage inhibition scores were obtained using a fluorescence polarization assay as described in the materials and methods section. T cell activation was quantified using the FACS based interferon-gamma production assay as materials and methods section.
Three groups of four mice were vaccinated with with 100 μg of either ALKDVEERV, [PHG][2-AOC]KDVEERV or [CSME][2-AOC]KDVEERV. ALKDVEERV is an immunogenic peptide derived from Melanoma-associated protein C2 (Mage-C2). At several time points blood was taken and tested for ALKDVEERV-specific CD8+ T cells using tetramers loaded with ALKDVEERV. This was done for all three groups of mice. [CSME][2-AOC]KDVEERV gave the highest initial response whereas [PHG][2-AOC]KDVEERV came up later but still gave a higher response than the wild-type ALKDVEERV peptide did. The results are summarised in
These peptides were also tested for MHC binding and T cell response using an existing T cell line specific for ALKDVEERV (Table 11). Percentage inhibition scores were obtained using a fluorescence polarization assay as described. T cell assay results were obtained following the protocol described in the materials and methods section.
Similar to examples 1 to 7, various amino acid substitutions in peptides EAAGIGILTV, FMYSDFHFI and VIWEVLNAV were explored the results of which are summarised in Table 12 below.
In summary, the present examples show that the unnatural peptide analogues, containing non-naturally occurring amino acids, display stronger MHC binding and show stronger and prolonged capacity to induce T cell activation at concentrations lower than required for their natural counterparts.
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| PCT/EP2010/069246 | Dec 2010 | EP | regional |
| Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PCT/EP2011/072377 | 12/9/2011 | WO | 00 | 6/7/2013 |
