The present invention relates to apparatus for characterising a component, such as a biomolecule, present within a liquid sample. In particular, the present invention relates to an apparatus configured to determine at least two characteristics of the component simultaneously.
The work leading to this invention has received funding from the European Union's Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013) under ERC grant agreement No 337969 and from the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 766972″.
Protein-protein interactions form the basis of many biologically and physiologically relevant processes including: protein self-assembly; protein-aggregation; antibody-antigen recognition; muscle contraction and cellular communication. Nevertheless, studying protein-protein interactions, especially under physiological conditions in complex media, remains challenging. Current techniques, such as an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) bead-based multiplex assay and surface plasmon resonance (SPR) spectroscopy, rely on immobilisation of one binding partner. These techniques include potential unspecific interactions with the surface, which can cause false positive results and the Hook/Prozone effect, which causes false-negative results, thereby allowing semi-quantitative analysis only.
Of the more than 4500 proteins abundant in human serum, many are considered as potential biomarkers. Such biomarkers are not only useful tools in diagnosis of many diseases, including cancer, cardiovascular diseases, protein mis-folding diseases, type-2-diabetes, mental disorders, and validation of drug trials, but are also proposed to be important indicators for auto-immune diseases and graft rejection. Assessment of biomarker levels requires a quantitative and reproducible procedure for absolute quantification, especially for long time evaluation. The absolute abundance and binding properties of distinct biomolecules correlate with the prevalence of certain diseases or act as hallmarks for potential immunological risk. Absolute quantification in human samples would not only streamline the finding of new biomarkers for diagnostics, but also help to gain understanding of detrimental processes through enabling correlation of concentration and affinity to the occurrence of an immune response.
As an example of a biomarker with clinical significance, the binding behaviour of antibodies against human leukocyte antigens (HLA), also known as the human major histocompatibility complex (MHC), has been identified as a suitable biomarker for numerous studies. The characteristic and unique structure of HLA facilitates the recognition of multiple pathogens. As such, HLA is involved in the distinction between self and foreign or malignant entities such as pathogens or extrinsic cells and tissues. As HLA is crucial in recognition of foreign organs and associated with allograft rejection, histocompatibility screening prior to organ transplantation is essential.
Currently all known approaches for clinical protein detection and quantification involve assays relying on surface immobilisation or bead immobilisation, as for example ELISA assays. While ELISA assays can achieve a relatively high sensitivity (usually down to fmol in ca. 100 μL well corresponding to 10,000-100,000 molecules), it is not capable of determining biophysical parameters describing the binding interaction in solution, although the physiologically relevant processes take place in solution.
Recently, alternative strategies have emerged for achieving enhanced sensitivity including the use an antibody pair for detecting protein molecules and the use of apparatus developed for flow cytometry for reading out relative intensities. However, these assays are still performed on the surface of a bead and therefore encounter the usual disadvantages of surface-based techniques described above.
Thus, there is a requirement to provide an in-solution platform that can be used to detect and determine specific concentrations, affinities, and the exact interaction stoichiometry of the interaction between biomarkers and their specific targets in body fluids in a fully quantitative manner.
It is against the background that the present invention has arisen.
According to an aspect of the present invention, there is provided an apparatus for characterising a biomolecule, the apparatus comprising:
The apparatus of the present invention allows for the determination of biophysical binding parameters in human samples such as human serum samples. The technique as disclosed herein allows for the determination of the dissociation constant or affinity Kd, the absolute concentration of the antibody present in the sample, as well as the stoichiometry of the interaction.
By using global analysis with varying the concentration of the serum as well as the concentration of the labelled antigen, it becomes possible to refine the characterisation using Bayesian Analysis.
In some cases, it can be highly advantageous to detect and measure two characteristics of each biomolecule simultaneously because it provides further granularity of information on the properties of the biomolecule which are not obtainable from known measurement techniques such as ELISA. For example, the apparatus can be used to detect and determine the concentration and the affinity of a biomolecule at the same time. Additionally or alternatively, the apparatus can be used to detect and determine the concentration and the avidity of a biomolecule at the same time.
The apparatus of the present invention may allow for the detection and determination of the biomolecule and its binding partner in solution. In some embodiments, biomolecule-biomolecule interactions may be characterised using the apparatus of the present invention. In some embodiments, the apparatus can be used to detect and determine the bound and/or unbound biomolecule. The relative concentration of both the biomolecule and of its binding partner can be varied. When biomolecules are bound to a surface the user is not able to freely vary the concentration of the bound biomolecule.
Furthermore, biomolecules immobilised onto a surface may not truly reflect their native state as an immobilisation species such as a chemical linker is often attached onto the biomolecule in order to immobilise the species onto the surface. This may affect the natural state or functional activity of the biomolecule immobilised on the surface. The apparatus as described in the present invention does not require an immobilisation technique of a biomolecule onto a surface to study binding interactions for example. Hence, the interactions between biomolecules can be determined and detected in solution and in their native state.
In some embodiments, the apparatus can be used to characterise a component such as a biomolecule where the biomolecule is a protein, a peptide, an exosome, an antibody or an antibody fragment thereof, a nucleotide such as DNA or DNA piece, RNA or mRNA, or a polysaccharide.
In some embodiments, the biomolecule is an antibody, a polypeptide, a polynucleotide or a polysaccharide. In some embodiments, the biomolecule is an antibody or an antibody fragment thereof. In some embodiments, the antibody is an allo-antibody, an autoantibody or an antibody raised against an external antigen. The term “allo-antibody” in this context is used to refer to an antibody that recognises foreign molecules, such as HLA, within the field of organ transplantation.
In some embodiments, the biomolecule is a multi-biomolecule mixture. In some embodiments, the biomolecule may be an affinity reagent such as an antibody, a single domain antibody or an aptamer. In some embodiments, the multi-biomolecule mixture comprises an antibody and an antigen. In some embodiments, one biomolecule in the multi-biomolecule mixture can be labelled or at least two or more biomolecules can be labelled. In some embodiments, the antibody can be labelled in order to detect other biomolecules of interest. In some cases, due to the fact that the antibody of interest may be mixed with other antibodies in a sample, it is preferable for the antigen to be labelled.
In some embodiments, the sample fluid can be any type of human fluid or sample. In some embodiments, the sample fluid can be a human serum comprising the biomolecule.
Bayesian analysis can be advantageous as it can be used to quantify both the affinity and the antibody concentration of a sample such as a human serum sample simultaneously with great accuracy and in a robust manner.
In some embodiments, the measured dataset may include one or more of the following, but is not limited to, auto fluorescence background measurements, flow profile, concentration of a labelled sample such as a labelled serum sample, the stoichiometry interactions, the molecular weight of interacting biomolecules, total ligand concentration, binding sites, size, charge, modification such as post translational modification for example methylation and/or the hydrodynamic radius.
In some embodiments, a microfluidic platform can be used as an in-solution technique capable of detecting and quantifying molecules in body fluids absolutely. More specifically, the platform is configured to quantify the abundance and affinity of antibodies in human serum. Thereby, an antigen against which the antibodies are reactive is added externally, and the change in hydrodynamic radius of the complex is monitored as a function of the serum concentration.
In some embodiments, the apparatus further comprises a controller configured to receive the stored dataset from the storage location and to receive the measured dataset from the analysis module to further tune one or more parameters associated with the measured dataset; and an output module associated with the controller configured to provide a notification to an operator indicating a further cycle of measurements such that further measurements obtained provide a pre-determined level of confidence set by a user in the determined characteristics of the biomolecule.
The level of confidence may involve statistical error analysis associated with the measurements obtained. The level of confidence can be set by the user as a pre-determined threshold value. If the threshold value or level is not reached as a result of an initial set of measurements, a further set of data is obtained to increase the level of confidence until it reaches the pre-determined threshold value or level set by the user. In some embodiments, the level of confidence may take into account the interactions between the biomolecules within the sample such as the interactions between the antibody and antigen in a human serum sample for instance.
The apparatus and method of the present invention provides an iterative process. Earlier measurements can be fed back into the controller in order to optimise one or more parameters associated with the measured dataset. Since the controller is associated with the output module, the output module is able to notify the operator an indication of further cycle of measurements. This enables the measurements to be taken in the most information rich part of the dataset. This, in turn, provides an increased level of confidence in the determined characteristics of the biomolecule such as affinity and concentration. Hence, this reduces the amount of time required to obtain further measurements of affinity and concentration of biomolecules.
In some embodiments, the level of confidence can be determined using statistical analysis to set a pre-determined threshold value. In some embodiments, the level of confidence value can be set by a user to be within an acceptable statistical range and/or standard deviation.
In some embodiments, the apparatus may further comprise the use of microfluidic diffusion analysis (MDS) to determine and analyse the amount of interaction between human leukocyte antigen (HLA) and allo-specific antibodies in patient sera and more particularly, in order to assess the risk of allograft rejection. Using this approach, it is possible to determine dissociation constants, Kd, the absolute concentration of the allo-specific antibody and the stoichiometry of the interaction at the same time.
In some embodiments, the concentration of the molecules that can be characterized using the apparatus of the present invention is unknown and can be determined through the use of a different data fitting method such as Bayesian analysis to both determine the fraction of serum and the concentration of HLA required to obtain measurements and to analyse these measurements.
Furthermore, the apparatus and method as described herein can be more widely applicable and describe it as a way of being able to profile the immune status of patients, for example, by being able to detect different antibodies in auto immune diseases.
In some embodiments, the distribution channel is adapted to generate a lateral distribution of biomolecule. The distribution channel may be of sufficient length/width to enable lateral distribution by diffusion. In some embodiments, the distribution channel may have a length of between 2 mm and 100 mm, for example 20 mm. In some embodiments, the distribution channel may have a length of more than 2, 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, 80 or 90 mm, or it may be less than 100, 90, 80, 70, 60, 50, 40, 30, 20 or 10 mm. The distribution channel may have a width of between 30 microns and 3,000 microns, for example between 20 and 2500 microns, 20 and 2000 microns, 20 and 1500 microns, 20 and 1000 microns, 20 and 750 microns, 20 and 500 microns, 20 and 400 microns or 20 microns and 300 microns. In some embodiments, the width of the distribution channel may exceed 20, 40, 60, 80, 100, 120, 150, 180, 200, 220, 250 or 280 microns, or it may be less than 300, 280, 250, 220, 200, 180, 150, 120, 100, 80, 60 or 40 microns. For example, the distribution channel may have a width of 40×40 microns and a length of 23 mm. In a further example, the distribution channel may have a width of between 50×70 microns and a length of 10 mm.
Alternatively, the distribution channel can be “adapted” by having an electric field spanning it to enable distribution of components by electrophoresis. Alternatively, the distribution channel can be adapted by providing a heat source which is configured to enable thermophoresis to distribute biomolecules.
In some embodiments, the lateral distribution of the biomolecule is perpendicular to the fluid flow along the distribution channel.
In some embodiments, the distribution channel may be adapted to generate a longitudinal distribution of a biomolecule. In such embodiments, the distribution of the biomolecules is parallel to (i.e. in direction of) the flow through the distribution channel. The distribution of the biomolecules may take place under steady state conditions or, conversely, under flow conditions.
In some embodiments, the apparatus may further comprise at least two outlet channels to divide the fluid in the distribution channel into two or more flows. At least one of the outlet channels may comprise a measurement zone where the measurement module is able to detect and measure one or more signature profiles of the biomolecule.
In some embodiments, the analysis module can be configured to detect and determine the concentration and the affinity of each biomolecule. The concentration and affinity measurements can provide useful information on how the biomolecule behaviours individually or in complex with other components for example in protein-protein interactions.
In some embodiments, the analysis module may be configured to detect and determine the concentration and the avidity of each biomolecule. As disclosed herein and unless otherwise defined, the term “avidity” refers to the overall binding strength of the interactions between components such as biomolecules when there is more than one binding site. As an example, the binding strength of the interactions between an antibody and an antigen can be determined. In some embodiments, the overall binding strength of the antibody-HLA interaction can be determined. The term “avidity” is applicable to quantifying the binding of multivalent biomolecules which have multiple binding sites. A measurement of the avidity takes into consideration the interaction at all available binding sites. As an example, the avidity of a biomolecule with at least two binding sites such as IgG, IgD or IgE can be quantified.
As disclosed herein and unless otherwise defined, the term “affinity” refers to the binding measurement of a component such as a biomolecule at one binding site.
Optionally, the analysis module may be configured to determine one or more of the following: flow profile, concentration of a labelled sample such as a labelled serum sample, the stoichiometry interactions, the molecular weight of interacting biomolecules, total ligand concentration, binding sites, size, charge, modification such as post translational modification for example methylation and/or the hydrodynamic radius.
In some embodiments, the analysis module may further be configured to detect and determine the stoichiometry of each biomolecule.
By using the apparatus as disclosed in the present invention, specific concentrations, affinities, and the exact interaction stoichiometry of the interaction between biomarkers and their specific targets in body fluids can be detectable in a fully quantitative manner.
In some embodiments, the distribution channel may be a T-sensor. In some embodiments, the distribution channel, together with the sample inlet channel, an auxiliary inlet channel and the outlet channels may form an H-filter. In the context of this specification, the term T-sensor is used to describe a distribution channel with exactly two inlets and the term H-filter is a distribution channel with exactly two inlets and exactly two outlets. Although some T-sensors and H-filters have 180° between their inlets this is not essential.
In some embodiments, the biomolecule comprises a label such as a fluorophore, a quantum dot or a nanoparticle. In some embodiments, the biomolecule is labelled with a fluorophore. The fluorophore enables the user to visually detect the biomolecule of interest. An example of a fluorophore is Alexafluor® 647 fluorophore.
Other examples of suitable fluorophore may include, but is not limited to, Alexa Fluor™, ATTO, DyLight or other families exemplified by, but not limited to, individual dyes such as DyLight 350, ATTO 488, DY-489XL, Alexa Fluor™ 647 or Alexa Fluor™ 700. Dyes are not restricted to visible wavelength fluorescence, and may be active in the UV, visible or IR regions of the spectrum.
The label selected can provide a reliable and stable labelling strategy for fluorescence detection.
In some embodiments, a labelling strategy can be deployed for specific labelling of HLA and controlling the stoichiometry of the antibody-HLA interaction. In some embodiments, HLA can be covalently labelled with a fluorescence dye such as Alexafluor® 647. This ensures that the protein autofluorescence (tryptophan fluorescence) does not interfere with detection as the complexity of the autofluorescence from the sample can make it difficult to distinguish between the different proteins abundant in the serum.
In some embodiments, a correction for autofluorescence may be required in human serum. The background contribution of serum can be corrected by subtracting the background intensity from the measured intensities, allowing the correction of all binding curves in measurements. Hence, a standard curve of the fluorescence background may be needed for each sample.
In some embodiments, the fluorophore selected for labelling the biomolecule is in the far-red spectral region.
A fluorophore in the far-red spectral region can be advantageous at around Δem,max=665 nm wavelength, since there is a reduced autofluorescence of human serum in this region. This means that there is less background interference for detecting biomolecules.
In some embodiments, an electrode is provided at the upstream of the distribution channel and an electrode is provided at the downstream of the distribution channel, so that, together, these electrodes apply an electric field across the distribution channel, perpendicular to the direction of the flow along the distribution channel. In such embodiments, the distribution of the component may occur by free flow electrophoresis (FFE).
The provision of an electric field will enable separation/distribution of the components for example, a biomolecule to occur by electrokinetic separation techniques such as capillary zone electrophoresis (CE) capillary gel electrophoresis (CGE), capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF), capillary isotachophoresis and micellar electrokinetic chromatography (MEKC) or via an enrichment process or a blood lysis procedure.
In another aspect of the invention, there is provided a method for characterising a biomolecule, the method comprising the steps of:
In some embodiments, the method may further comprise the steps of:
The output module can be a reader device or it can be any other device capable of displaying data to the operator.
In some embodiments, the lateral distribution is created by diffusion. Additionally or alternatively, the lateral distribution is created electrophoretically through the application of an electric field.
Additionally or alternatively, the measurement of the biomolecule is determined by microfluidic diffusional sizing (MDS), which is used to measure the size of the biomolecule based on the degree to which they diffuse within a fluid flow. In some embodiments, the apparatus and method as disclosed in the present invention may rely on MDS, which is capable of determining concentrations, affinities and stoichiometry of interactions in body fluids, and is, thus, able to shed light on the relevance of those biophysical properties for clinical assessment.
The sensitivity of the MDS platform is high i.e. it provides a good signal to noise ratio and therefore, it is a suitable technique for characterising biomolecule interactions in a sample at concentration in the low nM range.
MDS can also be used for the determination of binding parameters by utilising the measured hydrodynamic radius, Rh, of a fluorescently labelled protein by tracking its spatial and temporal evolution in a microfluidic channel under laminar flow.
Moreover, MDS can be used as an advanced technique to quantify an analyte in human serum under native solution conditions, thereby yielding physiological relevant results with further clinical implications.
In addition, the use of MDS on body fluids avoids the requirement for a washing step and therefore the apparatus and method as described in the present invention can avoid sample loss and reducing false negative effects. This is in contrast to surface assays which require a washing step to take place and hence can result in sample loss and false negative effects.
Additionally or alternatively, the lateral distribution can be created by thermophoresis via the application of heat. In such embodiments, the apparatus may further comprise a heat source.
In some embodiments, the analysis module may be configured to detect and determine the concentration and the affinity and/or the avidity of each biomolecule.
In some embodiments, the analysis module may be further configured to detect and determine the stoichiometry of each biomolecule.
In some embodiments, the method may further comprise the step of detecting the biomolecule using fluorescence spectroscopy.
The invention will now be further and more particularly described, by way of example only, and with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
According to the present invention, there is provided an apparatus for characterising a biomolecule and in some cases the apparatus can be used to characterise biomolecule interactions such as antibody-antigen interactions. The apparatus comprises a sample inlet channel configured to introduce a sample fluid including the biomolecule to the apparatus, an auxiliary inlet channel configured to introduce an auxiliary fluid to the apparatus and a distribution channel which is in fluid communication with the sample inlet channel and the auxiliary inlet channel. The distribution channel is adapted to generate a distribution of biomolecules through diffusion such as lateral diffusion and/or through electrophoresis upon the application of an electric field or through thermophoresis upon the application of heat. Additionally or alternatively, the distribution of biomolecules within the distribution channel can be generated via microfluidic diffusional sizing (MDS).
In utilising the MDS assay for absolute quantification and characterisation of molecules in solution, it is possible to determine the hydrodynamic radius, Rh, in human serum and hence, it is possible to characterise the interactions of biomolecules in measured in human serum. This is because MDS has been show to allow the determination of binding parameters by utilising the measured hydrodynamic radius, Rh, of a fluorescently labelled protein by tracking its spatial and temporal evolution in a microfluidic channel under laminar flow.
The apparatus further comprises a measurement module configured to detect a signature profile of the biomolecule to obtain a measured dataset of the detected biomolecule; a storage location configured to store and maintain a stored dataset comprising a plurality of parameters that are associated with the measured dataset obtained from the measurement module; and an analysis module configured to receive the stored dataset from the storage location and correlate the stored dataset with the measured dataset from the measurement module to provide a correlation value. The analysis module is further configured to use the correlation value to determine at least two characteristics of the biomolecule simultaneously using Bayesian analysis.
Referring to
The device 100 further comprises at least two outlet channels 120, 122 located downstream from the distribution channel 110 where the fluid flow comprising the sample and auxiliary flows in the distribution channel 110 is divided the fluid into two outlet flows, one flow entering each outlet channel 120, 122. As shown in
A measurement module comprising a detector may be positioned at the outlet channels to detect the biomolecule of interest. The fluorescence at each of the outlet channels 120, 122 can be measured. From the ratio between the fluorescence in both the outlet channels, the hydrodynamic radius, Rh, of the protein can be determined. In some cases, the measurement module is able to detect and/or identify a signature profile of the biomolecule of interest to obtain a measured dataset of the detected biomolecule. The measured dataset can then be transmitted to an analysis module.
The size of the complex is subsequently determined by microfluidic diffusional sizing of which the dissociation constant Kd and the antibody concentration are evaluated using Bayesian analysis.
MDS has been shown to allow the determination of binding parameters by utilising the measured hydrodynamic radius, Rh, of a fluorescently labelled protein by tracking its spatial and temporal evolution in a microfluidic channel under laminar flow as illustrated in
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
In order to demonstrate the usability of the MDS assay for absolute quantification and characterisation of molecules in complex media, well characterised interactions were measured in human serum. First, varying concentration of antibodies SN23OG6 and OUW4F11 are added into blank human serum and measured their interactions with HLA A*02:01 and HLA B*08:01, respectively. As a first step, the hydrodynamic radii of both antigens are determined. The radii of pure HLA obtained human serum are consistent with the theoretical values as well as the radii obtained in buffer as shown in
This also shows that human serum does not contain any other protein that can perturb the measurements by binding to the investigated antigen. For these two antigen/antibody pairs, the dissociation constants determined are independent of the buffer conditions used. More specifically, for the interaction of the antibody SN23OG6 against HLA A*02:01, the dissociation constant Kd=3.83±1.26 nM in human serum is in good agreement with the Kd=3.64±0.43 nM in PBS (see
Referring to
The hydrodynamic radius, Rh, of the measured species can be correlated with the molecular weight (Mw) of the biomolecule, which is then used to sum and examine whether the Rh values observed make sense as Rh can't be added since it is a volumetric measure and scales with molecular weight by approximately a one third power.
Referring to
Referring to
In some embodiments, the mean fluorescence intensities of a patient serum against HLA A*02:01 and A*24:01 at different serum concentration can be shown.
As shown in
Subsequently, the applicability of this platform in patient serum is further described herein. For this purpose, the interaction of both HLA A*02:01 and HLA A*24:02 with the same patient serum is of interest. The patient can be highly sensitised for both HLA types, showing a higher Mean Fluorescence Intensity (MFI) on the Luminex platform for the HLA A*24:02. As shown in
By using Bayesian analysis, both the affinity and the antibody concentration can be quantified. For the interaction of serum allo-antibody with HLA A*02:01, the concentration of the antibody could be constrained to 6.02±2.66 nM, with a Kd≤30 nM, assuming a binding ratio of one to two. Similarly, for the same patient serum, antibody binding to HLA A*24:02 can be investigated, which show a higher Luminex signal than for HLA A*02:01. The antibody concentration could be determined as 15.26±3.17 nM, and the affinity can be given with an upper limit of Kd≤3 nM.
As shown in
Referring to
Using the apparatus and method as disclosed in the present invention, it is possible to determine the hydrodynamic radius Rh in human serum. The auto-fluorescence of human serum above 600 nm seems to be reduced, although a signal is detectable on the microfluidic platform.
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
Analysis of MDS Data
The analysis of MDS data to establish a binding equilibrium between antibody and antigen are shown below. Assuming 1:1 binding, we therefore have the following equilibrium
Ab+H
AbH (1)
where AbH denotes the bound antibody-HLA complex.
Expressing the total concentrations of antibody and HLA as [Ab]0 and [H]0, respectively:
Solving this:
In the microfluidic diffusional sizing method, the measured hydrodynamic radius of our reaction mixture is calculated by recording the total fluorescence intensities of the ‘diffused’ and ‘undiffused’ channels, termed Id and Iu, respectively.
Since the measured radius is not linearly correlated with the concentrations of free and bound labelled HLA, in order to avoid skewing the data, the fraction of labelled HLA that ends up in the ‘diffused’ channel Id/Id+Iu can be observed and used. In order to relate the observed quantity to the predicted concentration bound, [AbH], pf and ρb are introduced as the fractions of free and bound HLA, respectively, that are detected in the ‘diffused’ channel. The following equations can be obtained as shown below:
I
d=κ([AbH]ρ
I
u=κ([AbH](1-ρb)+([H]0−[AbH])(1-ρf)) (7)
where κ is a constant that relates the concentration of HLA to the fluorescence intensity observed. Therefore the predicted fraction to end up in the diffused channel, fd is:
with [AbH] as determined in the above equation. Therefore, the predicted fraction to end up in the diffused channel is a function of ρfd, ρb, Kd and the total concentrations of antibody and HLA and this is denoted by fd(ρf,ρb,Kd,[Ab]0,[H]0).
Using fd as the observable, the ρfd, ρb, and Kd can therefore be determined as the unknown parameters by Bayesian inference as disclosed in further detail below. In order to account for the actual 1:2 non-cooperative binding stoichiometry of antibody:HLA, we assume that the radii of the singly and doubly bound antibody are equal, as their sizes are within the expected error of the experimental method. Therefore, we simply use [Ab] to denote concentration of antibody binding sites, rather than antibody concentration, and Kd is thus the dissociation constant with respect to binding sites. As each IgG antibody contains two binding sites, we simply multiply antibody concentration by two to obtain [Ab].
Determining Unknown Antibody Concentration
In patient serum samples, the concentration of antibody in serum is unknown. The concentration of HLA-reactive antibody binding sites in a given sample, [Ab]0 is related to the concentration of binding sites in the original serum, [Ab]tot, and the fraction of serum used in this particular sample, α, by
[Ab]0=α[Ab]tot (9)
where 0≤α<1.
Substituting this into equation 5 as above, an updated equation is shown below:
Serum Auto-Fluorescence
Using this expression in equation 8 we get a new expression for the predicted fraction to end up in the diffused channel, fd(ρf,ρb,Kd,[Ab]tot,α,[H]0).
A further complication of performing the measurements in human serum is serum auto-fluorescence, which requires pre-processing of the data. Since the raw channel fluorescence intensities are measured, this background fluorescence can be corrected for. By performing a calibration of the serum fraction and intensity in each channel in the absence of HLA, a linear relationship between the fluorescence intensity of each channel and the serum fraction, a can be obtained:
I
d,s
=s
dα (11)
I
u,s
=s
uα (12)
where Id,s and Iu,s are the intensities in the ‘diffused’ and ‘undiffused’ channels arising from the serum, respectively, and sd and su are constants obtained through linear regression.
A datapoint, y, is thus computed during pre-processing by
It is therefore possible to analyse the data by Bayesian inference, with ρf, ρb, Kd, and [Ab]tot as unknown parameters, thereby obtaining values for both Kd, and [Ab]tot through binding measurements by microfluidic diffusional sizing.
Bayesian Inference
The Bayesian inference analysis method utilises Bayes' theorem, and allows the determination of the probability distribution of unknown parameters, given the observed data, by the following equation
P(parameters|data)∝P(parameters)P(data|parameters) (14)
where P(parameters|data) is known as the posterior, P(parameters) as the prior, and P(data|parameters) as the likelihood. The prior probability distribution is an expression of our information about the system before any measurement data can be acquired. For ρf and ρb, prior is assumed to be flat in linear space, whereas for the Kd and total concentration of antibody, a prior that is flat in logarithmic space is more appropriate, to reflect the scale invariance of the problem.
Experimental measurement data as described herein are normally to be distributed about the true value, and the likelihood function is therefore a Gaussian, centred on the theoretical measurement value.
where fd is defined in equation 8 with [AbH] defined in equation 10, αi and [H]i are the concentrations of serum and antibody, respectively, in the ith measurement and yi is the pre-processed data point obtained in the ith measurement. In order to define an appropriate standard deviation, σ, for each dataset, the standard deviations of repeats of each measurement are calculated, and the maximum of these values are used as a global standard deviation for that dataset.
In order to maximise the information gained in each experiment, the entropy of the posterior distribution of the quantities of interest, e.g. the antibody concentration and affinity is used. The entropy of a distribution can simply be interpreted as a measure for how certain we are that a parameter had a specific value, the lower the entropy the more certain. Thus, the more a measurement decreases the entropy, the more information it contains. It can be predicted or estimated the entropy change if an additional measurement at a specific concentration of serum and antigen can be recorded. This is referred to as the expected entropy.
By calculating the expected entropy for all possible measurements i.e. all combinations of concentrations of serum and antigen, within the limits imposed by the experiment, the measurement point associated with the biggest expected decrease in entropy can be found. This can be performed in an iterative manner: after taking the first measurement, the expected entropy is calculated and the best next measurement is proposed. Once this measurement has been recorded, the expected entropies are updated and a new best next measurement is proposed. This process is repeated until the desired level of confidence and accuracy is obtained.
Referring to
Moreover, MAAP analysis showed strengthening of the antibody response against SARS-CoV-2 within this time frame (reduction in KD at 3 months compared to the 1 month time point) in the majority of the patients examined, providing direct evidence of affinity maturation in patients recovering from COVID-19. The data as shown in
Determination of Auto Fluorescence in Human Serum
Human serum (not containing specific anti-HLA antibodies) can be supplemented with PBS (pH 7.3, Oxoid tablets, Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc., Waltham, US; supplemented with NaN3 (0.02% (w/v), Sigma Aldrich, St Louis, US)) and the fluorescent label Alexafluor® 647 (Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc., Waltham, US),to yieldfluorophore concentrations between 10 pM and 1 pM in serum. Similar dilutions of fluorophore in buffer can be prepared for comparison. Subsequently, both absorption spectra and the emission spectra upon excitation at two wavelengths Δex,1=481 nm and Δex,2=632 nm can be recorded on a plate reader (Clariostar BMG Labtech, Ortenberg, Del.).
Labelling of HLA with Alexafluor® 647 Fluorophore
To label HLA (different variants from Emory, Atlanta, US; in NaHCO3(Sigma Aldrich, St Louis, US), 0.89 nmol, 1 equiv.), Alexa Fluor® 647 N-Hydroxysuccinimide ester (in DMSO 3 equiv.) can be added into a mixture containing HLA. The reaction mixture can be incubated for 1 hour at approx. 20° C., protected from light. The sample can be purified by size exclusion chromatography on a Superdex 200 increase 10/300 GL column (GE healthcare, Chicago, US) with a flow rate of approximately 0.5 mL/min and PBS (pH 7.3, supplemented with NaN3 (0.02% (w/v)) as eluent buffer, to yield labelled HLA (370 nM, DOL between 0.33 to 2.25, depending on variant). Conjugated HLA can then be stored at 4° C. until further use.
Microfluidic Diffusional Sizing (MDS)
All MDS experiments were performed using Fluidity One W (Fluidic Analytics, Cambridge, UK). The basic principle of MDS has been described elsewhere. In brief, labelled protein streams into the diffusion chamber from one side, auxiliary buffer from the other side. Due to the small channel size, laminar flow can be assumed, meaning that the particles can move into the buffer stream by diffusion only, whereby the rate depends on the size of the molecular complex. At the end of the diffusion channel or chamber, the stream is split again and the fluorescence at both sides of the chambers is measured. From the ratio between the fluorescence in both chambers, the hydrodynamic radius, Rh of the protein can be determined.
Verification of Binding
Labelled HLA A*03:01, A*02:01, and B*08:01, respectively, is diluted in PBS (pH 7.3, supplemented with NaN3 (0.02% (w/v)) to yield a 5 nM solution. The size of the HLA conjugates can be determined by MDS. Similarly, labelled HLA variants and respective antibodies are mixed, to yield a 5 nM concentration of HLA with 1 μM antibody. These conjugates were incubated at 4° C. for approx. 1 hour, then heated up to room temperature for 5 min and sized by MDS.
Negative Control Experiments
Labelled HLA variants were mixed with human IgG ab205198 (abcam, Cambridge, UK) or bovine serum albumin (BSA; Sigma Aldrich, St Louis, Del.) to yield a concentration of 5 nM of HLA variants and 1 μM antibody. These conjugates are incubated at 4° C. for 1 hour, then heated up to room temperature for 5 min and sized by MDS. Similarly, Alexafluor® 647 labelled BSA is diluted in PBS, to yield a solution of 5 nM of labelled BSA, as well as 250 equivalent of antibody, to demonstrate absence of unspecific interactions between the antibody and the fluorophore.
Measurements in PBS
Labelled HLA of a particular variant, together with a varying concentration of the antibody of interest, were added and diluted in PBS. The samples are incubated at 4° C. for approx. 1 hour or at room temperature for approx. 30 min. Subsequently, the size was determined by MDS. The data is fitted according to the non-linear binding equation (equation 16), which relates the measured hydrodynamic radius, Rh,m, to the total concentrations of antibody, [Ab]0, the binding site concentration, [B]0, the dissociation constant Kd, the stoichiometric ratio, n, the total increase in the hydrodynamic radius, ΔRh,tot and the hydrodynamic radius of unbound antigen, Rh,0, using GraphPad Prism (Version 8.2).
For the fitting of the data to a Hill's equation 17 is used as shown below:
As, experimentally, a non-cooperativity of HLA to antibody binding has been validated, a binding ration of n=½ for 2 to 1 binding has been used further on in equation 16.
Binding Measurements in Human Serum
A range of different HLA types can be added to human serum, supplemented with varying concentrations of specific antibodies. The samples are incubated at room temperature (r.t.) for 30 min and subsequently, the size is determined by MDS. The data is fitted according to equation 18, using GraphPad Prism (Version 8.2).
Bayesian Analysis
The priors used for the radius of the free species, rf, and the radius of the bound species, rb, are flat in linear spice, while a flat log-space prior is used for Kd and binding site concentration, meaning that the probability of the Kd being between 1 nM and 10 nM equals the probability of lying between 10 nM and 100 nM. A flat log-space allows facilitates the constraint the order of magnitude.
Various further aspects and embodiments of the present invention will be apparent to those skilled in the art in view of the present disclosure.
“and/or” where used herein is to be taken as specific disclosure of each of the two specified features or components with or without the other. For example “A and/or B” is to be taken as specific disclosure of each of (i) A, (ii) B and (iii) A and B, just as if each is set out individually herein.
Unless context dictates otherwise, the descriptions and definitions of the features set out above are not limited to any particular aspect or embodiment of the invention and apply equally to all aspects and embodiments which are described.
It will further be appreciated by those skilled in the art that although the invention has been described by way of example with reference to several embodiments. It is not limited to the disclosed embodiments and that alternative embodiments could be constructed without departing from the scope of the invention as defined in the appended claims.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2007690.7 | May 2020 | GB | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/GB2021/051244 | 5/21/2021 | WO |