Patent Grant
RE39353
The present invention relates to mass spectrometer systems useful for obtaining matrix-assisted laser desorption measurements. More particularly, this invention is directed to an automated mass spectrometer system for combining high sample throughput with high reliability.
Matrix-assisted laser desorption and ionization (MALDI) is a relatively new technique that allows very large molecules, such as DNA fragments and proteins, to be desorbed from a solid sample and ionized without significant decomposition. Coupled with mass spectrometry, this technique allows the molecular weights of biological polymers and other large molecules, including industrial polymers, to be precisely determined. One version of MALDI is described in a 1991 article in Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry, Vol. 5, Pages 198-202. A mass spectrometer suitable for obtaining highly reliable matrix-assisted laser desorption measurements is described in U.S. Pat. 5,045,694.
Most MALDI applications to date have employed time-of-flight mass spectrometers, although magnetic deflection, Fourier Transform ion cyclotron resonance, and quadrupole ion trap mass analyzers have also been used. A liquid solution of the sample to be analyzed is mixed with a solution containing an appropriate matrix, and a small aliquot of this mixtures is deposited on the source of the mass spectrometer (inside a vacuum system). A vacuum lock is generally utilized to avoid venting the vacuum system. Loading a sample typically requires from one to several minutes, and the attention of a skilled operator. A diligent operator should theoretically be able to load and run a sample every five or ten minutes using such a system, but it is difficult to maintain such a rate over an extended period. U.S. Pat. 5,288,644 discloses one technique for reducing the required time. A plurality of samples are loaded onto the solid surface of a disk, which is rotated by a stepper motor for positioning each sample respectively for striking by a laser beam.
Further improvements in the loading of samples for the laser desorption mass analysis are required for this analytical procedure to gain greater acceptance and significantly increase the use of this analytical tool. The disadvantages of the prior art overcome by the present invention, and an improved system is hereinafter disclosed for obtaining matrix-assisted mass spectrometer measurements. The loading of the samples is highly automated for achieving both high sample throughput and high reliability. The present invention has a wide range of application, and may be used with various analytical methods.
The present invention provides a highly automated system for preparing, loading, and running samples by MALDI mass spectrometry. Each step in the process may be controlled and monitored by a computer. All sample processing and identification information is recorded along with the mass spectra measurements, so that automated processing of the data may be performed. The typical input to this system is a collection of samples in relatively crude or unprocessed form, and the output provides direct answers to specific questions posed by the scientists relative to the samples. This system is particularly useful in application that require processing a large number of samples to provide the required data. Examples include DNA sequencing on the scale required by the Human Genome Project, protein sequencing, and determination of the locations and nature of post-translational modifications of proteins.
While there are many potential applications of this invention, the Human Genome Project provides a particularly timely example of the need for this advancement. The DNA that composes the human genome has about 3.5 billion base pairs. Although highly developed techniques for sequencing DNA have been developed, at least a decade would be required using available techniques to accurately sequence even one such DNA. Completion of the genome project will require sequencing thousands or possibly millions of such genomes from both humans and other organisms. The present invention will accordingly be described in detail below with particular emphasis on its application to DNA sequencing, but it should be recognized that it has other applications.
It is an object of this invention to provide improved equipment and techniques for performing MALDI mass spectrometry analysis. The equipment and techniques of this invention substantially reduce both the time and expertise required to load, run, and analyze multiple samples, thereby significantly reducing the cost of the analysis.
A significant feature of this invention relates to the effective combination of mass spectrometry equipment and techniques with matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization equipment and techniques. The equipment and techniques may be utilized to substantially reduce the cost of DNA sequencing. The invention may also be used for determining the molecular weight of various large molecules, such as biological and industrial polymers.
A significant advantage of this invention relates to the reduced time required for mass spectrometry analysis of multiple samples. The invention is particularly well suited for use with a time-of-flight mass spectrometer.
These and further objects, features, and advantages of the present invention will become apparent from the following detailed description, wherein reference is made to the figures in the accompanying drawings.
The system according to this invention typically involves many components integrated under computer control into a fully automated system. A typical system of ten primary components includes: (1) a sample plate or other sample receiving surface upon which a large number of physically separated and distinguishable samples can be loaded in liquid solution then allowed to dry; (2) identification means for uniquely identifying each sample position and sample plate; (3) an automated system for processing and preparing samples and transferring aliquots to selected sample positions on a sample plate; (4) drying means for storing one or more sample plates in a controlled environment; (5) transferring means for automatically or manually transferring a plurality of sample plates from the controlled environment into the sample receiving chamber of the MALDI mass spectrometer; (6) an automated vacuum lock system for transferring sample plates between the receiving chamber and the ionization source of the MALDI mass spectrometer without significantly increasing the pressure in the mass spectrometer vacuum system; (7) sequencing means for sequentially placing each sample on the sample receiving surface in the path of the laser beam, so that its MALDI spectrum is recorded and stored along with the sample identification information; (8) means for automatically adjusting the laser intensity and sample position relative to the laser beam to obtain MALDI spectra which meet or exceed predetermined criteria; (9) means for automatically calibrating the mass axis of the MALDI mass spectrometer; and (10) means for automatically interpreting the MALDI mass spectra obtained from one or more samples to determine and produce the answer to a specific question. A scientist may thus make inquiry as to the sequence of the bases in a particular DNA fragment, and the system of this invention will rapidly provide the answer in a highly cost-effective manner.
In some applications manual operations may be substituted for the corresponding automated step, but the full power and speed of the invention is realized when operator intervention is required at most, once or twice per day. Each of the ten primary components (and/or corresponding steps) which may comprise an exemplary system is described in more detail below.
1. Sample Receiving Surface
A preferred embodiment of a sample receiving surface is illustrated in FIG. 1. The depicted sample plate 10 consists of a thin, substantially square plate 12 of stainless steel or other suitable electrically conducting material approximately 1.5 mm thick and 50 mm wide. The plate 10 may contain precisely located holes to allow the position and orientation of the plate to be accurately determined relative to a moveable stage, which is required both in the sample loading step and in the ion source of the mass spectrometer. The sample plate 10 also contains a plurality of precisely determinable sample positions 16 on the upper sample receiving surface 18 of the plate. These sample positions may be determined by a number of photoetched and numbered sample positions or wells as illustrated in FIG. 1. Alternatively, a number of sample positions may be identified by electroplated sample spots and numbers on the surface 18 of the sample plate, with the sample identification providing the row and column number of a respective adjoining sample, i.e., position identification 34 being the sample in the third row and the fourth column of the plurality of samples on the plate 10.
A plate 10 may thus contain 100 sample positions each identified by a sample spot which is about 2.5 mm in diameter in a precisely known location on the plate, with each sample support being suitable for accepting a few microliters of sample solution. Each sample spot may be further identified by a corresponding number similarly plated or etched on the surface 18. Alternatively, the plate may contain a larger number of spots in which photoetched sample wells or photoplated sample spots of appropriate diameter in precisely known locations are prepared on the sample surface without the corresponding sample numbers on the surface. The known sample coordinates thus may be sufficient to identify each sample well or spot. In the case of a 400 sample array (20 rows and 20 columns), 2 mm sample wells or spots have been used successfully. For a 1024 array (32 rows and 32 columns), a 50 mm square plate and 1 mm diameter sample positions have been successfully used. Another alternative is to use a smooth unmodified sample plate in which the x-y coordinates are sufficient to define a unique sample position. The detailed description of the invention discussed below utilizes 50 mm plates with square arrays of sample positions which can accommodate up to 1024 distinguishable sample positions. Any distribution of samples over a surface, either known or unknown, can be accommodated. Sample plates of a variety of geometries could be used, including circular, rectangular, and regular and irregular polygons. The maximum size of the sample plate is limited only by the size of the ion source vacuum chamber and travel limits of the x-y table on which the sample receiving stage is mounted. It should be understood that smaller or larger numbers of distinguishable sample positions may thus be defined on sample receiving surfaces of other geometries.
In a preferred embodiment as illustrated in
The sample plate 10 has beveled comerscorners 22 yet provides a total square surface having 50 mm sides interior of the beveled comerscorners on the top surface of the plate 10 for receiving multiple samples. Samples may be deposited on this plate in a variety of ways, and for explanation purposes it may be assumed that an array of circular spots 16 is photoetched into the plate 10 along with identifying numbers. This arrangement easily accommodates up to 1024 sample spots each 1 mm in diameter in a 32×32 array without identifying numbers. Each of these 1024 sample spots will accommodate about 100 nanoliters of sample solution.
As shown in
As shown in
2. Identification of Sample Position and Plate
The x-y coordinate of each sample position on one side (typically the top side) of the sample plate may be used to determine a unique sample position on each sample plate. The diameter of a sample spot centered on each position may be used to further define a sample position. The minimum data required to uniquely identify a sample position is the x-y coordinate and the diameter of the spot. As discussed above, the sample position may be further defined by a photoetched well or photoplated spot centered at the corresponding x-y coordinate on the sample plate, and may be even further defined by the corresponding number etched or plated near the corresponding sample spot.
Each particular sample plate may be identified by a serial number etched into the top surface of the plate or attached to or etched into the bottom surface of the plate. A computer readable bar code may be used with a sufficient number of digits to uniquely identify the sample plate relative to any other which might be encountered within a series of similar runs. The systems involved in applying the samples to the sample plates and those for loading the plates into the mass spectrometer as discussed below may also be equipped with bar code readers to provide the required identification of the sample plates.
3. Processing and Preparing Samples
The details of this component will depend on the application, the types of samples to be tested, and the degree to which the samples are prepared and purified prior to being input to the analysis system described below. The following discussion sets forth the representative steps required to carry out an automated MALDI analysis. It should be appreciated that additional automated sample preparation and purification steps could be added. Rate-determining steps may be used, for example, to determine the speed with which the complete determination can be done.
The invention is particularly suited for DNA sequencing. For this purpose, it is assumed that a set of sequencing mixtures has been prepared off-line using either the Maxxam-Gilbert or Sanger method. The mixtures may be presented to the system in the form of liquid solutions in small vials or tubes in a tray which may be accessed by an autosampler. Substantially the same samples in the same form may be presented for separation by electrophoresis in conventional DNA sequencing.
With reference to
4. Drying and Storing Sample Plates
When each sample location on a plate has been loaded with a sample, the samples are allowed to dry before the plate is transferred into the vacuum chamber of the mass spectrometer. In the simplest case, the plates may be transferred from the sample loading system to a rack or cassette where they are allowed to dry in laboratory air. In the preferred embodiment, however, this rack or cassette 54 is located inside a sealed chamber 52 equipped with a computer-controlled door 56 which allows the samples to be dried in an environment in which the pressure, temperature, and composition of the surrounding atmosphere is controlled. In the fully automated mode, each of the loaded and dried sample plates may be transferred from the sample plate storage chamber 52 to an adjacent mass spectrometer. Alternatively, the samples may be prepared and loaded off-line onto the sample plates. When a sufficient number of sample plates has been loaded with samples, the plurality of sample plates may be transferred manually to the mass spectrometer and loaded as a complete cassette using the manually operated sample loading door.
5. Transferring Sample Plates into the Mass Spectrometer Sample Receiving Chamber
The manual step involved in loading the sample plates may be eliminated by adding a sample storage region to the vacuum lock chamber of a mass spectrometer, as shown schematically in
The system as shown in
When analysis of the samples on one plate 10 within the ion source is completed, the plate 10 is ejected and placed in a vacant slot in the sample storage cassette 80. This cassette 80 is then moved by stepper motor 66 and lead screw 64 to bring a new sample plate in the transport tray 80 in line with the transporter 89, and the new sample plate is loaded. The exchange of samples may thus be accomplished without venting of the vacuum lock chamber 68, which was evacuated during the time that the samples on the previous plate were being analyzed. This allows sample plates to be changed very quickly (at most a few seconds) while maintaining the ion source at high vacuum.
The sample storage chamber 60 is equipped with a manually operated door 70 through which a number of sample plates loaded with samples that are off-line can be introduced simultaneously. To load a set of samples, a “manual load” setting is selected on the computer 36. This causes the sample storage chamber 60 to be vented to atmosphere via vent valve 72, and allows the manual load door 70 to be opened. The samples are then loaded and the chamber evacuated. The entire set of sample plates can now be analyzed automatically without further operator intervention.
6. Automated Vacuum Lock System
The vacuum lock chamber 68 is equipped with computer controlled valves and mechanical transport devices which allow the sample plates 10 to be transported under computer control from the sample storage chamber 60 (which may be at atmospheric pressure) to the sample receiving stage within the evacuated ion source chamber 74 of a mass spectrometer, without venting the evacuated chamber 74. The vacuum lock chamber 68 has an input port which may be opened or closed by door 58 and through which sample plates are loaded from the sample storage chamber 60 into the vacuum lock chamber 68. An output port through which a sample plate is transported from the vacuum lock chamber 68 to the ion source vacuum chamber 74 is similarly opened and closed by output door 76. Each door includes an “O” ring seal and may be opened and closed by a respective air cylinder 75 controlled from the computer 107.
A preferred embodiment of the vacuum lock chamber 68 is depicted in
A simplified version of the vacuum lock designed for use with remote sample storage chamber is shown schematically in
With reference now to
To eject the sample plate and load a new one the process is reversed. First the output door 76A is opened, and the transport cylinder 89A equipped with the electromagnet 102 is extended so that the electromagnet makes contact with the magnetic strip on the sample plate 10. The electromagnet is energized and the cylinder 89A retracted to move the sample plate from the ion source chamber 97 to the transport tray 99 in the vacuum lock chamber 92. The output door 76A is closed, the magnet 102 is de-energized, the input door 98 is opened, and the sample tray 99 extended so that the old sample plate can be removed by the operator and replaced with a new sample plate. Except for this final step, the entire operation is accomplished entirely under control of computer 107 with no intervention from the operator except for selecting a “eject” setting on the computer to remove a sample, and an “operate” setting to load a new sample and begin the test.
Operation of the fully automated system shown in
7. Sequentially Testing Loaded Sample Plates
A preferred embodiment of the ion source 110 and a MALDI mass spectrometer 112 is depicted in
With computer control of the stepper motors, this system allows any selected point on the sample plate to be positioned precisely (typically within one thousandths of an inch) on the optic axis of the mass spectrometer where it is irradiated by the laser beam 136. Beam 136 strikes a sample on plate 10 at point 120 within plane 117, resulting in ion beam 134. Accordingly ions may be produced from each sample on the plate 10, which is moved automatically by the x-y table 114 between sample positions with respect to the laser beam.
The remaining components of a suitable time-of-flight mass spectrometer 112 as shown in
Most of the low weight ions are prevented from reaching the detector 140 by deflection plates 130 and 132, which may be spaced 1 cm. apart. Plate 130 may be a ground potential. Plate 132 receives a square wave pulse timed as a function of the laser beam striking a particular sample. Each pulse thus suppresses low mass ions, so that substantially only desired ions reach the detector 140. Other details with respect to a suitable spectrometer are disclosed in U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,045,694 and 5,160,840.
8. Automatically Adjusting Laser Intensity and Sample Position
In MALDI, the intensity and quality of the mass spectra generated is strongly dependent on the intensity of the plume of ionized and neutral material that is produced by the incident laser pulse impinging on the sample and matrix. This intensity depends on the laser intensity, the composition of the matrix used, and details of the crystalline structure of the matrix and sample on the surface. While it is possible to establish a narrow range of laser intensities which produce acceptable spectra, one typically cannot predict with the desired precision the laser intensity which will yield the best results on a particular sample. In general, if the laser intensity if too high, the signal-to-noise ratio may be excellent, but the mass resolution and mass accuracy is degraded. Conversely, if the laser intensity is too low, the mass resolution and accuracy are satisfactory, but the signal level is low and signal-to-noise ratio is poor. Also, the surfaces of multiple samples on a plate tend to be non-uniform, so that some locations yield excellent results and others do not. Under manual control of the laser beam and sample position, it is possible through a process of trial and error to find a combination of laser intensity and sample position which provides excellent results.
An automatic control used according to this invention closely mirrors what is generally the most successful strategy when operating manually. The intensity of the beam output 136 from the laser source 148 is increased until the ion signal suddenly appears at a relatively high setting. At this point, signal-to-noise is excellent, but resolution is poor. As the laser intensity is decreased, the signal may actually increase at first (sometimes going into saturation), but at some lower intensity the signal is decreased, and the resolution is dramatically increased. With an improved attenuator 138, this hysteresis appears to be entirely related to changes in the sample properties, and is not due to hysteresis in the attenuator. The upper and lower values for these events are very reasonably reproducible and appear to depend primarily on the particular matrix used, and only weakly on the sample preparation, source voltage, or other parameters.
The strategy for exploiting these observations in the automatic mode follows. The upper and lower limits in the acquisition set-up menu and the laser step size are established. Two choices are provided for the number of spectra to be averaged: an upper number and a lower number. The upper number of spectra are averaged when the laser beam 136 is at its maximum intensity, and the lower number is used at all other laser intensities.
When a new sample is selected by the autosampler menu, the acquisition starts with the laser beam 136 set at the upper limit. The number of spectra requested is averaged. If a spectrum acquired contains intensity within the desired mass and intensity limits set, the spectrum is saved and calibrated using the upper calibration file associated with this set-up file. If the spectrum acquired is too intense, i.e., the maximum intensity within the mass window is greater than the upper intensity level (typically set just below saturation), the laser intensity is decreased by one increment and the process repeated until a spectrum meeting the selection criteria is obtained or the lower limit is reached. If the spectrum is too weak, i.e., the maximum intensity within the mass window is too weak, the sample is incremented to a new spot and the process is repeated. If a spectrum is obtained which has intensity within the chosen limits at any laser intensity other than the lower limit, that spectrum is saved as an upper intensity spectrum and the upper calibration file associated with the acquisition set-up file is used. If an acceptable spectrum is obtained at the lower limit of laser intensity, that spectrum is saved as a lower intensity spectrum and the lower calibration file associated with the acquisition set-up file is used. If both an upper and a lower intensity spectrum are obtained on the selected sample spot, the acquisition proceeds to the next sample. If only one of these is obtained, or neither one, the sample is incremented to a new spot until both an upper and a lower spectrum have been saved, or until the range of possible sample spots has been exhausted.
9. Automatically Calibrating the Mass Axis
During automatic operation of the MALDI instrument, an automatic procedure may be used for checking the calibration of and recalibrating the mass scale to maintain the desired mass accuracy. This can be accomplished by loading a sample plate containing one or more known samples so that the known mass spectrum can be used to automatically check and correct the mass scale as necessary.
The procedure for calibrating the mass axis is described below. Each acquisition set-up file must have both an upper and a lower calibration file associated with it. These files may be chosen from a list of files already in existence by the operator preparing the set-up file, or may be generated using the “calibrate” selection in the set-up file for calibration based on a selected known sample. Each calibration file which is saved may have all of the parameters associated with its generation saved, so that in the event the operator chooses a calibration file which employs different parameter values, a warning is given and the acquisition set-up file corresponding to the one that was used may be displayed with the parameters highlighted that are different from those which have been selected in the new acquisition set-up. The operator has the option of approving the chosen calibration file which is then associated with the new set-up file, even if some parameters are different. Alternatively, the operator may reject the chosen calibration file, return to the set-up file, and either choose a different calibration file or generate a new one. If a new calibration file is generated using a particular set-up file, a “check replace” selection may be employed to determine if the file is to replace a pre-existing calibration file. A new designation for upper or lower calibration numbers is also an option.
In addition to the above changes in the manual calibration procedure, an automatic calibration mode may be used. Particular samples on the sample plate may be identified as calibration samples, and the calibration compound selected from a list. For each sample or calibration compound, the matrix from a list may be selected. For each calibration compound and matrix combination chosen, a list of masses and laser intensities may be stored. The normally used mass and intensity valvesvalues may be entered as an initial equipment set-up. A service technician will be able to alter initial factory data at the location of the customer.
During automatic calibration, the procedure for acquiring the calibration spectrum is the same as for acquiring data from a sample. If the calibration designation is selected in the autosampler set-up, that sample is treated as a calibration sample and the spectrum obtained is compared to that expected from the reference file. If peaks are found within the default values of mass and internally (typically set by the service technician), the calibration file for the particular acquisition set-up and laser intensity being used is recomputed, and the old file replaced by the new file. If the observed spectrum falls outside the default limits, a warning message is momentarily displayed and then stored for later display when the data are processed. If the attempted calibration does not succeed, the old value is retained, and automatic acquisition proceeds. For instrument service purposes, it may be desirable to retain the old calibration files in a directory accessible to the service technician.
To implement the above, columns may be added to the autosampler set-up menu. These columns might include a choice of sample or calibrant, a choice of matrices from a pull-down list, and a pull-down menu showing the list of known calibrants. The operator may also enter new parameters characterizing a new calibrant within another column. The operator may also have the option of designating a matrix choice in the acquisition set-up file.
10. Automatically Interpreting the MALDI Mass Spectra
Mass spectra interpretation depend on the type of samples analyzed and the information required. The first step is to convert the observed time-of-flight spectrum into a mass spectrum, i.e., a table of masses and intensities for all of the peaks observed in the time-of-flight spectra. Peaks that are known to be due to the matrix or other extraneous material will normally be deleted from this list. This mass spectrum is obtained by calculating the centroid and integral intensity of each peak. The peak width may also be included (e.g., full width at half maximum) to provide a measure of the maximum uncertainty in the mass determination.
In the application to DNA sequencing, each set of four samples consists of one sample ending, so that all possible fragments ending in a specific base are included in each sample set. Accordingly, for each DNA fragment to be sequenced, there is a sample with all possible fragments terminating in C, T, A, and G, respectively. Each of these fragments is observed as a peak in the time-of-flight spectrum of that sample. By superimposing the four spectra, the sequence of bases can be read directly. Furthermore, the mass difference between any pair of peaks in these four spectra mass correspond to the total mass associated with the nucleotides in that portion of the sequence. This provides a significant redundancy in the results, which may be useful for analysis other than that involving the simple ordering of the peaks, a feature which is not available in electrophoresis. If a peak is very weak and is missed, or if two peaks are insufficiently resolved, a base may be missed by simple ordering. The mass difference observed between the next pair of adjacent peaks will thus show the error and allow correction. The computer may thus interpret the spectra and directly produce the sequence of bases in the DNA fragment. If there are any regions of the spectrum where the results may be considerconsidered ambiguous or unreliable, e.g., because the observed mass differences are inconsistent, those regions may be flagged so that the operator may perform either manual study or further automated analysis on those regions.
According to the technique of this invention a MALDI mass spectrometer is used rather than electrophoresis separation for DNA sequencing. Until recently, the MALDI technique was limited to single-stranded DNA fragments up to about 50 bases in length, but the range has now been extended to fragments as large as 500 bases in length.
Conventional large-scale sequencing is currently being done at a rate approaching 1 Mb per year of finished sequence. The cost of sequencing is in the vicinity of one U.S. dollar per base. A rate of 500 Mb per year is required for the Human Genome Project. A price of 20 cents per finished base is commensurate with the budget and goals of this project.
At the present stage of development, MALDI analysis of DNA fragments can be done readily on mixtures containing components less than 50 bases in length. Recent work suggests that this fragment length can be extended, perhaps as much as one order of magnitude to fragments 500 bases in length. Large scale sequencing would proceed much more rapidly by this technique if the fragments analyzed could be extended significantly. A reasonable goal is to be able to accurately analyze mixtures containing oligimers up to 300 bases in length. The resolution and sensitivity of presently available instruments is satisfactory. Even with the limitations imposed by the short segments, the MALDI technique with application of the present invention could be competitive with conventional approaches.
The present invention can readily handle at least 4 samples per minute, which corresponds with 50 base fragments to 50 bases of raw data per minute, since 4 separate samples are required to sequence each segment. A single instrument can run at least 1200 minutes per day to provide 60,000 bases per day of raw sequence. This is about 22 Mb/year from a single instrument. This is raw data, however, and the piercing together of fragments from short sequence generated data is likely to require considerable redundancy. Nevertheless, a single instrument, even with the limitations imposed by short segments, can surpass the total output of present conventional sequencing. The price for this instrument is about $200,000, and it should have a useful life of at least 5 years. Total cost for operating and maintaining the instrument (including amortization) should be less than $100,000/year. If the instrument produces 2 Mb of finished sequence/year, this corresponds to 5 cents/base. 250 such instruments would be required to provide sequences at the rate required by the Human Genome Project. If the length of the fragments analyzed can be extended, the speed will increase and the cost will rapidly decrease since less redundancy will be required. If the fragment length was increased to 300 bases, the raw data rate increases proportionally to about 120 Mb/year. The ratio of this raw rate to finished data rate should improve dramatically and may approach 50 Mb/year for a single instrument. In this case, ten instruments could provide the rate required by the Human Genome Project at a cost of 0.2 cent per base. Although this rate would not include the cost of sample preparation and data analysis, the rate and cost of raw sequence determination would no longer be the limiting feature.
It should be understood that this invention has been disclosed so that one skilled in the art may appreciate its feature and advantages, and that a detailed description of specific components and the spacing and size of the components is not necessary to obtain that understanding. Many of the individual components of the mass spectrometer are conventional in the industry, and accordingly are only schematically depicted. The foregoing disclosure and description of the invention are thus explanatory, and various details in the construction of the equipment are not included. Alternative embodiments and operating techniques will become apparent to those skilled in the art in view of this disclosure, and such modifications should be considered within the scope of the invention, which is defined by the following claims.
Note that more than one reissue application has been field. This application is a continuation of reissue application Ser. No. 09/038,324, filed on Mar. 11, 1998, issued as RE37485, the entire content of which is incorporated by reference herein.
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3117223 | Brunnee | Jan 1964 | A |
| 4076982 | Ritter et al. | Feb 1978 | A |
| 4296322 | Wechsung | Oct 1981 | A |
| 4330208 | Eloy | May 1982 | A |
| 4405860 | Brunnee et al. | Sep 1983 | A |
| 4431924 | Suovaniemi et al. | Feb 1984 | A |
| 4468468 | Benninghoven et al. | Aug 1984 | A |
| 4620103 | Kambara et al. | Oct 1986 | A |
| 4740692 | Yamamoto et al. | Apr 1988 | A |
| 4816638 | Ukai et al. | Mar 1989 | A |
| 4911815 | Kamei et al. | Mar 1990 | A |
| 4919894 | Daniel | Apr 1990 | A |
| 4988879 | Zare et al. | Jan 1991 | A |
| 5037611 | Ledford, Jr. | Aug 1991 | A |
| 5041725 | Izumi | Aug 1991 | A |
| 5045694 | Beavis et al. | Sep 1991 | A |
| 5083020 | Takahashi | Jan 1992 | A |
| 5160840 | Vestal | Nov 1992 | A |
| 5288644 | Beavis et al. | Feb 1994 | A |
| 5382793 | Weinberger et al. | Jan 1995 | A |
| RE37485 | Vestal | Dec 2001 | E |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| 3221681 | Dec 1993 | DE |
| 88917 | Sep 1993 | EP |
| 2029634 | Mar 1980 | GB |
| 2967166 | Aug 1981 | GB |
| 2257295 | Jan 1993 | GB |
| 61-58153 | Mar 1986 | JP |
| 63-244619 | Oct 1988 | JP |
| WO 9104781 | Apr 1991 | WO |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 09038324 | Mar 1998 | US |
| Child | 08278405 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 08278405 | Jul 1994 | US |
| Child | 09755951 | US |
