Method and apparatus for chemically-mechanically polishing semiconductor wafers

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6261959
  • Patent Number
    6,261,959
  • Date Filed
    Friday, March 31, 2000
    24 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, July 17, 2001
    23 years ago
Abstract
An apparatus for chemically-mechanically polishing a semiconductor wafer comprises a receiving surface attached with a frame; a loading mechanism in contact with the receiving surface, the loading mechanism being configured to load measured portions of a wafer-polishing member containing a fixed abrasive onto the receiving surface; a reciprocation device attached with at least a portion of the receiving surface, the reciprocation device being powered to move the receiving surface in a linear, bi-directional motion; and a wafer holder positioned to releasably hold a wafer adjacent to the receiving surface. Methods of chemically-mechanically polishing semiconductor wafers are also provided.
Description




FIELD OF THE INVENTION




The present invention relates to polishing and planarization of semiconductor wafers. More particularly, the present invention relates to method and apparatus for linearly reciprocating a portion of a continuous polishing member to process a semiconductor wafer.




BACKGROUND




Chemical mechanical planarization techniques are used to planarize and polish each layer of a semiconductor wafer. Available CMP systems, commonly called wafer polishers, often use a rotating wafer carrier that brings the wafer into contact with a polishing pad rotating in the plane of the wafer surface to be planarized. A chemical polishing agent or slurry containing microabrasives and surface modifying chemicals is applied to the polishing pad to polish the wafer. The wafer holder then presses the wafer against the rotating pad and is rotated to polish and planarize the wafer. Some available wafer polishers use orbital motion, or a linear belt, rather than a rotating surface to carry the polishing head. One challenge of polishing semiconductor wafers using a disposable polishing pad on the available wafer polishers is that these polishers must be frequently stopped to replace the polishing member after a limited number of uses. Accordingly, there is a need for a method and system of performing CMP that addresses this issue.




SUMMARY




In one aspect of the invention, an apparatus for chemically-mechanically polishing a semiconductor wafer comprises a receiving surface attached with a frame; a loading mechanism in contact with the receiving surface, the loading mechanism being configured to load measured portions of a wafer-polishing member containing a fixed abrasive onto the receiving surface; a reciprocation device attached with at least a portion of the receiving surface, the reciprocation device being powered to move the receiving surface in a linear, bi-directional motion; and a wafer holder positioned to releasably hold a wafer adjacent to the receiving surface.




In another aspect of the invention, a loading mechanism for loading measured portions of a wafer-polishing member containing a fixed abrasive into an apparatus for the chemical-mechanical polishing of semiconductor wafers comprises a polishing member dispensing roller connected with a frame, the polishing member dispensing roller holding a supply of waferpolishing member, and a feeding device in contact with the supply of waferpolishing member, the feeding device configured to move measured portions of the wafer-polishing member onto a receiving surface in the apparatus for the chemical-mechanical polishing of semiconductor wafers.




In another aspect of the invention, a method of polishing semiconductor wafers comprises loading a measured portion of a wafer-polishing member containing a fixed abrasive onto the receiving surface; and reciprocating the receiving surface and wafer-polishing member in a linear, bi-directional motion against the semiconductor wafer.




In another aspect of the invention, an apparatus for chemically-mechanically polishing semiconductor wafers comprises a receiving surface attached to a frame; a loading mechanism in contact with the receiving surface, the loading mechanism being configured to loads discrete sheets of wafer-polishing members containing a fixed abrasive onto the receiving surface; a reciprocation device attached with at least a portion of the receiving surface, the reciprocation device being powered to move the receiving surface in a linear, bi-directional motion; and a wafer holder positioned to releasably hold a wafer adjacent to the receiving surface.




In another aspect of the invention, a loading mechanism for loading discreet sheets of wafer-polishing members containing a fixed abrasive into an apparatus for the chemical-mechanical polishing of semiconductor wafers comprises a supply bin in a frame, the supply bin adapted to contain a plurality of discrete sheets of wafer-polishing members; an automated sheet feeder in contact with the supply bin, the sheet feeder being configured to automatically uptake a first discrete sheet in the supply of discrete sheets and to load the first discreet sheet onto the receiving surface; and an adjustment mechanism in contact with the supply bin and the automated sheet feeder such that the adjustment mechanism adjusts the relative positioning of the automated sheet feeder and the supply of discrete sheets in the supply bin.




In still another aspect of the invention, a method of simultaneously conditioning a measured portion of a wafer-polishing member containing a fixed abrasive and chemically-mechanically polishing a semiconductor wafer comprises a) loading a measured portion of a wafer-polishing member containing a fixed abrasive onto the receiving surface; and b) reciprocating the receiving surface and wafer-polishing member in a linear bi-directional motion against the semiconductor wafer, c) repeating (b) and (c) until the semiconductor wafer is polished and the measured portion of the wafer-polishing member is conditioned.




The present invention provides the foregoing and other features, and the advantages of the invention will become further apparent from the following detailed description of the presently preferred embodiments, read in conjunction with the accompanying drawings. The detailed description and drawings are merely illustrative of the invention and do not limit the scope of the invention, which is defined by the appended claims and equivalents thereof.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF SEVERAL VIEWS OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a side view of an apparatus for chemically-mechanically polishing a semiconductor wafer.





FIG. 2

is a front view of the chemical-mechanical polishing apparatus of FIG.


1


.





FIG. 3

is a top view of the chemical-mechanical polishing apparatus of FIG.


1


.





FIG. 4

is a side view of a loading mechanism and the chemical-mechanical polishing apparatus for which the loading mechanism is used.





FIG. 5

is a side view of a loading mechanism and the chemical-mechanecal polishing apparatus for which the loading mechanism is used.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS




There are several preferred embodiments of the method and apparatus for chemically-mechanically polishing semiconductor wafers.




EMBODIMENTS HAVING A CONTINUOUS SUPPLY OF ABRASIVE MATERIAL




A preferred embodiment of an apparatus for chemically-mechanically polishing a semiconductor wafer is depicted in

FIGS. 1

,


2


, and


3


. The apparatus


2


is built about frame


4


and mounting plate


6


.




An abrasive belt feed roll


10


holds a supply of wafer-polishing member


12


. A preferred wafer-polishing member comprises a flexible strip having an abrasive layer fixed onto the strip. In one embodiment, the abrasive layer comprises a series of discrete cylindrical abrasive members such that as the abrasive layer becomes worn down through use, the surface area of the discrete cylindrical abrasive members remains substantially constant. The abrasive layer is preferably covered with a protective polymer layer. The polymer layer is removed before the abrasive can be used to polish a semiconductor wafer. This preferred wafer-polishing member is commercially available through the Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company as part numbers 3M 307EA and 3M 237AA, which are available in grades A100, A65, A45, A16, and A6.




In another preferred embodiment, the wafer-polishing member comprises a polishing pad adapted to receive an abrasive slurry such as the slurries disclosed in U.S. Pat. Nos. 6,007,407, 6,012,966 and 6,022,266. These patents are incorporated by reference in their entirety. A suitable polishing pad material is commercially available from the Rodel Corporation of Delaware.




Attached to a sidewall of abrasive belt feed roll


10


is belt tension control


14


. When belt tension control


14


is off, feed roll


10


is free to rotate. Any known belt tension control mechanism is contemplated for use with this embodiment. The preferred belt tension control


14


can be activated many ways, including but not limited to electronically, pneumatically, hydraulically or a combination.




Although not required, each of the above embodiments described herein may utilize a non-abrasive liquid during polishing, such as deionized water, to facilitate the polishing process. The non-abrasive liquid may be applied via nozzles


43


(See

FIG. 1

) to the region of the polishing strip intended for contact with a wafer.




Belt conditioner


20


is positioned between belt feed roll


10


and ingress rollers


22




a


and


22




b


. In a preferred embodiment, belt conditioner


20


conditions the wafer-polishing member


12


before polishing member


12


is used to polish a semiconductor wafer. In a preferred embodiment, belt conditioner


20


removes the protective polymer layer from the wafer-polishing member


12


. Suitable belt conditioners


20


include, but are not limited to, the conditioners described in U.S. Pat. Nos. 6,022,266, 5,938,507, and 5,934,980, which are hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety. In another preferred embodiment, there is no belt conditioner


20


because the process of polishing occurs simultaneously with the process of conditioning. This is described in greater detail supra in this specification.




Ingress roller


22




a


is powered, and ingress roller


22




b


is not powered. In alternative embodiments, both rollers can be powered or roller


22




b


can be powered while


22




a


is not. Wafer-polishing member


12


is in contact with belt conditioner


20


and ingress rollers


22




a


and


22




b


. In the depicted embodiment, wafer-polishing member


12


frictionally fits between ingress rollers


22




a


and


22




b


. These rollers move wafer-polishing member


12


onto a receiving surface


30


. That is, through ingress rollers


22




a


and


22




b


, a measured portion of wafer-polishing member


12


is pulled from feed roll


10


onto receiving surface


30


.




Referring to

FIG. 3

, clamps


26




a


and


26




b


secure the measured portion of wafer-polishing member


12


onto receiving surface


30


. Clamps are merely an exemplary securing mechanism. Any securing mechanism known in the art could be used to secure wafer-polishing member


12


onto receiving surface


30


.




Receiving surface


30


has an ingress side and an egress side. In a preferred embodiment, belt cutter


27


is positioned above receiving surface


30


on the ingress side. In another preferred embodiment, belt cutter


27


is positioned above receiving surface


30


on the egress side. The position of the belt cutter


27


determines how much of the chemical mechanical polishing assembly oscillates with receiving surface


30


along guide rails


36




a


and


36




b


when polishing occurs. Reciprocating table


32


is attached to reciprocation drive assembly


35


. Preferred drive assemblies


35


include a crank shaft, drive motor, connecting rods, and a counter balance. A preferred drive assembly reciprocates linearly (+/−one inch) at an adjustable frequency of from about 0 to about 25 Hertz.




Reciprocating table


32


reciprocates in guide rails


36




a


and


36




b


. It is preferred that the guide rails have linear bearings.




When the belt cutter


27


is on the ingress side of receiving surface


30


, as shown, the moving parts include clamps


26




a


and


26




b


, egress roller


28




b


, driven portions of reciprocation drive assembly


35


that impart reciprocation motion onto reciprocated table


32


and counterweight


34


. When the belt cutter is on the egress side of receiving surface


30


, the following additional parts move with receiving surface


30


: feed roll


10


, belt tension control


14


, ingress rollers


22




a


and


22




b


, and egress roller


28




a.






Egress rollers


28




a


and


28




b


are in contact with wafer-polishing member


12


on the egress side of receiving surface


30


. Egress roller


28




a


is powered, and egress roller


28




b


is not powered. In other embodiments, both rollers may be powered or roller


28




b


may be powered while roller


28




a


is not. Belt disposal container


29


is positioned to receive spent measured portions of wafer-polishing member


12


from egress rollers


28




a


and


28




b


. Any container or disposal mechanism known to those of skill in the art for disposing of spent measured portions of wafer-polishing member


12


is contemplated for use in this embodiment.




In a preferred embodiment, receiving surface


30


comprises reciprocating table


32


positioned above air-bearing platen assembly


34


.




Platen assemblies contemplated for use with this embodiment can be any known platen assembly, including but not limited to the platen assemblies disclosed in U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,558,568, 5,985,093, 6,000,997, 6,015,499 and 6,015,506, which are hereby incorporated by reference. Other acceptable platens are those commercially available from the Lam Research Corporation of Fremont, California, including the ones with the trade name TERES. Note that some of these platens are rotating platen assemblies. The platen assemblies contemplated for use with this embodiment are preferably not rotating.




Wafer holder


40


comprises spindle


42


and carrier head


44


. Carrier head


44


releasably holds wafer


46


. During polishing, wafer


46


is pressed against wafer-polishing member


12


by the wafer holder


40


. Spindle


42


rotates carrier head


44


and wafer


46


about an axis perpendicular to receiving surface


30


as wafer polishing member


12


reciprocates with reciprocating table


32


along guide rails


36




a


and


36




b


. In another preferred embodiment, wafer holder


40


does not rotate wafer


46


, but instead holds wafer


46


stationary while polishing member


12


reciprocates with reciprocating table


32


along guide rails


36




a


and


36




b.






In a preferred embodiment using the apparatus described in

FIGS. 1

,


2


, and


3


, the method works as follows. A supply of wafer polishing member


12


is kept on belt feed roll


10


. The belt conditioner


24


conditions the wafer-polishing member


12


as it is drawn off of the feed roll so that it is ready to polish wafer


46


. After being conditioned, a measured portion of the wafer polishing member


12


is fed through ingress rollers


22




a


and


22




b


, then secured to receiving surface


30


with clamps


26




a


and


26




b


. This measured portion is preferably about


8


inches in length. Then, belt cutter


27


cuts the measured portion of wafer polishing member


12


, separating the wafer polishing member from the remainder of the belt feed roll


10


. Then, the reciprocation drive assembly reciprocates the receiving surface


30


, and all the parts attached therewith reciprocate along guide rails


36




a


and


36




b.






In the meantime, wafer holder


40


, which is holding wafer


46


, is brought into contact with the measured portion of polishing member


12


. Wafer holder


40


spins about an axis perpendicular to receiving surface


30


while polishing member


12


reciprocates with the receiving surface. Wafer


46


is polished by the combination of spinning and reciprocating. When polishing is complete, the measured portion of polishing member


12


is taken through egress rollers


28




a


and


28




b


, and is discarded into disposal container


29


.




In the alternative preferred embodiment wherein the belt cutter is on the egress side of receiving surface


30


, belt conditioner


20


is omitted. The alternative apparatus works as follows. A supply of wafer polishing member


12


is kept on belt feed roll


10


. A measured portion of the wafer polishing member


12


is fed through ingress rollers


22




a


and


22




b


, then secured to receiving surface


30


with clamps


26




a


and


26




b


. This measured portion is small, preferably less than one inch in length, more preferably less than one-half inch, and most preferably about ¼ inch. Then, the receiving surface


30


and all the parts attached therewith reciprocate along guide rails


36




a


and


36




b


. Wafer holder


40


, which is holding wafer


46


, is in contact with the measured portion of polishing member


12


. Wafer holder


40


spins about an axis perpendicular to receiving surface


30


while polishing member


12


reciprocates with the receiving surface. Wafer


46


is polished at the same time the wafer is conditioned by the combination of spinning and reciprocating. When the first small measured portion is complete, the next small measured portion is pulled onto receiving surface


30


and the reciprocation process is repeated. This occurs until the entire wafer


46


is polished and the polishing member


12


is conditioned. Once a measured portion of polishing member


12


has been conditioned, small or otherwise, it is preferably used to polish more than one wafer


46


.




When polishing and conditioning of a wafer


46


is complete, the belt cutter


27


cuts off the spent portion of polishing member


12


. Then, the measured portion of polishing member


12


is taken through egress rollers


28




a


and


28




b


, and is discarded into disposal container


29


. Any mechanism for disposing of spent polishing member is within the scope of the described embodiment. Such mechanisms include but are not limited to take-up rollers.




EMBODIMENTS USING DISCREET SHEETS OF ABRASIVE MATERIAL




In another preferred embodiment, an apparatus for chemically-mechanically polishing semiconductor wafers has an improved loading mechanism for loading discrete sheets of polishing member


12


onto a receiving surface


30


.




Referring to

FIGS. 4 and 5

, two embodiments of a loading mechanism are shown. In

FIGS. 4 and 5

, loading mechanism


100


is shown. Supply bin


105


contains a supply of discrete sheets of polishing member


12


. Feed roll


110


makes a first discrete sheet available to a web pick up vacuum member


115


. In the embodiment depicted in

FIG. 4

, there is only one web pick up vacuum member


115


. In the embodiment depicted in

FIG. 5

, there are two web pick up vacuum members


115


.




Vacuum member


115


is attached to a frame at a pivot point


120


. Vacuum member


115


makes contact with a discreet sheet of polishing member


12


, rotates about the pivot point


120


, and delivers the discreet sheet of polishing member


12


to transfer rollers


125




a


and


125




b


. Then, in

FIG. 4

, the discreet sheet of polishing member


12


is slid along web transfer guide


126


where it is fed to ingress rollers


128




a


and


128




b


. In

FIG. 5

, no transfer guide


126


is shown, but such a guide is optional and can be included in the assembly.




After the first discreet sheet of polishing member


12


is removed from the supply bin


105


, the supply bin's position is adjusted using any indexing mechanism known to those of skill in the art. Exemplary non-limiting indexing mechanisms are disclosed in U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,248,413, 4,807,868, and 5,013,026. These patents are hereby incorporated by reference.




In these embodiments, it is preferred that the discreet sheets of polishing member


12


be durable enough to remain undamaged while being stacked in a pile and being handled by several sets of rollers and a vacuum member


115


. To achieve such a durable set of discreet sheets of polishing member


12


, it is preferred that the abrasive be a fixed abrasive as described above.




SCOPE




It should be appreciated that the apparatus of the present invention is capable of being incorporated in the form of a variety of embodiments, only a few of which have been illustrated and described above. The invention may be embodied in other forms without departing from its spirit or essential characteristics. For example, the embodiments of the present invention may be modified to include a linear motor drive. The described embodiments are to be considered in all respects only as illustrative and not restrictive, and the scope of the invention is therefore indicated by the appended claims rather than by the foregoing description. All changes that come within the meaning and range of equivalency of the claims are embraced to be within their scope.



Claims
  • 1. An apparatus for chemically-mechanically polishing a semiconductor wafer, comprising:a receiving surface attached with a frame; a loading mechanism in contact with the receiving surface, the loading mechanism being configured to load measured portions of a wafer-polishing member containing a fixed abrasive onto the receiving surface; a reciprocation device attached with at least a portion of the receiving surface, the reciprocation device being powered to move the receiving surface in a linear, bi-directional motion; and a wafer holder positioned to releasably hold a wafer adjacent to the receiving surface.
  • 2. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein the loading mechanism comprises:a polishing member dispensing roller connected with the frame, the polishing member dispensing roller holding a supply of wafer-polishing member, and a feeding device in contact with the supply of wafer-polishing member, the feeding device configured to move measured portions of the wafer-polishing member onto the receiving surface.
  • 3. The apparatus of claim 2 wherein the polishing member dispensing roller is motorized.
  • 4. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein the reciprocation device is attached with both the receiving surface and the loading mechanism.
  • 5. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein the wafer holder is rotatable about an axis perpendicular to the receiving surface.
  • 6. The apparatus of claim 1 further comprising a securing device attached with the frame that releasably secures the measured portion of the wafer-polishing member onto the receiving surface.
  • 7. The apparatus of claim 1 further comprising a cutting device attached with the frame, the cutting device being positioned opposite the receiving surface, wherein cutting activity occurs against the receiving surface.
  • 8. The apparatus of claim 1 further comprising a polishing member conditioner attached with the frame, the polishing member conditioner being positioned between the loading mechanism and the receiving surface.
  • 9. A loading mechanism for loading measured portions of a wafer-polishing member containing a fixed abrasive into an apparatus for the chemical-mechanical polishing of semiconductor wafers, comprising:a polishing member dispensing roller connected with a frame, the polishing member dispensing roller holding a supply of wafer-polishing member, and a feeding device in contact with the supply of wafer-polishing member, the feeding device configured to move measured portions of the wafer-polishing member onto a receiving surface in the apparatus for the chemical-mechanecal polishing of semiconductor wafers.
  • 10. The loading mechanism of claim 9 wherein the polishing member dispensing roller is motorized.
  • 11. In an apparatus for chemically-mechanically polishing a semiconductor wafer comprising a receiving surface attached with a frame, a loading mechanism in contact with the receiving surface, the loading mechanism being configured to load measured portions of a wafer-polishing member containing a fixed abrasive onto the receiving surface, a reciprocation device attached with at least a portion of the receiving surface, the reciprocation device being powered to move the receiving surface in a linear, bi-directional motion, and a wafer holder positioned to releasably hold a wafer adjacent to the receiving surface, a method of polishing semiconductor wafers comprising:a) loading a measured portion of a wafer-polishing member containing a fixed abrasive onto the receiving surface; and b) reciprocating the receiving surface and wafer-polishing member in a linear, bi-directional motion against the semiconductor wafer.
  • 12. The method of claim 11 further comprising conditioning the measured portion of the wafer-polishing member before loading the measured portion of the wafer-polishing member onto the receiving surface.
  • 13. The method of claim 11 further comprising securing a measured portion of the wafer-polishing member onto the receiving surface after loading the measured portion of the wafer-polishing member onto the receiving surface.
  • 14. The method of claim 11 wherein the loading mechanism reciprocates with the receiving surface and the measured portion of the wafer-polishing member.
  • 15. The method of claim 11 wherein the loading mechanism remains stationary while the receiving surface and the measured portion of the wafer-polishing member reciprocate.
  • 16. The method of claim 11 further comprising cutting the measured portion of the wafer-polishing member from the remainder of the strip.
  • 17. The method of claim 16 wherein the cutting occurs after (b) and before (c).
  • 18. The method of claim 16 wherein the cutting occurs after (c).
  • 19. An apparatus for chemically-mechanically polishing semiconductor wafers, comprising:a receiving surface attached to a frame; a loading mechanism in contact with the receiving surface, the loading mechanism being configured to loads discrete sheets of wafer-polishing members containing a fixed abrasive onto the receiving surface; a reciprocation device attached with at least a portion of the receiving surface, the reciprocation device being powered to move the receiving surface in a linear, bi-directional motion; and a wafer holder positioned to releasably hold a wafer adjacent to the receiving surface.
  • 20. The apparatus of claim 19 wherein the loading mechanism comprises:a supply bin connected with frame, the supply bin being sized to contain a supply of discrete sheets of wafer-polishing members; an automated sheet feeder in contact with the supply bin, the sheet feeder being configured to automatically uptake a first discrete sheet in the supply of discrete sheets and to load the first discreet sheet onto the receiving surface; and an adjustment mechanism in contact with the supply bin and the automated sheet feeder such that the adjustment mechanism adjusts the relative positioning of the automated sheet feeder and the supply of discrete sheets in the supply bin.
  • 21. The apparatus of claim 20 wherein the supply bin is accessible for adding a supply of discrete sheets thereto without interrupting the chemical-mechanical polishing process.
  • 22. The apparatus of claim 20 wherein the reciprocation device is attached with both the receiving surface and the loading mechanism.
  • 23. The apparatus of claim 19 wherein the wafer holder is rotatable about an axis perpendicular to the receiving surface.
  • 24. The apparatus of claim 19 further comprising a securing device attached with the frame that releasably secures the measured portion of the wafer-polishing member onto the receiving surface.
  • 25. The apparatus of claim 19 further comprising a polishing member conditioner attached with the frame, the polishing member conditioner being positioned between the loading mechanism and the receiving surface.
  • 26. A loading mechanism for loading discreet sheets of wafer-polishing members containing a fixed abrasive into an apparatus for the chemical-mechanecal polishing of semiconductor wafers, comprising:a supply bin in a frame, the supply bin adapted to contain a plurality of discrete sheets of wafer-polishing members; an automated sheet feeder in contact with the supply bin, the sheet feeder being configured to automatically uptake a first discrete sheet in the supply of discrete sheets and to load the first discreet sheet onto the receiving surface; and an adjustment mechanism in contact with the supply bin and the automated sheet feeder such that the adjustment mechanism adjusts the relative positioning of the automated sheet feeder and the supply of discrete sheets in the supply bin.
  • 27. In an apparatus for chemically-mechanically polishing a semiconductor wafer comprising a receiving surface attached with a frame, a loading mechanism in contact with the receiving surface, the loading mechanism being configured to load measured portions of a wafer-polishing member containing a fixed abrasive onto the receiving surface, a reciprocation device attached with at least a portion of the receiving surface, the reciprocation device being powered to move the receiving surface in a linear, bi-directional motion, and a wafer holder positioned to releasably hold a wafer adjacent to the receiving surface, a method of simultaneously conditioning a measured portion of a wafer-polishing member containing a fixed abrasive and chemically-mechanically polishing a semiconductor wafer comprising:a) loading a measured portion of a wafer-polishing member containing a fixed abrasive onto the receiving surface; and b) reciprocating the receiving surface and wafer-polishing member in a linear bi-directional motion against the semiconductor wafer, c) repeating (b) and (c) until the semiconductor wafer is polished and the measured portion of the wafer-polishing member is conditioned.
US Referenced Citations (25)
Number Name Date Kind
3753269 Budman Aug 1973
4318250 Klievoneit et al. Mar 1982
4720939 Simpson et al. Jan 1988
4934102 Leach et al. Jun 1990
5081051 Mattingly et al. Jan 1992
5335453 Baldy et al. Aug 1994
5484323 Smith Jan 1996
5536202 Appel et al. Jul 1996
5547417 Breivogel et al. Aug 1996
5558568 Talieh et al. Sep 1996
5575707 Talieh et al. Nov 1996
5593344 Weldon et al. Jan 1997
5611943 Cadien et al. Mar 1997
5622526 Phillips Apr 1997
5643044 Lund Jul 1997
5655951 Meikle et al. Aug 1997
5692947 Talieh et al. Dec 1997
5692950 Rutherford et al. Dec 1997
5759918 Hoshizaki et al. Jun 1998
5762536 Pant et al. Jun 1998
5871390 Pant et al. Feb 1999
5897426 Somekh Apr 1999
5899798 Trojan et al. May 1999
5908530 Hoshizaki et al. Jun 1999
5958794 Bruxvoort et al. Sep 1999
Foreign Referenced Citations (2)
Number Date Country
WO 9845090 Oct 1998 WO
WO 9922908 May 1999 WO