The present invention relates to a method and apparatus for monitoring a property of a sample. The present invention relates particularly, though not exclusively, to a method and apparatus for monitoring a nanoscopic property of a sample.
Advancement of our understanding of biological and condensed matter systems would greatly benefit from an ability to monitor the structure and dynamics at a molecular level. For example, cell membranes include ion channels and detailed information concerning the activity of the ion channels would be very useful for advancing our understanding of the function of cell membranes and cells.
Two stage quantum probes have been used as a sensitive spatial electrometer or magnetometer to produce images. However, the methods known to date do not allow monitoring processes and dynamics at the nanoscale in a satisfactory manner. There is a need for technological advancement.
The present invention provides in a first aspect a method of monitoring a property of a sample, the method comprising the steps of:
The property of the sample typically is a nanoscopic property.
The present invention opens new avenues in science and technology. The property may relate to a local atomic of molecular property of the sample, such as an electric or a magnetic property. The nanoscopic property may relate to a fundamental spin, such as the spin of an ion, or a charge or a collection thereof. For example, the ion may move thorough an ion channel of a cell membrane in the proximity surface of the quantum probe. The ion influences the decoherence rate of the quantum probe and consequently is detectable using the method in accordance with the embodiments of the present invention and can be resolved both spatially and temporally. In another example the spin may be the spin of a free-radical particle moving in a biological structure.
Quantum probes, for example quantum qubits in quantum information applications, are generally isolated as far as possible from the environment in order to maintain quantum coherence. Embodiments of the present invention are consequently counterintuitive as they deliberately cause decoherence of the quantum probe and use detection of the decoherence rate to detect properties of the samples in a unique manner.
The quantum probe may comprise a two-state quantum probe (qubit) or multi-state quantum probe, for instance a charge state qubit, or may comprise a number of quantum systems that may be entangled. The quantum probe may be based on electric charge or magnetic spin degrees of freedom. Alternatively, the quantum probe may be any other suitable type of quantum probe.
The quantum probe may be movable relative to the sample or may be stationary relative to the sample. The quantum probe may also be incorporated in the sample.
The quantum probe may comprise a quantum system consisting of a single particle, such as an atom or ion, or comprising a plurality of particles, a portion of a material, a crystal and/or may be positioned in a matrix of a surrounding material. Further, the quantum probe may comprise a plurality of particles sharing a quantum entangled state.
The quantum probe may also be one of a plurality of quantum probes and the step of providing the quantum probe may comprise providing a plurality of quantum probes, such as an array of the quantum probes. The plurality of quantum probes may comprise any number of quantum probes.
The step of detecting a rate of quantum decoherence may comprise detecting photons emitted from the plurality of quantum probes. For example, if the quantum probes are provided in the form of an array, the step of setecting the photons may comprise use of a corresponding array of respective detectors.
The quantum probe may comprise one quantum system or a plurality of quantum systems and the step of exposing the quantum probe to the sample may comprise exposing the probe to property of a sample, such as a nanoscopic property associated with single particles or a small group of particles. For example, the nanoscopic property of the sample may be associated with the spin of an ion or a small groups of ions. Alternatively, the quantum probe may also comprise one quantum system or a plurality of quantum systems, but the step of exposing the quantum probe to the sample may comprise exposing the probe to a larger scale property, such as a microscopic or macroscopic property which may be associated with a larger group of particles or with a bulk property of the sample.
In one specific example the quantum probe comprises a diamond material having at least one nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centre. The quantum probe may comprise one NV centre, but may alternatively also comprise a plurality of NV centres in the diamond material.
The step of providing the quantum probe may comprise transforming the quantum probe into a predefined quantum state, for example a superposition or entangled state in which the quantum probe may be particularly sensitive to magnetic fields. Transforming the quantum probe may comprise the application of suitable radiation. For example, if the quantum probe comprises a NV centre, the step of transforming the quantum probe may comprise exposing the NV-centre to suitable microwave radiation to generate a suitable quantum state of Zeeman energy levels. Further, the method may comprise optically pumping the NV-centre, which may comprise use of a suitable laser such as a laser having a wavelength of the order of 520 nm. The step of detection a decoherence rate may comprise detecting fluorescence photons emitted from the NV-centre.
Then method may also comprise the step of controlling the quantum state of the quantum probe by applying suitable radiation. For example, the method may comprise the step of controlling quantum coherence time of the quantum probe by applying suitable radiation.
The method typically comprises the step of moving the quantum probe and the sample relative to each other and performing the method so that the decoherence rate is detectable at a plurality of sample locations. In this case the method typically comprises the step of generating a line scan or a map of a portion of the sample and showing a distribution of decoherence properties. For example, the method may comprise scanning the quantum probe with NV centre across the surface of the sample.
In one specific embodiment of the present invention the method allows monitoring a function of biological samples typically at the nanoscale. The method may comprise detecting fluctuations or particle, such as ions, in the surface or bulk of the sample. The sample may for example be a cell membrane and may comprise a bi-lipid. The sample may comprise ion channels, such as channels though which single ions diffuse. The method may comprise exposing the sample, or the sample and the quantum probe, to a liquid, such as water, a salt-containing solution, or any other suitable solution. The method may further comprise detecting a change (usually an increase) in quantum decoherence rate caused by an influence of a spin of the particle on the quantum probe and thereby monitoring for example the function of the ion channel. The spin may be a nuclear spin of the particle.
In other embodiments the method may also comprise combining generated decoherence rate maps with maps of other properties, such maps showing electric, magnetic or structural sample properties, which is particularly advantageous for characterising solid state samples. The method may further comprise generating a map of an effective quantum Hamiltonian as a function of position on the sample. Combining a map of the decoherence rate with a map of the Hamiltonian may provide an image of the sample surface that is a direct window into the distribution and sources of magnetic or electric field fluctuations emanating from the sample surface.
The present invention provides in a second aspect and apparatus for monitoring a property of a sample, the apparatus comprising:
The property of the sample typically is a nanoscopic property.
The apparatus typically also comprises a source for transforming the quantum probe into the quantum state.
The holder of the apparatus typically comprises a scanning arrangement that is suitable for scanning the quantum probe and the sample relative to each other. In one specific example the holder comprises an arrangement similar to an atomic force microscope.
In one specific embodiment of the present invention the quantum probe comprises a diamond material having one or a plurality of NV centres. In this case the source for transforming the quantum probe typically comprises a source for emitting microwave radiation suitable for generating a Zeeman shift of energy levels and/or controlling the quantum state of the quantum probe, for example controlling a coherence time of the quantum probe. Further, the apparatus typically comprises an optical light source for optically pumping the at least one NV-centre. The detector typically is a photon detector arranged to detect fluorescence photons emitted from the at least one NV-centre.
The quantum probe may be movable relative to the sample or may be stationary relative to the sample. The quantum probe may also be incorporated in the sample.
The quantum probe may comprise one quantum system or a plurality of quantum systems.
The quantum probe may comprise a quantum system consisting of a single particle such as an atom or ion, or comprising a plurality of particles, a portion of a material, a crystal and/or may be positioned in a matrix of a surrounding material. Further, the quantum probe may comprise a plurality of particles sharing a quantum entangled state.
The quantum probe may also be one of a plurality of quantum probes and the step of providing the quantum probe may comprise providing a plurality of quantum probes, such as an array of the quantum probes. The plurality of quantum probes may comprise any number of quantum probes.
The detector may also comprise a plurality of detector elements. For example, if the quantum probes are provided in the form of an array, the detector may comprise an array of respective detector elements.
The invention will be more fully understood from the following description of specific embodiments of the invention. The description is provided with reference to the accompanying drawings.
a) is a schemtaic diagram showing a single nitrogen-vacancy (NV) defect in a diamond nanocrystal placed on an AFM tip (The unique properties of the NV atomic level scheme allows for optically induced readout and microwave control of magnetic (spin) sub-levels);
b) is a schematic diagram showing a cell membrane nearby the diamond nanocrystal of
c) is a three-dimensional representation of decoherence results in a decrease in fluorescence, which is most pronounced in regions close to the ion channel opening;
d) is a two dimensional plot of ion channel state against time showing that changes in fluorescence also permit the temporal tracking of ion channel dynamics;
a) is a schemtaic diagram showing a NV-centre diamond lattice defect;
b) is an energy level schematic diagram of the C3v-symmetric NV system showing NV spin detection through optical excitation and emission cycle (Magnetic sublevels ms=0 and ms=±1 are split by D=2.88 GHz in the crystal field. Degeneracy between the ms=±1 sublevels is lifted by a Zeeman shift, δω. Application of 532 nm green light induces a spin-dependent photoluminescence and pumping into the ms=0 ground state);
c) is a two-dimensional graph showing a specific microwave and optical pulse sequence for coherent control and readout;
a) is a two dimensional plot showing typical magnetic field signals from water, ion channel and lipid bilayer sources at a probe standoff of 4 nm over a 1 ms timescale;
b) is a two dimensional plot showing a comparison of σB for various sources of magnetic fields against probe standoff distance;
c) is a two dimensional plot showing a fluctuation regime, Θ=fe/γpσB, for magnetic field sources vs probe standoff (Rapidly fluctuating fields (Θ>>1) are said to be in the fast-fluctuating limit (FFL). Slowly fluctuating fields (Θ<<1) are in the slow fluctuation limit (SFL). The ion channel signal exists in the Θ˜1 regime, and therefore has an optimal dephasing effect on the NV probe;
a) is a two dimensional plot showing dephasing rates due to the sources of magnetic field plotted as a function of probe standoff, hp;
b) is a two dimensional plot showing optimum temporal resolution as a function of crystal T2 times for hp=2-6 nm;
c) is a two dimensional plot showing temporal resolution as a function of interrogation time, τ, for separations of 2-6 nm and T2=300 μs (Dashed lines show expected improvements from much longer T2 times, T2>>τ);
a) is a two dimensional plot showing the dependence of temporal resolution (δt) and signal variance (δP) on the number of data points included in the running average (Ns);
b) is a two dimensional plot showing simulated reconstruction of a sodium ion channel signal with a 200 Hz switching rate using optical readout of an NV centre (blue curve) (The actual ion channel state (on/off) is depicted by the dashed line, and the green line depicts the analytic confidence threshold);
a) illustrates an apparatus for monitoring a property in accordance with a specific embodiment of the present invention;
b) is a series of three signal images, representing respectively a measurement signal, a Correlated signal and a Spectral response;
c) is a pair of images of the surface, one a static field map and the other a dynamic fluctuation map;
d) is a 3-D terrain image derived from combination of the static field map and the dynamic fluctuation map of
a) is a series of images of an example sample with uniform distribution of fluctuators (shaded dots) within non-trivial spatial regions (outlined in white);
b) is a series of images (corresponding to
c) is a series of images (corresponding to
d) is a series of images where the corresponding images of
a) is a plot of magnetic field strength as measured via the variation in the probe qubit Hamiltonian. The pixel intensity represents the normalized fractional variation in the probe spin Hamiltonian;
b) is a plot of the effective temperature of each spin, based on the population of the ground and excited states;
c) is a surface plot of the magnetisation with shading based on the fraction of time spent in the excited spin state of the sample spin; and
Referring initially to
Referring now to
In drug discovery research there is a need for non-invasive detection of cell membrane ion channel operation with wide-field capability [65]. Existing techniques are generally invasive [66], require specialized nano structures [67-70], or are only applicable to certain ion channel species [71]. Quantum nanotechnology may be used to address at least some of these problems. The nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centre in nano-diamond is currently of great interest as a novel single atom quantum probe for nanoscale processes [72-84]. However, until now, beyond the use of diamond nanocrystals as fluorescence markers [73-77], nothing was known about the quantum behaviour of a NV probe in the complex room temperature extra-cellular environment. What follows is an exploration of the quantum dynamics of a NV probe in proximity to the ion channel, lipid bilayer and surrounding aqueous environment. Results indicate that real-time detection of ion channel operation at millisecond resolution is possible by directly monitoring the quantum decoherence of the NV probe. With the potential to scan and scale-up to an array-based system this conclusion may have wide ranging implications for nanoscale biology and drug discovery.
The cell membrane is a critical regulator of life. Its importance is reflected by the fact that the majority of drugs target membrane interactions [69]. Ion channels allow for passive and selective diffusion of ions across the cell membrane [86], while ion pumps actively create and maintain the potential gradients across the membranes of living cells [87]. To monitor the effect of new drugs and drug delivery mechanisms a wide field ion channel monitoring capability is essential. However, there are significant challenges facing existing techniques stemming from the fact that membrane proteins, hosted in a lipid bilayer, require a complex environment to preserve their structural and functional integrity. Patch clamp techniques are generally invasive, quantitatively inaccurate, and difficult to scale up [87-89], while black lipid membranes [90,91] often suffer from stability issues and can only host a limited number of membrane proteins.
Instead of altering the way ion channels and the lipid membrane are presented or even assembled for detection, the approach described herein is to consider a novel and inherently non-invasive in-situ detection method based on the quantum decoherence of a single-atom probe [78]. In this context, decoherence refers to the loss of quantum coherence between magnetic sub-levels of a controlled atom system due to interactions with an environment. Such superpositions of quantum states are generally fleeting in nature due to interactions with the environment, and the degree and timescale over which such quantum coherence is lost can be measured precisely. The immediate consequence of the fragility of the quantum coherence phenomenon is that detecting the loss of quantum coherence (decoherence) in a single atom probe offers a unique monitor of biological function at the nanoscale.
The NV probe [
In order to determine the sensitivity of the NV probe to the ion channel signal the lipid membrane, embedded ion channels, and the immediate surroundings are described as a fluctuating electromagnetic environment and quantitatively assess each effect on the quantum coherence of the NV centre. The net magnetic field due to diffusion of nuclei, atoms and molecules in the immediate surroundings of the nanocrystal containing the NV system and the extent to which each source will decohere is considered to be the quantum state of the NV. Over and above these background sources, the decoherence of the NV spin levels is in fact highly sensitive to the particular signal due to the ion flux through a single ion channel. Theoretical findings demonstrate the potential of this approach to revolutionize the way ion channels and potentially other membrane bound proteins or interacting species are characterized and measured, particularly when scale-up and scanning capabilities are considered.
In the following, the quantum decoherence imaging system is described with reference to
The energy level scheme of the C3v-symmetric NV system [
Typical ion channel species K+, Ca2+, Na+, and nearby water molecules are electron spin paired, so any magnetic signal due to ion channel operation will be primarily from the motion of nuclear spins. Ions and water molecules enter the channel in thermal equilibrium with random spin orientations, and move through the channel over a μs timescale. The monitoring of ion channel activity occurs via measurement of the contrast in probe behavior between the on and off states of the ion channel. This then requires the dephasing due to ion channel activity to be at least comparable to that due to the fluctuating background magnetic signal. The decoherence of the NV quantum state due to the diffusion of water molecules, buffer molecules, saline components as well as the transversal diffusion of lipid molecules in the cell membrane must therefore be accounted for.
The nth nuclear spin with charge qn, gyromagnetic ratio γn, velocity {right arrow over (v)}n and spin vector {right arrow over (S)}n, interacts with the NV spin vector {right arrow over (P)} and gyromagnetic ratio γp through the time-dependent dipole dominated interaction:
where κdip(n)≡μ04πℏ2γpγn are the probe-ion coupling strengths, and {right arrow over (r)}n(t) is the time-dependent ion-probe separation. Additional Biot-Savart fields generated by the ion motion, both in the channel and the extracellular environment, are several orders of magnitude smaller than this dipole interaction and are neglected here. Any macroscopic fields due to intracellular ion currents are of nano-Tesla (nT) order and are effectively static over T2 timescales. These effects will thus be suppressed by the spin-echo pulse sequence.
a) shows typical field traces at a probe height of 1-10 nm above the ion channel, generated by the ambient environment and the on-set of ion-flow as the channel opens. The contribution to the net field at the NV probe position from the various background diffusion processes dominate the ion channel signal in terms of their amplitude. Critically, since the magnetometer mode detects the field by acquiring phase over the coherence time of the NV centre, both the ion channel signal and background are well below the nT Hz−1/2 sensitivity limit of the magnetometer over the (˜1 ns) self-correlated timescales of the environment. However, the effect of the various sources on the decoherence rate of the NV centre are distinguishable because the amplitude-fluctuation frequency scales are very different, leading to remarkably different dephasing behaviour.
To understand this effect, it is useful to consider the full quantum evolution of the NV probe. In the midst of this environment the probe's quantum state, described by the density matrix ρ(t), evolves according to the Liouville equation, (d/dt)ρ(t)=−iℏ[H(t)ρ(t)−ρ(t)H(t)], where ρ(t) is the incoherent thermal average over all possible unitary evolutions of the entire system, as described by the full Hamiltonian, H=Hnv+Hint+Hbg, where Hnv is the Hamiltonian of the NV system, and Hint describes the interaction of the NV system with the background environment (e.g. diffusion of ortho spin water species and ions in solution) and any intrinsic coupling to the local crystal environment (e.g. due to 13C nuclei or interface effects). The evolution of the background system due to self interaction is described by Hbg, which, in the present methodology, is used to obtain the noise spectra of the various background processes. The following analysis assumes dephasing to be the dominant decoherence channel in the system. Relaxation processes are ignored since all magnetic fields considered are at least 4 orders of magnitude less than the effective crystal field of D/γp˜0.2 T, and are hence unable to flip the probe spin over relevant timescales. Phonon excitation in the diamond crystal lead to relaxation times of the order of 100 s [83] and may also be ignored. Before moving onto the numerical simulations, it is useful to consider some important features of the problem.
The decoherence rate of the NV centre is governed by the accumulated phase variance during the control cycle. Maximal dephasing due to a fluctuating field will occur at the cross-over point between the fast (FFL) and slow (SFL) fluctuation regimes [84]. A measure of this cross-over point is the dimensionless ratio Θ≡fe/γpσB, where τe=1/fe is the correlation time of the fluctuating signal, with cross-over at Θ˜1. The field standard deviation σBic due to the random nuclear spin of ions and bound water molecules moving in an ion channel (ic) can be estimated as:
The fluctuation strength of the ion channel magnetic field, σBic, is plotted in
Considering the dephasing effects of the various sources of background magnetic fields, the first source of background noise is the fluctuating magnetic field arising from the motion of the water molecules and ions throughout the aqueous solution. Due to the nuclear spins of the hydrogen atoms, liquid water consists of a mixture of spin neutral (para) and spin-1 (ortho) molecules. The equilibrium ratio of ortho to para molecules (OP ratio) is 3:1 [99], making 75% of water molecules magnetically active. In biological conditions, dissolved ions occur in concentrations 2-3 orders of magnitude below this and are ignored here (they are important however for calculations of the induced Stark shift, see below). The RMS strength of the field due to the aqueous solution is
This magnetic field is therefore 1-2 orders of magnitude stronger than the field from the ion channel [
An additional source of background dephasing is the lipid molecules comprising the cell membrane. Assuming magnetic contributions from hydrogen nuclei in the lipid molecules, lateral diffusion in the cell membrane gives rise to a fluctuating B-field, with a characteristic frequency related to the diffusion rate. Atomic hydrogen densities in the membrane are nH˜3×1028 m−3. At room temperature, the populations of the spin states of hydrogen will be equal, thus the RMS field strength is given by
The strength of the fluctuating field due to the lipid bilayer is of the order of 10−7 T [
giving rise to dephasing rates of the order ΓL˜100 Hz, with corresponding dephasing envelope DL(t)=e−Γ
The electric fields associated with the dissolved ions also interact with the NV centre via the ground state Stark effect. The coefficient for the frequency shift as a function of the electric field applied along the dominant (z) axis is given by R3D=3.5×10−3 HzmV−1 [98]. Fluctuations in the electric field may be related to an effective magnetic field via Bzeff=R3DEz/γp, which may be used in an analysis similar to that above. An analysis using Debye-Hückel theory [102] shows charge fluctuations of an ionic solutions in a spherical region Λ of radius R behave as
where DE is the diffusion coefficient of the electrolyte, and κ is the inverse Debye length (lD); lD=1/κ=1.3 nm for biological conditions. Whilst this analysis applies to a region Λ embedded in an infinite bulk electrolyte system, simulation results discussed below show very good agreement when applied to the system considered here. Eq. 6 is used to obtain the electric field variance, σE=√{square root over (E2
−
E
2)}, as a function of hp. Relaxation times for electric field fluctuations are τeE=εεoρE [103], where ρE is the resistivity of the electrolyte, giving feE˜1/τeE=1.4×109 Hz under biological conditions. Given the relatively low strength [
The problem of non-invasively resolving the location of a sodium ion channel in a lipid bilayer membrane is now considered. When the channel is closed, the dephasing is the result of the background activity, and is defined by Doff=DH
otherwise. By scanning over an open ion channel and monitoring the probe via repeated measurements of the spin state, a population ensemble may be built up for each lateral point in the sample. The signal to noise ratio improves with the dwell times at each point.
Similar techniques are employed to temporally resolve a sodium ion channel switch-on event. By monitoring a single point, a measurement record sequence, |, may be built up. In an experimental situation, the frequency with which measurements may be performed has an upper limit of fm=(τ+τm+τ2π)−1, where τm≈900 ns is the time required for photon collection, and τ2π is the time required for all 3 microwave pulses. A potential trade-off exists between the increased dephasing due to longer interrogation times and the corresponding reduction in measurement frequency.
Interrogation times are ultimately limited by the intrinsic T2 time of the crystal. A second trade-off exists between the variance of a given set of Nτ consecutive measurements and the temporal resolution of the probe. For the monitoring of a switching event, the spin state population may be inferred with increased confidence by performing a running average over a larger number of data points, Nτ. However increasing Nτ will lead to a longer time lag before a definitive result is obtained. The uncertainty in the ion channel state goes as δP˜(√{square root over (Nτ)})−1, where Nτ is the number of points included in the dynamic averaging. We must take sufficient Nτ to ensure that δP<ΔP(τ,hp,T2)=Poff−Pon. The temporal resolution depends on the width of the dynamic average and is given by δt˜Nτ(τ+τm), giving the relationship
It is desirable to minimise this function with respect to τ for a given stand-off (hp) and crystal T2 time.
In reality, not all crystals are manufactured with equal T2 times. An important question is therefore, for a given T2, what is the best achievable temporal resolution?
A plot of δt as a function of τ is shown in
As an example of monitoring of ion channel behaviour, consider a crystal with a T2 time of 300 μs at a standoff of 3 nm.
An ion channel switching between states after an average waiting time of 5 ms (200 Hz) [
With regard to scale-up to a wide field imaging capability, beyond the obvious extrinsic scaling of the number of single channel detection elements (in conjunction with micro-confocal arrays), an intrinsic scale-up strategy using many NV centres in a bulk diamond probe, with photons collected in a pixel arrangement, is considered. Since the activity of adjacent ion channels is correlated by the μm scale activity of the membrane, the fluorescence of adjacent NV centres will likewise be correlated, thus wide field detection will occur via a fluorescence contrast across the pixel. Implementation of this scheme involves a random distribution of NV centres in a bulk diamond crystal. The highest NV densities reported in bulk crystals with no neutrally charged NV0 defects are 2.8×1024 m−3 [104], giving typical NV-NV couplings of <10 MHz, which are too weak to induce NV spin-flips. It is desirable to seek a balance between increased population contrast and increased dephasing rates due to higher NV densities.
For ion channel operation correlated across each pixel, the total population contrast ΔΦ between off and on states is obtained by averaging the local NV state population change ΔΦ(τ)=Poff({right arrow over (r)}i,{right arrow over (r)}c,τ)−Pon({right arrow over (r)}i,{right arrow over (r)}c,τ) over all NV positions {right arrow over (r)}i and orientations; and ion channel positions {right arrow over (r)}c (and species); and maximizing with respect to τ. As an example, consider a crystal with an NV density of 1024 m−3 whose surface is brought within 3 nm of the cell membrane containing an sodium and potassium ion channel densities of ˜2×1015 m−2[105]. Ion channel activity is expected to be correlated across pixel areas of 1 μm×1 μm, so the population contrast between off and on states is ΔΦ≈500. This directly translates into an improvement in the temporal resolution by a factor of 1000, opening up the potential for single-shot measurements of ion channel activity across each pixel.
An analysis of the quantum dynamics of a NV diamond probe in the cell-membrane environment has been carried out so as to determined the theoretical sensitivity for the detection, monitoring and imaging of single ion channel function through quantum decoherence. Using current demonstrated technology a temporal resolution in the 1-10 ms range is possible, with spatial resolution at the nanometer level. With the scope for scale-up and novel scanning modes, this fundamentally new detection mode has the potential to revolutionize the characterization of ion channel action, and possibly other membrane proteins, with important implications for molecular biology and drug discovery.
Referring now to
This embodiment of the method in accordance with the present invention also aims to use decoherence based imaging to detect random magnetic field fluctuations as a result of their impact on the quantum evolution of a quantum probe system. Because many interesting biological processes would be characterized by random field variations and these may average out to zero, the detection of the average field using DC magnetometry would not be suitable. AC detection is more sensitive but relies on precise control of the sample's evolution. The decoherence rate can be an effect measure of such random zero mean fluctuations.
The following will initially describe establishing a control sample of non-immersed NV-centre in a diamond nanocrystal in air. A region of the sample which has diamond nanocrystals of size roughly 50 nm deposited (see
From this Rabi period the duration of control pulses is determined to carry out the spin-echo measurements of the decoherence. As described previously, in these measurements the decoherence time corresponds to how the spin-echo signal determined by fluorescence decays as a function of time.
While there are slight differences, after the Rabi pulse has been tuned for the particular immersion condition, air and water have a similar effect. This is an important control experiment that shows that immersion in water (required for biology) does not significantly affect the decoherence time of the NV centre, as theory predicts.
Referring now to
At each point (x,y) a measurement Ixy(t) is obtained and recorded, see
From the spectral response Sxy(ω) a measurement of the effective qubit Hamiltonian Hxy (static magnetometer or electrometer) field map is made, and a decoherence rate Γxymap as a function of probe position is obtained, see
If the components of the Hamiltonian were plotted as a function of position across the sample (Hxy), the probe would be acting as a sensitive electrometer or magnetometer (depending on the type of qubit), as given in the Hxy example, see
Complete analysis of the probe evolution allows the decoherence channel(s) to be extracted, giving information about the strength, direction and character of the dynamics of the environment, as well as the induced static field.
The sample in this case consists of fluctuators with a non uniform distribution in both spatial density and fluctuation rate. The decoherence rate Γxy map (or Fluctuation map), shown in
Combining the decoherence rate Γxy map together with the static field map Hxy provides a direct window into the distribution and character of the sources of field fluctuations in both space and time, see
Monitoring both the position dependent probe Hamiltonian and decoherence channels allows one to use the scanning quantum system as both a magnetometer/electrometer and as a probe of the decoherence environment simultaneously.
Thanks (in part) to the ongoing work to construct controllable quantum devices5, a number of techniques have been developed to measure the state or evolution characteristics of a quantum system. These include techniques to reconstruct an arbitrary quantum state or process5,6, quantum channel5,7 and the Hamiltonian governing a few state quantum system8-13 or even spin echo techniques14 from magnetic resonance. We have focused on the technique of Hamiltonian characterization8-10 but other techniques can be similarly applied.
Quantitative Model
To make the embodiments of the present invention quantitative, we introduce a simple model for weak continuous measurement15 which captures all of the essential physics50. We assume the measurement of the qubit can be modeled as a inefficient (or weak) POVM (Positive Operator Valued Measure) in the σz basis. The density matrix after measurement, ρ′, is given by
for a measurement operator
with some measurement strength κ. The measurement process consists of repeated weak POVM measurements separated by a time interval Δt, during which time the system undergoes normal evolution. The measurement repetition interval is then a measure of the bandwidth of the detector, BW=1/Δt.
The measurement record I(t), is the result, +1 or −1, of a measurement at time t. The steady-state autocorrelation of this measurement signal I(t) is then given byI(t)I(t+τ)
ss=Tr[σze
τσzρss] (10)
via the quantum regression theorem16,17. Here ρss=ρ(∞) is the steady state density matrix and is the solution to the density matrix evolution governed by, where H is the qubit Hamiltonian and Γ represents the decoherence rate of the system without measurement. The spectrum of the signal is then
Where F[ρ2(t)
] is the Fourier transform of the (ensemble averaged) expectation value of the σz operator. From this response spectrum, we extract the Hamiltonian and decoherence parameters directly9,10 for each spatial location across the sample.
In the limit of small κ, this model is equivalent15 to more complicated master equation models15,18-21. Expanding the evolution to first order in both κ and Δt, we can derive an equivalent Lindbladian master equation with an effective σz decoherence channel of strength
which corresponds to the measurement induced decoherence. In general, the measurement strength should be chosen such that this induced decoherence is smaller than both the sample induced decoherence and other intrinsic decoherence sources51.
We can also calculate the information extracted from the system at each measurement step by looking at the reduction in entropy of the system. Expanding for small κ, this gives
as the information obtained (in bits) from a single measurement of an initially mixed state. So, it is clear that we have a trade off. As we increase κ or the bandwidth, the amount of information obtained in a given time interval is increased, Eq. (11), at the expense of greater measurement induced decoherence, Eq. (12).
The spatial resolution of the probe system is ultimately governed by the effective strength of the environmental decoherence as a function of distance. Most decoherence channels (for solid-state qubits) depend, in some way, on the inverse of the separation between qubit and environment. The coupling between a single decoherence (point) source and the probe qubit is, in general, proportional to 1/rn, hence the response of the qubit as a function of (x−)position across the sample is given by a exponentiated Lorenztian. The Full Width at Half Maximum (FWHM) of this function gives the spatial resolution, where hp is the height of the probe above the sample. By inspection, we see an electric dipole induced potential (1/r2) has a FWHM 2hp whereas a magnetic dipolar interaction (1/r3) has slightly better resolution, Δx≈1.53hp. The achievable spatial resolution is lower than (for example) Scanning Tunnelling Microscopy (STM) where the electron current is exponentially dependent on the sample-probe separation22. The point here is that the information provided by this imaging mode is of a fundamentally different and complementary nature to conventional imaging techniques.
The following will consider in detail two examples in which the effects of a decohering environment on an example probe are simulated. These examples provide both a straightforward illustration of the power of imaging the sample induced decoherence and a test of the feasibility using current and near future technology.
Our first example system comprises an electrostatic qubit interacting with a sample containing background charge fluctuators. This example is of particular interest as background charge fluctuations have been the subject of intense scrutiny due to their relevance to solid-state quantum devices and that they are a good example of a nontrivial environmental bath23,24. In this case, we can probe the spatial and frequency distribution of these fluctuators in a way which is not possible using current microscopy techniques.
For this application, a suitable probe qubit would be any of the myriad of charge based 35 qubit designs such as quantum-dots25, donors26 or cooper-pair-box27-29. A probe based on a cooper-pair-box (CPB) system provides a particularly good example as CPB qubits are now regularly produced experimentally30-32 and the bias point of the system can be varied, resulting in a change in the sensitivity to different components of the environmental decoherence23. Although, for these devices the ultimate resolution limit is given by the physical size of the device, in which case a quantum dot or even charge donor system may be better.
For generality, this analysis does not assume a particular qubit implementation, modelling the qubit purely as a two-state system which interacts via a field dependent component in its Hamiltonian (see Methods section I below). For this reason, all the dimensions in this example are given in terms of a normalized length scale (L).
We consider a 2D surface which contains background charge fluctuators that we wish to image. We use a simplified model of these fluctuators in the fast fluctuator limit, to illustrate the concepts. (In example II, we will consider a more specific example in the slow fluctuator limit.)
We take the potential felt by the qubit as a simple electrostatic potential due to a charge defect dipole and simulate the effective decoherence field felt by the qubit due to the fluctuator bath (defects in the sample). In
The fluctuators are modeled as point sources but have been enlarged in
The variation of the probe Hamiltonian, Hxy, due to the presence of background charges is shown in
In
To further demonstrate the utility of mapping both Hamiltonian and decoherence components simultaneously,
In principle, the frequency sensitivity of the qubit can be tuned to probe different components of the decoherence and obtain more information about its characteristics.
The following will consider the imaging of (bio)molecules with large uncompensated spin, such as 15 Horse-spleen Ferritin34,35 or Fe836. Here, the point is neither to image an individual spin37 or image the location of the molecules22,38,39 as both can be done with existing technology. We show that qubit probe imaging can both map the location of the spins and probe their magnetic dynamics.
The decoherence introduced at the probe qubit will be a function of both the interaction strength and the flipping rate of the sample spins. As we are considering large sample spins in a static magnetic field at low temperature, we will assume that the flipping rate is slow on the scale of the probe Hamiltonian. This means that the spectral response of the qubit is split, with the separation between the peaks giving the effective difference in the Hamiltonian between the two sample spin states.
We compute the coupling strength between the spins, given the simplified magnetic dipolar model, as illustrated in the insert of
In
An alternative probe qubit system would be a microSQUID or flux qubit2,3,27. This allows easier coupling to the measurement channel, higher precision spectral response measurements and uses demonstrated technology, but it is not a point-source probe. These devices also have the advantage of a tunable working point, which allows adjustment of the qubit's sensitivity to decoherence.
For our example, we use known system parameters for an NV centre driven by a microwave loop and readout via a laser probe measurement48. We take the Rabi frequency of the qubit to be 10 MHz, the measurement bandwidth BW=100 MHz but not necessarily ‘strong’ and the intrinsic decoherence rate is approximately 100 times slower than the Rabi frequency. The measurement strength κ is chosen such that the measurement induced decoherence is weaker than the intrinsic decoherence, for a given detector bandwidth.
In
The magnetisations are M0=50, 70, 100 and 200μB and the average population of the excited state is given by a Boltzmann distribution for a background magnetic field of B=0.1 T and temperature T=4K. The spatial resolution of the probe position is a 50×50 grid, giving 2500 points over 10000 nm2 and the probe height was set to hp=20 nm.
a) shows the measured magnetic field over the sample. Note that the probe in this mode (purely acting as a magnetometer) does not successfully resolve two of the spins.
b) shows the measured decoherence field over the same sample. As each spin has a different magnetisation, the decoherence effects (in this case splitting of the Rabi peak) resulting from each spin are different. The ratio of the two split peaks provides the population of the spin states, which is in turn directly related to the magnetisation and effective temperature of the sample spin.
In this plot, the ratio of the split peaks has been used to code the data, with deep shading indicating both a large spin magnetisation (or low effective temperature) and a small magnetisation (high temperature). The intensity of the shading is given purely by the amount of signal available from each decoherence source (compared to the probe spin's intrinsic decoherence), whereas in
Finally, we can combine this data to produce a plot showing the field intensity with each decoherence source (mesoscopic spin) tagged based on its effective temperature. This is shown in
While we have demonstrated that new information can be obtained by looking at the induced decoherence, this is only useful if the information can be obtained within an experimentally accessible time. Using the measurement model discussed earlier, we can estimate the parameter uncertainties in the Hamiltonian characterisation process. Retaining the parameters from Example II, we calculate the noise expected for a finite dwell time (tdwell) on each pixel and the total image acquisition time (ta).
It should be noted that this ignores the effect of noise induced in the detection setup. This additional noise will contribute directly to the measured response spectrum and 20 will add directly to the measurement variance. The result is an increase in measurement times but, provided the detector noise is characterised, this does not restrict the systems ability to characterise the probe and therefore the sample.
To allow fast image acquisition times, it is important to have both large detector bandwidth and a large ratio of bandwidth to intrinsic decoherence rate BW/Γq. The qubit transition frequency is less important, provided it is at least an order of magnitude greater than the intrinsic decoherence. However, a tunable qubit frequency is advantageous as many types of decoherence depend strongly on the frequency at which they are probed.
Embodiments of the present invention provide a fundamentally new and complementary imaging mode which takes advantage of current qubit technology and modern techniques for characterising few-state quantum systems. Mapping the induced decoherence across a sample effectively images the dynamics of the environment, providing a new window into the microscopic world with wide applications to spin and charge fluctuations and transport in both solid-state and biological systems.
Fluctuators
We wish to use a simple model of the decoherence felt by a probe (charge−)qubit interacting with a bath of 1/f fluctuators23,24,33. The numerical parameters used for such a model vary greatly depending on the system and even from sample to sample. Here we are interesting in the functional dependence, rather than the explicit values. We draw heavily from references [33] and [24] as an example.
Consider a qubit interacting with a bath of fluctuators via an interaction Hamiltonian Hint which has the form
where σz acts on the qubit and bj destroys (creates) an electron in a localized state in the bath.
The spectral response from the jth fluctuator (in the fast fluctuator limit) is given by
where νj is the strength of the fluctuator which fluctuates with rate γj The total spectral response is then the sum over each of the fluctuators
S(ω)=Σjsj(ω) (16)
and a simplified Golden rule model gives the relaxation rate (Γ2GR) and dephasing rate as
where EJ is the tunnelling energy of the qubit. Given a functional form for how vj(r) 30 depends on the fluctuator/qubit separation r, we can then compute the effective decoherence rate felt by the qubit.
For this analysis, we will use a simplified (but quite general model) consisting of a probe spin interacting via the magnetic dipolar interaction with a much larger sample spin (see insert of
The magnetic dipolar interaction is given by14
where γp and γs are the probe and sample spin gyromagnetic ratios, rr is the vector separation between the spins and P and S are the probe and sample spin operators.
We assume the system is bathed in a global magnetic field Bglobal which orientates both the sample and probe spins53 and sets their energy scales. The dipolar interaction is then given by the separation between the spins r and the angle subtended between the spin orientation and the vector separating the spins φ, as illustrated in the insert to
which is a purely Ising type interaction whose strength depends on both the separation and angle between the spins. The perturbing effect of this dipolar Hamiltonian can then be measured in the spectral response of the qubit, giving an direct link to both the spin state and magnetisation of the sample spin.
All the following references are incorporated herein by reference.
The references are incorporated herein by reference.
Reference that is being made to references 1 to 105 does not constitute and admission that these references are part of the common general knowledge in any country.
Although the invention has been described with reference to a particular example, it should be appreciated that it could be exemplified in many other forms and in combination with other features not mentioned above.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2008905684 | Nov 2008 | AU | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/AU2009/001434 | 11/4/2009 | WO | 00 | 9/8/2011 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2010/051580 | 5/14/2010 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3892485 | Merritt et al. | Jul 1975 | A |
4142416 | Smith et al. | Mar 1979 | A |
6218832 | Chuang et al. | Apr 2001 | B1 |
6528997 | Zhong et al. | Mar 2003 | B2 |
7328059 | Sevick-Muraca et al. | Feb 2008 | B2 |
7521928 | Romalis et al. | Apr 2009 | B2 |
8467842 | Hegg et al. | Jun 2013 | B2 |
20070194225 | Zorn | Aug 2007 | A1 |
20070215861 | Stafford et al. | Sep 2007 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
2009073736 | Jun 2009 | WO |
Entry |
---|
Jared H. Cole and Lloyd L. Hollenberg, “Scanning Quantum Decoherence Microscopy,” (online), arXiv:0811.1913v1 [quant-ph], Nov. 12, 2008. Retrieved from the Internet Dec. 11, 2009 <URL:http://lanl.arxiv.org/PS—cache/arxiv/pdf/0811/0811.1913v1.pdf> Abstract, pp. 1-8. |
Laim T. Hall, Jared H. Cole, Charles D. Hill and Lloyl C.L. Hollenberg, “Sensing of Fluctuating Nanoscale Magnetic Fields Using NV Centres in Diamond,” (online), arXiv:0907.2292v1 [cond-mat.mes-hall], Jul. 14, 2009. Retrieved from the Internet Dec. 11, 2009 <URL:http://lanl.arxiv.org/PS—cache/arxiv/pdf/0907/09072292v1.pdf> Abstract, pp. 1-4. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20120019242 A1 | Jan 2012 | US |