This is a non-provisional application of U.S. application No. 61/057,242 filed May 30, 2008 and U.S. application No. 61/178,675 filed May 15, 2009. The contents of U.S. applications Nos. 61/057,242 and 61/178,675 are incorporated herein by reference.
The present invention relates generally to methods and systems involving both a mass spectrometer and a differential mobility spectrometer.
In differential mobility spectrometer/mass spectrometer systems, a drift gas is typically supplied from a compressed gas source upstream of the differential mobility spectrometer. This drift gas acts as a carrier gas flow through the differential mobility spectrometer. The delivery of the drift gas to the differential mobility spectrometer can be controlled by flow restriction valves. Sensitivity is related to the transmission efficiency of the system—what percentage of the ions end up being actually detected. Selectivity or resolution refers to the detector's ability to distinguish between similar ions.
Differential mobility spectrometry, also referred to as high field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) or Field Ion Spectrometry (FIS), is a variant of ion mobility spectrometry (IMS). IMS separates ions by the difference in the time it takes for them to drift through a gas, typically at atmospheric pressure, in a constant electrostatic field of low field strength applied along the axial length of a flight tube. Ions are pulsed into the flight tube and their flight times are recorded. The time of flight is inversely related to the mobility of an ion. Ions have a single motion of direction (axial) and are separated according to their mobility through the gas under these low field conditions (E<1000 V/cm). The drift time and thus mobility is a function of the size and shape of an ion and its interactions with the background gas.
Differential mobility spectrometry differs from IMS in the geometry of the instrumentation and adds an additional dimension to the separation theory. RF voltages, often referred to as separation voltages (SV), are applied across the ion transport chamber, perpendicular to the direction of the transport gas flow. Ions will migrate toward the walls and leave the flight path unless their trajectory is corrected by a counterbalancing voltage, a DC potential often referred to as a compensation voltage (CV). Instead of recording the flight time of an ion through the chamber, the voltage required to correct the trajectory of a particular ion is recorded. Ions are not separated in time as with an IMS: instead, the mobility measurement is a function of the compensation voltage used to correct the tilt in ion trajectory caused by the difference between high field and low field ion mobilities. As such, ions are not pulsed into the analyzer but instead introduced in a continuous fashion and the compensation voltage is scanned to serially pass ions of different differential mobility or set to a fixed value to pass only ion species with a particular differential mobility.
Typically, there is a tradeoff between selectivity and sensitivity, both of which are linked to the residence time of the ions in the differential mobility spectrometer. Specifically, increasing the residence time of the ions in the differential mobility spectrometer may increase selectivity, but at the price of reducing sensitivity.
As described above, in the description that follows, sensitivity is related to the transmission efficiency of the system—what percentage of the ions end up being actually detected. Selectivity or resolution refers to the detector's ability to distinguish between similar ions.
In accordance with an aspect of an embodiment of the invention, there is provided a mass spectrometer system comprising:
a) a differential mobility spectrometer for receiving ions from an ion source, the differential mobility spectrometer having an internal operating pressure, electrodes, and at least one voltage source for providing DC and RF voltages to the electrodes;
b) a mass spectrometer at least partially sealed to, and in fluid communication with, the differential mobility spectrometer for receiving the ions from the differential mobility spectrometer;
c) a vacuum chamber surrounding the mass spectrometer for maintaining the mass spectrometer at a vacuum pressure lower than the internal operating pressure, such that the vacuum chamber is operable to draw a gas flow including the ions through the differential mobility spectrometer and into the vacuum chamber; and,
d) a gas port for modifying a gas flow rate through the differential mobility spectrometer, the gas port being located between the differential mobility spectrometer and the mass spectrometer.
In accordance with an aspect of a further embodiment of the invention, there is provided a method of operating a mass spectrometer system including a differential mobility spectrometer and a mass spectrometer contained in a vacuum chamber at least partially sealed to, and in fluid communication, with, the differential mobility spectrometer. The method comprises:
a) maintaining the differential mobility spectrometer at an internal operating pressure;
b) providing ions to the differential mobility spectrometer, and providing a selected separation RF voltage and a selected compensation DC voltage to the differential mobility spectrometer;
c) maintaining the mass spectrometer at a vacuum pressure lower than the internal operating pressure to draw a gas flow including the ions through the differential mobility spectrometer and into the vacuum chamber; and,
d) modifying the gas flow between the differential mobility spectrometer and the mass spectrometer to change a gas flow rate through the differential mobility spectrometer.
The skilled person in the art will understand that the drawings, described below, are for illustration purposes only. The drawings are not intended to limit the scope of the applicant's teachings in any way.
Referring to
The differential mobility spectrometer 202 comprises plates 206 and an electrical insulator 207 along the outside of plates 206. The plates 206 surround a drift gas 208 that drifts from an inlet 210 of the differential mobility spectrometer to an outlet 212 of the differential mobility spectrometer 202. The insulator 207 supports the electrodes and isolates them from other conductive elements. For example, the insulator may be fabricated from ceramic or Teflon™. The outlet 212 of the differential mobility spectrometer 202 releases the drift gas into a juncture or baffle chamber 214 defined by baffles 216, which juncture chamber 214 defines a path of travel for ions between the differential mobility spectrometer 202 and the mass spectrometer 204. In some embodiments, the outlet 212 of the differential mobility spectrometer 202 is aligned with the inlet of the mass spectrometer 204 to define the ion path of travel therebetween, while the baffles 216 are spaced from this path of travel to limit interference of the baffles 216 with the ions 222 traveling along the path of travel.
The differential mobility spectrometer 202 and juncture chamber 214 are both contained within a curtain chamber 218, defined by curtain plate (boundary member) 219 and supplied with a curtain gas from a curtain gas source 220. The curtain gas source 220 provides the curtain gas to the interior of the curtain chamber 218. Ions 222 are provided from an ion source (not shown) and are emitted into the curtain chamber 218 via curtain chamber inlet 224. The pressure of the curtain gas within the curtain chamber 218 provides both a curtain gas outflow 226 out of curtain gas chamber inlet 224, as well as a curtain gas inflow 228 into the differential mobility spectrometer 202, which inflow 228 becomes the drift gas 208 that carries the ions 222 through the differential mobility spectrometer 202 and into the juncture chamber 214. The curtain plate 219 may be connected to a power supply to provide an adjustable DC potential to it.
As illustrated in
As shown, the baffles 216 of the curtain chamber comprise a controlled leak or gas port 232 for admitting the curtain gas into the juncture chamber 214. Within the juncture chamber 214, the curtain gas becomes a throttle gas that throttles back the flow of the drift gas 208 through the differential mobility spectrometer 202. Specifically, the throttle gas within the juncture chamber 214 modifies a gas flow rate within the differential mobility spectrometer 202 and into the juncture chamber 214, thereby controlling the residence time of the ions 222 within the differential mobility spectrometer 202. By controlling the residence time of the ions 222 within the differential mobility spectrometer 202, resolution and sensitivity can be adjusted. That is, increasing the residence times of the ions 222 within the differential mobility spectrometer 202 can increase the resolution, but can also result in additional losses of the ions, reducing sensitivity. In some embodiments it can therefore be desirable to be able to precisely control the amount of throttle gas that is added to the juncture chamber 214 to provide a degree of control to the gas flow rate through the differential mobility spectrometer 202, thereby controlling the tradeoff between sensitivity and selectivity. In the embodiment of
The baffles can be configured to provide a randomizer surface member, and the gas port 232 can be oriented to direct the throttle gas at least somewhat against the baffles 216 and randomizer surface to disburse the throttle gas throughout the juncture chamber 214. In one embodiment, the gas port 232 introduces the throttle gas without disrupting the gas streamlines between the differential mobility spectrometer 202 and the mass spectrometer inlet 229.
As described above and as known in the art, RF voltages, often referred to as separation voltages (SV), can be applied across an ion transport chamber of a differential mobility spectrometer perpendicular to the direction of drift gas 208 (shown in
Similarly, a DC declustering or inlet potential can be provided to the vacuum chamber inlet 229 (again as shown in
In embodiments of the present invention in which the vacuum chamber inlet 229 is smaller then an outlet of the differential mobility spectrometer 202, it can be advantageous to provide a braking potential to the vacuum chamber inlet 229 relative to the differential mobility spectrometer 202. This braking potential can be provided by providing a DMS DC offset voltage to the plates or electrodes of the DMS relative to the declustering or inlet potential provided to the vacuum chamber inlet 229. By slowing down the ions prior to them entering the vacuum chamber 229, the braking potential can increase the extent to which these ions are entrained within the gas flows, thereby increasing the likelihood that the ions will actually pass through the vacuum chamber inlet, instead of impacting on the sides of the vacuum chamber inlet 229.
Alternatively, in some embodiments of the present invention, such as, for example without limitation, embodiments in which the vacuum chamber inlet 229 is larger relative to the slit or outlet from the differential mobility spectrometer 202, it can be desirable to adjust the DMS DC offset voltage. In particular this DC offset voltage may actually be positive to speed up ions as they pass through the vacuum chamber inlet 229, if it is not desirable to slow them down to improve transmission from the differential mobility spectrometer 202 into the vacuum chamber 227.
This DMS DC offset can also be adjusted based on a mass of the ions being selected in a differential mobility spectrometer 202. This could be part of a two-stage process. Specifically, the declustering voltage provided to the vacuum chamber inlet 229 can first be adjusted based on the mass of the ions being selected in the differential mobility spectrometer 202. Then, relative to this declustering potential provided to the vacuum chamber inlet 229, the DMS DC offset voltage could be adjusted to enhance transmission from the differential mobility spectrometer 202 through the vacuum chamber inlet 229. Alternatively, the DMS offset DC potential may be selected for a given ion. In some embodiments, a voltage source controller can be set to automatically adjust the DMS electrode DC offsets to maintain the same potential difference relative to the orifice potential. Then the declustering potential or inlet potential may be adjusted, That is, in these embodiments the DMS offset voltage is merely the difference between the DC potential applied to the electrodes as an offset and the inlet voltage. Say, for example, that a preferred DMS offset voltage is −3 V. Then, when the inlet voltage is tuned, the control system can, in these embodiments, maintain that −3 V offset regardless of the current inlet voltage. For instance, if the inlet potential is initially 50 V, the DC potential on the DMS electrodes can be automatically maintained at 47 V (CV=0 situation). If the inlet potential is tuned up to 100 V, the DC applied to the DMS electrodes can be automatically changed to 97 V.
Referring to
It is important to note that due to the compensation voltage provided to the plates or electrodes of the differential mobility spectrometer, the actual DC potential of one or both of the electrodes of the differential mobility spectrometer may not differ by the DMS DC offset amount from the declustering potential applied to vacuum chamber inlet element. For example, say that a declustering potential is applied to vacuum chamber inlet element 329. This declustering potential (DP) is determined based on the m/z of the ion being selected by the differential mobility spectrometer, and this determination of the DP is known in the art. Then, a DC offset voltage is applied to the plate or electrodes 306 of the differential mobility spectrometer 302. In addition, the CV will be applied to the electrodes 306. Application of a CV may proceed in different ways. For example, say that there is a CV of 10 volts, then 5V can be applied to one electrode, while −5V are applied to the other electrode. Alternatively, 10V can be applied to one electrode and no volts to the other electrode.
Consider an example where all of the CV is applied to one electrode. Then, say that a DP of 100V is first determined for the vacuum chamber inlet. The offset between the vacuum chamber inlet and the differential mobility spectrometer is determined to be −5V. The CV for the differential mobility spectrometer is 10V. Then, one electrode of the differential mobility spectrometer would have a potential of 100V−5V+10V or 105V, while the other electrode would have a potential of 100V−5V=95V.
As noted above, the DC offset voltage need not be negative. Specifically, where the orifice or inlet dimension more closely matches the slit dimension for the differential mobility spectrometer, there may be no need to slow the ions down to properly entrain them in the gas flow so that they can flow through the orifice. Instead, it could even be desirable to speed the ions up.
Referring to
As with the system 200 of
As with the system 200 of
Please note that schematic
Conduit branch 320a comprises a controllable valve 320b that can be used to control the rate of flow of the throttle gas into the juncture chamber 314. For example, to increase resolution or selectivity, at the price of an acceptable loss in sensitivity, the controllable valve 320b could be opened to admit more throttle gas into the juncture chamber 314 via conduit branch 320a to reduce the gas flow rate within the differential mobility spectrometer 302. This, in turn, can increase the residence time of the ions 322 within the differential mobility spectrometer. The increased residence time manifests itself as narrower mobility peak widths, and therefore, improved selectivity. At the same time, the increased residence time lowers sensitivity somewhat due to increased diffusion losses. At the same time, because of the increased residence time within the differential mobility spectrometer, more of the ions can be lost.
As shown,
As the differential mobility spectrometer 302 is sealed, or at least partially sealed (no seal is perfect) to the mass spectrometer, or at least to the first vacuum chamber 327, The mass spectrometer can comprise a circular orifice to receive the ions 322 from the differential mobility spectrometer 302. This is enabled by the streamlines resulting from sealing the differential mobility spectrometer 302 to the mass spectrometer. The gas streamlines exiting the differential mobility spectrometer 302 converge on the orifice inlet 329, and these bending streamlines can transport ions through the inlet 329. It can be desirable to maintain a circular orifice to ensure high transmission efficiency through subsequent vacuum stages and lenses.
Referring to
As with the system 300 of
In addition, gas restriction plates 434 are provided at an inlet 410 of the differential mobility spectrometer 402. These gas restriction plates 434 can facilitate tuning the pressure of the differential mobility spectrometer 402 for further optimization of selectivity, in an analogous fashion to Nazarov et al. (Nazarov E G, Coy S L, Krylov E V, Miller A R, Eiceman G., Pressure Effects in Differential Mobility Spectrometry, Anal. Chem., 2006, 78, 7697-7706). Specifically, when the gas restriction plates 434 are provided to restrict the flow of drift gas into the differential mobility spectrometer 402, pumping at the back of the differential mobility spectrometer 402, by providing the lower pressure in the vacuum chamber 427, can lower the pressure within the differential mobility spectrometer to provide an extra degree of selectivity or an extra parameter to adjust for tricky separations. The diameter of the aperture in the gas restriction plate 434 can be adjustable to allow an operator to tune the pressure within the differential mobility spectrometer 402 for the vacuum draw established with a fixed mass spectrometer inlet diameter.
Referring to
The system 500 of
Referring to
In a system 600 of
In some embodiments of the present invention, such as the system 600 illustrated in
Specifically, if the flow of throttle gas into the juncture chamber is increased while the flow of curtain gas into the curtain chamber is kept constant, then the outflow of curtain gas away from the inlet of the differential mass spectrometer can be expected to increase. This can be undesirable. That is, as shown in
This balancing of increases in throttle gas flow with proportional decreases in curtain gas flow can also be achieved using other means in connection with other embodiments of the present invention. For example, in the case of the system 500 of
Referring to
As shown in
The flow of the curtain gas through branch 720d passes into a bubbler 720h, which can be used to add a modifier liquid to the curtain gas/drift gas, which passes through branch 720d and will ultimately be pumped into the differential mobility spectrometer 702 by the vacuum maintained in the vacuum chamber 727. Similarly, a separate modifier can be added to the curtain gas flowing through branch 720e in bubbler 720i. The curtain gas outflows from the bubblers 720h and 720i can be controlled by outlet valves 720j and 720k respectively, after which the two branches 720d and 720e merge and then release the curtain gas with the modifiers into the curtain chamber 718. As noted above, the curtain gas and drift gas are one and the same; thus, adding the modifiers to the curtain gas adds simplicity to the system 700. Modifiers can be vapors that provide selectivity by clustering with ions to different degrees, thereby shifting the differential mobility. Examples of modifiers can include alcohols such as isopropyl alcohol, water, as well as hydrogen and deuterium exchange agents, such as deuterated water or methanol, which can be used, amongst other things, to count the number of exchangeable protons on a molecule. In general, a modifier may be defined as any additive to the drift gas that changes the observed compensation voltage for a peak at a given AC amplitude. The compensation voltage is related to the ratio of high to low field mobility. Modifiers can act in other ways as well as clustering phenomena. For instance, changing the polarizability of the drift gas can also change the observed compensation voltage. Clustering and polarizability changes are two examples of mechanisms that modifiers may use to change compensation voltage optima; however, there may also be many other mechanisms.
Referring to
As shown in
Referring to
As shown in
The flow of throttle gas through branch 942 passes into a bubbler 950, which can be used to add a modifier liquid to the throttle gas passing through branch 942. Similarly, a separate liquid modifier can be added to the throttle gas flowing through branch 944 by bubbler 952. The throttle gas/liquid modifier outflows from the bubblers 950 and 952 can be controlled by outlet valves 954 and 956 respectively, after which the two branches 942 and 944 merge into common branch 958. The flow of the throttle gas and modifier liquids added by bubblers 950 and 952 through conduit 958 and eventually into juncture chamber 914 can be controlled by controllable valve 960.
The various controllable valves 946, 948, 954 and 956 enable liquid modifiers to be added to the throttle gas by bubblers 950 and 952 in a controlled manner to facilitate selectivity by clustering and reacting ions to different degrees thereby shifting their masses observed in the mass spectrometer 904. As described above, the modifiers added may also include hydrogen and deuterium exchange agents, such as deuterated water or methanol, used, amongst other things, to count the number of exchangeable protons on the ions prefiltered with the differential mobility spectrometer.
In the differential mobility spectrometer/mass spectrometer systems of
Referring to
As shown in
The bleed gas may also be useful for DMS/MS systems where the mass spectrometer inlet is sized to provide either a discontinuous gas flow into vacuum, or a very low gas flow rate. As known in the art, a very small diameter orifice can provide a very low gas flow rate into the vacuum system, and an inlet diaphragm or adjustable orifice dimension may provide a discontinuous or variable gas flow into the mass spectrometer vacuum system. Under these conditions, as described below in more detail, the bleed gas draw can provide a continuous flow of carrier gas through the DMS cell regardless of the flow rate into the vacuum system of the mass spectrometer system.
For example, drawing a bleed gas from the juncture of a differential mobility spectrometer and a mass spectrometer can be used to match the higher flow capacity of the differential mobility spectrometer with the lower flow capacity of a low-flow, low-cost, portable mass spectrometer. Because pumping capacity can be the primary limitation in reducing the size and weight of a mass spectrometer, this pumping capacity can be sacrificed to provide a smaller mass spectrometer. To compensate for this lower pumping capacity, a shutter can be provided at the orifice or inlet to the vacuum chamber. This shutter might have a duty cycle of, say, 1%, so that it is open for 10 milliseconds, and then closed for one second (1000 milliseconds), to reduce the load on the vacuum pump.
However, the flows through the differential mobility spectrometer can be, and preferably are, continuous. Thus, to avoid turbulence or other problems, as shown in
Referring to
As shown the compensation voltage peak width decreases (improved selectivity) as more throttle gas is added to the juncture chamber, while sensitivity correspondingly diminishes. That is, the top trace in
Accordingly, according to some aspects of these embodiments of the present invention, a throttle gas can be added to the juncture chamber until an acceptable compromise between sensitivity and selectivity is reached, such that sensitivity remains at a level to enable the peaks to be discerned, while selectivity has been improved to enable the peaks to be readily distinguished.
According to some aspects of some other embodiments of the present invention, in which no throttle gas is provided, but instead a bleed gas is drawn from the juncture chamber, the initial mass spectrum obtained may show peaks that are distinguishable, but which represent very faint signals, given the loss of sensitivity due to the very high residence times within the differential mobility spectrometer. According to these aspects of the present invention, increasing amounts of bleed gas can be drawn from the juncture chamber to increase the gas flow rate through the differential mobility spectrometer, thereby reducing the residence time of ions within the differential mobility spectrometer (the electrode geometry having been selected to provide this long residence time). As this occurs, the peak height will increase, representing the greater sensitivity, but may also become broader and overlap. By observing this process, an operator can stop increasing the bleed gas flow rate at a point where the peaks are still readily distinguishable and sensitivity is still acceptable.
According to some aspects of various embodiments of the present invention, a method of operating mass spectrometer systems as defined above is provided in which the differential mobility spectrometer is maintained at an internal operating pressure (the curtain chamber operating pressure), while the mass spectrometer is maintained at a vacuum pressure that is substantially lower than the internal operating pressure. The differential mobility spectrometer is also in fluid communication with the mass spectrometer to draw a gas flow, including ions provided to the differential mobility spectrometer, through the differential mobility spectrometer and into a vacuum chamber containing the mass spectrometer. A gas flow between the differential mobility spectrometer and the mass spectrometer can be modified to change the gas flow rate within the differential mobility spectrometer without changing the total volumetric flow rate into the mass spectrometer. As described above, this gas flow rate can be modified, for example, by adding a throttle gas at a throttle gas flow rate to the gas flow between the differential mobility spectrometer and the mass spectrometer to decrease the gas flow rate through the differential mobility spectrometer. Optionally, the throttle gas flow rate can be varied to vary the decreases in the gas flow rate.
Optionally the method further comprises detecting the ions drawn into the mass spectrometer to provide a mass spectrum. Initially, the electrode geometry of the differential mobility spectrometer may be selected to provide good sensitivity but poor selectivity. Then, an operator can select a selected resolution for the mass spectrum and determine and then adjust the gas flow rate to provide the selected resolution. The operator can then vary the throttle gas flow rate to decrease the gas flow rate to provide the adjusted gas flow rate to provide the selected resolution for the mass spectrum, by increasing a residence time of the ions within the differential mobility spectrometer. This can also have the result of decreasing sensitivity somewhat, however.
Optionally, an outlet of the differential mobility spectrometer can be connected to an inlet of the mass spectrometer to define an ion path of travel for ions therebetween using a juncture chamber. In such embodiments, the throttle gas can be directed into the juncture chamber and away from the ion path of travel to reduce disruption of the ion path of travel by the throttle gas. Alternatively, the throttle gas can simply be dispersed throughout the juncture chamber.
Optionally, the selected resolution for the mass spectrum and the adjusted gas flow rate for providing this selected resolution can be determined substantially contemporaneously. For example, these steps can be performed substantially contemporaneously with the step of varying the throttle gas flow rate, whereby an operator can simply observe how the resolution of the mass spectrum changes (along with the sensitivity) as the throttle gas flow rate is increased. Then, after an operator reaches an acceptable resolution (while retaining acceptable sensitivity), the throttle gas flow rate can be maintained at a constant level, thereby determining the adjusted gas flow rate to provide the selected resolution of the mass spectrum.
According to aspects of other embodiments of the present invention, instead of supplying a throttle gas to a juncture chamber between the differential mobility spectrometer and the mass spectrometer, a bleed gas can be drawn from the gas flow between the differential mobility spectrometer and the mass spectrometer at a bleed gas flow rate to increase a gas flow rate through the differential mobility spectrometer. The bleed gas flow rate can be varied to vary the increase in the gas flow rate. That is, in embodiments in which a bleed gas is drawn from the gas flow between the differential mobility spectrometer and the mass spectrometer, an electrode geometry of the differential mobility spectrometer can initially be selected to provide good selectivity at the price of poor or very poor sensitivity. Then, sensitivity can be improved, while selectivity is diminished, by increasing the bleed gas flow rate of the bleed gas drawn from the gas flow between the differential mobility spectrometer and the mass spectrometer.
According to some aspects of some embodiments of the present invention, an operator can determine a selected transmission sensitivity, determine an adjusted gas flow rate to provide the selected transmission sensitivity, and vary the bleed gas flow rate to provide the increase in the gas flow rate to provide the adjusted gas flow rate to provide the selected transmission sensitivity. Optionally, the steps can be performed altogether. That is, an operator can gradually increase a vacuum pump speed connected to the juncture chamber to increase the bleed gas flow rate, observing at the same time from the mass spectrum how the selected transmission sensitivity improves. Then, once an acceptable transmission sensitivity has been reached (and while selectivity is still acceptable) the bleed gas flow rate can be maintained to provide the adjusted gas flow rate to provide the selected transmission sensitivity. For example, for a given separation, an operator may try to optimize the sensitivity by seeing how much selectivity is required to eliminate an interference, and then maximizing the sensitivity while still removing the interference.
While the Applicant's teachings are described in conjunction with various embodiments, it is not intended that the Applicant's teachings be limited to such embodiments. On the contrary, the Applicant's teachings encompass various alternatives, modifications and equivalents as will be appreciated by those of skill in the art. For example, instead of a curtain wall other boundary members could be provided, such as a tube-like structure that directs the flow of the curtain gas to the inlet of the mass spectrometer. In addition to heating devices mounted in front of the DMS, heating devices may also be mounted elsewhere such as in the ion source, in the curtain chamber or around the mass spectrometer inlet, and the curtain gas and/or throttle gas may also be heated to facilitate declustering. Also, with respect to embodiments of the present invention such as that shown in
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
4023398 | French et al. | May 1977 | A |
5552600 | Davies et al. | Sep 1996 | A |
6504149 | Guevremont et al. | Jan 2003 | B2 |
6593568 | Whitehouse et al. | Jul 2003 | B1 |
6703609 | Guevremont et al. | Mar 2004 | B2 |
6770875 | Guevremont et al. | Aug 2004 | B1 |
6774360 | Guevremont et al. | Aug 2004 | B2 |
6799355 | Guevremont et al. | Oct 2004 | B2 |
6806466 | Guevremont et al. | Oct 2004 | B2 |
7045778 | Guevremont et al. | May 2006 | B2 |
7399958 | Miller et al. | Jul 2008 | B2 |
20030020012 | Guevremont | Jan 2003 | A1 |
20060255261 | Whitehouse et al. | Nov 2006 | A1 |
20100102222 | Musselman | Apr 2010 | A1 |
20100282966 | Schneider et al. | Nov 2010 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20090294650 A1 | Dec 2009 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61057242 | May 2008 | US | |
61178675 | May 2009 | US |