The invention relates to the field of surface acoustic wave detectors and an apparatus and method for improving the limit of detection (LOD), while employing an isothermal method for DNA manipulation when modifying a gene sequence, and for a system for delivering such compositions. More specifically, the disclosure relates to modifying a gene sequence using a CRISPR-Cas9 or other nucleic acid editing system and the ability to minimize the LOD with a secondary mass payload attached to the specific gene sequence.
The discovery of a prokaryotic viral defense mechanism, clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR-Cas9), has ushered in the ability to target virtually any DNA sequence for binding and cleavage. Essentially the simplest model CRISPR-Cas9 system is composed of two components: a guide RNA 97 nucleotides and a Cas9 protein. The guide RNA 97 nucleotides is the CRISPR part. Clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) are segments of prokaryotic DNA containing short, repetitive base sequences. Each repetition is followed by short segments of spacer DNA from previous exposures to foreign DNA (e.g., a virus or plasmid). Small clusters of Cas (CRISPR-associated system) genes are located next to CRISPR sequences.
The CRISPR/Cas system is a prokaryotic immune system that confers resistance to foreign genetic elements such as those present within plasmids and phages that provides a form of acquired immunity. RNA harboring the spacer sequence helps Cas proteins recognize and cut exogenous DNA. Other RNA-guided Cas proteins cut foreign RNA. CRISPRs are found in approximately 40% of sequenced bacterial genomes and 90% of sequenced archaea.
A simple version of the CRISPR/Cas system, CRISPR/Cas9, has been modified to edit genomes. By delivering the Cas9 nuclease complexed with a synthetic guide RNA (gRNA) into a cell, the genome can be cut at a desired location, allowing existing genes to be removed and/or new ones added. The last twenty nucleotides at the 3′ end of the RNA is programmed to be homologous to the target DNA sequence. The protein, Cas9, binds the guide RNA which targets a twenty nucleotide DNA sequence. Upon binding to the target, the DNA is cleaved on both strands by two distinct Nickase active sites.
An increasing number of CRISPR-Cas9 type systems from different bacteria species continue to be uncovered. The characterized variations in cleavage sites and subtle differences in mechanism are providing an expanding palette of gene editing tools. Cas9 mutants, which are unable to carry out the DNA cleavage function, create a CRISPR-Cas-DNA complex, which is virtually irreversible under physiological pH and salt conditions. These mutants have been used to fluorescently label sequence specific loci in situ. Gene editing and delivery of Cas9 mRNA by a lipid nanoparticle is generally disclosed in WO2015/191693 incorporated herein by reference.
Surface acoustic wave sensors (SAW) are a class of microelectromechanical systems (MEMS) which rely on the modulation of surface acoustic waves to sense a physical phenomenon. The sensor transduces an input electrical signal into a mechanical wave which, unlike an electrical signal, can be easily influenced by physical phenomena. The device then transduces this wave back into an electrical signal. Changes in amplitude, phase, frequency, or time-delay between the input and output electrical signals can be used to measure the presence of the desired phenomenon. One example of usable SAW device for is described in U.S. Pat. No. 8,436,509 incorporated herein by reference.
What is needed is a way to improve the limit of detection (LOD) of a SAW device and solve the required minimal mass loading associated with the minimum mass' threshold necessary in obtaining a measurable signal, relative to the frequency domain and its time delay, to capture a biological event(s) above the noise floor of the system at its SNR lowest resolution.
A high affinity, sequence specific DNA is used in the illustrated embodiments of the invention in a surface acoustic wave (SAW) sensor. The CRISPR/Cas9 methodology of cutting and splicing DNA allows DNA to be bound orthogonally to the detection surface of the SAW device and a protein spliced into the DNA with a nanoparticle conjugated to the protein to enhance its mass, thereby rendering the enhanced mass DNA more readily detectable by the SAW. The limit of detection (LOD) of the SAW is thus substantially decreased, thereby enabling the system to improve the LOD by minimizing the amount of analyte in question needed for detection and to improve resolution. The enhanced SAW device can be used as a counter for conjugation of a specific DNA segment as enabled by the use of the CRISPR methodology.
Gene Editing Using Isothermal DNA Method
In one embodiment, the employment of the CRISPR/Cas9 methodology of cutting, splicing and replicating a DNA segment of interest and altering the DNA structure, is supplemented by exploiting the acousto-electric properties of a gold nanoparticle (GNP) coupled with the guided RNA (gRNA) in the operation of the SAW. The SAW sensor with its shear horizontal wave propagation (at ˜400 MHz) interacts with a conjugated gRNA whereby the functionalized or chemically modified gold nanoparticle operates in a manner suitable for a single electron transistor topology. The functionalized treated GNP acts as an antenna with the characteristics of a quantized acousto-electric current-generating element.
In the SAW-driven pumps the electrons are transported by the SAW along a one-dimensional semiconductor channel by the acousto-electric effect. The acousto-electric effect is a nonlinear phenomenon generating an electric current in a piezo-electric semiconductor and/or in an island insulator (with low capacitive value) formed on a semiconductive layer, where a propagating acoustic wave induces the emission of a single electron. The generated electric current is proportional to the intensity of the acoustic wave and to the value of its electron-induced attenuation. The effect noted above was theoretically predicted in 1953 by R. H. Parmenter, “The acousto-electric effect”, Physical Review, vol. 89, pp. 990-998 (1953) and Its first experimental observation was reported in 1957 by G. Weinreich and H. G. White, “Observation of the acoustoelectric effect”, Physical Review, vol. 106, pp. 1104-1106 (1957).
GNP as Single Electron Transistor (SET)
In one embodiment, where the GNP is formed as a single-electron transistor gate, an attenuation is observed by the effect of the shear acoustic wave propagation, due to a Coulomb blockade (CB) generated with the formation of a small gap insulator-island between two metal electrodes on a gold nanoparticle, simulating a drain-source topology where electron tunneling through a barrier is emitted by the SAW. By employing the semiconductive characteristics of different coatings disposed on the nanoparticle, such as a GNP, we employ a method of activating advanced functions of a transistor gate to enable the emission of a single electron. In the illustrated embodiment the electrical characteristics of a doped SET are used, such as conductance switching, sensitivity to the acousto-electric generating events (“Coulomb blockade staircase” state), whereby the I-V characteristics for the highly asymmetric junction circuit formed across the GNP cause a single electron to move across junctions (capacitive gap between source and drain on the GNP surface) in response to the surface acoustic wave thereby generating the Coulomb blockade staircase response.
In one embodiment, the GNP's are chemically modified (as defined and shown for example by Khondaker S et al, “The fabrication of single-electron transistors using dielectrophoretic trapping of individual gold nanoparticles”) to function as beacons and where such passive device (GNP) element(s) respond to the emitted surface acoustic wave and by exhibiting an electron tunneling phenomenon thereby switching momentarily to emit an electron due to SAW energy propagation, thereby acting as an SET, and where the electronic detector “listens” to the emitted SET event by recording its presence as evidenced by the Coulomb blockade staircase characteristic of the I-V curve.
This application demonstrates the use of GNP with other amperometric value(s) such as conductivity and ohmic parameters can be employed while using GNP nanoparticles as beacons. Using acousto-electric energy due to SAW propagation's wave momentarily attenuates a newly formed junction a single electron transistor (SET), and a suitable listening detector identifies that their presence within the analyte-conjugated assay (to the antibody or the guided RNA), are present. The electrical response of such events formed out of chemically modified gold nanoparticle provides a method for measuring the GNP's presence and for means of counting and recording their presence.
In one other embodiment, we teach a method where nanoparticles are integrated with the gate dielectric of an SET coated by employing SiO2 through plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition (PCVD) to form the simulated source-drain transistor gate to produce momentary acousto-electric effects, or an antenna signature response due to the tunneling effect of an SET in a SAW sensor in response to an acousto-electric event.
The GNP formed as a transistor is fabricated on a heavily doped n-type silicon (n+Si) substrate with a thermally grown oxide layer of up to 100 nm thick. N+Si serves as the gate electrode while the oxide layer functions as the gate dielectric. An example of such fabrication method is reported by Zhegchun Liu et al. IEEE Transactions on Nanotechnology (Volume: 5, Issue: 4, July 2006 Page(s): 379-384).
Variations on the technology of single electron transistor-gate (SET), formed by doping the GNP and its coated surface (SiO2) are described where the GNP conductive surface is provided with source/drain electrodes which GNP's are also modified by functionalization with a chemical and/or biochemical probe, where switching of the SET in response to an acousto-electric event generated by the SAW is indicative of binding of a target analyte with its matching epitope, where at least some of the impedimetric characteristic of the SET is a response to the SAW acousto-electric event as derviced from the corresponding electrical output change as an output signal, thereby switching the dielectric gate, and providing a measurable unit(s) to a suitable detector.
In one embodiment, the GNP's are chemically modified with linker molecules such as guided RNA (gRNA) may be an organic mono-molecule and the channel region may include a linker layer composed of a self-assembled monomolecular layer formed by a plurality of organic mono-molecules bonded to the substrate of the GNP. The channel region may further include a linker layer composed of a silane compound layer formed on the substrate and having a functional group selected from among an amine group (—NH2), a carboxyl group (—COOH) and a thiol group (—SH). The functional group selected from among the amine group (—NH2), carboxyl group (—COOH) and thiol group (—SH) may be a portion(s) of the linkers.
The drawback associated with the processes and experimental tools cited by the literature is its inability to readily measure the outcome of such biological events or processes in a near real time method, as all the above procedures are dependent on secondary and lengthy analyses employing techniques such as PCR or ELISA for assessing the outcome of the experiments, while the proposed method of isothermal gene editing employing the CRISPR/Cas9 methodology of cutting and splicing and replicating a DNA segment of interest and altering the DNA structure is supplemented by exploiting the properties of the conjugated gold nanoparticles (GNP) to the a specific locus of a gene of the DNA and marking such locus with a GNP acting as a mass enhancement. Such conjugation to the specific gene in question is immediately available to the detector with analysis by using the SH SAW biosensor. The detector and its reader measure the resultant conjugation of GNP and gRNA at the specific site. By use of this technique, the detector electronics records and displays such biochemical events. The system register then reports the resultant output of these biological events as a corresponding change in frequency, or phase-shift.
The step of conjugating a nanoparticle to the selected protein includes the step of conjugating a gold or iron nanoparticle to the selected protein.
The step of performing a CRISPR/Cas9 preparation of the DNA segments to cut and splice a selected protein into a selected target site on at least one of a plurality of the DNA segments includes the steps of: functionalizing the detection surface of the SAW with streptavidin; binding a first Cas9 protein with a first guide RNA to a first selected target site on at least one of the plurality of DNA segments, the first Cas9 protein and the first guide RNA comprising a first RNA/Cas9 pair; biotinylating the Cas9 protein; binding the biotinylated Cas9 protein to the streptavidin; and binding the selected protein as a second Cas9 protein with a second guide RNA to the second selected target site on at least one of the plurality of DNA segments, the second Cas9 protein and the second guide RNA comprising a second RNA/Cas9 pair.
The method further includes the step of disposing a semiconductive layer on the nanoparticle, wherein measuring the number of DNA segments with conjugated nanoparticles using a surface acoustic wave sensor (SAW) comprises utilizing an electromagnetic property of the semiconductive layer to measure the number of DNA segments with conjugated nanoparticles.
The step of disposing a semiconductive layer on the nanoparticle comprises disposing a selectively doped semiconductive layer on the nanoparticle so that an active or passive electrical device is formed in the semiconductive layer.
The step of disposing a selectively doped semiconductive layer on the nanoparticle so that an active or passive electrical device is formed in the semiconductive layer includes the step of forming an antenna, diode or transistor in the semiconductive layer.
The scope of the illustrated embodiments of the invention also include a delivery system for use in a surface acoustic wave sensor (SAW) for isothermal detection of DNA including a plurality of delivery vehicles, each including (i) one or more guide RNA (gRNA) and (ii) a nucleic acid editing system. One or more gRNA is provided in a first delivery vehicle and the nucleic acid editing system is provided in a second delivery vehicle including a conjugated gold or iron nanoparticle, so that a limit of detection of the surface acoustic wave sensor (SAW) is improved.
The delivery system further includes an active or passive selectively doped semiconductive layer disposed on the gold or iron nanoparticle; so that electromagnetic interaction with the semiconductive layer is utilized in the surface acoustic wave sensor (SAW) for detection.
The illustrated embodiments of the invention also include a method comprising the step of modifying a target nucleotide sequence in a DNA segment to enhance the mass of the DNA segment for detection by a surface acoustic wave sensor (SAW). The method includes the step of administering to the DNA segment a delivery system for isothermal detection of DNA including a plurality of delivery vehicles, each including (i) one or more guide RNA (gRNA) and (ii) a nucleic acid editing system, wherein the one or more gRNA is provided in a first delivery vehicle and the nucleic acid editing system is provided in a second delivery vehicle including a conjugated gold or iron nanoparticle, so that a limit of detection of the surface acoustic wave sensor (SAW) is improved.
While the apparatus and method has or will be described for the sake of grammatical fluidity with functional explanations, it is to be expressly understood that the claims, unless expressly formulated under 35 USC 112, are not to be construed as necessarily limited in any way by the construction of “means” or “steps” limitations, but are to be accorded the full scope of the meaning and equivalents of the definition provided by the claims under the judicial doctrine of equivalents, and in the case where the claims are expressly formulated under 35 USC 112 are to be accorded full statutory equivalents under 35 USC 112. The disclosure can be better visualized by turning now to the following drawings wherein like elements are referenced by like numerals.
The disclosure and its various embodiments can now be better understood by turning to the following detailed description of the preferred embodiments which are presented as illustrated examples of the embodiments defined in the claims. It is expressly understood that the embodiments as defined by the claims may be broader than the illustrated embodiments described below.
Using two Nickase dead mutant Cas9 proteins, each loaded with different guide RNA, a DNA capture and detection amplification system is developed for DNA detection in a SAW device. No temperature cycling is required in preparation of the DNA segments as is the case of polymerase chain reactions (PCR). A Cas9 protein with guide RNA 1, collectively denoted by reference numeral 14, is modified such that it can be captured on the surface of a SAW chip 10 as diagrammatically depicted in
Reducing LOD by Incorporating GNP
A second CRISPR-Cas9 pair with guide 2 RNA, collectively denoted by reference numeral 20, provides signal amplification and orthogonal specificity. The guide 2 RNA 20 for the detection complex encodes for a second selected independent DNA site (DNA sequence 2) near the first site (DNA sequence 1). The distance between the two binding sites is anticipated to be less than 100 nucleotides, as determined empirically. The second Cas9 20 is modified so that it is tethered to a large, dense mass (LDM) 22. In the illustrated embodiments the mass 22 comprises a “nanoparticle”, but it is within the scope of the embodiments of the invention that it could include a bacteriophage virus such as PhiX174 or be a (gold) nanoparticle. The composition of the nanoparticle mass 22 is determined empirically in SAW experiments. The enhanced mass 22 allows the limit of detection of the SAW to be substantially increased. For example, with a low cost electronic implementation of the SAW, the limit of detection can be reliably reduced to an order to 10-100 DNA strands.
Variations on this basic two component system includes additional detection CRISPR-Cas9 pairs to increase signal amplitude as well as specificity by using the modifications as diagrammatically illustrated in
Further, incorporation of a third CRISPR-Cas9 pair 20b that is DNA cleavage competent allows release of the third detection pair after a measurement. This would control for a nonspecific or negative signal as the removal of the Cas9 with guide 2 RNA 20a, indicating that the specific gene modified site, is no longer present at the sensing lane substrate 10, therefore the measuring surface (sensing area 10) will contain only the remaining Cas9 with guide1 RNA 14 attached to linker molecule (biotin) 16 which is conjugated to the surface chemistry modifier (streptavidin) 12 as diagrammatically depicted in
Another variation allows for the detection of a single nucleotide polymorphism by using a fine-tuned guide RNA sequence specifically targeted for the nucleotide polymorphism of interest.
While the earlier discovered CRISPR/Cas9 system was used as an example, subsequently uncovered systems may prove more advantageous due to more desirable biochemical traits.
Overall, this is the first system to detect sequence specific DNA at or below a hundred-molecule level, at a constant room temperature with no thermocycling (PCR), in a few minutes.
The operation of the SAW device of
The interdigital transducers 66, 68 are comprised of a series of interleaved electrodes made of a metal film deposited on a piezoelectric substrate. The width of the electrodes usually equals the width of the inter-electrode gaps (typically ˜0.3 μm) giving the maximal conversion of electrical to mechanical signal, and vice versa.
Controlling the covalent bonding of antibodies 12 and 16 onto functionalized substrate 64 using a SH SAW platform 500 is a key step in the design and preparation of label free-based transducer for targeting cells, biomarkers and synthetic oligonucleic acid or peptide or DNA 18. The chemical biosensors forming the sensing substrate 64, their chemical probes and the sensing/reference lane's architecture, undergo conformational electrical impedance (phase shift) changes due to hybridization of bioagents. The changes are realized through the respective mass-loading (in the time domain) with kinetic detection by electronics as described in
Two devices of the type illustrated in
Turn now and consider chemical functionalization of the biological probe. See the example shown in
One of the preferred embodiments of this application is illustrated by the ability of the system shown in
Gene Editing Detection Employing SAW
In one of the preferred embodiments we describe an isothermal DNA detection methodology employing a surface acoustic wave, where a gRNA coupled with a GNP form a conjugate with specificity and minimal mass threshold to meet the objective of minimizing the LOD. It should be noted that the use of mutated “nickase” version of the Cas9 enzyme generates a single-strand DNA break (Nick) at a specific location based on a co-expressed gRNA-defined target sequence, thereby reducing potential error of non-specificity. Such homology improves the odds of the detector (the SAW) to generate a statistically high reliability signal response with minimal LOD, since the minimal thresholds of the system sensitivity rely on the GNP payload and its added mass.
In one of the preferred embodiments the SAW biosensors are specifically targeted towards the detection of DNA of whole microbial pathogens, DNA of protein biomarkers and nucleic acid in a biological matrix. The illustrated SAW biosensors provide relevant information for patients who are likely to respond to a given therapy, as well as biomarkers that can measure a patient's response to therapy. In one of the embodiments of this application we teach how these two measures are necessary for personalizing the drug treatment for each patient. The SAW devices will provide information with respect to rapid, point-of-care detection of biological contaminations or infection.
In one example, we teach the use of the method in the field of food safety, namely monitoring food quality before food items are consumed.
The use of interdigitated electrodes with acoustic wave biosensors on a lithium tantalite piezoelectric-substrate presents a platform which is ideally suited as a label-free biosensor for aqueous-based samples. This general technology of SAW has been used extensively as a portable, rapid and sensitive detection system for decades, primarily in the telecommunications industry. Recent advancements in the technology, has allowed for the creation of guided shear surface acoustic wave (SAW) devices that can operate in liquid environments. These devices can be functionalized through immobilization of antibodies or antibody fragments to target biomarkers and enhanced using the isothermal DNA detection while adding a GNP as a mass enhancement to improve the use of this system over previous generation of SAW devices. This involves enhanced surface chemistry techniques along with methods of attaching antibody fragments that bind specifically to biomarkers for various diseases, a novel method described in
When performing SAW biosensing in liquid environments for the detection of microbes, eukaryotic cells, protein biomarkers or nucleic acid sequences, there is a strong loss of longitudinal bulk modes such as Raleigh surface waves and most Lamb-wave modes. Surface waves with displacements normal to the surface generate compressional waves, which dissipate wave energy in the liquid. For this reason, acoustic waves that have the particle displacement parallel to the device surface and normal to the wave propagation direction are essential. These waves, which are referred to as shear-horizontal (SH) waves, propagate without coupling acoustic energy into the liquid. Love-waves are SH waves that propagate in a thin guiding layer on SH-SAW devices. If a no-slip boundary condition is assumed at the sensing surface, a thin layer of liquid becomes entrained with a shear movement at the surface for viscous liquids. This viscous loading affects the Love-wave in two ways. First, the entrainment results in mass loading of the wave-guiding layer, resulting in changes to the wave number. Second, the wave becomes damped due to viscous losses in the liquid. To reduce aqueous effects, the guiding layer can be shielded with suitable dialectic material e.g. SiO2, to prevent electrical loading on the IDTs. Love-waves that are SH are confined to the thin layer between the wave-guides with the requirement that the shear velocity in this guiding layer (the velocity in the material forming the wave-guides) is less than the shear velocity in the piezoelectric substrate. For this reason, the waveguide is the most significant structure for proper Love mode operation as a mass-sensitive biosensor.
SH SAW devices are well known to offer high surface-mass detection sensitivity for biochemical sensing. It is possible to measure mass sensitivities from surface loading in the 1-100 ng/cm2 range. The traditional configuration of SAW devices involves a chemically functionalized area that immobilizes a targeted species with a selective surface coating. The novel use of attaching the targeted species via the gRNA+GNP perturbs the mass of the sensing lane by providing a beacon with added mass at site specific area defined by the attached gRNA. A propagating surface acoustic wave is generated by the interdigitated (IDT) gold or aluminum electrodes, and such a wave responds to the added mass with a proportional electrical phase shift output. The system uses a reference lane, which employs an antibody that is nonspecific to the target. This reference lane (with similar dimensional footprints and matching impedance) is used to enable a differential mode for measuring the binding between the specific added mass and the reference, thereby eliminating the needs for absolute or calibrated standard.
The acoustic wave is detected by a second set of IDTs 68 located across from the first set of IDT 66. If the targeted species is present, then the propagating wave will be perturbed in such a way to cause a shift in the phase, frequency or amplitude, relative to wave that propagated across the reference electrode. This configuration is illustrated in
Temperature compensation is inherent to this system since the SAWs reference and the sensing lanes are on the same substrate and therefore experience the same temperature fluctuations. Therefore, any adjustment to the phase due to temperature fluctuation is automatically adjusted and compensated. The determination of the phase shift is defined by using homodyne mixing using a Gilbert cell mixer, (illustrated in
In one embodiment, the SAW device with a single delay lane, fabricated on a piezoelectric substrate such as LTaO3, obtains a differential output signal between the sensing and reference lanes, where phase, frequency or amplitude differences is determined using a mixing cell. With the electronic scheme described in
In one embodiment of this application we teach the value of employing the improved technique of gRNA conjugation of GNP to the specific gene, where we employ an antibody-based coated SAW biosensor which permits the rapid and sensitive analysis of a range of pathogens and their associated toxins. The presence of bacterial pathogens, fungus and viral particles are ubiquitous in our environment and can pose considerable risk to persons, who are exposed to these pathogens. Therefore, monitoring for the presence of microorganisms will be critical for maintaining proper health. This is especially true for short shelf-life foods.
Mass-based piezoelectric biosensors operate on the principle that a change in the mass, resulting from the molecular interactions between a targeting molecule and the target analyte, can be determined. For example, mass changes result in alterations in the resonance frequency of a lithium tantalite crystal. These piezoelectric sensors are affordable and disposable options for pathogen and biomarker detection.
In one embodiment, we employ the improved technique of DNA gene's editing for detecting the outbreaks of food-borne and water-borne pathogens, which remain a major cause of disease and mortality throughout the world. The rapid detection of these pathogenic microorganisms is critical for the prevention of public health epidemics. The quantitative identification of microorganisms has become one of the key points in areas of biodefense and food safety. To date, the detection and identification of pathogens rely primarily on classic microbiology methods of culturing. In such cases, the technician is required to go through a series of handling steps. There are several rapid methods that are now also used in microbiology that utilize enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA) or polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assays. These methods are laborious and time consuming. These methods are also not able to deliver real-time analysis or point-of-care or detection's analysis. The use of portable biosensors to rapidly identify pathogens in food and water offers several advantages over the other rapid methods. The use of the isothermal DNA employing crisper Cas9 methodology as is described by the application, facilitate such findings and enable a near-real time analysis.
Experimental Results of SAW Performance
In one embodiment of this application we employ the use of the SAW sensor disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 8,436,509 Branch et al, incorporated herein by reference in its entirety, where the author describes a study of low-level detection using a SH SAW biosensor to identify a pathogen such as Bacillus Anthracis Simulant. The study with its Love-Wave biosensors, employed a 36° YX LiTaO3 piezoelectric substrate, with physical and electrical characteristics like the one employed by this application. The study demonstrated results in which the device detected an endospore from the gram-negative bacteria specie (Bacillus thuringiensis B8). Bacillus anthracis is the causative agent for anthrax, a potentially fatal bacterial infection that has being used as a bioterrorist agent. The results indicate that the level of detection is equal to the control group tested by polymerase chain reaction (PCR method).
In other studies, such as reported in Branch et al, “Low-level detection of a Bacillus anthracis simulant using Love-wave biosensors on 36°YX LiTaO3”, the sensor (SH-SAW biosensor), was used to demonstrate a detection level of 1 ng/cm2 when using a polyimide guided layer and BSA as the blocking agent. The detection of such low levels of anthrax simulants revealed the ability of the sensor platform to detect clinically relevant doses of anthrax. The authors employed a similar device to detect both HIV1/HIV2 and Ebola viruses at clinically relevant doses. This application employs a similar configuration of the sensor architecture to obtain improved results by the incorporation of DNA editing technique noted and illustrated by
In preliminary experiments noted by the of U.S. Pat. No. 8,436,509, the SAW biosensor proved capable of detecting concentrations spanning three orders of magnitude, with an estimated limit of detection (LOD) of 74 cells were used. While the cell mass is not a true concentration, the use of an accurate standard curve will allow the rapid correlation to a potential start concentration. In these studies, the SAW biosensors, have been used to detect Ebola virus as a potential point-of care diagnostic tool. The area of improvement in such studies were limited by the inability of the prior art to reduce the LOD to a minimal threshold-relative to the SNR base, (Sensitivity vs. LOD), value of the system.
To achieve high sensitivity in SAW sensors thereby reducing the LOD to its minimal base line above SNR floor, and relative to the sensor frequency domain, it is essential to confine a maximum amount of acoustic energy near the surface of the substrate and minimize wave scattering into the bulk of the substrate. To achieve this in Love-mode SAW devices, a waveguide layer shown in
Optimization of SAW while Reducing LOD
One of the elements forming the boundary conditions of the sensor performance is the concentration of the analyte. At low-level detection, and where the limit of detection (LOD) of bioagents (in an aqueous environment), is limited, it is the threshold and mass-sensitivity which limits the ability of the existing art to meet clinical and relevant information while employing the SAW biosensor.
The optimization of the Love-Wave acoustic sensor, is enhanced by novel method of isothermal DNA editing using the Crisper Cas9 process, which provides a SAW system for reduced analyte concentration by performing the procedure noted in
The invention provides a method and apparatus for sensing the presence and/or the behavior of individual target DNA or molecules dissolved in a sample, wherein single nanoparticles is used in detecting individual target in DNA or molecule, with high temporal resolution. This is achieved through the detection of a slight shift in the SAW sensor and where the frequency attenuation, in an individual target DNA or molecule binds or detaches from the nanoparticle. Such individual binding event can be observed with the apparatus of the invention with enhanced sensitivity. Details of the electronic data capture and the problems of temporal limitation of the existing art are noted and proposed solution to such limitations as it affects the LOD are described in relation to
There are multiple parameters which affect the SAW biosensor LOD, evaluation of the SAW sensitivity SmvSmv measure: defined by the smallest concentration of a measurand that can be reliably measured by an analytical procedure of the SAW, is used as the metric when comparing the results of the method provided by this application.
In one embodiment, we employed the intrinsic parameter of “Sensitivity vs. LOD” metric to optimize the sensor ability to reduce the LOD to a minimum of surface mass density (σ) relative to 3 times the SNR value. The sensitivity parameter measures the effective performance of the sensor output, where wave velocity (v) attenuation to the accumulated mass (m) is assessed. This measure is the metric scale which this application utilizes to verify the improvements of the sensor performance relative to the minimum LOD of the system's performance.
Sensitivity vs LOD Measure
The sensitivity Smv measure is further represented by the derivative of the response (R) with respect to the physical quantity (analyte mass loading) to be measured as a phase shift (M):
(It is possible to have different units of sensitivity depending on the used sensor response. e.g. for frequency output sensors, frequency (R=f), relative frequency (R=f/f0), frequency shift (R=f˜f0) and relative frequency shift (R=(f−f0)/f0) can be found by the reader, where f0 is the non-perturbed starting frequency).
The sensitivity of the proposed SAW sensors gives the correlation between measured electric signals delivered by the sensor and a perturbing event which takes place on the sensing area of the sensor, where a high sensitivity measure (M) relates as a strong signal variation with a small perturbation change. Depending on the electronic configuration used (shown in
When the sensor response R (ref. designator 46 in
Where vφ is the unperturbed phase velocity and vφσ is the phase velocity after a surface mass change. In this sensor applications, the phase velocity shift must be obtained from the experimental values of phase or frequency shifts relative to the initial conditions of the sensor parameter K2. For the closed loop configuration, where the experimentally measured quantity is the frequency, the frequency mass sensitivity Sfσ, is defined as:
For the open loop configuration, where the experimentally measured quantity is the phase, the phase sensitivity (also called gravimetric sensitivity) is noted by the measure Sφσ. such that in absence of interference is defined as:
Where D is the distance between input and output IDT and kLz is the wave-number of the Love mode, therefore kLzD is the unperturbed phase equal to φ0, when initial calibration of the system is performed.
The relationship between the elements forming the sensor shown schematically in
SAW Modeling as an Oscillator with Delay Line
The components described by
a and 11b are graphical illustrations of the SAW sensor characteristic electrical phase response relative to mass loading. The simplified representation of the circuit is used to demonstrate the sensitivity of the acoustic sensor as an equivalent RLC circuit, where the load over the circuit is proportional to the energy in the propagation path. The system sensitivity, measured with the added GNP 22 is schematically represented by employing an RLC circuit where the capacitive loading and its equivalent resistive value varies with proportionality to the mass increase on the sensing lane.
In the bulk acoustic wave mode of propagation, the energy disperses from the oscillating surface of the transducer though the coating material. The ratio between the energy dissipated during one period of oscillation and the energy stored in the oscillating system determines the quality factor (Q-factor) of the resonator (The SAW), an important characteristic of the device. In surface, acoustic wave sensors, the energy is trapped near the oscillator surface, which increases the sensitivity of the device in measurements of the surface mass of sensing area 10 in
Δf/f0=Δvϕ/vϕ0,
where f0 and vϕ0 are the unperturbed oscillation frequency and wave velocity, respectively, and Δf and Δvϕ are the shifts in frequency and velocity respectively. Thus, the modification of the phase of delay line due to mass changes can be measured as frequency shifts. Counting the oscillator frequency with a digital frequency counter provides an indirect measurement of the acoustic wave velocities. Generally, the high sensitivity of microacoustic sensors is closely related to the fact that they show a high temperature stability (low TCF) and a large signal-to-noise ratio, which, in turn yields low LOD and a high resolution of the sensor assembly when coupled with a digital circuitry that provides the processing capabilities of the system 46 as shown in
We can define the impact of the mass loading on SH SAW sensor by characterizing the system 900 in
Sensitivity Vs. LOD
where fo is the operating frequency, Sσϕ is the phase (or gravimetric) sensitivity which is a term describing the relationship of the phase shift and the added mass relative to the signal fidelity as defined by the expression, and ϕ0 is the unperturbed phase. In this way, we can also define the LOD for phase measurements as:
where Nϕ is the noise in the measured signal above the 3×Nf of the noise-floor and it is represented as the mass add on to the sensing area and indicated by the reader as a differential output in terms of phase shift.
SAW Biosensor Structure
SAW Substrate Coupling (K2)
In one embodiment, the application demonstrates that modeling the effect of the guiding layer for the Love modes is a parameter which influences the substrate coupling factor K2. Increasing electromechanical coupling coefficient (K2) improves the sensitivity of the device. In addition, it influences the temperature behavior, since it modifies the temperature coefficient, in relation to the materials used for guiding layer, those materials with a low shear velocity, low acoustic loss and low insertion loss seem to be the optimized for developing sensitive biosensors as it is used by this application. Materials, such as polymers, silicon dioxide (SiO2), gold (Au) and zinc oxide (ZnO) have been used as guiding layers, and due to the wide frequency band availability of these materials, the issue of signal loss becomes negligible. However, in a certain frequency band, the scattered waves are in phase, adding them constructively and causing a very strong reflection which distorts the transducer frequency response.
In one embodiment of the proposed system, the modeling noted by
SAW Crystal Orientation
This application employs the SH SAW sensor, where the crystal is based on a 36° rotated Y Cut and X-axis propagating wave (LiTaO3) (36° YX LTO) direction (as shown by
As noted by the prior art, the SAW in the Love mode operation is a complex of variables (see modeling description of
SAW Limit of Detection (LOD)
The critical parameters which affect the SAW sensitivity and affect the minimalization of the LOD are:
The transducing area includes the interdigital transducers (IDTs) 66, 68, which are metal electrodes, sandwiched between the piezoelectric substrate 60 and the guiding layer 62. A typical IDT pattern is diagrammatically depicted in
In one of the preferred embodiment of the proposed sensor we employ the model illustrated in
where V is the acoustic velocity in the media, and fofo is the center or synchronous frequency. The frequency (e.g. 300-400 MHz) is an indication of where “sweet spot” tuning occurs and the center frequency optimal design must match the IDT resistance (real impedance) to the source resistance.
The device aperture is adjusted so that the IDT design achieves the correct resistance. Where the wave energy is guided through the guiding layer (waveguide) 62 up to the output IDT 68, where it is transformed back into a measurable electrical signal (phase shift) 46. The sensing area 64 is the area of the sensor surface, located between the input IDT 66 and output IDT 68, which area 64 is exposed to the analyte. A simplified diagram of a SAW device is depicted in
The sensor uses shear horizontal (SH) surface acoustic waves, which are frequently used for liquid-loaded biosensing applications. In SH-SAWs, the particle displacement is in the plane of the surface. SH-SAWs are not affected or damped by liquid loading, as compared to Rayleigh waves. On the other hand, almost all SH wave propagation on various substrates results in leaky waves which also leak into longitudinal and shear vertical wave components when excited. For this reason, special cuts of typical wafer types of wafers are typically used for SH waves, in which the energy is highly concentrated on the SH mode. Typical wafer types used in this application employ a SH-SAW with ST cut quartz, (36° Y-cut of lithium tantalate (LiTaO3)).
The sensing mechanism of SH-SAW sensors relies on the change of SAW speed either by change in mass loading (most biological and chemical sensors) or by changing physical parameters, such as the sensor native frequency, mode of detection e.g. phase shift or amplitude change, geometry layout of the IDT's, or the delay dielectric material forming the waveguide.
Phase Shift Vs Mass Loading
In one embodiment, the reader 800 employ (in a background mode) the Sauerbrey equation, correlating changes in the oscillation frequency of a piezoelectric crystal with the mass deposited on it, for computational modelling of the SAW as a resonant cavity when the crystal is perturbed due to resonance upon application of layers at the sensor surface. As illustrated by the equation below, the expression correlates the changes in oscillation frequency (of a piezoelectric crystal), with the mass deposited on its sensing lanes and provides an added value to the system reliability as it enables a reference theoretic point of comparison to the proposed system, where kinetic of hybridization is commuted.
Further illustration of the embodiment is the co-generation of theoretical plot to assess the performance of the SAW devices in practice and in accordance with the modeling noted by
where ρ′ is the added mass density and h is the height of the added mass, and the perturbative shift in frequency f is proportional to ζ (which depends on device parameters and can be experimentally verified). Here we define the resonant mode as the mode that results in maximum average displacement over time. For any linear elastic mass addition, we expect a change in frequency to be proportional to the change in added mass based on the parameters noted by our model.
In this application, we consider the process of minimizing the added mass to meet the minimal LOD's threshold for which the SAW resonator can display a measurable signal above the noise floor of the system, i.e. its native SNR, as we deploy a method of DNA editing whereby the specific area of the gene is modified via RNA guide (gRNA) so that the locus of interest on the code specific area is modified with the added mass of GNP. The process of such editing and splicing the specific gene with its conjugated mass of GNP is described in
SAW Array Configuration
Microfluidic and Convection Enhanced Delivery
The microfluidic chamber assembly 263, indicated by a phantom line in
SAW Reader
The apparatus 904 of
In one embodiment, we employ individual sets of microspheres such as gold nanoparticles (GNPs) 22 that can be modified with reactive components such as antigens, antibodies, or oligonucleotides, and/or guided RNA 20 and then mixed to form a multiplexed assay set as shown in
Further elaboration of the system 900 operation is noted by following
Reader Embedded Instructions
The circuit architecture shown in
Impedance and Phase Shift
The SH-SAW is excited on a 36° YX LiTaO3 and the right-angle edge of the substrate is used to reflect the SAW. The SAW has two components of particle displacement (see
The magnitude of the output signal is the function of the ratio of the signal's wavelength 113 and the distance 2d 2d, 114 in
Defining the pitch and the electrodes length deposited over the crystal LiTaO3 is a critical parameter in establishing the resolution of the sensor. Hence, the limit of detection (LOD) is directly related to the frequency domain that operates the device and it is linearly related to the frequency, the higher the frequency the higher is the resolution.
If the distance 2d is equal to the wavelength λ, the magnitude of the output voltage is maximal. The corresponding frequency is called the “center” or the synchronous frequency of the apparatus 900. The magnitude of the output voltage decays as the frequency shifts from the center frequency. It means basically, a SAW device is a transversal bandpass filter, see layout on
Top Level Architecture of SAW Platform
In one embodiment, the system's use of a lower frequency IF signal relaxes an ADC sampling rate and clock jitter requirement. A common local oscillator and a differential phase calculation eliminates IF synthesizer jitter. Digital I/Q demodulator 980 produces an accurate phase calculation due to perfect 90° phase shift.
A clear representation of the mixer's 903 performance is shown when the system is algebraically analyzed: the mixer produces two side bands,
Down-conversion: after low pass filtering the upper sideband
Phase and amplitude of the RF signal are conserved during down conversion, but time period corresponding to the phase value is dramatically enlarged. This feature of the electronic scheme enables the system 900 to perform a sampling and analysis of the acquired signal in a time domain that improves data collection by order of magnitude and thereby, reduces the LOD minimum required to obtain similar resolution which otherwise will necessitate higher concentration of the analyte in question.
GNP as Single-Electron Transistor
This application, although not claiming novelty in single electron transistor (SET) topology, rather indicates the possibility of employing the GNP as a mass enhancement as described in
In one embodiment, this application claims the use of mass-enhancement modality of the GNP with additional properties associated with the use of a chemically-modified GNP to form a transistor-like behavior, as it is defined by its Coulomb blockade geometry.
Many alterations and modifications may be made by those having ordinary skill in the art without departing from the spirit and scope of the embodiments. Therefore, it must be understood that the illustrated embodiment has been set forth only for the purposes of example and that it should not be taken as limiting the embodiments as defined by the following embodiments and its various embodiments.
Therefore, it must be understood that the illustrated embodiment has been set forth only for the purposes of example and that it should not be taken as limiting the embodiments as defined by the following claims. For example, notwithstanding the fact that the elements of a claim are set forth below in a certain combination, it must be expressly understood that the embodiments include other combinations of fewer, more or different elements, which are disclosed in above even when not initially claimed in such combinations. A teaching that two elements are combined in a claimed combination is further to be understood as also allowing for a claimed combination in which the two elements are not combined with each other, but may be used alone or combined in other combinations. The excision of any disclosed element of the embodiments is explicitly contemplated as within the scope of the embodiments.
The words used in this specification to describe the various embodiments are to be understood not only in the sense of their commonly defined meanings, but to include by special definition in this specification structure, material or acts beyond the scope of the commonly defined meanings. Thus, if an element can be understood in the context of this specification as including more than one meaning, then its use in a claim must be understood as being generic to all possible meanings supported by the specification and by the word itself.
The definitions of the words or elements of the following claims are, therefore, defined in this specification to include not only the combination of elements which are literally set forth, but all equivalent structure, material or acts for performing substantially the same function in substantially the same way to obtain substantially the same result. It is therefore contemplated that an equivalent substitution of two or more elements may be made for any one of the elements in the claims below or that a single element may be substituted for two or more elements in a claim. Although elements may be described above as acting in certain combinations and even initially claimed as such, it is to be expressly understood that one or more elements from a claimed combination can in some cases be excised from the combination and that the claimed combination may be directed to a subcombination or variation of a subcombination.
Insubstantial changes from the claimed subject matter as viewed by a person with ordinary skill in the art, now known or later devised, are expressly contemplated as being equivalently within the scope of the claims. Therefore, obvious substitutions now or later known to one with ordinary skill in the art are defined to be within the scope of the defined elements.
The claims are thus to be understood to include what is specifically illustrated and described above, what is conceptionally equivalent, what can be obviously substituted and also what essentially incorporates the essential idea of the embodiments.