This application claims the priority of China patent application No. 201911193974.5 filed on Nov. 28, 2019, disclosure of which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
The present disclosure belongs to the technical field of high voltage and insulation, and relates to a method of trap measurement in an XLPE cable, in particular to a method for measuring the trap charge density and the trap depth in the XLPE cable based on a polarization-depolarization current test.
As power transmission systems in China are increasingly growing in size, the application of a high-voltage DC cross-linked polyethylene (XLPE) cable is becoming more extensive. However, with the increasing voltage level and service life of the XLPE cable, it will be subjected to aging under the electricity, thermals and mechanical stresses, and micro-structural changes at the same time, such as creating traps. Carriers trapped in a medium forms space charges. The accumulation of space charges will cause distortion of the electric field distribution, and further accelerate the aging of insulation materials, even leading to insulation breakdown.
Trap characteristics in the XLPE cable can be obtained through measuring the space charge distribution in the XLPE cable. At present, main methods for measuring the space charge distribution in insulating materials include: the pulsed electro-acoustic method (PEA) and the pressure wave propagation method (PWP). However, these methods are problematic due to complex testing and signal processing processes, high precision requirements of instruments, and confined shapes of test materials, etc., and they cannot reflect material features such as trap depths. Researches have shown that the accumulation of trap charges can be reflected through measuring their detrapping current. A detrapping current refers to the current created by carriers (charges) escaping from a trap. Main methods for measuring the detrapping current include: the thermally stimulated current method (TSDC) and isothermally relaxed current method (IRC): (1) The IRC test method tests the isothermal relaxation current of a cable, and analyzes trap characteristics in the cable according to the measured isothermal relaxation current. However, the test result of the actual isothermal relaxation current contains the dipole relaxation current and the space charge detrapping current which cannot be distinguished from the isothermal relaxation current, and thus it is difficult to ensure the validity of the trap parameter measurement. (2) The TSDC test method obtains related trap parameters of carriers (charges) through observing process changes happening to the carriers from the low-temperature disequilibrium to the elevated-temperature thermal equilibrium, while widely ranged temperature adjustments are required for samples during the measurement, and the test system is quite complicated and difficult to apply to actual cable dimensions.
Therefore, there is still a lack of effective methods for measuring the space charge detrapping current and then analyzing trap depths and space charge accumulation in XLPE cable insulation materials.
To address the current difficulty of effective measurement and analysis of characteristics related to trap charges in an XLPE cable, the present disclosure is aimed at providing a method for measuring trap parameters in an XLPE cable based on the polarization-depolarization current test, which separates, from the polarization current, the detrapping current generated due to detrapping of the trap charges, and calculates trap depth and trap charge density parameters in an insulating medium by using the separated trap current.
According to the concept of the present disclosure, the polarization-depolarization current method (PDC) is widely applied in the diagnosis of insulating materials because of its advantages of nondestructive testing and abundant diagnostic information. The investigations have shown that, in the PDC test result, a polarization current contains a detrapping current which can be separated from the polarization current, and that the trap charge density and the corresponding trap depth of an insulating medium can be characterized.
The present disclosure provides a method for measuring trap parameters in an XLPE cable based on a polarization-depolarization current test, including:
(1) Obtaining a polarization current ipol and a depolarization current idepol through a polarization-depolarization current test performed on an XLPE cable;
(2) Calculating a detrapping current ide-trap according to the following formula:
i
de-trap=(ipol−idepol)−iconstruction;
wherein, iconduction is a conduction current stable value;
(3) taking the logarithm of the detrapping current curve obtained in step (2), then dividing the logarithm-taken detrapping current curve into n linear segments, and correspondingly building n trap energy levels, with the mth level Em corresponding to a detrapping current component definition formula:
i
m(t)=Amexp(−t/τm);
wherein, Am is a fitting parameter, and τm is a residence time of charges staying in the trap built with the energy level Em;
(4) conducting the staged linear fitting on respective linear segments of the logarithm-taken detrapping current curve according to lnim(t)=ln(Amexp(−t/τm)), resulting in Am and τm; and further summing all stages of fitting curves together to get a fitting curve of the detrapping current as:
i
de-trap(t)=Σm=1nim(t)
(5) Obtaining the trap parameters, wherein Am·τm and τm are respectively used to represent an accumulated charge density and a trap depth in a trap built with the energy level Em, and the ide-trap·t-lnt curve is used to represent a relationship between the trap charge density and its corresponding trap depth in the XLPE cable insulating medium.
According to the aforesaid method for measuring trap parameters in the XLPE cable based on the polarization-depolarization current test, there are a large number of defective parts in a polymer insulating medium which are caused by local non-uniformities of the polymer molecular structure. In these defective parts, polymer molecules often have a large affinity to carriers (such as charges) which easily attracts the carriers to fill in voids. This process is called the carrier capture, while these defect areas in the polymer molecular structure are called traps. When the carriers are trapped by the traps, they become trapped charges. The trap charges can escape from the traps and enter a conduction band by obtaining energy, and then leave the insulating medium to be released into an outer loop. A conductive current generated in this process is called a detrapping current of trap charges. If the detrapping current of trap charges may be measured, the trap charge density and the corresponding trap depth in the insulating medium can be calculated indirectly.
After ignoring the capacitance charging current and displacement polarization current in the polarization current, the polarization current ipol mainly includes the dipole polarization current idipole-pol, the conductance current iconduction and the trap charge detrapping current ide-trap, namely:
i
pol
−i
dipole-pol
+i
conduction
+i
de-trap (1);
wherein idipole-pol represents the current generated by dipole polarization; ide-trap represents the current generated by charges escaping from the trap; iconduction represents the conduction current of an insulating medium without charge injection, i.e., the steady-state value of the conduction composition in the polarization current.
In the depolarization stage of the XLPE cable, the tested insulating medium is grounded, and the depolarization current has a dipole relaxation current as its main composition. It is assumed that the polarization and relaxation process of dipoles is a linear process, which is:
i
dipole-pol
=i
depol (2).
and then the conduction composition in the polarization current is:
i
pol
−i
depol
=i
conduction
+i
de-trap (3);
Wherein, the detrapping current ide-trap i of trap charges is attenuated over time, while the conduction current iconduction is constant during polarization. Therefore, when the polarization time is long enough, the attenuation of the detrapping current ide-trap becomes close to 0, with only iconduction left in the right term of equation (3) at this moment which is the steady-state value of the conduction component in the polarization current, namely:
i
conduction
=i
pol(tfinal)−idepol(tfinal) (4);
Wherein, ipol (tfinal) represents the polarization current after a set time for polarization of the XLPE cable, and idepol (tfinal) represents the depolarization current after a set time for depolarization of the XLPE cable.
Finally, by using formulas (3) and (4), the detrapping current ide-trap can be obtained as:
i
de-trap=(ipol−idepol)−[ipol(tfinal)−idepol(tfinal)] (5);
It is worth noting that there is no space charge injection and ionization during the polarization because the polarization voltage is not high during the PDC test. In addition, due to the Onsager effect, the charge recombination probability decreases in the presence of an electric field, so the charge recombination process is not put into consideration during the polarization.
According to the aforementioned method of the trap parameter measurement in the XLPE cable based on the polarization-depolarization current test, as detrapping currents of traps at all energy levels present attenuation exponential curves, and, however, it has been found through researches that the direct exponential function fitting shows poor effect, in the present disclosure, the detrapping current goes through the staged linear fitting.
The trap with an energy level Em in the insulating medium correspond to the detrapping current
wherein N0(Em) is an initial density of the trap with the energy level of Em, and τm is the residence time of carriers (charges) staying in the trap with the energy level of Em. As a result, the definition formula of the detrapping current component corresponding to the trap built with the trap energy level Em constructed in the present disclosure is im(t)=Amexp(−t/τm), Am·τm∝N0(Em). Then, the detrapping current extracted from polarization current in previous steps is fitted in stages to obtain the detrapping currents corresponding to traps built with respective energy levels, and then the detrapping currents corresponding to the respective energy levels are combined to form a total detrapping current as ide-trap (t)=Σm=1nim(t). Based on this formula, the detrapping current is linearly fitted in stages. Firstly, a logarithm is taken for the detrapping current obtained in step (2), and then the logarithm-taken detrapping current is substantially divided into n linear segments according to a slope (because the curve is fitted herein, an absolute linear segment is not necessary, and an approximate linear segment will be accepted). Then, the linear fitting is performed (such as by the least square method) on an ending linear segment of the logarithm-taken detrapping current curve to obtain a detrapping current fitting curve lni1(t)=ln(A1exp(−t/τ1)) corresponding to a trap built with an energy level E1, wherein A1 is the fitted parameter, and τ1 is a residence time of charges staying in the trap built with the energy level E1. The fitted linear segment is removed from the logarithm-taken detrapping current curve and then the linear fitting is performed on (such as by the least square method) an ending linear segment of the remaining part of the logarithm-taken detrapping current curve to obtain a detrapping current fitting curve lni2(t)=ln(A2exp(−t/τ2)) corresponding to a trap built with an energy level E2, wherein 2 is the fitted parameter and T2 a residence time of charges staying in the trap built with the energy level E2. Proceeding in this way until the remaining part of the logarithm-taken detrapping current curve is a linear segment, and the linear fitting is again performed on this linear segment to obtain a detrapping current fitting curve lnin(t)=ln(Anexp(−t/τn)) corresponding to a trap built with an energy level En. Then, all pieces of fitted curves are summed up to obtain a fitting curve: ide-trap(t)=Σm=1nim(t) of the detrapping current.
According to the aforementioned method for measuring trap parameters in an XLPE cable based on polarization-depolarization current test, since Am·τm is proportional to the charge density N0 (Em), the charge density accumulated in the trap built with an energy level Em can be represented by Am·τm. Because the trap depth can be represented by the detrapping time, i. e., the longer the time constant is, the longer the detrapping time and the deeper the trap will be, τm may be used to represent the trap built with the energy level Em. Because ide-trap·t is the product of the detrapping current and time, i.e., the amount of detrapping charges, while lnt is proportional to the trap depth, the relationship between the trap charge density and the corresponding trap depth in the XLPE cable insulating medium can be expressed by the ide-trap·t˜lnt curve.
In comparison to prior arts, the method provided in the present disclosure for measuring trap parameters in an XLPE cable based on the polarization-depolarization current test provides the following beneficial effects:
i In the present disclosure, firstly, the detrapping current is extracted from the polarization current, then the staged linear fitting is executed for the detrapping current, moreover, fitting parameters Am·Lm and τm are used to represent trap parameters such as the trap charge density and trap depth in the XLPE current, and consequently, the trap charge density and charge accumulation of the XLPE cable insulation are reflected. As the present disclosure can accurately extract the detrapping current from the polarization current, it can guarantee the accuracy and effectiveness of the trap parameter measurement; and moreover, in the present disclosure, the staged linear fitting is executed for the detrapping current, resulting in an excellent fitting effect, effective elimination of various interference signals, and further accuracy improvement of the trap parameter measurement.
ii The ide-trap·t˜lnt curve depicted by using the fitted parameters in the present disclosure may greatly represent the relationship between the trap charge density and the corresponding trap depth in the XLPE cable insulating medium.
iii The present disclosure is based on a PDC non-destructive test method without high requirements for test apparatuses, which is simple to operate, causes no damage to the cable insulation, and has very high practicability in terms of acquiring XLPE cable trap characteristics, making it suitable for promotion and application in this field.
The present disclosure will be specifically described by the following embodiment. It is necessary to point out that this embodiment is only used for further illustrating the present disclosure, but should not be understood as limiting the protection scope of the present disclosure. Those skilled in the art can make some non-essential improvements and adjustments to the present disclosure according to the above-mentioned contents of the present disclosure.
5 circular XLPE sheets of a diameter of 10 cm and a thickness of 1 mm are selected as experimental samples. The samples are made by pressing polyethylene particles using a vacuum laminator and cross-linking them at 180 degrees Celsius and 15 Pa for 15 minutes, and the samples are degassed.
In this embodiment, the space charge injection method is the corona injection method, and the experimental principle of space charge injection adopted is shown in
4 of the samples are subjected to thermal aging treatment wherein the samples are put into a wet-temperature control box and treated by accelerated thermal aging under a thermal aging temperature of 135 degrees Celsius and a humidity of 0% for 2, 4, 6, and 8 days respectively. Then the space charges are injected into the XLPE cable samples according to the aforementioned process.
Then, the polarization-depolarization current (PDC) test is performed on the samples. The test schematic diagram is shown in
Based on the aforementioned test apparatus, the trap parameters of samples are measured according to the trap parameter measurement method in an XLPE cable provided in this embodiment as follows:
(1) Obtaining the polarization current ipol and the depolarization current idepol of an XLPE cable by performing a polarization-depolarization current test on the XLPE cable.
The process of performing the polarization-depolarization current test on the samples by using the aforementioned test apparatus includes: controlling the single-pole double-throw relay through the upper computer; when connecting the pole to the contact a, applying a polarization voltage of 4 kV through the high-voltage DC power supply to the cable sample for polarization; after a polarization period t1 (1000 seconds in the embodiment) elapses, controlling the single-pole double-throw relay to switch and connect the pole to the contact b; grounding the samples; discharging through the current limiting resistor b and carrying out depolarization of which a duration is t2 (1000 seconds in the embodiment). The pico-ammeter measures the polarization current ipol during polarization and measures depolarization current idepol during depolarization, respectively.
(2) Calculating a detrapping current ide-trap according to the following formula:
i
de-trap=(ipol−idepol)−iconduction;
i
conduction
=i
pol(tfinal)−idepol(tfinal);
ipol (tfinal) represents the polarization current after 1000 seconds of polarization performed on the XLPE cable; idepol (tfinal) represents the depolarization current after 1000 seconds of depolarization performed on the XLPE cable.
(3) taking the logarithm of the detrapping current curve obtained in step (2), then dividing the logarithm-taken detrapping current curve into n linear segments, and correspondingly building n trap energy levels, with the mth level Em corresponding to a detrapping current component definition formula:
i
m(t)−Amexp(−t/τm);
wherein, Am is a fitting parameter, and τm is a residence time of charges staying in the trap built with the energy level Em.
Taking the logarithm of the detrapping current extracted from the polarization current in step (2) in this embodiment, as shown in
(4) Conducting the staged linear fitting on respective linear segments of the logarithm-taken detrapping current curve according to lnim(t)−ln(Amexp(−t/τm)), resulting in Am and τm, and further summing all stages of fitting curves up to get a fitting curve of the detrapping current as:
i
de-trap(t)=Σm=1nim(t).
In this embodiment, the fitting process of the detrapping current curve corresponding to the sample aged for 2 days (with a charge injection duration of 30 minutes) is explained in detail. At first, an ending linear segment of the logarithm-taken detrapping current curve is fitted linearly by using the least square method, in order to obtain a detrapping current fitting curve (corresponding to the dashed line) lni1(t)=ln(A1exp(−t/τ1)) corresponding to a trap built with a trap energy level E1, wherein A1 is the fitting parameter and τ1 is the residence time of charges staying in the trap built with the trap energy level E1. The fitted linear segment is removed from the logarithm-taken detrapping current curve, and then the least-square-method linear fitting is performed on an ending linear segment of the remaining part of the logarithm-taken detrapping current curve to obtain a detrapping current fitting curve lni2(t)=ln(A2exp(−t/τ2)) (corresponding to the dotted line) corresponding to a trap built with a trap energy level E2, wherein A2 is the fitting parameter, and τ2 is the residence time of charges staying in the trap built with the trap energy level E2. Further, all stages of fitting curves are summed up to get a fitting curve (the solid portion) of the detrapping current as: (solid line): ide-trap=A1exp(−t/τ1)+A2exp(−t/τ2).
(5) Obtaining the trap parameters, wherein Am·τm and τm are respectively used to represent an accumulated charge density and a trap depth in a trap built with an energy level Em, and the ide-trap·t˜lnt curve is used to represent a relationship between the trap charge density and its corresponding trap depth in the XLPE cable insulating medium.
In this embodiment, as the fitting curve of the detrapping current can be expressed as ide-trap=A1exp(−t/τ1)+A2exp (−t/τ2), A1·τ1 and τ1 are used to represent the accumulated charge density and the trap depth in the trap built with the energy level E1, A2·τ2 and τ2 are respectively used to represent the accumulated charge density and the trap depth in the trap built with the energy level E2, and ide-trap·t˜lnt is used to represent the relationship between the trap charge density and its corresponding trap depth in the XLPE cable insulating medium in this embodiment. The trap characteristics of the XLPE cable can be obtained by analyzing the change trends of A1·τ1, τ1, A2·τ2, τ2 and ide-trap·t˜lnt.
Verifying the effectiveness of the extraction method of the detrapping current and the calculation method of the trap density provided in the present disclosure
The charge injection durations (0, 15 min, 30 min, 45 min in turn, with a short-circuit heat cleaning (at 100 degrees Celsius for 24 hours) performed between every two experiments to eliminate any influence arising from the space charge injection history) are changed for a sample not aged yet. Then, the sample is tested according to the aforementioned steps (1)-(5) to obtain the corresponding trap parameters, with the test results shown in Table 1,
Fitting curves of the detrapping current after space charge injection performed on the sample for different durations are shown in
Fitting parameters of the detrapping current after space charge injection performed on the sample for different durations are shown in Table 1, and ide-trap·t˜lnt curve is shown in
Researches for the relationship between the trap charge trap current and sample aging degree, and verifications for the effectiveness of representing trap characteristics in the XLPE cable by using fitting parameters of the trap current curve extracted from the polarization current
According to the aforementioned steps (1)-(5), tests are performed on samples with different aging degrees after the charge injection (with the charge injection duration of 30 minutes) to get the corresponding trap parameters, as shown in Table 2,
It can be observed from
The fitting parameters of the detrapping current of samples with different aging degrees are shown in Table 2, and the corresponding ide-trap·t˜lnt curve is shown in
Apparently, those skilled in the art can make various modifications and variations without departing from the spirit and scope of the present disclosure. In this way, if these modifications and variations of the present disclosure fall within the scope of the claims and their equivalents, the present disclosure is also intended to incorporate these modifications and variations.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
201911193974.5 | Nov 2019 | CN | national |