THIS APPLICATION IS A U.S. NATIONAL PHASE APPLICATION OF PCT INTERNATIONAL APPLICATION PCT/JP2003/012001.
The present invention relates to a method and an apparatus used for introducing the impurity in the course of manufacturing semiconductor devices, etc. The present invention also relates to those devices manufactured in accordance with the method using the apparatus.
Solid substances are generally covered at the surface with an oxide film formed as the result of coupling between the atoms constituting solid substance and the oxygen in the atmospheric air. The introduction of impurity material to a solid substance has been conducted using an ion implantation or the like physical procedures, from above the oxide film which is kept on the surface as it is. Namely, irradiating the surface of a solid substance with ion of impurity source energized with electric fields, etc., thereby introducing the impurity into the inside.
As the result of recent development of finer device technologies in the device sector, it is requested to form a junction in a shallower profile. The low-energy ion implantation is a conventional technology used for forming a shallow junction. A number of improvements have been introduced to the low-energy ion implantation technology; for example, pulling ion out of the source using a substantially high voltage and then reducing the speed at a later stage. In this way, a low-energy implantation is realized while keeping the beam current value at a substantially high level. Such technologies have been successful in providing impurity layers in a profile as shallow as several 10 nm; and the layers have been in practical use in the semiconductor device industry.
Plasma doping technology is attracting the attention as a new technology for forming the junction in a still shallower profile. In the plasma doping process, plasma containing a certain desired particle is made to have contact with the surface of a target semiconductor substrate; thereby, the certain desired particle is introduced to the surface. Since the energy of plasma is as low as several hundreds volts at the highest, it is a suitable vehicle for forming an impurity layer in a shallow profile. According to experimental reports, the shallow junctions of ten-odd nm to several 10s nm deep have been formed. The Technical Digest of Symposium on VLSI Technology, Honolulu, p 110, (2000), discloses an experimental result; according to which, depth of a P-type junction is the smallest ever, or 7 nm.
Gaseous phase doping method which uses a gas source is also proposed in the IWJT, p. 19, (2000), the Japan Vacuum. Science Technology, A16, p 1, (1998), the Silicon Technology, No. 39, 18th Jun. 2002, and other publications. According to the method, a semiconductor substrate is heated in the normal pressure atmosphere of hydrogen, and B2H6, PH3 are supplied thereto for providing impurity diffusion layers, P-type and N-type. The hydrogen carrier gas is effective for removing the natural oxidation film sticking on the silicon surface, and for keeping the surface clean. So, it is advantageous in suppressing a surface segregation of the impurity, a.o. boron. For decomposing the gas, it requires a high temperature, generally higher than 600° C. The Silicon Technology, No. 39, 18 Jun. 2002, for example, reports an experimental result of forming a high-concentration shallow junction, in which a semiconductor substrate is heated to 900° C. and a 1 ppm B2H6 gas is delivered. Defining a level of boron concentration 1×1018/cm3 as the junction depth, depth of a junction attained in the above experiment is approximately the same as that reported in the earlier-described technology, 7 nm.
The above-described plasma doping and the low-energy ion implantation are the new technologies proposed to meeting the needs of a shallower junction, which needs have arisen as the result of efforts to implement finer device technologies. According to the recent publications, shallow junctions of ten-odd nm to several 10s nm deep have already been realized on experimental basis. The shallowest ever P-type junction is 7 nm, as already described in the above. In the face of continuous developments towards finer processing technologies, the needs of a new technology that can form an impurity layer through an easy process in a still shallower profile are growing. The plasma doping is a process for implanting the particles having acceleration energy into a semiconductor substrate, although the energy is small. So, it seems to be difficult for the plasma process to form an impurity layer in a still shallower profile. The gaseous phase doping which uses a gaseous source is a technology for forming an impurity layer taking advantage of the surface reaction by supplying a dopant having no acceleration energy to the substrate. This technology appears to be promising as a breakthrough to the limit in the conventional technologies which irradiate the substrate with energized ion. However, as described earlier, the technology requires a high temperature, higher than 600° C., for decomposing the gas. The high temperature makes it impossible to use a photo resist for the mask material. As the result, it becomes necessary to form a CVD-SiO2, etc., or to provide a patterning; which leads to an increase in the process steps for forming transistors.
In the course of introducing a certain impurity material to a solid substance which has an oxidation film or other film, etc. sticking at the surface, a method in accordance with the present invention first removes the oxidation film and other film with at least one means selected from among the group consisting of a means to irradiate the surface of solid substance with plasma, a means to irradiate the surface of solid substance with gas and a means to dip the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid; and then, attaches or introduces a certain desired particle to the surface.
In the course of introducing a certain impurity material to a solid substance which has an oxidation film or other film, etc. sticking at the surface, an apparatus for introducing the impurity in accordance with the present invention first removes the oxidation film and other film with at least one means selected from among the group consisting of a means to irradiate the surface of solid substance with plasma, a means to irradiate the surface of solid substance with gas and a means to dip the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid; and then, attaches or introduces a certain desired particle to the surface.
Impurity-containing component devices in accordance with the present invention are those manufactured through a procedure in which, in the course of introducing a certain material to a solid substance which has an oxidation film or other film, etc. sticking at the surface, the oxidation film and other film are first removed with at least one means selected from among the group consisting of a means to irradiate the surface of solid substance with plasma, a means to irradiate the surface of solid substance with gas and a means to dip the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid; and then, a certain desired particle is attached or introduced to the surface.
In the course of introducing a certain material to a solid substance which has an oxidation film or other film, etc. sticking at the surface, a method of introducing the impurity and an apparatus for introducing the impurity in accordance with the present invention first remove the oxidation film and other film using at least one means selected from among the group consisting of a means to irradiate the surface of solid substance with plasma, a means to irradiate the surface of solid substance with gas and a means to dip the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid; and then, attaches or introduces a certain desired particle to the surface.
The removal of the surface film facilitates easier sticking of the particle, and an impurity layer can be formed at the vicinity of the surface. Plasma of argon or that of a hydrogen system, etc. is used for irradiating the surface of solid substance. In the case where a gas is used, gas of a hydrogen system is used. The reductive liquid is at least the one item which is selected from among the group consisting of hydrogen fluoride, sodium hydroxide, aqueous ammonia, sulfinic acid and adipic acid di-2-ethylhexyl ester. In the means for dipping the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid, it is preferred that the surface is rubbed mechanically when it is dipped in a reductive liquid. This is because the mechanical rubbing facilitates easier removal of the surface film.
One of the methods of attaching or introducing a certain desired particle is bringing a gas containing the desired particle to the surface of solid substance, which surface has been made to be free of the oxidation film and other film, to have the particle attached or introduced to the surface, or the vicinity, of solid substance. Other method of attaching or introducing a certain desired particle is; irradiating the surface of solid substance, which surface has been made to be free of the oxidized film and other film, with electromagnetic wave whose energy is stronger than that which is binding the hydrogen or hydroxyl radical sticking at the surface with the atom of solid substance, thereby converting the binding into a non-coupled state to have the sticking hydrogen or hydroxyl radical separated, exposing the atom constituting the solid substance to the surface, and then irradiating the surface with a certain desired particle in order to have it attached or introduced to the surface, or the vicinity, of solid substance. At the surface of solid substance whose oxidized film and other film have already been removed, there is hydrogen or hydroxyl radical, having substantially uniform binding energy, bound with the atom of solid substance. The state of their binding can be easily broken by delivering an energy that is stronger than the binding energy. Since the energy of electromagnetic waves is easy to control, the above-described irradiation procedure can be performed with high reproducibility. Namely, it is easy to select an optimum electromagnetic wave, whose energy is strong enough to break the binding at the same time it does not ill-affect the solid substance's surface conditions, and to irradiate it with a good reproducibility. The solid substance's atom thus exposed to the surface is in an activated state; which means that it is readily bound with other particles. Therefore, it is easy to have an impurity attached or introduced on the surface, or the vicinity, of solid substance, by irradiating a certain desired particle after the constituent atom has been activated. The certain desired particle should preferably be making access to the constituent atom at a low velocity, viz. with a low energy. This is because the low-energy particle can be easily trapped by the activated atom. The low-energy particle signifies that in the state of plasma, gas or ultra low-energy ion. The gas containing a certain desired particle does not need to be heated to a high temperature for decomposition; the temperature of solid substance may be lower than 600° C., furthermore, impurity can be introduced even in the normal room temperature.
The energy of electromagnetic wave irradiated in the present impurity introducing method corresponds to 318 kJ/mol or higher, lower than 666 kJ/mol.
More preferably, the energy should be higher than 425 kJ/mol, lower than 666 kJ/mol. The reason for that is that: the typical value of binding energy with the oxygen atom at the surface of solid substance is 452 kJ/mol, and it is desired to irradiate an electromagnetic wave whose energy is sufficient for removing the oxygen.
As already described, in a method of introducing the impurity in accordance with the present invention, the process of attaching or introducing a certain desired particle is conducted in an environment where the solid substance's temperature is lower than 600° C.
In a method of introducing the impurity in accordance with the present invention, in the course of introducing a material in the phase of ion, plasma, gas, etc. to a solid substance having an oxidized film or other film, etc. sticking at the surface, the oxidized film and other film are first removed as the surface treatment to solid substance using at least one means selected from among the group consisting of a means to irradiate the surface of solid substance with plasma, a means to irradiate the surface of solid substance with gas and a means to dip the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid; and then, a certain desired particle is attached or introduced.
A certain desired particle in the present impurity introducing method is attached or introduced from either one of the states among plasma, gas and ultra low-energy ion.
An impurity introducing method in accordance with the present invention uses at least one item selected from among each of the following respective categories; at least one apparatus selected from among the group consisting of an apparatus for irradiating the surface of solid substance with plasma, an apparatus for irradiating the surface of solid substance with gas and an apparatus for dipping the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid; an apparatus for bringing a gas containing a certain desired particle to make contact with the surface of solid substance; and an annealing apparatus for diffusing the certain desired particle attached or introduced therein.
An apparatus for dipping the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid used in the present impurity introducing method is provided with a mechanism for rubbing the surface of solid substance mechanically.
An apparatus for bringing a gas containing a certain desired particle to make contact with the surface of solid substance used in the present impurity introducing method is provided with a facility which is capable of irradiating electromagnetic wave whose energy is stronger than the energy that is binding the hydrogen or hydroxyl radical sticking on the surface of solid substance, which surface has been made to be free of the oxidized film and other film, with the atom of solid substance.
An impurity introducing method in accordance with the present invention uses, in a combination mode or as an integration, at least two items selected from among the following categories; at least one apparatus selected from among the group consisting of an apparatus for irradiating the surface of solid substance with plasma, an apparatus for irradiating the surface of solid substance with gas and an apparatus for dipping the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid; an apparatus for bringing a gas containing a certain desired particle to make contact with the surface of solid substance; and an annealing apparatus for diffusing the certain desired particle attached or introduced therein.
Active component devices such as a semiconductor device, an LCD, a bio-chip, etc. and passive component devices such as a resistor, a coil, a capacitor, etc. in the present invention are those manufactured by taking advantage of the above-described method of introducing the impurity.
In an impurity introducing apparatus in accordance with the present invention, in the course of introducing a material to a solid substance which has an oxidized film or other film, etc. sticking at the surface, the oxidized film and other film are first removed as the surface treatment to the solid substance using at least one means selected from among the group consisting of a means to irradiate the surface of solid substance with plasma, a means to irradiate the surface of solid substance with gas and a means to dip the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid; and then, a certain desired particle is attached or introduced.
The plasma used in the present impurity introducing apparatus is that of rare gas argon or a system containing hydrogen.
The gas used in the present impurity introducing apparatus is a gas of a system containing hydrogen.
The reductive liquid used in the present impurity introducing apparatus is at least one item selected from among the group consisting of hydrogen fluoride, sodium hydroxide, aqueous ammonia, sulfinic acid and adipic acid di-2-ethylhexyl ester.
A means for dipping the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid used in the present impurity introducing apparatus rubs the surface mechanically when it is dipped in the reductive liquid.
A method of attaching or introducing a certain desired particle used in the present impurity introducing apparatus is bringing a gas containing a certain desired particle to make contact with the surface of solid substance, which surface has been made to be free of oxidized film and other film, thereby attaching or introducing the particle to, or the vicinity, of the surface.
A method of attaching or introducing a certain desired particle used in the present impurity introducing apparatus is irradiating the surface of solid substance, which surface has been made to be free of oxidized film and other film with electromagnetic wave whose energy is stronger than the energy that is binding the hydrogen or hydroxyl radical at the surface with the atom of solid substance, thereby converting the binding into a non-coupling state to have the sticking hydrogen or hydroxyl radical separated, and the atom constituting the solid substance exposed to the surface, and then bringing the certain desired particle to make contact to the surface. Thus the particle is attached or introduced to the surface, or the vicinity, of solid substance.
The energy of electromagnetic wave irradiated in the present impurity introducing apparatus corresponds to 318 kJ/mol or higher, lower than 666 kJ/mol.
More preferably; the energy should be higher than 425 kJ/mol, lower than 666 kJ/mol. The reason for that is that: the typical value of binding energy with oxygen atom at the surface of solid substance is 452 kJ/mol, and it is desired to irradiate an electromagnetic wave that is sufficient for removing the oxygen.
A method of attaching or introducing a certain desired particle used in the present impurity introducing apparatus is performed in an environment where the solid substance's temperature is lower than 600° C.
In an apparatus for introducing the impurity in accordance with the present invention, in the course of introducing a material in the phase of ion, plasma, gas, etc. to a solid substance having an oxidized film or other film, etc. sticking at the surface, the oxidized film and other film are first removed as the surface treatment using at least one means selected from among the group consisting of a means to irradiate the surface of solid substance with plasma, a means to irradiate the surface of solid substance with gas and a means to dip the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid; and then, a certain desired particle is attached or introduced.
A certain desired particle in the present impurity introducing apparatus is attached or introduced from either one of the states among plasma, gas and ultra low-energy ion.
An apparatus for introducing the impurity in accordance with the present invention is provided with at least one item selected from among each of the following respective categories; at least one apparatus selected from among the group consisting of an apparatus for irradiating the surface of solid substance with plasma, an apparatus for irradiating the surface of solid substance with gas and an apparatus for dipping the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid; an apparatus for bringing a gas containing a certain desired particle to make contact with the surface of solid substance; and an annealing apparatus for diffusing the certain desired particle attached or introduced therein.
An apparatus for dipping the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid used in the present impurity introducing apparatus is provided with a mechanism for rubbing the surface of solid substance mechanically.
An apparatus for bringing a gas containing a certain desired particle to make contact with the surface of solid substance used in the present impurity introducing apparatus is provided with a facility which is capable of irradiating electromagnetic wave whose energy is stronger than the energy that is binding the hydrogen or hydroxyl radical sticking at the surface of solid substance, which surface has been made to be free of the oxidized film and other film, with the atom of solid substance.
An impurity introducing apparatus in accordance with the present invention uses, in a combination mode or as an integration, at least two items selected from the following categories; at least one apparatus selected from among the group consisting of an apparatus for irradiating the surface of solid substance with plasma, an apparatus for irradiating the surface of solid substance with gas and an apparatus for dipping the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid; an apparatus for bringing a gas containing a certain desired particle to make contact with the surface of solid substance; and an annealing apparatus for diffusing the certain desired particle attached or introduced therein.
Impurities-containing component devices in the present invention are those manufactured through a procedure, in the course of introducing a material to a solid substance having an oxidized film or other film, etc. sticking on the surface, in which procedure the oxidized film and other film are first removed as the surface treatment using at least one means selected from among the group consisting of a means for irradiating the surface of solid substance with plasma, a means for irradiating the surface of solid substance with gas and a means for dipping the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid; and then, a certain desired particle is attached or introduced.
The plasma used for manufacturing the impurity-containing component devices in the present invention is that of rare gas argon or a system containing hydrogen.
The gas used for manufacturing the impurity-containing component devices in the present invention is a hydrogen system gas.
The reductive liquid used for manufacturing the impurity-containing component devices in the present invention is at least one items elected from among the group consisting of hydrogen fluoride, sodium hydroxide, aqueous ammonia, sulfinic acid and adipic acid di-2-ethylhexyl ester.
The means for dipping the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid used for manufacturing impurity-containing component devices in the present invention rubs the surface mechanically when it is dipped in the reductive liquid.
A method of attaching or introducing a certain desired particle used for manufacturing the present impurity-containing component devices brings a gas containing a certain desired particle to make contact to the surface of solid substance, which surface has been made to be free of the oxidized film and other film; thereby, the certain desired particle is attached or introduced to the surface, or the vicinity, of solid substance.
A method of attaching or introducing a certain desired particle used for manufacturing the impurity-containing component devices in the present invention irradiates the surface of a solid substance, which surface has been made to be free of the oxidized film and other film, with electromagnetic wave whose energy is stronger than the energy that is binding the hydrogen or hydroxyl radical at the surface with the atom of solid substance, thereby converting the binding into a non-coupling state to have the sticking hydrogen or hydroxyl radical separated and exposing the atom constituting the solid substance to the surface; and then, delivers a certain desired particle to make contact to the surface in order to have it attached or introduced at the surface, or the vicinity, of solid substance.
The energy of electromagnetic wave irradiated for manufacturing the impurity-containing component devices in the present invention corresponds to 318 kJ/mol or higher, lower than 666 kJ/mol.
More preferably, the energy should be higher than 425 kJ/mol, lower than 666 kJ/mol. The reason for that is that: typical value of the binding energy with the oxygen atom at the surface of solid substance is 452 kJ/mol, and it is desired to apply a sufficient electromagnetic wave for removing the oxygen.
The method of attaching or introducing a certain desired particle used for manufacturing the impurity-containing component devices in accordance with the present invention is performed in an environment where the solid substance's temperature is lower than 600° C.
Impurity-containing component devices in the present invention are manufactured through a procedure, in the course of introducing a material in the phase of ion, plasma, gas, etc. to a solid substance which has an oxidized film or other film, etc. sticking at the surface, in which the oxidized film and other film are first removed as the surface treatment to solid substance using at least one means selected from among the group consisting of a means for irradiating the surface of solid substance with plasma, a means for irradiating the surface of solid substance with gas and a means to dip the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid; and then, a certain desired particle is attached or introduced.
A certain desired particle used for manufacturing the impurity-containing component devices in the present invention is attached or introduced from either one of the states among plasma, gas and ultra low-energy ion.
Impurity-containing component devices in the present invention are manufactured on a manufacturing facility which includes at least one item selected from among each of the following respective categories; at least one apparatus selected from among the group of an apparatus for irradiating the surface of solid substance with plasma, an apparatus for irradiating the surface of solid substance with gas and an apparatus to dip the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid; an apparatus for bringing a gas containing a certain desired particle to make contact with the surface of solid substance; and an annealing apparatus for diffusing the certain desired particle attached or introduced therein.
An apparatus of dipping the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid used for manufacturing impurity-containing component devices in the present invention is provided with a mechanism which rubs the surface of solid substance mechanically.
An apparatus of bringing a gas containing a certain desired particle to make contact with the surface of solid substance used for manufacturing impurity-containing component devices in the present invention is provided with a facility which is capable of irradiating electromagnetic wave having an energy stronger than the energy that is binding the hydrogen or hydroxyl radical at the surface, which surface has been made to be free of the oxidized film and other film, with the atom of solid substance.
Impurity-containing component devices in the present invention are those manufactured on a production facility which includes in a combination mode or as an integration at least two items selected from the following categories; at least one apparatus selected from among the group consisting of an apparatus for irradiating the surface of solid substance with plasma, an apparatus for irradiating the surface of solid substance with gas and an apparatus for dipping the surface of solid substance in a reductive liquid; an apparatus for bringing a gas containing a certain desired particle to make contact with the surface of a solid substance; and an annealing apparatus for diffusing the certain desired particle attached or introduced therein.
Preferred embodiments of the present invention are described below.
An experiment was made using a semiconductor silicon substrate. The main part of the facilities used in the experiment A includes a preliminary vacuum chamber and a process chamber. In the first place, the preliminary vacuum chamber is made open to the normal atmospheric pressure, and then semiconductor substrate 13, or the solid substance, is put on a handling arm in the preliminary vacuum chamber. After the pressure of preliminary vacuum chamber is lowered, the handling arm carries semiconductor substrate 13 to the inside of process chamber.
Semiconductor substrate 13 is transferred to the process chamber to be placed on lower electrode 14. After the transportation is finished, the transfer channel is closed to separte the process chamber from the preliminary vacuum chamber. The process chamber is connected with independent gas intake ducts, for argon gas and diborane gas, respectively. In the present process chamber, mass flow controller 5 can control respective flow rates.
Semiconductor substrate 13 placed on lower electrode 14 in the process chamber is irradiated at the surface with argon plasma for spattering. Flow rate of the argon gas is 50 sccm, pressure within the chamber is 0.7 Pa, helicon power is 1500 W, and bias power is 300 W. The spattering is continued for 70 sec. One second after the spattering is finished, diborane (B2H6) gas is introduced to the inside of chamber for 70 sec. Flow rate of the diborane (B2H6) gas is 50 sccm, pressure within the chamber is 1.7 Pa. And then, distribution of boron concentration is measured using a low-energy SIMS in the direction of depth from the surface.
Irradiating the silicon (Si) with electromagnetic wave seems to bring silicon atom (Si) 15 exposed to the surface to make an activated state.
As the next step, diborane (B2H6) gas, for example, is brought to make contact with the terminal silicon (Si) atom.
Some of the particulars of the above-described exemplary embodiment are as follows. Binding energy at a single coupling of silicon (Si) atom and hydrogen (H) atom is 318 kJ/mol. Binding energy at a single coupling of silicon (Si) atom and oxygen (O) atom is 452 kJ/mol. While, binding energy at a single coupling of silicon (Si) atoms is 222 kJ/mol. Since the terminal silicon (Si) atom is connected with three other silicon (Si) atoms, a 666 kJ/mol energy seems to be needed for separating the terminal silicon (Si) atom from a crystalline silicon (Si). By taking advantage of the difference among the binding energies, only the sticking hydrogen (H) or hydroxyl radical (OH) can be separated by irradiating electromagnetic wave whose energy is stronger than the energy that is binding the hydrogen (H) or hydroxyl radical (OH) with the silicon (Si) atom in a single coupling. Namely, silicon (Si) atom can be exposed to the surface to bring the surface to an activated state as shown in
Through the above procedure, semiconductor substrate 13, or the solid substance, becomes those impurity-containing component devices manufactured in accordance with a method of introducing an impurity, or manufactured on an apparatus for introducing an impurity, in the present invention. In other wards, semiconductor substrate 13, or the solid substance, is made into those semiconductor devices, liquid crystal display devices, bio-chips or the like active components, or resistors, coils, capacitors or the like passive components manufactured in accordance with a method of introducing an impurity, or manufactured on an apparatus for introducing an impurity, in the present invention.
As described in the above, the present invention offers a method, as well as an apparatus, for forming an impurity layer in a shallower profile through an easier and simpler procedure. The present invention also offers those component devices whose impurity layer is shallower than the conventionally available impurity layers. Thus the present invention will open the way towards a still-finer processing technology, which would lead to a still-higher integration density, a still-faster signal processing and a less power consumption in the components.
A method of introducing an impurity, or an apparatus for introducing an impurity, in accordance with the present invention makes it possible to form the impurity layers with ease in a shallower profile. Those component devices in the present invention are manufactured by taking advantage of the method of introducing impurity, or the apparatus for introducing impurity, in accordance with the present invention. The impurity layers contained in these component devices have a profile that is shallower than that in the conventional devices. Thus the present invention is expected to open a way towards a still finer micro devices.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2002-274554 | Sep 2002 | JP | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/JP03/12001 | 9/19/2003 | WO | 00 | 3/7/2005 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2004/027847 | 4/1/2004 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
5387545 | Kiyota et al. | Feb 1995 | A |
5851906 | Mizuno et al. | Dec 1998 | A |
6324715 | Hymes et al. | Dec 2001 | B1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
0 430 168 | Jun 1991 | EP |
03-173420 | Jul 1991 | JP |
04-219927 | Aug 1992 | JP |
07094427 | Apr 1995 | JP |
08031779 | Feb 1996 | JP |
08-172214 | Jul 1996 | JP |
09-007962 | Jan 1997 | JP |
09-115844 | May 1997 | JP |
09-283456 | Oct 1997 | JP |
10-135244 | May 1998 | JP |
11-204450 | Jul 1999 | JP |
2000-164523 | Jun 2000 | JP |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20060088989 A1 | Apr 2006 | US |