This application is a U.S. National Phase Application submitted under 35 U.S.C. 371 based on International Application No. PCT/EP2017/058468 filed Apr. 7, 2017 (published as WO2017/174809 on Oct. 12, 2017) which claims the benefit of United Kingdom Patent Application 1606013.9 filed Apr. 8, 2016, each of which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
This application includes as part of its disclosure a biological sequence listing which is being concurrently submitted through EFS-Web. Said biological sequence listing is contained in a file named “43297o3401.txt” which was created on Oct. 8, 2018, and has a size of 138,613 bytes, and is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
The present invention relates to a method for producing hybrid bacteriophage host range determinant (HRD) sequences. The present invention is particularly suited for providing a recombinant phage bearing hybrid HRDs having a broad host range.
The World Health Organisation's 2014 report on global surveillance of antimicrobial resistance reveals that antibiotic resistance is a global problem that is jeopardising the ability to treat common infections in the community and hospitals. Without urgent action, the world is heading towards a post-antibiotic era, in which common infections and minor injuries, which have been treatable for decades, can once again kill (WHO, 2014). Antibiotic resistance complicates patients' recovery from even minor operations and is increasingly causing treatment failures. In fact, there are now strains of some genera of bacteria circulating globally which are resistant to all available antibiotics. Such strains commonly fall within the scope of the so-called ESKAPE pathogens—Enterococcus faecium, Staphylococcus aureus, Klebsiella pneumoniae, Acinetobacter baumannii, Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Enterobacter species (Boucher et al., 2009). The term ESKAPE pathogens was coined by Boucher et al., to emphasize that these bacteria currently cause a majority of hospital infections in the US and Europe and can effectively “escape” the majority, if not all, available antibiotics with panantibiotic-resistant infections now occurring. The death rate for patients with serious infections caused by common bacteria treated in hospitals is approximately twice that of patients with infections caused by the same non-resistant bacteria, e.g. people with methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) infections are estimated to be 64% more likely to die than people with a non-resistant form of the infection (WHO, 2014). Of the Gram positive bacteria, methicillin resistant S. aureus continues to be a major cause of morbidity and mortality in hospitals in the US and Europe. However, in more recent years, several highly resistant Gram negative pathogens, including Acinetobacter species, multidrug resistant (MDR) P. aeruginosa, and carbapenem-resistant Klebsiella species and Escherichia coli, have emerged as major pathogens causing serious, and sometimes untreatable, infections. Advances in medicine mean that increasingly complex procedures take place: and these advances are leading to a growing number of elderly patients and patients undergoing surgery, transplantation, and chemotherapy all of which will produce an even greater number of immunocompromised individuals at risk of these infections (Walker et al., 2009). This phenomenon has led to a greater dependence on, and requirement for, effective antibiotics.
P. aeruginosa is one bacterium which is frequently multi-drug resistant (MDR) having intrinsic resistance due to low permeability of its outer membrane limiting drugs getting into the cell, and a multitude of efflux pumps to expel any drugs that successfully manage to enter the cell. P. aeruginosa is also acquiring additional resistance mechanisms, including resistance to the “antibiotics of last resort” for Gram negatives, the carbapenems. P. aeruginosa causes approximately 10% of all hospital acquired infections and is the second leading cause of hospital-acquired pneumonia, which accounts for 50% of all hospital-acquired infection prescribing. P. aeruginosa infections in hospitals commonly require intravenous (IV) treatment with current standard of care for P. aeruginosa infections dictating that patients are treated with at least two antibiotics. Unfortunately, resistance frequently develops in patients during therapy. With so few new classes of antibiotic developed and approved for market within the last 30-40 years, there is a critical need for novel, safe and effective antibacterial agents.
One alternative to current antibiotics is bacteriophage-based medicines. Bacteriophage (or phage) have been used as medicines for the treatment of bacterial infections since the 1920s or 30s.
Recent developments include the use of phage as the basis for modification to make tailored gene delivery vehicles, which can be used for the delivery of genes encoding toxic proteins to target pathogenic bacteria. Such an approach is described in the SASPject system (WO2009/019293), in which bacteriophage are engineered to be non-lytic, thus ultimately non-viable, and to carry a SASP gene expression cassette, which is delivered into the targeted bacteria, which leads to rapid SASP expression. SASP are Small Acid-soluble Spore Proteins, which protect the DNA of Gram positive bacterial endospores during dormancy. However, upon expression of SASP in vegetative cells, rapid binding of SASP to the cell's DNA in a non-sequence specific manner (Nicholson et al., 1990) leads to rapid cell death.
However, generally, bacteriophage are specific to their bacterial host. Thus a phage specific to one bacterial host may be of little use when seeking to treat an infection caused by another bacterial host which the phage cannot infect. For useful medicines, the challenge is to provide bacteriophage compositions which can be used to treat infection from a variety of bacterial strains in an effective way.
One way to meet this challenge is by selecting for bacteriophage based upon their ability to infect a broad range of bacterial strains (broad host range phage). However, this approach is limited, as a single phage usually has insufficient host range due to the plasticity of the bacterial cell surface, especially in Gram negative bacteria (Carlton, 1999; Kutateladze and Adamia, 2010).
Another way is to select a mixture or a “cocktail” of phage to ensure broad coverage across the range of bacterial strains. To this end, cocktails of wild type phage have been used to ensure sufficient spectrum of activity against clinical strains of bacteria (Burrowes and Harper, 2012). Such cocktails can consist of up to 20 different and unrelated phage (Abedon 2008). However, the manufacturing and testing such a large cocktail of phage can be complex.
Therefore there remains a need to provide improved bacteriophage having a broad host range for use in treating bacterial infections in medicine as well as inhibiting or preventing bacterial cell growth in medical and non-medical situations.
The present invention provides a method for producing one or more hybrid bacteriophage host range determinant (HRD) sequences, which comprises: (1) identifying at least two DNA sequences, each encoding an HRD in a series of regions in the DNA sequence, wherein the HRDs are different from one another, (2) incorporating each region into a vector in which each region is flanked by a recognition site of a restriction enzyme capable of cutting DNA at a specific cleavage site outside of the recognition sequence, so that the cleavage site of the restriction enzyme is situated at the boundary of each region, wherein the cleavage site sequences of the regions from an individual series are different from one another and wherein the cleavage site sequences at the boundaries of corresponding regions from different series are the same; (3) treating the vectors with a restriction enzyme capable of cutting DNA at a specific cleavage site outside of the recognition sequence so as to generate a mixture of the regions; and (4) treating the mixture of the regions with a ligase to ligate them to form an array of DNA sequences encoding an array of hybrid HRDs.
In an aspect the present invention provides a method for producing one or more hybrid bacteriophage host range determinant (HRD) sequences, which comprises: (1) identifying at least two DNA sequences, each encoding an HRD in a series of regions in the DNA sequence, wherein the HRDs are different from one another, (2) incorporating each region into a vector in which each region is flanked by a Type IIS or Type IIB restriction enzyme recognition site so that the cleavage site of the Type IIS or Type IIB restriction enzyme is situated at the boundary of each region, wherein the cleavage site sequences of the regions from an individual series are different from one another and wherein the cleavage site sequences at the boundaries of corresponding regions from different series are the same; (3) treating the vectors with a Type IIS or Type IIB restriction enzyme so as to generate a mixture of the regions; and (4) treating the mixture of the regions with a ligase to ligate them to form an array of DNA sequences encoding an array of hybrid HRDs
The method of the present invention allows for identifying regions of bacteriophage host range determinant (HRD) proteins which are both essential and sufficient for determining the host range conferred by an HRD protein, when such regions are incorporated into the sequence of a chimeric HRD protein, where two or more heterologous HRD proteins form the chimeric protein. In so doing, the invention provides a method for engineering bacteriophage to carry chimeric HRD proteins, so that the host specificity of the bacteriophage may be altered, for instance by one phage acquiring the host range of two or more bacteriophage upon acquisition of a single chimeric HRD protein carrying sequence from two or more heterologous HRD proteins. The method finds particular utility in creating, and selecting for, chimeric HRD proteins where regions of the HRD proteins are mixed, such that chimeric HRD proteins may be derived from two or more HRD sequences which have been split into two or more regions. The method is summarised schematically in
There are known examples of engineered phage which have gained the host range of another closely related phage, by forming hybrid HRD proteins. However, these examples have failed to broaden the host range of bacteriophage, and allowed for only insignificant recombination events, and thus are of limited use. The examples involved the use of two phage sharing a conserved protein-protein interaction region (e.g. tail attachment region), usually in the N-terminal end of the protein, with a more divergent receptor binding region, usually in the C-terminal end of the protein. Hybrid phage HRD proteins are created by swapping the divergent receptor binding region from the two phage, utilising homologous recombination. As an example, Duplessis and Moineau (2001) selected for recombinant Streptococcus thermophilus DT1 phage which were provided with the putative HRD protein gene sequence from a related phage, MD4, as a substrate for recombination. The sequencing of the HRD protein genes from the recombinant phage showed that the recombination sites lay outside of a region encoding a variable region in the C-terminus of the protein. The recombinant phage inherited the host range of the donating MD4 phage, but had lost the host range of the parent DT1 phage.
In the known example described above, the reliance upon homologous recombination to generate sequence diversity in the HRD protein gene limits the number of possible variant sequences which could be produced. There are limitations on the site at which recombination can occur—sequence identity is required, and therefore the regions swapped must be flanked by sequence homologous to the target phage. The frequency of recombination varies according to the level of identity between two sequences (lower identity causing a lower frequency of recombination) and the length of homology (shorter regions of identity leading to a lower frequency of recombination), resulting in a range of recombination frequencies of 10−5 to 10−9 recombination events per viable cell in E. coli (Watt et al., 1985). Thus the exchange of sequences within the “variant” regions of an HRD protein are unlikely, due to the low sequence homology found in these sequences, so recombination generally happens between conserved regions of the proteins only. The likelihood of more than one region of the DNA sequence being replaced by homologous recombination is extremely low as the replacement of a single section of DNA by homologous recombination requires a minimum of two recombination events, whereas to replace an additional section of DNA would require another two recombination events, and thus four in total. Thus methods which rely solely upon recombination for generating chimeric HRD proteins, such as those described, are only likely to return recombinant phage carrying HRD proteins with a single region of variable sequence replaced by the corresponding region from a related HRD protein: there is little chance of genetic exchange, and hence chimera formation, within the DNA sequences encoding the variable regions of HRD proteins. The methods described in the art are likely to give rise to chimeric HRD proteins where a single section of heterologous sequence has been exchanged to create chimeras from a maximum of 2 donor HRD protein genes
On the other hand, it has surprisingly been found that, using the method of the present invention, bacteriophage can be created which carry the host range of two or more bacteriophage, gaining the host range of the phage donating HRD sequences, thereby broadening or otherwise improving the host range.
The method of the present invention generates phage carrying genes encoding chimeric HRD proteins, where the variable region of the chimeric HRD protein consists of two or more variable region sequences from two or more phage. This method relies upon the use of a restriction enzyme that is capable of recognising a specific DNA sequence, i.e. its recognition sequence, and cleaving DNA at a specific cleavage site outside of the recognition sequence. The term “restriction enzyme” will be used hereafter in the present specification to mean a “restriction enzyme that is capable of recognising a specific DNA sequence, i.e. its recognition sequence, and cleaving DNA at a specific cleavage site outside of the recognition sequence”. In an aspect, the restriction enzyme is a Type IIS or Type JIB restriction enzyme. Type IIS restriction enzymes cut the DNA at a specific location outside of its recognition site. Type IIB restriction enzymes cut the DNA at specific locations outside of and on both sides of its recognition site. The restriction enzyme is used in accordance with the present method to create libraries of HRD gene sequences, such that selected sections of the HRD gene sequences may be combined in an ordered manner, independently of DNA homology (sequence identity), from 2 or more HRD gene sequences, from 2 or more phage. The library of chimeric HRD gene sequences may be used to create a library of recombinant phage, and methods are provided to select recombinant phage possessing the combined host range conferred by the component HRD proteins. Homologous recombination occurs between the conserved sequences flanking the chimeric variable regions, and thus the generation of sequence variation in regions of the HRD gene encoding the variable protein sequences is dependent upon the random joining of fragments by ligation, rather than being dependent upon multiple recombination events. In an aspect, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 or more DNA sequences are identified in step (1). The method is based upon a Golden Gate shuffling technique (Engler et al., 2009), which describes the shuffling of the DNA coding sequences of 3 different trypsinogens.
In an aspect, at least two DNA sequences may be identified by HRD nucleotide sequence alignment, HRD amino acid sequence alignment or HRD protein structure alignment. The method of the present invention finds particular utility in the creation of libraries from genes for HRD proteins with amino acid sequence homology; alternatively the method is particularly useful for the creation of chimeric analogous proteins, which are not necessarily homologous in DNA or protein sequence, but which may be aligned utilising structure-based alignment algorithms, where regions of conserved protein sequence or structure may be identified. Proteins may be aligned using programmes which make alignments based upon sequence similarity (e.g. BLAST, Needle (EMBOSS) or Clustal Omega) or based upon structural alignments (e.g. TM-Align). Providing the HRD protein sequences or structures can be aligned, DNA coding sequences for the proteins may be aligned without the requirement of DNA sequence homology. The aligned sequences may be split into 2 or more regions. In an aspect, the sequences are split into 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 or more regions. Such regions may be chosen according to sequence or structural characteristics. For instance, regions may be identified which are similar or dissimilar (according to protein sequence homology or structural similarity). Alternatively, regions of the protein may be chosen arbitrarily.
In an aspect, the restriction enzyme recognition sites may be added to each region. Each region may be flanked by a unique sequence, which may be a 3, 4 or 5 (or more) base pair (bp) sequence (depending on the particular restriction enzyme), which acts as the cut site for a restriction enzyme when such regions are cloned into a suitable plasmid vector.
In an aspect, the Type IIS restriction enzyme may selected from BsaI, BpiI, BcoDI, BbvI, BbsI, BsmAI, BsmFI, FokI, SfaNI, BfuAI, BsmBI, BspMI, BtgZI, Esp3I and isoschizomers of these enzymes. These are examples of Type IIS restriction enzymes which yield a 4 base overhang upon digestion. The Type IIS restriction enzyme may also be selected from EarI, BspQI, SapI, and isoschizomers of these enzymes. These are examples of Type IIS restriction enzyme which yield a 3 base overhang upon digestion. The Type IIS restriction enzyme may also be selected from HgaI. In an aspect, the Type IIB restriction enzyme may selected from AlfI, AloI, BaeI, BsgI, BplI, BsaXI, CspCI, FalI, PpiI, PsrI and isoschizomers of these enzymes. There are many other examples of Type IIB and Type IIS restriction enzymes which could be suitable for use in the method of the present invention. Such enzymes can be found listed on the websites of molecular biology reagent companies such as New England Biolabs or Thermo Scientific.
The use of restriction enzymes allows the cut site to be chosen within the HRD DNA sequence regions, as the recognition site can be added in sequences flanking these regions, upon cloning. Alternatively, the recognition sites can be added by incorporation into PCR primers, to make PCR products which carry restriction enzyme recognition and cleavage sites.
The sequences chosen to delineate the selected regions in the DNA sequences must consist of the 3, 4 or 5 base pair sequence which will form the cleavage site of the restriction enzyme. These 3, 4 or 5 bp cleavage site sites are equivalent to the sequences Engler et al. (2009) refer to as “recombination sites”. Each 3, 4 or 5 base cleavage site must be unique for one end of each region.
In an aspect, the cleavage site sequence of at least one of the regions may be formed by changing the nucleotide base sequence of the region without changing the amino acid sequence encoded by the region. If one or more of the DNA sequences chosen does not contain an exact match to the selected 3 or 4 bp sequence, sequences may be altered without changing the coding sequence of the protein. This can be achieved by changing the base which corresponds to the “wobble” position of a 3 bp codon. The advantage of this aspect of the invention is that, together with the selection of an appropriate restriction enzyme, a restriction site may be incorporated almost at any desired position, without affecting the coding sequence of the protein.
In an aspect, the regions may be amplified or synthesised prior to incorporation into the vectors. Each region of a chosen coding sequence may be amplified by PCR or synthesised, so that restriction sites are engineered into the regions thus:
In an aspect, the amplified or synthesised sequences of each region may be cloned into a plasmid vector. Alternatively, after the recognition sites and cleavage sites are engineered into the regions as described above, for instance by way of PCR primers to provide a PCR product, sequences of each region need not be cloned into a plasmid. In this aspect the sequences of each region may be digested by the restriction enzyme as described below. In this respect, the DNA sequence comprising the recognition sites and cleavage sites and the region, such as the PCR product, may be understood to fall within the meaning of the term “vector” as defined in steps (2) and (3).
Thus a library of HRD sequences may be created, each library carrying the DNA coding sequences from 2 or more regions of each HRD protein, of which there may be 2 or more. For instance, an HRD protein could be split into 6 regions based upon sequence homology or structural similarity to other HRD proteins. In this example the 6 regions could be designated regions A, B, C, D, E and F, ordered, in this example, from the 5′ to 3′ coding sequence of the gene. Phage which provide HRD sequences for construction of DNA fragment libraries are designated “donor” phage. In this example, a library from donor phage 1 may be created, where the DNA fragments may be designated 1A, 1B, 1C, 1D, 1E and 1F. For the HRD protein of donor phage 2, a library of fragments may be created designated 2A, 2B, 2C, 2D, 2E and 2F. Phage 1 and 2 may have different host ranges. These DNA sequence may be cloned into plasmid vectors, such that the recognition sites for the restriction enzymes are located outside the coding sequence of the gene fragments (
In an aspect, the method may further comprise step (5) of incorporating each hybrid HRD from the array of hybrid HRDs into a delivery vector to form an array of delivery vectors.
In an aspect, steps (3) and (4) may be carried out in a single reaction. In another aspect, where the method further comprises step (5), steps (3), (4) and (5) may be carried out in a single reaction. This may involve adding both the restriction enzyme and ligase, and if appropriate, the delivery vector, together to a mixture of the vectors from step (2) at the same time to allow both the restriction and ligation to occur in a single reaction. In other words, the mixture of regions generated in step (3), and if appropriate, the delivery vector, may be treated with the ligase without isolating or separating the restriction enzyme from the mixture. This is advantageous, since it provides for a simplified process. Further, the lack of a separation step ensures the mixture retains all the regions produced by step (3) that may otherwise be lost or reduced during a separation step after step (3). Thus the donor plasmids are cut by the restriction enzyme, and the chimeras formed by ligation. The ligated chimeras cannot be re-cut by the restriction enzyme because the ligated sequence no longer contains the recognition site.
In an aspect, the method of the present invention may further comprise the following steps: (a) the array of delivery vectors is contacted with first host cells so as to introduce each delivery vector into a first host cell to form an array of transformed first host cells; (b) the array of transferred first host cells is infected with a target phage; (c) phage replication and recombination are effected; (d) recombinant phage are screened; and (e) recombinant phage bearing hybrid HRDs are selected.
A library of such plasmids may be constructed as described above. The number of different HRD protein chimeras that could be created can be calculated from the number of HRD protein gene sequences (H) to the power of the number of regions, or fragments (F), i.e. HF. The library of plasmids may be transferred into a bacterial host for the target phage, by standard methods such as electroporation or conjugation. The target phage may be one of the donor phage which provides HRD DNA sequence, from an identified varied region of an HRD protein, to form one component of the plasmid library. Thus, in an aspect, the target phage may comprise one of the at least two DNA sequences that encode an HRD. Alternatively, the target phage might not be a donor phage, instead only DNA sequences for HRD proteins which are homologous or analogous to the HRD protein for the target phage may be provided in the DNA fragment libraries. The host cell library may be infected by the target phage and a lysate obtained. Some of the phage in the lysate may be recombinant phage, which have acquired the chimeric HRD sequences from the plasmid library by recombination.
In an aspect, the steps (d) and (e) may comprise propagating recombinant phage on a second host cell which is a host for phage bearing a hybrid HRD and not a host for the target phage. Useful recombinant phage may be selected by screening for the formation of plaques, when the lysate is mixed with a strain or strains which are the host for one or more of the donor phage which have contributed HRD sequences to the DNA fragment libraries, but are not the normal host for the target phage. This step usefully selects against phage which have not acquired the chimeric HRD sequences from the plasmid library by recombination. In an aspect, the method of the present invention may further comprise the steps: (f) the selected recombinant phage bearing hybrid HRDs are contacted with the first host cells so as to infect the first host cells; (g) phage replication is effected; and (h) recombinant phage bearing hybrid HRDs capable of infecting the first host cell and the second host cell are selected.
In an aspect of the present invention, step (e) may comprise selecting a recombinant phage bearing hybrid HRDs which confer a host range which is broader than a host range of the target phage. In another aspect of the present invention, step (e) may comprise selecting a recombinant phage bearing hybrid HRDs which confer a host range comprising host ranges of the HRD sequences encoded by the at least two DNA sequences. In this aspect, the overall host range conferred by the hybrid HRDs may not necessarily be broader than the combined host ranges of the original HRD sequences encoded by the at least two DNA sequences, or that of the target phage. Nonetheless, it will be appreciated that this aspect is still advantageous, particularly if the overall host range covers a plurality of target bacteria which are particularly pathogenic, resistant to antibiotics, or otherwise difficult to treat, etc. In the above examples the recombinant phage may be screened on the host for Phage 1, which is not a host for Phage 2, and the host for Phage 2 which is not the host for Phage 1. The recombinant phage may be screened sequentially, by plaquing on one host, isolating phage from plaques formed on that host, and then screening these plaques on the second host. Alternatively, the recombinant phage could be screened by plaquing against the two hosts simultaneously, identifying clear plaques where the phage has been able to infect both host strains. By isolating plaques in such screens, phage can be obtained which carry chimeric HRD protein genes which convey an altered host range to the target phage, such that the chimeric HRD proteins confer the host range of both of the component HRD proteins to the chimeric HRD proteins selected. The phage HRD protein genes from the isolated phage may be PCR amplified and sequenced. Thus regions of the HRD proteins which confer a particular host range may be identified.
The above technique can be performed with more than two phage HRD sequences. For instance a library of HRD regions from 3 phage HRD proteins may be created. The desired recombinant phage may be recovered by screening against 3 host strains, where each host strain is a host for only one of the 3 phage and not the other 2. In this way, chimeric HRD proteins may be selected which are able to infect all 3 strains. Similarly 4, or more, HRD protein sequences may be selected and the technique applied.
An alternative approach would be to re-create active phage particles using an in vitro packaging system (Rosenberg et al., 1985), in combination with the DNA fragments from the plasmid library of HRD sequences, to transfect a suitable host strain to propagate the reconstituted phage. Such phage may be host range tested, in order to isolate phage with the desired characteristics, as described herein.
Another approach would be to use the DNA fragments from the library, together with the rest of the genome sequence from the target phage, to create cell-free transcription-translation system to create engineered phage particles in vitro (Shin et al., 2012). Such phage may be host range tested, in order to isolate phage with the desired characteristics, as described herein.
A further approach would be to use the DNA fragments in the plasmid library, together with the phage genome DNA, and transfecting a suitable host, to construct viable phage using a recombineering approach, such as Bacteriophage Recombineering of Electroporated DNA (BRED) (Marinelli et al., 2008). Such phage may be host range tested, in order to isolate phage with the desired characteristics, as described herein.
In a further aspect of the invention, step (e) may comprise selecting a recombinant phage bearing hybrid HRDs having a broad host range as defined by more than 50% of a collection of at least 35 and preferably more than 50 clinical isolates, from a plurality of different infection sites and including range of antibiotic resistance phenotypes.
According to the present invention it is preferred to select a recombinant phage bearing hybrid HRDs on the basis of a broadened host range. A broad host range may be defined as the ability to infect >50% of a diverse collection or clinical isolates, of at least 35 and preferably totalling >50 in number. Such isolates should be from a range of geographical locations, including Europe, the Americas, and Asia, should carry a diverse range of antibiotic resistance phenotypes, including multi-drug resistant (MDR) strains, and should be from a diverse range of infection sites, such as strains cultured from blood, lung and skin infections. Such isolates can be obtained from public strain collections such as the American Type Culture Collection (ATCC) and the National Collection of Type Cultures (NCTC).
According to the present invention, 2 or more phage are required to provide divergent HRD protein sequences. Suitable phage may be isolated by screening for phage capable of infecting a single chosen bacterial species. In this way several phage may be isolated which infect different isolates of that species. For instance, Gram negative bacteria show high degree of variation in their cell surface, where the binding receptors for phage commonly reside (Wang et al., 2010; Rakhuba et al., 2010). Bacterial strains may also be typed by the anti-sera that can be raised against their cell surface antigens, so-called serotyping (Faure et al., 2003; Lu et al., 2014). For instance, in P. aeruginosa, there are 20 serotypes (Faure et al., 2003; Lu et al., 2014). In K. pneumoniae the polysaccharide surface capsule in the major source of surface variation and an important virulence factor, and 78 capsule types have been found by molecular typing methods (Pan et al., 2013). If the use of a modified bacteriophage is as a medicine, it is advantageous for that modified bacteriophage be able to bind and infect as many different isolates of that species as possible, to address the spectrum of activity of such a modified phage for the treatment of bacterial infections. Thus, the use of HRD proteins from several phage which infect the same bacterial species, where the cumulative host range of these bacteriophage is greater than any single component bacteriophage, is advantageous.
Alternatively, this technique may be applied to create bacteriophage may be isolated which are able to infect more than one bacterial species. For instance a bacteriophage may be isolated which infects one species, and another bacteriophage may be isolated which infects another. Their host range may be mutually-exclusive. Such bacteriophage could provide HRD protein sequence which could be used, in the way described, to create modified bacteriophage to be used as medicines, where the modified bacteriophage are able to target 2 or more bacterial species, providing a broad spectrum anti-bacterial agent.
In the former case, where phage are required to target a single bacterial species, phage may be isolated by screening samples for infectivity against the chosen species. For instance, phage may be isolated which infect Pseudomonas aeruginosa, by screening for phage from environmental sources which are able to form plaques on representative P. aeruginosa strains (Gill and Hyman, 2010). Isolated phage may have their whole genomes sequenced and annotated.
The approach described in the present invention is particularly advantageous as compared to the previous approaches to broaden or improve the host range of a bacteriophage composition, such as the “cocktail” approach described previously. The present invention is useful in improving phage compositions such as the SASPject system, which is described in greater detail below. In particular, the present invention may be used to broaden the host range of a SASPject vector. A single SASPject vector could replace the need to use two or more SASPject vectors, if the host range of multiple SASPject vectors were combined and thereby broadened using the methods of the present invention. One advantage is that there would be fewer component phage to manufacture (i.e. if the host range of a single phage produced in accordance with the invention were broadened, compared to the case where the desired host range is conferred by two or more phage in a mixture). This is an important aspect of a pharmaceutical preparation: the costs of manufacture will be reduced. Further, in accordance with the invention, fewer phages, possibly just one phage, will be required to provide the equivalent breadth in host range provided by the “cocktail” approach described previously, thus reducing the complexity of a pharmaceutical preparation.
In an aspect, the HRDs may comprise tail fibre proteins. Each tail fibre protein may comprise a receptor binding region for binding to the target bacteria and a region linking the receptor binding region to the body of the bacteriophage. The receptor binding region may be a C-terminal receptor binding region and the region linking the C-terminal receptor binding region to the body of the bacteriophage may be an N-terminal region. The N-terminal region may comprise amino acids 1 to 628 of the tail fibre protein and the C-terminal region may comprise amino acids 629 to 964 of the tail fibre protein, based on the amino acid sequence of bacteriophage Phi33.
Tail fibre proteins are commonly found to be proteins responsible for the initial recognition/binding to the host bacterium, for instance in phage T4, T5 and T7 (Rakhuba et al., 2010). Alternatively other HRD may be baseplate proteins. Phage genomes may be searched for potential HRD sequences by assessing the homology of all proteins in the phage genome to known sequences, using BLAST searches.
It is advantageous to identify phage tail fibre proteins which share sequence identity of greater than 90% in the N-terminal region. For example several phage—Phi33, PTP47, PTP92 and C36—with a broad host range for P. aeruginosa strains (each of these phage infect >60%, when analysed against 260 strains), have been isolated/identified and their genomes sequenced. Analysis of the genome sequences of Phi33, PTP47, PTP92 and C36 reveals that they contain genes encoding putative tail fibre proteins with a high level of sequence identity in the N-terminal region (>95% amino acid sequence identity), following a 2 sequence BLAST alignment, compared to the Phi33 tail fibre amino acids 1-628 (amino acid identity in parentheses): C36 (96%), PTP47 (98%), PTP92 (97%). BLAST searches have shown that these 4 phages are related to 10 other deposited phage genome sequences which, together, form the family of PB1-like phage: PB1, SPM1, F8, LBL3, KPP12, LMA2, SN, JG024, NH-4, 14-1 (Ceyssens et al., 2009). The homology of these putative tail fibre proteins was assessed. Following a 2 sequence BLAST alignment, compared to the Phi33 tail fibre protein (amino acid identity in parentheses): LBL3 (96%), SPM-1 (95%), F8 (95%), PB1 (95%), KPP12 (94%), LMA2 (94%), SN (87%), 14-1 (86%), JG024 (83%), NH-4 (83%), C36 (96%), PTP47 (86%), PTP92 (83%). An alignment of all 14 of the aforementioned phage tail fibre proteins is shown in
Analysis of the annotated tail fibre protein sequences from these 14 phages reveals that the N-terminal region of the proteins—equivalent to Phi33 tail fibre amino acids 1-628—show an even higher level of sequence identity at the amino acid level than the sequence identity of these proteins over their entire length, in the range of 96-100% for all 14 proteins. Following a 2 sequence BLAST alignment, compared to the N-terminal amino acids 1-628 of the Phi33 tail fibre protein (amino acid identity in parentheses): LBL3 (96%), SPM-1 (96%), F8 (96%), PB1 (96%), KPP12 (98%), LMA2 (99%), SN (99%), 14-1 (97%), JG024 (97%), NH-4 (97%), PTP47 (98%), C36 (96%), PTP92 (97%). However, the C-terminal region of the protein—equivalent to Phi33 tail fibre amino acids 629-964—is not as conserved as the N-terminal region in some of the proteins, the range of sequence identity being typically 57-96%. Following a 2 sequence BLAST alignment, compared to the C-terminal 629-964 amino acids of the Phi33 tail fibre protein (amino acid identity in parentheses): LBL3 (94%), SPM-1 (93%), F8 (93%), PB1 (94%), KPP12 (87%), LMA2 (85%), SN (65%), 14-1 (65%), JG024 (57%), NH-4 (57%), PTP47 (64%), C36 (96%), PTP92 (57%). Analysis of phage tail fibres from other, well characterised, phage has shown that they possess an N-terminal tail base plate binding region and a C-terminal receptor binding region (Veesler and Cambillau, 2011). In experimental analysis of their bacterial strain host range, using plaque assay or growth inhibition tests, the phage Phi33, PTP47, PTP92 and C36 have overlapping but non-identical host range (
It is thus provided, according to this invention, that the genes for homologous tail fibre proteins can be taken from two or more of these exemplified phage and combined, via the methods described, to form chimeric tail fibre proteins, in particular where the C-terminal variable region of the chimeric tail fibre proteins contains sequences from two or more of these phage in a mixed fashion. In such a way, the C-terminal region of such tail fibre proteins may be delineated into 2 or more regions, and these regions may be fused together in an ordered fashion, to create variation in the C-terminal region of the protein, and allow selection of variants for improved host range.
The method of the present invention was used to select recombinant tail fibre proteins which conferred improved host range to a homologous target phage. The tail fibre DNA and protein sequences from phage PTP92 and PTP47 were aligned (
In an aspect, the recombinant phage bearing hybrid HRDs produced in accordance with the present invention are provided with a gene encoding a protein which is toxic to a target bacterium. Such a gene may encode an α/β-type small acid-soluble spore protein (SASP). The SASP is preferably a SASP-C. The SASP-C may be from Bacillus megaterium.
As an alternative to conventional antibiotics, one family of proteins which demonstrate broad spectrum antibacterial activity inside bacteria comprises the α/β-type small acid-soluble spore proteins (known as SASP). Inside bacteria, SASP bind to the bacterial DNA: visualisation of this process, using cryoelectron microscopy, has shown that SspC, the most studied SASP, coats the DNA and forms protruding domains and modifies the DNA structure (Francesconi et al., 1988; Frenkiel-Krispin et al., 2004) from B-like (pitch 3.4 nm) towards A-like (3.18 nm; A-like DNA has a pitch of 2.8 nm). The protruding SspC motifs interact with adjacent DNA-SspC filaments packing the filaments into a tight assembly of nucleo-protein helices. In 2008, Lee et al. reported the crystal structure at 2.1 {acute over (Å)} resolution of an α/β-type SASP bound to a 10-bp DNA duplex. In the complex, the α/β-type SASP adopt a helix-turn-helix motif, interact with DNA through minor groove contacts, bind to approximately 6 bp of DNA as a dimer and the DNA is in an A-B type conformation. In this way DNA replication is halted and, where bound, SASP prevent DNA transcription. SASP bind to DNA in a non-sequence specific manner (Nicholson et al., 1990) so that mutations in the bacterial DNA do not affect the binding of SASP. Sequences of α/ß-type SASP may be found in appendix 1 of WO02/40678, including SASP-C from Bacillus megaterium which is the preferred a/B-type SASP. WO02/40678 describes the use as an antimicrobial agent of bacteriophage modified to incorporate a SASP gene.
Bacteriophage vectors modified to contain a SASP gene have generally been named SASPject vectors. Once the SASP gene has been delivered to a target bacterium, SASP is produced inside those bacteria where it binds to bacterial DNA and changes the conformation of the DNA from B-like towards A-like. Production of sufficient SASP inside target bacterial cells causes a drop in viability of affected cells.
In particularly preferred embodiments, the method of the present invention may be used to engineer improved SASPject vectors carrying chimeric tail fibre genes, created and selected by this method, together with a SASP gene under the control of a selected promoter. Such SASPject vectors would have improved host range in comparison to the wild-type, unmodified, bacteriophage upon which they are based.
The SASP gene may be chosen from any one of the genes encoding the SASP disclosed in Appendix 1 of WO02/40678. In a preferred arrangement the SASP is SASP-C. The SASP-C may be from Bacillus megaterium.
In one aspect, the term ‘SASP’ as used in the present specification refers to a protein with α/β-type SASP activity, that is, the ability to bind to DNA and modify its structure from its B-like form towards its A-like form, and not only covers the proteins listed in appendix 1 of WO02/40678, but also any homologues thereof, as well as any other protein also having α/β-type SASP activity. In an alternative aspect, the term ‘SASP’ as used in the specification refers to any protein listed in appendix 1 of WO02/40678, or any homologue having at least 70%, 75%, 80%, 85%, 90%, 92%, 94%, 95%, 96%, 98% or 99% sequence identity with any one of the proteins listed in appendix 1 of WO02/40678. In another alternative aspect, the term ‘SASP’ as used in the specification refers to any protein listed in appendix 1 of WO02/40678.
It is preferred that the SASP gene is under the control of a constitutive promoter which is advantageously sufficiently strong to drive production of toxic levels of SASP when the modified bacteriophage is present in multiple copies in the target bacterium. Useful constitutive promoters include pdhA for pyruvate dehydrogenase E1 component alpha sub units, rpsB for the 30S ribosomal protein S2, pgi for glucose-6-phosphate isomerase and the fructose bisphosphate aldolase gene promoter fda/fba. Preferred regulated promoters, active during infection, are lasB for elastase. These promoters are typically from P. aeruginosa. Promoters having a sequence showing at least 90% sequence identity to these promoter sequences may also be used.
Summary of a method for the genetic modification of a bacteriophage such that it carries chimeric tail fibre variants that confer a desired altered host range.
As an example only, it is shown here how the amino acid sequences of phage host range determinants, such as those from PTP92 and PTP47 may be aligned, and how the regions of conservation and variation thus identified may be used to divide one of the HRD-encoding genes (such as that from PTP92) into several modules. The sequence alignment can then be used to divide any other HRD-encoding genes under consideration (in this example, PTP47) into positionally-corresponding modules.
It is shown how the HRD modules thus defined from PTP92 and PTP47 may each be flanked by TypeIIS (BsaI) restriction sites and suitable cleavage sites (cs). It is then shown how a plasmid library consisting of every possible combination of PTP92 and PTP47 HRD modules may be constructed by Golden Gate assembly, to form a plasmid library of chimeric HRDs.
There are several ways in which phages carrying non-native genetic DNA sequences can be constructed and the following is an example of such methods. One way in which genes can be removed and added to the phage genome is by using homologous recombination. Here, it is shown, as an example, how the chimeric HRDs can be cloned in between a Phi33 sequence located immediately upstream of the corresponding identified variable region of the Phi33 HRD, and another Phi33 sequence located immediately downstream of the corresponding Phi33 HRD. These Phi33 sequences can act as regions of homology for homologous recombination with Phi33 bacteriophage. The resulting plasmid library of chimeric HRDs cloned in between Phi33 regions of homology can then be transferred to a P. aeruginosa strain that is a host for Phi33, PTP92 and PTP47.
To isolate Phi33 derivatives which have undergone recombination with the chimeric HRDs library, a Phi33 lysate may be made on a mixed culture of P. aeruginosa, each cell of which carries a representative of the chimeric HRDs library, and where each representative of the chimeric HRDs library is present in the mixed culture. The resulting lysate may then be propagated on a P. aeruginosa strain that is a host for PTP92, but not Phi33 or PTP47, to isolate recombinant phage that have acquired the plaquing ability of PTP92. A second round of phage propagation may be carried on the same PTP92 host P. aeruginosa strain to enrich the resulting lysate for the desired recombinant phage that have acquired the plaquing ability of PTP92. This second lysate may then be plagued on a P. aeruginosa strain that is a host for PTP47, but not Phi33 or PTP47, as a means of isolating recombinant phage that have acquired the plaquing ability of PTP47. After plaque purification on the same PTP47 host P. aeruginosa strain, individual plaques may then be tested for plaquing on the P. aeruginosa strain that is a host for PTP92, but not PTP47 or Phi33. Phages that plaque on both the PTP47 discriminatory host and the PTP92 discriminatory host have acquired the host range of both PTP47 and PTP92, and are likely to carry genes encoding chimeric HRD proteins. The HRD region from phage thus identified may be amplified by PCR and sequenced, or alternatively genomic DNA from the phage may be isolated and submitted to whole genome sequencing, to identify the sequence of the chimeric HRD that confers the desired dual host range of PTP92 and PTP47 upon the recombinant Phi33 derivatives.
PCR reactions to generate DNA for cloning purposes may be carried out using Herculase II Fusion DNA polymerase (Agilent Technologies), depending upon the melting temperatures (Tm) of the primers, according to manufacturer's instructions. Alternatively, DNA for cloning may be obtained via custom DNA synthesis, for example by GenScript or DNA 2.0. PCR reactions for screening purposes may be carried out using Taq DNA polymerase (NEB), depending upon the Tm of the primers, according to manufacturer's instructions. Unless otherwise stated, general molecular biology techniques, such as restriction enzyme digestion, agarose gel electrophoresis, T4 DNA ligase-dependent ligations, competent cell preparation and transformation may be based upon methods described in Sambrook et al., (1989). Enzymes may be purchased from New England Biolabs or Thermo Scientific. DNA may be purified from enzyme reactions and prepared from cells using Qiagen DNA purification kits. Plasmids may be transferred from E. coli strains to P. aeruginosa strains by conjugation, mediated by the conjugation helper strain E. coli HB101 (pRK2013). A chromogenic substrate for β-galactosidase, S-gal, that upon digestion by β-galactosidase forms a black precipitate when chelated with ferric iron, may be purchased from Sigma (S9811).
Primers may be obtained from Sigma Life Science. Where primers include recognition sequences for restriction enzymes, additional 2-6 nucleotides may be added at the 5′ end to ensure digestion of the PCR-amplified DNA.
Standard clonings may be achieved by ligating DNAs overnight with T4 DNA ligase and then transforming them into E. coli cloning strains, such as DH5a or TOP10, with isolation on selective medium, as described elsewhere (Sambrook et al., 1989). Clonings involving TypeIIS restriction enzymes may be achieved by incubating the DNAs simultaneously with T4 DNA ligase and with the relevant TypeIIS restriction enzyme, in T4 DNA ligase buffer, using a thermal cycler programmed as follows:
An E. coli/P. aeruginosa broad host range vector, such as pSM1484A, may be used to transfer genetic material between E. coli and P. aeruginosa. This type of vector is otherwise known as a delivery vector. Plasmid pSM1484A is a previously engineered construct carrying a broad-host-range, low copy origin of replication from a P. aeruginosa plasmid, an E. coli-specific high-copy origin of replication from plasmid pUC19, the oriT origin of transfer from plasmid RP4, a tetracycline resistance marker, and sequence modified from phage Phi33. The latter sequence comprises the conserved region of Phi33's HRD, silently mutated to suppress an intrinsic BsaI site, followed by a CTCGtGAGACC (SEQ ID NO: 1) BsaI site containing cs1 (CTCG), a lacZa reporter gene, a second BsaI site GGTCTCaAATG (SEQ ID NO: 2) containing cs7 (AATG), and finally sequence from Phi33 corresponding to sequence downstream of the HRD gene's stop codon in the native genome.
Detection of Phi33-like phage (PB1-like phage family) conserved N-terminal tail fibre regions by PCR 1. Primers for the detection of Phi33-like phage-like tail fibre genes in experimental phage samples may be designed as follows:
The DNA sequences of the tail fibre genes from all sequenced Phi33-like phage (including Phi33, PB1, NH-4, 14-1, LMA2, KPP12, JG024, F8, SPM-1, LBL3, PTP47, C36, PTP92 and SN) may be aligned using Clustal Omega, which is available on the EBI website, and the approximately 2 kb-long highly conserved region mapping to the gene's 5′ sequence may be thus identified (positions 31680-33557 in the PB1 genome sequence, Acc. EU716414). Sections of 100% identity among the 11 tail fibre gene sequences may be identified by visual inspection. Three pairs of PCR primers targeting selected absolutely conserved regions, and amplifying PCR products no longer than 1 kb may be chosen as follows: pair B4500 and B4501, defining a 193 bp-long region; pair B4502 and B4503, defining a 774 bp-long region; and pair B4504 and B4505, defining a 365 bp-long region.
Primer B4500 consists of sequence of PB1 phage genome (Acc. EU716414) ranging from position 31680 to 31697. Primer B4501 consists of sequence of PB1 phage genome (Acc. EU716414) ranging from position 31851 to 31872. Primer B4502 consists of sequence of PB1 phage genome (Acc. EU716414) ranging from position 31785 to 31804. Primer B4503 consists of sequence of PB1 phage genome (Acc. EU716414) ranging from position 32541 to 32558. Primer B4504 consists of sequence of PB1 phage genome (Acc. EU716414) ranging from position 32868 to 32888. Primer B4505 consists of sequence of PB1 phage genome (Acc. EU716414) ranging from position 33213 to 33232.
2. Phi33-like tail fibre genes may be detected in experimental phage samples as follows:
Plaques of isolated phage of environmental origin may be picked from agar plates and added to water and incubated for 30 minutes, making plaque soak outs. The plaque soak outs may be diluted and a portion added to PCR reactions containing one or all of the above primer pairs, and PCR may be performed according to a standard protocol. PCR products may be visualised on a 1.5% agarose gel with ethidium bromide staining, and evaluated for their size. PCR products of the correct size for the primer pair used may be gel-extracted and submitted to an external facility for sequencing. Sequencing results may be compared with the available tail fibre gene sequences in order to confirm the identity of the PCR product.
An example of the construction of chimeric HRDs from two parental HRDs.
Selection of Module Boundaries
Design and Cloning of Module Sequences
Construction of a Plasmid Library Containing Chimeric HRD, and Subsequent Transfer to E. coli
Where
M is the sequence length of the module plasmid (or DNA fragment length, if linear DNA molecules are being used instead of plasmids) in base pairs
A is the sequence length of the delivery vector in base pairs
Q is the quantity of module plasmid (or linear DNA fragment, if these are being used instead of plasmids) required in ng
P is the amount of delivery vector being used in the reaction in ng
N is the number of alternatives available for each module
Taking pSMG1 as an example,
M=2894 bp
A=14039 bp
P may be fixed at 200 ng, as described above
N=2 (in this example, there are two alternatives for the module, i.e. module 1A and module 2A, originating from the HRD of PTP92 and PTP47 respectively).
Quantity of pSMG1 required per 200 ng of delivery vector,
Generation of Phage Carrying Chimeric HRD, Via Recombination with the Plasmid Library
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
1606013.9 | Apr 2016 | GB | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/EP2017/058468 | 4/7/2017 | WO | 00 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2017/174809 | 10/12/2017 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
6310191 | Collins et al. | Oct 2001 | B1 |
20100239536 | Fairhead | Sep 2010 | A1 |
20150064770 | Lu et al. | Mar 2015 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
102010013834 | Dec 2010 | DE |
1 384 779 | Jan 2004 | EP |
2451750 | Feb 2009 | GB |
1998033901 | Aug 1998 | WO |
2002007742 | Jan 2002 | WO |
2002040678 | May 2002 | WO |
2004113375 | Dec 2004 | WO |
2009019293 | Feb 2009 | WO |
2016055584 | Apr 2016 | WO |
2016055585 | Apr 2016 | WO |
2016055586 | Apr 2016 | WO |
2016055587 | Apr 2016 | WO |
Entry |
---|
Lin TY, et al. “A T3 and T7 recombinant phage acquires efficient adsorption and a broader host range,” PLoS One. 2012;7(2):e30954. |
Le S, et al. “Mapping the tail fiber as the receptor binding protein responsible for differential host specificity of Pseudomonas aeruginosa bacteriophages PaP1 and JG004,” PLoS One. Jul. 9, 2013;8(7):e68562. |
Pitts K, et al. “SASPject: Efficacy of SASPject against Pseudomonas aeruginosa ATCC 27853 in a Mouse Lung Model,” 54th ICAAC, 2014. http://www.phicotx.co.uklwp-contentluploadsl2014/12/F1551.pdf. |
Yoichi M, et al. “Alteration of tail fiber protein gp38 enables T2 phage to infect Escherichia coli O157:H7,” J Biotechnol. Jan. 12, 2005;115(1):101-7. |
Yu P, et al. “Isolation of Polyvalent Bacteriophages by Sequential Multiple-Host Approaches,” Appl Environ Microbiol. Nov. 20, 2015;82(3):808-15. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20190093100 A1 | Mar 2019 | US |