Patent Grant
11170905
The present invention belongs to the field of the materials employed in the nuclear field, in particular materials intended to exhibit the best possible resistance to the physicochemical conditions encountered under nominal conditions and during an accident scenario of a nuclear reactor, such as, for example a Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) or a Boiling Water Reactor (BWR), or a reactor of “Canadian Deuterium Uranium” (CANDU) type.
The invention relates more particularly to nuclear fuel claddings, to their processes of manufacture and uses against oxidation and/or hydriding.
The constituent zirconium alloy of nuclear fuel claddings oxidizes on contact with the water constituting the coolant of PWR or BWR or of CANDU type nuclear reactors.
As the oxide formed is brittle and the take-up of hydrogen associated with the oxidation results in the precipitation of zirconium hydrides which cause embrittlement, the lifetime of the claddings is in large part limited by the maximum thickness of oxide acceptable and the content of associated absorbed hydrogen. In order to guarantee satisfactory residual mechanical properties of the cladding targeted at ensuring an optimum confinement of the nuclear fuel, the residual thickness of healthy and ductile zirconium alloy has to be sufficient and the fraction of hydrides sufficiently limited.
The possibility of limiting or of delaying such an oxidation and/or the hydriding may thus prove to be crucial in accident conditions.
These conditions are, for example, reached in the case of hypothetical accident scenarios of the RIA (“Reactivity Insertion Accident”) or LOCA (Loss Of Coolant Accident) type, indeed even in conditions of dewatering of the spent fuel storage pool. They are characterized, among others, by high temperatures which are generally greater than 700° C., in particular between 800° C. and 1200° C., and which may be reached with a high rate of rise in temperature. At such temperatures, the coolant is in the form of steam.
The oxidation in accident conditions is much more critical than in conditions of normal operation of the nuclear reactor, as the deterioration in the cladding, the first barrier for confinement of the fuel, is faster and the associated risks greater. These risks are, among others, as follows:
In view of these risks, it is essential to limit as far as possible the high temperature oxidation and/or hydriding of the cladding in order to improve the safety of nuclear reactors using, among others, water as coolant.
The solution proposed by the patent application “WO 2013/160587” consists in producing a nuclear fuel cladding in which the zirconium-based substrate is covered with a multilayer coating comprising metal layers composed of chromium, of a chromium alloy and/or of a ternary alloy of the Nb—Cr—Ti system.
Nevertheless, additional experiments have shown that the resistance to high-temperature oxidation, although improved with respect to the prior claddings, proves to be insufficient at very high temperature, typically for temperatures of greater than or equal to 1200° C. when the deposition of the multilayer coating on the zirconium-based substrate was carried out by a process of physical vapor deposition (PVD) by magnetron cathode sputtering of conventional type.
These very high temperatures lie at the extreme of, indeed even beyond, those of the high temperatures between 700° C. and 1200° C. which are set by accident regulatory conditions.
In point of fact, the regulatory criteria governing the dimensioning accidents according to the scenario of “LOCA” type defined from the 1970s require that the maximum temperature of the cladding does not exceed 1204° C. (2200° F.) and a maximum degree of “ECR” oxidation of 17%.
The degree of “ECR” (“Equivalent Cladding Reacted”) oxidation is the percentage of thickness of metal cladding converted into zirconia (ZrO2) resulting from the oxidation of the zirconium contained in the nuclear fuel cladding, it being assumed that all the oxygen which has reacted forms stoichiometric zirconia.
In order to take into account the additional embrittling effect related to the in service hydriding of the cladding, this acceptable residual degree of “ECR” oxidation may henceforth be much lower than 17% under certain conditions, such as, for example, a cladding hydrided in service up to several hundred ppm by weight, which corresponds in practice to a duration of oxidation of the cladding which should not exceed a few minutes at 1200° C.
An improvement in the resistance to oxidation and/or hydriding at very high temperature would advantageously make it possible to obtain additional margins of safety, among others by preventing or delaying all the more the deterioration in the cladding in the event of aggravation or of persistence of the accident situation.
One of the aims of the invention is thus to prevent or to alleviate one or more of the disadvantages described above by providing a nuclear fuel cladding and a process for the manufacture thereof which makes it possible to improve the resistance to oxidation and/or hydriding, among others in the presence of steam.
Another aim of the invention is to improve this resistance to oxidation and/or hydriding at very high temperature, namely above 1200° C., particularly between 1200° C. and 1400° C., more particularly between 1200° C. and 1300° C.; among others when these temperatures are reached with a rate of rise in temperature which is between 0.1° C./second and 300° C./second.
Another aim of the invention is to improve the duration of the resistance to oxidation and/or hydriding, beyond which duration the confinement of the nuclear fuel is no longer certain.
The present invention thus relates to a process for the manufacture of a nuclear fuel cladding comprising i) a substrate containing a zirconium-based internal layer coated or not coated with at least one interposed layer placed over the internal layer and ii) at least one external layer placed over the substrate and composed of a protective material chosen from chromium or a chromium alloy; the process comprising the following successive steps:
a) ion etching of the surface of the substrate;
b) deposition of the at least one external layer over the substrate with a high power impulse magnetron sputtering (HiPIMS) process in which the magnetron cathode is composed of the protective material.
The nuclear fuel cladding thus manufactured can be composite (presence of an interposed layer) or not.
In comparison with the processes of the state of the art, the manufacturing process of the invention has among others the distinctive feature that it uses a high power impulse magnetron sputtering (HiPIMS) process in order to deposit, according to step b), the at least one chromium-based external layer over the zirconium-based internal layer. Such a process is known to a person skilled in the art and described, for example, in the document “Techniques de l'ingénieur, La pulvérisation cathodique magnétron en régime d'impulsions de haute puissance (HiPIMS) pulvérisation cathodique magnétron, Réference IN207” [Techniques of the Engineer, Magnetron cathode sputtering under high power impulse conditions (HiPIMS) magnetron sputtering, Reference IN207].
The HiPIMS sputtering process differs in a number of aspects from conventional magnetron cathode sputtering processes.
In accordance with the conventional magnetron cathode sputtering process as used in “WO 2013/160587” (mentioned hereinbelow as conventional magnetron PVD process), a difference in potential is applied between a negatively polarized chromium target (magnetron cathode) and the walls of the cathode sputtering reactor which are connected to earth.
For this type of process, the continuous polarization voltage applied to the target is typically between −600 V and −200 V. The discharge current is a few amperes.
Under these conditions, the rarefied atmosphere, generally composed of argon, is then partially ionized and forms a cold plasma. It then essentially comprises argon atoms Ar and a low proportion of argon ions Ar+, but no metal ions or metal ions in an infinitesimal amount far below 10−6. The Ar+ ions are subsequently accelerated by the electric field of the target, which they impact, which results in the ejection of chromium atoms which are deposited on the substrate to be coated which generally faces the target.
The HiPIMS sputtering process differs in particular from the conventional magnetron PVD process used in “WO 2013/160587” in several characteristics, among others:
Unexpectedly, the inventors have discovered that a nuclear fuel cladding obtained by the manufacturing process of the invention made it possible to confer on it an improved resistance to oxidation and/or hydriding, in particular at very high temperature, among others in the presence of steam.
Such properties cannot be anticipated from the viewpoint of the specific chemical and metallurgical qualities of zirconium and the zirconium alloys used for nuclear applications, among others their chemical composition, surface condition, crystal texture, final metallurgical state (work-hardened or more or less recrystallized), which properties are liable to influence the quality and the behavior of the coatings.
In particular, the α phase of a zirconium alloy (denoted “Zr-α”, of compact hexagonal crystallographic structure) at low temperature is converted into the β phase (denoted “β-Zr”, of cubic centered crystallographic structure) in a temperature range typically ranging from 700° C. to 1000° C. On changing from the Zr-α structure to the β-Zr cubic structure, the alloy undergoes local dimensional variations. These variations are a priori unfavorable to the mechanical strength of an external layer which would cover a zirconium-based internal layer, due among others to the incompatibility in their coefficients of expansion. These difficulties of adhesion are accentuated by the mechanisms of diffusion of chemical entities, which are faster in the β-Zr phase than in the Zr-α phase, and which may modify the interface between the substrate and its coating.
The invention also relates to a nuclear fuel cladding (composite or not) obtained or obtainable by the manufacturing process of the invention.
The invention also relates to a composite nuclear fuel cladding comprising i) a substrate containing a zirconium-based internal layer and at least one interposed layer placed over the internal layer and composed of at least one interposed material chosen from tantalum, molybdenum, tungsten, niobium, vanadium, hafnium or their alloys and ii) at least one external layer placed over the substrate and composed of a protective material chosen from chromium or a chromium alloy.
In this case, the interposed material or the protective material may be respectively deposited on the internal layer or on the substrate by any type of process, for example a process of physical vapor deposition by magnetron cathode sputtering different from the HiPIMS sputtering process, or by a high power impulse magnetron sputtering (HiPIMS) such as described, among others in its alternative forms, in the present description wherein the magnetron cathode is composed of the interposed material or of the protective material.
The internal layer of the composite nuclear fuel cladding can be composed of a zirconium alloy comprising, by weight, from 100 ppm to 3000 ppm of iron, the cladding comprising an interface layer positioned between the internal layer and the external layer and composed of an interfacial material comprising at least one intermetallic compound chosen from ZrCr2 of cubic crystal structure, Zr(Fe,Cr)2 of hexagonal crystal structure or ZrFe2 of cubic crystal structure. Naturally, it is in particular positioned between the internal layer and the first external layer.
The interface layer is formed during the HiPIMS deposition according to step b) of the external layer on the substrate in the absence of at least one interposed layer placed over the internal layer and when the constituent zirconium alloy of the internal layer comprises, by weight, from 100 ppm to 3000 ppm of iron.
Unexpectedly, it does not damage the adhesion of the external layer with regard to the substrate, whereas intermetallic compounds are known for their mechanical properties of brittle type.
Furthermore, under oxidation in the presence of steam, at high temperature, indeed even very high temperature (for example at 1200° C.), the inventors have found that the interfacial layer predominantly or completely comprising at least one intermetallic compound thickens. Here again, unexpectedly, no generalized exfoliation is found, despite the assumed intrinsic brittleness of an intermetallic compound and the interfacial stresses which theoretically may develop during the manufacturing steps, indeed even subsequently in service and/or in nominal conditions or certain accident conditions. See, for example, example 2.4
Preferably, the interface layer has a mean thickness of 10 nm to 1 μm.
These types of nuclear fuel claddings according to the invention, namely obtained or liable to be obtained by the manufacturing process of the invention, composite or noncomposite or with an interface layer, may be provided according to one or more of the alternative forms described in the present description for the abovementioned manufacturing process of the invention, among others the alternative forms relating to the structure and/or to the composition of a nuclear fuel cladding.
These alternative forms relate among others and not exclusively to: the internal layer, the internal coating, the composition of the zirconium alloy or of the chromium alloy, the structure of the external layer, such as are described in detail in the present description, among others the description of the manufacturing process of the invention.
The geometry of these claddings is such that they may be provided in the form of a tube, or of a plate resulting more particularly from the assembling of two subunits.
The invention also relates to a process for the manufacture of a composite nuclear fuel cladding, comprising the following successive steps:
A) production of a substrate by deposition, on a zirconium-based internal layer, of at least one interposed layer composed of at least one interposed material chosen from tantalum, molybdenum, tungsten, niobium, vanadium, hafnium or their alloys;
B) deposition, on the substrate, of at least one external layer composed of a protective material chosen from chromium or a chromium alloy.
The deposition according to step A) and/or B) can be carried out by a physical vapor deposition or a pulsed electrolysis.
The physical vapor deposition may be a cathode sputtering, more particularly of magnetron type, still more particularly an HiPIMS sputtering process preferably according to one or more of the characteristics shown in the present description.
When the interposed layer is composed of hafnium, its thickness is from 1 nm to 1 μm.
The invention also relates to the use of these types of claddings, for combating oxidation and/or hydriding in a humid atmosphere comprising water, in particular in the form of steam.
The invention also relates to the use of these types of claddings (in particular the composite nuclear fuel cladding), for combating hydriding in a hydrogenated atmosphere comprising hydrogen, in particular an atmosphere comprising more than 50 mole % of hydrogen and/or water, in particular in the form of steam.
The humid atmosphere or the hydrogenated atmosphere may further comprise an additional gas chosen from air, nitrogen, carbon dioxide or their mixtures.
Preferably, the purpose of these uses is to combat oxidation and/or hydriding:
In the present description of the invention, a verb such as “to comprise”, “to incorporate”, “to include”, “to contain”, “composed of” and its conjugated forms are open terms and thus do not exclude the presence of additional element(s) and/or step(s) which are added to the initial element(s) and/or step(s) stated after these terms. However, these open terms are targeted in addition at a specific embodiment in which only the initial element(s) and/or step(s), with the exclusion of any other, are targeted; in which case, the open term is targeted in addition at the closed term “to consist of”, “to constitute ” and its conjugated forms.
The expression “and/or” is targeted at connecting elements for the purpose of simultaneously denoting just one of these elements, both elements, indeed even their mixture or their combination.
The use of the indefinite article “one” or “a” for an element or a step does not exclude, unless otherwise mentioned, the presence of a plurality of elements or steps.
Any reference sign in brackets in the claims should not be interpreted as limiting the scope of the invention.
Furthermore, unless otherwise indicated, the values of the limits are included in the ranges of parameters shown and the temperatures shown are considered for an implementation at atmospheric pressure.
The manufacturing processes of the invention are targeted at producing a nuclear fuel cladding (composite or not) comprising:
i) a substrate containing a zirconium-based internal layer intended to be in contact with or facing the nuclear fuel, the internal layer being coated or not with at least one interposed layer; and
ii) at least one chromium-based external layer placed over the substrate and intended to protect the cladding with regard to the exterior environment, in particular the coolant.
As previously mentioned, the alternative embodiments described hereinafter, among others the alternative forms relating to the structure and/or to the composition of a nuclear fuel cladding are also alternative forms for all the types of nuclear fuel claddings of the present description.
Preferably, at least one interposed layer is placed between the internal layer and the external layer with regard to which layers it acts as diffusion barrier. In this embodiment, the substrate is formed by the combination of the internal layer and of the at least one interposed layer.
The cladding may also comprise an internal coating placed under the internal layer, the thickness of which is, for example, between 50 μm and 150 μm. The internal coating may comprise one or more layers. It constitutes an internal “liner” which improves the strength of the cladding with regard to the physicochemical and mechanical interactions with the fuel. It is generally obtained by hot coextrusion during the manufacture of the internal layer.
The internal layer is zirconium-based, namely that it is composed of zirconium to more than 50% by weight, particularly more than 90%, indeed even more than 95%.
More specifically, the internal layer and/or the internal coating is composed of zirconium or of a zirconium alloy. The zirconium alloy may comprise, by weight:
The zirconium alloy is, for example, Zircaloy-2 or Zircaloy-4.
The zirconium alloy may in particular be chosen from an alloy meeting the constraints of the nuclear field, for example Zircaloy-2, Zircaloy-4, Zirlo™, Optimized-Zirlo™ or M5™. The compositions of these alloys are such that they comprise, by weight, for example:
The at least one external layer placed over the substrate is composed of a protective material chosen from chromium or a chromium alloy, in particular any chromium alloy capable of being used in the nuclear field and/or under irradiation.
More particularly, the chromium alloy composing the protective material may comprise at least one alloying element chosen from silicon, yttrium or aluminum, for example at a content of 0.1% to 20% by atoms.
The at least one external layer optionally has a columnar structure.
Preferably, the constituent columnar grains of the columnar structure have a mean diameter of 100 nm to 10 μm.
The at least one chromium-based external layer is deposited over the substrate with the manufacturing process of the invention according to the following successive steps:
a) ion etching of the surface of the substrate;
b) deposition over the substrate of the at least one external layer with a high power impulse magnetron sputtering (HiPIMS) process.
The magnetron cathode constituting the target is then composed of the protective material.
Steps a) and b) are carried out over the final layer of the substrate, namely over the zirconium-based internal layer or over the final interposed layer, according to whether the substrate respectively contains an internal layer coated or not coated with at least one interposed layer.
In order to place at least one interposed layer over the internal layer, it is possible to carry out the following successive steps carried out before the etching step a):
a′) ion etching of the surface of the internal layer;
b′) production of a substrate by deposition of the at least one interposed layer over the internal layer with a high power impulse magnetron sputtering (HiPIMS) process in which the magnetron cathode is composed of the at least one interposed material.
This embodiment constitutes a specific case of the process for the manufacture of the composite nuclear fuel cladding according to the invention in that the at least one interposed layer is deposited with an HiPIMS sputtering process.
The distance separating the substrate and the magnetron cathode used according to the etching step a) or a′) and/or the deposition step b) or b′) may be between 40 mm and 150 mm.
The ion etching according to step a) and/or a′) may be carried out with an HiPIMS etching process or a cathodic arc etching process.
The use of the HiPIMS sputtering process according to step b) or b′) requires the establishment of a polarization voltage using polarization impulses which are applied to the target present in the cathode sputtering reactor.
The magnetron cathode may be a flat cathode, or a hollow cathode for example a cylindrical cathode.
The ranges of values which follow relating to the polarization voltages and the polarization impulses are given by way of indication for a magnetron cathode with a surface area of 300 cm2. A person skilled in the art may in particular adjust the values shown for the polarization impulses applied to the magnetron cathode in order to observe the recommended power density range, it being known that the polarization voltage to be applied varies inversely in proportion to the surface area of the target.
The HiPIMS etching process used in step a) and/or a′) may comprise the polarization of the magnetron cathode with a voltage of between −1000 V and −500 V.
The cathodic arc etching process according to step a) and/or a′) may comprise the polarization of an arc cathode with a voltage of between −20 V and −50 V or according to an intensity of 50 A to 250 A.
The HiPIMS or cathodic arc etching process according to step a) and/or a′) may comprise the polarization of the substrate with a voltage of between −800 V and −600 V.
The Cr+ ions produced during step a) and/or a′) etch the surface of the substrate for the purpose of improving the adhesion of the external layer to be deposited.
The HiPIMS sputtering process according to step b) and/or b′) generally comprises the maintenance of the polarization of the magnetron cathode or so that the voltage remains between −1000 V and −500 V.
The polarization of the substrate is for its part decreased with respect to the step of etching according to step a) and/or a′), for example so that the HiPIMS sputtering process according to step b) and/or b′) comprises the polarization of the substrate with a voltage of between −200 V and 0 V.
The HiPIMS sputtering process according to step b) and/or b′) may comprise the application to the magnetron cathode of polarization impulses, each of which may exhibit at least one of the following characteristics:
The polarization impulses may be applied to the magnetron cathode according to a frequency of 50 Hz to 600 Hz, more particularly of 100 Hz to 600 Hz.
The HiPIMS etching process according to step a) and/or a′) or the HiPIMS sputtering process according to step b) and/or b′) is carried out with a carrier gas comprising at least one rare gas.
The rare gas may be chosen from argon, xenon or krypton.
The carrier gas is, for example, at a pressure of between 0.2 Pa and 2 Pa.
According to a specific embodiment of the manufacturing process of the invention, after the deposition over the substrate of the first external layer with the HiPIMS sputtering process according to step b) and/or b′), at least a part of the additional external layer(s) are deposited during step b) and/or b′) with a magnetron cathode sputtering process of a different type from the HiPIMS which is carried out simultaneously with the HiPIMS sputtering process according to step b) and/or b′).
The magnetron cathode sputtering process of a different type from the HiPIMS is, for example, such that the polarization of the target is continuous (“DC” for “Direct Current”) or pulsed at a medium frequency (“pulsed DC”), resulting in a polarization voltage delivering an instantaneous power of a few kilowatts.
The deposition of the additional external layers with a conventional magnetron PVD process combined with the HiPIMS sputtering process according to step b) and/or b′) makes it possible to improve the industrial operation of the manufacturing process of the invention by increasing the rate of deposition of the additional external layers.
On the conclusion of the manufacturing process of the invention, at least one external layer is obtained which has a thickness of 1 μm to 50 μm, preferably of 3 μm to 25 μm, still more preferably of 3 μm to 10 μm. The cumulative thickness of the external layers is generally from 1 μm to 50 μm, indeed even 2 μm to 50 μm.
Several external layers may be deposited on the substrate. For example, the nuclear fuel cladding comprises from 1 to 50 external layers, in order to constitute a multilayer external coating. If appropriate, the external layers may merge to give a single external layer in order to constitute a monolayer external coating, for example after application of a heat treatment to the external layers or by varying the etching and deposition conditions.
According to a preferred embodiment of the manufacturing process of the invention, the at least one interposed layer is composed of at least one interposed material chosen from tantalum, molybdenum, tungsten, niobium, vanadium, hafnium or their alloys.
Such an interposed layer constitutes a diffusion barrier which limits, indeed even prevents:
Preferably, the interposed material is tantalum.
Tantalum or its alloy can be replaced or combined with at least one refractory metal element or its alloy, the physicochemical properties of which are compatible with the zirconium-based internal layer up to 1300° C. In particular, up to 1300° C., the refractory metal element or its alloy does not form a eutectic and exhibits a limited diffusion into the zirconium and/or the chromium.
Apart from tantalum, such a refractory metal element is, for example, molybdenum, tungsten or niobium, vanadium, hafnium.
Other subject matters, characteristics and advantages of the invention will now be specified in the description which follows of specific embodiments of the process of the invention, given by way of nonlimiting illustration, with reference to the appended figures.
1. Manufacture of a Plate using the Process of the Invention
This example of implementation of the manufacturing process of the invention is carried out in a cathode sputtering reactor sold by Balzers (BAK 640 model) and equipped with a Hüttinger generator. The experimental conditions applied may nevertheless vary as a function of the reactor used or of its magnetic configuration, of the shape and of the size of the target, . . . .
In accordance with his general knowledge, a person skilled in the art may, however, easily adapt himself to these variations by modifying at least one of the parameters, such as, for example, the polarization voltage of the substrate which is applied during the step a) of ion etching or the step b) of deposition of the internal layer, the duration, the frequency, the intensity or the polarization voltage of the polarization impulses, the distance between the chromium target and the substrate, or the pressure of the carrier gas.
More particularly, these parameters influence the mean energy of the Cr+ Pions which are produced during steps a) or b). This energy can condition the density, the homogeneity, the texture, the microstructure or the state of stress of the external layer.
1.1. Step of Ion Etching
A Zircaloy-4 plate with dimensions of 45 mm×14 mm×1.2 mm is degreased in an alkaline solution, rinsed with water and cleaned ultrasonically in ethanol.
It is subsequently placed in an HiPIMS cathode sputtering reactor containing a chromium magnetron cathode placed at a distance generally of between 6 cm and 8 cm and in this instance of 8 cm. The chamber of the reactor is placed under a vacuum of less than 2.10−5 mbar and then filled with a carrier gas composed of argon at a pressure of 0.5 Pa.
The plate constituting the internal layer and thus the substrate to be coated is polarized negatively with a polarization voltage of −800 V.
The chromium target is subsequently supplied using the HiPIMS generator according to a polarization voltage of −800 V in order to generate a strongly ionized discharge. The chromium is then sputtered in the form of ions which are accelerated by the electric field of the substrate. The adsorbed carbon-based entities and the nanometric layer of native zirconium oxide or hydroxide are then removed from the surface of the substrate in order to improve the adhesion of the external layer. This ion etching of the substrate lasts 3 minutes in order to limit the heating up of the plate.
1.2. Step of Deposition of the External Layer by HiPIMS Sputtering
The polarization voltage applied to the etched plate is, for example, decreased between −50 V and 0 V, in the present case to −50 V for 8 hours. As the rate of deposition is generally between 0.5 μm/h and 1 μm/h, these conditions lead to the deposition of an external chromium layer with a thickness of 6 μm.
The polarization voltage of the chromium target is maintained at −800 V. Several polarization impulses are applied to the magnetron cathode according to the following characteristics:
The surface condition of the plate coated with the external chromium layer is illustrated by
The combined
2. Properties with Regard to the Oxidation/Hydriding
2.1. Evaluation of the Resistance to Oxidation in Accident Conditions at 1200° C.
In order to evaluate its resistance to oxidation, a plate based on Zircaloy-4 provided with a single external chromium layer of 6 μm in accordance with example 1 stays for 300 seconds in a furnace in which steam brought to 1200° C. circulates.
By way of comparison, the same experiment is carried out with a control Zircaloy-4 plate which has been covered with a chromium coating of the same thickness using a conventional cathode sputtering process in accordance with example 1 of “WO2013/160587”.
The condition of the plates obtained on completion of this oxidation is illustrated by
On the other hand, even if
Such results are confirmed by
The absence of measurable diffusion of oxygen within the residual metal layer of the HiPIMS coating and a fortiori in the zirconium-based internal layer may be observed.
For the control plate, the measurements of
For the plate produced in accordance with the manufacturing process of the invention, the measurements of
Furthermore, similar experiments of an oxidation at 1200° C. for 300 seconds, followed by a quenching with water at ambient temperature, have confirmed such a behavior when the plate geometries are replaced by tubular cladding geometries nevertheless involving a different crystal texture: the gain in weight representative of the take up of oxygen is from 10 to 30 times less for the tube produced by the process of the invention in comparison with that measured for the tube covered with a chromium coating with a conventional cathode sputtering process.
2.2. Evaluation of the Resistance to Oxidation in Accident Conditions at 1300° C.
Another sample of the plate produced in accordance with the manufacturing process of the invention stays for 5600 seconds in an equimolar oxygen/helium atmosphere brought to 1300° C.
In this specific oxidation temperature domain, such an atmosphere composition is reasonably representative of the oxidation conditions under steam as, except for in a particular case (confined steam, alloy of mediocre quality, degraded surface condition, . . . ), no significant hydriding of the substrate occurs during the oxidation at 1300° C.
Although these temperature conditions lie more than 100° C. above the “LOCA” regulatory limits, the photograph of
The Zircaloy-4 substrate predominantly exhibits a structure of Zr-ex-β type which provides most of the residual ductility of the plate.
In comparison, the metallic residual internal layer of Zircaloy-4 of a control plate not coated with an external chromium layer and subjected to the same oxidation conditions for its part exhibits a wholly α-Zr(O) structure which is brittle at low temperature and which is responsible for a loss of integrity by transverse splitting.
Even in oxidizing conditions at 1300° C., far above regulatory safety limits, a nuclear fuel cladding obtained by the manufacturing process of the invention may retain its mechanical integrity and exhibit a comfortable residual margin of resistance to oxidation/hydriding.
2.3. Evaluation of the Resistance to Oxidation with an Interposed Tantalum Layer
A plate is produced under conditions similar to those of example 1, apart from the fact that an interposed layer with a thickness of 2 μm to 3 μm approximately composed of tantalum is deposited on the internal layer using an HiPIMS sputtering process. The deposition of the interposed tantalum layer is carried out according to conditions similar to those of the deposition of the external chromium layer for example 1, apart from the fact that the tantalum target is polarized at −800 V for an impulse duration of 25 μs. After carrying out the ion etching (according to step a) of the manufacturing process of the invention) of the interposed tantalum layer, an external chromium layer with a thickness of 4 μm is subsequently deposited on this interposed layer in accordance with step b) of the manufacturing process of the invention.
By way of comparison, several corresponding control plates, apart from the fact that they are devoid of interposed tantalum layer, are produced.
After a residence of 300 seconds in a furnace in which steam at 1200° C. circulates, the profiles of diffusion of the chromium of the external layer toward the internal Zircaloy-4 layer are measured from the interface between these layers.
These measurements illustrated in
Generally, the interposed layer reduces, indeed even eliminates, the phenomenon of diffusion, which increases the lifetime of the external layer and thus of the corresponding nuclear fuel cladding, amongst others in accident conditions, such as, for example, the dewatering of a spent fuel storage pool or those defined by the criteria of dimensioning accident of LOCA type.
Furthermore, the impact of the interposed layer on the diffusion of the chromium toward the zirconium alloy also has the advantage of delaying the formation of a eutectic between the zirconium and the chromium above 1330° C. and thus the production of a surface liquid phase, which makes it possible to avoid or limit the potentially negative consequences which might result therefrom in the event of an incursion above ˜1320° C.
2.4. Evaluation of the Resistance to Hydriding at 1000° C.
Hydriding is a phenomenon which occurs within a nuclear fuel cladding in nominal conditions or in certain accident conditions. The hydriding results from the sequence of the following reactions (1) and (2): the zirconium present in the nuclear fuel cladding is oxidized by the pressurized water or the steam according to the reaction,
Zr+2H2O→ZrO2+2H2 (1)
then a portion of the hydrogen thus released diffuses into the zirconium alloy of the cladding and may form a hydride with the zirconium of the cladding which has not yet oxidized, according to the reaction
Zr+xH→ZrHx. (2)
The index “x” indicates that hydrides of variable stoichiometry may be formed, this index being in particular equal to or less than 2.
According to the overall hydrogen content and/or the temperature, all or a portion of the hydrogen will precipitate, the remainder remaining in solid solution (in insertion in the α-zirconium crystal lattice).
For example, at 20° C., virtually all of the hydrogen is precipitated in the form of hydrides, whereas their dissolution may be total at high temperature (typically greater than 600° C.)
Hydrogen in solid solution, but especially in the form of zirconium hydride precipitate, has the disadvantage of decreasing the ductility of zirconium alloys and thus of causing embrittlement of the cladding, among others at low temperature. This embrittlement is all the more to be feared when it is desired to reach high burn-up rates as, at these rates, an increase in the proportion of zirconium oxidized according to the reaction (1) and thus in the amount of hydrides formed according to reaction (2) is found. It then generally results in the corrosion of the usual industrial alloys at levels which are harmful with regard to the criteria of safety and integrity of the cladding, and may present problems for post-service transportation and storage.
Observed in normal conditions with regard to the zirconium alloys M5™ or Zirlo™ of a nuclear fuel cladding, hydriding is generally observed in accident conditions only in the vicinity of 1000° C., or toward 800° C. for longer oxidation times. This phenomenon, known as “breakaway”, is associated with an increase in the kinetics of oxidation beyond a certain critical time. It results from the appearance of cracks and/or porosities in the ZrO2 phase related to the presence of stresses generated at the Zr/ZrO2 interface probably related to the reversible transformation of tetragonal ZrO2 into monoclinic ZrO2. The consequences of this uptake of hydrogen are, in the same way as in normal conditions, an embrittlement of the material in the vicinity of 1000° C. which can result in the fracturing thereof during a quenching or after returning to low temperature.
The “breakaway” phenomenon generally occurs after 5000 seconds at 1000° C. for a zirconium alloy, such as the Zircaloy-4 or M5™.
In order to evaluate the resistance to the hydriding of a nuclear fuel cladding according to the invention, another sample of the plate produced in accordance with the manufacturing process of the invention stays for 15 000 seconds in an atmosphere of steam brought to 1000° C.
By way of comparison, the same experiment is carried out with a control plate of Zircaloy-4 which has been covered with a chromium coating of the same thickness using a conventional cathode sputtering process in accordance with example 1 of “WO 2013/160587”.
The results obtained are illustrated by
On the other hand,
3. Geometry of the Nuclear Fuel Cladding According to the Invention
The nuclear fuel cladding obtained by the manufacturing process of the invention is described with reference to
According to a first embodiment of the invention, the cladding illustrated by
According to a second embodiment illustrated by
According to a third nonillustrated embodiment, an internal coating is placed under the internal layer (1), and thus directly facing the volume capable of receiving the nuclear fuel.
It emerges from the preceding description that the process of the invention makes it possible to manufacture a nuclear fuel cladding exhibiting an improvement in the resistance to oxidation at very high temperature. The additional safety margins thus obtained make it possible among others to prevent or delay the deterioration in the cladding in the event of worsening or persistence of the accident situation.
The present application is a CIP of international applications number PCT/FR2015/052475, filed Sep. 16, 2015, and PCT/FR2015/052476, filed Sep. 16, 2015, both of which claim benefit to U.S. provisional application, 62/051,913, filed Sep. 17, 2014, the entire contents of all three of which are hereby incorporated herein by reference.
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4022662 | Gordon | May 1977 | A |
| 4268586 | Hanneman | May 1981 | A |
| 4336118 | Patten | Jun 1982 | A |
| 4494987 | Korenko | Jan 1985 | A |
| 5267290 | Corsetti et al. | Nov 1993 | A |
| 5373541 | Mardon et al. | Dec 1994 | A |
| 8187720 | Choi et al. | May 2012 | B2 |
| 20090169910 | Myrtveit | Jul 2009 | A1 |
| 20100040189 | Brachet et al. | Feb 2010 | A1 |
| 20100091934 | Kim | Apr 2010 | A1 |
| 20110180389 | Cremer | Jul 2011 | A1 |
| 20130209834 | Engelhart et al. | Aug 2013 | A1 |
| 20130302639 | Song | Nov 2013 | A1 |
| 20130344348 | Koo | Dec 2013 | A1 |
| 20140234616 | Hultman | Aug 2014 | A1 |
| 20140254740 | Ledford | Sep 2014 | A1 |
| 20140323367 | Mordente et al. | Oct 2014 | A1 |
| 20150050521 | Flem | Feb 2015 | A1 |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| 0 240 110 | Oct 1987 | EP |
| 0240110 | Oct 1987 | EP |
| 0624882 | Nov 1994 | EP |
| 1493040 | Jul 1967 | FR |
| 2789404 | Aug 2000 | FR |
| 2 849 620 | Jul 2004 | FR |
| 2989923 | Nov 2013 | FR |
| 2992331 | Dec 2013 | FR |
| 1203700 | Sep 1970 | GB |
| 02-263943 | Oct 1990 | JP |
| 5-171418 | Jul 1993 | JP |
| 2008046999 | Apr 2008 | WO |
| 2013045454 | Apr 2013 | WO |
| 20130160587 | Oct 2013 | WO |
| 2016042261 | Mar 2016 | WO |
| Entry |
|---|
| Ferrec, A., et al. “Correlation between mass-spectrometer measurements and thin film characteristics using dcMS and HiPIMS discharges” Surface & Coatings Technology 2010, vol. 250, pp. 52-56. (Year: 2014). |
| Ehiasarian, A. “High-power impulse magnetron sputtering and its applications” Pure Appl. Chem. 2010, vol. 82 No. 6, pp. 1447-1258. (Year: 2010). |
| Ferreira, F. et al. “Effect of peak target power on the properties of Cr thin filsm sputtered by HiPIMS in deep oscillation magnetron sputtering (DOMS) mode” Surface & Coatings Technology 2014, vol. 258, pp. 249-256. (Year: 2014). |
| Kim et al., “Performance of a diffusion barrier under a fuel-clad chemical interaction (FCCI)” Journal of Nuclear Materials, 394:144-150(2009). |
| Chemelle et al., “Morphology and Composition of Second Phase Particles in Zircal0y-2” Journal of Nuclear Materials, 113:58-64 (1983). |
| Taylor et al., “A Simple Kinetic Model of Zircaloy Zr(Fe,Cr)2 Precipitate Amorphization During Neutron Irradiation” Lockheed Martin Corporation, Knolls Atomic Power Laboratory (KAPL), Document No. KAPL-P-000319(K99115), Jul. 1999. |
| Ati Wah Chang.,“Reactor Grade Zirconium Alloys for Nuclear Waste Disposal”, Zirconium Alloys, pp. 1-4 (Nov. 21, 2003) downloaded on Dec. 16, 2015, from: https:j/www.atimetals.com/businessesjatispecialtyalloysandcomponentsjproducts/Documents/Zr nuke waste disposal.pdf. |
| Igbal et al., “Synthesis and characterization of bulk amorphous Zr65Cu18Ni9Al8 and [Zr0.65Cu0.18Ni0.09Al0.08]98Er2 Alloys” Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids 352:3290-3294 (2006). |
| Davidson et al., “The Effects on Fracture Toughness of Ductile-Phase Composition and Morphology in Nb—Cr—Ti and Nb—Si In Situ Composites” Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A, vol. 27A, pp. 3007-3018, Oct. 1996. |
| Database WPI, Week Jan. 2011, Jan. 1, 2011, Thomson Scientific. London. GB; AN 2010-N85039 XP002690390, —& KR 2010 0114392 A (Korea Atomic Energy Res Inst) (Oct. 25, 2010). |
| Database CA {Online] Chemical Abstracts Service, Columbus, Ohio, US; May 12, 1984 (May 12, 1984), Bykov, V. N. et al: “Effect of erbium on the oxidation resistance of z1rconium” XP002432538 Database accession No. 1981:501621, abrege & Zashchita Metallov , 17(2), 219-21 CODEN: ZAMfA9; ISSN: 0044-1856, 1981. |
| International Search Report for PCT/FR2015052475, dated Feb. 1, 2016. |
| International Search Report for PCT/FR2015052476, dated Jan. 18, 2016. |
| International Search Report for PCT/FR2013/050849, dated Jul. 18, 2013. |
| International Search Report for PCT/FR2007/001698, dated Mar. 20, 2007. |
| Brachet, et al., Behavior of Cr-Coated M5 Claddings During and After High Temperature Steam Oxidation From 800° C. up to 1500° C. (Loss-of-Coolant Accident & Design Extension Conditions), pp. 1-10, Conference Paper, Topfuel 2018 (Prague, Czech Republic, Oct. 2018). |
| Ferrec, Axel, Dépôt et Caractérisation de Métaux et de Nitrures à Base de Chrome par Pulvérisation Magnétron Pulsée (HiPIMS)[ Deposition and Characterization of Metals and Nitrides Based on Chromium by Pulsed Magnetron Spray (HIPIMS)]pp. 1-265 (Doctoral Thesis, University of Nantes, Science of Materials, Dec. 6, 2013). |
| French search report for FR1458933, dated Aug. 31, 2015, pp. 1-8. |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20170287578 A1 | Oct 2017 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 62051913 | Sep 2014 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | PCT/FR2015/052475 | Sep 2015 | US |
| Child | 15462176 | US | |
| Parent | PCT/FR2015/052476 | Sep 2015 | US |
| Child | PCT/FR2015/052475 | US |
