This application is a national phase application of and claims priority under 35 U.S.C. § 371 of PCT Application Serial No. PCT/IB2018/060095 filed on Dec. 14, 2018 and titled OPTO-MAGNETIC SENSOR DEVICE AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION SYSTEM. The content of this application is incorporated herein by reference.
The present invention refers to the field of sensing the presence and concentration of an analyte in a sample by means of an optical sensor.
According to a known technique, it is used a chip provided with optical sensors suitably functionalized to the surface thereof by probe molecules which specifically bind to analyte molecules in a molecular recognition process, for sensing the presence and concentration of said analyte molecules in a sample. Said sensing is made possible by varying the optical characteristics, generally the refraction index, upon a chemisorption of the analyte molecules on the sensor surface due to the hybridization with the probes, which causes a response optical change of the sensor itself. If the sensor is a ring optical resonator, the variation of the refraction index causes a measurable shift of the resonance, which is assumed as an indicator of the locally captured quantity of analyte molecules.
The use of microresonators is for example described in the document: “Label-Free Single Exosome Detection Using Frequency-Locked Microtoroid Optical Resonators”, Judith Su, ACS Photonics 2015, 2, 1241-1245. The signal useful for having the analyte concentration is obtained by measuring the shift of the resonance wavelength upon the molecular recognition and consequently requires that, during said measure, there are not spurious phenomena causing a shift of the resonance uncorrelated to the molecular recognition and therefore causing false positives. Such spurious phenomena can be tied to temperature variations, a partial evaporation of the sample on the optical chip, variations of the optical coupling, mechanical instabilities, etcetera. From the operative point of view, this requires to provide several experimental provisions minimizing the spurious effects: stabilization of the temperature, use of a suitable microfluid cell preventing the evaporation, assembly on an antivibration optical table, the addition of further control sensor elements, etcetera. Moreover, it is necessary to acquire the signals during all the molecular recognition process, this step often requires more than 30 minutes, in order to find possible spurious variations which could make invalid the result. This makes the test burdensome in terms of the required instrumentation and less adapted to be used in the field, outside a specialized scientific laboratory, which instead is required in many applications.
Document US-A-2013/4101 A1 describes a biosensing platform by which magnetic nanoparticles which can selectively bind to the analyte, are dispensed. By acting on a magnetic static field, said particles are attracted to the chip surface, so that the interaction between the analyte and probes is promoted. Even though this technique makes faster the test and increases the sensibility of the sensor due to the particle size greater than the analyte, it suffers from the beforehand described spurious phenomena.
Document US-A-2016/0146798 describes an optical biosensor based on the optical measure, in light transmission, of the variation of the Brownian relaxing times of magnetic particles freely moving in a suspension, upon a molecular recognition on the surface thereof. The Applicant observes that such method has some limitations about the use of the optical biosensor for the parallel recognition of different analytes, substantially due to the requirement of having different classes of particles, one for each analyte, specifically functionalized and having a frequency response well defined to oscillating magnetic fields used for exciting them.
The present invention addresses the problem of proposing a molecular recognition technique based on an optical sensor, enabling to reduce the effect of spurious phenomena (temperature variations, partial evaporation of the sample, optical coupling variations, mechanical instabilities, for example) in comparison with the known prior art.
Particularly, the object of the present invention is an opto-magnetic device as defined in claim 1, and the preferred embodiments thereof as defined in claims from 2 to 8.
It is also an object of the present invention an analyte recognition system as described in claim 9 and in the particular embodiments thereof defined in claims from 10 to 16.
The present invention is specifically described in the following in a non-limiting exemplifying way, with reference to the attached drawings, wherein:
While the invention is susceptible to different modifications and alternative constructions, some particular embodiments are shown in the drawings and will be specifically described in the following. In the present description, analogous or identical elements or components will be indicated in the figures by the same identifying symbol.
The optical sensor device 100 comprises an integrated optical circuit 101 having an input IN for an input optical radiation, and an output OU for an output optical radiation. The integrated optical circuit 101 comprises at least one area 102 sensible to the variations of a local refraction index probed (or seen) by the optical radiation. Such area 102 determines a surface adapted to immobilize the probe molecules, as will be described in the following.
Advantageously, the optical sensor device 100 is associated to a suitable dispensing system adapted to dispense a sample to be analyzed, containing the analyte, at least on the surface of the area 102 of the optical device itself, for example in a solution. Such dispensing system is also adapted to dispense other reagents necessary to perform a diagnostic test, among them suitable suspensions of magnetic particles, and also possible washings. If the sample is in a liquid phase, said dispensing system can consist of a microfluidic cell connected to a suitable apparatus provided with pumps and valves for managing the flows of the reagents on the optical device 100. In suitable embodiments of the diagnostic test, which do not require multiple washings or recognitions of the “sandwich” type, the dispensing system can comprise a well for receiving the sample.
In the example of
Specifically, an upper wall of the guiding layer 104 is the surface of the area 102 and on which the sample is destined to be placed in contact.
For example, the planar waveguide 101 is made by one of the following technologies: silicon photonics, silicon nitride, silicon oxynitride, indium phosphide, chalcogenides.
The optical sensor device 100, in an operative step, comprises a plurality of probe molecules 105 capable of anchoring to the surface of the area 102 of the optical circuit 101 and exhibiting a selective affinity to an analyte 106. The selection of the type of probe molecules 105 to be used depends on the type of analyte 106 of which the presence is expected to be sensed. Examples of substances useable as probe molecules 105 are: proteins, antibodies, nucleic acids, etcetera.
Moreover, the optical sensor device 100 is provided with a plurality of magnetic particles 107 capable of binding (anchoring) to the molecules 106 of the analyte. Such bond can be obtained during a step of preparing the sample, before a dispending step on the surface of the optical sensor device 100, or directly on the surface of the area 102 of the same, after the hybridization step between the probe molecules 105 and analyte 106. It is observed that the length of the probe molecule 105 is selected in order to obtain a good mobility of the magnetic particle 107 anchored to it by the analyte molecule 106.
Such magnetic particles 107 can be of the ferromagnetic, ferrimagnetic or paramagnetic type. Preferably, they are superparamagnetic particles. The superparamagnetic particles are the preferred ones because they avoid an undesired aggregation to each other while ensuring a substantial susceptibility.
Exemplary useable magnetic particles 107 comprise: single superparamagnetic nanoparticles (Co, CoFe, NiFe, ferrites FexOy, etc.), aggregates (“beads”) of said superparamagnetic nanoparticles dispersed in a polymeric matrix, antiferromagnetic synthetic particles consisting of two ferromagnetic layers separated by a non-magnetic layer, having a thickness such to determine an antiparallel coupling of the magnetization in the two layers in a null field (Co/Cu/Co, CoFe/Ru/CoFe, CoPt/Ta/CoPt, etc.).
Particularly, the magnetic particles 107 in the nanometric range exhibit a diameter typically comprised from 50 to 250 nm. Greater dimensions must be avoided for limiting the disproportion between the linear dimensions of the probe-analyte complex after the molecular recognition at the surface and the dimensions of the magnetic particles 107. The purpose of this is also for limiting the high number of anchoring points of the single particle to the surface, in order to promote the motion thereof in response to external magnetic fields.
Moreover, said magnetic particles 107 can be advantageously designed for exhibiting a shape and magneto-crystalline anisotropy enabling a more effective mechanical implementation by time-varying magnetic fields.
The optical sensor device 100 is also provided with a magnetic actuator 108 (for example an electromagnet) configured to generate a variable magnetic field and move the magnetic particles 107, causing a variation of the refraction index of the optical circuit 101 and a variation of at least one characteristic parameter of the output radiation, correlated to a concentration of the analyte 106.
The magnetic actuator 108 can be arranged in different possible configurations with respect to the optical circuit 101. According to the example of
In the embodiment illustrated in
During the operation of the optical sensor device 100, a sample suspended in the analyte substance 106 is suitably disposed on the surface of the area 102 of the planar waveguide 101, sensible to the variations of the refraction index. In this case, the molecules 106 of the analyte specifically bind (by chemical bonds) to the probe molecules 105 (anchored to the area 102 of the guiding layer 104) and, then, the magnetic particles 107 bind to the molecules 106 of the analyte.
According to another possible mode, the sample placed on the surface of the area 102 of the guiding layer 104 is an analyte-particle complex comprising the molecules 106 of the analyte, already bound to the magnetic particles 107. According to this further mode, the already formed analyte-particle complex is specifically bound to the probe molecules 105.
Upon such bonds, and without a variable magnetic field, the magnetic particle 107 is disposed at a fixed distance Z0 from the upper wall of the guiding layer 104, defined by the dimensions of the probes 105.
An optical radiation is injected in the input IN of the planar waveguide 101 and the optical mode thereof propagates along the direction y (indicated in Figures from 1 to 3).
The magnetic actuator 108 is capable of producing a distribution of the magnetic field with a high gradient in a direction normal to the surface (axis z).
When the magnetic field is generated by the electromagnet 108, the magnetic particles 107 are in a gradient of the field and are subjected to a force directed towards the areas having a higher field (in other words towards the electromagnet 108 itself).
For magnetic particles 107 of the ferromagnetic type, the associated force is proportional to the gradient of the field ∇H. By preferably using magnetic particles 107 of the superparamagnetic type, having a high susceptibility and a substantially null residual magnetism, in order to avoid the aggregation and anyway obtain high forces, the force exerted to the magnetic particle 107 is proportional to the gradient of the square of the magnetic field ∇H2. The magnetic particles 107 subjected to such force, therefore, tend to move along the axis z.
The described method of operation provides to generate, by the electromagnet 108, an oscillating field, causing a spatial oscillation of the magnetic particles 107 with a total amplitude Δz, shown in
The displacement of the magnetic particles 107 modifies the interaction with the optical radiation OF (or optical field) guided by the guiding layer 104 and shown in
Therefore, sensing the changes of at least one parameter of the optical radiation caused by the oscillating magnetic field produced by the electromagnet 108 enables to obtain information regarding the concentration of the molecules 106 of the analyte in the used sample solution.
It is observed that the optical circuit 101 can be also of a type different from the above described planar wave guide. For example,
Moreover, the microresonator 109 is also coupled to a further planar optical guide 112, integrated on the substrate 103, having an additional output OUD for the optical radiation.
If the wavelength of the optical radiation injected in the optical circuit 101 is a submultiple of the optical path of the ring of the microresonator 109, the resonance condition is attained and the transmission of the guiding layer 104 towards the output OU is substantially decreased since is destined to the additional output OUD.
The oscillation of the magnetic particles 107 bound to the probe-analyte complex 105-106 on the surface of the area 102 of the resonator 109, causes a modification of the effective refraction index of the optical mode, causing a variation of the resonance frequency of the microresonator 109.
During the operation of the optical sensor device 100 of
If the transmission as a function of the wavelength is assumed linear about the considered work point (this is a small-signal approximation which does not jeopardize the principle on which this invention is based), a shift Δz of the magnetic particle 107 causes a resonance shift equal to Δλ and therefore an intensity modulation I(λ) transmitted to the output OU and to the additional output OUD, expressible as:
∛ΔI(λ)=I(λ+Δλ)−I(λ)=I′(λ)Δλ
wherein:
I(λ) is the optical intensity transmitted at the output OU or OUD;
ΔI(λ) is the variation of the transmitted optical intensity;
Δλ is the shift of the resonance;
I′(λ) is the first derivative of the optical intensity.
From the above written expression it is evident that the trend of an electric signal, obtained by the opto-electric conversion of the radiation transmitted by the optical circuit 101, is maximized at the most sloping point of the transmission curve shown in
For the superparamagnetic-type magnetic particles 107, whose force oscillates at a frequency twice the one of the magnetic field H, the electric signal obtained by the opto-electric conversion of the radiation outputs by the optical circuit 101, has a frequency equal to 2f0, wherein f0 is the oscillation frequency of the magnetic field.
According to a particular embodiment practical example of the optical circuits 101 in
The optical radiation source 201 can be, for example, a tunable laser having an output port coupled (e.g. by an optical fiber or by suitable lenses) to the inlet IN of the optical circuit 101. The optical radiation source 201 is capable of generating a continuous radiation at the wavelength at which the guiding layer 104 is transparent to the radiation itself. Typically, the used wavelengths are the telecommunications ones (from 1500 to 1600 nm and from 1200 to 1400 nm), the near infra-red (750, 850, 980 nm), medium infra-red (from 2 to 8 microns), and the visible range (from 400 to 650 nm).
As it is well known to the persons skilled in the field, the photodetector and/or the laser source can be directly integrated on the chip by using technologies such as indium phosphide for photodiodes and lasers, the germanium or silicon/germanium for the photodiodes, hybridally or monolithically added to the integrated optical sensor device 100.
The optical sensor device 100 can be one of the devices beforehand described with reference to Figures from 1 to 7. Moreover, the recognition system 200 comprises a pilot signal generator 204 (DS-G) such to generate a pilot electrical signal Sdr (preferably a sinusoidal voltage and/or current signals) destined to supply the magnetic actuator 108. According to an embodiment example, the pilot electric signal has a peak-to-peak voltage comprised between 0 and 5 Vpp and a frequency to 100 Hz.
The magnetic actuator 108 can comprise an electromagnet in which a current of 0-2 A flows, for example, to which a magnetic field of intensity 0-5 mT corresponds, which supplies the optical circuit 101, at a distance σ.
The opto-electric conversion module 202 can comprise at least one photodiode and has an input optically coupled to the output OU and/or to the additional output OUD of the optical circuit 101 and an output for an electric signal SE, proportional to the intensity of the output optical radiation, to be supplied to the processing electronic apparatus 203.
The electronic processing apparatus 203 is capable of receiving the electric signal Se and from which, calculating data regarding the concentration in the analyzed sample of the molecules 106 of the analyte.
By considering the case in which the electric signal Se represents an intensity modulation of the optical radiation as described with reference to Figures from 5 to 7 (by the microresonators 109), the electronic processing apparatus 203 can be selected for performing a coherent demodulation of the electric signal Se. For example, such processing apparatus includes a lock-in demodulator capable of extracting the amplitude of the modulated electric signal Se.
The operation of the molecular recognition system 200 is based on the operation of the optical sensor device 100, as described. In summary, the generation of the optical radiation is provided by the source 201 coupled to the optical circuit 101 and the variable magnetic field is generated by the magnetic actuator 108, commanded by the pilot electric signal Sdr. The low-frequency (preferably from 10 Hz to 100 Hz, or more broadly from 1 Hz to 1 kHz) variable magnetic field generates the oscillating motion of the magnetic particles 107 anchored to the surface of the area 102 of the circuit 101 by one or more probe molecules 105, which causes a variation of the intensity of the optical radiation transmitted at the output OU and/or OUD, at the same excitation frequency or at a double frequency.
Specifically, it is observed that the optical radiations at outputs OU and/or OUD are converted in one or more electric signals Se having an amplitude function of several experimental parameters, among which:
(i) the wavelength λ0 of the incident optical radiation,
(ii) the amplitude of the oscillating magnetic field H,
(iii) the distance of the electromagnet 108 from the optical circuit 101, which determines the entity of the gradient ΔH of the magnetic field,
(iv) the length and the rigidity of the probe-analyte complex,
(v) the number of magnetic particles 107 bound to the surface of the area 102 and oscillated by the magnetic field H,
(vi) the optical characteristics of the resonator 109 (the width and depth of the resonant peak).
All the parameters (in other words the above listed ones) being equal it is possible to establish a relationship between the number of magnetic particles 107 bound to the area 102 of the microresonator 109, in turn function of the molecular recognition events on said area, and the entity of the electric signal Se at the output. This is the physical principle for quantifying the concentration of an analyte in the used sample, by comparing a suitable calibration curve, beforehand measured, in response to samples having titrated concentrations of the analyte.
The electric signal Se, supplied by an opto-electric conversion module 202, is demodulated at the frequency 2f0 by the electronic processing circuit 203, such as a lock-in amplifier, using, as a reference, the pilot signal Sdr at the input of the electromagnet 108.
By the amplitude of the electric signal Se, obtained by a demodulation, a computing module (for example included in the processing electronic device 203) determines the concentration in the analyzed sample of the molecule 106 of the analyte, by a comparison with a suitable calibration curve.
It is observed that calibration steps made on known samples, enabling to determine a calibration curve for each considered specific analyte, are performed before using the optical sensor device 100 and recognition system 200.
Due to the times required to measure the concentration of the analyte, it is observed that the sensor optical device 100 and recognition system 200 enable to quantify the molecular recognition events at the surface of the sensor optical device 100 in a particularly short time. For example, it is sufficient to acquire signals in an interval of few tens of seconds. This can be performed in a step following the probe-analyte hybridization step, without requiring to continuously monitor the signal which can cause the risk of errors generated by spurious fluctuations. On the other hand, the short quantifying time is independent from the time required for the molecular recognition between the probe and the analyte which is dictated by the association and dissociation constants of the complex.
According to a particular embodiment, the optical sensor device 100 enables to implement a kind of “magnetic color” for the magnetic particles 107. More particularly, using pairs of magnetic particles 107 and probe molecules 105 having suitable dimensions, shape and mechanical properties, it is possible to have on a same area sensible to the optical circuit 101, magnetic nanoparticles having a different frequency response to the magnetic fields. Measuring the signal modulation at different frequencies makes consequently possible to obtain the concentrations of different anlytes on the optical sensor device 100 itself.
This enables to reliably quantify relative concentrations also in case of a competitive molecular recognition, without the problem of the different sensibility of nominally identical sensors on which it is possible to simultaneously measure different analytes.
With reference to the examples of the optical circuit 101, beforehand described, it is observed that this latter can comprise, in addition, or as a substitution, at least one of the following integrated optical devices: any interferometers (a Fabry-Perot interferometer, a resonant ring interferometer, a Mach-Zehnder interferometer, a Sagnac interferometer, an all-pass type Gires-Tournois interferometer, a Michelson interferometer, a diffraction grating, a Bragg grating, an apparatus exploiting the Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR), the Localized Surface Plasmon resonance (LSPR) or the Surface Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy (SERS). The electric signal Se will have a trend function of the characteristic parameter of the optical radiation correlated to a concentration of the molecules 106 of the analyte in the sample.
The Applicant has made a prototype of the optical sensor device 100 by using optical microresonators 109 by which double DNA helixes, of 60 bases (about 20 nm) were immobilized, which expose a molecule of biotin. The immobilization step was performed by different concentrations of DNA, for evaluating the dependency of the sensed signal from the concentration of the immobilized molecules, simulating the results of a real molecular recognition experiment.
Then, a solution of magnetic nanoparticles Micromod®Nanomag®-D having a diameter of 250 nm and coated by streptavidin, was dispensed on the surface of the area 102 of the optical sensor device 100. Due to the strong chemical affinity between biotin and streptavidin, the magnetic nanoparticles 107 bind to the surface thanks to the concentration of the immobilized double helixes. The unbound surplus magnetic particles 107 were removed by suitably washing them in PBS, and the optical sensor device 100 is positioned on a sample-holder of the measure station, by always maintaining the particles in a wet environment for maintaining their stability.
The rigidity of the double helix, having a length less than the typical persistence length of DNA, does not enable substantial elongations or inflections, but a DNA rotation with respect to the anchoring point, which causes a net shift of the particles in a direction perpendicular to the surface of the optical sensor device 100.
For a magnetic field H on the surface of the optical circuit 101 with a maximum amplitude of 0.6 A/m and ∇H2 equal to 2×109 A2/m3, and a sinusoidal modulation of 10 Hz, at a DNA concentration of 1 μM used for the immobilization on the optical circuit 101, it is obtained a percentage modulation of the intensity at the output at frequency 2f0 equal to about 0.7%, as shown in
As can be seen in
The signal/noise ratio for the signal in
The described approach is particularly advantageous because the used sensing technique, based on magnetic particles bound to the analyte and probe molecules and based on the use of a variable magnetic field, enables to have a high variation of the local refraction index, entailing the availability of an optical signal by which the impact of the spurious fluctuations is reduced, substantially increasing the signal/noise ratio. Moreover, the quantification according to the described technique is performed within tens of seconds, without requiring to continuously record the signal during the molecular recognition, which typically requires few tens of minutes for obtaining a saturation.
Specifically, it is observed that the optical sensor device 100 and system 200 enable to asynchronously measure the analyte with respect to a molecular recognition reaction which leads to the bonds with the analyte, provided that the stability of the particles and bonds between it and the optical circuit surface is ensured. This enables to substantially relax the stability requirements of the different measure parameters (temperature, optical coupling, etcetera) with respect to the standard techniques using optical devices such as microresonators, without a magnetic particle-induced modulation.
In an embodiment of the present invention it is also possible to demodulate the differential signal obtained by electrically subtracting the outputs OU and OUD in order to cancel the common mode noises or without requiring possible normalizations of the signal itself. In this case, the electronic processing apparatus 203 is configured to demodulate the differential signal obtained by the subtraction (e.g., between electric signals obtained by corresponding opto-electronic converters) of the radiation at the output OU and at the additional output OUD, or by other analogous normalization forms.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
102017000145130 | Dec 2017 | IT | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/IB2018/060095 | 12/14/2018 | WO | 00 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2019/116337 | 6/20/2019 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
20060268408 | Toussaint, Jr. | Nov 2006 | A1 |
20130214040 | Beerling | Aug 2013 | A1 |
20130261010 | Bailey | Oct 2013 | A1 |
20140241590 | Day, Jr. | Aug 2014 | A1 |
20190038190 | Zhong | Feb 2019 | A1 |
20190338341 | Gusiatnikov | Nov 2019 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
2005524052 | Aug 2005 | JP |
WO-2005111619 | Nov 2005 | WO |
WO-2008072156 | Jun 2008 | WO |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20200386680 A1 | Dec 2020 | US |