Packaged bottle beverage having an ingredient release closure with improved additive release and method and apparatus thereof

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 8142827
  • Patent Number
    8,142,827
  • Date Filed
    Wednesday, April 16, 2008
    16 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, March 27, 2012
    12 years ago
Abstract
A packaged bottled beverage has a base component of the beverage in a container under vacuum separate from an additive in a sealed compartment of an ingredient release closure. Upon opening the sealed compartment, suction is created forcing the additive to quickly and thoroughly exit the ingredient release closure, a region of relatively higher pressure, and flow into the base component in the container, a region of relatively lower pressure.
Description
TECHNICAL FIELD

The present invention relates generally to packaged bottled beverages, and, more particularly, to such packaged bottled beverages having closures which contain compartments therein with additives for release into the bottles upon latter opening of the bottles by consumers and methods and apparatuses for same.


BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

Consumers have become increasingly particular with respect to the freshness of food and beverage products. As a result, food and beverage manufacturers have developed packaging which provides such freshness by allowing consumers to mix additional ingredients immediately prior to consumption. For example, yogurt containers are provided with lids having sealed compartments for storing additives such as granola, dried fruit, sugared confections and the like. The consumer opens the sealed compartment and mixes the additives with the yogurt immediately prior to consuming.


Beverage manufacturers are desirous of providing the same experience for consumers with respect to incorporating additives, such as flavors, vitamins, natural ingredients and the like, to base components of beverages immediately prior to consumption. Numerous closures for packaged bottled beverages have been developed which contain a compartment for storing additives. These ingredient release closures have various mechanisms to release the additives. For example, some ingredient release closures contain a frangible seal which may be broken, such as by puncturing, cutting or tearing, to release the ingredient. The frangible seal is typically designed to be broken before the closure is detached from the container, thus allowing the additive stored within the ingredient release closure to combine with the base component of the beverage with minimal spillage of the additive onto a nearby surface or the consumer. Other ingredient release closures utilize plunger type mechanisms which seal an opening between the body of the container and the compartment containing the additive. Upon moving the plunger, the additive is released into the base component of the beverage.


Regardless of the mechanism for releasing the additive into the container, the additive must be sufficiently and quickly eliminated from the ingredient release closure to insure a quality product for the consumer. Sufficient elimination depends in part on construction of the ingredient release closure. The ingredient release closure should be designed to have minimum obstructions between the opening of the compartment and the body of the container, allowing for open flow of the additive from the ingredient release closure into the container. The viscosity of the additive also plays a role in elimination because of its effect on the flow of the additive. Higher viscosity additives, such as those with a syrupy consistency, may have a slower flow rate as compared to lower viscosity additives, such as those with a watery consistency. Problems in managing the flow rate are complicated if the ingredient release closure has an obstructive configuration.


Thus, there exists a need in the art to develop a solution for improving the flow rate of additives such that, when released from an ingredient release closure, such additives may be sufficiently and quickly eliminated so as to immediately mix with the base components in containers.


BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

Briefly described, in a preferred embodiment, the present invention overcomes the above-mentioned disadvantages and meets the recognized need by providing a packaged bottled beverage with superior additive delivery having a base component of the beverage in a container under vacuum and separate from an additive in a sealed compartment of an ingredient release closure. Upon opening of the sealed compartment, suction is created forcing the additive to quickly and thoroughly exit the ingredient release closure, a region of higher pressure, and flow into the base component in the container, a region of lower pressure.


Accordingly, one feature and advantage of the present invention is its ability to provide a method of improving the delivery of an additive contained within a sealed compartment of an ingredient release closure into a base component of a beverage contained within a vessel of a container by applying compression to the outer surface of the vessel during the capping process to create a vacuum in the container.


Another feature and advantage of the present invention is its ability to provide a container closing apparatus in a filling plant that efficiently applies compression to a container during capping, thus creating vacuum within the sealed container.


These and other features and advantages of the present invention will become more apparent to those ordinarily skilled in the art after reading the following Detailed Description and Claims in light of the accompanying drawing Figures.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

Accordingly, the present invention will be understood best through consideration of, and with reference to, the following drawing Figures, viewed in conjunction with the Detailed Description referring thereto, in which like reference numbers throughout the various Figures designate like structure, and in which:



FIG. 1A is a side view of a container of the present invention;



FIG. 1B is a side view of a packaged bottled beverage of the present invention;



FIG. 2 is a cross-sectional view at line 2-2 of the container of FIG. 1A;



FIG. 3 is a cross-sectional view at line 3-3 of the packaged bottled beverage of FIG. 1B;



FIG. 4 is a schematic illustration of a capper star wheel mechanism employed in the apparatus and method of the present invention;



FIG. 5 is a perspective view of a container entering a container closing apparatus according to the apparatus and method of the present invention;



FIG. 6 is a top perspective view of an adjustable rail employed in the apparatus and method of the present invention;



FIG. 7 is a perspective view of a container in contact with the adjustable rail of the container closing apparatus according to the apparatus and method of the present invention; and



FIG. 8 is a cut away view of (i) an ingredient release closure containing an additive sealed to (ii) the top of a container containing a base component.





It is to be noted that the drawings presented are intended solely for the purpose of illustration and that they are, therefore, neither desired nor intended to limit the invention to any or all of the exact details of construction shown, except insofar as they may be deemed essential to the claimed invention.


DETAILED DESCRIPTION

In describing preferred embodiments of the present invention illustrated in FIGS. 1-8, specific terminology is employed for the sake of clarity. The invention, however, is not intended to be limited to the specific terminology so selected, and it is to be understood that each specific element includes all technical equivalents that operate in a similar manner to accomplish a similar purpose.


The present invention addresses the performance of packaged bottled beverages that have the additional feature of ingredient release closures containing additives providing consumers with freshly mixed beverages immediately prior to consumption. To insure quality performance of such packaged bottled beverages, the delivery outcome should result in sufficient and quick elimination of the additive from ingredient release closures. Regardless of the structure of ingredient release closures, this outcome may be achieved by providing in one preferred embodiment of the invention a packaged bottled beverage comprising: (a) a beverage comprising a base component and an additive; (b) a container comprising an opening for receiving an ingredient release closure and a vessel containing the base component; (c) the ingredient release closure comprising a sealed compartment containing the additive, a release mechanism for dispensing the additive and attaching means for attachment to the opening of the container; and (d) the attaching means of the closure attached to the opening of the container to form a packaged bottled beverage; wherein the base component is contained under vacuum in the container. In operation, the vacuum in the container creates a pressure differential between the base component and the additive in the ingredient release closure. Upon releasing the additive from the ingredient release closure using the release mechanism and prior to opening the packaged bottle beverage for drinking, the vacuum sufficiently and quickly pulls or draws the additive out of the ingredient release closure to provide a freshly mixed beverage with no spilling or leaking of the base component or additive. A pressure differential between a region of relatively higher pressure, i.e. the additive in the ingredient release closure, and a region of relatively lower pressure, i.e. the base component under vacuum in the container, enables a suction force between the ingredient release closure and the container to pull or draw the additive from the ingredient release closure into the base component in the container. Further, the additive preferably efficiently discharges from the ingredient release closure whereby minimal residual additive remains in the ingredient release closure.


The base component of the beverage may be water, tea, juice, energy drink or the like. The additive may be one or more flavors, vitamins, energy enhancements, natural ingredients or the like and may be in liquid or powdered form. The container may be metal, glass, plastic or the like. Preferably, the container is made from a flexible plastic such as polyethylene terephthalate, commonly referred to as PET. The ingredient release closure may be of any construction having a sealed compartment for containing the additive and a release mechanism such as a plunger, a frangible seal, or the like. Further, the ingredient release closure may be a sports type closure. The attaching means may be a crimped seal, a threaded seal or the like which provides a sufficient seal to prevent ingress of external gases; thereby, undesirably reducing the vacuum in the container. The vacuum may be formed by applying compression to an outer surface of the vessel, by a vacuum pump, by a vacuum chamber, or the like.


With reference to FIGS. 1A and 1B, packaged bottled beverage 10 comprises container 11 containing base component 80 and ingredient release closure 12. Container 11 preferably is made of flexible plastic, such as polyethylene terephthalate or the like. Container 11 has vessel 13 for holding the base component 80 of a beverage and opening 14 for receiving ingredient release closure 12. Best seen with reference to FIG. 1B and FIG. 8, ingredient release closure 12, as shown, is a sports closure having sealed compartment 15 containing additive 81, release mechanism 16 and spout 20. FIG. 1A represents container 11 when filled with the base component 80 and prior to application of ingredient release closure 12 containing additive 81. Vessel 13 has a circular cross-sectional shape in label panel area 17 along line 2-2 of FIG. 1A, as shown in FIG. 2. FIG. 1B represents packaged bottled beverage 10 with ingredient release closure 12 containing additive 81 attached to container 11 containing base component 80 under vacuum. Under vacuum, in one method of the present invention as more fully described below, the cross-section in label panel area 17 is altered by vacuum pressure forces which transform the circular cross-sectional shape into a square cross-sectional shape along line 3-3 of FIG. 1B, as shown in FIG. 3. Alternatively, the cross-sectional shape may take one of a variety of different forms, such as oval.


In use, the consumer activates ingredient release closure 12 by pulling up spout 20 to engage release mechanism 16 and transfer the additive into the base component of the beverage. With other ingredient release closures available in the art, consumers may activate the release mechanism by twisting, applying pressure, or the like depending on the mechanical function of the release mechanism.


In one example, a 0.5 liter lightweight container 11, which is made from 15 to 20 grams of PET, has a pre-vacuum diameter in label panel area 17 along line 2-2 of 6.35 centimeters. Under vacuum, the diameter is reduced to between 5.84 to 4.57 centimeters depending on the viscosity of the additive in ingredient release closure 12. Using a correlation in percentages, the diameter of vessel 13 in packaged bottled beverage 10 is 95% to 65%, preferably 92% to 72%, of the original size diameter of vessel 13 prior to attaching ingredient release closure 12 to container 11. For a 0.7 liter container with circular diameter of 6.92 centimeters, the diameter of packaged bottled beverage 10 would be preferably set to between 6.35 to 4.82 centimeters. When using a 0.5 liter container 11 made from 20-25 grams of PET, the wall thickness of the vessel 13 is greater. As such, the cross-sectional shape of the vessel 13 may be oval rather than square. The resulting cross-sectional shape of vessel 13 depends upon the amount of compression applied during the capping process as further discussed below. For container 11 made of flexible plastic, the vacuum is preferably created by application of compression to the outer surface of vessel 13, which effectively reduces the diameter of vessel 13. Alternatively, the vacuum is created utilizing a vacuum pump or vacuum chamber, which is effective for flexible and rigid containers alike.


In another preferred embodiment, a method for improving delivery of an additive contained within a sealed compartment of an ingredient release closure into a base component of a beverage contained within a vessel of a packaged bottled beverage comprises the steps of providing a container, a closure and a vacuum means. The container comprises (i) an opening for receiving a closure and (ii) a vessel containing a base component of a beverage. The closure comprises (i) a sealed compartment containing an additive, (ii) a release mechanism for dispensing the additive, and (iii) attaching means for attachment to the opening of the container. Preferably, in one simultaneous operation, the closure is attached to the opening of the container and a vacuum is created with the vacuum means to form a packaged bottled beverage with a container under vacuum. Preferably the container is a flexible container and the vacuum means is provided by applying compression to an outer surface of the vessel of the container. The compression is preferably applied to the outer surface of the vessel by an adjustable rail having a decreasing arc from a point of initial contact with the container to a point of final contact with the container. Other structures, such as plungers, projectors, opposing plates, rollers or the like, may be used to apply to the outer surface of the vessel. Alternatively, the vacuum means is provided by a vacuum pump or vacuum chamber.


With reference to FIGS. 4-7, another preferred embodiment of the invention shows container closing apparatus 40 in a bottled beverage filling plant, which conventionally includes rotatable capper star 41, rotatable capper mechanism 42 (partially shown), and fixed rear guide 43 spaced radially outwardly from capper star 41 for retaining containers 11 within capper star 41. Additional star wheel mechanisms are strategically situated to assist movement of containers 11 into and out of the capper star 41. A transfer star 44 is mated to capper star 41 and feeds filled containers 11 into capper star 41 at inlet 45. Discharge star 46 is mated to capper star 41 and transfers sealed containers 11a from outlet 47 of capper star 41. Both transfer star 44 and discharge star 46 have a rotatable star wheel mechanism having a plurality of pockets adapted to receive containers.


Capper star 41 is a rotatable star wheel mechanism having a plurality of capper pockets 48 adapted to receive containers 11 fed in an assembly line fashion thereto. Overlying capper star 41 is capper mechanism 42, such as a turret capper head, which rotates in synchronism with wheel 49 of capper star 41. Capper mechanism 42 has a plurality of capper heads 50, designed to apply ingredient release closures 12 to threaded neck 18 of containers 11 as shown in FIG. 1A. Best seen with reference to FIG. 7, capper heads 50 may employ a clutch mechanism whereby capper head 50 is rotated and driven axially downward at a predetermined force and torque limiting value to tighten ingredient release closures 12 onto threaded neck 18 of container 11. Fixed rear guide 43 extends between inlet 45 and outlet 47 of capper star 41. Fixed rear guide 43 is spaced radially outwardly from capper star 41 and functions to retain containers 11 in capper pockets 48 and in axial alignment with capper mechanism 42 as capper star 41 rotates. Capping mechanism 42 is preferably used to apply ingredient release closures 12 of the type having threading onto threaded neck 18 of containers 11, such as plastic PET containers. Plastic container 11, shown in FIG. 1A, is preferably of the type that has flange 19 extending radially outwardly from threaded neck 18 and positioned a spaced distance below threaded neck 18.


In the operation of container closing apparatus 40, filled containers 11 containing base component 80 are rotated in a first direction by transfer star 44 to inlet 45 on capper star 41, which rotates in a direction opposite the direction of rotation of transfer star 44. Ingredient release closures 12 containing additive 81 are supplied to filled containers 11 preferably through a supply channel (not shown) of capper mechanism 42, but may also already be placed on threaded necks 18 prior to entering capper mechanism 42. Capper mechanism 42 has rotation means to attach ingredient release closures 12 to filled containers 11. Sealed containers 11a with tightened ingredient release closures 12 containing additive 81 thereon and base component 80 therein are rotated out of capper star 41 at outlet 47 to discharge star 46 rotating in the same direction as transfer star 44 and from thence to a conveyor leading to further processing or handling equipment.


Upon entering container closing apparatus 40, container 11 is received by capping star 41 in specially contoured capper pocket 48, which is preferably semi-circular in shape and of a diameter similar to that of the diameter of container 11 which it engages. Best seen with reference to FIG. 5, container 11 is preferably held and suspended at threaded neck 18, in which the underside of flange 19 rests on top on upper ledge 51 of capper pocket 48. Panel 17 of container 11 is supported by fixed rear guide 43 of capper star 41 to hold container 11 in vertical alignment during the capping operation.


Adjustable rail 60, as shown in FIG. 6, has arcuate member 61 having proximate end 62, distal end 63, curved inner wall 64, and straight outer wall 65. Fixed fastening means 66 is located at distal end 63 and adjustable fastening means 67 is located at proximate end 62. With reference to FIG. 4, adjustable rail 60 is attached to fixed rear guide 43 with an arc of decreasing radius relative to fixed rear guide 43. The radius is decreased by securing fixed fastening means 66 near inlet 45 of capper star 41 and securing adjustable fastening means 67 near outlet 47 of capper star 41. Fixed fastening means 66 preferably is a nut and bolt that passes through a hole of substantially the same diameter. Adjustable fastening means 67 preferably is a nut and bolt that passes through a slot, which allows for adjustment of arcuate member 61 at a decreasing radius relative is to the radius of fixed rear guide 43. Adjusting the radius of arcuate member 61 is desirable for use with different size containers 11 or the need to vary the compression applied to containers 11. Any type of fastening means well known in the art may be used for either adjustable fastening means 67 or fixed fastening means 66.


With reference to FIG. 4 and FIG. 7, as filled container 11 containing base component 80 rotates in capper star 41, adjustable rail 60 comes in contact with filled container 11 at point A. Upon rotation of filled container 11 by capper star 41, the radius of arcuate member 61 decreases causing adjustable rail 65 to exert compression on outer wall 21 of filled container 11, as shown in FIG. 7. While compression is being applied, filled container 11 containing base component 80 is capped with ingredient release closure 12 containing additive 81 to form packaged bottled beverage 10 with container 11 under vacuum. Packaged bottled beverage 10 comes off adjustable rail 60 at point B and continues its rotation in capper star 41 until exiting at outlet 47 to discharge star 46. Upon exiting outlet 47, container 11 of packaged bottle beverage 10 changes in shape to adjust to the vacuum created therein. A standard packaged bottle beverage without internal vacuum has a circular cross-sectional shape as shown in FIG. 2. As the internal vacuum in container 11 of packaged bottled beverage 10 exerts negative pressure, the shape of container 11 containing base component 80 adjusts preferably to a square cross-sectional shape as shown in FIG. 3.


Having thus described exemplary embodiments of the present invention, it should be noted by those skilled in the art that the within disclosures are exemplary only and that various other alternatives, adaptations, and modifications may be made within the scope and spirit of the present invention. Accordingly, the present invention is not limited to the specific embodiments as illustrated herein.

Claims
  • 1. A packaged bottled beverage comprising: a container comprising (i) a container opening for receiving a closure and (ii) a container vessel containing a beverage base component;an ingredient release closure comprising a sealed compartment containing an additive, a release mechanism for dispensing the additive, and attaching means for attachment to said container opening of said container;said attaching means of said ingredient release closure attached to said container opening of said container,wherein said beverage base component is contained under vacuum in said container vessel, and said container vessel has an intentionally altered cross-sectional shape in a label panel area of said container vessel, said intentionally altered cross-sectional shape resulting in said vacuum.
  • 2. The packaged bottled beverage of claim 1, wherein upon releasing said additive from said ingredient release closure using said release mechanism, suction is created due to said vacuum in said container vessel, wherein the suction pulls said additive from said ingredient release closure into said beverage base component in said container vessel.
  • 3. The packaged bottled beverage of claim 1, wherein said container vessel comprises a flexible plastic.
  • 4. The packaged bottled beverage of claim 3, wherein said flexible plastic comprises polyethylene terephthalate.
  • 5. The packaged bottled beverage of claim 1, wherein said ingredient release closure comprises a sports closure having a pull-up spout engaged with said release mechanism.
  • 6. The packaged bottled beverage of claim 1, wherein said container vessel has a circular cross-sectional shape in the label panel area of said container vessel prior to being altered, and said intentionally altered cross-sectional shape comprises a square or oval cross-sectional shape.
  • 7. The packaged bottled beverage of claim 6, wherein said intentionally altered cross-sectional shape comprises a square cross-sectional shape.
  • 8. The packaged bottled beverage of claim 6, wherein said container vessel has an original diameter in the label panel area of said container vessel prior to being altered, and said intentionally altered cross-sectional shape has a corresponding cross-sectional dimension with a length ranging from about 95% to about 65% of the original diameter.
  • 9. The packaged bottled beverage of claim 8, wherein said intentionally altered cross-sectional shape has a corresponding cross-sectional dimension with a length ranging from about 92% to about 72% of the original diameter.
  • 10. The packaged bottled beverage of claim 1, wherein said beverage base component comprises water, tea, juice, or an energy drink; and said additive comprises one or more additives selected from flavors, vitamins, energy enhancements, or natural ingredients.
  • 11. A method of creating a vacuum in the container vessel of the packaged bottled beverage of claim 1, said method comprising: applying compression to an outer surface of the container vessel during a capping process.
  • 12. A method for improving delivery of an additive contained within a sealed compartment of an ingredient release closure into a beverage base component so as to form a final beverage contained within a container vessel of a packaged bottled beverage, said method comprising the steps of: providing a container comprising (i) a container opening for receiving a closure and (ii) a container vessel containing a beverage base component;providing a closure comprising (i) a sealed compartment containing an additive, (ii) a release mechanism for dispensing the additive, and (iii) attaching means for attachment to the container opening of the container;andattaching the closure to the container opening of the container while creating a vacuum within the container vessel so as to form a packaged bottled beverage having the container vessel under vacuum,wherein the container vessel is a flexible container vessel and said step of creating a vacuum within the container vessel comprises applying compression to an outer surface of the container vessel during said attaching step so as to intentionally alter a cross-sectional shape of the container vessel in a label panel area of the container vessel.
  • 13. The method of claim 12, wherein the compression is applied to the outer surface of the container vessel by an adjustable rail having a decreasing arc from a point of initial contact with the container vessel to a point of final contact with the container vessel.
  • 14. The method of claim 12, wherein the step of creating a vacuum within the container vessel reduces an original diameter of the container vessel in a label panel area of the container vessel to a cross-sectional length ranging from about 92% to about 72% of the original diameter.
  • 15. The method of claim 12, further comprising: pulling up a spout component of the closure so as to activate the release mechanism and initiate dispensing of the additive into the beverage base component contained within the container vessel.
  • 16. A packaged bottled beverage comprising: a container comprising (i) a container opening for receiving a closure and (ii) a container vessel containing a beverage base component and having an intentionally altered cross-sectional shape in a label panel area of said container vessel;an ingredient release closure comprising a sealed compartment containing an additive, a release mechanism for dispensing the additive, a spout for activating said release mechanism, and attaching means for attaching said ingredient release closure to said container opening of said container;said attaching means of said ingredient release closure being attached to said container opening of said container,wherein said beverage base component is contained under vacuum in said container vessel, said vacuum resulting from said intentionally altered cross-sectional shape.
  • 17. The packaged bottled beverage of claim 16, wherein said spout comprises a pull-up spout.
  • 18. The packaged bottled beverage of claim 17, wherein said container vessel has a circular cross-sectional shape in the label panel area of said container vessel prior to being altered, and said intentionally altered cross-sectional shape comprises a square or oval cross-sectional shape.
  • 19. The packaged bottled beverage of claim 17, wherein said container vessel has a circular cross-sectional shape in the label panel area of said container vessel prior to being altered, and said intentionally altered cross-sectional shape comprises a square cross-sectional shape.
  • 20. The packaged bottled beverage of claim 16, wherein said spout has a spout exit in fluid communication with said container vessel.
US Referenced Citations (48)
Number Name Date Kind
3295293 Lodding Jan 1967 A
3457699 Tatibanu Jul 1969 A
3491803 Galik Jan 1970 A
3590557 Vogel Jul 1971 A
3674060 Ruekberg Jul 1972 A
3945174 Franz Mar 1976 A
3973603 Franz Aug 1976 A
4102451 Clarke et al. Jul 1978 A
4338765 Ohmori et al. Jul 1982 A
4497855 Agrawal et al. Feb 1985 A
4642968 McHenry et al. Feb 1987 A
4889250 Beyer Dec 1989 A
4905450 Hansen et al. Mar 1990 A
4939890 Peronek et al. Jul 1990 A
5000314 Fuller et al. Mar 1991 A
5014492 Fiorini et al. May 1991 A
5060453 Alberghini et al. Oct 1991 A
5090180 Sorensen Feb 1992 A
5143211 Miczka et al. Sep 1992 A
5809741 Tovey Sep 1998 A
5819507 Kaneko et al. Oct 1998 A
6003728 Elliott Dec 1999 A
6165523 Story Dec 2000 A
6435383 Lee Aug 2002 B1
6517878 Heczko Feb 2003 B2
6523330 Hurd Feb 2003 B1
6755298 Heuft et al. Jun 2004 B1
6908011 Cho Jun 2005 B2
6935493 Cho Aug 2005 B2
6962254 Spector Nov 2005 B2
6974024 Cho Dec 2005 B2
6994211 Cho Feb 2006 B2
7017735 Carlson Mar 2006 B2
7028857 Peronek Apr 2006 B2
7070046 Cho Jul 2006 B2
7083043 Sharon Aug 2006 B2
7325372 Bernhard Feb 2008 B2
7503453 Cronin et al. Mar 2009 B2
7546919 Lee Jun 2009 B2
7617929 Lee et al. Nov 2009 B2
7748526 Iwatschenko Jul 2010 B2
20020119222 Searle et al. Aug 2002 A1
20030222102 Cho Dec 2003 A1
20040187441 Cirio Sep 2004 A1
20070006550 Kemper et al. Jan 2007 A1
20100012532 Frutin Jan 2010 A1
20100163442 Lee et al. Jul 2010 A1
20100187142 Lee et al. Jul 2010 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (2)
Number Date Country
WO 2008023197 Feb 2008 WO
WO2009146192 Dec 2009 WO
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20090260690 A1 Oct 2009 US