The present disclosure relates to the field of the authentication of a content such as a beverage, in particular an alcoholic beverage. More specifically, the present disclosure concerns a device and a method to authenticate a beverage through the walls of a container, more particularly when the container is a bottle.
The statements in this section merely provide background information related to the present disclosure and may not constitute prior art.
The production and marketing costs of the high-end alcoholic beverages, such as vintage wines and spirits, lead to high selling prices. These high prices generate, as often for the luxury products, fraud as well as acts of counterfeiting. Thus, there is regularly observed the appearance on the market of counterfeit bottles, that is to say having the external appearance of a genuine bottle, but filled with a beverage of much lower quality than the quality of the original product. This phenomenon of counterfeiting is particularly significant for high-end wines and spirits, such as cognac.
For economic, safety and brand image reasons, the concerned producers are vigorously fighting against these acts of fraud and counterfeiting. This struggle is reflected in particular in the manufacture of bottles including increasingly advanced anti-counterfeiting devices, aiming at preventing the exact reproduction of a bottle and/or its reuse.
However, counterfeiters also make constant efforts and are able to reproduce genuine bottles with such faithfulness that it becomes very difficult to distinguish a counterfeit bottle from a genuine bottle. In other cases, counterfeiters recover used genuine bottles, which are then filled with a non-genuine product.
In addition, this question of authentication arises in various places related to different actors in the distribution chain (resellers, distributors, etc.).
The present disclosure provides a portable device for controlling an alcoholic beverage in an at least partially transparent container, including:
a single light source emitting a monochromatic excitation light beam having a wavelength between 350 and 650 nanometers;
a beam splitter oriented at 45° with respect to the direction of emission of the light source to reflect the excitation light beam;
a focus and collection lens;
a positioning device allowing to orient the light beam coming from the light source along a direction substantially normal to the outer surface of the container, the positioning device also allowing to position the outer surface of the container at a predetermined distance from the focus lens, the predetermined distance between the focus lens and the container is chosen so that the light beam is focused inside the container, at a distance from the wall of the container less than 1 millimeter, and in one form is less than 500 micrometers, the positioning device including a through opening for the passage of the light beam coming from the light source;
a filtering device for filtering the fluorescence radiation captured by the focus lens and transmitted by the beam splitter, so as to eliminate the wavelengths which are shorter than or equal to the wavelength of the light beam emitted by the light source;
a spectrometer module for producing a signal corresponding to the measured spectrum of the fluorescence radiation of the beverage; and
an analysis module for comparing the measured spectrum with a reference spectrum.
By using the fluorescence phenomenon, the device in accordance with the present disclosure allows reducing the power of the excitation light source with respect to known devices, particularly those using the Raman effect (the intensity of the light emitted in the fluorescence process is indeed about a million times more intense than the Raman scattering). The device in accordance with the present disclosure includes a single light source, which contributes to the simplicity and portability of the system. In addition, by being limited to wavelengths greater than 350 nanometers, the influence of water and ethanol molecules (very much predominating in concentration in an alcoholic beverage such as a wine or a spirit) is limited. Indeed, water and ethanol molecules do not absorb the light radiation for wavelengths which are greater than 200 nanometers. Furthermore, by providing an assembly called “reflection” assembly, the attenuation of the fluorescence radiation is limited. Moreover, the 180° angle of incidence between the emitted ray and the reflected fluorescence ray allows reducing the undesirable effects due to the wall of the container, since the traversed thickness will be relatively thin. Further, by providing a positioning device, the focus of the emitted beam will be at the desired location, without further adjustments. The repeatability and reproducibility of the measurements are thus enhanced.
In one form, the beam splitter is a dichroic filter, in particular a high-pass dichroic filter (relative to the wavelengths).
In another form, the filtering device includes a Notch-type band-stop filter and/or a high-pass filter (relative to the wavelengths).
In another form, the spectrometer module is linked to the filtering device via an optical fiber.
In another form, the positioning device includes a contact surface configured to be complementary to the outer surface of the container.
In another form, the device includes a display device allowing in particular to display the result of the comparison between the measured spectrum and the reference spectrum.
In another form, the device includes a casing which is secured to the positioning device.
In another form, the casing includes all the components of the device.
In another form, the positioning device is connected to the casing by a flexible connection, the focus lens being integrated to the positioning device, the flexible connection including an optical fiber for transmitting the light beams passing through the focus lens.
In another form, the analysis module and the display device are included in an appended portable device, such as a tablet computer or a mobile phone.
In another form, the device includes a connection to a remote database.
The present disclosure also concerns a system for controlling an alcoholic beverage, the system including a device as defined above and a database stored in a remote server of the device.
In one form, the database includes one or more reference spectrum/spectra that can be downloaded by the device.
The present disclosure further concerns a method for controlling an alcoholic beverage through an at least partially transparent container, the method including the steps of:
acquiring a fluorescence spectrum of the beverage through the wall of the container;
normalizing the profile of the spectrum measured with respect to the maximum intensity of the reference spectrum;
calculating a resemblance factor between the measured spectrum and the reference spectrum; and
determining, according to the obtained value of the resemblance factor, whether the beverage is genuine.
The control method in accordance with the present disclosure has many advantages. Thanks to the step of normalizing the measured spectrum, for example with respect to the maximum intensity of the reference spectrum, the dispersions due to the temperature of the controlled content and to the variations in the characteristics of the container (in particular the dimensional characteristics) are avoided. This normalization step also allows collecting, with a low-power excitation source, a signal of sufficient quality to be correctly analyzed. In addition, the step of comparing the measured spectrum with the reference spectrum, which involves the calculation of a resemblance factor, involves very limited calculation capacity, which capacity is now available on a “smartphone” type mobile phone.
In one form, the fluorescence spectrum is acquired by using a source emitting a monochromatic beam of a wavelength comprised between 350 and 650 nanometers.
In another form, the resemblance factor is calculated over a predetermined wavelength range, for example a wavelength range between 550 and 650 nanometers.
In another form, the resemblance factor is calculated by the method called least squares method or by an algorithm of the Hausdorff algorithm type.
In another form, the beverage is determined to be non-genuine if the resemblance factor is greater than 20.
In another form, the reference spectrum is obtained from the measurement of the fluorescence spectrum measured on a sample of a plurality of genuine bottles.
In another form, the method includes a step of downloading the reference spectrum from a remote database.
In another form, the method is implemented using a device or a system as defined above.
Further areas of applicability will become apparent from the description provided herein. It should be understood that the description and specific examples are intended for purposes of illustration only and are not intended to limit the scope of the present disclosure.
In order that the disclosure may be well understood, there will now be described various forms thereof, given by way of example, reference being made to the accompanying drawings, in which:
The drawings described herein are for illustration purposes only and are not intended to limit the scope of the present disclosure in any way.
The following description is merely exemplary in nature and is not intended to limit the present disclosure, application, or uses. It should be understood that throughout the drawings, corresponding reference numerals indicate like or corresponding parts and features.
As seen in
As shown in
The wavelength λ0 of the light source 32 is between 350 nanometers and 650 nanometers. This range allows obtaining that the emitted light beam generates a strong fluorescence emission of the molecules allowing to characterize the alcoholic beverage (that is to say the molecules other than those of water and ethanol). Moreover, in this range, the beam emitted by the light source 32 is only slightly attenuated by the glass of the bottle 2. Still in this range, the fluorescence emission of the content of the bottle 2 is only very weakly attenuated by the glass of the bottle 2.
The light beam 34 coming from the light source 32 is directed toward a beam splitter 36. The beam splitter 36, for example a dichroic filter, is oriented according to a 45° angle with respect to the direction of the light beam 34 emitted by the source 32. Thus, the beam emitted by the source 32 is reflected by the beam splitter 36 and the reflected beam 38 is directed toward a focus lens 40, for example an achromatic doublet lens. The focus lens 40 is located at a distance A from the bottle 2.
As seen in
The spacing provided by the wedge 12 between the focus lens 40 and the bottle 2 will be determined so that the reflected beam 38 is focused inside the bottle 2, within the beverage 26, but as close as possible to the inner surface 24.
The fluorescence signal 42 induced in the content of the bottle 2 by the light beam is collected by the focus lens 40, by retro-emission, and is directed toward the beam splitter 36. The beam splitter 36 allows the fluorescence signal, which is directed toward a spectrometer module 50, to pass.
Advantageously, the device 1 includes one or more filtering device(s) allowing to filter the fluorescence signal 42 before the latter is transmitted to the spectrometer module. The purpose of this filtering is in particular to eliminate the component of the signal collected by the focus lens 40 linked to the light beam emitted by the source 32. For this purpose, there is provided for example a band-stop filter 44 or “notch” filter. The interval of frequencies not transmitted by the band-stop filter will be close to the wavelength of the monochromatic light beam emitted by the source 32. The non-transmitted band will have for example a width of about 10 nanometers, and will be centered over a wavelength greater, by a few nanometers or less (for example 1 nanometer), to the wavelength λ0 of the laser source.
It can further be provided that an additional high-pass type filtering (with respect to the wavelengths), is performed by the beam splitter 36. In this case, the beam splitter 36 is a high-pass type dichroic filter with a high cutoff slope (in particular an “edge”-type filter) which reflects the beam 34 toward the focus lens, and transmits the radiation emitted by the beverage and its container to the spectrometer module by eliminating the wavelengths which are shorter than a threshold value corresponding to the wavelength of the monochromatic beam emitted by the source 32 increased by about 10 nm.
In the example of
In one variant, the lens 46 may be replaced by a magnification lens.
The spectrometer module 50 includes a diffraction grating 52 allows directing the diffracted signal toward a sensor 54, for example a CCD-type sensor which has the advantage of not requiring cooling. For example, the diffraction grating 52 is a reflective diffraction grating. The signal entering the spectrometer module 50, via an input slot 56, is directed toward a first mirror 58, which is a convex mirror. The signal reflected by the diffraction grating 52 is directed toward a second planar-type mirror 60. The second mirror reflects the diffracted signal toward the sensor 54. In one variant, the set 52-58-60 can be replaced by a single concave diffraction grating allowing to improve the compactness of the device. In another variant, the set 52-58-60 can be replaced by a single diffraction grating operating in transmission.
The sensor 54 provides a signal corresponding to a fluorescence spectrum. This signal is transmitted from the spectrometer module 50 to an analysis module 62. The analysis module 62 includes in particular a storage unit 64, allowing to store in memory a signal coming from the spectrometer module. The storage unit 64 has a capacity allowing to store a signal obtained over a certain acquisition time, for example in the order of 150 milliseconds. The analysis module 62 further includes a calculation unit 66, allowing to determine whether the recorded signal corresponds to that of a genuine beverage. To this end, the calculation unit 66 performs in particular a comparison between the recorded signal and a reference signal, according to the method in accordance with the present disclosure, which will be described in more detail below. The reference signal may be previously stored in the storage unit 64 and/or downloaded or updated from a remote database. To this end, the analysis module 62 includes a communication unit 68, in particular of the wireless type.
The device finally includes a display device 70, allowing to display the result of the test. The display device 70 may include a display screen or any other means, such as a plurality of indicator lights (made for example with light-emitting diodes). For example, it is possible to provide that the result of the test is given according to one of two even three possibilities: “GOOD”, “BAD” and possibly “DUBIOUS”. In the case of a plurality of indicator lights, it will be thus possible to provide three different indicators (in particular of different colors), each corresponding indicator lighting up respectively according to one of the three possibilities mentioned above.
Alternatively, part or all of the analysis module 62 and/or of the display device 70 may be disposed in a casing distinct from the rest of the device.
The control method in accordance with the present disclosure allowing the authentication of an alcoholic beverage is described hereinafter, in the context of an example applied to a cognac. The main steps of the method in accordance with the present disclosure are shown in
The method in accordance with the present disclosure includes a first step comprising acquiring a measured spectrum of the controlled beverage. This acquisition step 80 is carried out in particular by the spectrometer module 50 of the device 1.
The method then includes a comparison step 82 of the measured spectrum with a reference spectrum. This reference spectrum can be stored in a memory of the device 1, for example a memory of the storage unit 64, or can be downloaded from a remote database. Optionally, the method may include a step 84 of selecting the reference spectrum. This selection can be made among several reference spectra stored in memory, or among several reference spectra available in the remote database. This selection can be done automatically or to the user's request.
The comparison step 82 of the measured spectrum with the reference spectrum includes a sub-step comprising normalization of the measured spectrum, with respect to the maximum of the reference spectrum (or alternatively, with respect to the total intensity of the spectrum or with respect to the area under the spectrum). This normalization has several advantages. This allows in particular overcoming the effects of the temperature variations. The temperature is known to have a significant influence on the fluorescence phenomenon. But the inventors have discovered that a temperature change has a significant influence on the maximum intensity of the fluorescence spectrum, and a negligible influence in the form of the fluorescence spectrum profile. In other words, after normalization, spectra of the same beverage obtained at different temperatures are superimposable. Thus, the method in accordance with the present disclosure allows overcoming temperature variations during the collection of the fluorescence spectrum. Particularly, this allows taking into account the difference between the temperature at which the measured spectrum is collected and the temperature at which the reference spectrum has been created. In addition, the normalization of the measured spectrum allows overcoming the effects of the dispersions observed between each bottle of the same type. It is known that the same products on the same production line, two “identical” containers (such as glass bottles) will have dispersions, in particular dimensional dispersions (and therefore in the thickness). However, the greater the glass thickness, the more the beam emitted by the excitation source will be attenuated and also the more the emitted fluorescence radiation will be attenuated in the wall of the container. However, the inventors have discovered that this attenuation had a limited influence on the profile of the collected fluorescence spectrum, the attenuation having especially the effect of reducing the intensity of the spectrum. This influence on the profile of the spectrum is even more negligible if the length of the spectrum collected is less than 700 nanometers. It is therefore advantageous to limit the range of wavelengths used to implement the comparison step, for example between 550 and 650 nanometers. Thus, the method in accordance with the present disclosure allows overcoming thickness variations for the same container model.
The comparison step 82 of the measured spectrum with the reference spectrum includes a sub-step of determining a resemblance factor R between the curves corresponding respectively to a measured spectrum for a given beverage and to the reference spectrum corresponding to this beverage, for example the curves C′2 and C′1. This sub-step thus allows quantifying the resemblance between the measured spectrum and the reference spectrum. This factor R can be calculated for example by using the least squares method, according to the formula:
wherein:
A zero value is thus obtained if the two spectra are completely identical. The higher the factor R, the more the compared spectra differ.
Of course, the resemblance factor can be calculated by using any other adapted algorithm such as, for example, the Hausdorff algorithm, according to the following formula:
According to this formula, we calculate for each point y1(λi) of the spectrum y1(λ) its smallest distance to the points of the spectrum y2(λ). We then choose the greatest calculated distance noted δmax(y1, y2). We then perform the same calculation for each point of the spectrum y2(λ) compared to the spectrum y1(λ) by choosing the greatest calculated distance δmax(y2, y1). The resemblance factor or Hausdorff distance will then be the greatest value of these two maximum retained distances.
Whatever the method used, we obtain a zero R value if the two spectra are completely identical. Likewise, whatever the method used, the higher the factor R, the more the compared spectra differ.
The R value will be calculated on at least a hundred points, advantageously several hundred. For example, the number of points taken into account is in the order of 600.
The R value is used during the evaluation step 86 of the authenticity of the beverage. This step allows determining, based on the calculated value of the resemblance factor R whether the controlled bottle contains a genuine beverage or not. For example, the tested content will be declared “bad” if the resemblance factor R is greater than a predetermined value, for example equal to 20.
By implementing a comparison by calculation of a resemblance factor that involve limited calculation resources, the method in accordance with the present disclosure leads to a low calculation time. Advantageously, the measured spectrum will be collected and/or compared to the reference spectrum only over a limited range, for example between 550 and 650 nanometers. Restricting the field of analysis allows indeed excluding the possible residual luminescence of the glass and, as explained above, overcoming the thickness variations of the wall of the container. In addition, restricting the field of analysis allows further reducing the calculation time.
The device and the method in accordance with the present disclosure provides a portable device that is simple and quick to use. By normalizing the spectra with respect to the intensity maxima, both the dispersions related to the temperature of the content and to the shape of the container are avoided, and the calculation capacity is reduced.
In addition, the architecture and operation of the device allow limiting the maximum number of components. Thus, thanks to the choice of an excitation light source emitting at a determined wavelength, the use of filters is avoided in order to select a narrow band of wavelengths. By enhancing the intensity and the quality of the fluorescence signal, in particular by the choice of the wavelength of the laser source, it is possible to use a low power laser source, for example of a few milliwatts. This allows providing an autonomous device that can operate on batteries or cells, and avoiding the need for a cooling device. In this respect, it will be noted that the choice of a CCD-type sensor for the spectrometer module also avoids providing any cooling.
The description of the disclosure is merely exemplary in nature and, thus, variations that do not depart from the substance of the disclosure are intended to be within the scope of the disclosure. Such variations are not to be regarded as a departure from the spirit and scope of the disclosure.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
15 57433 | Jul 2015 | FR | national |
This application is a continuation of International Application No. PCT/FR2016/051971, filed on Jul. 28, 2016, which claims priority to and the benefit of FR 15/57433 filed on Jul. 31, 2015. The disclosures of the above applications are incorporated herein by reference.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
20040000653 | Nordlund | Jan 2004 | A1 |
20070023521 | Wildey et al. | Feb 2007 | A1 |
20110184681 | Augustine | Jul 2011 | A1 |
20110292376 | Kukushkin | Dec 2011 | A1 |
20150009490 | Poteet et al. | Jan 2015 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
2002033404 | Apr 2002 | WO |
2005001451 | Jan 2005 | WO |
2014184506 | Nov 2014 | WO |
Entry |
---|
International Search Report for International Application PCT/FR2016/051971, dated Jan. 9, 2017. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20180149592 A1 | May 2018 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | PCT/FR2016/051971 | Jul 2016 | US |
Child | 15884721 | US |