QPSK modulated backscatter system

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6456668
  • Patent Number
    6,456,668
  • Date Filed
    Tuesday, December 31, 1996
    27 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, September 24, 2002
    22 years ago
Abstract
In accordance with the present invention, a duplex radio communication system comprises an Interrogator which generates a radio signal to at least one remote Tag. The remote Tag receives the radio signal. The Tag then generates a subcarrier signal, and using Quadrature Phase Shift Keying (QPSK), modulates an information signal onto the subcarrier. A Backscatter Modulator, using this modulated subcarrier, modulates the reflection of the radio signal, the reflected signal being a reflected modulated signal. The Interrogator receives and demodulates the reflected modulated signal to obtain the information signal. In one embodiment, demodulation utilizes a homodyne detector. In another embodiment, the Interrogator modulates an information signal onto the radio signal, transmits that modulated radio signal to the Tag, and the Tag demodulates that modulated radio signal to recover the information signal. In another embodiment, higher order phase modulations are used to modulate an information signal onto the subcarrier.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




1. Field of the Invention




This invention relates to wireless communication systems and, more particularly, to a wireless communication system using modulated backscatter technology.




2. Description of the Related Art




Radio Frequency IDentification (RFID) systems are used for identification and/or tracking of equipment, inventory, or living things. RFID systems are radio communication systems that communicate between a radio transceiver, called an Interrogator, and a number of inexpensive devices called Tags or transponders. In RFID systems, the Interrogator communicates to the Tags using modulated radio signals, and the Tags respond with modulated radio signals. The Interrogator first transmits an amplitude modulated signal to the Tag. Then, the Interrogator transmits a Continuous-Wave (CW) radio signal to the Tag. The Tag then modulates the CW signal using Modulated BackScattering (MBS) where the antenna is electrically switched, by the Tag's modulating signal, from being an absorber of RF radiation to being a reflector of RF radiation; thereby encoding the Tag's information onto the CW radio signal. The Interrogator demodulates the incoming modulated radio signal and decodes the Tag's information message.




MBS systems typically utilize amplitude modulated techniques for communications from the Interrogator to the Tag. For Tag to Interrogator MBS communications, prior art maintains the use of Frequency Shift Keying modulation techniques. Prior art also maintains baseband homodyne detection of the MBS signal at the interrogator; however baseband homodyne detection suffers from oscillator phase noise, large DC offsets, and mixer noise.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




In an embodiment of this invention, we disclose techniques for utilizing Quadrature Phase Shift Keying (QPSK) in an MBS system; we also disclose techniques for extending QPSK to higher orders of phase modulation.




In accordance with an embodiment of the present invention, a duplex radio communication system comprises an Interrogator which generates a radio signal to at least one remote Tag. The remote Tag receives the radio signal. The Tag then generates a subcarrier signal, and using Quadrature Phase Shift Keying (QPSK), modulates an information signal onto the subcarrier. A Backscatter Modulator, using this modulated subcarrier, modulates the reflection of the radio signal, the reflected signal being a reflected modulated signal. The Interrogator receives and demodulates the reflected modulated signal to obtain the information signal. In one embodiment, demodulation utilizes a homodyne detector. In another embodiment, the Interrogator modulates an information signal onto the radio signal, transmits that modulated radio signal to the Tag, and the Tag demodulates that modulated radio signal to recover the information signal. In another embodiment, higher order phase modulations are used to modulate an information signal onto the subcarrier.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWING





FIG. 1

shows a block diagram of an illustrative Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) system;





FIG. 2

shows a block diagram of an illustrative Interrogator Unit used in the RFID system of

FIG. 1

;





FIG. 3

shows a block diagram of a Tag Unit used in the RFID system of

FIG. 1

;





FIG. 4

shows a block diagram of a Differential Quadrature Phase Shift Keying (DQPSK) baseband encoder process;





FIG. 5

shows a logic diagram of an illustrative external MBS subcarrier modulation circuit;





FIG. 6

illustrates the four phases of the sub-carrier; and





FIG. 7

shows a logic diagram of a Gate Array DQPSK receiver.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION




One class of RFID applications involves using RFID technology to read information from a Tag affixed to a container or pallet. In this application, the container is moved across the reading field of an Interrogator. The reading field is defined as that volume of space within which a successful communication can take place. While the Tag is in the reading field, the Interrogator and Tag must complete their information exchange before the Tag moves out of the field. Since the Tag is moving through the reading field, the RFID system has only a limited amount of time to successfully complete the transaction.




With reference to

FIG. 1

, there is shown an overall block diagram of an illustrative RFID system useful for describing the application of the present invention. An Application Processor


101


communicates over Local Area Network (LAN)


102


to a plurality of Interrogators


103


-


14




104


. The Interrogators may then each communicate with one or more of the Tags


105


-


107


. For example, the Interrogator


103


receives an information signal, typically from an Application Processor


101


. The Interrogator


103


takes this information signal and Processor


200


(

FIG. 2

) properly formats a downlink message (Information Signal


200




a


) to be sent to the Tag. The information signal (


200




a


) includes information such as information specifying which Tag is to respond (each Tag may have fixed or programmed identification number), instructions for the Tag's processor to execute or other information to be used and/or stored by the Tag's processor. With joint reference to

FIGS. 1 and 2

, Radio Signal Source


201


generates a radio signal, the Modulator


202


modulates the Information Signal


200




a


onto the radio signal, and the Transmitter


203


sends this modulated signal via Antenna


204


, illustratively using amplitude modulation, to a Tag. Amplitude modulation is a common choice since the Tag can demodulate such a signal with a single, inexpensive nonlinear device (such as a diode).




In the Tag


105


(see FIG.


3


), the Antenna


301


(frequently a loop or patch antenna) receives the modulated signal. This signal is demodulated, directly to baseband, using the Detector/Modulator


302


, which, illustratively, could be a single Schottky diode. The diode should be appropriately biased with a current level so that the impedance of the diode matches the impedance of the Antenna


301


such that losses of the radio signal are minimized. The result of the diode detector is essentially a demodulation of the incoming signal directly to baseband. The Information Signal


200




a


is then amplified, by Amplifier


303


, and synchronization recovered in Clock and Frame Recovery Circuit


304


. The Clock Recovery Circuit


304


can be enhanced by having the Interrogator send the amplitude modulated signal using Manchester encoding. If large amounts of data are being transferred in frames, frame synchronization may be implemented, for example, by detecting a predetermined bit pattern that indicates the start of a frame. The bit pattern may be detected by clock recovery circuit (


304


) or processor (


305


). Bit pattern detection is well known in the art. The resulting information is sent to a Processor


305


. The Processor


305


is typically an inexpensive 4- or 8-bit microprocessor and its associated memory; the Clock Recovery Circuit


304


can be implemented in an ASIC (Applied Specific Integrated Circuit) which works together with Processor


305


. This Processor


305


can also serve as the driver for an optional Display Unit


309


should this Tag require a display. The Processor


305


generates an Information Signal


306


based on the particular program being executed by processor


305


. Signal


306


is eventually communicated from the Tag


105


back to the Interrogator (e.g.,


103


). This Information Signal


306


is sent to a Modulator Control Circuit


307


, which uses the Information Signal


306


to modulate a subcarrier frequency generated by the subcarrier Frequency Source


308


. The Frequency Source


308


could be a crystal oscillator separate from the Processor


305


, or it could be a frequency source derived from signals present inside the Processor


305


—such as a divisor of the primary clock frequency of the Processor. The Modulated Subcarrier Signal


311


is used by Detector/Modulator


302


to modulate the modulated signal received from Tag


105


to produce a modulated backscatter (e.g., reflected) signal. This is accomplished by switching on and off the Schottky diode using the Modulated Subcarrier Signal


311


, thereby changing the reflectance of Antenna


301


. A Battery


310


or other power supply provides power to the circuitry of Tag


105


. Power may also be received, for example, by using inductive coupling on microwaves.




Modulation




There are a variety of techniques for using MBS to send information from the Tag to the Interrogator. In some MBS technologies, the Modulator Control Circuit


307


of the Tag generates an amplitude modulated signal modulated at an Information Signal


306


frequency f


2


. If the Radio Signal Source


201


generates a CW frequency f


c


, then the Interrogator receives signals at f


c


whose bandwidth is 2f


2


and filters signals outside of this bandwidth range. This approach could be termed the “MBS at baseband” approach.




Another approach would be for the Tag to generate a subcarrier frequency f


s


, generated by Frequency Source


308


, as shown in FIG.


3


. The information could be conveyed using AM, FSK or Phase Shift Keying (PSK) by modulating the subcarrier with a frequency of f


s


with the Information Signal having a primary frequency f


2




306


. The Interrogator receives signals at f


c


whose bandwidth is 2f


2


but at a frequency f


s


away from f


c


. This method is termed “MBS of a subcarrier”.




In a Binary PSK (BPSK) system the phase of the subcarrier transitions nominally between 0 and 180 degrees. We disclose here specific techniques to apply Quadrature PSK (QPSK) to MBS systems. Based upon this disclosure, general levels of phase modulation are possible (such as MPSK), or other complex modulation schemes such as Differentially-encoded BPSK (DBPSK) or Differentially-encoded QPSK (DQPSK).




When the Tag detects the presence of the Interrogator downlink signal it responds by transmitting its RFID data. In one embodiment, the Tag differentially encodes the uplink data and uses the differentially encoded data to QPSK modulate the subcarrier. The QPSK modulated a subcarrier


311


modulates the reflected CW signal, which has a frequency f


c


by changing the reflectance of antenna


301


using signal


311


.

FIG. 4

shows the baseband encoding algorithm for DQPSK. The data bits, at rate f


2


(for example, 100 k bit/sec, are taken two at a time, Gray encoded, and then the Gray encoded bits G


I


and G


Q


are added to the previous phase of the QPSK modulated signal; the result is the present phase of the baseband DQPSK signal. Gray encoder


410


does a simple conversion in accordance with the following: IQ=00→G


I


G


Q


=00; IQ=01→G


I


G


Q


=01; IQ=10→G


I


G


Q


=11; IQ=11→G


I


G


Q


=10. The outputs, G


I


G


Q


of Gray encoder


410


are provided to phase adder


420


. Phase adder


420


simply does a module


2


addition of G


I


G


Q


and the present value of G


I


{grave over ( )}G


Q


{grave over ( )} to produce the new value of G


I


{grave over ( )}G


Q


{grave over ( )}. For example if G


I


G


Q


=11 and the present value of G


I


{grave over ( )}G


Q


{grave over ( )}=01 the new value of G


I


G


Q




=00. The information signal (306) is used to modulate the subcarrier which has a frequency f




s


(for example 250 kHz); the Modulated Subcarrier Signal


311


is used to control the reflectivity of the Detector Modulator


302


thereby sending a CW signal (having frequency f


c


) that has been modulated by the DQPSK modulated subcarrier back to the Interrogator. For QPSK systems the Interrogator receives signals at f


c


whose bandwidth is f


2


but at a frequency f


s


away from f


c


.




There are at least two ways in which to modulate the subcarrier


311


. The first method derives the subcarrier from the microprocessor crystal circuit (


312


) and is generated internally by the microprocessor


305


. Here the DQPSK data is stored as a phase “word” inside the microprocessor memory. During uplink transmission the word representing the current data bit is written to an external Port to produce


306


which controls the backscattering modulator


307


. The word is shifted out the Port at twice the subcarrier frequency rate thereby producing the desired subcarrier frequency f


s


. For example, to get a square wave of frequency f


s


, an alternating 1.0 pattern is written to the port at a rate of 2f


s


. The number of cycles in which the word is shifted out of the Port produces the desired channel symbol rate of the DQPSK modulated uplink signal. (This is half the channel symbol rate of BPSK and resulting in the channel bandwidth f


2


described above.)




The second method for generating the modulated uplink is to generate the subcarrier frequency external to the microprocessor


305


. In one embodiment,

FIG. 5

, a 4-to-1 multiplexor


503


is used as the QPSK modulator control


307


. The multiplexor selects the phase of the subcarrier


311


by the current value of G


I


{grave over ( )} and G


Q


{grave over ( )}, written to the select lines of the multiplexor from the processor port as signal


306


. The subcarrier signal can be generated from the microprocessor's external crystal or clock circuit


312


by connecting a buffer circuit


501


and a digital clock divider circuit


502


(if necessary) to the microprocessor's clock circuit


312


. The two O-flip-flops comprising clock divider circuit


502


produce the 4 phase shifts of the subcarrier signal


504


and multiplexor


503


selects one of the 4 phases based on the signals G


I


{grave over ( )} and G


Q


{grave over ( )} which are presented at multiplexor


503


's select inputs.

FIG. 6

illustrates the relationship between the output of buffer


501


and the outputs of the two O-flip-flops. The subcarrier signal


504


is phase modulated by the multiplexor circuit


503


; thereby producing the second information signal.




The methods described above for either internally or externally generating the modulated subcarrier signal


311


are extendible to M-ary Phase Shift Keyed modulation. For example, DMPSK requires that the data bits be Gray encoded M bits at a time and the digital clock divider will need additional stages to produce the M phase shifts of the subcarrier signal; an M-to-1 multiplexor is used as the modulator controller


307


.




Receiver




Returning to

FIG. 2

, the Interrogator


103


receives the reflected and modulated signal with the Receive Antenna


206


, amplifies the signal with a Low Noise Amplifier


207


, and demodulates the signal using homodyne detection in a Mixer


208


down to the Intermediate Frequency (IF) of the single subcarrier f


s


. (In some Interrogator designs, a single Transmitter


204


and Receive


206


Antenna is used. In this event, an electronic method of separating the transmitted signal from that received by the receiver chain is needed; this could be accomplished by a device such as a Circulator.) Using the same Radio Signal Source


201


as used in the transmit chain means the demodulation to IF is done using Homodyne detection; this has advantages in that it greatly reduces phase noise in the receiver circuits. The Mixer


208


then sends a Demodulated Signal


209


—if using a Quadrature Mixer, it sends both I (in phase) and Q (quadrature) signals—into Filter/Amplifier


210


to filter the Demodulated Signal


209


. The resulting filtered signal—then typically an Information Signal


211


carried on an IF subcarrier—is then demodulated from the subcarrier in the Subcarrier Demodulator


212


, which then sends the Information Signal


213


to Processor


200


to determine the content of the message. The I and Q channels of Signal


209


can be combined in the Filter/Amplifier


210


, or in the Subcarrier Demodulator


212


, or they could be combined in the Processor


200


.




The are several choices for implementing the data recovery


212


part of the receiver hardware: conventional analog I/Q demodulation of the subcarrier signal using, e.g., a Costas Loop, Digital Signal Processing (DSP) of the sampled subcarrier, or implementing a receiver in digital logic. Since minimizing the system cost is one objective, one embodiment of this invention has been implemented in digital logic.




The data recovery circuit


212


is implemented in Gate Array circuit, FIG.


7


. It has two functions:




1) demodulation of the differentially encoded phase shift keyed data (data recovery circuit), and




2) deriving the received bit clock for the demodulated data stream (clock recovery circuit).




The input to the data recovery circuit


212


is the hard limited subcarrier


601


, which is modulated by differential QPSK. The subcarrier


601


is sampled at frequency rate F


s


(for example, 4 MHz)


601




a


, and is input to a N+2 stage shift register


602


(in this example, N=80), the N


th


stage providing a one symbol delay


603


(the shift register


602


is also clocked at the sampling rate F


s


). The N+2 stage is designed to advance the Quadrature modulated subcarrier signal by 45°


603




a


and the N−2 stage


603




b


is at −45° relative to the subcarrier


601


. The sampled subcarrier


601


is essentially multiplied with each of the delayed subcarriers


603




a


and


603




b


(using exclusive-OR gates)


604


and the results are filtered by accumulator circuits


605


, which are the digital equivalent to the classic integrate and dump (Matched Filter) receiver, which integrates over one symbol period (in the example, one symbol period is N periods of shift register


602


's clock, where N=80 and F


s


=4 MHz). The output of the accumulators are passed to symbol decision comparators


606


and the resulting decision symbols are the I and Q information symbols bits, which are multiplexed (interleaved) to produce the demodulated data stream


607


. With regard to symbol decision comparators


606


, if the output of the accumulator is greater than or equal to N/2 (in this example, N/2=40) comparator


606


outputs a 1, and if the output of the accumulator is less than N/2, comparator


606


outputs a 0.




After information bit demodulation, the data clock is be generated. The demodulator implements a Maximum A Posteriori (MAP) bit timing circuit. The demodulated data is sent to a bank of correlators


608


, each of which is testing a different clock phase. The correlators measure the alignment of the input data with their clock over a B data bit window. The B bit window is 8 data bits long in this example; however, larger values of B are less sensitive to long strings of 1's or 0's, but require more hardware (or software/time) to implement. Each correlator is made from an integrate-and-dump filter, a weighting function that gives higher weight to high signal-to-noise data, and an accumulator (that accumulates over a period of B). A weighting function is not required, but it is possible to give higher weight to higher correlator outputs and lower weights to low correlator outputs. For example, correlator outputs approaching +1 or −1 are multiplied by a factor of 10, and correlator outputs approaching 0 are given a value equal to the square root of the actual output. After B bits have been examined, the correlator with the highest accumulator value is found and its associated clock phase


609


is used to sample the next B bits of data. The accumulator is then reset, and the next B bits are examined. The important thing here is that there is no memory from one set of bits to the next; every B bits the clock estimation circuit generate a new estimate of the best clock phase that does not depend on previous estimates. This lets us acquire a bit clock quickly—providing a bit clock even for modest SNR. Prior art maintains that a Phase Locked Loop (either analog or digital) be used in clock recovery. However, Phase Locked Loops have a minimum “lock-up” time that is a function of the loop filter. This lock-up time also increases as system noise increases and are unreliable for modest SNR.




There are a few other functions that may be incorporated in the Gate Array chip; for example, the largest correlator value is checked to see if it is higher than a fixed threshold. If it is, a signal is generated indicating that the bit clock is valid


610


. The framing scheme uses a Barker code to indicate the start of the payload data. The presence of the Barker word is detected and generates a signal that indicates that the next bit is part of the payload


611


.




The methods described above demodulating the sampled subcarrier signal


601


are extendible to M-ary Phase Shift Keyed modulation. For example, DMPSK requires additional shift register delay stages to produce the M phase shifts of the sampled modulated subcarrier signal and the additional XOR, accumulator and decision circuits to decode the M parallel bit paths.




The methods can also be extended to more sophisticated phase modulation schemes such as MSK (Minimum Shift Keyed), GMSK (Gaussian Minumum Shift Keyed), etc. For MSK, pre-computed phase transitions could be stored in the processor's memory. Also, for example, through computation in the processor, the Tag can generate a smooth transition from one phase to another, and thereby produce an appropriately filtered phase modulation to produce a GMSK-modulated subcarrier. Other phase modulation schemes are also possible.




Using the above techniques as an example, an inexpensive, short-range, bi-directional digital radio communications channel is implemented. These techniques are inexpensive as the Tag components consist of (for example) a Schottky diode, an amplifier to boost the signal strength, bit and frame synchronization circuits, an inexpensive 4 or 8 bit microprocessor, subcarrier generation circuits, and a battery. Most of these items are already manufactured in large quantities for other applications, and thus are not overly expensive. The circuits mentioned above for subcarrier generation may also be implemented in logic surrounding the microprocessor core; thus, except for a relatively small amount of chip real estate, these functions come almost “for free.”




What has been described is merely illustrative of the application of the principles of the present invention. Other arrangements and methods can be implemented by those skilled in the art without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention.



Claims
  • 1. A modulated backscatter interrogator, comprising:a transmitter that transmits a first transmitted signal; a receiver that receives a reflected first transmitted signal; a demodulator that obtains a received PSK modulated subcarrier signal from the reflected first transmitted signal; a subcarrier demodulator that obtains an information signal from the received PSK modulated subcarrier signal, wherein the subcarrier demodulator includes: a shift register that receives a signal representative of the received PSK modulated subcarrier signal, at least one exclusive-or device that performs an exclusive-or function on signals from at least two different outputs of the shift register; and a plurality of correlators each having an accumulate circuit and an integrate and dump circuit that receives an input from the exclusive-or device, each of the correlators testing a different clock phase in order to estimate which of the different clock phases is closest to a clock phase for a set of bits.
  • 2. The modulated backscatter system of claim 1, wherein the PSK modulated subcarrier and the received PSK modulated subcarrier signals are QPSK signals.
  • 3. The modulated backscatter system of claim 1, wherein the PSK modulated subcarrier and the received PSK modulated subcarrier signals are DQPSK signals.
  • 4. The modulated backscatter system of claim 1, wherein the PSK modulated subcarrier and the received PSK modulated subcarrier signals are MPSK signals.
  • 5. A modulated backscatter interrogator, comprising:a transmitter that transmits a first transmitted signal; a receiver that receives a reflected first transmitted signal; a demodulator that obtains a received PSK modulated subcarrier signal from the reflected first transmitted signal; a subcarrier demodulator that obtains an information signal from the received PSK modulated subcarrier signal, wherein the subcarrier demodulator includes: a shift register that receives a signal representative of the received PSK modulated subcarrier signal, at least one exclusive-or device that performs an exclusive-or function on signals from at least two different outputs of the shift register; and a data clock recovery circuit that receives an input from the exclusive-or device.
  • 6. The modulated backscatter interrogator of claim 5, wherein the data clock recovery circuit comprises a phase lock loop circuit.
  • 7. The modulated backscatter interrogator of claim 5, wherein the data clock recovery circuit comprises at least one correlator having an accumulate circuit and an integrate and dump circuit that receives an input from the exclusive-or device.
  • 8. The modulated backscatter system of claim 5, wherein the PSK modulated subcarrier and the received PSK modulated subcarrier signals are QPSK signals.
  • 9. The modulated backscatter system of claim 5, wherein the PSK modulated subcarrier and the received PSK modulated subcarrier signals are DQPSK signals.
  • 10. The modulated backscatter system of claim 5, wherein the PSK modulated subcarrier and the received PSK modulated subcarrier signals are MPSK signals.
RELATED APPLICATIONS

Related subject matter is disclosed in the following application filed concurrently herewith and assigned to the same Assignee hereof: U.S. patent applications “Shielding Technology In Modulated Backscatter System”, Ser. No. 08/777,770; “Encryption for Modulated Backscatter Systems”, Ser. No. 08/777,832; “Antenna Array In An RDID System”, Ser. No. 08/775,217; “Modulated Backscatter Location System”, Ser. No. 08/777,643; “Modulated Backscatter Sensor System”, Ser. No. 08/777,771; “Subcarrier Frequency Division Multiplexing Of Modulated Backscatter Signals”, Ser. No. 08/777,834; “IQ Combiner Technology In Modulated Backscatter System”, Ser. No. 08/775,695; “In-Building Personal Pager And Identifier”, Ser. No. 08/775,738; “In-Building Modulated Backscatter System”, Ser. No. 775,701; “Inexpensive Modulated Backscatter Reflector”, Ser. No. 08/774,499; “Passenger, Baggage, And Cargo Reconciliation System”, Ser. No. 08/782,026. Related subject matter is also disclosed in the following applications assigned to the same assignee hereof: U.S. patent application Ser. No. 08/504188, entitled “Modulated Backscatter Communications System Having An Extended Range”; U.S. patent application Ser. No. 08/492,173, entitled “Dual Mode Modulated Backscatter System”; U.S. patent application Ser. No. 08/492,174, entitled “Full Duplex Modulated Backscatter System”; and U.S. patent application Ser. No. 08/571,004, entitled “Enhanced Uplink Modulated Backscatter System”.

US Referenced Citations (96)
Number Name Date Kind
3720940 Fox et al. Mar 1973 A
3944928 Augenblick et al. Mar 1976 A
3984835 Kaplan et al. Oct 1976 A
4068232 Meyeres et al. Jan 1978 A
4075632 Baldwin et al. Feb 1978 A
4360810 Landt Nov 1982 A
4471345 Barrett, Jr. Sep 1984 A
4510495 Sigrimis et al. Apr 1985 A
4584534 Lijphart et al. Apr 1986 A
4641374 Oyama Feb 1987 A
4656463 Anders et al. Apr 1987 A
4691202 Denne et al. Sep 1987 A
4737789 Nysen Apr 1988 A
4739328 Koelle et al. Apr 1988 A
4816769 Ma et al. Mar 1989 A
4816839 Landt Mar 1989 A
4827395 Anders et al. May 1989 A
4888591 Landt et al. Dec 1989 A
4912471 Tyburski et al. Mar 1990 A
4937581 Baldwin et al. Jun 1990 A
4963887 Kawashima et al. Oct 1990 A
4993068 Piosenka et al. Feb 1991 A
5030807 Landt et al. Jul 1991 A
5039994 Wash et al. Aug 1991 A
5055659 Hendrick et al. Oct 1991 A
5086391 Chambers Feb 1992 A
5131038 Puhl et al. Jul 1992 A
5153919 Reeds Oct 1992 A
5164985 Nysen et al. Nov 1992 A
5214409 Beigel May 1993 A
5214410 Verster May 1993 A
5227803 O'Connor et al. Jul 1993 A
5251218 Stone et al. Oct 1993 A
5252979 Nysen Oct 1993 A
5264854 Spiess Nov 1993 A
5305008 Turner et al. Apr 1994 A
5305459 Rydel Apr 1994 A
5339073 Dodd et al. Aug 1994 A
5347263 Carroll et al. Sep 1994 A
5353301 Mitzlaff Oct 1994 A
5381137 Ghaem et al. Jan 1995 A
5390339 Bruckert et al. Feb 1995 A
5400949 Hirvonen et al. Mar 1995 A
5410315 Huber Apr 1995 A
5420757 Eberhardt et al. May 1995 A
5423056 Linquist et al. Jun 1995 A
5425032 Shloss et al. Jun 1995 A
5426667 van Zon Jun 1995 A
5434572 Smith Jul 1995 A
5438329 Gastouniotis et al. Aug 1995 A
5448110 Tuttle et al. Sep 1995 A
5448242 Sharpe et al. Sep 1995 A
5455575 Schuermann Oct 1995 A
5461385 Armstrong Oct 1995 A
5463402 Walrath et al. Oct 1995 A
5477215 Mandelbaum Dec 1995 A
5478991 Watanabe et al. Dec 1995 A
5479160 Koelle Dec 1995 A
5479416 Snodgrass et al. Dec 1995 A
5485520 Chaum et al. Jan 1996 A
5491484 Schuermann Feb 1996 A
5510795 Koelle Apr 1996 A
5521944 Hegeler et al. May 1996 A
5523749 Cole et al. Jun 1996 A
5525993 Pobanz et al. Jun 1996 A
5525994 Hurta et al. Jun 1996 A
5530202 Dais et al. Jun 1996 A
5543798 Schuermann Aug 1996 A
5559828 Armstrong et al. Sep 1996 A
5565858 Guthrie Oct 1996 A
5572222 Mailandt et al. Nov 1996 A
5581576 Lanzetta et al. Dec 1996 A
5600538 Xanthopoulos Feb 1997 A
5610939 Takahashi et al. Mar 1997 A
5633613 MacDonald May 1997 A
5640683 Evans et al. Jun 1997 A
5649295 Shober et al. Jul 1997 A
5649296 Maclellan et al. Jul 1997 A
5686928 Pritchett et al. Nov 1997 A
5708444 Pouwels et al. Jan 1998 A
5727027 Tsuda Mar 1998 A
5760653 Soda Jun 1998 A
5774673 Beuk et al. Jun 1998 A
5774876 Woolley et al. Jun 1998 A
5796827 Coppersmith et al. Aug 1998 A
5804810 Wolley et al. Sep 1998 A
5850187 Carrender et al. Dec 1998 A
5852403 Boardman Dec 1998 A
5872516 Bonge, Jr. et al. Feb 1999 A
5873025 Evans et al. Feb 1999 A
5874903 Shuey et al. Feb 1999 A
5929779 MacLellan et al. Jul 1999 A
5940006 MacLellan et al. Aug 1999 A
5943378 Keba et al. Aug 1999 A
5952922 Shober Sep 1999 A
6023610 Wood et al. Feb 2000 A
Foreign Referenced Citations (15)
Number Date Country
0 313 491 Apr 1989 EP
0 346 922 Dec 1989 EP
0 520 445 Dec 1992 EP
0 670 558 Feb 1995 EP
0 724 351 Jul 1996 EP
0 732 597 Sep 1996 EP
0 750 200 Dec 1996 EP
0 750 201 Dec 1996 EP
0779 520 Dec 1996 EP
1 098 431 Nov 1982 GB
2 193 359 Feb 1988 GB
2 202 415 Sep 1988 GB
S63-52082 Mar 1988 JP
WO 8905549 Jun 1989 WO
WO 9419781 Sep 1994 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (2)
Entry
“A Microwave Noncontact Identification Transponder Using Subharmonic Interrogation,” Carol W. Pobanz, 8099 IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theroy and Techniques, 43 (1995), Jul., No. 7, PT. II, New York, US, pp. 1673-1679.
“A Coded Radar Reflector For Remote Identification Of Personnel And Vehicles,” Frank R. Williamson, Lacey F. Moore, Ralph Brooks, Julie Anne Williamson, and Melvin C. McGee, Record of the 1993 IEEE National Radar Conference, Lynnfield, MA, USA, Apr. 20-22, 1993, ISBN 0-7803-0934-0, pp. 186-191.