Refrigeration method and installation

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 10060653
  • Patent Number
    10,060,653
  • Date Filed
    Tuesday, August 14, 2012
    12 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, August 28, 2018
    6 years ago
Abstract
Method and installation for refrigerating the same application by means of several refrigerators/liquefiers disposed in parallel, the refrigerators/liquefiers in parallel using a working gas of the same nature having a low molar mass, that is to say having a mean total molar mass of less than 10 g/mol such as pure gaseous helium, each refrigerator/liquefier comprising a station for compressing the working gas, a cold box intended to cool the working gas at the output from the compression station, the working gas cooled by each of the respective cold boxes of the refrigerators/liquefiers being put in thermal exchange with the application with a view to supplying cold to the latter, in which a single compression station compresses the working gas for each of the respective separate cold boxes of the refrigerators/liquefiers disposed in parallel, the single compression station comprising only compression machines of the lubricated-screw type and systems for removing oil from the working fluid output from the compression machines, so that the compression machines and the oil-removal systems are shared by the refrigerators/liquefiers disposed in parallel.
Description
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a § 371 of International PCT Application PCT/FR2012/051893, filed Aug. 14, 2012, which claims § 119(a) foreign priority to French patent application 1158478, filed Sep. 23, 2011.


BACKGROUND
Field of the Invention

The present invention concerns a refrigeration installation and method.


The invention concerns in particular a low-temperature refrigeration installation and method in which a gas with a low molar mass (for example hydrogen or helium) is used as a refrigerating fluid in order to attain very low refrigeration temperatures (for example 4.5 K for helium). Obtaining refrigeration at temperatures of 30 K and lower generally requires the use of a refrigerant such as helium. The helium is compressed at a hot end of the loop or circuit, and then cooled and expanded in the cold part of the loop (cold box). The major part of the refrigerant is heated by exchange and recycled in the compression stage. In some applications, part of the working gas may be liquefied.


Related Art

The compression of the helium liquefaction/refrigeration cycles generally uses one or more stages of compression machines (compressors) with lubricated screws followed by an oil-separation system.


If it is necessary to have several refrigerators, each refrigerator is connected to its own compression station. According to the rates required, each compression level may be divided into several compressors in parallel. The primary oil-management and cooling systems may be common to several compressors or be dedicated to each one.


After the compression and oil separation thereof the low molecular mass gas is cooled and expanded in cryogenic expansion turbines of a cold box in order to attain the required temperature level. The removed heat not used by the user of the refrigerator/liquefier is then transmitted to the working fluid at high pressure in order to cool it in the heat exchangers. The working gas at low and medium pressure of the circuit returns to the intake of the compressors.


For large refrigeration systems, for example greater than 20 kW, equivalent to 4.5 K, it is necessary to use several separate refrigerators in parallel connected to the same application to be cooled. The fluctuating thermal loads of the application to be cooled cause fluctuations in output on the compressors of the compression station. The costs of the compression station (equipment, integration and installation) are relatively high compared with the total cost of the installation.


The refrigeration cycles (which generate the cold) are conventionally “closed” at each refrigerator. That is to say the cycle output of working fluid that enters the cold box stems mainly from this same cold box. On the other hand, these cycle outputs are “open” or combined at the application to be cooled (the working fluid outputs applied by the refrigerators is shared for the application to be cooled and then returns to each refrigerator through a respective distribution system).


SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

One aim of the invention is to propose a refrigeration method and installation of an application by means of several refrigerators/liquefiers disposed in parallel that solves all or some of the above problems. In particular, one aim of the invention may be to propose a refrigeration method and installation that are less expensive and/or more compact and/or more effective and/or more flexible in use than the known systems.


To this end, the refrigeration installation of the same application comprises several refrigerators/liquefiers disposed in parallel, the refrigerators/liquefiers in parallel using a working gas of the same nature having a low molar mass, that is to say having a mean total molar mass of less than 10 g/mol such as pure gaseous helium, each refrigerator/liquefier comprising a station for compressing the working gas, a cold box intended to cool the working gas at the output from the compression station, the working gas cooled by each of the respective cold boxes of the refrigerators/liquefiers being put in thermal exchange with the application with a view to supplying cold to the latter, in which a single compression station compresses the working gas for each of the respective separate cold boxes of the refrigerator/liquefiers disposed in parallel, the single compression station comprising only compression machines of the lubricated-screw type and systems for removing oil from the working fluid at the outlet of the compression machines, so that the compression machines and the oil-removal systems are shared by the refrigerators/liquefiers disposed in parallel.


The invention concerns in particular a refrigeration/liquefaction in which the working gas is brought to a cryogenic temperature close to the liquefaction temperature thereof at the output from the cold box.


Moreover, embodiments of the invention may comprise one or more of the following features:

    • the single compression station comprises a plurality of compression machines defining several pressure levels for the working fluid,
    • the passage from one pressure level to the following higher pressure level is achieved via one or more compression machines in series or via several compression machines disposed in parallel,
    • the passage from at least one pressure level to the following higher pressure level is achieved via two compression machines disposed in parallel, an oil-removal system being disposed at the discharge from the two compression machines, the oil-removal system comprising either a single oil-removal member common to the two compression machines disposed in parallel, or two oil-removal members allocated respectively to the two compression machines disposed in parallel,
    • the installation comprises at least one final oil-removal system disposed at the discharge from at least one final oil-removal system disposed at the discharge from the last compression level, that is to say before a fluid connection supplying the cold box with fluid,
    • the installation comprises at least one exchanger for cooling the working fluid downstream of a compression machine,
    • the installation comprises three compression machines defining three increasing pressure levels above the pressure level of the fluid at the inlet of the compression station, first and second compression machines being disposed in series and defining at their respective fluid outlet pressure levels respectively said to be “low” and “high”, a third compression machine being supplied at its inlet with fluid issuing from the cold boxes at a so-called “medium” pressure level intermediate between the low and high levels, the third compression machine defining at its fluid outlet also a “high” pressure level,
    • the installation comprises a fourth compression machine disposed in parallel with the second compression machine, the outlet of the fourth compression machine being connected to the inlet of the third compression machine,
    • the outlets of the third compression machine and of the second compression machine are connected to a common point defining the same high pressure level,
    • the outlet of the third compression machine and the outlet of the second compression machine are connected to at least one cold box at separate locations defining respective and separate high pressure levels for the fluid.


Another aim of the invention is to propose a refrigeration installation for the same application by means of a single refrigerator/liquefier or several refrigerators/liquefiers disposed in parallel, the refrigerator(s)/liquefier(s) using a working gas of the same nature having a low molar mass, that is to say having a mean total molar mass of less than 10 g/mol such as pure gaseous helium, each refrigerator/liquefier comprising a station for compressing the working gas, a cold box intended to cool the working gas discharged from the compression station, the working gas cooled by each of the respective cold boxes of the refrigerators/liquefiers being put in heat exchange with the application with a view to supplying cold to the latter, in which a single compression station provides the compression of the working gas for each of the cold boxes of the refrigerator(s)/liquefier(s), the compression station comprising only compression machines of the lubricated-screw type and systems for removing oil from the working fluid discharged from the compression machines, and in that the compression station comprises a plurality of compression machines defining several pressure levels for the working fluid, the passage from one pressure level to the following higher pressure level is achieved via one or more compression machines in series or via several compression machines disposed in parallel, the compression station comprising at least two compression machines defining at least two increasing pressure levels above the pressure level of the fluid at the inlet of the compression station, two main compression machines being disposed in series and defining at their respective fluid outlets pressure levels respectively said to be “low” and “high”, another secondary compression machine being supplied at its inlet with fluid issuing from the cold boxes at a so-called “medium” pressure level intermediate between the low and high pressure levels, this secondary compression machine defining at its fluid outlet also a “high” pressure level.


According to other possible particularities

    • the outlets of the secondary compression machine and of the main compression machine are connected to a common pipe defining the same high pressure level,
    • the outlets of the secondary compression machine and of the main compression machine are connected to at least one cold box at separate locations defining respective separate high pressure levels for the fluid.


The invention also concerns a method for refrigerating the same application by means of a refrigeration and/or liquefaction installation comprising several refrigerators/liquefiers disposed in parallel, the refrigerators/liquefiers in parallel using a working gas of the same nature having a low molar mass, that is to say having a mean total molar mass of less than 10 g/mol such as pure gaseous helium, each refrigerator/liquefier comprising a station for compressing the working gas, a respective cold box intended to cool the working gas discharged from the compression station, the working gas cooled by the respective cold boxes of the refrigerators/liquefiers being put in heat exchange with the application with a view to supplying cold to it, in which a single compression station compresses the working gas for each of the separate cold box of the refrigerators/liquefiers disposed in parallel, the single compression station comprising solely compression machines of the lubricated-screw type and systems for removing oil from the working fluid discharged from the compression machines, so that the compression machines and the oil-removal systems are shared by the refrigerators/liquefiers disposed in parallel.


According to other possible particularities:

    • when the thermal load of the application to be cooled varies, the power variations of the installation are achieved by varying the regime of only some of the compression machines of the common compression station,
    • the application cooled by the refrigerators/liquefiers in parallel is disposed in the same chamber and comprises superconductor elements be cooled.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES

The invention may also concern any alternative device or method comprising any combination of the above or following features.


Other particularities and advantages will emerge from a reading of the following description given with reference to the figures, in which:



FIG. 1 shows in a simplified fashion the structure and functioning of an installation according to the invention,



FIG. 2 shows a partial schematic view illustrating the structure and functioning of a first example embodiment according to the invention,



FIG. 3 shows a partial schematic view illustrating the structure and functioning of a second example embodiment according to the invention,



FIG. 4 shows a partial schematic view illustrating the structure and functioning of a third example embodiment according to the invention.





DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

The refrigeration installation shown schematically in FIG. 1 comprises several refrigerators/liquefiers (L/R) disposed in parallel, which cool the same physical entity (that is to say the same application 1).


The refrigerators/liquefiers (L/R) disposed in parallel use a working gas of the same nature having a low molar moss, that is to say having a mean total molar mass of less than 10 g/mol such as pure gaseous helium for example.


Each refrigerator/liquefier (L/R) uses a station 2 for compressing the working gas and a cold box 3 intended to cool the working gas output from the compression station 2. The working gas cooled by each of the respective cold boxes 3 of the refrigerators/liquefiers (L, R) is put in heat exchange, via a distribution circuit 11, with the application 1 with a view to supplying cold to the latter.


According to an advantageous particularity, a single compression station 2 compresses the working gas for each of the separate respective cold boxes 3 of the refrigerators/liquefiers L/R disposed in parallel.


The compression 2 station 2 may where applicable be connected to a so-called “hot” buffer 12 for storing working fluid. According to another advantageous particularity, the single compression station 2 comprises compression machines solely of the lubricated-screw type and systems for removing oil from the working fluid at the discharge from the compression machines. In this way, the compression machines (lubricated-screw compressors) and the oil-removal systems are shared by the refrigerators/liquefiers disposed in parallel.


This configuration makes it possible to limit the number of machines and items of equipment necessary for compressing the working fluid.


This also makes it possible to concentrate the variations in load over a limited number of compressors with suitable regulation means (for example frequency variators, regulator valves, etc.).


In addition, this also where applicable makes it possible to group the compression stations by type of compressor or by function (refrigeration cycle and/or customer supply) rather than by refrigeration cycles.


The architecture also where applicable makes it possible to provide several fluid cycle pressures per function or per compression station.



FIG. 2 illustrates a first possible example embodiment according to the invention. As can be seen in FIG. 2, the single common compression station 2 comprises a plurality of compression machines EC1, EC2, EC3 defining several pressure levels VLP, LP, MP, HP, HP1, HP2 for the working fluid.


At the inlet of the compression station 2, the fluid issuing from one or more cold boxes 3 arrives at a so-called “very low” pressure (VLP). This very low level pressure depends on the application 1 and this very low pressure level may not be present for some applications (that is to say the first pressure level in the compression station is said to be “low”, that is to say included in the range mentioned below). A first compression machine EC1 provides a pressure rise in the working fluid to a so-called “low” pressure LP that is higher than the very low pressure VLP. At the discharge from this first compression machine EC1, the fluid may be de-oiled in an oil-removal member 4 and then cooled in a heat exchanger 5. The discharge of the first compression machine EC1 is then connected to the inlet of a second compression machine EC2, which compresses the fluid from the basic pressure LP to a high pressure HP. The inlet of this second compression machine EC2 also receives the fluid at this low pressure level LP issuing from the cold boxes 3. As before, at the discharge from this second compression machine EC2, the fluid may be de-oiled in an oil-removal member 4 and then cooled in a heat exchanger 5. Before returning to the cold boxes 3, the fluid may undergo a last more selective oil removal in final oil-removal system 14. A third compression machine EC3 is disposed in the compression station 2. This third compression machine EC3 is supplied at its inlet with fluid from the boxes 3 at a so-called “medium” pressure MP intermediate between the low LP and high HP levels. This third compression machine EC3 also defines at its fluid outlet a “high” pressure level HP for the working fluid. At the discharge from this second compression machine EC2, the fluid may be de-oiled in an oil-removal member 4 and then cooled in a heat exchanger 5. The high-pressure working fluid is injected upstream of the final oil-removal system 14 (a pipe is connected to the outlet of the second compression machine EC2.


This solution therefore combines several lubricated-screw compression machines between the low pressure LP and high pressure HP and in addition has a compression level between the intermediate pressure MP and the same high pressure HP.


This configuration has the advantage of reducing the size of the primary oil-management systems 4 (oil-removal system 4 before the final oil removal 14) in particular on part of the cycle between the low pressure LP and the high pressure HP. This architecture also makes it possible simultaneously to preserve flexibility on the variations in flow rate and pressure possible in this part of the circuit (in particular between the medium pressure MP and the high pressure HP).


On the other hand this solution is less flexible with regard to the possibility of varying the flow rate of working fluid in the low pressure LP since the combined compression machines are interdependent and the fluctuations are more difficult to control.


Each of the compression stages implemented by a compression machine may of course be replaced by two (or more) compressors disposed in parallel. This is because, depending on the flow rates of working fluid necessary, each compression level may be divided into several compressors disposed in parallel. In this case, the primary oil management (oil removal) and cooling systems may be common to several compressors or be dedicated to each one.


According to the very low pressure level VLP and the compression ratio of the first compression machine EC1, the outlet of the first compression machine EC1 may also be connected to the inlet of the third compression machine EC3 at a so-called “medium” pressure level MP. The rest of the architecture remaining similar.


The variant in FIG. 3 is distinguished from that in FIG. 1 only in that the installation comprises a fourth compression machine EC12 disposed in parallel with the second compression machine EC2. In the same way as for the second compression machine EC2, the fluid inlet of the fourth compression machine EC12 is connected both to the outlet of the first compression machine EC1 and to a fluid inlet at this low pressure from the cold boxes 3. The outlet of the fourth compression machine EC12 is for its part connected to the inlet of the third compression machine EC3 (the inlet of the third compression EC3 also receives fluid at the medium pressure MP from the cold boxes).


As before, the second EC2 and fourth EC12 compression machines in parallel may each have at their outlet a dedicated oil-removal system 4 and a dedicated heat exchanger 5. In a variant these oil-removal systems 4 and heat exchanger 5 may be common and therefore shared.


As before, according to the working fluid flow rates required, each compression level may be divided into several machines (compressors) disposed in parallel.


As before also, this solution combines several compressors between the low pressure LP and the high pressure HP and in addition provides a compression level between the intermediate pressure MP and the same high pressure HP.


In the case of FIG. 3 however, part of the flow of working fluid at low pressure LP passes through compression machines EC12 that compress the fluid only to the intermediate pressure MP.


The latter compression machines EC12 may be equipped with speed variators in order to react to variations in low-pressure fluid flow rate. The recirculation of fluid between the low pressures LP and medium pressure MP is also possible in order to react to variations in load.


The compressor or compressors EC2 combined between the low pressure LP and the high pressure HP may function with a constant flow rate and independently of the fluctuations in load (application 1) and working cycle. The fluctuations in flow rates and pressures are absorbed by the group of compressors EC1, EC2, EC12 between the very low input pressure VLP as far as the higher levels (LP→MP→HP).


The variant in FIG. 4 is distinguished from that in FIG. 3 only in that the outlets of the third compression machine EC3 and second compression machine EC2 are connected to at least one cold box 3 at separate locations defining respective separate high pressure levels HP1, HP2 for the fluid. In addition, in FIG. 4, the conduit comprising the fourth compression machine EC12 and the downstream members thereof (oil-removal unit 4 and heat exchanger 5) has been shown in broken lines (in order better to show the optional character thereof).


In this configuration of FIG. 4, each high-pressure outlet HP1, HP2 of the third EC3 and second EC2 compression machines comprises, downstream of a respective heat exchanger 5, a respective final oil-removal member 14. Two final oil-removal systems 14 are in fact essential because of the difference in pressure between the two lines.


As before, part of the flow of fluid at low pressure LP is compressed directly to a high pressure HP2. In this configuration in FIG. 4, this high pressure HP2 is independent of the high pressure HP1 obtained at the outlet of the compressors that compress between the medium pressure MP and the high pressure HP1.


This architecture also makes it possible to optimise the sizes and efficiencies of the various types of compressor of the various compression stages.


The variations in flow rate and pressure of the fluid on the circuits resulting respectively in the two high pressure levels HP1 and HP2 can therefore also be managed more independently.


The circuit comprising a compression stage between the medium pressure MP and high pressure HP1 in general supplies the majority of the pressure-reduction turbines of the cycle of the cold boxes 3 that are the refrigeration source of the system. A variation of this cycle therefore permits a direct variation of the refrigeration capacity of the refrigerators/liquefiers L/R.


On the other hand, the high-pressure fluid circuit HP2 issuing from the second compression machine EC2 may be used preferentially for supplying an application 1 and/or an expansion circuit of a cooling of the Joule-Thompson type at the cold end of the cycle.


The invention may in particular apply to any refrigeration/liquefaction unit with a high liquefaction or refrigeration capacity using helium or a rare gas.


By way of non-limitative example (circuit with three compression stages but defining four pressure levels), the respective pressure levels very low VLP, low LP, medium MP and high HP of the compression stages as well as the corresponding compression ratios and flow rates of the working gas may be included in the following ranges.
















aspiration pressure





of the
flow rates in




corresponding
the




compression
compression
compression ratios of


Compression
machine
machine
the compression stage


stage
(in bar)
(in g/s)
(without unit)


















VLP
0.05 → 1.0 
10 → 500
2 → 15


LP
1.0 → 2.5
500 → 2000
2 → 5 


HP
3 → 6
800 → 4500
2 → 5 









The architectures of the compression stations in the examples illustrated may advantageously, apply also to an installation using a single liquefier/refrigerator (rather than several in parallel).


While the invention has been described in conjunction with specific embodiments thereof, it is evident that many alternatives, modifications, and variations will be apparent to those skilled in the art in light of the foregoing description. Accordingly, it is intended to embrace all such alternatives, modifications, and variations as fall within the spirit and broad scope of the appended claims. The present invention may suitably comprise, consist or consist essentially of the elements disclosed and may be practiced in the absence of an element not disclosed. Furthermore, if there is language referring to order, such as first and second, it should be understood in an exemplary sense and not in a limiting sense. For example, it can be recognized by those skilled in the art that certain steps can be combined into a single step.


The singular forms “a”, “an” and “the” include plural referents, unless the context clearly dictates otherwise.


“Comprising” in a claim is an open transitional term which means the subsequently identified claim elements are a nonexclusive listing i.e. anything else may be additionally included and remain within the scope of “comprising.” “Comprising” is defined herein as necessarily encompassing the more limited transitional terms “consisting essentially of” and “consisting of”; “comprising” may therefore be replaced by “consisting essentially of” or “consisting of” and remain within the expressly defined scope of “comprising”.


“Providing” in a claim is defined to mean furnishing, supplying, making available, or preparing something. The step may be performed by any actor in the absence of express language in the claim to the contrary.


Optional or optionally means that the subsequently described event or circumstances may or may not occur. The description includes instances where the event or circumstance occurs and instances where it does not occur.


Ranges may be expressed herein as from about one particular value, and/or to about another particular value. When such a range is expressed, it is to be understood that another embodiment is from the one particular value and/or to the other particular value, along with all combinations within said range.


All references identified herein are each hereby incorporated by reference into this application in their entireties, as well as for the specific information for which each is cited.

Claims
  • 1. An installation for the cryogenic refrigeration of a same application using several refrigerators/liquefiers, the refrigerators/liquefiers using a working gas having a mean total molar mass of less than 10 g/mol, wherein: each refrigerator/liquefier receives working gas from a single shared compression station so that each of the refrigerators/liquefiers is in downstream flow communication in parallel from the single shared compression station, the single shared compression station compressing the working gas, each refrigerator/liquefier comprising an associated cold box cooling and expanding the working gas at an output from the single shared compression station to a cryogenic temperature;the working gas that is cooled by each of the cold boxes of the refrigerators/liquefiers supplies cold to said same application via thermal exchange; andsaid single shared compression station comprising two or more compression machines only of the lubricated-screw type and two or more systems for removing oil from the working fluid from the compression machines, so that each of the compression machines and the oil-removal systems is shared by the refrigerators/liquefiers in downstream flow communication in parallel.
  • 2. The installation of claim 1, wherein the two or more compression machines provide the working fluid at several pressure levels.
  • 3. The installation of claim 2, wherein passage of a pressure of the working fluid from one pressure level to a higher pressure level is achieved via one or more of the compression machines in series or in parallel.
  • 4. The installation of claim 2, wherein passage of a pressure of the working fluid from at least one pressure level to a higher pressure level is achieved via two of the compression machines disposed in parallel, the oil-removal system comprising either a single oil-removal member disposed at outlets of the two compression machines disposed in parallel or two oil-removal members each one of which is disposed at a respective outlet of a respective one of to the two compression machines disposed in parallel.
  • 5. The installation of claim 2, further comprising at least one exchanger for cooling the working fluid downstream of at least one of the compression machines.
  • 6. The installation of claim 1, wherein: the two or more compression machines comprise first, second, and third compression machines providing the working fluid at a corresponding three increasing pressure levels above a pressure level of the working fluid at an inlet of the compression station,the first and second compression machines are disposed in series and provide, at respective fluid outlets thereof, the working fluid at respective low and high pressure levels,the third compression machine is supplied at an inlet thereof with working fluid issuing from the cold boxes at a medium pressure level between the low and high levels, the third compression machine providing the working fluid at a fluid outlet thereof at a pressure level equal to the pressure of the working fluid provided at the fluid outlet of the second compression machine.
  • 7. The installation of claim 6, wherein the two or more compression machines further comprise a fourth compression machine disposed in parallel with the second compression machine, an outlet of the fourth compression machine being connected to the inlet of the third compression machine.
  • 8. The installation of claim 6, wherein an outlet of the third compression machine and the outlet of the second compression machine are connected to a common conduit providing the working gas at the same high pressure level.
  • 9. The installation of claim 6, wherein the outlet of the third compression machine and the outlet of the second compression machine are connected to at least one cold box at separate locations providing the working gas at respective separate high pressure levels.
  • 10. A method for refrigerating a same application with a refrigeration and/or liquefaction installation comprising several refrigerators/liquefiers, the refrigerators/liquefiers using a working gas having a mean total molar mass of less than 10 g/mol, wherein: each refrigerator/liquefier receives working gas from a single shared compression station so that each of the refrigerators/liquefiers is in downstream flow communication in parallel from the single shared compression station, the single shared compression station compressing the working gas, each refrigerator/liquefier comprising an associated respective cold box adapted and configured to cool and expand the working gas discharged from the single shared compression station where the working gas is brought to a cryogenic temperature upon discharge from the cold box;the working gas cooled and expanded by the respective cold boxes of the refrigerators/liquefiers supplies cold to said same application via heat exchange;the single shared compression station comprising solely compression machines of the lubricated-screw type and systems for removing oil from the working fluid discharged from the compression machines, so that each of the compression machines and the oil-removal systems is shared by the refrigerators/liquefiers in downstream flow communication in parallel.
  • 11. The method of claim 10, where the working gas comprises helium.
  • 12. The method of claim 10, wherein the working gas essentially consists of helium.
Priority Claims (1)
Number Date Country Kind
11 58478 Sep 2011 FR national
PCT Information
Filing Document Filing Date Country Kind 371c Date
PCT/FR2012/051893 8/14/2012 WO 00 3/21/2014
Publishing Document Publishing Date Country Kind
WO2013/041789 3/28/2013 WO A
US Referenced Citations (6)
Number Name Date Kind
4181174 Grenier Jan 1980 A
4267701 Toscano May 1981 A
4486210 Gauthier Dec 1984 A
5603227 Holden Feb 1997 A
20070204649 Kaart Sep 2007 A1
20100275616 Saji Nov 2010 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (5)
Number Date Country
2 105 685 Sep 2009 EP
2 196 746 Jun 2010 EP
2 919 716 Feb 2009 FR
WO 2004 027 324 Apr 2004 WO
WO 2005 036 072 Apr 2005 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (1)
Entry
International Search Report for PCT/FR2012/051893, dated Feb. 21, 2013.
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20140238074 A1 Aug 2014 US