Patent Application
20120295838
Natural antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) defend a wide array of organisms against bacterial invaders and show potential as supplements for or replacements of conventional antibiotics, since few bacteria have evolved resistance to them. Many AMPs kill bacteria by permeabilization of the cytoplasmic membrane, causing depolarization, leakage, and death, whereas others target additional anionic bacterial constituents (e.g. DNA, RNA, or cell wall components). Bacterial resistance to AMPs is rare probably because they have evolved along with the resistance mechanisms designed to evade them; furthermore, the targets of many AMPs (e.g. bacterial plasma membranes, anionic intracellular macromolecules) are sufficiently general that changes to their sequence can be made that subvert resistance, yet have negligible impact on overall functionality.
Although AMPs have been actively studied for decades, they have yet to see widespread clinical use. This is in part due to the vulnerability of many peptide therapeutics to rapid in vivo degradation, which dramatically reduces their bioavailability. Non-natural mimics of AMPs can circumvent the proteolytic susceptibility of peptides while retaining their beneficial features. The short (<40 amino acids), simple structure of AMPs in the cationic, linear, a-helical class, which includes the well-known magainins, are especially amenable to mimicry. β-peptide mimics of these AMPs have been successfully created with antibacterial and non-hemolytic in vitro activity. Poly-N-substituted glycines (peptoids) comprise another class of peptidomimetics, and are isomers of peptides in that peptoid side chains are attached to the backbone amide nitrogen rather than to the α-carbon. More than any of the other peptidomimetic systems under study, including β-peptides, β-peptoids, oligoureas, and oligo(phenylene ethynylene)s, peptoids are particularly well-suited for AMP mimicry because they are easily synthesized on solid phase (using conventional peptide synthesis equipment) with access to diverse sequences at relatively low cost. By way of an elegant submonomer synthetic method, any chemical functionality available as a primary amine can be incorporated, whether it be an analog of a proteinogenic amino acid or a totally non-natural moiety; thus, peptoids are highly and finely tunable. Furthermore, they are protease-resistant, and can be designed to form amphipathic helices that resist thermal and chaotropic denaturation.
The poly-N-substituted glycine structure of peptoids precludes both backbone chirality and intrachain hydrogen bonding; nevertheless, peptoids can be driven to form stable helical secondary structures via periodic incorporation of bulky, α-chiral side chains. X-ray, NMR, and CD studies of peptoid oligomers have shown that incorporation of homochiral side chains can give rise to polyproline type-I-like helices with a periodicity of ˜3 monomers per turn and a helical pitch of 6.0-6.7 Å. The three-fold periodicity of the peptoid helix facilitates the design of facially amphipathic structures similar to those formed by many AMPs; for example, the trimer repeat (X—Y—Z)n forms a peptoid helix with three faces, composed of X, Y, and Z residues, respectively.
Amphipathic secondary structures in which residues are segregated into hydrophobic and cationic regions are the hallmark of most AMPs. Regardless of their final target of killing, AMPs must interact with the bacterial cytoplasmic membrane, and amphipathicity is integral to such interactions. The cationic region facilitates electrostatically driven adsorption to anionic bacterial membranes and imparts some measure of selectivity, since mammalian cell membranes are largely zwitterionic. The hydrophobic region provides an additional driving force for incorporation of the AMP into the lipid bilayer. The precise nature of AMP-membrane interactions remains controversial and actively debated; a variety of mechanisms have been proposed, including the carpet, barrel-stave pore, toroidal pore, and aggregate models.
In light of the foregoing, it is an object of the present invention to provide new poly-N-substituted glycine compounds and methods for and/or therapies relating to their use as antibiotics, thereby improving upon the prior art and/or overcoming various deficiencies or shortcomings thereof It will be understood by those skilled in the art that one or more aspects of this invention can meet certain objectives, while one or more other aspects can meet certain other objectives. Each objective may not apply equally, in all its respects, to every aspect of this invention. As such, the following objects can be viewed in the alternative with respect to any one aspect of this invention.
It can be an object of the present invention to provide such compounds having minimum inhibitory concentrations in the low micromolar range against both Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria, with lower manunalian cytotoxicities and negligible hemolysis, at such concentrations, as compared to compounds of the prior art.
It can be another object of the present invention to provide such compounds and/or compositions, variable by residue sequence and/or N-substituent, so as to affect hydrophobicity and/or amphipathicity and/or to enhance selectivity.
It can be another object of the present invention alone or in conjunction with one or more of the preceding objectives, to provide a new class of N-alkylated peptoids, providing such potencies and selectivities at monomer numbers and peptoid lengths shorter than previously available.
Other objects, features, benefits and advantages of the present invention will be apparent from this summary and its descriptions of certain embodiments, and will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art having knowledge of various peptidomimetic compounds and their syntheses. Such objects, features, benefits and advantages will be apparent from the above as taken into conjunction with the accompanying examples, data, figures and all reasonable inferences to be drawn therefrom, alone or with consideration of the references incorporated herein.
In part, the present invention can be directed to a poly-N-substituted glycine antibiotic compound of a formula
A-(X—Y—Z)n—B
In such a compound, A can be selected from H and one or more terminal N-substituted glycine residues, where such a substituent can be selected from about C4 to about C20 linear, branched and cyclic alkyl moieties or as described below; n can be an integer selected from 1-3; B can be selected from NH2, and one and two N-substituted glycine residues, such N-substituents as can be independently selected from α-amino acid side chain moieties and structural/functional analogs thereof; and X, Y and Z can also be independently selected from N-substituted glycine residues, such N-substituents as can be independently selected from α-amino acid side chain moieties and structural/functional analogs thereof and proline residues. As described elsewhere herein, such X—Y—Z periodicity can provide such a compound a certain amphipathicity. As would be understood by those skilled in the art made aware of this invention, such structural and/or functional analogy can be considered in the context of any such α-amino acid side chain, N-substituent and/or a sequence of such N-substituted glycine residues, such structure and/or function including but not limited to charge, chirality, hydrophobicity, amphipathicity, helical structure and facial organization. Such analogs include, without limitation, carbon homologs of such side chain—such homologs as would be understood in the art, including but not limited to plus or minus 1 or 2 or more methylene and/or methyl groups.
Regardless, in certain embodiments A can be H, and B can be selected from one or two N-substituted glycine residues, such a selection as can reduce the hydrophobicity of such a compound, as compared to compounds of 3-fold periodicity. In certain such embodiments, X can be an NLys residue; n can be 2-3; and B can be two N-substituted glycine residues. Without limitation, such a compound can be of a formula
H—(NLys—Nspe—Nspe3—NLys—Nspe—NH2
In various other embodiments, regardless of identity of A, X and B, at least one of Y and Z can be a proline residue. In certain such embodiments, X, Y and Z can be proline residues.
In certain other embodiments, A can be a terminal N-alkyl substituted glycine residue, with such an alkyl substituent as can be selected from about C6 to about C18 linear alkyl moieties. Regardless, B can be NH2, and n can be selected from 1 and 2. In certain such embodiments, A can be a terminal N-alkyl substituted glycine residue, with an alkyl substituent selected from about C6 to about C18 linear alkyl moieties. Regardless, B can be an NLys residue, and n can be 1.
In part, this invention can also be directed to a poly-N-substituted glycine antibiotic compound of a formula
H—( NLys—Y—Z)n—Y′—Z′—NH2
wherein n can be selected from 2 and 3; and Y, Z, Y′ and Z′ can be independently selected from N-substituted glycine residues, where such substituents can be independently selected from α-amino acid side chain moieties and carbon homologs thereof. Such Y′ and Z′ residues can be selected to provide such compound reduced hydrophobicity as compared to a compound of 3-fold periodicity. In certain such embodiments, at least one of X and Y can be a proline residue. Regardless, n can be selected from 2 and 3, and Y′ can be an NLys residue. In certain such embodiments, one or both X and Y can be proline residues. Without limitation, such a compound with reduced hydrophobicity can be of a formula
H—(NLys—Nspe—Nspe)—NLys—Nspe—NH2
In part, this invention can also be directed to a poly-N-alkyl substituted glycine antibiotic compound of a formula
H—NR—(X—Y—Z)n—B
wherein B can be selected from NH2 and X′; X, Y, Z and X′ can be independently selected from N-substituted glycine residues, where such substituents can be independently selected from α-amino acid side chain moieties and carbon homologs thereof; n can be an integer selected from 1 and 2; and R can be an N-alkyl substituent of such a glycine residue, as can be selected from about C4 to about C20 linear, branched and cyclic alkyl moieties. In certain embodiments, n can be 2, and B can be NH2. In certain other embodiments, n can be 1, and B can be X′. Accordingly, one or both of X and X′ can be NLys residues. Regardless, an alkyl substituent can be selected from about C6 to about C18 linear, branched and cyclic alkyl moieties, and X and X′ can be NLys residues. Without limitation, such a compound can be of a formula
H—Ntridec—NLys—Nspe—Nspe—NLys—NH2.
In part, the present invention can be directed to a poly-N-substituted glycine antibiotic compound comprising an N-terminus selected from H and one or two N-substituted glycine residues of the sort described elsewhere herein; a C-terminus selected from NH2, one and two N-substituted glycine residues, such N-substituents as can be independently selected from α-amino acid side chain moieties and structural/functional analogs thereof; and 2 to about 15 or about 18 monomeric residues between the N- and C-termini, each such residue as can be independently selected from proline residues and N-substituted glycine residues, said N-substituents independently selected from α-amino acid side chain moieties and structural/functional analogs thereof. As illustrated herein and as distinguished over the prior art, such monomers can be selected to provide such a compound a non-periodic sequence of monomers. As would be understood by those skilled in the art made aware of this invention, such structural and/or functional analogy can be considered in the context of any such a-amino acid side chain, N-substituent and/or a sequence of such N-substituted glycine residues, such structure and/or function including but not limited to charge, chirality, hydrophobicity, amphipathicity, helical structure and facial organization. Such analogs include, without limitation, carbon homologs of such side chain—such homologs as would be understood by those skilled in the art, including but not limited to plus or minus 1 or 2 or more methylene and/or methyl groups.
In certain embodiments, the N-terminus of such a compound can be H; and the C-terminus can be selected from NH2, one and two N-substituted glycine residues. Regardless, such a compound can comprise 2 to about 5 or about 6 (X—Y—Z) non-periodic trimers. In certain such embodiments, at least one of X, Y and Z in each of the trimers can be selected to interrupt 3-fold periodicity. Without limitation, at least one X in at least one said trimer can be an NLys residue. In certain such embodiments, at least one of Y and Z in at least one such trimer can be a proline residue. In other embodiments, the monomeric residues can comprise at least two non-consecutive of the same or repeat trimers, with at least one such residue therebetween to interrupt periodicity. In certain such embodiments, at least one X in at least one such trimer can he an NLys residue, and at least one of Y and Z in at least one said trimer can be a proline residue.
In various other non-limiting embodiments, the N-terminus of such a compound can be an N-alkyl substituted glycine residue, with an alkyl substituent selected from about C6 to about C18 linear alkyl moieties. Regardless, such a compound can comprise 2 to about 5 (X—Y—Z) non-periodic trimers. In certain such embodiments, at least one of X, Y and Z in each of the trimers can be selected to interrupt 3-fold periodicity. In certain other embodiments, the monomeric residues can comprise at least two non-consecutive of the same or repeat trimers, with at least one residue therebetween to interrupt peridicity. In certain such embodiments, at least one X in at least one said trimer can be an NLys residue, and at least one of Y and Z in at least one said trimer can be a proline residue.
In part, the present invention can also be directed to one or more antimicrobial peptoid compositions comprising one or more of the poly-N-substituted glycine compounds of this invention. Such compounds as can optionally comprise one or more antimicrobial peptides and/or peptidomimetic compounds now or hereafter known in the art. Accordingly, this invention can be directed to a range of pharmaceutical compositions comprising one or more of the present polypeptoid/ampetoid compounds, optionally with an antimicrobial component of the prior art, and a pharmaceutically-acceptable carrier. Such compositions can be prepared and/or formulated as would be understood by those skilled in the art made aware of this invention. Regardless, as illustrated below, any of the present polypeptoid/ampetoid compounds and/or related compositions can be used alone or in combination, whether administered together or sequentially, in conjunction with one or more bacteria or microbial treatment methodologies. Without limitation, such a method can comprise providing one or more such poly-N-substituted glycine compounds and/or related compositions; and administering such compound(s)/composition(s) and/or contacting bacteria therewith. As would be understood by those skilled in the art, such administration can be in vitro or in vivo, using techniques of the sort described herein or straight-forward modifications thereof, such modifications as would also be known to those skilled in the art and made aware of this invention.
As illustrated, the present invention provides a class of helical, cationic, amphipathic, sequence- and/or length-specific poly-N-substituted glycines (peptoids) and related compositions with potent and very selective antibacterial activity. These molecules demonstrate broad-spectrum antimicrobial activity against a range of pathogens, and are able to effectively treat a bacterial infection in vivo. It has been demonstrated that these peptoids are both structurally and functionally analogous to antimicrobial peptides (AMPs), the natural molecules. Moreover, by modulating the sequence and side chain functionality, the activity and selectivity of antimicrobial peptoids can be tuned. Some compounds have minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) in the low micromolar range against Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria, with low mammalian cytotoxicity and negligible (<1%) hemolysis at their MICs. These activities are substantially improved over previous antibacterial peptoids earlier reported, the best of which were much more hemolytic toward human red blood cells. This invention also provides a new class of alkylated antibacterial peptoids, which retain the antimicrobial potency and selectivity in analogs as short as 5 monomers in length.
With reference to examples 1-9 and
Structure-activity studies of antimicrobial peptoids suggest close analogy between their mechanisms of bacterial killing and those of AMPs. Numerous studies of AMPs have found that, in general, increases in hydrophobicity and amphipathicity and decreases in net charge can bias a peptide toward a less selective mechanism. The converse is true, in that adding cationic charge, and decreasing hydrophobicity or amphipathicity can lead to a more selective peptide. The structure-activity studies conducted show that peptoids respond similarly to changes in physicochemical properties. That is, selective peptoids become less selective when their sequences are altered to make them more hydrophobic, more amphipathic, or less cationic, and vice versa. Antimicrobial peptoids are thus functional analogs of AMPs.
Specular X-ray reflectivity was used to examine molecular-level interactions of antimicrobial peptoids with lipids. Just as selective AMPs spend.the majority of their time oriented parallel to the plane of the membrane surface, antimicrobial peptoids are oriented in anionic DPPG monolayers with 56° between the surface normal and the long axis of the peptide—clearly not perpendicular to the membrane, which would be expected for a transmembrane pore-forming peptide—with clear interactions between the peptoid and the lipid headgroups. The similar lipid-bound orientations of AMPs and antimicrobial peptoids further suggests mechanistic analogy between the two classes of molecules.
The present invention, therefore, provides a novel class of antibiotics which offers a combination of several desirable properties, including but not limited to: 1. Efficacy in reducing bacterial counts in a mammalian system over a 24-hour exposure using an intraperitoneal injection mouse model. 2. low-micromolar antibacterial activity against a broad spectrum of clinically relevant pathogens; 3. selectivity that is tunable by molecular sequence characteristics, whereby mammalian cells are not harmed at the compounds' MICs; 4. functional analogy to natural antimicrobial peptides, which implies that, like AMPs, antimicrobial peptoids are not readily susceptible to the development of bacterial resistance.
The role of hydrophobicity is articulated by studies of antimicrobial lipopeptides, such as polymyxin B and trichogin. These AMPs are composed of a peptide chain with a fatty acid tail at the N-terminus. For example, the deacylated version of polymyxin B is much less bactericidal than the natural lipopeptide. Also, trichogin analogues with varying lengths of lipids showed greater activity with longer tails, and analogues with tails shorter than four carbon atoms were found to he inactive. Attachment of fatty tails to AMPs that are not normally acylated has also been attempted, and in some cases, alkylation of inactive cationic peptides was sufficient to endow the resulting lipopeptides with antibacterial or antifungal activity. Furthermore, studies by Shai et al. have found that when varying the length of an alkyl tail, a threshold of hydrophobicity is reached at which the peptide is no longer selective. That is, at a point, increasing tail length only increases hemolytic activity without improving antibacterial activity.
As illustrated herein, the in vitro activities of simple peptoid mimics of AMPs are strikingly similar to those of AMPs themselves. (See, e.g., Table 1.) Certain antimicrobial peptoids (“ampetoids”) exhibit broad-spectrum antimicrobial activity, low hemolysis, minimal effects on mammalian cellular metabolism, and efficacy at treating an infection in vivo. Furthermore, conjugation of fatty tails to peptoids can lead to selective, non-natural analogs of AMPs as short as five monomers in length that are potent against both bacteria and fungi. Structure-activity relationships observed in a library of rationally designed ampetoids are wholly analogous to those which describe many AMPs. Using synchrotron radiation to probe the interactions between ampetoids and lipid layers, AMP-ampetoid analogy was found to extend to molecular-level interactions.
rpe-
rpe)4-NH2
sap-Nspe)4-NH2
sna)2-NH2
sna)2-NH2
his)2-NH2
glu-Nspe-Nspe)2-NH2
glu-Nspe-Nspe)4-NH2
Nlys-Nssb-Nssb-Nspe-Nlys-NH2
E. coli MIC
B. subtilis MIC
†With 10 mM ammonium acetate and no TFA, pH 7.0.
‡Selectivity ratio, SR = (HD10)/(E. coli MIC).
§For concentrations reported as “> x”, x = 200 μg/mL-the highest concentration tested
An initial set of 15 ampetoid analogs was synthesized to determine whether peptoids are affected by structural and sequence modifications in a manner consistent with AMP activities. The designs for ampetoids in this library were derived from two antibacterial and selective amphipathic dodecamers, 1 and 2. Peptoid 1 [H-(Nlys-Nspe-Nspe)4-NH2] is composed of 2/3 Nspe, the peptoid analog of phenylalanine, and 1/3 Mys, the peptoid analog of lysine (see
A selectivity ratio (SR) for each compound was defined, also shown in Table 1, as the quotient of the 10% hemolytic dose (HD10) and the E. coli MIC. Thus, the SR is an estimate of an ampetoid's tendency to kill bacteria rather than mammalian cells. Ampetoid 1 has an SR of 6.0, similar to that of pexiganan (SR=5.8). As expected, melittin (well known to be cytotoxic) has a low SR of 0.16. Most AMPs have antibacterial activities in the low-micromolar range; since peptoid 1 has MICs in that range, the ampetoid library was primarily expected to yield variants with increased selectivity. Indeed, six of 13 variants are more selective than 1 and pexiganan (i.e. SRs>6).
The biocompatibility of selected oligomers with A549 lung epithelial cells was evaluated using the MTS [3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-5-(3-carboxymethoxyphenyl)-2-(4-sulfophenyl)-2H-tetrazolium] assay.
Structure-activity relationships derived from a library of ampetoids are discussed below according to the primary physicochemical parameter that was altered. As in previous studies, circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy was used to compare the helicities of the ampetoids by monitoring the intensity of spectral extrema, particularly at 190 and 220 nm. CD was performed in 10 mM aqueous Tris buffer, pH 7.4, alone and in the presence of two types of small unilamellar vesicles (SUVs) composed of model binary lipid mixtures: (1) anionic E. coli membrane-mimetic SUVs [POPE/POPG (7:3 mole ratio)], and (2) zwitterionic erythrocyte membrane-mimetic SUVs [POPC/cholesterol (CH) (1:1 mole ratio)].
With regard to chirality, using enantiomeric side chains (Nrpe in place of Nspe;
With regard to length, variants of 1 were created, ranging from 6 to 15 monomers, all with the same three-fold sequence repeat and 1:3 charge-to-length ratio. The shortened variants of 1, 16mer and 19mer (approx. 12 Å and 18 Å in length, respectively), are both active antimicrobials and are more selective than 1 (Table 1). In contrast, the lengthened variant of 1, 115mer (approx. 30 Å in length), is substantially more hemolytic (SR=0.55) and cytotoxic (
Hydrophobicity was modulated independently of length by replacing hydrophobic Ile-like Nssb and Phe-like Nspe monomers in 1 and 2 with bulkier and more hydrophobic Nsmb and Nsna, respectively (
Two variants of 1 with reduced hydrophobicity were also created. Two evenly spaced hydrophobic Nspe residues in 1 were replaced by /Vhis, an achiral peptoid monomer analog of histidine (
With respect to charge, the majority of AMPs are cationic, and replacement of their basic residues with uncharged or anionic moieties typically leads to a loss of antibacterial activity. To investigate this phenomenon in ampetoids, Mys monomers in 1 were substituted with glutamate-like Nglu (
To study amphipathicity, a terminally, rather than facially, amphipathic isomer of 1 with block-like architecture (1block) was created, as well as a scrambled sequence of 2 designed to preclude global amphipathicity (2 scrambled) ( Table 1). The terminal segregation of cationic and hydrophobic residues in the 1block sequence ensures a strongly amphipathic structure independent of the facial organization of residues along a helix. 1 block is slightly less antibacterial and more hemolytic than 1 (SR=2.6), although it has the same monomer composition. The CD spectra of 2scrambled in buffer and lipid environments (
pent-(Nlys-Nspe-Nspe)4-NH2
dec-(Nlys-Nspe-Nspe)4-NH2
pent-(Nlys-Nspe-Nspe)3-NH2
dec-(Nlys-Nspe-Nspe)3-NH2
pent-(Nlys-Nspe-Nspe)2-NH2
dec-(Nlys-Nspe-Nspe)2-NH2
dec-Nlys-Nspe-Nspe-Nlys-NH2
tridec-Nlys-Nspe-Nspe-Nlys-NH2
E. coli
B. subtilis
C. albicans
In order to test the effects of alkylation on antimicrobial peptoids, a series of alkylated variants of 1 was synthesized, systematically varying both the alkyl tail length and the length of the peptoid chain. In general, the length of the peptoid chain was decreased in increments 3 monomers (one full helical turn) from the original sequence of 1. However, based on the report of active ultrashort AMPs containing two positive charges, an additional Mys monomer was retained at the shortest length. Alkyl tails were incorporated via the submonomer peptoid synthetic protocol (using the appropriate alkylamine for the substitution step) as the side chain of the N-terminal peptoid residue. All peptoids were amidated at the C-terminus. Table 2 lists the shorthand names and sequences of the alkylated peptoids investigated, as well as the activities of these alkylated variants. Interestingly, it should be noted that C13-14mer—a compound roughly half the molecular weight of 1—exhibited antibacterial activity comparable to 1 and was in fact found to be more selective against erythrocytes.
Additionally, in order to characterize possible antifungal activity, a library of alkylated compounds was tested against C. albicans, a representative fungal strain. In several instances, compounds such as C10-16mer and C13-14mer were found to have potent and selective antifungal activity.
Whereas the preceding generation of molecules was designed to elucidate structure function relationships of specific molecular parameters (chirality, length, hydrophobicity, etc.), another generation compounds were designed explicitly to explore effects on selectivity. Antimicrobial activity of these compounds was tested against bacterial strains E. coli (ATTC 35218) and B. subtilis (ATTC 6633) in cation-adjusted MHB using the microdilution protocols previously described. The sequences, antimicrobial activities, hemolytic activities, and metabolic inhibitory concentrations against NIH 3T3 mouse fibroblast cells are summarized in Table 3 and the rationale of their design is described below.
spe-Nspe)3-NH2
spe-L-Pro-(Nlys-Nspe-Nspe)2-NH2
spe-L-Pro-Nlys-Nspe-Nspe-NH2
spe-L-Pro-Nlys-
spe-Nspe-Nlys-
spe-L-Pro-Nlys-
spe-Nspe-NH2
his variants
his-(Nlys-Nspe-Nspe)2-NH2
his)2-NH2
his)3-NH2
pm-
pm)4-NH2
spe-NH2
pm-Nspe)4-NH2
pm-
pm-Nlys-Nspe-Nspe)2-NH2
Nsdp variants
smb-
smb)4-NH2
smb-Nspe)4-NH2
lys-Nspe)2-NH2
lys-Nlys-Nspe)2-NH2
lys-Nspe)2-Nspe-Nlys-Nspe-NH2
lys-Nlys-
lys-Nspe-Nlys-Nspe-
lys-
Nlys-Nspe-NH2
lys-Nlys-
lys-Nspe-Nlys-Nspe-
lys-
Nlys-Nspe-Nspe-lys-Nspe-NH2
E. coli
B. subtilis
Without limitation, two molecules in Table I found to be extraordinary selective (1-Pro6 and 1-Nhis6,12) were used to derive several new sequences. Since 1-Pro6 was found to be highly antimicrobial but less hemolytic than 1, two isomcrically related compounds (1-Pro3, 1-Pro9) were created to explore the effect of proline residue position on activity and selectivity. One variant with prolines in both the third and ninth position (1-Pro3,9) was also designed to evaluate the effect of increasing the number of proline residues on the activity profile. A second pair of molecules (1-Nhis6 and 1-Nhis3,6,9,12) was created to explore the effect of modulating the number of Nhis residues within the sequence.
The effects of hydrophobicity on activity and selectivity was further explored with an additional set of molecules described in Table 3. Several sequences were designed with replacement of selected Nspe residues by achiral Npm residues (see
The hydrophobic side chain Nsdp, which is isomerically related to Nsmb (
A final family of sequences was designed to evaluate the effect of sequence register, charge distribution, and length on activity and selectivity. Compounds 1B and 1C are isomers of 1 in which the sequence register was changed to preclude the presence of terminal charges (Nspe-Mys-Nspe) or exhibit a C-terminal charge (Nspe-Nspe-Mys), respectively. Several compounds were also created with increased number of charges (i.e. decreased hydrophobicity) distributed over multiple faces of the molecule. Compound 1-Mys5,11 exhibits the sequence of 1 with the two Nspe monomers at positions 5 and 11 replaced with Mys resulting in two additional charges. Other variants include a 1B register sequence analogously substituted with Mys and positions 4 and 10 as both a 12mer (1B12mer-Mys4,10) and a 15mer (1B15mer-Mys4,10). Similarly, molecules with additional Mys monomers distributed on three faces (1B12mer-Mys4,6,10 and 1B15mer-Mys4,6,10) were also created.
Liquid (aqueous buffer) surface specular X-ray reflectivity (XR) studies were conducted using synchrotron radiation to investigate the membrane orientation and depth of penetration of ampetoid 1 in a model lipid layer which mimics the outer leaflet of the cell membrane (
XR data for a pure DPPG (anionic) film (FIG. 6—circles) fit well with a two-slab model, yielding a hydrocarbon tail density (ρr/ρs) of 0.99 and a hydrocarbon tail slab thickness (L1) of 17.9 Å, as well as a headgroup electron density (ρh/ρs) of 1.54 and headgroup slab thickness (L2) of 5.7 Å. These data are in good agreement with previous DPPG monolayer X-ray work. The XR profile changed dramatically after peptoid 1 was introduced (FIG. 6—squares), and fit a four-slab model. According to this fit, the first slab (ρt/ρs=0.96, L1=12.1 Å) corresponds to the lipid tails without 1, the second slab (ρt+p/ρs=1.05, L2=2.8 Å) to the tails region with partial insertion of 1, the third slab (ρh+p/ps=1.33, L2=7.0 Å) to the lipid headgroup region with 1 fully inserted, and the fourth slab (ρp/ρs=1.16, L2=3.6 Å) to 1 alone, protruding beyond the DPPG headgroups. This electron density profile is consistent with insertion of 1 through the lipid headgroups and partially into the lipid tail region. Furthermore, assuming that 1 retains its helical structure in model lipid monolayers, the data suggest that 1 inserts at an angle of approximately 56° between the interface normal and the long helical axis of the peptoid.
Proteus vulgaris ATCC 49132
Pseudomonas aeruginosa ATCC 27853
Proteus mirabilis
Klebsiella pneumoniae ATCC 33495
Enterobacter aerogenes ATCC 35029
Escherichia coli ATCC 25922
Serratia marcescens ATCC 13880
Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 29213
Staphylococcus aureus VAN1*
Staphylococcus aureus VAN2*
Staphylococcus aureus NRS100 (COL)
Staphylococcus aureus NRS119
Staphylococcus aureus NRS120
Enterococcus faecalis ATCC 29212
Enterococcus faecalis 99*
Enterococcus faecium 106*
Broad-spectrum activity against a variety of pathogenic bacteria is a hallmark of AMPs. Accordingly, selected peptoids and comparator peptide pexiganan were tested against sixteen clinically relevant biosafety-level-2 (BSL2) bacterial pathogens, 7 Gram negative strains and 9 Gram positive strains. The MICs for these microorganisms, summarized in Table 4, demonstrate promising activity comparable to that of pexiganan, which was optimized for pharmaceutical applications. In vivo efficacy of peptoids to treat infection in a mouse peritoneal injection model.
Using a murine peritoneal injection mouse model, the ability of peptoids to treat infection was evaluated in vivo. The results from three separate studies of peptoid 1 and two of peptoid 1-Nhis6,12 against saline treated controls are shown in
Previous work has shown that peptoids can be used to create compounds with antimicrobial activities similar to AMPs. In this study, the facile synthesis and high propensity for helix formation of peptoids was exploited to create and study a library of ampetoid variants that suggests functional and mechanistic analogy between ampetoids and AMPs and that demonstrates ampetoids' potential for development into clinically useful antibiotics.
The equivalent activities of 1 and 1enantiomer demonstrate that ampetoid mechanism is not dependent on overall handedness nor on stereospecific interactions with receptors or enzymes, an attribute which has also been observed for many AMPs. Evidence that ampetoids interact with and insert into membranes is provided by X-ray reflectivity studies (
Ultimately, whether ampetoid activity also adheres to trends relating structure and function was determined in a manner analogous to AMPs, and physicochemical properties of selective ampetoids were found consistent with those of selective AMPs and non-selective peptoids exhibit close similarities to cytotoxic peptides. Numerous structure-activity studies of a wide variety of AMPs have delineated the physicochemical characteristics that give rise to selective antibacterial activity or non-selective cytotoxicity. Regardless of structural class (i.e. α-helix, β-sheet, loop, or extended), non-selective AMPs typically (1) are very hydrophobic, such that their interactions with membranes are governed primarily by the hydrophobic effect, and (2) have a well-defined amphipathic structure. In contrast, the antibacterial activity of selective AMPs is dependent on (1) high net cationic charge (although excessive cationic charge can also lead to hemolytic activity) and (2) only moderate hydrophobicity. Perhaps counterintuitively, a well-defined amphipathic structure is not necessary for selective antimicrobial activity; destabilization of AMP secondary structure often leads to improvements in selectivity.
The ampetoids 1-Nglu4,10, 115mer, 1-Nsna6,12, and 1block are all less selective than peptoid 1 (SRs<6.0) (Table 1). Consistent with properties of non-selective AMPs, these compounds are all either more hydrophobic (according to RP-HPLC elution time) and/or less charged (1-Nglu4,10) than 1. Furthermor, they are all as (or more) helical than I in erythrocyte-mimetic POPC/CH SUVs (
In contrast, 19mer, 1-Nhis6,12, and 1-Pro6 all have antibacterial activities comparable to 1, but enhanced selectivities (SRs>6.0). These peptdids are all more hydrophilic than 1, and all have a net charge of at least +3. Thus, ampetoids are selectively active provided they have a net positive charge and are sufficiently but not excessively hydrophobic, a phenomenon that is wholly consistent with observations of selective AMPs. Additionally, retention of antibacterial activity and enhancement of selectivity in the shortened 19mer is is analogous to behavior observed in studies of truncated AMPs.
In general, the effect of length on ampetoid potency and selectivity can largely be attributed to differences in hydrophobicity (RP-HPLC retention time, Table 1), which increases proportionally with length. Since the 12mer 1 is more antibacterial than longer and shorter analogs, these results suggest the existence of an optimal hydrophobicity at which antibacterial activity is maximized; added hydrophobicity increases only hemolytic activity. This conclusion is also supported by the hydrophobicity variants, since moderately hydrophobic 2-Nsap2,5,8,11 and 2-Nsna6,12 are both more antibacterial and more hemolytic than 2, while the strongly hydrophobic 1-Nsna6,12 (Table 1) shows enhancement of hemolytic but not antibacterial activity relative to 1. These results are in agreement with observations of AMPs and their variants.
Although they are more hemolytic than 2, peptoids 2-Nsna6,12 and 2-Nsap2,5,8,11 are still more selective (SRs of 7.6 and 16, respectively) than 1, and their physicochemical properties are consistent with this finding. They are highly charged (+4), moderately hydrophobic, and exhibit CD spectra consistent with low helicity (
Indeed, results on the whole suggest that, consistent with AMPs, a highly amphipathic structure is required for hemolytic activity, but not for antibacterial activity. CD spectra of ampetoids in POPE/POPG SUVs (
CD spectra in erythrocyte-mimetic POPC/CH SUVs (
Results also indicate that hydrophobicity is relevant to hemolytic activity, and comparison of 1-Pro6 and 1 establishes this relationship more concretely. These ampetoids have similar sequences with the same net charge and yield nearly congruent CD spectra (
The results in Table 3 provide further insight into how molecular structural features modulate peptoid activity and selectivity. While antimicrobial activity does not change with respect to proline position, cytotoxicity is decreased as the proline is moved closer to the C-terminus. It is possible that proline provides structural stability at the C-terminus that makes it less harmful to mammalian cells while not affecting its ability to kill bacteria. Increasing the number of Nhis residues decreased both the antimicrobial activity as well as the cytotoxicity. Interesting, 1-Nhis6,12, the basis sequence for this family, was found to be far less active against E. coli ATCC 35218 than the strain originally tested (JM109).
The family of compounds containing varying amounts of achiral residues shows that while the positions of the achiral residues does not significantly affect antimicrobial activity, it may have an impact on selectivity (Table 3, 1-Npm2,5,8,11 vs. 1-Npm2,3,8,9). Interestingly, both of these compounds exhibit antimicrobial activity equal to that of compound 1, but exhibit superior selectivity. It also appears that antimicrobial activity is decreased with increasing achiral residues, an effect that could be due to the reduced hydrophobicity and decreased organizational structure of the helix. The sequence containing all Nsdp residues is relatively inactive, but that containing 4 Nsdp residues along one face (1-Nsdp2,5,8,11) exhibits antimicrobial activity.
Several compounds were made to investigate how increasing the number of charges and distributing them on multiple faces effects activity. Two molecules were increased in length in order to add hydrophobicity to counteract the increased charges. Interestingly, no molecule in this family was shown to be active against E. coli, likely due to the decreased hydrophobicity, but all are very active against B. subtilis. At the same time, all of them are completely nontoxic to both erythrocytes and mammalian cells. It is possible that this family acts via a different mechanism of action than less highly charged molecules.
The results of the broad spectrum antimicrobial testing and in vivo efficacy study demonstrate the therapeutic potential of antimicrobial peptoids. Nearly all seven peptoids tested were more potent against the nine Gram positive strains (including four vancomycin-resistant) than pexiganan. Against Gram negative strains, compounds 1 and 1-Nsdp2,5,8,11 showed activity comparable to that of pexiganan.
The in vivo results shown in
In summary, the results suggest that antibacterial activity among AMPs and ampetoids alike is dependent on moderate hydrophobicity and net cationic charge, while hemolytic activity is associated primarily with high hydrophobicity and a strongly amphipathic structure, regardless of helical content. MTS assays demonstrate a similar trend between hemolytic activity and cytotoxicity against A549 eukaryotic mammalian cells. The relationships between structure and function in ampetoids are empirically analogous to those in AMPs. X-ray reflectivity studies, which show that ampetoid 1 is membrane-active and adopts a stable membrane-bound orientation, demonstrate molecular-level analogy between AMPs and ampetoids.
Results with alkylated variants demonstrate that alkyl chain attachment may be used to create very short peptoids that are as antimicrobially active and non-toxic as longer unalkylated helices. In particular, both Ndec-16mer and Ntridec-14mer were found to be comparable in activity and selectivity to 1. Given that the lengths of most AMPs range from ˜12-100 amino acids, it is notable that such low molecular weight (<1 kDa) peptoids exhibit such potency and selectivity against both bacteria and fungi. N-terminal attachment of alkyl tails can be a useful motif for improving the potency and decreasing the molecular weight of ampetoids. Moreover, alkylation is an effective and tunable modification that exhibits a clear effect on peptoid function.
Peptoids have greater potential than peptides to be used as pharmaceuticals and in biomaterials due to their improved stability, bioavailability, and highly tunable side chain chemistry. Since peptides' potential for toxicity is a major obstacle limiting their clinical use, ampetoids' low cytotoxicity observed here relative to the AMP pexiganan further emphasizes their therapeutic potential. The results reported herein will aid in the rational design and optimization of ampetoids and other non-natural oligomers as antimicrobials in the future.
As a continuation of the study described above, various other ampetoids were created with the goal of more fully exploring how and to what extent specific structural characteristics influence selectivity. (See Tables 5-7,
Schematic structures showing the three-fold periodic architecture of peptoid 1 (the basis sequence) and ampetoid variants, including those discussed above, are shown in
The activities of all compounds against bacterial strains and mammalian cells are summarized in Table 6. The potencies of all compounds were determined against representative Gram-negative (E. coli ATCC 35218) and Gram-positive (B. subtilis ATCC 6633) biosafety level 1 (BSL1) organisms. In addition to hemolytic activity, the conventional measure of toxicity to mammalian cells, the effect of each ampetoid on NIH 3T3 mouse fibroblast cells was determined using the MTS tetrazolium salt-based colorimetric assay. While hemolysis measures the degree to which erythrocytes are lysed, the MTS assay indirectly quantifies the extent to which cellular metabolic activity is inhibited.
Because the range of hemolytic activities displayed by these molecules is significantly greater than that of inhibitory activities, hemolysis assays provide a more sensitive gauge of activity against mammalian cells. Therefore, the selectivity of each ampetoid for various bacterial strains compared to erythrocytes is reported as the selectivity ratio (SR), which is defined as the quotient of the 10% hemolytic dose and the minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) for each bacterial strain.
The ampetoids in this library exhibited antibacterial potencies against Grain-negative E. coli that ranged from 3.1 μM to >100 μM. Likewise, hemolytic activity ranged from HD10=16 μM to HD10>200 μM and metabolic inhibitory activity from ID50=4.9 μM to ID50>100 μM. The breadth of activities and selectivities evidenced by these compounds suggests that this library was well designed to effect a range of responses for elucidating structure-activity relationships. Compared to 1 (SRE. coli,=3.3), 17 of the 26 ampetoid variants demonstrate improved selectivity for E. coli (SRE. coli =6.8-26). Four ampetoids (1-Npm2,5,8,11, 111mer, 1ach-NSpe2, 1ach-NSpe12) exhibited equivalent activity (6.3 μM) and superior selectivity (SRE. coli=14-26) compared to pexiganan (SRE. coli=11). In comparison to their activities against E. coli, all oligomers were more potent against B. subtilis, with MICs ranging from 0.78 to 1.6 μM. Corresponding selectivity ratios were as high as >256.
Nlys4,10
Nspe-NH2
Nlys4,6.10
E. coli
B. subtilis
The secondary structure of ampetoids was evaluated using circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy in 10 mM Tris buffer (pH 7.4) and the same buffer containing small unilamellar vesicles (SUVs) comprised of either POPC/cholesterol (2:1 mole ratio) or POPE/POPG (7:3 mole ratio). Whereas the POPC/cholesterol mixture is a zwitterionic binary model lipid preparation that mimics the membrane of erythrocytes, the negatively charged POPE/POPG mixture mimics the composition of the E. coli outer membrane. A peptoid composed of aromatic right handed poly-proline-type-I-like helix exhibits spectral features including a maximum at 192 nm and two local minima at ˜202 nm and ˜220 nm, respectively.
Peptoid 1, with a periodic trimer repeat sequence of Mys-Nspe-Nspe, is composed of four facially-aligned Mys monomers (positions 1, 4, 7, and 10) along the left molecular face and has a charged N-terminal monomer, as shown in
The antimicrobial potencies against E. coli (MIC=6.3 μM) and B. subtilis (MIC=1.6 μM) of all three variants were the same as for 1, and their toxicities to NIH 3T3 cells were also similar, with ID50 values ranging from 4.9-5.6 μM. The hemolytic activity, however, was reduced for 1scr (HD10=64 μM) and 1B (HD10=55 μM) compared to 1 (HD10=21 μM) and 1C (Hp10=25 μM). As a result, the selectivities for 1scr (SRE. coli=10) and 1B (SRE. coli=8.7) were more favorable in comparison to 1 (SRE. coli=3.3) and 1C (SRE. coli=4.0).
CD spectroscopy showed that all these variants exhibited helicity in 10 mM Tris buffer similar to that of 1, with 1scr being slightly more helical and 1C, slightly less (
A second family of ampetoids was designed to evaluate the effect of increased charge density on potency and selectivity (
All variants in this family were significantly less active against E. coli (MIC=50→100 μM) and were non-hemolytic (HDE. coli>100 μM), a result largely effected by the reduced hydrophobicity of these variants compared to 1. Because this family of variants does not exhibit a broad range of selectivities (SRE. coli>2 to >4), elucidating a meaningful relationship between physicochemical properties and selectivity is difficult. A general trend observed, however, is that variants with a CTLR of less than ˜0.50, hydrophobicity greater than ˜50% acetonitrile, and one completely hydrophobic face (1-Mys5,11, 1B-Mys4,10, and 1B15mer-Mys4,10) exhibited weak activity (MICE. coli=50 μM). Variants with CTLRs greater than ˜0.50, hydrophobicity less than ˜50% acetonitrile, and had charges distributed on all three molecular faces (1B-Mys4,6,10 and 1B 15mer-Mys4,6,10) were completely inactive (MICE. coli>100 μM). These results are commensurate with structure activity relationships previously established for both AMPs, and ampetoids: (1) antimicrobial oligomers must be sufficiently hydrophobic to be potent against Gram-negative bacteria, and (2) highly charged and poorly amphipathic structures are generally selective.
It is most notable that the reduction in activity against E. coli exhibited by this family of molecules did not carry over to their activities against B. subtilis. Despite the marked change in physicochemical properties (NC as high as +8, hydrophobicity as low as 45.4% acetonitrile, and CTLR as high as 0.58) exhibited by this family of molecules compared to 1 (NC=+4, hydrophobicity=65.1%, and CTLR=0.33), the MICs of these variants against B. subtilis were very similar to that of 1, ranging from 0.78-1.6 μM. The resultant selectivity ratios of molecules in this library for B. subtilis were among the highest of all compounds tested (SRB. submis>256).
The CD spectra in
Variants of the dodecameric peptoid 1 that ranged in length from 10-13 monomers were explored as shown in
Considering first only those variants with a net charge of +4 (110mer, 111mer, 1), both hydrophobicity, and CTLR scale monotonically with length. Ampetoid 1 (12mer) is the most hydrophobic (65.1% acetonitrile) and exhibits the lowest CTLR (0.33), while 110mer is the least hydrophobic (60.9% acetonitrile) and is characterized by the highest CTLR (0.40). The data in Table 5 show that cell selectivity is directly related to CTLR and inversely related to hydrophobicity. The slight reduction in activity of 110mer against E. coli (12.5 μM), (a result of its lowered hydrophobicity), was accompanied by a much larger improvement in its hemolytic activity (HD10>200 μM); 110mer is therefore the most selective of this group (SRE. coli>16). 111mer retained antimicrobial activity equivalent to that of 1 (MICE. coli6.3 μM), but was less selective than 110mer (SRE coli=16). Ampetoid 1 was found to be the least selective (SRE. coli=3.3). The same trend was observed for selectivity against B. subtilis (Table 6).
It is notable that based on the above correlation, 113mer (CTLR of 0.38) would be expected to have an improved selectivity compared to 111mer (CTLR=0.36), however this is not the case. On the contrary, ampetoid 111 mer (SRE. coli=16) is more selective than 113mer (SRE. coli=6.8). This may be attributable to the fact that while 110mer, 111 mer, and 1 all have a net charge of +4, that of 113mer is increased to +5. As discussed previously, net charge can affect cell selectivity, particularly against Gram-negative strains. 111mer, with a CTLR of 0.36 and net charge of +4 represents the optimum balance of potent antimicrobial activity and cell selectivity from this group of molecules. However, the selectivity ratios of 110mer (SRE. coli>16), 111mer (SRE. coli=16), and 113mer (SRE. coli=6.8) are all superior to that of 1 (SRE. coli=3.3)
While proline monomers in naturally-occurring AMPs are known to destabilize a-helical secondary structure and induce the formation of helix-bend-helix motifs, here, proline is well accommodated in the polyproline type-I-like peptoid helical architecture. Because of proline's reduced hydrophobicity compared to Nspe, substituting L-proline for a centrally-located hydrophobic residue in ampetoid 1's sequence (variant called 1-Pro6) was found to lower molecular hydrophobicity and improve selectivity. A family of molecules was designed to evaluate how the relative position and number of proline monomers affects potency and selectivity, while maintaining constant CTLR and helicity. Similar to 1-Pro6, 1-Pro3 and 1-Pro9 have a single proline monomer substituted into the third and ninth positions of the ampetoid 1 sequence, respectively. A fourth variant, 1-Pro3,9 incorporates two substituted proline monomers (
The activity of these variants against E. coli scales with hydrophobicity; 1-Pro3, 1-Pro6, and 1-Pro9 exhibited uniformly reduced potencies against E. coli (12.5 μM) compared to peptoid 1 (6.3 μM). The potency of 1-Pro3,9 was lessened further against E. coli (50 μM). Because these variants also exhibited reduced activity against mammalian cells, selectivity was improved for all the mono-substituted variants (SRE. coli=5.9-13) compared to 1 (SRE. coli=3.3).
An intriguing observation regarding the mono-substituted proline-containing variants is that the relative position of the proline monomer in the sequence affected cell selectivity. 1-Pro3, 1-Pro6, 1-Pro9 comprise a family of molecules in which CTLR, net charge, and hydrophobicity are held constant. Moreover, the degree of amphipathicity among these variants is similar, based on the similarity of their CD spectra in both aqueous buffer and lipid environments (
Another strategy for improving selectivity relates to a family of ampetoids with less hydrophobic, achiral Npm side chains in place of selected Nspe monomers in ampetoid 1 (
The hydrophobicities of these compounds ranged from 59.8% for 1achiral to 65.1% for peptoid 1 and generally increased with Nspe content. Moreover, as shown in
All variants with achiral side chains exhibit activities similar to peptoid 1 against E. coli (MIC=6.3-12.5 μM) and B. subtilis (MIC=0.78-1.6 μM), yet have substantially higher selectivities for bacteria over mammalian cells (SRE. coli=6.2-26; SRB. subtili=24-235) (Table 6). In general, selectivity increased with Npm content, a monomer substitution for Nspe that simultaneously decreases amphipathicity and hydrophobicity.
This family of variants provides further insight into how hydrophobicity and helicity impact potency and selectivity. Previous studies have shown that variants designed to be less hydrophobic, (via incorporation of more polar histidine-like side chains (e.g. 1-Nhis6,12) or less hydrophobic L-proline monomers (e.g. 1-Pro6) improved selectivity, but only at the expense of reduced antimicrobial activity. Indeed, this observation also held true for the proline-containing variants reported herein. The activity and selectivity profiles of four molecules in this family, however, demonstrate clearly that hydrophobicity can be reduced to improve selectivity without compromising antimicrobial activity. Variants 1ach-Nspe2, 1ach-Nspe12, 1-Npm2,5,8,11, and 1-Npm2,3,8,9) demonstrate antimicrobial activity equivalent to that of 1 (MICE. coli=6.3 μM), yet significantly improved selectivities (SRE. coli=6.2-26) compared to 1 (SRE. coli=3.3). The most overt difference between using achiral Npm compared to Nhis or L-Pro monomers to lower hydrophobicity is their effect on helicity. While both 1-Nhis6,12 and 1-Pro6 exhibited helicity equivalent to that of 1, the substitution of Npm monomers resulted in a progressive decrease in helical stability, as shown in
Comparison of the isomeric pairs within this group suggest that the relative position of achiral monomers does not have a significant effect on selectivity. For example, comparison of 1ach-Nspe2(SRE. coli=25, ID50=11 μM) and 1ach-Nspe12 (SRE. coli=26, ID50=15 μM) suggests that selectivity against both erythrocytes and NIH 3T3 cells was unaffected by the position of the one chiral Nspe monomer in the sequence. Comparison of isomeric variants containing equal numbers of Npm and Nspe monomers in different positions (1-Npm2,5,8,11 and 1-Npm2,3,8,9) suggest that while 1-Npm2,5,8,11 (SRE. coli=14) was more selective against erythrocytes than 1-Npm2,3,8,9 (SRE. coli=6.2), the opposite trend was evident in selectivity against NIH 3T3 cells (ID50=6.8 μM and 15 μM, respectively). Taken together, these results suggest that there is no clear relationship between the degree of selectivity and relative position of achiral monomers within the ampetoid sequence.
1enantiomer, a variant of peptoid 1 in which all Nspe side chains were replaced with enantiomeric Nrpe monomers, has previously been shown to exhibit left-handed helicity, but antibacterial activities and cell selectivities congruent to those of peptoid 1. Because peptoid secondary structure is dictated by the chirality of its side chains, it is unclear what the resultant secondary structure (and associated activity/selectivity profiles) would be in a peptoid that included both enantiomeric side chains. Moreover, diasteriomeric peptides that contain both D- and L-amino acids were found to exhibit potent, broad-spectrum antimicrobial activity and improved selectivity. Here, variants of 1 can contain equal numbers of Nspe and Nrpe side chains in different arrangements as shown in
The antibacterial potencies and cell selectivity profiles of these variants are very similar to that of peptoid 1, despite their disparate secondary structures.
The CD spectal intensity for all Nrpe containing peptoids are significantly reduced compared to that of 1, an observation previously correlated with decreased amphipathicity. However, because the CD spectra corresponding to variants in cell membrane-mimetic lipid environments are not typical of a peptoid helical secondary structure, it is not clear how amphipathicity is affected in these molecules.
The effect of side chain chemistry on cell selectivity, was evaluated with a family of ampetoids that have bulky, hydrophobic, aliphatic Nsdp side chains in place of some or all of the aromatic Nspe monomers in ampetoid 1 (
1-Nsdpall has Nsdp substituted at all eight hydrophobic monomers in the peptoid 1 sequence. 1-Nsdp2,5,8,11 and 1-Nsdp2,3,8,9 are isomers in which half of peptoid 1's Nspe monomers were replaced with aliphatic Nsdp's. As shown in
The CD spectra of right-handed helical peptoids with chiral, aliphatic side chainS have been shown to be distinctly different from those with aromatic side chains in that the most pronounced spectral feature is a maximum at 210 nm. Indeed, the speCtrum of 1-Nsdpall exhibits this feature in both aqueous and lipid environments (
The increase in selectivity of 1-Nsdpall (SRE. coli>8) was realized at the cost of significantly reduced activity against E. coli of (25 μM) in comparison to 1 (SRE. coli=3.3; MICE. coli=6.3 μM). 1-Nsdpall was highly potent against B. subtilis (0.78 μM), resulting in a selectivity ratio of 256 (Table 6).
The sequences containing equal numbers of aromatic and aliphatic monomers, 1-Nspd2,5,8,11 and 1-Nsdp2,3,8,9, exhibited slightly reduced antimicrobial activity (MICE. coli=12.5 μM) and improved selectivity (SRE. coli=9.7 and 6.2, respectively) compared to 1 (MICE. coli=6.25 μM, SRE. coli=3.3). While the slightly reduced hydrophobicity could be in part responsible for the improved selectivity, comparison with other variants suggests that the aliphatic side chain chemistry also plays an important role in its activity profile. Unlike what has been observed in some sequences that contain all aromatic hydrophobic monomers, the incorporation of aliphatic side chains appears to improve selectivity, but only at the expense of antimicrobial activity. For example variants 1-Npm2,3,8,9 (63.3% acetonitrile) , 1-Npm2,5,8,11 (63.6% acetonitrile) and 111mer (63.5% acetonitrile) all exhibit hydrophobicities comparable to that of 1-Nsdp2,5,8,11 (63.8% acetonitrile). The balance of the antimicrobial activity and selectivity profiles of 1-Nsdp2,5,8,11, however, is less optimal than for sequences containing only these aromatic side chains; compared with these three molecules (MICE. coli=6.3 μM, SRE. coli=6.2-16) the antimicrobial activity of 1-Nsdp2,5,8,11 is reduced (MICE. coli=12.5 μM) and selectivity (SRE. coli=9.7) comparable. The overall hydrophobicities of these three molecules (63.2%-64.7%) were slightly reduced compared to 1 (65.1%). The reduced hydrophobicity of 1-Nsdpall (63.2%) could in part be responsible for its reduced activity, however the lack of aromatic side chains may also play a role. Variants containing both aliphatic and aromatic side chains appear to provide a balance of low antimicrobial activity (MICE coli=12.5 μM) and improved selectivity compared to 1 (SRE. coil=6.2-12): 1-Nsdp2,3,8,9 (SRE. coli=6.2-12), and 1-Nsdp2,5,8,11 (SRE. coli>9.7).
The antimicrobial activity of selected ampetoids and comparator peptide pexiganan was tested against 16 clinically-relevant BSL2 bacterial strains. The panel of bacterial strains included seven Gram-negative species (Proteus vulgaris, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Proteus mirabilis, Klebsiella pneumonia, Enterobacter aerogenes, Escherichia coli, and Serratia marcescens) and nine strains from three Gram-positive species (Staphylococcus aureus, Enterococcus faecalis, and Enterococcus faecium). Ampetoids 1, 1-Pro6, 1-Pro9, 1achiral, 1 -NpM2,5,8,11, and 1-Nsdp2,5,8,11 were tested against these organisms. The MICs (expressed in μg/mL) are shown in Table 7A and corresponding selectivity ratios (quotient of 10% hemolytic dose and MIC) are presented in Table 7B.
The activities of the six peptoids tested were all similar to that those of pexiganan against P. vulgaris (MTC=32-64 μg/mL), K pneumoniae (MIC=8-16 μg/mL), and E. coli (4-16 μg/mL). Against P. mirabilis and S. marcescens, pexiganan and all peptoids tested were inactive (MIC≧128). The activities of ampetoids tested against BSL2 Gram-positive strains, however, compared very favorably to those of pexiganan. The MIC of pexiganan against the six strains of S. aureus tested ranged from 8-64 μg/mL, whereas those of all the peptoids tested ranged from 4-16 μg/mL. Interestingly, 1 was uniquely active against both strains of E. faecalis (MIC=4-8 μg/mL), compared to other ampetoids (MIC=8-64 μg/mL) and pexiganan (MIC=32-128 μg/mL). All compounds were equally potent against E. faecium (MIC=4 μg/mL).
P. vulgaris ATCC
P. aeruginosa ATCC
P. mirabilis ATCC
K. pneumoniae
E. aerogenes ATCC
E. coli ATCC 25922*
S. marcescens ATCC
S. aureus
E. faecalis
E. faecium 106*
P. vulgaris ATCC
P. aeruginosa ATCC
P. mirabilis ATCC
K. pneumoniae ATCC
E. aerogenes ATCC
E. coli ATCC 25922*
S. marcescens ATCC
S. aureus
E. faecalis
E. faecium 106*
§indicates methicillian-resistant S. aureus (MRSA) strain;
†indicates vancomycin-resistant strain;
‡indicates linezolid-resistant strain.
The selectivity ratios presented in Table 7B show that against most Gram-negative bacterial species, at least one ampetoid had greater selectivity compared to pexiganan; the most favorable selectivity ratio against each Gram-negative species is shown in boldface type in Table 7B. 1achiral, 1-Pro9, and 1-Nsdp2,5,8,11 were the most selective against selected MDR bacterial strains. Against Gram-positive strains, ampetoids more consistently demonstrated improved selectivity compared to pexiganan or ampetoid 1. Against all S. aureus strains, for example, the selectivity ratios of pexiganan ranged from 2.8-23, ampetoid 1 ranged from 4.8-9.5, and those of the panel of more selective ampetoids ranged from 9.1-39.
As shown above, ampetoids are a new class of AMP mimics that have been shown to exhibit potent, broad-spectrum antimicrobial activity and appear to use mechanisms of action similar to their natural counterparts. An understanding of factors that influence cell selectivity can be used in the context of corresponding pharmaceutical agents. Accordingly, a library of ampetoids was designed to explore how and to what extent various physicochemical properties and structural motifs influenced their cell selectivity.
To broaden understanding of how ampetoids may be affecting different types of mammalian cells, the hemolytic dose as well as the metabolic inhibitory dose was determined against NIH 3T3 mouse fibroblast cells. While the hemolytic and inhibitory activities exhibited similar trends for many ampetoids, the hemolytic dose was consistently higher than the inhibitory dose for the same compound. This is a trend that has also been reported for pexiganan as well as other AMP mimics. It is possible that the disparity between the hemolytic and inhibitory closes is due in part to differences in membrane composition between the two cell types. The cholesterol content of erythrocyte membranes, for example is approximately 230 μg/mg protein, whereas NIH 3T3 cholesterol content has been reported as only 30.5 μg/mg protein. The increased cholesterol content of erythrocytes may affect the rigidity of the membrane and offer increased resistance to membrane-active antimicrobial agents compared to NIH 3T3 cells.
Another disparity between hemolysis and MTS assays is that they differ in terms of the measure used to quantify cytotoxicity; while hemolysis measures the ampetoid dose needed to lyse erythrocytes, the MTS assay quantifies the dose needed to inhibit cellular metabolism, measured indirectly by the amount of NADH produced by the cell population. It is reasonable to expect, therefore that a dose needed to lyse a cell membrane would not necessarily be equivalent to the dose required to inhibit cellular metabolism. Whereas lysis implies membrane disruption activity, interference with cellular metabolism implies intracellular targets. While animal testing would be required to determine a true therapeutic index for these molecules, hemolysis and MTS assay results together suggest that the relative effect of many ampetoids against both cell types may be similar.
This library of ampetoids was designed to include members that exhibit a variety of structural motifs and possess physicochemical properties that span a wide range of values. Different ampetoids demonstrated promising activities against the various Gram-negative strains, but were most potent against K. pneumonia (ATCC 33495) and E. coli (ATCC 25922). It is particularly notable that all 26 ampetoid variants were consistently very potent against the Gram-positive screening organism, B. subtilis. The broad-spectrum testing results of selected ampetoids against MDR strains of S. aureus, E. faecalis, and E. faecium show that ampetoids are also potent against MRSA (4-8 μM) as well as vancomycin- and linezolid-resistant organisms (4-8 μM and 4-16 μM, respectively). The corresponding selectivity ratios of 1achiral (19-39) and 1-Pro9 (18-36) against MDR S. aureus strains are particularly favorable compared to those of pexiganan (2.8-23) or ampetoid 1 (4.8-9.5). The burden of MDR Gram-positive infections on the healthcare system is significant and only increasing; these results suggest that ampetoids can be a viable alternative to conventional therapies to address this unmet clinical need.
Structure-activity studies have shown that the antibacterial activity and selectivity profiles of ampetoids are governed by the physicochemical properties that, in a similar manner, dictate the activity and selectivity of AMPs. The structure-activity relationships gleaned from these studies not only provide further evidence to re-affirm these findings in ampetoids, but also provide additional insight into principles that influence how more subtle changes related to the number, sequence position, arrangement and chemical structure of specific structural moieties influence activity and selectivity.
Potent, but non-selective AMPs and ampetoids tend to be hydrophobic and adopt well-defined amphipathic structures, while more selective AMPs and ampetoids are typically highly cationic, exhibit only moderate hydrophobicity, and are often less amphipathic. As discussed previously, the activity and selectivity results of this study, which included several new ampetoid sequences, re-affirm these general relationships in several ways: (1) Comparison of the less amphipathic, more selctive 1scr to 1; (2) Comparison of the highly charged, less amphipathic variants (1-Mys5,11, 1B-Mys4,10, and 1B15mer-Mys4,10, 1B-Mys4,6,10 and 1B15mer-Mys4,6,10) compared to 1, (3) Comparison of less hydrophobic proline-containing variants (1-Pro3, 1-Pro6, 1-Pro9, 1-Pro3,9) to 1 (4) Comparison among achiral variants (1achiral, 1ach-NSpe2, 1ash-Nspe12, 1-Npm2.3,8,9, 1-Npm2,5,8,11), which exhibit a range of hydrophobicities and amphipathicities that scale with selectivity. Taking a closer look at more specific structural characteristics of the ampetoids included in this study, the influence of subtle molecular changes on activity and selectivity can be elucidated.
Comparison among the mono-substituted proline monomers suggests that the position of monomers along the length of the molecule and can impact selectivity. The mono-substituted proline monomers exhibited progressively increased selectivity as the less hydrophobic proline monomer was moved from the N-terminal toward the C-terminal region.
Trends observed in the selectivity profiles of sequence register variants (1, 1B and 1C) as well as length variants, 113mer suggest that monomer position with respect to the termini also influences selectivity. All variants are similarly potent against E. coli: the MICE.coli of 1, 1B, and 1C was 6.3 μM, while that of 113mer was improved by one dilution (3.1 μM). While 1 and 1C each have one charged Mys monomer at the N and C-termini, respectively, 1B has hydrophobic Nspe monomers at both termini. Conversely, 1l3mer has charged Mys monomers at both terminal positions. Consider these molecules in two groups: (1) those with both termini charged or hydrophobic (1B and 113mer), and (2) those with one charged and one hydrophobic terminus (1 and 1C). Interestingly, the hydrophobicity of those.with dissimilar termini, 1 (65.1% acetonitrile) and 1C (64.8% acetonitrile) is greater than that of variants with like monomers at terminal positions, 1B (63.4% acetonitrile) and 113mer (62.8% acetonitrile). Correspondingly, the selectivity of the less hydrophobic variants 1B and 113mer (SRE. coli=6.8-8.7, SRB. subuilis=27-34) is improved compared to that of 1 and 1C (SRE. coli=3.3-4.0, SRB. subtilis=13-16). This suggests that having similarly charged termini (either both hydrophobic or both positively charged) reduces molecular hydrophobicity and results in an improvement in selectivity. This could be related to a similar phenomenon reported for antimicrobial peptide analogs of magainins, which found that the relative position of hydrophobic monomers in the sequence can impact resultant hydrophobicity and cell selectivity. These results indicate that a strategy for improving selectivity, while maintaining antimicrobial activity, is to design the sequence with similarly charged or similarly hydrophobic terminal monomers.
As discussed previously, the achiral family of variants provide evidence that suggests the incorporation of achiral Npm hydrophobic monomers in place of chiral Nspe monomers is another means of improving selectivity without compromising antimicrobial activity. Variants in which as many as seven of the eight Nspe's in ampetoid 1's structure exhibited equivalent activity and significantly improved selectivity. It appears that the decrease amphipathicity that occurs concomitantly with increased Npm content results in a favorable selectivity profile. It is possible that the less rigid structure of ampetoids with increased achiral monomer content is less able to penetrate the rigid cell membranes of mammalian cells.
A third way in which this library of compounds was designed to affect selectivity is through increased CTLR. The increased charge density variants, with CTLRs in the range of 0.47-0.58 (compared to 0.33 for ampetoid 1), were at best mildly active against E. coli (MIC=50 to >100 μM). Length variants, however, which were designed to effect a change in CTLR over a lower range (0.33-0.40). Of these variants, 111mer was found to exhibit the most optimum balance of CTLR (0.36) and sufficient hydrophobicity to perrneabilize bacterial membranes (63.5%) at a low minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICE. coli=6.3 μM).
Two other means of reducing hydrophobicity, substituting in L-proline content or aliphantic Nsdp monomers, are less favorable because they improve selectivity at the expense of antimicrobial activity against Gram-negative bacteria. The addition of one proline monomer (1-Pro3, 1-Pro6, and 1-Pro9, MICE. coli=12.5 μM) and two proline monomers (1-Pro3,9, MICE coli=50 μM) progressively decreased activity compared to that of ampetoid 1 (MICE. coli=6.3 μM). Molecules with four (1-Nsdp2,3,8,9 and 1-Nsdp2,5,8,11, MICE. coli=12.5 μM) and eight (1-Nsdpall, MICE. coli=25 μM) aliphatic monomers exhibited a similar trend in reduced antimicrobial activity.
Another observation is evident from the characterization of 1achiral, 1-Nrpe3,6,9,12, and I-Nrpe2,5,8,11, which suggests that ampetoids can exhibit potent antimicrobial activity without necessarily adopting a stable helical secondary structure. As the name suggests, 1achiral is devoid of any chiral monomers and is thus not optically active; the resultant CD spectra in aqueous buffer and lipid environments is flat (
A pair of molecules was designed to evaluate if the facial segregation aliphatic and aromatic hydrophobic monomers impacts selectivity. While 1-Nsdp2,5,8,11 has four substituted aliphatic monomers aligned along molecular faces, 1-Nsdp2,3,8,9 has a mixture of aliphatic and aromatic hydrophobic monomers on both faces (
The most promising therapeutic agents exhibit are highly potent against bacteria and are nontoxic to mammalian cells. This relationship is depicted graphically in
As shown, ampetoids are a promising class of AMP mimics that exhibit potent, broad-spectrum activity, particularly against many multi-drug resistant Gram-positive organisms. Of the 26 sequences presented here, 17 demonstrate improved selectivity for E. coli compared to the basis sequence, 1. The structure-activity relationships derived from this library of compounds reaffirm and extend the analogy between the mechanism of action of AMPs and ampetoids. Selective ampetoids tended to be only moderately hydrophobic and amphipathic, while non-selective ampetoids were highly hydrophobic and exhibit more highly amphipathic structures. The relationships among ampetoid variants in this library also point to the effects of how more subtle changes in sequence, side chain chemistry, and monomer position effect selectivity. Three strategies to improve ampetoid selectivity without compromising selectivity include (1) Positioning of similarly cationic or hydrophobic monomers at the sequence terminal positions, (2) Inclusion of hydrophobic achiral Npm monomers in place of Nspe monomers (3) Optimizing the CTLR while retaining sufficient hydrophobicity to permeabilize bacterial cell membranes. Two approaches, specifically designed to reduce hydrophobicity effected the desired outcome of improving selectivity, but only at the cost of reduced antimicrobial activity. This less optimal activity profile resulted from (1) Substitution of less hydrophobic L-proline monomers as well as (2) Substitution of aliphatic Nsdp monomers. Interestingly, while the relative position along the helix of some monomers played a role in selectivity (e.g. mono-proline substituted variants), this was not always the case (e.g. achiral variants). The preservation of at least one aromatic face may also play a role in increasing selectivity. Lastly, thus study provides evidence that antimicrobial activity can be maintained in ampetoids which lack a stable secondary structure (1achiral) or appear to adopt a secondary structure different from that of the canonical peptoid helix (1-Nrpe2,5,8,11 and 1-Nrpe3,6,9,12). Because peptoids are sequence-specific biopolymers that can be made from a diversity of primary amines, it is conceivable that ampetoid potency and selectivity could be finely tuned to fight specific, clinically-relevant organisms. The design heuristics established herein may aid in the design of potent, yet selective, future generations of ampetoids.
As discussed above, cationic AMPs comprise a diverse class of natural antibiotics produced by a vast array of organisms. This universal presence and broad-spectrum activity against multiple pathogens has created substantial interest in developing them for clinical applications. Due to rising rates of drug resistance, the need for novel antibiotics is acute, but many AMPs suffer from high dose-limiting toxicity. One potential solution to the problems of both resistance and toxicity is to use a, synergistic combination of antimicrobial compounds.
Accordingly, as an extension of the foregoing, antimicrobial peptoids of this invention can be employed synergistically with antimicrobial peptides and with each other. Using checkerboard antibacterial assays, fractional inhibitory concentrations were determined for a panel of representative cationic, helical antimicrobial peptoids and peptides against both Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria, which revealed highly synergistic interactions.
For such studies, a panel of two AMPs and seven antimicrobial peptoids, with a range of hydrophobicities and selectivities for bacterial versus mammalian cells, were selected. Peptoids were synthesized as described herein, and peptides were synthesized using conventional 9-fluorenyl-methoxy carbonyl (Fmoc) chemistry. The names, sequences, hydrophobicities, antibacterial activities against Gram-negative (E. coli) and Gram-positive (B. subtilis) bacteria, and hemolytic activities of these nine compounds are shown in. Table 8 (with reference to Examples 16-18, below). The antibacterial activities are reported as MICs and were determined according to standard CIST M7-A6 protocols (CLSI. 2006. Methods for dilution antimicrobial susceptibility tests for bacteria that grow aerobically, 6th ed. Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute, Wayne, Pa.); hemolytic activities, determined as previously reported (Chongsiriwatana, N. P., et al. 2008. Peptoids that mimic the structure, function, and mechanism of helical antimicrobial peptides. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 105:2794-2799), serve as a measure of antimicrobial peptide/peptoid toxicity performance (Findlay, B., G. G. Zhanel, and F. Schweizer. 2010. Cationic amphiphiles, a new generation of antimicrobials inspired by the natural antimicrobial peptide scaffold. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 54:4049-4058), as is commonly used in the art to optimize antimicrobial peptide/peptoid therapeutic.
E. coli
B. subtilis
Nspe-Nspe)2-NH2
aCompounds are listed in order of increasing molecular hydrophobicity, as measured by reverse-phase
bBoldface indicates residues that differ from the sequence of peptoid 1.
cDetermined using a gradient of 5 to 95% acetonitrile (ACN) over 45 min on a C18 column at 0.2 ml/min.
dCalculated as HD10/E. coli MIC.
Selectivity ratios (SRs) were calculated for each compound, which were defined as the quotient of the 10% hemolytic dose (HD10) and the E. coli MIC. All seven peptoids were based on dodecamer 1, above, which contains one-third lysine-like NLys monomers and two-thirds phenylalanine-like Nspe residues (See, in particular, the residue monomers of
Checkerboard antibacterial assays were used to determine fractional inhibitory concentrations (FICs) and FIC indices (ΣFICs) for interactions between peptoids and peptides. A EFIC of 1 is defined as additive with no synergy, and values of ≦0.5 indicate increasing degrees of synergy. Lowest ΣFICs for combinations of the compounds in Table 8 are shown in Tables 9 and 10 (for E. coli and B. subtilis, respectively).
Against E. coli (Table 9), 21 of 36 combinations tested (excluding controls) demonstrated ZFICs of ≦0.50, indicating synergy; 7 combinations yielded ΣFICs of ≦0.25, indicating highly synergistic interactions with at least an 8-fold decrease in the MIC of each compound in the presence of the other. These highly synergistic interactions comprised all three possible classes of combinations: peptide-peptide, peptide-peptoid, and peptoid-peptoid. In contrast, but without limitation, no synergistic trends were observed against B. subtilis (Table 10).
E. coli ATCC 35218a
(51.2)
-NHis
(51.4)
(60.4)
Pro6 (62.2)
0.16 (0.20/3.1)
0.16 (1.6/6.3)
0.25 (6.3/6.3)
0.31 (3.1/3.1)
0.50 (3.1/6.3)
0.19 (0.20/3.1)
0.25 (6.3/3.1)
0.31 (12.5/1.6)
0.31 (3.1/3.1)
0.50 (3.1/6.3)
0.16 (0.20/1.6)
0.16 (1.6/1.6)
0.31 (3.1/3.1)
0.31 (3.1/0.78)
0.50 (3.1/3.1)
0.38 (0.78/1.6)
0.50 (0.20/3.1)
0.50 (12.5/1.6)
0.50 (3.1/1.6)
0.50 (0.1/1.6)
0.50 (1.6/3.1)
(65.1)
(70.1)
aΣFICs or ≦0.50 are shown in bold type. Additionally. ΣFICs of ≦0.25 are underlined. The molar compositions of the lowest. FIC wells are shown in parentheses beside each ΣFIC. Compounds are organized in order of increasing molecular hydrophobicity horizontally and decreasing molecular hydrophobicity vertically.
b“A” denotes the compound listed across the top, and “B” denotes the compound listed on the left side.
indicates data missing or illegible when filed
B. subtilis ATCC 6633a
ACN) for B. subtilis ATCC 6633b
(60.4)
-Pro6 (62.2)
ACN) for B. subtilis ATCC 6633b
(68.1)
aCompounds are organized in order of increasing molecular hydrophobicity horizontally and decreasing molecular hydrophobicily verically.
b“A” denotes the compound listed across the top, whereas “B” denotes the compound listed on the left side.
indicates data missing or illegible when filed
Without limitation to any one theory or mode of operation, two possible mechanisms may account for synergy between two compounds: the compounds associate to form a third entity with more potent antimicrobial activity, or the two compounds operate through complementary mechanisms. The latter situation may be applicable for the compounds tested for several reasons. First, although the seven peptoids were all derived from the sequence of peptoid 1, many of the most synergistic combinations involved both peptoids and peptides that differ considerably in sequence. Were these compounds forming synergistic dimers, they might be expected to share common structural (i.e., dimerization) motifs. Second, intermolecular associations should give rise to both antagonistic and synergistic interactions—it is likely that dimerization would, in some cases, inhibit the normal action of each molecule, with antibacterial activity of the dimer being worse than that of its constituents. The conspicuous absence of antagonism in both Tables 9 and 10 (i.e., ZFICs ≧4.00) implies that intermolecular associations are not responsible for synergy in these cases. (Notably, Gal, which is well known for its synergistic interaction with magazine-2, has been shown to interact antagonistically with AMPs other than magazine-2). Third, if heterodimerization were responsible for synergy, synergistic combinations would be expected to exhibit 1:1 stoichiometry. Instead, the majority of the highly synergistic pairs worked most efficiently in molar ratios other than 1:1 (Tables 9 and 10).
If complementary mechanisms are indeed responsible for the observed synergy, then several important mechanistic hypotheses may be deduced. As seen in Table 9, highly synergistic interactions (ΣFIC≦0.25, corresponding to at least an 8-fold decrease in the MIC for each compound in the presence of the other) between these nine oligomers against E. coli occurred exclusively in ,combinations containing one selective (less hydrophobic) compound and one nonselective (more hydrophobic) compound. It is therefore likely that the members of synergistic pairs in Table 9 employ distinct but complementary mechanisms.
Notably, these synergy data are highly consistent with mechanistic analogy between antimicrobial peptoids and peptides. One of the most synergistic combinations consists of the peptides pexiganan and melittin (ΣFT=0.16). A high degree of synergy is maintained either if the nonselective melittin is replaced by a nonselective peptoid (e.g., 117mer) or if pexiganan is replaced by a highly selective peptoid (e.g., 1-NLys5.11), or both. The robustness of synergy to these substitutions implies that the mechanisms used by peptoids are fully analogous to those used by AMPs of similar hydrophobicity and selectivity.
The hemolytic activities of the nine most synergistic pairs in Table 9 were determined by combining them in the molar ratios present in lowest-ΣFIC wells and serially diluting them. The resulting HD10 and FID50 for each combination, as well as the molar ratio used, are shown in Table 11. In addition, the theoretical HD10 and HD50 were calculated for each combination from the individual hemolysis data (Table 8) by assuming an additive hemolytic interaction; i.e., using averaged individual percent hemolysis curves, weighted according to the molar composition of the combinations, with the hemolytic doses determined from the averaged curves (Table 11). A close correspondence was found between experimentally determined hemolytic doses and those theoretically calculated assuming that hemolysis was nonsynergistic, demonstrating that hemolytic activities are the result of additive, rather than synergistic, interactions (Table 11). This is not particularly deleterious, however, since much current development of antimicrobial peptides is for topical applications, and synergy can be maximized while hemolytic activity is minimized by using two moderately selective peptoids, as in the combination 1-1-Pro6.
Accordingly, it has demonstrated that the present invention can be used to provide highly synergistic interactions between antimicrobial peptoids and/or peptides. The observed synergy strongly suggests mechanistic analogy between these two classes of compounds. Furthermore, the tendency of hydrophobic oligomers to synergize with relatively hydrophilic oligomers suggests that selective and nonselective antimicrobial peptides and peptoids kill bacteria via distinct but complementary mechanisms, offering a pathway to further optimize both for therapeutic applications.
aAssumes additive interaction—calculated as the weighted average of percent hemolysis curves.
The following non-limiting examples and data illustrate various aspects and features relating to the compounds, compositions and/or methods of the present invention, including the preparation of various helical peptoid compounds, as are available through the synthetic methodology described herein. In comparison with the prior art, the present peptoid compounds provide results and data which are surprising, unexpected and contrary to the prior art. While the utility of this invention is illustrated through the use of several compounds and/or compositions, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that comparable results are obtainable with various other compositions, component compounds, peptoid lengths, residue sequences and/or N-pendant side chains, as are commensurate with the scope of this invention.
Synthesis and purification. Peptoids were synthesized either using an ABI 433A peptide synthesizer or a parallel synthesis robot on Rink amide resin according to the submonomer method. (See, e.g., Zuckermann, R. N., Kerr, J. M., Kent, S. B. H., & Moos, W. H. (1992) J. Am. Chem. Soc., 114, 10646-10647.) Briefly, the amide on the nascent chain is bromoacetylated, followed by SN2 displacement of bromide by a primary amine to form the side chain. Peptides were synthesized using standard Fmoc chemistry. Following synthesis, peptoids and peptides were cleaved and deprotected in trifluoroacetic acid (TFA):triisopropylsilane:water (95:2.5:2.5 by vol.) for 10 min. Compounds were purified to >97% homogeneity by RP-HPLC on a C18 column with a linear acetonitrile/water (0.1% TFA) gradient. Mass spectrometry was used to confirm the molecular weight of the purified product.
The submonomer method is illustrated graphically in
More specifically, Rink Amide resin (4-(2′,4′-Dimethoxyphenyl-(9-fluorenylmethyloxycarbonyl)-aminomethyl)-phenoxy resin, 0.25 mmol; Novabiochem) can be initially swelled for 30 min in CH2Cl2. Following the resin swelling, the 9-fluorenylmethyloxycarbonyl (Fmoc) protecting group is removed by treatment with 20% piperdine solution in 1-methyl-2-pyrrolidone (NMP). The resin-bound deprotected amine is then bromoacetylated by reaction with 4.2 ml of 1.2 M bromoacetic acid (50 mmol) in N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) and 1.0 ml (11 mmol) neat N,N′-diisopropylcarbodiimide (DIC) for 60 minutes at room temperature with constant mixing. Next, the resin is rinsed with DMF (3×10 ml), followed by NMP rinses (3×10 ml). 6 ml of a 1 M solution (6 mmol) of a primary amine “submonomer” (see below) in either NMP or CH2Cl2 reacted with the resin-bound bromoacetyl moiety, displacing bromide. A protected submonomer (N-tert-butoxycarbonyl-1,4-butanediamine) is synthesized in order to create the N-(4-aminobutyl)glycine residue (Mys). The resin is then rinsed again with NMP (3×10 ml) followed by DMF (3×10 ml). The product of these two reactions generates a peptoid “residue”, the identity of which depended upon the submonomer amine employed. Peptoids are elongated by this submonomer method until the desired chain-length was attained.
Following synthesis, peptoid oligomers can be cleaved from the resin, simultaneously removing the tert-butoxycarbonyl (Boc) protecting group from Mys residues, by treatment with 10 ml 2,2,2-trifluoroacetic acid (TFA)/triisopropylsilane/H2O (95:2.5:2.5 by volume) for 30 min. The cleavage mixture is then diluted with 25 ml 50% aqueous acetonitrile, frozen, and lyophilized. Dilution and lyophilization is repeated twice more in order to remove excess TFA. Subsequent to cleavage, peptoids are each purified to >97% homogeneity by preparative scale reversed-phase HPLC using a Waters Prep LC 4000 system, with Waters 2487 dual-wavelength UV detection, and gradient elution (solvent A, 0.1 vol % trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) in water; solvent B, 0.1 vol % TFA in acetonitrile) through a Vydac (Hysperia, Calif.) 214TP101550 C4 peptide/protein column (10-15 μm, 300 Å, 5×25 cm). Following prep HPLC, peptoid purities and crude yields were determined from analytical scale HPLC, performed with a Waters 2695 Separations Module with a Waters 2487 dual-wavelength UV detector and gradient elution (solvent A, 0.1 vol % TFA in water; solvent B, 0.1 vol % TFA in acetonitrile) through a Vydac C4 214TP53 peptide/protein column (5 μm, 300 Å, 3.2×250 mm). The precise gradient employed for HPLC depended on the identity and hydrophobicity of the oligomer in question. The composition of the HPLC solvent at gradient elution is an indication of this hydrophobicity, and is provided in Table 1. All analytical HPLC was performed at 0.5 ml/min flow and 58° C. Preparative HPLC was performed at 50 ml/min flow and room temperature.
Such synthesis and characterization are also described in U.S. Pat. No. 6,887,845, the entirety of which is incorporated herein by reference. As illustrated therein and as would be understood by those skilled in the art made aware of this invention, the present N-substituted glycine residues and resulting peptoid compounds are limited only by synthetic or commercial availability of the corresponding amine reagents.
SUV preparation. Lipid mixtures, either POPE/POPG (7:3) or POPC/CH (1:1), were dissolved in chloroform, dried under N2, and lyophilized overnight. The resulting lipid film was hydrated with 10 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.4) at 40° C. for one hour. The resulting multilamellar vesicle suspension was vortexed, then sonicated at 40° C. until the solution clarified to make SUVs, which were used within 6 hours.
CD spectroscopy. CD measurements were perfbrmed on a Jasco 715 spectropolarimeter, using a quartz cylindrical cell (path length=0.02 cm), with 50 μM peptoid in 10 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.4) and 5 mM lipids when SUVs Were used. Scans were conducted at 100 nm/min between 185 and 280 nm with 0.2 nm data pitch, 1 nm bandwidth, 2 s response, 100 mdeg sensitivity, and 40 accumulations.
Antibacterial assays. MICs were determined according to CLSI M7-A6 protocols in a 96-well microtiter plate. In test wells, 50 uL bacterial inoculum (5×105 CFU/ml) in Mueller-Hinton broth (MHB) was added to 50 μL peptoid solution in MHB (prepared by 1:2 serial dilutions). Positive controls contained 50 μL inoculum and 50 μL MHB without peptoid. The MIC was defined as the lowest concentration of peptoid that completely inhibited bacterial growth after incubation at 35° C. for 16 h. MIC values reported were reproducible between three independent experimental replicates, each consisting of two parallel trials. Broad-spectrum antimicrobial susceptibility testing was performed against BSL2 pathogens by Nova Biologicals, Inc. (Conroe, Tex.).
Antifungal Assays. MICs were determined using the broth microdilution assay given by CLSI M27-A2 protocols. Candida albicans (SC5314) was grown on Sabouraud dextrose agar for 24 hours at 30° C. Cells were suspended in 0.145 M saline, and the cell concentration was adjusted to 3×106 cells/mL. After adjusting the cell concentration, the suspension was diluted 1:1000 with RPMI 1640 (with L-glutamine and without sodium bicarbonate, Invitrogen) buffered with 0.145 M 3-(N-morpholino) propanesulfonic acid (MOPS). Two-fold serial dilutions of peptoids, peptides, and amphotericin B (Calbiochem) were prepared in RPMI 1640 and mixed with an equal volume of the cell suspension in 96-well plates. The final testing concentrations for the peptoids and peptides were 0.20 to 100 μM, and concentrations for amphotericin B were 0.031 to 16 μM. Growth controls and sterility controls were also included. Plates were incubated for 48 hours at 35° C., and growth of C. albicans was inspected visually to determine the MICs. The MIC for each compound was defined as the lowest concentration with no visible fungal growth. Experiments were performed in duplicate on two separate days.
Hemolysis assays. Erythrocytes were isolated from freshly drawn, heparanized human blood and resuspended to 20 vol % in PBS (pH 7.4). In a 96-well microtiter plate, 100 μL erythrocyte suspension was added to 100 uL peptoid solution in PBS (prepared by 1:2 serial dilutions), or 100 μL PBS in the case of negative controls. 100% hemolysis wells contained 100 μL, blood cell suspension with 100 μL 0.2 vol % Triton X-100. The plate was incubated for 1 h at 37° C., then each well was diluted with 1504 PBS. The plate was then centrifuged at 1200 g for 15 min, 100 μL of the supernatant from each well transferred to a fresh microtiter plate, and A350 measured. Percent hemolysis was determined as (A−A0)/(Atotal−A0)×100, where A is the absorbance of the test well, A0 the absorbance of the negative controls, and Atotal the absorbance of 100% hemolysis wells, all at 350 nm.
MTS Assays. A549 carcinoma-derived lung epithelial cells (ATTC CCL-185) were cultured in Ham's F12K media (ATTC, Manassas, Va.). A peptoid solution plate (100 μL/well) was prepared by serial dilution of aqueous peptoid stocks in media. Peptoid solutions were transferred onto a 96-well plate of day-old cell monolayers containing 100 μL/well media with 5000 cells/well. MTS reagent (Promega Corporation, Madison, Wis.) (40 μL/well) was added to each well and the plate was incubated at 37° C. for 3 h, after which absorbance at 490 nm was determined. Percent inhibition was determined as [1−(A−Atest blank)/(Acontrol−Ablank)]×100, where A is the absorbance of the test well and Acontrol the average absorbance of wells with cells exposed to media and MTS (no peptoid). Atest blank (media, MTS, and peptoid) and Ablank (media and MTS) were background absorbances measured in the absence of cells. The average of six replicates are reported, and error bars show one standard deviation.
Specular X-ray reflectivity. XR experiments were carried out at the 9-ID beamline at the Advanced Photon Source, Argonne National Laboratory (Argonne, Ill.). The custom-built Langmuir trough was mounted in a helium-filled, sealed canister and equipped with a moveable single barrier. The surface pressure was measured using a Wilhelmy plate. Constant-pressure insertion experiments were performed at room temperature on Dulbecco's PBS (D-PBS) subphase. DPPG (Avanti Polar Lipids, Alabaster, Al) was dissolved to a known concentration in 65/35 (v/v) chloroform/methanol, then spread at the air-buffer interface using a glass syringe; organic solvent was allowed to evaporate for 10 minutes. The monolayer was compressed to the surface pressure thought to occur in cell membranes, 30 mN/m, and XR was performed on the pure lipid layer. Then, peptoid 1 dissolved in D-PBS was injected into the subphase to a total concentration of 6.26 μM (well above the MICs), and allowed to insert for approximately 45 minutes, after which XR measurements were again collected. The X-ray reflectivity (XR) profile was determined by the Fourier transform of the gradient of the electron density perpendicular to the interface. XR measurements were carried out over a range of angles corresponding to qz values of ˜0-0.6 Å−1, where qz=(4π/λ)sin(α), λ is the wavelength, and α is the angle.
Murine intraperitoneal infection model. Bacteria was prepared by inoculating 5 mL of MHB with a single colony of Staphyloccus aureus (ATCC #25923) from a freshly streaked plate and grown overnight at 37 C. The following morning, the bacteria was subcultured by diluting 1/3 in MHB and grown for approximately 1 .5 hours. The bacteria were then diluted 10-fold in a 5% mucin in PBS solution and thoroughly mixed. A sample was reserved to later determine the amount of bacteria the mice received.
Mice were weighed, marked, and injected I.P. with 200 uL of S. aureus inoculum. Four hours post infection, mice were treated I.P. with 4 mg/kg peptoid (˜100 ug per mouse). The infection is allowed to proceed overnight. Mice were euthanized by CO2 asphyxiation after 24 hours, and the peritoneal cavity was exposed and lavaged with 5 mL PBS. The lavage was mixed and reserved on ice until plating. The lavages were diluted to 10−5 (in1/10 increments) in PBS, and all dilutions were plated onto MH agar, in duplicate. 50 uL of lavage was spot plated, allowed to dry, and incubated overnight at 37° C. Colonies were counted the following day, and the CFU/ml of each sample was calculated. Plates that had too many colonies to count were assigned an arbitrary number of 1000 colonies.
Compound synthesis and purification. Peptoids were synthesized using an ABI 433A peptide synthesizer (Applied Biosystems, Inc.) on Rink amide MBHA resin (Novabiochem, Inc.) using the submonomer approach3. Briefly, bromoacetic acid, activated by diisopropylcarbodiimide was used to form a bromocetylated intermediate on the terminal amide group. Bromide was then substituted with the desired primary amine through SN2 displacement to build the peptoid chain. The amines used in peptoid synthesis include benzylamine, octadecylamine, (s)-(+)-2-amino-3-methylbutane, (s)-α-methylbenzylamine, (r)-(α-methylbenzylamine (all purchased from Sigma-Aldrich), and N-tert-butoxycarbonyl-1,4 diaminobutane (Mys) that was made using a published procedure83. Resin-bound peptoids were then exposed to a mixture of trifluoroacetic acid (TFA): triisopropylsilane:water (95:2.5:2.5, v:v:v) for ten minutes to cleave peptoids from the solid phase. Peptoids were purified by reversed-phase HPLC (RP-HPLC) (Waters Corporation) using a C18 column and a linear acetonitrile/water gradient. A final purity greater than 97% as measured by analytical RP-HPLC (Waters Corporation) was achieved, and the identity of each molecule was checked using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. All reagents were purchased from Sigma Aldrich.
Circular dichroism spectroscopy. A Jasco 715 spectropolarimeter was used to perform all CD measurements in a cylindrical quartz cell with a path length of 0.02 cm. Measurements were taken over the range of 190 nm to 280 nm at a scanning rate of 100 nm/min. Other parameters include data pitch of 0.2 nm, bandwidth of 1 nm, response time of 2 seconds, and sensitivity of 100 mdeg. Compound concentration was 60 μM in 10 mM Tris buffer (pH 7.4). For samples in the presence of SUVs, the lipid concentration was 5 mM. 40 accumulations were collected for each sample.
Screening antibacterial assays. MICs were determined in 96-well microtiter plates in accordance with CLSI M7-A6 protocols. Peptoid solutions with 50 μL total volume were prepared using 2:1 serial dilutions. 50 i—tL of bacteria inoculum (1×106 CFU/mL) prepared in cation-adjusted Mueller-Hinton broth (CAMHB) was added to test wells. Control wells contained 100 μL MHB (no growth) or 50 μL inoculums with 50 μL MHB with no peptoid. The MIC was taken as the lowest concentration of peptoid that completely inhibited bacterial growth after 16 hours of incubation at 35° C. Reported values were reproducible over three experiments, each containing two parallel trials.
Broad-spectrum antibacterial assays. MICs of compounds were determined by microdilution procedure in Mueller-Hinton broth (MHB) in accordance with CLSI M7-A6 protocols in a manner similar to that described for the screen antibacterial assays. Inoculated microtiter plates were incubated at 35° C. for 24 hours prior to the result being recorded. Four ATCC strains that were used as standards are recommended by CLSI: Pseudomonas aeruginosa ATCC 27853, Escherichia coli ATCC 25922, Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 29213 and Enterococcus faecalis ATCC 29212. Other strains from the ATCC collection include Proteus vulgaris ATCC 49132, Proteus mirabilis ATCC 35659, Klebsiella pneumoniae ATCC 33495, Enterobacter aerogenes ATCC 35029 and Serratia marcescens ATCC 13880. S. aureus NRS100 (COL) is a well characterized methicillian-resistant S. aureus (MRSA) strain. The strains S. aureus VAN1 and S. aureus VAN2, vancomycin-resistant MRSA strains that were isolated in Michigan and Pennsylvania, were the first vancomycin-resistant strains clinically isolated. S. aureus NRS 119 and S. aureus NRS 120 are linezolid-resistant isolates from the Network on Antimicrobial Resistance in S. aureus (NARSA) collection. E. faecalis 99 and E. faecium 106 are vancomycin-resistant enterococcal strains.
Hemolysis assays. Erythrocytes were isolated from freshly drawn, heparanized human blood and resuspended in PBS (pH 7.4) to make a 20% volume suspension. Peptoid solutions were prepared by serial dilution (2:1) in a 96-well microtiter plate. For test wells, 100 μLL of erythrocyte suspension was added to 100 μL of peptoid solution in PBS; PBS without peptoid was used as the negative control and 0.2 vol % Triton X-100 as the positive control that indicates 100% hemolysis. After 1 hour incubation at 37° C., each well was diluted with 150 μL PBS. Plates were then centrifuged at 1,200×g for 15 minutes to pellet the cells. 30 μL of the supernatant from each well were transferred to the corresponding well of a second 96-well plate that contains 70 μL PBS. Using a plate reader, the absorbance at 350 nm was measured, and percent hemolysis was defined as (A−A0)/(Atotal−A0)×100, where A is the absorbance of the test well, A0 the average absorbance of negative controls, and Atotal the average absorbance of 100% hemolysis wells.
MTS assays. NIH/3T3 cells (ATCC Corporation) cultured at 37° C. and 5% CO2 in complete Dulbecco's modified eagle's media (CDMEM) supplemented with 1% sodium pyruvate, 1% penicillin-streptomycin, 1.5 g/L NaHCO3, and 10% fetal bovine serum. Cells were seeded at a density of 5,000 cells per well for NIH/3T3 cells in 96-well plates (100 μl total volume). A peptoid solution plate (100 μL total volume per well) was prepared by serial dilution of aqueous peptoid stock solution in Hank's balanced salt solution (HBSS) media. The day-old cell monolayers were washed with HBSS and media was replaced with 100 μL HBSS. The contents of the peptoid solution plate were transferred onto corresponding wells of the cell monolayer plate, and 40 μL MTS reagent (Promega, Inc.) was added to each well. After incubating for 3 hours at 37° C., absorbance at 490 nm was determined. The percentage inhibition was determined as [1−(A−Atestblank)/(Acontrol−Ablank)]×100, where A is the absorbance of the test well and Acontrol the average absorbance of the wells with cells exposed to media and MTS (no peptoid). Atestblank (media, MTS, and peptoid) and Ablank (media and MTS) were measured as background absorbances in the absence of cells. The average of six replicates is reported.
Antibacterial Assays for Compositions. MICs were determined according to CLSI M7-A6 protocols in a 96-well microtiter plate. In test wells, 50 μL bacterial inoculum (1×106 CFU/ml) in cation-adjusted Mueller-Hinton broth (CAMHB) was added to 50 μL peptoid solution in CAMHB (prepared by 1:2 serial dilutions). Positive controls contained 50 μL inoculum and 50 μL CAMHB without peptoid. The MIC was defined as the lowest concentration of peptoid that completely inhibited bacterial growth after incubation at 35° C. for 16 h. MIC values reported were reproducible between three independent experimental replicates, each consisting of two parallel trials.
Hemolysis assays for Compositions. Erythrocytes were isolated from freshly drawn, heparanized human blood and resuspended to 20 vol % in PBS (pH 7.4). In a 96-well microtiter plate, 100 μL erythrocyte suspension was added to 100 peptoid solution in PBS (prepared by 1:2 serial dilutions), or 100 μL PBS in the case of negative controls. 100% hemolysis wells contained 100 μL blood cell suspension with 100 μL 0.2 vol % Triton X-100. The plate was incubated for 1 h at 37° C., then each well was diluted with 150 μL PBS. The plate was then centrifuged at 1200g for 15 min, 100 μL of the supernatant from each well transferred to a fresh microtiter plate, and A350 measured. Percent hemolysis was determined as (A−A0)/(Atotal−A0)×100, where A is the absorbance of the test well, Ao the absorbance of the negative controls, and Atotal the absorbance of 100% hemolysis wells, all at 350 nm.
Checkerboard antibacterial assays for Compositions. FIC indices were determined in a 96-well plate, which was assembled from two separate auxiliary plates. Inoculation with bacteria was performed at the end, after all solutions of compound in growth media had been prepared. For growth media, a cation-adjusted Mueller-Hinton broth (CAMHB)—the same media used for antibacterial assays. The overall format of the final, main plate after inoculation was as follows: column 1—negative growth controls (200 μL CAMHB only); column 2—positive growth controls (100 μL CAMHB and 100 μL bacterial inoculum); columns 3 and 4—individual MIC determinations for compounds A (in column 3) and B (in column 4), each well consisting of 100 μL serially diluted peptide or peptoid in CAMHB and 100 μL bacterial inoculum; columns 5 through 12—the 8×8 well “checkerboard,” each well consisting of 50 μL serially diluted compound A, 50 μL serially diluted compound B, and 100 μL bacterial inoculum.
The checkerboard was assembled by overlaying serial dilutions of compound B perpendicularly to serial dilutions of compound A. To ensure that all peptoid/peptide solutions in the assay were transferred the same number of times, and thus that each well was subject to identical pipetting errors, dilutions of A and B were prepared in two separate auxiliary plates, and both were transferred into the main plate. Because they were to be compared directly with results in the checkerboard, the solutions making up the individual MIC determinations in columns 3 and 4 of the main plate were also assembled from two separate transfers from the auxiliary plates.
Each of two auxiliary plates consisted of ten columns of 2:1 serial dilutions of each compound to a final volume of 60 μL. While only 50 μL were transferred from each well, the extra 10 μL ensured greater accuracy when withdrawing the 50 μL. The main plate was assembled from the auxiliary plates according to the following protocol. (1) Prepare the control wells in the main plate by pipetting 200 μL CAMHB into column 1 and 100 μL CAMHB into column 2. (2) Prepare each auxiliary plate for serial dilutions by pipetting 60 μL CAMHB into columns 3 through 10, rows B through H only. (3) Pipette enough CAMHB and peptoid/peptide stock solution into columns 3 through 10, row A to make 120 μL of compound (at 2× the final upper concentration for the individual MIC determinations and 4× the final upper concentration for the cheCkerboard) in each well. (4) Serially dilute the auxiliary plates by aspirating row A to mix well, transferring 60 μL from row A into row B. Repeat mixing and transfer down the rows of the plate. (5) To assemble the individual MIC determinations in the main plate, transfer 50 μL of column 3, then overlay 50 μL column 4 from auxiliary plate A (which contains dilutions of compound A) into main plate column 3; likewise, transfer columns 3 and 4 from auxiliary plate B into main plate column 4. This should give 100 μL of serial dilutions of compound A in column 3 and 100 μL serial dilutions of B in column 4 of the main plate. (6) To assemble the checkerboard, transfer 50 μL columns 5 through 12 from auxiliary plate A into the same wells on the main plate. Then, rotate and transfer auxiliary plate B wells into columns 5 through 12 of the main plate as follows: auxiliary plate B column 5 into main plate row A, auxiliary plate B column 6 into main plate row B, etc.
To prepare the bacterial inoculum, an aliquot of an overnight culture of E. coli ATCC 35218 or B. subtilis ATCC 6633 in CAMHB was adjusted with fresh CAMHB to yield a 1×106 CFU/mL inoculum. To inoculate the main plate, 100 μL inoculum was pipetted into all wells except column 1, bringing the total volume for each well to 200 μL. The plates were incubated at 35° C. for 16 hours (the same conditions used for MIC assays). Inhibition was determined by naked-eye observation, or by OD590 if assistance was needed.
This application claims priority benefit from application Ser. No. 61,439,621 filed Feb. 4, 2011 and is a continuation-in-part of and claims priority benefit from application Ser. No. 12/378,034 filed Feb. 9, 2009 and application Ser. No. 61/065,189 filed Feb. 8, 2008, each of which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
This invention was made with government support under Grant Nos. 1 R01HL67984 and AI007266 awarded by the National Institutes of Health and Contract No. DE-AC02-05CH11231 awarded by the U.S. Department of Energy. The government has certain rights in the invention.
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 61065189 | Feb 2008 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 12378034 | Feb 2009 | US |
| Child | 13385181 | US |
