Sinter-homogenized heating products

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 5611953
  • Patent Number
    5,611,953
  • Date Filed
    Monday, May 15, 1995
    29 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, March 18, 1997
    27 years ago
Abstract
Electrical heating elements operable at high temperatures for long periods are produced by a method involving micropyretic synthesis. Compositions subjected to micropyretic synthesis comprises a powdery mass of electrically conductive and semiconductive material, a reactive system, a grain growth inhibitor and a plasticizer or extrusion agent.
Description

FIELD OF INVENTION
This invention relates to composite silicide or carbide heating element compositions which include improved combustion sources and refractory silicides such as tungsten silicide. This invention will enable combustion synthesized composite heating elements which include the combustion sources disclosed herein to be used at temperatures up to 900.degree. C. for long periods of time in oxidizing atmospheres.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
This invention has been conceived to create heating elements which can work at high temperatures for long periods. Accordingly, this invention discloses new micropyretic sources and their combinations which allow for the first time, manufacture of heating elements displaying extended life at very high temperatures. A micropyretic synthesis method is used for the manufacture of heating elements, similar to that disclosed in our co-pending U.S. patent application Ser. No. 08/027,710, filed Mar. 8, 1993 (herein after referred to as "the '710 application", the contents of which are incorporated herein by way of reference). The synthesis method used in this invention differs from that disclosed in co-pending U.S. patent application Ser. No. 07/847,782, filed Mar. 5, 1992 (hereinafter referred to as "the '782 application", the contents of which are incorporated herein purely by way of reference), in an important aspect. As in the '782 application, a combustible slurry is prepared, extruded and combusted. However, unlike the '782 application, after combustion, these wire or other shapes are densified and homogenized by passing current, as described in the '710 application.
The '782 application discloses various combustion sources as part of the compositions, for the manufacture of heating elements. MoSi.sub.2 composites are preferred in the '782 application. MoSi.sub.2 composites are very sensitive to phase composition and impurity at temperatures above 1600.degree. C. The present compositions comprise new undisclosed combustion sources, grain growth inhibitors and other additives which substantially improve the applicability of heating elements manufactured using these compositions at temperatures up to 1900.degree. C. Additionally, some of the combustion sources and their products described in the '782 application may react with filler materials, and therefore may not be suitable as combustion sources for high temperature applications although they may be excellent for low and middle temperature applications (up to 1400.degree. C.). The compositions of the present invention are designed so that the combustibles do not react with the silicides, which is believed to be one of reasons leading to the effective utilization of heating elements manufactured using the compositions of the present invention for extended periods at high temperatures. By utilizing combustibles which may react with the filler materials, the '782 application teaches away from the present invention.
The high temperature superiority of heating elements manufactured using the compositions of the present invention, over the compositions of the '782 application, has been observed by experimentation. These experiments have revealed that heating elements using the compositions of the present invention are stable at temperatures above 1400.degree. C., for much longer periods than those manufactured using the compositions of the '782 application. Without exception, a difference in time periods of at least two orders of magnitude has been observed. At temperatures above 1400.degree. C. to 1600.degree. C., after operation for 10-100 hours, heating elements using the '782 compositions deteriorate substantially. Conversely, typical heating elements using the compositions of the present invention show similar deterioration at 1400.degree. C. to 1600.degree. C., only after 5000 hours. Additionally, above 1600.degree. C., heating elements using the '782 compositions last for less than 1 hour, whereas typical heating elements using the compositions of the present invention last for greater than 1000 hours. This tremendous increase in high temperature operability, is very beneficial and also quite unexpected.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
It is a primary object of the present invention to provide new combustion sources and compositions for manufacturing heating elements which are stable up to 1900.degree. C.
It is a further object of the present invention to provide new combustion sources which will enhance the working temperature and life of heating elements and improve the oxidation resistance of heating elements at high temperatures.
It is another object of the present invention to provide new combustion sources which will prevent any possible reaction between the combustion sources, the combustion products, the silicides and the plasticizers.
It is yet another object of this invention to provide combustion synthesis product(s) with increased creep resistance and strength, by forming in situ compounds between carbides such as tungsten carbide and metalloids such as carbon or silicon. Such compounds are finely and homogeneously distributed in matrix of a major silicide phase e.g. in MoSi.sub.2 or WSi.sub.2. In addition, these finely distributed particles will also act as grain growth inhibitors and also influence the recrystallization behavior.
In accordance with the present invention, there is provided a pliable composition comprising by weight percent: (a) between about 10 and 90% of a powdery mass of electrically conductive and/or semiconductive material selected from the group consisting of WSi.sub.2, MoSi.sub.2 and mixtures thereof; (b) between about 5% and 50% of a combustible source which is selected from the group consisting of WO.sub.3 +Al+Si, MoO.sub.3 +Zr+Si, WO.sub.3 +Zr+Si, WC+Si, Mo.sub.2 C+Si and mixtures thereof; (c) between about 0.5 to 10% of grain growth inhibitors selected from the group consisting of TiB.sub.2, HfB.sub.2, SiC and mixtures thereof; (d) at least about 1 weight percent bentonite; and (e) at least about 3 ml per 30 g of the above listed components, of colloidal silica solution.
In accordance with another aspect of the present invention there is provided a method of manufacturing a composite article using the composition described above, comprising the steps of: (a) premixing the powders comprising the combustible source in the composition; (b) blending said premixture with the other components of the composition; (c) forming a pliable slurry from said blend; (d) fashioning said slurry into a final desired article shape; (e) combusting said shape by ignition at a temperature between about 100.degree. C. and 1600.degree. C.; (f) initially applying sufficient current to said article so as to raise the temperature of said article to a minimum of 50% of the melting point in degrees Kelvin, of the lowest melting phase in the article, wherein the current applied is selected from the group consisting of a DC current, an AC current, a pulsed current and an induction current; and (g) greatly reducing the porosity of said article so as to make the repetitive distance between consecutive homogenous sections of said article to less than 0.002 m, by increasing said current applied so as to cause the elimination of thermal and mass gradients.
In accordance with a further aspect of the present invention, there is provided a pliable composition comprising by weight percent: (a) between about 60 and 85% of a powdery mass of electrically conductive and/or semiconductive material selected from the group consisting of WSi.sub.2, MoSi.sub.2 and mixtures thereof; (b) about 15% of WO3+Al+Si as a combustible source; (c) about 2% of HfB.sub.2 as a grain growth inhibitor; (d) about 1 weight percent bentonite; (e) about 3 ml per 30 g of the above listed components, of colloidal silica solution; and (f) about 0.5 weight percent C.





DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT
Examples of specific compositions which have been found to provide heating elements having longer working life up to 1900.degree. C., are disclosed as follows:
______________________________________(all compositions herein are by weight percent of the totalcomposition, unless otherwise indicated)______________________________________Composition 1WSi.sub.2 10MoSi.sub.2 71.5WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si.sub.2 15HfB.sub.2 2C (present in the form of 0.5graphite in all compositions herein)Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica (type 830 3 ml/30 g powderNycol corporation) (this implies 3 ml per 30 g of the remaining components)Composition 2WSi.sub.2 20MoSi.sub.2 61.5WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si.sub.2 15HfB.sub.2 2C 0.5Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 3 ml/30 g powderComposition 3WSi.sub.2 30MoSi.sub.2 51.5WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si.sub.2 15HfB.sub.2 2C 0.5Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 3 ml/30 g powderComposition 4WSi.sub.2 40MoSi.sub.2 41.5WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si.sub.2 15HfB.sub.2 2C 0.5Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 3 ml/30 g powderComposition 5WSi.sub.2 50MoSi.sub.2 31.5WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si.sub.2 15HfB.sub.2 2C 0.5Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 3 ml/30 g powderComposition 6WSi.sub.2 20MoSi.sub.2 61.5WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si.sub.2 72WO.sub.3 + 3Zr + 4Si 8HfB.sub.2 2C 0.5Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 3 ml/30 g powderComposition 7WSi.sub.2 20MoSi.sub.2 57WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si.sub.2 5WC + 3Si 15TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 g powderComposition 8WSi.sub.2 20MoSi.sub.2 54WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si.sub.2 8WC + 3Si 15TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 g powderComposition 9WSi.sub.2 20MoSi.sub.2 52WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si.sub.2 10WC + 3Si 15TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 g powderComposition 10WSi.sub.2 20MoSi.sub.2 47WC + 3Si 15WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si.sub.2 15TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Water with organic binders 5 ml/30 g powder.(organic binders may be methyl cellulose, polyethyleneglycol with an average molecular weight. of 200, polyethyleneglycol with an average molecular weight of 300, glycerol,99.5%, polyvinyl butyral, dioctyl adipate and theircombinations)Composition 11WSi.sub.2 20MoSi.sub.2 57MO.sub.2 C + 5Si 15WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si.sub.2 5TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica (5 ml/30 g powder)Composition 12WSi.sub.2 20MoSi.sub.2 54MO.sub.2 C + 5Si 15MoO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si 8TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 g powderComposition 13WSi.sub.2 20MoSi.sub.2 57Mo.sub.2 C + 5Si 15WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si.sub.2 5HfB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 g powderComposition 14WSi.sub.2 20MoSi.sub.2 47WC + 3Si 25WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si.sub.2 5TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 g powderComposition 15WSi.sub.2 20MoSi.sub.2 47Mo.sub.2 C + 5Si 25WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si 5TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 g powderComposition 16WSi.sub.2 20MoSi.sub.2 47Mo.sub.2 C + 5Si 25WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si.sub.2 5TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 g powderComposition 17MoSi.sub.2 872WO.sub.3 + 3Zr + 4Si 10TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 gComposition 18MoSi.sub.2 822WO.sub.3 + 3Zr + 4Si 5WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si 10TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 gComposition 19MoSi.sub.2 772WO.sub.3 + 3Zr + 4Si 10WO.sub.3 + 2Al + 2Si 10TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 gComposition 20WSi.sub.2 20MoSi.sub.2 622WO.sub.3 + 3Zr + 4Si 5WC + 3Si 10TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 gComposition 21MoSi.sub.2 872WO.sub.3 + 3Zr + 4Si 10Si.sub.3 N.sub.4 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 gComposition 22MoSi.sub.2 822WO.sub.3 + 3Zr + 4Si 15SiC 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 gComposition 23MoSi.sub.2 772WO.sub.3 + 3Zr + 4Si 20TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 gComposition 24MoSi.sub.2 772WO.sub.3 + 3Zr + 4Si 102MO.sub.3 + 3Zr + 4Si 10TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 gComposition 25WSi.sub.2 10MoSi.sub.2 722MoO.sub.3 + 3Zr + 4Si 10WC + 3Si 5TiB.sub.2 2Bentonite 1Colloidal Silica 5 ml/30 g______________________________________
Broadly stated, the compositions of the present invention comprise between about 10 and 90% of a powdery mass of electrically conductive and/or semiconductive material selected from the group consisting of WSi.sub.2, MoSi.sub.2 and mixtures thereof; between about 5 % and 50% of a combustible source which is selected from the group consisting of WO.sub.3 +Al+Si, MoO.sub.3 +Zr+Si, WO.sub.3 +Zr+Si, WC+Si, Mo.sub.2 C+Si and mixtures thereof; between about 0.5 to 10% of grain growth inhibitors selected from the group consisting of TiB.sub.2, HfB.sub.2, SiC and mixtures thereof; at least about 1 weight percent bentonite; and at least about 3 ml/30 g of colloidal silica solution.
The combustion sources have to be premixed before mixing with other powders, in order to produce sufficient heat during combustion. The weight percentage of combustibles in the compositions of the present invention will not be less than 5 wt %, but will not be more than 90%. A combustible content of more than 50% will lead to too strong combustion, and therefore, to samples (heating elements) with large pores and deformed shapes. Compositions with combustibles less then 5% will not be able to produce enough heat to sinter the wire and therefore the wire may not be conductive enough to be finally sintered, densified and homogenized by passing current. The addition of WSi.sub.2 or MoSi.sub.2 increases the working temperature, life of heating elements at high temperature and creep resistance, but WSi.sub.2 or MoSi.sub.2 content of more than 90 weight percent will drastically decrease thermal shock resistance and oxidation resistance of heating element.
The preferred compositions of the present invention comprise from about 10 to 30 percent WSi.sub.2, up to 4% SiC, up to 3% TiB.sub.2, up to 3% HfB.sub.2 (said SiC, TiB.sub.2 and HfB.sub.2 being at least 0.5 percent), close to 2% bentonite and close to 15 ml/100 g of powder of colloidal silica. The most preferred composition for manufacturing high temperature heating elements is as follows: 15-30 percent of WSi.sub.2, 15-20 percent combustibles, 1-2 percent TiB.sub.2 and HfB.sub.2 and 0.5-1 percent C. Heating elements made from compositions 1, 2 and 3 above, lasted for over 1000 hours at temperatures from 1700.degree. to 1750.degree. C.
Yet another preferred and unique composition discloses the use of a combination of WC+Si or Mo.sub.2 C+Si with WO.sub.3 +Al+Si or WO.sub.3 +Zr+Si. The content of carbide combustion source (WC+Si or Mo.sub.2 C+Si) will be from 1 to 50%; oxide combustion source (WO.sub.3 +Al+Si or WO.sub.3 +Zr+Si) will be 5-30%. The total weight percent of the combustion source is at least 5%. In its more preferred aspects, the carbide combustion source ranges from 15 to 20%, oxide combustion source will be 5-10 wt %. By using carbide combustion sources, alumina content in the final products will be tremendously reduced. It was found that heating elements manufactured using a combination of carbide and oxide combustion sources (for instance, composition 9), show excellent temperature capacity and improved life up to 1850.degree. C.
Yet another preferred and unique composition discloses WO.sub.3 +Zr+Si and MOO.sub.3 +Zr+Si as combustion sources or combinations thereof. These compositions show strong and stable combustion when mixed with MoSi.sub.2 and WSi.sub.2 powders. The final products of these combustion sources are WSi.sub.2 (or MoSi.sub.2) and ZrO.sub.2. Part of ZrO.sub.2 will react further with SiO.sub.2 during sintering to form zircon which has high melting point and phase stability with MoSi.sub.2 and WSi.sub.2. The total weight percent of the combustion source in these compositions is at least 5%. In its more preferred aspects, the WO3+Zr+Si combustion source will be from 10 to 25 weight percent. It was found that the compositions using this combustion source show excellent sintering properties and high temperature capability up to 1850.degree. C.
Optimal (these are merely preferred particle sizes) particle sizes are disclosed for various the components listed above as follows:
______________________________________SiC 1 .mu.mWSi.sub.2 4 .mu.mZr 3.5-4 .mu.mMoSi.sub.2 4 .mu.mC 300 mesh (15 .mu.m)WO.sub.3 8 .mu.mMo.sub.2 C 325 mesh (44 .mu.m)Al 325 mesh (44 .mu.m)Si 325 mesh (44 .mu.m)HfB.sub.2 325 mesh (44 .mu.m)WC 1 .mu.mTiB.sub.2 1 .mu.mMoO.sub.3 8 .mu.mSi.sub.3 N.sub.4 325 mesh (44 .mu.m)Bentonite 5 .mu.mColloidal silica nanosize colloid______________________________________
Thus it is apparent that there have been provided, in accordance with the invention, compositions suited for preparing heating elements which may be operated at temperatures up to 1900.degree. C. or for very long durations at lower temperatures such as 1750.degree. C., which fully satisfy the objects, aspects and advantages set forth above. While the invention has been described in conjunction with specific embodiments thereof, it is evident that many alternatives, modifications, and variations will be apparent to those skilled in the art in light of the foregoing description. For example, it is contemplated that in addition to the combustion sources described and claimed herein, a particular composition may comprise other combustion sources. Accordingly, it is intended to embrace all such alternatives, modifications and variations which fall within the spirit and scope of the appended claims.
Claims
  • 1. A pliable composition comprising by weight percent:
  • (a) between about 10 and 90% of a powdery mass of material which is electrically conductive, semiconductive or electrically conductive and semiconductive, selected from the group consisting of WSi.sub.2, MoSi.sub.2 and mixtures thereof;
  • (b) between about 5 % and 50% of a combustible source which is selected from the group consisting of WO.sub.3, Al and Si, MoO.sub.3, Zr and Si, WO.sub.3, Zr and Si, WC, and Si, MoC.sub.2 and Si and mixtures thereof;
  • (c) between about 0.5 to 10% of grain growth inhibitors selected from the group consisting of TiB.sub.2, HfB.sub.2, SiC and mixtures thereof;
  • (d) at least about 1 weight percent bentonite; and
  • (e) at least about 3 ml per 30 g of (a) through (d), of colloidal silica solution.
  • 2. An electrical heating element capable of being used at temperatures up to 1900.degree. C. formed by micropyretic synthesis of the composition of claim 1.
  • 3. An integral article having improved mechanical stability, room temperature fracture toughness, and oxidation resistance at temperatures up to 1900.degree. C., and stable electrical conductivity, comprising an integral article formed by micropyretic synthesis of the composition of claim 1.
  • 4. A integral article formed by micropyretic synthesis of the composition of claim 1 for use as a gas ignitor.
  • 5. An electrical heating element capable of being used at temperatures up to 1900.degree. C. formed by micropyretic synthesis of the composition of claim 1, said heating element comprising WSi.sub.2, MoSi or a mixture thereof.
  • 6. The composition of claim 1 further comprising up to 20 weight percent bentonite.
  • 7. An electrical heating element suitable for use as a high temperature indicator comprising an integral article formed by micropyretic synthesis of the composition of claim 6.
  • 8. The composition of claim 1 comprising about 10 to 30 weight percent WSi.sub.2, from about 0.5 weight percent to 4 weight percent SiC, from about 0.5 weight percent to 3 weight percent TiB.sub.2, from about 0.5 weight percent to 3 weight percent HfB.sub.2, up to 2 weight percent bentonite and up to 15 ml per 30 g of (a) through (d), of colloidal silica.
  • 9. An electrical heating element capable of being used at temperatures up to 1900.degree. C. comprising an integral article formed by micropyretic synthesis of the composition of claim 8.
  • 10. The composition of claim 8 comprising 15-30 weight percent of W/Si.sub.2, 15-20 weight percent combustibles, 1-2 weight percent TiB.sub.2 and HfB.sub.2 and further comprising 0.5-1 weight percent C.
  • 11. An electrical heating element capable of being used at temperatures up to 1900.degree. C. comprising an integral article formed by micropyretic synthesis of the composition of claim 10.
  • 12. The composition of claim 1 further comprising up to 1 weight percent carbon; up to 2 weight percent bentonite; and up to 15 ml per 30 g of (a) through (d), of colloidal silica.
  • 13. An electrical heating element capable of being used at temperatures up to 1900.degree. C. comprising an integral article formed by micropyretic synthesis of the composition of claim 12.
  • 14. The composition of claim 12, wherein said combustible source is selected from the group consisting of MoO.sub.3, Zr and Si, WO.sub.3, Zr and Si and mixtures thereof.
  • 15. An electrical heating element capable of being used at temperatures up to 1900.degree. C. comprising an integral article formed by micropyretic synthesis of the composition of claim 14.
  • 16. The composition of claim 14 wherein said combustible source is between about 10 to 25 weight percent WO.sub.3, Zr and Si.
  • 17. An electrical heating element capable of being used at temperatures up to 1900.degree. C. comprising an integral article formed by micropyretic synthesis of the composition of claim 16.
  • 18. A method for the preparation of integral articles having improved mechanical stability, room temperature fracture toughness, and oxidation resistance at temperatures up to 1900.degree. C., and stable electrical conductivity, comprising the steps of:
  • (a) premixing the powders comprising the combustible source in the composition of claim 1;
  • (b) blending the powders with the other components of the composition of claim 1;
  • (c) forming a pliable slurry from the powders and the other components;
  • (d) fashioning said slurry into a final desired article shape;
  • (e) combusting said shape by ignition at a temperature between about 100.degree. C. and 1600.degree. C.;
  • (f) initially applying sufficient current to said article so as to raise the temperature of said article to a minimum of 50% of the melting point in degrees Kelvin, of the lowest melting phase in the article, wherein the current applied is selected from the group consisting of a DC current, an AC current, a pulsed current and an induction current; and
  • (g) greatly reducing the porosity of said article so as to make the repetitive distance between consecutive homogenous sections of said article to less than 0.002 m, by increasing said current applied so as to cause the elimination of thermal and mass gradients.
  • 19. An integral article having improved mechanical stability, room temperature fracture toughness, and oxidation resistance at temperatures up to 1900.degree. C., and stable electrical conductivity, produced in accordance with the process of claim 18.
  • 20. A pliable composition comprising by weight percent:
  • (a) between about 60 and 85 % of a powdery mass of material which is electrically conductive, semiconductive or electrically conductive and semiconductive, selected from the group consisting of WSi.sub.2, MoSi.sub.2 and mixtures thereof;
  • (b) about 15% of WO.sub.3, Al and Si as a combustible source;
  • (c) about 2 % of HfB.sub.2 as a grain growth inhibitor;
  • (d) about 1 weight percent bentonite;
  • (e) about ml per 30 g of (a) through (d), of colloidal silica solution; and
  • (f) about 0.5 weight percent C.
  • 21. An electrical heating element capable of being used at temperatures up to 1900.degree. C. comprising an integral article formed by micropyretic synthesis of the composition of claim 20.
Parent Case Info

This application is a continuation-in-part of application Ser. No. 8/242,362 filed May 13, 1994 now abandoned.

US Referenced Citations (75)
Number Name Date Kind
3090094 Schwartzwalder May 1963
3097930 Holland Jul 1963
3111396 Ball Nov 1963
3314876 Ransley Apr 1967
3330756 Ransley Jul 1967
3608599 Spear Sep 1971
3617358 Dittrich Nov 1971
3705791 Bredzs Dec 1972
3726643 Merzhanov et al. Apr 1973
3872419 Groves et al. Mar 1975
3969696 Wolfe et al. Jul 1976
4003014 Branson et al. Jan 1977
4193106 Coleman Mar 1980
4202691 Yurasko May 1980
4217948 Merzhanov et al. Aug 1980
4267435 Best May 1981
4459363 Holt Jul 1984
4610726 King Sep 1986
4655830 Akashi et al. Apr 1987
4710348 Brupbacher et al. Dec 1987
4738389 Moshier et al. Apr 1988
4747873 Kamloka May 1988
4751048 Christodoulou et al. Jun 1988
4772452 Brupbacher et al. Sep 1988
4774052 Nagle et al. Sep 1988
4800065 Christodoulou et al. Jan 1989
4808372 Koczak et al. Feb 1989
4836982 Brupbacher et al. Jan 1989
4877759 Holt et al. Oct 1989
4894273 Lieberman et al. Jan 1990
4902457 Wada et al. Feb 1990
4904424 Johnson Feb 1990
4909842 Dunmead et al. Mar 1990
4915903 Brupbacher et al. Apr 1990
4915905 Kampe et al. Apr 1990
4948761 Hida Aug 1990
4957885 Hida Sep 1990
4965044 Miyamoto et al. Oct 1990
4975412 Okazaki et al. Dec 1990
4985202 Moshier et al. Jan 1991
4988480 Meerzhanov et al. Jan 1991
4988645 Holt et al. Jan 1991
4990295 Hida Feb 1991
4999049 Balderson et al. Mar 1991
4999137 Wapler et al. Mar 1991
4999144 Miyamoto et al. Mar 1991
5006290 Hida Apr 1991
5011800 Abramovici et al. Apr 1991
5019454 Busse May 1991
5022991 Day et al. Jun 1991
5030600 Hida et al. Jul 1991
5032332 Hida et al. Jul 1991
5063121 Sato et al. Nov 1991
5071797 Hida Dec 1991
5086210 Nunogaki et al. Feb 1992
5110688 Sekhar et al. May 1992
5143668 Hida Sep 1992
5145619 Abramovici Sep 1992
5149677 Merzhanov et al. Sep 1992
5169572 Matthews Dec 1992
5188678 Sekhar et al. Feb 1993
5198188 Holt et al. Mar 1993
5213730 Hida May 1993
5217583 Sekhar et al. Jun 1993
5221647 Hida et al. Jun 1993
5279737 Sekhar et al. Jan 1994
5316718 Sekhar May 1994
5320717 Sekhar Jun 1994
5340014 Sekhar et al. Aug 1994
5340448 Sekhar et al. Aug 1994
5342491 Sekhar Aug 1994
5376421 Sekhar et al. Dec 1994
5382405 Lowrance, II et al. Jan 1995
5420399 Sekhar et al. May 1995
5425496 Zhu et al. Jun 1995
Foreign Referenced Citations (7)
Number Date Country
0164830 Dec 1985 EPX
0258510 Sep 1986 EPX
0404943 Sep 1991 EPX
1096063 Apr 1989 JPX
584052 Dec 1977 SUX
9003956 Apr 1990 WOX
9013513 Nov 1990 WOX
Continuation in Parts (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 242362 May 1994