The present disclosure relates to distributed temperature sensing, and more particularly relates to strain and hydrogen tolerant optical distributed temperature sensor system and method.
Optical distributed temperature sensors, commonly referred to as “DTS” systems, based on fiber optic sensing techniques are being used broadly in a number of applications and markets (for more information, see www.sensa.org). Oil and gas applications for optical DTS have been especially prolific, being adopted by most downstream operators to monitor producing zones and take actions to optimize production. Optical DTS serving these oil and gas applications is predominantly based on nonlinear type optical sensors, in which high intensity pulsed laser energy is launched into a sensing fiber to stimulate nonlinear effects that cause light scattering. Optical DTS systems have been made using optical Raman effects and other optical DTS systems have been made using optical Brillouin effects. It is known that both Raman effects and Brillouin effects cause both forward (Stokes) and backward (anti-Stokes) shifted signals in which their relative intensity and/or frequency is dependent on temperature. Raman effects and Brillouin effects are discussed in the paper, Daniele Inaudi and Branko Glisic, “Integration of distributed strain and temperature sensors in composite coiled tubing”, 2006 SPIE Smart Structures and Materials Conference, San Diego, Calif., Feb. 27 to Mar. 2, 2006, (Authors from SMARTEC SA, Via Pobiette 11, CH-6928 Manno, Switzerland, www.smartec.ch), which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety. Using Optical Time Delay Reflectometry (OTDR), temperature at distinct positions all along the fiber can be derived, so that the entire fiber is probed as a fully distributed temperature sensor.
Use of Raman type far exceeds that of the Brillouin type in current DTS systems primarily because of the advantage of Raman effect being insensitive to strain compared to the Brillouin effect (acoustic) that is sensitive to both temperature and strain. Use of the latter for DTS therefore requires complete isolation of fiber strain or extraction of its strain error in the temperature measurement. Conversely, Brillouin systems are frequently used to monitor strain in known or controlled thermal environments.
The main drawback to Raman systems in oil and gas applications is its sensitivity to hydrogen. Raman shifted lines are widely separated in wavelength (e.g. over 200 nm for a 1550 nm operating system), so received intensity of these lines, and subsequent temperature measurement, can be significantly offset by changes in background fiber attenuation because of hydrogen—which is pervasive in typical oil and gas well environments. Hydrogen diffusion into optical fibers results into both transient and permanent attenuation i.e., signal loss. Transient losses are reversible, caused by absorption owing to dissolved hydrogen in the glass. Upon removal of the fiber from the hydrogen environment, and subsequent out-diffusion of the hydrogen, the fiber returns to its original clarity. In contrast, permanent losses are irreversible, caused by chemical reactions of hydrogen with glass molecular defects that form light absorbing species (e.g. hydroxyl ion).
Upon hydrogen diffusion into the fiber, the magnitude of transient hydrogen loss is a function of hydrogen solubility, determined by the temperature and concentration of hydrogen the fiber is exposed to, with subsequent loss growth at several hydrogen absorption lines within the near-infrared telecom wavelength range of interest. Transient losses are essentially the same for silica fibers regardless of type-single mode or multimode, as solubility of hydrogen in the fiber is independent of these design features. In contrast, the chemical reactions that drive permanent losses are more complex: a function of defect type, their population, and the activation energy specific to each reaction. The range of potential defect types is dependent upon the glass composition, and their concentration created in subtleties of the fiber manufacturing process. As a consequence, contrary to transient loss, permanent losses manifest differently for different fibers, resulting in a more complex attenuation spectrum as each reaction product has its own absorption spectra. The sensitivity of fiber to permanent hydrogen loss is directly dependent upon the amount of common refractive-index modifying dopants used in conventional telecom-grade fibers such as germanium, boron, and phosphorus the latter two having been found to especially sensitize the fiber to hydrogen. Table 1 below lists the three common fiber types used in oil and gas sensing, and their relative hydrogen sensitivity.
Intuitively, as can be seen in Table 1, pure silica core fiber that has no dopants in the core, exhibits superior hydrogen performance. Such pure silica single mode fibers were originally developed and have long been used in undersea telecommunication cables specifically for their insensitivity to permanent hydrogen losses. Pure silica core fibers are used in some downhole oil and gas cables to exploit this performance. Despite this advantage, most commercial Raman DTS systems are designed to operate on over multimode fibers because their larger core size creates more Raman scattering signal and allows for greater efficiency in capturing this light. However operating on these fibers makes these systems especially prone to hydrogen-induced measurement error associated with changes in background fiber attenuation.
Brillouin systems, on the other hand, are inherently less sensitive to such hydrogen errors. Brillouin systems operate exclusively on single mode optical fibers that are less sensitive to hydrogen-induced attenuation, and the separation between Brillouin lines is comparatively much smaller than with Raman lines—only fractions of nanometers—so that changes in background fiber attenuation tends to apply almost equally on the two lines. More importantly, however, relative to hydrogen effects, Brillouin systems measure frequency changes in these lines rather than intensity—the frequency shift independent and therefore not affected by changes in background fiber attenuation.
The below Table 2 illustrates some of the differences between Raman and Brillouin sensing systems.
Despite the superior hydrogen performance of Brillouin systems, faced with the tradeoff of strain and hydrogen sensitivity between the two nonlinear DTS technologies, Raman has emerged as the predominant technology in oil and gas because of its independence from strain effects. The Brillouin type is used much less due to the difficulty in isolating strain acting on downhole optical fiber cables. The sensitivity to hydrogen with Raman systems has been addressed by employing hydrogen barriers (cables and fiber coatings) to protect sensing fibers from hydrogen. While these hydrogen strategies have worked well, their effectiveness dissipates at higher temperatures, 200° C. or so, where they lose hermeticity (i.e., the hermetic seal with the outside), and become porous to hydrogen diffusion into the glass optical fiber.
While some oil and gas wells can be addressed at this temperature, there are emerging thermal recovery operations, especially in the unconventional heavy oil sector, that use steam flood operations in the production process. In many of these steam operations, for example Steam-Assisted Gravity Drainage (SAGD), there is great benefit in monitoring the steam front and/or thermal chamber growth to optimize steam injection and reservoir fluid inflow and recovery. A fully distributed optical DTS architecture along the injection and producing interval in SAGD, for example, is an ideal monitoring solution. However at the high operating temperature of these thermal recovery operations, in excess of about 250° C., hermetic barriers are ineffective, leading to significant hydrogen-induced degradation of quality of data in time, and shortened mean time to failure (MTTF). Commercial Raman DTS systems used successfully in the conventional market have exhibited poor performance in these thermal recovery applications with significant hydrogen-induced measurement offset (10 s of degrees Celsius) to render the data meaningless and total system failure because of hydrogen darkening of the fiber within a few weeks.
Because of the poor history of performance in high temperature thermal recovery operations, most operators will only use optical DTS during initial steam startup, or as a retrievable well survey tool. There are no effective hermetic solutions to the higher temperature operating regime above about 200° C. There remains no suitable optical DTS solution that delivers reliable data for reasonable period of time at the higher operating temperature of thermal recovery applications in oil and gas. Operators continue to use conventional thermocouples to monitor key points, with the size, complexity, and cost of these thermocouples limiting their use to only several points at most per well, which does not provide the desired number of sensing points and spatial resolution to give a meaningful representation of the well.
The following references contain subject matter related to as background to that discussed herein and the disclosure of each is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety:
There is a need in these high temperature thermal recovery applications for DTS technology capable of operating and delivering high quality data under the aggressive hydrogen environment.
In one aspect of the present invention, a distributed temperature sensing system includes an optical sensing waveguide. The optical sensing waveguide is a single mode waveguide having a substantially pure silica core and a large outer diameter. The system further includes an optical instrument optically connected to the optical sensing waveguide. The optical instrument is configured for providing an optical excitation signal along the optical sensing waveguide, and is also configured for receiving a return optical signal indicative of the temperature at one or more locations along the optical sensing waveguide.
In another aspect of the present invention, a method of measuring distributed temperature includes providing an optical sensing waveguide. The optical sensing waveguide is a single mode waveguide having a substantially pure silica core and a large outer diameter. An optical excitation signal is generated along the optical sensing waveguide. A return optical signal is received and is indicative of a temperature at one or more locations along the optical sensing waveguide. The above-mentioned temperature is calculated based on a Brillouin effect.
The subject of this invention is to realize a high temperature DTS system capable of operating in an aggressive hydrogen environment by leveraging the hydrogen tolerance of Brillouin systems and addressing the strain sensitivity of Brillouin sensing fibers through novel fiber and cable designs that eliminate strain introduced deployment and operation of these sensors in a broad range of applications covering harsh environments including, but not limited to, oil and gas wells. In addition these fibers may include pure silica core waveguide designs to augment hydrogen performance of the Brillouin system.
Referring to
The optical instrument 16 is configured to provide the appropriate excitation (or incident) light and performs Brillouin Optical Time Domain Analysis (BOTDA) on the returning (or reflected) optical signal along the optical sensing fiber or waveguide 12. The optical instrument 16 may be any known optical instrument capable of performing BOTDA, e.g., a Fiber Optic Brillouin Analyzer, DiTeST, Model No. STA 200 Series, made by OmniSense, Riond Bosson 31110 Morges, Switzerland, www.omnisens.ch. In particular, the optical instrument 16 is optically connected to the sensing fiber 12 and injects pulses of incident light into the sensing fiber and analyzes the back reflected signal for temperature and strain induced frequency shifts. By measuring these shifts, the optical instrument 16 determines the state of strain and temperature along the length of the fiber 12, as is discussed in the paper, Daniele Inaudi and Branko Glisic, “Integration of distributed strain and temperature sensors in composite coiled tubing”, 2006 SPIE Smart Structures and Materials Conference, San Diego, Calif., Feb. 27 to Mar. 2, 2006, (Authors from SMARTEC SA, Via Pobiette 11, CH-6928 Manno, Switzerland, www.smartec.ch), which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
In some embodiments, the core of the sensing fiber 12 may be made of a substantially pure (or undoped) silica core. A pure silica core fiber provides substantial insensitivity to hydrogen ingress. In particular, the absorption of light in the core of the fiber owing to hydrogen ingress is greatly increased with the presence of dopants such as GeO2 and P2O5 in standard optical fibers. However, pure silica core fiber is designed and fabricated in a way to almost completely eliminate reaction sites for the hydrogen and thus eliminate the substantial permanent losses as shown in the graph of
Referring to
Referring again to
With reference to
With reference to
With reference to
While the previous embodiments employing a low friction optical sensing fiber coating are effective in isolating strain acting on the optical sensing fiber by retarding the dragging forces as a result of thermal expansion of the outer stainless steel tube, the system 600 shown in
In this structure, the fiber and protective tubing expand in unison, with the outer tube deflecting any external forces acting on the outer tube to mechanically isolate the fiber. If the outer Teflon tube is unable to overcome any dragging forces or unable to expand freely within its environment, the low friction polymer coated fiber will be free to move or “float” within the composite tube. This construction is especially useful and effective when used in a so-called coiled-tubing—a preferred method of installing and operating instrumentation in SAGD wells. A coiled tubing is a continuous length of ductile steel or composite tubing stored and transported in a coil on a large reel used to perform well intervention services such as well cleaning and pumping, fracturing, and completion workovers. It is uncoiled and pushed into the well using a coiled tubing injection rig. Tubing sizes range from 1 inch to 4½ inches; the larger the diameter, the farther it can be used. Typical SAGD coiled tubing instrumentation sizes are between 1″ and 2″. Instrumentation such as thermocouple cables and fiber optics are integrated within the coiled tubing and then the coiled tubing is injected into the well. Upon heating, the steel coiled tubing will expand and measures are taken by the installer to avoid compression or buckling of the expanded coiled tubing assembly. The construction shown in
Although the present invention has been described herein using exemplary techniques, algorithms, and/or processes for implementing the present invention, it should be understood by those skilled in the art that other techniques, algorithms and processes or other combinations and sequences of the techniques, algorithms and processes described herein may be used or performed that achieve the same function(s) and/or result(s) described herein and which are included within the scope of the present invention.
It should be understood that, unless otherwise explicitly or implicitly indicated herein, any of the features, characteristics, alternatives or modifications described regarding a particular embodiment herein may also be applied, used, or incorporated with any other embodiment described herein. Also, the drawings herein are not drawn to scale.
Conditional language, such as, among others, “can,” “could,” “might,” or “may,” unless specifically stated otherwise, or otherwise understood within the context as used, is generally intended to convey that certain embodiments could include, but do not require, certain features, elements and/or steps. Thus, such conditional language is not generally intended to imply that features, elements and/or steps are in any way required for one or more embodiments or that one or more embodiments necessarily include logic for deciding, with or without user input or prompting, whether these features, elements and/or steps are included or are to be performed in any particular embodiment.
Although the invention has been described and illustrated with respect to exemplary embodiments thereof, the foregoing and various other additions and omissions may be made therein and thereto without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 60/911,015, filed on Apr. 10, 2007 and entitled “Strain And Hydrogen Tolerant Optical Distributed Temperature Sensor”, the disclosure of which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
60911015 | Apr 2007 | US |