Power modules are used for power conversion, and due to a wide range of power applications, one might be required to utilize parallel semiconductor structures or components in power modules, in order to achieve a specific power rating. A main objective of paralleling semiconductor devices or dies is to achieve higher current rating, as well as reducing the overall system on-resistance. To realize highly reliable power modules, the current distribution of each power electronic switch or transistor device in the power module and the total current of the power modules should be measured accurately in order to prevent current crowding, which can break the power semiconductor chip and/or shorten a power module's lifetime by partial heating. Moreover, an imbalanced distribution of circuit parasitic between paralleled devices can result in uneven power sharing leading to a degraded electrical and temperature performance by each of the paralleled devices. Therefore, it is essential to continuously monitor current sharing within paralleled devices of power modules in order to provide system prognostic and protection.
Many aspects of the present disclosure can be better understood with reference to the following drawings. The components in the drawings are not necessarily to scale, emphasis instead being placed upon clearly illustrating the principles of the present disclosure. Moreover, in the drawings, like reference numerals designate corresponding parts throughout the several views.
Increasing the efficiency and the reliability of power converters or modules is an important goal in power electronics. Apparatuses and methods of the present disclosure integrate a non-intrusive current sensor in the form of a current mismatch sensor into a power module having paralleled semiconductor structures or components. In various embodiments, to reduce the number of components and the circuit size, the current mismatch sensor is configured to measure or detect a current mismatch between the paralleled components in order to assess power module reliability. In one embodiment, the current mismatch can be detected by monitoring or measuring the magnetic flux density in between the paralleled components or devices. In various embodiments, such a shared current sensing power module circuit comprises Gallium Nitride (GaN) transistors or MOSFETs. In alternative embodiments, the shared current sensing power module circuit may comprise other semiconductor-based transistors, including Silicon transistors or MOSFETs.
GaN transistors as wide bandgap devices (WBG) have superior performance for their high breakdown electric field, low on-state resistance, fast switching speed and high working temperature, which results in power density improvement of GaN power modules or converters over Silicon power modules. To lower the conduction losses from GaN devices, the parallel configuration of GaN devices is commonly used. By assuring the symmetrical current sharing in parallel devices, the efficiency and reliability requirements for GaN paralleled devices are optimized. Thus, integration of a current mismatch sensor with paralleled components of a power module is a further step towards increasing the efficiency and reliability requirements for a power module in accordance with embodiments of the present disclosure. Moreover, improvements in safe power module/converter operation and rate of degradation of the semiconductor materials within the power module are realized due to better circuit protection and reliability assurance.
Referring now to
The shared current sensing power module 100 is manufactured on, but not limited to, a ceramic substrate material in various embodiments. Advantages of ceramic substrate include good thermal and electrical characteristics and a cost-effective production, while the trade-off is that the board cannot be routed using four layers and vias. Accordingly, in various embodiments, the shared current sensing power module circuit 100 contains power electronics (power transistors and sensor(s)), while additional circuitry such as gate drivers, power supplies, signal processing units, control circuits, etc. are contained in secondary circuit boards.
As discussed, current information is typically required in power converters and inverters for reliability assurance, circuit protection, and control purposes. The simplest way to measure a current is an intrusive one, where the current flows through a resistor and the voltage is measured. This technique unfortunately comes with power loss and the introduction of undesired inductance, among other drawbacks. Since power efficiency in power converters is crucial, non-intrusive current measurement is preferred with power modules.
Embodiments of a shared current sensing power module in accordance with the present disclosure contain an array of power devices or components, such as transistors or switches (also referred as semiconductor dies) in a parallel configuration that share the total electric current. While electric current measurement is often done with magnetic sensors due to the varying current resulting in a magnetic field, magnetic sensors, such as a Hall-Effect sensors, are too bulky, expensive, and slow for high power modules. Thus, in accordance with the present disclosure, a current mismatch sensor is selected to be integrated with the power module that is significantly smaller than conventional magnetic current sensors. Embodiments of a current mismatch sensor in accordance with the present disclosure measures or detects a current mismatch among paralleled devices, such as switches (dies), rather than the total current passing through each power device.
In various embodiments, an exemplary current mismatch sensor detects a current mismatch in paralleled devices by monitoring or measuring the magnetic flux density between the paralleled components or devices. Accordingly, the current mismatch sensor can be magnetic field sensors, such as Magneto-Resistive (MR) sensors, Hall-Effect sensors, inductive sensors, embedded sensors in a power module, and other magnetic sensor technologies. Possible MR sensors include Anisotropic Magneto-Resistive (AMR) sensor, a Giant Magneto-Resistive (GMR) sensor, and a Tunneling Magneto-Resistive (TMR) sensor, among others. Accordingly, embodiments of a current mismatch sensor can include any available current mismatch sensor that can measure a current mismatch among power semiconductor dies within a respective power module. For example, the bandwidth of Hall-Effect sensors is limited to around 100-200 kHz which is not sufficient for wideband GaN transistors (since they can switch in the MHz range) but can be sufficient for Si and SiC transistors in various embodiments. Conversely, wideband MR current mismatch sensors are sufficient for GaN transistors in various embodiments.
Developing a power module having paralleled components with an integrated current mismatch sensor involves board level design considerations to minimize the loop inductances, while providing an accurate interface for the current signal detection process. Since imbalanced current distribution of the power module system could be caused by unequal distribution of system parasitic coupled to paralleled devices (e.g., transistors), it is vital to provide symmetric board layout with respect to switching devices, in order to equalize the current sharing of these paralleled devices. Unequal current sharing can result in inaccurate measurement of the switch currents.
Therefore, an exemplary shared current sensing power module circuit is designed with symmetric layout consideration. Instead of requiring a full rated current sensing element per switching device, embodiments of the present disclosure utilize current mismatch measurement topology in order to reduce the number of sensing elements, as well as each sensor required rating per application. Accordingly, in one embodiment, a novel GaN current sharing monitoring technique utilizes a commercially available z-axis Anisotropic Magneto-Resistive (AMR) sensor integrated between parallel GaN semiconductor devices.
As a platform for testing operations of an embodiment of a pre-existing current monitoring power module (which will be used as a point of comparison with exemplary embodiments of the present disclosure), a synchronous buck converter, with two parallel GaN transistors or switches, is fabricated for testing purposes. For the power board, “GaN Systems GS66516B” transistors are used in the subsequent trials, which are 650V enhancement mode devices with a maximum current rating of 60 A, a drain-source on resistance (RDS(on) of 25 mΩ, and a capability of operating well above 10 MHz switching frequency. During testing, the initial board is manufactured on a 4-layer Printed Circuit Board (PCB) with the power devices 210 (e.g., GaN HEMT transistors) and driver circuits placed on the bottom side of a power board 202 and four current measurement sensor units 220 placed on a top side of a sensor board 204, as shown in
The sensor board 204 is positioned at a top of the figure, while the power board 202 is positioned at a bottom portion of the figure. The GaN switches/transistors 220, AC capacitors, and the connectors are located on a bottom side of the power board that is visible in the figure. On the top side of the power board 202, which is not visible in the figure, gate driver, power supplies, etc. are located. Accordingly, to measure the switch current of the four GaN transistors 210a-d, the sensor board 202 features four commercially available anisotropic magnetoresistors (AMR) sensors 220a-d that are placed in a way that the positions of the sensors 220a-d are exactly above the switches 210a-d to measure the current as accurate as possible.
In this pre-existing layout of a high frequency GaN module/converter, the current path is simulated using the software COMSOL Multiphysics, which works by applying the “Finite Element Methods” (FEM). A FEM simulation of the designed circuit and layout was carried out to understand the distribution of the currents and the properties of the generated magnetic fields. These simulations were executable at high frequencies over 500 kHz and showed an unequal current distribution despite the symmetrical placement of the transistors for this pre-existing design layout.
At the outset of testing, a 2D rectangle made from copper surrounded by air, with a current applied was simulated.
Next, the 2D case was extended to two parallel traces that conduct current. This case was analyzed by comparing simulation results with hands-on calculations from the interference of the two magnetic fields from both traces. It was found that the interference phenomenon is very well simulated with COMSOL as long as we do not observe high frequency behavior and as long as we are only interested in the magnetic flux density some distance away from the traces.
The next step was to change the geometry from 2D to 3D and to depict two parallel current carrying conductors. Accordingly,
In between, by the next peak, there is a positive magnetic flux density that comes from the fact that the current through the traces to and from the two parallel traces also result in a magnetic field and these two magnetic fields interfere in a constructive way. The peaks in between x=0.12 m and x=0.16 m are the ones that belong to the two parallel traces. It is obvious that the skin effect occurs and that the biggest amount of current flows along the inner edge of the inner trace despite the symmetrical design of the geometry.
An important finding, when the two parallel traces are observed, are the three minimal turning points in this area that are almost zero despite the unequal distribution of the current. The left and the right of these minimal turning points show the magnetic flux distribution in the middle of the current carrying traces, which is not surprising. However, the one in the middle is important as it shows the magnetic flux distribution between the two current carrying traces. Thus, this simulation shows that if the currents are not totally equal distributed between two parallel traces, the magnetic field density in the middle is only almost zero. Thus, measurements of the magnetic flux density can be used to determine whether the currents in both arms are equal or not, assuming that the sensitivity of a chosen sensor is high enough. Moreover, as this diagram shows, the magnetic flux density becomes zero for all frequencies in between the two parallel traces and thus the bandwidth does not play a crucial role for current mismatch cases as compared to pure current measurement cases.
Referring now to
As was observed through FEA simulations, the magnetic flux density in between the two traces (x=14 mm) is almost zero for all frequencies, hence the current flowing through the traces is almost equally distributed. Thus, this location between parallel traces is suitable for measuring the current mismatch using a point field detector sensing element, since the variations of the magnetic flux density are minimal in the vicinity of this location and will minimize the impact of imperfect positioning of the sensor between the two paralleled GaN devices.
Using the pre-existing circuit boards of
The labeled lines #3 and #4 show the sensors' output voltage in the no load case. For the current measured using the right sensors (220a, 220d) (
When it comes to the discussion of the left sensors' measurements (
Therefore, it is apparent that the left-hand sensors (220b, 220c) measure a considerable higher current, which confirms the assumption that the current is unequally distributed due to unsymmetrical power input and output connections in the preexisting design (
Based on the analysis of the problems evident with the pre-existing arrangement of power components, one embodiment of the present disclosure places power components, such as switches 110, 120, the power input and output connections (+Vin/Drain, GND/Source, etc.), and a current sensor 130 symmetrically on the same side (e.g., top side) of a circuit board. On the opposite side (e.g., bottom side), additional circuitry can be added as needed for a particular application.
In an alternative embodiment, the additionally circuitry may be contained on a separate circuit board. For example,
Further, in various embodiments, to equalize the current distribution and to reduce the influence of the high frequency AC capacitors' magnetic field on the magnetic field sensed with current mismatch sensor (e.g., AMR sensor), I/O connectors and/or capacitors are arranged in a symmetric location relative to the power components (e.g., GaN switches).
Using an exemplary sharing current sensing power module, as shown in
Accordingly,
Referring now to
Next,
Correspondingly,
Next,
Correspondingly,
A possible reason for the difference of 6.5mT (=53.9 mV-47.4 mV) is a small inequality in the current sharing between the two parallel traces in the case where both transistors are switching, leading to a minor variation of the reference value. Another possible reason can be that the load currents in cases for
Based on major existing power electronics applications, current sensing is required in power modules for reliability assurance, circuit protection and control purposes. In accordance with the present disclosure, single chip contactless current mismatch sensors are integrated with paralleled semiconductor devices on a power module. In one embodiment, a novel current mismatch sensor (e.g., AMR sensor) is positioned or mounted between paralleled power switches or transistors (e.g., GaN transistors) and is configured to measure a current mismatch between the parallel power switches. Such shared current sensing power components are faster, smaller, and integrable with high power applications. Further, current sensing power control components in accordance with the present disclosure can provide various functions such as enhanced prognostics, protection, and control. For example, resultant data, provided from the current mismatch sensor 130 can be used for prognostic using artificial intelligence (Al) enabled hardware and/or protection of power electronics.
In various embodiments, an exemplary shared current sensing power module can be applied to multiple parallel devices. In general, since there are equi-magnetic-field points if an electric current is shared equally inside any power device module with parallel devices, any current mismatch can results in a change in the equi-magnetic-field points. Thus, positioning or inserting magnetic sensors (e.g., point field detectors/sensors) at these points allows for measuring the field changes and current mismatch consequently. Magnetic sensors can be discrete ones such as magnetoresistors or Hall-effect sensors and embedded sensors in a power module such as embedded coils and antenna in the substrate or the housing of the power module. Once the current mismatch is detected or measured, this information can be used for prognostics and predictive maintenance of the power module and/or the system where the module is used. The current mismatch measurements can be also used as a feedback to balance the current among parallel devices within the module, in accordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.
Various embodiments of power modules are described in the present disclosure. In one such embodiment in accordance with the present disclosure, a power module 100 comprises two or more power switching devices 110, 120 connected in a parallel configuration, in which the two or more power switching devices 110, 120 are collocated on a substrate 140. A magnetic current sensor 130 is mounted on the substrate 140 between the two or more power switching devices 110, 120, in which the magnetic current sensor 130 is configured to detect a current mismatch between the two or more or multiple power switching devices 110, 120 by monitoring a magnetic flux density between the multiple power switching devices. In various embodiments, capacitors and/or input and output connectors may also be positioned or disposed in a symmetric configuration around the multiple power switching devices 110, 120. In one embodiment, the magnetic current sensor detects the current mismatch by determining that a magnitude of a magnetic field at a first one 110 of the multiple power switching devices is not equivalent to a magnitude of a magnetic field at a second one 120 of the multiple power switching devices and/or determining that a direction of the magnetic field at the first one 110 of the multiple power switching devices is not opposite a direction of the magnetic field at the second one 120 of the multiple(s) power switching devices. In various embodiments, the magnetic current sensor 130 is configured to measure a z-component of a magnetic flux density attributed to the multiple power switching devices in the parallel configuration.
Various embodiments of methods of operation for the power module 100 are also described in the present disclosure. In one such embodiment in accordance with the present disclosure, the method includes positioning or disposing a magnetic current sensor 130 between two or more power switching devices 110, 120 that are in a parallel configuration on a substrate 140; and operating the magnetic current sensor 130 to detect a current mismatch between the two or more or multiple power switching devices 110, 120 by monitoring a magnetic flux density between the multiple power switching devices. In various embodiments, the method further includes positioning or disposing capacitors and/or input and output connectors in a symmetric configuration around the multiple power switching devices 110, 120. In one embodiment, the method includes detecting the current mismatch by determining that a magnitude of a magnetic field at a first one 110 of the multiple power switching devices is not equivalent to a magnitude of a magnetic field at a second one 120 of the power switching devices and/or determining that a direction of the magnetic field at the first one 110 of the multiple power switching devices is not opposite a direction of the magnetic field at the second one 120 of the multiple power switching devices. In various embodiments, magnetic current sensor 130 detects the current mismatch by measuring a z-component of a magnetic flux density attributed to the multiple power switching devices 110, 120 in the parallel configuration.
The foregoing discussions describes some, but not all embodiments of the present disclosure. Indeed, an exemplary shared current sensing power module and related components, systems, apparatuses, and methods may be embodied in many different forms and should not be construed as limited to the embodiments set forth herein; rather, these embodiments are provided so that this disclosure will satisfy applicable legal requirements.
In describing the present disclosure, it will be understood that a number of techniques and steps are disclosed. Each of these has individual benefit and each can also be used in conjunction with one or more, or in some cases all, of the other disclosed techniques. Accordingly, for the sake of clarity, this description will refrain from repeating every possible combination of the individual steps in an unnecessary fashion. Nevertheless, the specification and claims should be read with the understanding that such combinations are entirely within the scope of the present disclosure.
It should be emphasized that the above-described embodiments of the present disclosure are merely possible examples of implementations, merely set forth for a clear understanding of the principles of the disclosure. Many variations and modifications may be made to the above-described embodiment(s) without departing substantially from the principles of the disclosure. All such modifications and variations are intended to be included herein within the scope of this disclosure and protected by the following claims.
This application claims priority to co-pending U.S. provisional application entitled, “Methods to Detect and Measure the Current Mismatch among Parallel Semiconductor Devices,” having Ser. No. 62/874,624, filed Jul. 16, 2019, which is entirely incorporated herein by reference, and co-pending U.S. provisional application entitled, “Methods to Detect and Measure the Current Mismatch among Parallel Semiconductor Devices,” having Ser. No. 62/744,358, filed Oct. 11, 2018, which is entirely incorporated herein by reference.
This invention was made with government support under contract no. 1610250 awarded by the National Science Foundation (NSF). The government has certain rights in the invention.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62874624 | Jul 2019 | US | |
62744358 | Oct 2018 | US |