Patent Grant
8653423
The present invention relates to a thick film high temperature thermoplastic insulated resistive heating element suitable for substrates having a low melting point and/or high coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) and a method for producing same using composite coating synthesis methods.
Thick film heating elements have been long sought after because of their ability to provide versatile designs, high power densities, uniform heat and rapid heating and cooling. These types of element designs are very efficient for direct heating either by placing the thick film element in contact with the component being heated or when they are required to radiate directed heat to the surroundings.
A voltage is applied to the resistive thick film either via conductive tracks or directly to the resistive thick film. This is a desirable element design, as it is low-profile and lightweight, provides rapid heat up and cool down times, provides very uniform heat, and delivers power at low temperatures resulting in safer operation of the heating element.
Metal substrates such as aluminum and aluminum alloys and austenitic grades of stainless steel, such as 300 series stainless (300SS), are desirable for this application because of their excellent thermal performance characteristics. Aluminum and aluminum alloys are particularly desirable for this application because they have a thermal transfer 10 to 20 times that of stainless steel making thick film heaters on these substrates thermally fast acting and have a low density making for a very light, efficient heating element.
Prior art shows an insulating layer (glass enamel) applied to the substrate to electrically insulate the resistive thick film from the substrate. Glass based products produced by companies such as DuPont, Ferro and (Electro-Science Laboratories, Inc. (ESL) use a combination of melt flowable glass binder and insulative filler components. Various combinations of metal oxides in the thick film glass frit lower the melting temperature of the glass so that it flows and produces a continuous glass matrix containing the filler material at suitable firing temperatures.
Typical thick film glass frits are designed to fire at temperatures in excess of 800° C. and are typically used on substrates made of ferritic stainless steels, such as 400 series stainless (400SS). However, it is difficult to produce viable electrically insulating layers on lower temperature metal substrates such as aluminum and aluminum alloys, which have a low melting temperature (less than 660° C.) or other substrates which have a relatively high coefficient of thermal expansion (22-26 ppm/K). Enamel-based insulating layers commonly used for ferritic stainless steel substrates cannot be used for aluminum or aluminum alloy substrates or austenitic stainless steels substrates, as mismatched thermal expansion coefficients result in cracking of the electrically insulating layer during initial processing or under thermal cycling of the heater. Furthermore, these enamel coatings need to be applied at temperatures typically greater than 600° C., which is too close to the melting temperature of the aluminum or aluminum alloy substrates to produce a stable electrically insulating layer.
Melting temperatures below 600° C. can be achieved but have several limitations. Many of these insulators have lead or Cd in the thick film frits. However, the thick film formulations used to produce this element must be lead free in order to comply with the RoHS Directive adopted by Europe in 2006. In addition, these insulators do not have the required dielectric strength to meet regulatory safety standards.
Low to no melt flow polymer formulations such as polyimide may be used to form an electrically insulating layer on low temperature substrate materials. However, these polymer formulations have either (1) a low temperature limitation, (2) are not able to transfer the wide range of power densities required for consumer and industrial heating element applications into heating the substrate, (3) do not provide the required electrical insulation performance, (4) cannot withstand the resistive thick film processing conditions, or (5) compromise the integrity of the deposited resistive thick film.
The above problems with traditional insulating materials necessitate a unique materials solution for substrates having a low melting point or high coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE).
It is the object of the present invention to provide an integrated thick film heating element on a substrate that may be processed below 600° C. so that it can be used with aluminum, aluminum alloys, low temperature and/or high CTE substrate materials, has suitable electrical insulation properties under temperature cycling of about 250° C. (or higher) and is capable of operating over a wide range of power densities for consumer and industrial heating element applications.
To that end high temperature melt-flowable thermoplastic polymers mixed with a particulate filler, along with an electrically resistive lead free thick film and an electrically conductive electrode track formulations are disclosed herein that may be deposited and fired to form an integrated thick film heating element which may be processed at temperatures below 600° C. This thick film heating element is capable of operating over a wide range of power densities for consumer and industrial heating element applications, with suitable electrical insulation properties under temperature cycling of about 250° C. thus making it very useful for integration into a wide range of commercially useful products.
Particularly, the present invention provides a thick film heating element comprising a substrate, an electrically insulated dielectric layer comprising a high temperature melt flowable thermoplastic polymer/filler material composite-, an electrically resistive lead free thick film that can be produced by composite sol gel technology, optionally a conductive thick film which is used to make electrical connection to the resistive element, and optionally a topcoat which is used to provide further electrical insulation and/or protection against moisture and oxidation. This heating element provides efficient and rapid heat up and cool down, can be designed to provide even temperature distribution, and delivers power at lower operating temperatures resulting in increased element safety.
The thick film heating element is cost effective and able to provide a competitive solution in a wide range of applications. These include but are not limited to space heaters, room heaters, device heaters, refrigerator defrosters, heated signage, food and beverage warmers and oil warmers to mention just a few.
In view of the fact that a great many commercial applications use aluminum or aluminum alloys, composite sol gel conductive and resistive formulations employed in certain embodiments of this invention have been selected so that they can be processed at temperatures below 600° C. on the substrates. In addition, these materials do not require the addition of lead or any other hazardous material to process the heating element, in keeping with the RoHS Directive adopted by Europe in 2006.
A dielectric coating comprising an electrically insulating high temperature thermoplastic polymer/filler material composite layer is deposited on the substrate and processed below 600° C. to form the dielectric layer coated substrate. The thermoplastic polymer powder is filled with a particulate lead-free material that does not exhibit significant melt flow up to the processing temperature of the polymer (which should not exceed about 600° C. when aluminum based substrates are used). The filler incorporated into the thermoplastic layer provides improved thermal expansion coefficient matching between the high temperature thermoplastic layer and the additionally deposited electrically resistive lead free thick film and the electrically conductive electrode track(s).
The filler material integrated into the thermoplastic layer increases the thermal conductivity of the resulting thermoplastic/filler composite layer to produce better heat transfer to the substrate and prevents generation of “hot spots”, and provides a bonding layer so that the electrically resistive lead free thick film and the electrically conductive electrode track reliably and consistently do not sink into the insulating thermoplastic/filler composite layer when any of the additionally deposited resistive lead free thick films or electrically conductive electrode tracks are processed to a temperature near or above the melting temperature of the high temperature thermoplastic matrix, to avoid compromising the integrity of the electrical insulation.
A composite sol gel resistive thick film is then deposited on the coated substrate and processed to form a thick film heating element. The constituents of the sol gel are selected so that they can be processed below 600° C. in the case where the substrate is aluminum, aluminum alloys or the like. Voltage can be applied directly to this resistor or through a conductive track that connects to the resistive thick film and is also deposited onto the insulated dielectric layer coated substrate at a temperature below 600° C. If necessary, a topcoat layer may be deposited onto the electrically resistive heater layer to provide oxidation protection, moisture resistance and electrical insulation for the integrated heater element.
Thus, in one aspect of the invention there is provided a lead free thick film heating element on a substrate, comprising:
a dielectric coating located on said surface, said dielectric coating being made from an electrically insulating melt flowable high temperature thermoplastic polymer mixed with a pre-selected amount of a filler material; and
an electrically resistive lead free thick film located on said dielectric coating having a resistance, such that when the voltage is applied to said electrically resistive lead free thick film it responsively heats.
The present invention provides a process for producing a sealed, electrically insulating thermoplastic based coating on a surface of a substrate comprising the steps of:
a) producing a dielectric coating on said surface of the substrate by
b) depositing an electrically resistive lead free thick film formulation onto a top surface of said at least one electrically insulating coating and thermally processing said electrically resistive lead free thick film formulation to produce an electrically resistive lead free thick film; and
c) applying an electrical conductor in electrical contact with said electrically resistive lead free thick film for applying electrical power to said electrically resistive lead free thick film to heat it.
The present invention also provides an article having a heated metal component, comprising:
a) an article having a metal component configured to contact another article, the metal component having a surface;
b) a lead free thick film heating element formed on the surface of the metal component for heating said metal component, said lead free thick film heating element including
c) a battery connected to said electrical conductor and a switch for electrically connecting said battery to said electrical conductor such that when said switch is turned on a voltage is applied through said electrical conductor so that said electrically resistive lead free thick film is heated.
A further understanding of the functional and advantageous aspects of the invention can be realized by reference to the following detailed description and drawings.
The invention will be more fully understood from the following detailed description thereof taken in connection with the accompanying drawings, which form a part of this application, and in which:
a is a top view of an embodiment of a thick film high temperature thermoplastic insulated heating element constructed in accordance with the present invention;
b is a cross sectional view of heating element of
a is a top view of another embodiment of a thick film high temperature thermoplastic insulated heating element constructed in accordance with the present invention; and
b is a cross sectional view of heating element of
Generally speaking, the systems described herein are directed to a thick film high temperature thermoplastic insulated substrate-based heating element and a method for producing same using composite coating synthesis methods. As required, embodiments of the present invention are disclosed herein. However, the disclosed embodiments are merely exemplary, and it should be understood that the invention may be embodied in many various and alternative forms, including substitution of the metal substrate with another material such as glass or ceramic that may require further electrical insulation or leakage current reduction to satisfy operating requirements for the integrated thick film heating element.
Therefore, specific structural and functional details disclosed herein are not to be interpreted as limiting but merely as a basis for the claims and as a representative basis for teaching one skilled in the art to variously employ the present invention. The figures are not to scale. For purposes of teaching and not limitation, the illustrated embodiments are directed to a thick film high temperature thermoplastic insulated metal based heating element and a method for producing same using composite coating synthesis methods.
As used herein, the term “about”, when used in conjunction with ranges of dimensions of particles or other physical properties or characteristics, is meant to cover slight variations that may exist in the upper and lower limits of the ranges of dimensions so as to not exclude embodiments where on average most of the dimensions are satisfied but where statistically dimensions may exist outside this region. It is not the intention to exclude embodiments such as these from the present invention.
As used herein, the phrase “electrically insulating melt flowable high temperature thermoplastic based thick film” means that a specified voltage may be applied across the thickness dimension of the thick film and electrical breakdown or unacceptable level of leakage current does not occur such that the film is termed electrically insulating, that the film structure includes a melt flowable thermoplastic matrix formed from melt flowable thermoplastic powders at a temperature typically above 250° C., and that the thick film structure withstands high temperatures, maintaining a solid structure at operating temperatures exceeding 180° C.
The term “thick film” as used herein is meant to refer to coatings that in general are >1 um in thickness. While the terms “thick films” and “thin films” are relative, in the coatings industry, “thin film” generally refers to technologies using nano or submicron thick coatings typically done for optical and electronic applications using techniques such as sputtering, PVD, MBE etc. which in some cases lay down atomic thick layers of the coating. On the other hand, “thick film” generally refers to technologies used for coatings that are >1 um and may be produced by deposition of several successive layers using techniques such as screen printing process. While “thick film” generally refers to films with a thickness in the range from about 1 to about 500 um which would cover the range for most commercial article heating applications, it will be appreciated that thicker films e.g about 1000 um or thicker are also covered by the term “thick film”.
It will be understood that when referring to a dielectric coating located on the surface of a substrate which is made from an electrically insulating melt flowable high temperature thermoplastic polymer mixed with a pre-selected amount of a filler material, it will be understood that this “dielectric coating” may be a monolithic coating deposited in a single deposition process. Alternatively, it can also be understood to mean that the “dielectric coating” may comprise two or more coatings deposited and cured one on top of the other so that the “dielectric coating” is in fact two or more coatings used to build up the “dielectric coating”. The amount of filler may be the same in each of the coatings or it may be varied for one or more of these multiple coatings.
When referring to processing temperatures for both the dielectric coating and the electrically resistive lead free thick film grown on top of the dielectric coating, it will be understood that the temperatures disclosed herein are exemplary only and not limited to those temperatures or temperature ranges. The temperatures that can be used will depend on the melt flowable high temperature thermoplastic polymer being used, the filler material being mixed with the thermoplastic polymer, the particular materials used to produce the electrically resistive lead free thick film, and the nature of the substrate. For example, when the substrates on which the heater elements are being formed are made from aluminum or aluminum alloys then an upper limit of around 600° C. since the melting point of these materials is around 600° C. Other the other hand, if stainless steels are the substrate material, processing temperatures higher than 600° C. could be used but in this case the processing temperatures would be dependent more so on the nature of the thermoplastic polymer being used, the filler material and the materials used to make the electrically resistive lead free thick film.
a and 1b illustrate an embodiment of the combined heater/substrate device shown generally at 10. More particularly,
The heater element 14 is lead (and cadmium) free and may withstand temperatures of e.g. 500° C. The surface of substrate 12 may be treated to provide improved uniformity and adhesion of the coating layers from deposition to thermal processing to heating element operation. Examples of the surface treatment of the surface of the substrate include sanding, rubbing and sandblasting.
Heater component 14 as shown in
Dielectric layer 16 is an electrically insulating melt flowable high temperature thermoplastic based thick film. This electrically insulating dielectric layer 16 is made from a formulation containing a combination of high temperature melt flowable thermoplastic powders and filler materials in a suitable vehicle which includes various volatile and/or organic constituents, for deposition, which may be deposited and thermally processed to a temperature in the range of 300-450° C. to melt flow the thermoplastic powder and form a cohesive composite coating with the filler particles embedded in a bonded thermoplastic matrix that is adhered to the substrate (which in many commercial embodiments may be a metal substrate). In an embodiment of the device, dielectric layers 20, 22 and 24 may be identical and layer 26 may be of a different composition from the other three.
While there are four layers shown, there may be more or less layers and the present device is not restricted to four layers. Depositing the overall dielectric layer 16 in four layers is to minimize the effect of pinholes on the overall electrical insulation properties of the coating and to ensure that the various volatile organic constituents in the carrier are removed during baking. Each layer is deposited or coated by being printed (for example), then fired to form a rigid layer with all the volatile organic constituents removed except of course the melt flowable organic material itself, and then the next layer is deposited until all four layers are laid down. This process has been found to ensure good quality dielectric layers.
The four insulating dielectric layers 20, 22, 24 and 26 are produced from a melt flowable high temperature thermoplastic polymer which comprises at least one of polyphenylene sulfide (PPS), polyphthalamide (PPA), polyarylamide (PARA), liquid crystal polymer, polysulfone (PS), polyethersulfone (PES), polyphenylsulfone (PPSU, polyamide-imide (PAI), polyetheretherketone (PEEK), polyetherketone (PEK), polyetherketoneetherketone (PEKEK) or self reinforced polyphenylene (SRP), and any combination of these may be used.
a and 2b show another embodiment of a heater element at 40 which is similar to element 10 of
In both embodiments of the heater illustrated in
The insulating dielectric layer 16 is important for the development of a functional heater for use on commercial products such as razor blades and hair irons. The primary requirement for the insulating dielectric layer 16 is high electrical insulation strength and high thermal conductivity, while at the same time the dielectric layer 16 must be deposited in such a way as to avoid pin holes. This is achieved by development of both appropriate formulations and proper processing parameters.
The melt flowable high temperature thermoplastic polymer layers are formulated using thermoplastic polymer powder particles which have a particle size in the range from about 1 to about 100 microns, and preferably has a particle size of from about 1 to about 20 microns. The powder size plays an important role in producing a uniform dispersion and even melt flow during processing. Combinations of melt flowable thermoplastic polymer powders were tested to improve dispersion and melt flow characteristics and wetting of filler, e.g., addition of PAI to PEEK was found to improve dielectric properties.
The filler material may include ceramics, glass or high temperature polymer particles. The filler material may have a particle size in the range from about 0.1 microns to about 100 microns, and preferably in a range from about 1 to about 20 microns. In each of the base dielectric layers 20, 22 and 24, the filler is present in the polymer in a range from about 5-80 weight percent and preferably in a range from about 20-60 weight percent, and most preferably it is present in an amount of about 35-45 weight percent.
The powder filler material is added to the melt flowable high temperature thermoplastic powder and has the following functions. First, it provides improved thermal expansion coefficient matching between the high temperature thermoplastic layer and the additionally deposited resistive and conductive thick films both during initial processing and during electrical cycling operation of the integrated heating element. Secondly, the filler increases the thermal conductivity of the insulating layer to produce better heat transfer to the metal substrate and prevent generation of “hot-spots” in the resistive layer during operation of the heater. Third, with the presence of the filler in the dielectric layer, additionally deposited resistive or conductive thick films on the top of layer 26 reliably and consistently do not sink into the insulating thermoplastic layer 16 when any of these additionally deposited resistive or conductive thick films are processed to a temperature near or above the melting temperature of the high temperature thermoplastic matrix, compromising the integrity of electrical insulation.
Thus the filler particles serve to reinforce the layer 16. Examples of suitable ceramic materials include alumina, zirconia, silica, (optionally ceria stabilized zirconia or yttria stabilized zirconia), titania, calcium zirconate, silicon carbide, titanium nitride, nickel zinc ferrite, calcium hydroxyapatite and any combinations thereof. Alumina has the highest thermal conductivity and dielectric strength.
It has been observed that layering of base dielectric layer 16 such as illustrated in
Alternatively, a thick film of the required thickness, required composition and filler loading can be placed directly on the substrate prior to processing at temperatures in the range from about 400 to about 450° C. Thermal processing is performed in air using conventional furnace or IR heating may be used. An advantage of the present heater element over glass frit dielectric based heaters is that in the present device the processing parameters to get melt flow are not critical and the furnace profile is not critical, unlike the conditions required with glass frit dielectric based heaters.
Top dielectric layer 26 is added to the base dielectric layers 20, 22 and 24 to provide a bonding layer which adheres to the electrically resistive heater layer 18 and conductive strips 28. Upper most layer 26, while made of the same thermoplastic polymer as the based dielectric layers 20, 22 and 24, has a higher filler loading than these base dielectric layers, up to 95% by weight, and can be applied and processed in the same was as the base dielectric layers 20, 22 and 24.
In the top dielectric layer 26, the filler is present in the polymer in a range from about 5-95 weight percent and preferably in a range from about 40-80 weight percent, and most preferably it is present in an amount of about 60-70 weight percent. The top dielectric layer 26 is also useful in that it provides increased mechanical stability and improved coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) which facilitates a much better thermal matching to the insulating dielectric layers 20, 22 and 24 and electrically resistive heater layer 18 both during processing and subsequent operation under applied electrical power at elevated temperatures.
A lead-free composite sol gel based electrically resistive heater layer 18 is deposited onto the thermoplastic composite coating and processed (fired) to a temperature below 600° C., typically in the range from about 400 to about 450° C. (but not limited thereto) to cure the coating. The temperature is selected to give a crack-free layer 18 free of volatile and/or organic constituents. The composite sol gel resistive thick layer 18 may be made according to the teachings of U.S. Pat. No. 6,736,997 issued on May 18, 2004 and U.S. Pat. No. 7,459,104 issued Dec. 2, 2008 both to Olding et al., (which are incorporated herein in their entirety by reference) and the resistive powder can be one or graphite, silver, nickel, doped tin oxide or any other suitable resistive material, as described in the Olding patent publication.
The sol gel formulation is a solution containing reactive metal organic or metal salt sol gel precursors that are thermally processed to form a ceramic material such as alumina, silica, zirconia, (optionally ceria stabilized zirconia or yttria stabilized zirconia), titania, calcium zirconate, silicon carbide, titanium nitride, nickel zinc ferrite, calcium hydroxyapatite and any combinations thereof. or combinations thereof. The sol gel process involves the preparation of a stable liquid solution or “sol” containing inorganic metal salts or metal organic compounds such as metal alkoxides. The sol is then deposited on a substrate material and undergoes a transition to form a solid gel phase. With further drying and firing at elevated temperatures, the “gel” is converted into a ceramic coating.
The sol gel formulation may be an organometallic solution or a salt solution. The sol gel formulation may be an aqueous solution, an organic solution or mixtures thereof.
A lead-free conductive thick film can be used to make the conductive strips/buss bars 28 for making an electrical connection to the resistive thick film element 18. This conductive strips 28 are deposited either before (see
Alternately, the conductive track 28 may be produced from any commercially available thick film product that is lead-free and can be thermally processed at a temperature of 450° C. or less. One suitable thick film product is Parmod VLT from Parelec, Inc. which contains a reactive silver metal organic, and silver flake or powder dispersed in a vehicle and can be fired at a temperature typically between 200-450° C. While Parmod VLT is a preferred commercially available conductive thick film product, it should be understood that other suitable conductive thick film products may be used, and that the present invention is not limited to these example products. Since the conductive film may not be exposed to the heating temperatures in the resistive thick film, some high temperature polyimide or polyamide-imide based silver thick film products may also be suitable for use in producing the conductive thick film track 28.
The present invention will now be illustrated with the following non-limiting examples. It will be appreciated that these examples and the processing conditions for making the heater elements are for purposes of illustration only and not meant to limit the scope of the present invention. For example, the substrates used, the constituents used to make each of the different layers will determine the processing temperatures but it will be appreciated that variations in substrate material, thermoplastic polymer, filler material, resistive heater layer composition may be accompanied by different processing temperatures and other conditions.
A thick film thermoplastic insulated resistive heating element 40 as shown in
A topcoat formulation containing 35 parts Vicote 704 PEEK powder, 2.2 parts Solvay Torlon AI-50 PAI powder, and 15 parts P662B alumina powder by weight in a uniform stable dispersion is deposited onto the heating element to provide top coat 42 to give both moisture protection and oxidation resistance. This topcoat 42 is processed to 400° C. Wire connectors are then attached to the thick film heating element 40 which are connected to a power source 32 as shown in
A thick film thermoplastic insulated resistive heating element is made according to Example 1, but the conductive track 28 is deposited and processed to 400° C. using a lead free silver thick film formulation comprising a silver flake dispersed in a silica-based sol gel solution.
A thick film thermoplastic insulated resistive heating element is made according to Example 1, but the substrate material 12 is aluminum instead of 304SS.
A thick film thermoplastic insulated resistive heating element is made according to Example 1, but the resistive thick film 18 is deposited before the conductive track 28 so that the track 28 is deposited on top of thick film 18 to give the structure of
A thick film thermoplastic insulated resistive heating element is made according to Example 1, but both the conductive track 28 and resistive thick film 18 were deposited before processing to 400° C.
A thick film thermoplastic insulated resistive heating element is made according to Example 1, but the conductive track 28 and resistive thick film 18 are processed to 450° C.
A thick film thermoplastic insulated resistive heating element is made according to Example 1, except that a topcoat 42 is not included to give the structure 10 of
A thick film thermoplastic insulated resistive heating element is made according to Example 1, except that four layers of base dielectric having the same composition such as layers 24/22/20 are deposited and processed to 400° C. and a top dielectric layer such as layer 26 is not included. The top layer of base dielectric in this example does not contain PAI, as it can react with the silver film track causing an electrical failure in the track during heating element operation.
A thick film thermoplastic insulated resistive heating element is made by depositing and processing the base 24/22/20 and top 26 dielectric layers as in Example 1. A resistive thick film track is then deposited and processed to 400° C. using a formulation comprising silver flake in an alumina sol-gel solution. The length and width of the silver track are set to give the required resistance. In this example, the resistive track of silver (or it may be graphite based, replaces both the electrically resistive layer 18 and conductive track 28 as it's dimensions and resistivity are selected such that it acts as both and it is laid in an elongate track pattern across the surface so as to be able to heat the surface up. Electrical contact is made to the two ends of this resistive track.
A thick film thermoplastic insulated resistive heating element is made according to Example 8, except that the formulation for the four deposited base dielectric layers is comprising 40 parts Ryton™ PPS powder, 40 parts P662B alumina powder and 1 part fumed silica by weight in a uniform stable dispersion. (four dielectric layers of same composition as 24, 22, 20. The heating element passes a 3.5 kV AC room temperature hi-pot test for 60 seconds.
As used herein, the terms “comprises”, “comprising”, “including” and “includes” are to be construed as being inclusive and open ended, and not exclusive. Specifically, when used in this specification including claims, the terms “comprises” and “comprising” and variations thereof mean the specified features, steps or components are included. These terms are not to be interpreted to exclude the presence of other features, steps or components.
The foregoing description of the preferred embodiments of the invention has been presented to illustrate the principles of the invention and not to limit the invention to the particular embodiment illustrated. It is intended that the scope of the invention be defined by all of the embodiments encompassed within the following claims and their equivalents.
This patent application relates to, and claims the priority benefit from, U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 61/071,336 filed on Apr. 22, 2008, in English, entitled THICK FILM HIGH TEMPERATURE THERMOPLASTICINSULATED METAL BASED HEATING ELEMENT, and which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5993973 | Lee et al. | Nov 1999 | A |
| 6184496 | Pearce | Feb 2001 | B1 |
| 6194692 | Oberle | Feb 2001 | B1 |
| 6222158 | Nakata et al. | Apr 2001 | B1 |
| 6229098 | Dunn et al. | May 2001 | B1 |
| 6736997 | Olding et al. | May 2004 | B2 |
| 20020145134 | Olding et al. | Oct 2002 | A1 |
| 20020153368 | Gardner et al. | Oct 2002 | A1 |
| 20060138121 | Werkman et al. | Jun 2006 | A1 |
| 20080290088 | Leboeuf et al. | Nov 2008 | A1 |
| 20090272731 | Olding et al. | Nov 2009 | A1 |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| 5507086 | Oct 1986 | AU |
| 1202511 | Dec 1998 | CN |
| 1973577 | May 2007 | CN |
| 200973180 | Nov 2007 | CN |
| 0209224 | Jan 1987 | EP |
| 0250905 | Jan 1988 | EP |
| 0 336 436 | Oct 1989 | EP |
| 0 640 669 | Mar 1995 | EP |
| 0 790 754 | Aug 1997 | EP |
| 0 954 201 | Nov 1999 | EP |
| 1905270 | Apr 2008 | EP |
| WO 9629447 | Sep 1996 | WO |
| WO 9711040 | Mar 1997 | WO |
| WO 9822548 | May 1998 | WO |
| WO 02072495 | Sep 2002 | WO |
| WO 02085072 | Oct 2002 | WO |
| Entry |
|---|
| Barrow, David. Applications of Composite Sol-Gel Coatings. Journal of the Danish Ceramic Society. No. 5(1), pp. 4-6. 2002. |
| International Search Report for PCT/CA2010/001652 included with the publication of the PCT application as WO2011047471 on Apr. 28, 2011. |
| Int'l Search Report PCT/CA2009/000525. |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20090272731 A1 | Nov 2009 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 61071336 | Apr 2008 | US |
