This application is related to a co-pending and commonly-assigned United States patent application titled “Recording Spatial and Temporal Properties of Ions Emitted from a Quadropole Mass Filter” (U.S. application Ser. No. 14/561,166), filed on Dec. 4, 2014 and having the named inventors of this application, the disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
The present invention relates to the field of mass spectrometry. More particularly, the present invention relates to a mass spectrometer detector system for detecting time-dependent two-dimensional distributions of ions that exit a mass analyzer of a mass spectrometer system.
Typically, a multipole mass filter (e.g., a quadrupole mass filter) may be used for mass analysis of ions provided within a continuous ion beam. A quadrupole field is produced within the quadrupole apparatus by dynamically applying electrical potentials on configured parallel rods arranged with four-fold symmetry about a long axis, which comprises an axis of symmetry that is conventionally referred to as the z-axis. By convention, the four rods are described as a pair of “x-rods” and a pair of “y-rods”. At any instant of time, the two x-rods have the same potential as each other, as do the two y-rods. The potential on the y-rods is inverted with respect to the x-rods. The “x-direction” or “x-dimension” is taken along a line connecting the centers of the x-rods. The “y-direction” or “y-dimension” is taken along a line connecting the centers of the y-rods.
Relative to the constant potential along the z-axis, the potential on each set of rods can be expressed as a constant DC offset plus an RF component that oscillates rapidly (with a typical frequency of about 1 MHz). The DC offset on the x-rods is positive so that a positive ion feels a restoring force that tends to keep it near the z-axis; the potential in the x-direction is like a well. Conversely, the DC offset on the y-rods is negative so that a positive ion feels a repulsive force that drives it further away from the z-axis; consequently, the potential in the x,y-plane is in the form of a saddle.
An oscillatory RF component is applied to both pairs of rods. The RF phase on the x-rods is the same and differs by 180 degrees from the phase on the y-rods. Ions move inertially along the z-axis from the entrance of the quadrupole to a detector often placed at the exit of the quadrupole. Inside the quadrupole, ions have trajectories that are separable in the x- and y-directions. In the x-direction, the applied RF field carries ions with the smallest mass-to-charge ratios out of the potential well and into the rods. Ions with sufficiently high mass-to-charge ratios remain trapped in the well and have stable trajectories in the x-direction; the applied field in the x-direction acts as a high-pass mass filter. Conversely, in the y-direction, only the lightest ions are stabilized by the applied RF field, which overcomes the tendency of the applied DC to pull them into the rods. Thus, the applied field in the y-direction acts as a low-pass mass filter. Ions that have both stable component trajectories in both x- and y-directions pass through the quadrupole to reach the detector.
In operation, the DC offset and RF amplitude applied to a quadrupole mass filter is chosen so as to transmit only ions within a restricted range of mass-to-charge (m/z) ratios through the entire length of the quadrupole. Such apparatuses can be operated either in the radio frequency (RF)-only mode or in an RF/DC mode. Depending upon the particular applied RF and DC potentials, only ions of selected m/z ratios are allowed to pass completely through the rod structures, whereas the remaining ions follow unstable trajectories leading to escape from the applied multipole field. When only an RF voltage is applied between predetermined electrodes, the apparatus serves to transmit ions in a wide-open fashion above some threshold mass. When a combination of RF and DC voltages is applied between predetermined rod pairs there is both an upper cutoff mass as well as a lower cutoff mass, such that only a restricted range of m/z ratios (i.e., a pass band) passes completely through the apparatus. As the ratio of DC to RF voltage increases, the transmission band of ion masses narrows so as to provide for mass filter operation, as known and as understood by those skilled in the art. As is further known, the amplitudes of the DC and RF voltages may be simultaneously varied, but with the DC/RF ratio held nearly constant but varied to maintain a uniform pass band, such that the pass band is caused to systematically “scan” a range of m/z ratios. Detection of the quantity of ions passed through the quadrupole mass filter over the course of such scanning enables generation of a mass spectrum.
Typically, such quadrupole mass filters are employed as a component of a triple stage mass spectrometer system. By way of non-limiting example,
The example mass spectrometer system 1 of
During conventional operation of a multipole mass filter, such as the quadrupole mass filter Q3 shown in
U.S. Pat. No. 8,389,929, which is assigned to the assignee of the present invention and which is incorporated by reference herein in its entirety, teaches a quadrupole mass filter method and system that discriminates among ion species, even when both are simultaneously stable, by recording where the ions strike a position-sensitive detector as a function of the applied RF and DC fields. When the arrival times and positions are binned, the data can be thought of as a series of ion images. Each observed ion image is essentially the superposition of component images, one for each distinct m/z value exiting the quadrupole at a given time instant. The same patent also teaches methods for the prediction of an arbitrary ion image as a function of m/z and the applied field. Thus, each individual component image can be extracted from a sequence of observed ion images by mathematical deconvolution or decomposition processes, as further discussed in the patent. The mass-to-charge ratio and abundance of each species necessarily follow directly from the deconvolution or decomposition.
The inventors of U.S. Pat. No. 8,389,929 recognized that ions of different m/z ratios exiting a quadrupole mass filter may be discriminated, even when both ions are simultaneously stable (that is, have stable trajectories) within the mass filter by recording where the ions strike a position-sensitive detector as a function of the applied RF and DC fields. The inventors of U.S. Pat. No. 8,389,929 recognized that such operation is advantageous because when a quadrupole is operated in, for example, a mass filter mode, the scanning of the device that is provided by ramped RF and DC voltages naturally varies the spatial characteristics with time as observed at the exit aperture of the instrument. Specifically, ions manipulated by a quadrupole are induced to perform a complex 2-dimensional oscillatory motion on the detector cross section as the scan passes through the stability region of the ions. All ion species of respective m/z ratios express exactly the same motion, at the same Mathieu parameter “a” and “q” values, but at different respective RF and DC voltages and at different respective times. The ion motion (i.e., for a cloud of ions of the same m/z but with various initial displacements and velocities) may be characterized by the variation of a and q, this variation influencing the position and shape cloud of ions exiting the quadrupole as a function of time. For two masses that are almost identical, the sequence of their respective oscillatory motions is essentially the same and can be approximately related by a time shift.
The aforementioned U.S. Pat. No. 8,389,929 teaches, inter alia, a mass spectrometer instrument having both high mass resolving power and high sensitivity, the mass spectrometer instrument including: a multipole configured to pass an abundance of one or more ion species within stability boundaries defined by applied RF and DC fields; a detector configured to record the spatial and temporal properties of the abundance of ions at a cross-sectional area of the multipole; and a processing means. The data acquired by the so-configured detector can be thought of as a series of ion images. Each observed ion image is essentially the superposition of component images, one for each distinct m/z value exiting the quadrupole at a given time instant. The aforementioned patent also provides for the prediction of an arbitrary ion image as a function of m/z and the applied field. As a result, each individual component can be extracted from a sequence of observed ion images by mathematical deconvolution or decomposition processes which generate the mass-to-charge ratio and abundance of each species. Accordingly, high mass resolving power may be achieved under a wide variety of operating conditions, a property not usually associated with quadrupole mass spectrometers.
The teachings of the aforementioned U.S. Pat. No. 8,389,929 exploit the varying spatial characteristics by collecting the spatially dispersed ions of different m/z even as they exit the quadrupole at essentially the same time.
As the ion approaches the exit of the stability region, a similar effect happens, but in reverse and involving the x-component rather than the y-component. The cloud gradually elongates in the horizontal direction and the oscillations in this direction increase in magnitude until the cloud is carried across the left and right boundaries of the image. Eventually, both the oscillations and the length of the cloud increase until the transmission decreases to zero.
To illustrate operability by way of an example, the first surface of the MCP assembly 13 can be floated to 10 kV, (i.e., +10 kV when configured for negative ions and −10 kV when configured to receive positive ions), with the second surface floated to +12 kV and −8 kV respectively, as shown in
The example biasing arrangement of
The biasing arrangement of the detector system 20 (
The photons p emitted by the phosphor coated fiber optic plate or aluminized phosphor screen 15 are captured and then converted to electrons which are then translated into a digital signal by a two-dimensional camera component 25 (
Each of the anodes of the two-dimensional camera 25 shown in
The ion imaging application described in U.S. Pat. No. 8,389,929 and under consideration herein requires high sensitivity and high signal linearity over a wide dynamic range. The two-dimensional anode array camera 25 shown in
Some system embodiments in accordance with the present invention include image intensifiers of novel design. Various image-intensifier technologies have been developed for use in commercial applications. The earliest cascaded image intensifier is based upon “generation 1” technology in which there is no micro channel plate but, instead, only a low work function coating on the entrance surface of a vacuum vessel that converts incoming photons to free electrons. As such generation-1 applications involve human vision, the internal electrostatic optics inverts the electron beam to create an upright image on a phosphor coated exit. Although such technology has found application in vehicle mounted systems, it is associated with a large physical size that is unacceptable for use with the mass spectrometer systems under consideration in the present disclosure.
U.S. Pat. No. 3,875,440 issued Apr. 1, 1975 describes a cascaded intensifier in which one side of a mica plate is coated with a photocathode material and the other with a phosphor. To form a cascaded image intensifier, a series of such parts are placed end-to-end and sealed into glass cylinders which are then evacuated. The mica tolerates 10 kV so the optocoupler arrangement allows multiple stages to operate with this single supply voltage.
A more recent patent, U.S. Pat. No. 6,958,474 dated Oct. 25, 2005 describes an ion detector for a time of flight mass spectrometer. While this application does not involve imaging or cascading multiple stages, specific advantages of using the phosphor as a gain stage are described, as well as a number of detailed design enhancements.
A problem that leads to premature photocathode wear is bombardment by positive ions produced by ionization of background gases. These ions are accelerated back towards the photocathode. U.S. Pat. No. 6,483,231 dated Nov. 19, 2002 assigned to Litton Industries describes this phenomenon and a means to eliminate it where the source is a micro-channel plate. By controlling dimensions, close spacing is provided, which reduces the ion formation such that a common image intensifier barrier film that blocks ions from leaving the MCP is not required.
In accordance with some ion imaging system embodiments, a cascaded phosphor imaging system is employed as a gain stage. The cascaded system can eliminate the need for a high gain micro channel plate, which can be replaced by either a low gain micro channel plate or another type of ion to electron conversion dynode, such as a metal channel dynode (MCD). The described novel ion imaging systems employing MCDs are associated with an increase in dynamic range over the strip current limited range achieved by typical MCPs. Further, taking into account system maintenance costs, replacing the conventional MCP by an MCD is expected to decrease long-term system cost. Although an MCD device is (as of this writing) more costly than a comparable single MCP device, the MCD is expected to have substantially longer lifetime, as the MCP is generally the most fragile component of MCP-phosphor based systems. Therefore, using an MCD is expected to provide a long-term system cost benefit.
The present inventors have realized that various alternative camera technologies may be employed, in accordance with some embodiments, as a less costly and less complex alternative, relative to the previously-described camera. By way of non-limiting example, such camera technologies include charge-coupled device (CCD), charge injection device (CID) complementary metal-oxide-semiconductor (CMOS) and silicon photomultiplier array technologies. In regard to the present application, the inventors contemplate the use of a detector system that is designed to observe signal with a resolution of 187 microns and a time specificity of 125 nanoseconds. This low gain and resolution requirement creates the opportunity to exploit alternative image-intensifier geometries other than those created for the typical applications noted above.
Using the gain characteristics of CID camera systems as an example and using the expected quantities of ions to be detected in the mass analyzer systems under consideration, the inventors calculate that between 103 and 105 photons must be generated for each incident ion. The photon generation system described in U.S. Pat. No. 8,389,929 comprises a microchannel plate (MCP) and a phosphor-coated substrate. Conventionally, such multi-component signal conversion systems are designed most of the signal gain is generated in the first component which, in the system shown in
The present inventors have further realized that a two-dimensional array of silicon photomultipliers may be employed, in accordance with some embodiments, as a high-performance alterative to the previously-described camera system. In such systems, the array of anodes of the previously-disclosed system is replaced with a two-dimensional array of silicon photomultipliers. Each micro sensor is a high gain (e.g., up to 106 gain in some implementations, with a gain range of 105 to 106 gain being typical for the present application) avalanche detector with a relatively rapid response and recovery. An alternative mass spectrometer detection system configuration employing a pair of one-dimensional silicon photomultiplier arrays (instead of a two-dimensional array) may also be employed. One such configuration is described in a co-pending and commonly-assigned United States patent application titled “Recording Spatial and Temporal Properties of Ions Emitted from a Quadropole Mass Filter” (U.S. Application Ser. No. 14/561,166), filed on Dec. 4, 2014. Silicon photomultiplier array detector systems are available as arrays of low-voltage avalanche photodiodes in pitch sizes of 10 μm, 20 μm, 30 μm and larger. Such an imaging system is expected to provide superior performance. Because of the high-gain characteristics of the camera system, high-gain characteristics are not required of either the micro channel plate (MCP) or the photon generating assembly (comprising the phosphor coated fiber optic plate 15 shown in
The above noted and various other aspects of the present invention will become further apparent from the following description which is given by way of example only and with reference to the accompanying drawings, not drawn to scale, in which:
The following description is presented to enable any person skilled in the art to make and use the invention, and is provided in the context of a particular application and its requirements. Various modifications to the described embodiments will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art and the generic principles herein may be applied to other embodiments. Thus, the present invention is not intended to be limited to the embodiments and examples shown but is to be accorded the widest possible scope in accordance with the features and principles shown and described. The particular features and advantages of the invention will become more apparent with reference to the
In operation of the detector system 100.1, ions (either positive or negative) are accelerated in the direction of the MCD 116 by application of an electrical potential difference between an electrode of the mass spectrometer (not shown) and the MCD 116 or between the MCD 116 and a an electrode 134 of the first gain stage S1, or both. The electrical potential difference is such as to provide ion impact energy of at least several kilo electron volts. For positive ions a typical value would be −10 kV. Secondary electrons, e−, generated at the MCD are accelerated in the direction of a phosphor coating 122 disposed on a substrate plate 118 of the first gain stage S1 by application of an electrical potential difference between the MCD 116 and an electrode 134 comprising a thin conductive metallic coating disposed on the phosphor 122. This metal coating allows high energy electrons to pass and induce photon production in the phosphor. Further, the coating is optically reflective and increases the efficiency of the phosphor by redirecting back-emitted or backscattered photons towards the thin insulating glass, mica, plastic or preferably fiber optic substrate plate 118.
At the phosphor 122 of the first stage S1, the kinetic energy of the electrons is converted to radiant energy of emitted photons p by cathodoluminescence. Thus, the substrate plate 118 and its phosphor coating 122, taken together, may be considered to comprise an “electron-to-photon” converter. Alternatively, the combination of substrate plate 118, phosphor coating 122 and electrode 134, when taken together, may be considered to comprise the electron-to-photon converter, since these three components will generally—but not necessarily always—occur together. The similar components of gain stages S1, S2 and S3 may be regarded, similarly, as additional electron-to-photon converters. Some of the photons p emitted by phosphor 122 propagate through the substrate plate 118 of gain stage S1 and are absorbed by a photocathode 164 of the same stage. Although each photocathode 164 is shown in the drawings as separated from its associated substrate plate 118, it may be provided as a coating on the back face of the substrate plate. At the photocathode, a portion of the photon energy is converted back to kinetic energy of electrons e−. Thus, each photocathode 164 may be regarded as an electron-to-photon converter.
The electrons generated at the first gain stage S1 are accelerated so as to impact the phosphor coating 122 disposed on a substrate plate 118 of the second gain stage S2 by application of an electrical potential difference between the photocathode 164 of stage S1 and a thin-film metallic electrode 154 disposed on the phosphor 122 of the second gain stage S2. The process of generating photons from the electrons and generating new electrons from the photons, and causing the new electrons to propagate toward the next stage is repeated at stages S2 and S3. More generally, this process is repeated at each gain stage except for the last stage. The final gain stage—stage S4 in the example illustrated in
The final population of photons (i.e., the population of photons generated by cathodoluminescence at the last gain stage) may be focused a light detector 125 by a lens assembly 127. In some embodiments, the light detector is provided as a two-dimensional detector, such as a charge-coupled-device (CCD) camera or, a charge injection device (CID) camera, a camera based on complementary metal-oxide-semiconductor technology or as an array of silicon photomultiplier detectors. In alternative embodiments, the detector may be a single channel photo detector to enable simple ion detection. Since the cathodoluminescence may consist of broadband light, an achromatic lens assembly is preferred. In the illustrated example, the lens assembly comprises lens elements 123a, 123b. Alternatively, the lens doublet could also be replaced by direct coupling of the detector to the fiber optic plate (if employed) or other phosphor-coated substrate plate or other scintillating material of the final gain stage.
The MCD 116.1 illustrated in
The MCD devices illustrated in
If positively charged ions are emitted from the mass analyzer, then the process of forcing secondary electrons through a single electroformed MCD plate is relatively easy. However, if the ions are negatively charged, then the electrical potential bias relative to the subsequent phosphor needs to be arranged such that the resulting electric field sufficiently penetrates the apparatus so as to keep the overall quantum efficiency of the first conversion stage sufficiently high to compete with that of an MCP.
Signal gain generated by the detector system 100.1 (
Each of the substrate plates 118 may comprise a single-piece or integral component, such as a plate made of glass, mica or plastic. Alternatively, each substrate plate may be formed as a fiber optic plate, which is an optical device comprised of a bundle of densely packed parallel optical fibers, each of micron size, with the set of fiber first ends and the set of fiber back ends each terminated and polished so as to essentially form parallel front and back faces, respectively. Such fiber optic plates are used in various applications including transferring images, possibly magnified or reduced in size, and are commercially available from Hamamatsu Photonics K.K. of Iwata City Japan. According to some alternative embodiments, one or more substrate plates may be provided as a thin scintillating plastic, thereby eliminating the need for a phosphor coating.
Note that the bias electrical potential that is applied to the electrode 134 disposed on the first gain stage S1 must be relative to the MCD 116 (or other ion to electron conversion device), but the downstream electrical potential biases (on photocathodes 164 and electrodes 154) are not similarly constrained. For convenience these downstream electrical potentials may be driven by common voltages, but such operation is not required. The use of common voltages simply reduces the power supply requirements. For example, the MCD bias might limit the gradient to the first phosphor, especially in the case of negative ions. Once the ion signal is converted to photons, the subsequent gain stages may be driven with higher potentials and therefore, higher gain.
The electrodes 134, 154 and photocathodes 164 may be formed as thin, flat plates or films disposed on or adjacent to the substrates. Such flat, parallel surfaces can produce a strong electric field gradient that will overcome the natural angular dispersion of the electrons and maintain the propagation of each packet of electrons between stages parallel to the long axis of the system. If the substrate used is a very small dimensioned fiber optic plate, the photon dispersion may be similarly controlled. The unavoidable image blurring that multiple stages will incur can be controlled by use of a fiber optic plate so as to easily match the desired pixel spatial resolution (for example, 187 μm) of a suitable camera 125. If the substrate plates 118 are formed from a non-fiber material (for instance, as a plate or sheet of glass, mica or plastic), then image blurring and stray light effects may be prevented by incorporating optical lenses (not shown) within one or more of the gain stages so as to transfer an image of the light emission pattern of each phosphor 122 to the respective photocathode 164.
The first such optional enhancement feature shown in
Still with reference to
Since the detector system 100.1 (
Alternatively, under circumstances in which the photocathode or phosphors of the detector system are not tolerant to air during shipment, it may be desirable to provide some of the detector components within a prefabricated, pre-evacuated and pre-sealed enclosure 171 as illustrated with regard to the detector system 100.3 shown in
Using the detector configuration illustrated in
The gain stages S1-S4 housed within the enclosure 171 are generally as previously described except that the first gain stage S1 does not comprise a phosphor and may substantially consist of just a photocathode which may or may not be disposed upon a substrate plate. Instead, a phosphor coating 126 is applied to the outer surface of the glass enclosure or, alternatively, to the transparent window, if present, at a position such that, when the enclosure 171 is mated to the mass spectrometer housing or wall 7, the phosphor coating 126 is disposed along a line of sight between the MCD 116 and the first gain stage S1. Thus, in operation of the detector system 100.3, the phosphor coating 126 is disposed within the high vacuum chamber 5. Photons generated at the phosphor coating 126 pass through the transparent window (if present) or wall of the enclosure 171 so as to create secondary electrons at the photocathode of the first gain stage S1 within the enclosure 171. The enclosure 171 and the components therein may be regarded, when considered together, as an image intensifier 173 which receives a photonic signal from an external photon source—in this instance, phosphor 126—and emits, as output, an amplified version (indicated by the rightmost arrow labeled p) of the original signal.
The final, amplified batch of photons generated at the final gain stage (for example, gain stage S4) within the enclosure are focused by lens assembly 127 onto optical detector 125 as previously described. In some embodiments, the lens assembly 127 and optical detector 125 may be housed within the enclosure 171. In other alternative embodiments, either the optical detector 125 or the lens assembly 127 or both may be housed in an optional, separate enclosure 172. If the lens assembly 127 is not housed within the same enclosure 171 as the gain stages, then the enclosure may comprise a second window disposed such that there is a direct optical line of sight between the final gain stage and the lens assembly 127. As will be readily appreciated, the interior of the enclosure 171 will generally include not-illustrated additional elements, such as electrical leads and support structures and the enclosure 171 will generally include a vacuum feed-through component so as to route electrical wires into the enclosure.
In the preceding discussion of various detector system embodiments, the high gain characteristics of the cascaded gain stages are exploited, and the MCD 116 is essentially only needed to “convert” ions into electrons with minimal gain. Gain is provided by the cascade sections that have ample supply currents. The various detector system embodiments described above thus do not suffer from strip-current-limited dynamic range associated with present commercially available off-the-shelf high-gain micro-channel plates (MCPs). Although the above discussion considers the use of a metal channel dynode (MCD) as a low-gain alternative to an MCP, it should be noted that low gain MCP devices are nonetheless available. Such low-gain MCP devices could be employed as an alternative form of low-gain ion-to-electron converter in the presently-described detector systems. However, the inventors consider that such low gain MCP devices, although functional, are less preferable than MCD devices for use in the present application for the following reason. MCP gain is controlled by a combination of factors including the length-to-diameter ratio. Values of this ratio of 40:1 and 60:1 are typical, so the present application would require an MCP device in which the length-to-diameter ratio is 40:1. A device having such a length-to-diameter ratio is expected to be thinner and therefore more fragile.
Other embodiments of detector systems in accordance with the present teachings may employ a semi-reflective metal layer disposed between each phosphor and the electron source from which it receives electrons, as schematically illustrated in
In the controlled feedback arrangement illustrated in
In the description of the invention herein, it is understood that a word appearing in the singular encompasses its plural counterpart, and a word appearing in the plural encompasses its singular counterpart, unless implicitly or explicitly understood or stated otherwise. Furthermore, it is understood that for any given component or embodiment described herein, any of the possible candidates or alternatives listed for that component may generally be used individually or in combination with one another, unless implicitly or explicitly understood or stated otherwise. Moreover, it is to be appreciated that the figures, as shown herein, are not necessarily drawn to scale, wherein some of the elements may be drawn merely for clarity of the invention. Additionally, it will be understood that any list of candidates or alternatives is merely illustrative, not limiting, unless implicitly or explicitly understood or stated otherwise. In addition, unless otherwise indicated, numbers expressing various measured or measurement quantities such as length, size, percentage, gain factor, etc. as used in the specification and claims are to be understood as being modified by the term “about.”
The discussion included in this application is intended to serve as a basic description. The present invention is not to be limited in scope by the specific embodiments described herein, which are intended as single illustrations of individual aspects of the invention, and functionally equivalent methods and components are within the scope of the invention. Indeed, various modifications of the invention, in addition to those shown and described herein will become apparent to those skilled in the art from the foregoing description and accompanying drawings. Such modifications are intended to fall within the scope of the appended claims. Any patents, patent applications, patent application publications or other literature mentioned herein are hereby incorporated by reference herein in their respective entirety as if fully set forth herein, except that, in the event of any conflict between the incorporated reference and the present specification, the language of the present specification will control.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3875440 | McGee | Apr 1975 | A |
3914634 | Overall | Oct 1975 | A |
4482836 | Washington | Nov 1984 | A |
4721880 | Mansell et al. | Jan 1988 | A |
4737623 | Uhl | Apr 1988 | A |
5532551 | Kyushima | Jul 1996 | A |
5801511 | Kyushima et al. | Sep 1998 | A |
6483231 | Iosue | Nov 2002 | B1 |
6617768 | Hansen | Sep 2003 | B1 |
6958474 | Laprade | Oct 2005 | B2 |
7498557 | Pinkas et al. | Mar 2009 | B2 |
7564043 | Hayashi | Jul 2009 | B2 |
7741758 | Hanai | Jun 2010 | B2 |
8389929 | Schoen | Mar 2013 | B2 |
20050104527 | Niigaki | May 2005 | A1 |
20070263223 | Hirai | Nov 2007 | A1 |
20080290267 | Hayashi | Nov 2008 | A1 |
20100243887 | Suyama | Sep 2010 | A1 |
20110095174 | Suyama | Apr 2011 | A1 |
20110095178 | Giannakopulos | Apr 2011 | A1 |
20110215235 | Schoen | Sep 2011 | A1 |
20130146778 | Nuetzel | Jun 2013 | A1 |
20130175443 | Schoen | Jul 2013 | A1 |
20130268212 | Makarov | Oct 2013 | A1 |
20140151549 | Steiner | Jun 2014 | A1 |
20140246579 | Hoyes | Sep 2014 | A1 |
20150034819 | Hoyes | Feb 2015 | A1 |
20150162174 | Badiei | Jun 2015 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20160172173 A1 | Jun 2016 | US |