Combination CVI/CVD and heat treat susceptor lid

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6257881
  • Patent Number
    6,257,881
  • Date Filed
    Friday, June 2, 2000
    24 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, July 10, 2001
    22 years ago
Abstract
The invention relates to a susceptor lid for use in a CVI/CVD furnace. More specifically, the invention is directed to a lid configured to consecutively run CVI/CVD and heat treatment processes without opening the furnace. The susceptor lid according to the invention comprises: a susceptor lid body having a gas exhaust hole, the susceptor lid body having a top surface and a bottom surface; and an exhaust lid disposed over the gas exhaust hole, with a clearance between the exhaust lid and the gas exhaust hole such that exhaust gas pressure within the clearance is approximately equal to, or less than the exhaust gas pressure within the gas exhaust hole, the exhaust lid being positioned to block the majority of the radiation from below the bottom surface of the susceptor lid body.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




The invention relates to a susceptor lid for use in a CVI/CVD furnace. More specifically, the invention is directed to a lid configured to consecutively run CVI/CVD and heat treatment processes without opening the furnace between the processes.




Refractory composites are commonly subjected to heat treatment and CVI/CVD processes. According to prior art processes, different susceptor lids are used for each specific process because a CVI/CVD susceptor lid is provided with holes to enable gas flow, while the heat treatment susceptor lid is imperforate in order to prevent radiative heat transfer through the lid. Changing the lids is both time consuming and results in loss of radiation heat from the furnace. Therefore, a lid that may be used for both processes without opening the furnace is desired.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




According to an aspect of the invention, a combined heat treat and CVI/CVD susceptor lid for a furnace susceptor, which allows exhaust gas to exit therefrom, is disclosed. The susceptor lid comprises: a susceptor lid body having a gas exhaust hole. The susceptor lid body has a top surface and a bottom surface. An exhaust lid is disposed over the gas exhaust hole, with a clearance between the exhaust lid and the gas exhaust hole such that exhaust gas pressure within the clearance is approximately equal to, or less than the exhaust gas pressure within the gas exhaust hole. The exhaust lid is positioned to block the majority of the radiation from below the bottom surface of the susceptor lid body.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

presents a cross-sectional side view of a CVI/CVD furnace that implements a susceptor lid according to an aspect of the invention.





FIG. 2

presents a top view of a susceptor lid according to an aspect of the invention.





FIG. 3

presents a cross-sectional side view of the susceptor lid depicted in

FIG. 2

taken along line


3





3


of FIG.


2


.





FIG. 4

presents a top view of a susceptor lid according to an aspect of the invention.





FIG. 5

presents a cross-sectional view of the susceptor lid depicted in

FIG. 4

taken along line


5





5


of FIG.


4


.





FIG. 6

presents a top view of a susceptor lid according to a preferred embodiment of the invention.





FIG. 7

presents a cross-sectional view taken along line A—A of the susceptor lid depicted in FIG.


6


.





FIG. 8

presents a cross-sectional side view of a CVI/CVD furnace that implements the susceptor lid of the instant invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION




Various aspects of the invention are presented in

FIGS. 1-8

which are not drawn to scale, and wherein like components are numbered alike. Referring now to

FIG. 1

, a cross-sectional view of a high temperature furnace


10


is presented, by way of example, that implements various aspects of the invention. Furnace


10


is configured to be employed with a high temperature process. As used herein, the term “high temperature” means a temperature substantially elevated above room temperature and in the range of 300° C. or greater. Refractory materials, generally, are manufactured and/or processed at temperatures greater than 300° C., and may be on the order of 900°-3000° C., or higher. For example, a porous carbon aircraft brake disk may have a pyrolytic carbon matrix deposited within it by a CVI/CVD process conducted at a temperature in the range of 900°-1100° C., and may be further heat-treated at a temperature up to 2200° C. or higher. Manufacturing and processing other types of ceramic materials may occur at other temperature ranges. Furnaces are commonly configured specifically for processing refractory composite materials using high temperature processes. Such processes include deposition of a binding matrix within a porous substrate, and heat treatment processes wherein refractory composite materials are heated for a defined period of time in order to alter some aspect of the material properties. Such processes are well known in the art.




Chemical vapor infiltration and deposition (CVI/CVD) for example, is a well-known process for depositing a binding matrix within a porous structure. The term “chemical vapor deposition” (CVD) generally implies deposition of a surface coating, but the term is also used to refer to infiltration and deposition of a matrix within a porous structure. As used herein, the term CVI/CVD is intended to refer to infiltration and deposition of a matrix within a porous structure. The technique is particularly suitable for fabricating high temperature structural composites by depositing a carbonaceous or ceramic matrix within a carbonaceous or ceramic porous structure resulting in very useful structures such as carbon/carbon aircraft brake disks, and ceramic combustor or turbine components. The generally known CVI/CVD processes may be classified into four general categories: isothermal, thermal gradient, pressure gradient, and pulsed flow. See W. V. Kotlensky,


Deposition of Pyrolytic Carbon in Porous Solids


, 8 Chemistry and Physics of Carbon, 173, 190-203 (1973); W. J. Lackey,


Review, Status, and Future of the Chemical Vapor Infiltration Process for Fabrication of Fiber-Reinforced Ceramic Composites


, Ceram. Eng. Sci. Proc. 10[7-8]577, 577-81 (1989) (W. J. Lackey refers to the pressure gradient process as “isothermal forced flow”).




In an isothermal CVI/CVD process, a reactant gas passes around a heated porous structure at absolute pressures as low as a few torr. The gas diffuses into the porous structure driven by concentration gradients and cracks to deposit a binding matrix. This process is also known as “conventional” CVI/CVD. The porous structure is heated to a more or less uniform temperature, hence the term “isothermal.”




In a thermal gradient CVI/CVD process, a porous structure is heated in a manner that generates steep thermal gradients that induce deposition in a desired portion of the porous structure. The thermal gradients may be induced by heating only one surface of a porous structure, for example by placing a porous structure surface against a susceptor wall, and may be enhanced by cooling an opposing surface, for example by placing the opposing surface of the porous structure against a liquid cooled wall. Deposition of the binding matrix progresses from the hot surface to the cold surface.




In a pressure gradient CVI/CVD process, the reactant gas is forced to flow through the porous structure by inducing a pressure gradient from one surface of the porous structure to an opposing surface of the porous structure. Flow rate of the reactant gas is greatly increased relative to the isothermal and thermal gradient processes which results in increased deposition rate of the binding matrix. This process is also known as “forced-flow” CVI/CVD. Finally, pulsed flow involves rapidly and cyclically filling and evacuating a chamber containing the heated porous structure with the reactant gas. The cyclical action forces the reactant gas to infiltrate the porous structure and also forces removal of the cracked reactant gas by-products from the porous structure.




Furnace


10


is generally cylindrical and comprises a shell


12


and a steel lid


14


. The shell


12


can be made of steel. The lid also comprises a vacuum port


20


. The furnace


10


also comprises a cylindrical induction coil


24


adjacent a cylindrical susceptor


26


. The induction coil


24


comprises coiled conductors


23


encapsulated by electrical insulation


27


. During operation, the induction coil


24


develops an electromagnetic field that couples with the susceptor


26


and generates heat within the susceptor


26


. The susceptor


26


rests upon a susceptor floor


28


and is covered by a susceptor lid


30


. A cylindrical insulation wall


32


is disposed in between the susceptor


26


and the induction coil


24


. Lid insulation layer


34


and floor insulation layer


36


are disposed over the susceptor lid


30


and beneath the susceptor floor


28


, respectively. A reactant gas is supplied to the furnace


10


by a main gas supply line


44


. If desired, a mixture of reactant gases can be used. In such instance, a multitude of individual gas supply lines


46


are connected in fluid communication with a multitude of gas ports


48


that pass through the shell


12


. A multitude of flexible gas supply lines


50


are connected in fluid communication with the gas ports


48


and a multitude of gas inlets


52


that pass through holes


54


in the furnace floor


38


, the floor insulation layer


36


, and the susceptor floor


28


. A multitude of porous substrates


62


, for example brake disks, are stacked within the furnace


10


inside the susceptor


26


on fixtures (not shown for clarity). Suitable fixtures are well known in the art.




The furnace and fixture configuration may vary substantially depending upon the type of process used, and the various aspects of the invention may be implemented with any of these processes, depending upon the particular configuration. As such, the furnace configuration of

FIG. 1

is presented by way of example, and is not intended to limit the invention to the specific arrangement presented.




Referring now to

FIGS. 2 and 3

, a top view and a cross-sectional view of the susceptor lid


30


are provided, according to an aspect of the invention. The susceptor lid


30


comprises a susceptor lid body


100


having a gas exhaust hole


102


and an exhaust lid


104


disposed over the gas exhaust hole


102


. The susceptor lid body


100


has a top surface


202


and a bottom surface


204


. There is a clearance


200


, defined by the dashed line, between the exhaust lid


104


and the gas exhaust hole


102


, and between the exhaust lid


104


and the susceptor lid body top surface


202


, such that the exhaust gas pressure within the clearance


200


is approximately equal to, or less than the exhaust gas pressure within the gas exhaust hole


102


. The exhaust lid


104


is positioned over the gas exhaust hole


102


to block the majority of the radiation from below the susceptor lid body bottom surface


204


. The gas exhaust hole


102


allows reactant gas introduced into the furnace


10


through the gas inlets


52


to pass through the susceptor lid


30


to the vacuum port


20


. According to a preferred embodiment, the exhaust lid


104


is positioned over the gas exhaust hole


102


such that there is no line of sight from above the susceptor lid body top surface


202


to below the susceptor lid body bottom surface


204


. In another preferred embodiment the exhaust lid


104


comprises a disk


206


with a top surface


207


and bottom surface


205


, and posts


208


which support the disk


206


, and which have opposing ends, wherein the bottom surface of the disk


205


is resting on one end


211


of the post


208


, and the opposing end


209


of the post


208


is resting on the top surface of the susceptor lid body


202


. The disk


206


, posts


208


and susceptor lid body


100


may be secured to each other by screws, bolts, posts, or any other appropriate means. In a further preferred embodiment, the susceptor lid body


100


comprises a plurality of gas exhaust holes


102


and a plurality of exhaust lids


104


disposed over the gas exhaust holes


102


, each gas exhaust hole


102


having a corresponding exhaust lid


104


disposed over the gas exhaust hole


102


, with a clearance


200


between the exhaust lids


104


and the gas exhaust holes


102


, and between the exhaust lid


104


and the susceptor lid body top surface


202


, such that exhaust gas pressure within the clearance


200


is approximately equal to, or less than the exhaust gas pressure within the corresponding gas exhaust holes


102


. The exhaust lids


104


are positioned to block the majority of the radiation from below the susceptor lid body bottom surface


204


. In another embodiment, the exhaust lids


104


are positioned such that there is no line of sight radiation from above the susceptor lid body top surface


202


, to below the susceptor lid body bottom surface


204


.




Referring now to

FIGS. 4 and 5

, a top view and a cross-sectional view of a susceptor lid


120


are provided, according to an aspect of the invention. The susceptor lid


120


comprises a susceptor lid body


122


having a top surface


222


and a bottom surface


224


, and having a gas exhaust hole


128


and an exhaust lid


136


disposed over the gas exhaust hole


128


. The susceptor lid body


122


comprises a susceptor plate


121


and an exhaust stack cap


126


with opposing ends, wherein one exhaust stack cap end


125


encircles the gas exhaust hole


128


, and the opposing exhaust stack cap end


127


extends above the susceptor lid body top surface


222


. The exhaust lid


136


comprises a stud


230


having a bottom surface


232


, and spacers


240


having a top surface


242


and a bottom surface


244


. The spacers


240


support the stud


230


above the susceptor lid body


122


, wherein the stud bottom surface


232


is resting on the spacer top surface


242


, and wherein the spacer bottom surface


244


is resting on the susceptor lid body top surface


222


. The exhaust lid


136


is disposed over the opposing exhaust stack cap end


127


. There is a clearance


220


between the exhaust lid


136


and the exhaust stack cap


126


, and between the exhaust lid


136


and the susceptor lid body top surface


222


, such that the exhaust gas pressure within the clearance


220


is approximately equal to, or less than the exhaust gas pressure within the gas exhaust hole


128


. The exhaust lid


136


is positioned over the gas exhaust hole


128


to block the majority of the radiation from below the susceptor lid body bottom surface


224


.




Referring now to

FIGS. 6

,


7


, and


8


, a susceptor lid


108


is presented according to a certain preferred embodiment, which features various aspects of the invention that may be employed alone or in combination.

FIG. 6

presents a top view of the susceptor lid


108


, and

FIG. 7

presents a cross-section of the susceptor lid


108


as indicated by line A—A of FIG.


6


. The susceptor lid


108


comprises a susceptor lid body


110


that comprises a susceptor plate


112


and an insulation layer


114


overlying the susceptor plate


112


. A gas exhaust hole


116


is provided through the susceptor plate


112


and the insulation layer


114


, and an exhaust lid


104


is disposed over the gas exhaust hole


116


. The susceptor lid body


110


has a top surface


212


and a bottom surface


214


. The exhaust lid


104


is positioned over the gas exhaust hole


116


to block the majority of the radiation from below the susceptor lid body bottom surface


214


. A plurality of gas exhaust holes


116


and corresponding exhaust lids


104


are preferably provided. In a preferred embodiment the susceptor lid body


110


further comprises a gas exhaust tube


130


with opposing ends, wherein one end


132


encircles the gas exhaust hole


116


, and the opposing end


134


extends above the susceptor lid body top surface


212


. In this embodiment the exhaust lid


104


is disposed over the opposing end


134


of the gas exhaust tube


130


, with a clearance


210


between the gas exhaust tube


130


and the exhaust lid


104


such that exhaust gas pressure within the clearance


210


is approximately equal to, or less than the exhaust gas pressure within the gas exhaust hole


116


. In a further embodiment of the invention an insulation sleeve


250


encircles the portion of the gas exhaust tube which extends above the susceptor lid body top surface


212


, with a clearance


213


between the insulation sleeve


250


and the exhaust lid


104


such that the exhaust gas pressure within the clearance


213


is approximately equal to, or less than the exhaust gas pressure within the gas exhaust hole.




In a further preferred embodiment at least one of the exhaust lids


107


has a through hole


105


which is smaller than the gas exhaust hole


116


, and where the center of the through hole


105


is centered above the corresponding gas exhaust hole


116


. These through holes are used to sight targets within the stacks of porous substrates, to determine the temperature in the center of the stacks during the CVI/CVD and heat-treat processes. This is necessary because the temperatures are too high for standard thermocouples. The susceptor plate


112


is made from a material that interacts with the susceptor coil magnetic field in the same manner as the susceptor


26


of FIG.


1


. The insulation layer


114


may superpose the susceptor plate


112


and be attached thereto, and may define an exposed upper surface


115


having sufficient rigidity to permit furnace service personnel to walk on the exposed upper surface


114


without damaging the insulation layer


114


.




The susceptor plate


112


, and insulation layer


114


are superposed and held together by a multitude of tie-rods


140


and nuts


142


threaded onto the tie-rods


140


. The tie-rods


140


closest to the periphery are provided with a threaded hole


144


into which a threaded eye-bolt (not shown) may be inserted for lifting and moving the susceptor lid


120


. The threaded eye-bolts are typically removed during a CVI/CVD or heat treatment process since they are metal and can melt during such processing.




Methods according to various aspects of the invention are also provided. Referring to

FIG. 8

, a CVI/CVD method is provided, comprising the steps of heat treating the porous substrate


62


disposed within the susceptor


26


within the CVI/CVD furnace


10


to an elevated temperature, the susceptor


26


having a susceptor lid


30


with at least one gas exhaust hole


102


; passing a flow of reactant gas into the CVI/CVD furnace


10


; exposing the porous substrate


62


to the reactant gas wherein the reactant gas decomposes and deposits a binding matrix within the substrate


62


; exhausting the flow of reactant gas through a gas exhaust hole


102


in the susceptor lid


30


, while blocking the majority of radiation with an exhaust lid


104


, positioned over the exhaust hole


102


such that the flow of reactant gas flows freely. A multitude of substrates


62


may be disposed within the CVI/CVD furnace, wherein each of the above steps is performed upon the multitude of substrates


62


.




According to a certain embodiment for CVI/CVD processing and heat treating carbon/carbon aircraft brake disks, the susceptor lid


108


is employed. The susceptor plate


112


is manufactured from monolithic graphite having suitable suscepting properties, such as CS grade graphite, available from UCAR Carbon Company Inc., United States of America, or HLM grade graphite, available from SGL Carbon Corporation, United States of America. The gas exhaust tubes


130


are manufactured from monolithic graphite, such as the CS grade graphite or HLM grade graphite materials just described. The tie rods


140


and nuts


142


are manufactured from monolithic graphite, such as ATJ grade, available from UCAR Carbon Company Inc. The outer tie rods


140


having threaded holes


144


are manufactured from a monolithic graphite having a greater strength, such as grade ATJ or CGW, available from UCAR Carbon Company Inc., since these are the lift points for moving the entire lid. The insulation layer


1




14


is manufactured from a rigid carbon felt, such as Calcarb CBCF material, available from Calcarb, Ltd., Scotland, or Fibergraph® material, available from SIGRI Polycarbon, Inc., United States of America. All exterior surfaces of the rigid carbon felt components are painted with a graphite paint, such as TC-2 graphite paint, available from EGC Enterprises Inc., United States of America, and then further sealed with an additional coat of phenolic based paint, such as Rigidseal® paint, available from SIGRI Polycarbon, Inc. The outside curcumferential surface of the insulation layer


114


, and the inside surface of the gas exhaust tube


130


are coated with a graphite foil sheet, such as Grafoil® material available from UCAR Carbon Company Inc., or Calgraph® material, available from SIGRI Polycarbon, Inc., bonded in place using a graphite adhesive, such as Graphi-Bond 669 adhesive, available from Aremco Products Inc., United States of America. A sheet of graphite foil may optionally be bonded to the top surface of the second insulation layer, but is not necessary since the graphite foam coated as described herein is sufficiently abrasion resistant to permit furnace service personnel to walk on its surface.




Although the invention has been described and illustrated with reference to specific illustrative embodiments thereof, it is not intended that the invention be limited to those illustrative embodiments. Those skilled in the art will recognize that variations and modifications can be made without departing from the true scope and spirit of the invention as defined by the claims that follow. It is therefore intended to include within the invention all such variations and modifications as fall within the scope of the appended claims and equivalents thereof.



Claims
  • 1. A combined heat treat and CVI/CVD susceptor lid for a furnace susceptor, which allows exhaust gas to exit therefrom, comprising:a susceptor lid body having a gas exhaust hole, said susceptor lid body having a top surface and a bottom surface; and, an exhaust lid disposed over said gas exhaust hole, with a clearance between said exhaust lid and said gas exhaust hole such that exhaust gas pressure within said clearance is approximately equal to, or less that the exhaust gas pressure within said gas exhaust hole, said exhaust lid being positioned to block the majority of the radiation from below said susceptor lid body bottom surface.
  • 2. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein said exhaust lid is positioned such that there is no line of sight from above said susceptor lid body top surface to below said susceptor lid body bottom surface.
  • 3. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said exhaust lid comprises:a disk having a top and a bottom surface; and, posts which support said disk resting on one end of said post, and the opposing end of said post is resting on said top surface of said susceptor lid body.
  • 4. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said susceptor lid body comprises a susceptor plate and an exhaust stack cap with opposing ends, wherein one end encircles said gas exhaust hole, and the opposing end extends above said susceptor lid body top surface, and wherein said exhaust lid comprises a stud having a bottom surface, and spacers having a top and bottom surface, supporting said stud above said susceptor lid body, wherein said stud bottom surface is resting on said spacer top surface, and wherein said spacer bottom surface is resting on said susceptor lid body top surface, and wherein said exhaust lid is disposed over said opposing end of said exhaust stack cap, with a clearance between said exhaust stack cap and said exhaust lid and between said exhaust lid and said susceptor lid body top surface, such that exhaust gas pressure within said clearance is approximately equal to, or less than the exhaust gas pressure within said gas exhaust hole, said exhaust lid being positioned to block the majority of the radiation from below said susceptor lid body bottom surface.
  • 5. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein said susceptor lid body comprises:a susceptor plate; and a gas exhaust tube with opposing ends, wherein one end encircles said gas exhaust hole, and the opposing end extends above said susceptor lid body top surface, and wherein said exhaust lid is disposed over said opposing end of said gas exhaust tube, with a clearance between said gas exhaust tube and said exhaust lid and between said exhaust lid and said susceptor lid body top surface, such that exhaust gas pressure within said clearance is approximately equal to, or less than the exhaust gas pressure within said gas exhaust hole, said exhaust lid being positioned to block the majority of the radiation from below said susceptor lid body bottom surface.
  • 6. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein said susceptor lid body comprises:a susceptor plate; a gas exhaust tube with opposing ends, wherein one end encircles said gas exhaust hole, and the opposing end extends above said susceptor lid body top surface, and wherein said exhaust lid is disposed over said opposing end of said gas exhaust tube, with a clearance between said gas exhaust tube and said exhaust lid such that exhaust gas pressure within said clearance is approximately equal to, or less than the exhaust gas pressure within said gas exhaust hole, said exhaust lid being positioned to block the majority of the radiation from below said susceptor lid body bottom surface; and, an insulation sleeve which encircles the portion of said gas exhaust tube which extends above said susceptor lid body top surface.
  • 7. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein said exhaust lid has a through hole smaller than said gas exhaust hole, the center of said through hole being centered over said gas exhaust hole.
  • 8. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein said susceptor lid body comprises a susceptor plate and an insulation layer overlying said susceptor plate.
  • 9. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein said susceptor lid body comprises a susceptor plate and an insulation layer overlying said susceptor plate, wherein said insulation layer defines an exposed upper surface and has sufficient rigidity to permit furnace service personnel to walk on said exposed surface without damaging said insulation layer.
  • 10. A combined heat treat and CVI/CVD susceptor lid for a furnace susceptor, which allows exhaust gas to exit therefrom, comprising:a susceptor lid body having a plurality of gas exhaust holes, said susceptor lid body having a top surface and a bottom surface; and, a plurality of exhaust lids disposed over said gas exhaust holes, each gas exhaust hole having a corresponding exhaust lid disposed over said gas exhaust hole, with a clearance between said exhaust lids and said gas exhaust holes such that exhaust gas pressure within said clearance is approximately equal to, or less than the exhaust gas pressure within the corresponding gas exhaust holes, said exhaust lids being positioned to block the majority of the radiation from below said susceptor lid body bottom surface.
  • 11. The apparatus of claim 10 wherein at least one said exhaust lid has a through hole smaller than said gas exhaust holes, the center of said through hole being centered over said gas exhaust hole.
  • 12. The apparatus of claim 10, wherein said exhaust lids are positioned such that there is no line of sight from above said susceptor lid body top surface to below said susceptor lid body bottom surface.
  • 13. In combination, a CVI/CVD and heat treat furnace comprising a susceptor and a susceptor lid, which allows exhaust gas to exit therefrom, said susceptor lid comprising a susceptor plate having a top and a bottom surface and having a gas exhaust hole, and an exhaust lid disposed over said gas exhaust hole, with a clearance between said exhaust lid and said gas exhaust hole such that exhaust gas pressure within said clearance is approximately equal to, or less than the exhaust gas pressure within said gas exhaust hole, said exhaust lid being positioned to block the majority of the radiation from below said susceptor plate bottom surface.
  • 14. A CVI/CVD method, comprising the steps of:heat treating a substrate disposed within a susceptor within a CVI/CVD furnace to an elevated temperature, said susceptor having a susceptor lid with at least one gas exhaust hole; passing a flow of reactant gas into said CVI/CVD furnace; exposing said substrate to said reactant gas wherein said reactant gas decomposes and deposits a binding matrix within said substrate; and, exhausting said flow of reactant gas through said gas exhaust hole, while blocking the majority of radiation with an exhaust lid, positioned over said gas exhaust hole such that said flow of reactant gas flows freely.
  • 15. The method of claim 14, wherein a multitude of substrates are disposed within said CVI/CVD furnace, and are subjected to said steps.
RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is related to U.S. patent application Ser. No. 09/178,395. Furthermore, this application claims the benefit of and incorporates by reference provisional application U.S. application Ser. No. 60/137,591 file date Jun. 4, 1999.

US Referenced Citations (20)
Number Name Date Kind
1933461 Toll Oct 1933
3884793 Penfold et al. May 1975
3995187 Penfold et al. Nov 1976
4030996 Penfold et al. Jun 1977
4031424 Penfold et al. Jun 1977
4422407 Bessot et al. Dec 1983
4573431 Sarkozy Mar 1986
4606650 Harris Aug 1986
4794220 Sekiya Dec 1988
4854266 Simson et al. Aug 1989
5073241 Watanabe Dec 1991
5118289 Bergman et al. Jun 1992
5377297 Nuutinen Dec 1994
5470452 Dickey et al. Nov 1995
5480678 Rudolph et al. Jan 1996
5625170 Poris Apr 1997
5725746 Dickey et al. Mar 1998
5853485 Rudolph et al. Dec 1998
5900297 Rudolph et al. May 1999
5910006 Conroy et al. Jun 1999
Foreign Referenced Citations (3)
Number Date Country
0 410 442 A1 Jan 1991 EP
0 832 863 A2 Apr 1998 EP
0 846 787 A1 Jun 1998 EP
Non-Patent Literature Citations (7)
Entry
European Search Report for EP0832 863 A3, published Apr. 4, 1998 in Bulletin 1998/18, 2 pages.
European Search Report for EP0011 2047 dated Oct. 4, 2000, 4 pages.
IBM Technical Disclosure Bulletin, “Adjustable Flat Gas-Inlet Detector,” Dec. 1987, pp. 41-42, taken from http:/www.delphion.com.
Kotlensky, W.V., “Deposition of Pyrolytic Carbon in Porous Solids,” Chemistry and Physics of Carbon, vol. 9, pp. 173, 186-203 (1973).
Lackey, W.J., “Review, Status, and Future of the Chemical Vapor Infiltration Process for Fabrication of Fiber-Reinforced Ceramic Composites”, Ceram. Eng. Sci. Proc., 10[7-8] 577-81 (1989).
Linke, J. and Vietzke, E., “Behavior of Boron Doped Graphites, Plasma-Sprayed B4C, and a-C/B:H as Plasma-Facing Materials,” Fusion Technology vol. 20, pp. 228-231, Sep. 1991.
Ponnekanti et al., “Failure mechanisms of anodized aluminum parts used in CVD chambers,” J. Vac. Sci. Technol., A14(3), pp. 1127-1131, May/Jun. 1996.
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
60/137591 Jun 1999 US