The present invention relates to an integrated method of adsorption and cryogenic separation for separating CO2 contained in a gas and to an installation for implementing such a method.
The recovery of CO2 from gases or flue gases is spreading inexorably due to the systems installed for limiting greenhouse gas emissions.
The prevalent technology for removing and/or recovering the CO2 contained in industrial effluents is chemical absorption and, more particularly, scrubbing with amines (MDEA, MEA, etc.) which serve to produce pure low pressure CO2, typically having a CO2 purity above 99%.
However, the chemical scrubbing methods have many limitations or drawbacks, that is: large quantity of steam required, sensitivity to oxygen, corrosion, high operating cost, solvent entrainment and, in general, releases of chemicals in non-negligible quantities, such as amines, ammonia, salts issuing from the amine regenerator, amine degeneration products, etc.
Another technology available for recovering the CO2, not having these drawbacks, and in particular, not requiring large quantities of steam, is pressure swing adsorption, like the VPSA (Vacuum Pressure Swing Adsorption), VSA (Vacuum Swing Adsorption) or PSA (Pressure Swing Adsorption) methods.
In the context of the invention, the acronyms have the following meanings:
VPSA unit: a gas separation or purification unit using a cyclic adsorption method comprising at least one adsorption phase on an adsorbent at a pressure above 1.5 bar absolute, and a regeneration phase during which the pressure is lower than atmospheric pressure.
VSA unit: a gas separation or purification unit using a cyclic method comprising at least one adsorption phase on an adsorbent solid at a pressure lower than 1.5 bar absolute, and a regeneration phase during which the pressure is lower than atmospheric pressure.
PSA unit: a gas separation or purification unit using a cyclic method comprising at least one adsorption phase on an adsorbent solid at a pressure above 1.5 bar absolute, and a regeneration phase during which the pressure is equal to or higher than atmospheric pressure.
The VPSA, VSA and PSA units will be referred to below by the generic term “adsorption units”.
Furthermore, in the context of the invention:
all the gas compositions are expressed on a dry basis. The basic dry composition of the component is the ratio, by mass or by volume, of the quantity of material of this component to the total quantity of material present, not including water molecules. Thus, if a stream containing, for example, 70% CO2 also contains 10% water, the basic dry CO2 content of the stream is about 78% (70%/90%);
all the gas compositions are stated in percentages by volume;
the relative humidity of a gas is the ratio, in percentage, of the partial pressure of the water vapor effectively contained in the gas to the water vapor saturation pressure under the same pressure and temperature conditions, according to the usual definition;
the gas compositions issuing from the adsorption methods described in this document are mean compositions, averaged over a whole number of method cycles, the adsorption methods being cyclic methods;
the recovery yield of a compound of a separation unit is the ratio between the quantity of this compound entering the unit and the quantity of this compound leaving the unit in the desired product form.
Today, the adsorption method is used in the iron and steel industry for deballasting gases issuing from processes of the DRI (Direct Reduced Iron) or COREX type. In this case, the purge gas from the adsorption method, which is CO2 rich, that is, typically containing between 60 and 80% CO2, 25% CO and 5% N2, leaving this unit, is used as fuel gas because it still contains a significant quantity of CO. The flue gases issuing from the combustion of this gas are discharged to the atmosphere. The streams from a DRI unit are preferably decarbonated by a VPSA unit, as described in document U.S. Pat. No. 5,858,057 and U.S. Pat. No. 5,676,732. However, the drawback of the flowcharts described in these documents is that the CO2 obtained is not utilized or stored but is simply discharged to the atmosphere.
Furthermore, to improve the operation of a VPSA CO2 method, documents U.S. Pat. No. 5,582,029 and U.S. Pat. No. 6,562,103 teach the use of an external purge gas, poor in CO2, to elute the adsorbent bed, for example, nitrogen produced by an air separation unit, or a natural gas stream. However, the drawback here is that the CO2 leaving the purge is diluted in these purge gases and therefore cannot be utilized or stored.
An adsorption unit is incapable of producing, on an economically acceptable basis or industrially, CO2 in a purity higher than 90%, in particular a purity between 90 and 96%, and hence particularly even less in a purity higher than 96%, from a CO2 poor feed gas, that is, often containing less than 45% CO2.
Because of this, these methods, used alone, are not suitable for concentrating CO2 for its industrial utilization, re-injection and its storage in geological formations (EOR, ECBM, etc.) or for any other use of CO2 requiring CO2 purities higher than 90%.
For their part, the cryogenic CO2 separation units, including liquefiers, are only used to process gases having a concentration above 50%, preferably above 70% and generally above 90%, because the CO2 recovery yield of these units declines sharply when the proportion of gas other than CO2 increases, due to the physical properties of CO2 mixtures with nitrogen, carbon monoxide, hydrogen, oxygen, methane, etc., and the triple point of CO2, which prevents falling to temperatures below −50° C.
In the context of the invention, “cryogenic unit” means an industrial unit for cooling a fluid, for example CO2, in which at least one process fluid is cooled to a temperature lower than or equal to 0° C. and undergoes at least one partial condensation step. This unit may, for example, produce CO2 in gas, liquid or supercritical form. A unit producing a liquid as a product is called a liquefier.
The recovery of CO2 from the offgas of an H2 PSA by a cryogenic unit is described in US-A-2002/0073845 and WO-A-9935455. The H2 PSA offgas typically contains about 50% CO2. These patents describe an original cryogenic method for recovering CO2 from this offgas but do not describe the optimized integration of the H2 PSA and the cryogenic unit, and in particular, do not explain how the interface between the PSA, which is a batch and cyclic process, and the cryogenic unit, which is a continuous process, is implemented. Furthermore, the CO2 content at the inlet of the cryogenic unit is imposed by the hydrogen production performance of the PSA, but there is no integration between the two units and no combined optimal operation. For example, no recycling between the two units is considered.
Document EP-A-341879 also describes a method for coproducing CO2 and H2, in which a syngas issuing from an SMR followed by a shift reactor is sent to an H2 PSA from which the offgas, which contains about 50% CO2, is sent to a CO2 PSA. This CO2 PSA produces a second CO2 enriched gas containing at least 98% CO2, which is sent to a cryogenic separation apparatus that produces a liquid containing at least 99.9% CO2. In this patent, the CO2 PSA produces a CO2 in a high purity (>98%), which culminates in an overall CO2 recovery method that is underoptimized. Moreover, although the interface between the H2 PSA and the CO2 PSA is described, the interface between the CO2 PSA and the liquefier is not addressed, although it is a point that raises important problems between a cyclic process and a continuous process.
The coupling of a PSA with a liquefaction unit is also described in Takamura et al., The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, 79 (5), 812-816: Application of high pressure swing adsorption process for improvement of CO2 recovery system from flue gas; 2001. An ultra cold separator is placed on the offgas from a PSA processing the effluents from a boiler. The incondensable compounds from the liquefier are introduced into a “high pressure” PSA and the purge from this PSA is reintroduced to the feed of the liquefier to improve the yield thereof. However, there is no mention of the way in which the cyclic PSA is coupled with the continuous liquefier.
Document EP-B-0417922 describes a method for producing CO2 from a gas that is relatively poor in CO2, which is first sent to adsorption drying beds and then to a distillation column. The incondensable compounds from the column are then sent to a PSA unit and the CO2 rich gas issuing from this PSA is recycled to the inlet of the liquefier. By the same principle, document GB-A-2174379 describes the use of a membrane instead of the PSA to separate the CO2 from the stream of incondensables issuing from the column. These flowcharts, in which the first CO2 separation takes place by cryogenic distillation, can only be economically viable if the CO2 content of the feed gas is not too low, typically if it is higher than about 50%.
Document EP-A-1319911 describes a CO2 liquefaction method in which drying by adsorption precedes the cryogenic separation of the CO2. This document does not describe a preseparation of the CO2 by adsorption unit.
Document EP-A-0945163 describes the combined use of membrane modules and PSA to separate and purify hydrogen. This system is not optimized for recovering CO2 and, more precisely, does not comprise a cryogenic portion that would serve to meet the more stringent specifications on the CO2 produced.
Furthermore, documents U.S. Pat. No. 4,639,257 and U.S. Pat. No. 4,602,477 teach methods using a combination of a membrane and a cryogenic distillation unit to separate the CO2. The adsorption units employed only serve to remove the water from the gas stream and not to separate the CO2 significantly.
It is a particular object of the present invention to overcome the drawbacks of the prior art and to propose solutions for implementing and optimizing a method integrating an adsorption unit and a cryogenic unit for the effective separation of CO2 from a stream containing less than 60% CO2, the other components being more volatile components, for example CO, N2, H2, CH4, etc.
More precisely, one object of the inventive method is to obtain, at minimum cost, a CO2 recovery yield of about 90% and/or a CO2 product purity meeting the specifications for geological disposal (aquifers, coal 30 seams, etc.) and/or the enhanced recovery of fossil fuels (EOR, ECBM, etc.). For example, the CO2 purities desired for these applications are generally above about 89%, typically above 94%, and lower than about 99%. 35 One of the subjects of the invention is accordingly an integrated method using an adsorption unit coupled to a cryogenic unit, in which a feed gas containing CO2 is sent to the adsorption unit where it is separated into a first CO2 enriched stream and a first CO2 depleted stream, the first CO2 enriched stream being sent to the cryogenic unit where it is separated into a second CO2 rich stream and a second CO2 depleted stream, characterized in that the first CO2 enriched stream issuing from the adsorption unit is first sent to gas homogenizing means for attenuating the cyclic variations of flow rates, pressure and/or composition of this first stream, inherent in the cyclic character of the adsorption unit, and then subjected to at least one intermediate compression step before entering the cryogenic unit, that is, upstream and/or prior to its entry into the cryogenic unit.
The gas homogenizing means for attenuating the cyclic variations of the stream issuing from the adsorption unit may be, for example, an intermediate storage unit, such as a vessel or reservoir, optionally maintained at a substantially constant pressure. More precisely, this intermediate gas storage unit may, for example, be a gas holder having a variable volume and at substantially constant pressure, or a vessel having a fixed volume equipped with a pressure control system for maintaining a substantially constant pressure.
In other words, one of the aspects of the present invention is the coupling of an adsorption unit and a cryogenic unit using a first gas homogenizing step for attenuating the cyclic variations of flow rates, compositions and/or pressures of the first CO2 enriched stream issuing from the adsorption unit and a second intermediate compression step, these two steps being carried out between the adsorption separation step and the cryogenic separation step, that is between the adsorption unit and the cryogenic unit.
The homogenizing step serves to attenuate the cyclic variations of the stream issuing from the adsorption unit and can be carried out by using an intermediate gas storage unit or any other device suitable for performing this attenuation/homogenization function, and suitable for collecting all or part of the CO2 enriched stream leaving the adsorption unit.
The adsorption unit therefore first carries out a “preseparation” of the CO2 and the cryogenic unit then carries out the final separation of the CO2 by means of various integration devices installed between the adsorption unit and the cryogenic unit.
The use of gas homogenizing means or a device for attenuating the cyclic variations of the CO2 enriched stream issuing from the adsorption unit (flow rate, composition, pressure, etc.) inherent in the cyclic operation of the adsorption unit, serves to ensure continuous operation of the compressor and of the cryogenic unit located downstream.
A system is thereby obtained coupling a cyclic batch process employed by the adsorption unit, and a continuous system employed by the cryogenic unit, with reduced process control means at the interface.
Furthermore, in case of interruption of one of these two units, for maintenance for example, the two units can be easily uncoupled.
Moreover, the fact of carrying out a compression up to at least 15 bar upstream of the cryogenic unit serves to guarantee the desired yields in the cryogenic unit on input gases containing between 40% and 95% CO2 , thereby relaxing the constraints on the separation performance of the adsorption unit.
Symmetrically, part of the incondensable gases issuing from the cryogenic unit is optionally recycled to the adsorption unit and therefore serves to relax the constraints on the separation performance of the cryogenic unit.
An integrated and combined system is thereby obtained between the adsorption unit and the cryogenic unit, which serves to optimize the separation costs of the overall system.
Depending on the case, the inventive method may further comprise one or more of the following features:
the first CO2 enriched stream issuing from the adsorption unit has a pressure of less than 4 bar, preferably less than 2 bar, and a CO2 content of between 40% and 95%, preferably between 60% and 85% and/or a relative humidity above 5%,
the second CO2 rich stream issuing from the cryogenic separation unit has a CO2 content above 80%, preferably above 90%, and even more preferably above 95%.
the first CO2 enriched gas leaving the adsorption unit is sent to the gas homogenizing means for attenuating the cyclic variations in flow rate, composition and/or pressure of this gas, and is then subjected to the intermediate compression,
the gas homogenizing means is a mixing vessel or reservoir, for example a constant volume vessel with pressure control or a gas holder having a variable volume and substantially constant pressure,
the first CO2 depleted stream produced by the adsorption unit is expanded in a turbine which can provide refrigerating capacity to the cryogenic unit,
the first CO2 poor gas produced by the adsorption unit is first cooled before being expanded in the turbine,
at least part of the second CO2 poor gas leaving the cryogenic unit is returned to the absorbtion unit, particularly either to the suction inlet of the compressor feeding the adsorption unit, or upstream of the adsorber(s) of the adsorption unit, or in the adsorbers during a repressurizing step, in cocurrent or countercurrent, or in the absorber(s) during an adsorption step,
at least part of the second CO2 depleted gas leaving the cryogenic unit is expanded in a turbine and then recycled to the adsorption unit, either to the suction inlet of the feed compressor, or upstream of the adsorber(s), or in the adsorber(s) during a repressurizing step, in cocurrent or countercurrent, or in the adsorber(s) during an adsorption step,
before entering the turbine, the recycled gas is first heated by direct combustion of this gas (injection of air or enriched air) and/or by heating in a boiler preferably burning blast furnace gas and/or by exchange with a fluid from the steel plant, whose temperature is higher than 150° C. and/or by exchange with the first CO2 enriched gas produced by the adsorption unit upstream of the cryogenic unit,
at least part of the second CO2 poor gas leaving the cryogenic unit is used as fuel for heating the gas of the cryogenic unit, heating the regeneration heater of the cryogenic unit, for example drying by adsorption, and/or heating the first CO2 poor gas from the adsorption unit, before or after expansion in an optional turbine, and/or heating a regeneration heater of an air separation unit and/or producing steam which can be used in the installation by the regeneration heater of the cryogenic unit and/or, one or more drive turbines of the machines and/or a refrigerating unit by absorption serving for example to cool the gas before the purifiers of the cryogenic unit and/or a heat exchanger heating the first CO2 poor gas leaving the adsorption unit,
at least part of the first CO2 poor gas leaving the adsorption unit is used as fuel to heat the regeneration heater, for example for drying beds, of the cryogenic unit and/or to produce steam which can be used in the installation by the regeneration heater and/or one or more drive turbines of the machines and/or a refrigerating unit by absorption serving for example to cool the gas before the purifiers of the cryogenic unit and/or a heat exchanger heating the first CO2 poor gas leaving the adsorption unit,
the refrigerating unit of the cryogenic unit also serves to cool the gas entering the adsorption unit,
the first CO2 enriched gas leaving the adsorption unit is sent to a mixing vessel or reservoir before being introduced into the cryogenic unit,
the incondensable compounds leaving the cryogenic unit are sufficiently cooled to freeze CO2 in the form of dry ice and to separate the CO2 thereby frozen from the stream containing the incondensable compounds,
at least part of the CO2 enriched stream compressed in the intermediate compression step is cooled to a temperature above 0° C., and the liquid part which condenses is preferably removed, for example in a phase separation device.
According to another aspect, the invention also relates to an integrated installation for producing CO2 from a feed gas containing CO2 , comprising an adsorption unit for separating the gas containing CO2 into a first CO2 enriched stream and a first CO2 depleted stream, the adsorption unit feeding a cryogenic unit with said first CO2 enriched stream, and a cryogenic unit for separating the first CO2 rich stream issuing from the adsorption unit into a second CO2 rich stream and a second CO2 poor stream, characterized in that the CO2 enriched stream issuing from the adsorption unit has a CO2 content of between 40 and 95% and in that it further comprises a gas homogenizing device or means suitable for attenuating the cyclic variations (flow rate, composition, pressure, etc.) of the CO2 enriched stream issuing from the adsorption unit and intermediate compression means, arranged on the path of the first CO2 enriched stream, between the adsorption unit and the cryogenic unit. Advantageously, the CO2 enriched stream issuing from the adsorption unit has a CO2 content of between 60 and 85%.
Preferably, the gas homogenizing means are arranged upstream of the compression means, that is between the adsorption unit and the compression means.
The installation of the invention optionally also comprises means for carrying out gas recyclings between the adsorption unit and the cryogenic unit, for example means for recycling at least part of the incondensable gases issuing from the cryogenic unit to the adsorption unit, particularly either at the suction inlet of the compressor feeding the adsorption unit, or upstream of the adsorber(s) of the adsorption unit, or in the adsorbers during a repressurizing step, in cocurrent or countercurrent, or in the adsorber(s) during an adsorption step, the recycles optionally passing through heating, combustion and expansion means.
The invention is described in greater detail with reference to
The gas 1 to be processed by the adsorption unit 3 is typically at a pressure between 1 and 10 bar absolute. This pressure is reached by optionally adding a compressor upstream of the adsorber(s) of the adsorption unit 3.
The method of the present invention is an integrated method using, in series, an adsorption unit 3 coupled with a cryogenic unit 9, the combination being optimized for producing CO2 at minimum cost, with a CO2 recovery yield of about 90% and/or a typical CO2 product purity of about 90 to 99%, particularly by the passage of the CO2 enriched gas issuing from the adsorption unit through a buffer vessel or reservoir 17 constituting all or part of the gas homogenizing means, and/or an intermediate compression, as described below.
According to the method shown in
The first CO2 enriched stream 6 is produced at lower than 4 bar, typically at lower than 2 bar, for example between 1 and 2 bar, and is then sent to the cryogenic unit 9, without undergoing other separation steps, except optionally a recovery of part of the water it contains.
The first CO2 enriched stream 6 leaving the adsorption unit 3 has a CO2 content of between 40% and 95%, typically between 60% and 85%, a pressure of less than 4 bar, typically about 1 to 2 bar, and a relative humidity generally of at least 5%.
According to the invention, the step of attenuation of the cyclic variations in flow rate, composition, pressure, etc. 17 and the intermediate compression step 7 are carried out on the first CO2 enriched stream 6 leaving the adsorption unit 3, upstream of the cryogenic unit 9, via one or more compressors or any other suitable gas compression device, placed between these two units 3, 9.
The gas homogenizing means or device for attenuating the cyclic variations 17, placed on the path of the CO2 enriched stream leaving the adsorption unit 3, before its intermediate compression 7, is for example a constant volume vessel with pressure control or a gas holder having a variable volume and substantially constant pressure. The pressure of this mixing vessel or reservoir is typically lower than 4 bar absolute, preferably lower than 2 bar absolute. The intermediate compression step serves to raise the pressure of the CO2 enriched gas issuing from the adsorption unit 3 and stored in the mixing vessel or reservoir 17 from a low pressure lower than 4 bar absolute to pressure levels compatible with an efficient cryogenic separation, that is to a pressure of above 15 bar, typically between 20 and 80 bar, in order to improve the CO2 recovery yield in the cryogenic unit.
In the cryogenic unit 9, the compressed gas stream is separated into a second CO2 rich stream 11 and a second CO2 poor stream 10. The second CO2 rich stream 11 leaving the cryogenic unit 9 has a CO2 content above 80%, preferably at least 90% even more preferably at least 94%.
In other words, the first CO2 enriched stream 6 leaving the adsorption unit 3 is then sent to the gas homogenizing means, then to one or more intermediate compression means or devices 7, such as one or more compressors or any other device suitable for carrying out a gas compression, before being conveyed, via the line 8, to a cryogenic unit 9 where it is condensed at least partially and at least once.
Before being partially condensed, the first CO2 enriched stream 6 issuing from the adsorption unit is therefore compressed to a pressure above 6 bar absolute, preferably above 20 bar absolute, typically between 20 and 80 bar and preferably between 30 and 50 bar, for a mean CO2 content of the stream 6 of 40 to 95%, typically between 60 and 85% at the outlet of the adsorption unit 3.
The cryogenic unit 9, which may, for example be a liquefier, produces a second CO2 poor gas 10 and a second CO2 rich gas 11 containing at least 80% CO2 and preferably 90 to 99% CO2, or optionally even more than 99% CO2.
The CO2 can then be stripped to produce a gas containing even purer CO2 , for example in a stripping column (not shown) located downstream, before being sent to a user or storage site.
Furthermore, the adsorption unit 3 further comprises one or more adsorbers operating in parallel, a system of valves and optionally one or more vacuum pumps in the case of a VPSA or VSA unit, a compressor of the gas to be processed, a CO2 enriched gas storage vessel or reservoir, and/or a CO2 depleted gas storage vessel or reservoir.
Moreover, the cryogenic unit 9 may in particular comprise one or more gas prepurifiers, typically containing alumina or a molecular sieve, an active carbon or a silica gel, and their regeneration heater, a cold heat exchanger and optionally one or more condensers/reboilers, separator pots, distillation columns, compressors, devices for the catalytic removal or not of the CO2 and hydrogen, mechanical or absorption refrigerating unit, and/or precooling device before the dryers.
The expanded gas leaving the turbine 22 may optionally be sent to the adsorbers of the adsorption unit 3 during a repressurizing step or during an adsorption step. A recycling method in which the stream 10 is recycled directly to the adsorption unit 3, hence without transiting via a turbine 22, would also be feasible.
The energy recovered at the shaft of the turbine 22 can either serve to generate electricity, or to drive a compressor.
It may also be advantageous, as shown in
The first CO2 rich gas stream 6, that is having a CO2 content of between 40% and 95%, typically between 60% and 85%, is conveyed by the line 8 (see
The purified gas recovered by the line 35 is then cooled in a heat exchanger 37 where it is partially condensed. The condensed liquid phase 51 is separated from the gas phase 53 in a phase separator 45.
The liquid part 51 is sent to a storage unit 49 after expansion in a pressure reducing valve 70, while the gas part 53 is sent to a second heat exchanger 43 where it is partially condensed.
The partially condensed phase 54 is separated from the gas phase 61 in a phase separator 47. The liquid stream 57 withdrawn from the phase separator 47 is sent to the storage unit 49, after expansion, here also in a pressure reducing valve 71.
The gas stream 59 issuing from the storage unit 49 is sent successively to the heat exchangers 43 and 37 in order to utilize the refrigerating capacity it contains, before being recycled to the additional compression means 55, if such means are present in the cryogenic unit 9, or, in the absence thereof to an intermediate step of the intermediate compressor 7 located between the adsorption units 3 and the cryogenic unit 9.
The stream 10 issuing from the phase separator 47 is also sent successively to the heat exchangers 43 and 37 in order to utilize the refrigerating capacity it contains.
The liquid product 11 containing at least 90% CO2 is withdrawn from the storage unit 49.
The refrigerating capacity for liquefaction in the heat exchangers 37 and 43 is supplied by two conventional refrigerating cycles 39, 41, which may optionally be coupled.
As previously, the gas stream 8 having a CO2 content of between 40% and 95%, typically between 60% and 85%, is compressed (at 55) then purified (at 33) and cooled in the heat exchanger 37 where it is partially condensed Here also, the condensed phase 51 is separated from the gas phase 53 in a phase separator 45.
The gas part 53 is sent to a second heat exchanger 43 where it is partially condensed. The partially condensed phase 54 is separated from the gas phase in a phase separator 47. The liquid stream 57 withdrawn from the phase separator 47 is expanded and sent successively to the heat exchangers 43 and 37 in order to utilize the refrigerating capacity it contains.
The gas stream issuing from the phase separator 47 is sent successively to the heat exchangers 43 and 37 in order to utilize the refrigerating capacity it contains.
The liquid part 51 issuing from the first phase separator 45 is also expanded and sent successively to the heat exchangers 43 and 37 in order to utilize the refrigerating capacity it contains.
The streams 67 and 68 are then combined and compressed to a pressure necessary for transport by gas lines If the combined stream 69 is a two-phase stream, it is heated to make it completely gaseous before being sent to the compressor 73, and then conveyed it via the line 11. This product stream, conveyed via the line 11, is formed of CO2 having a purity of at least 90%, typically at least 90 to 96%.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
0550906 | Apr 2005 | FR | national |
0552459 | Aug 2005 | FR | national |
0553219 | Oct 2005 | FR | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/FR06/50276 | 3/30/2006 | WO | 00 | 4/18/2008 |