Method and apparatus for applying downward force on wafer during CMP

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6712670
  • Patent Number
    6,712,670
  • Date Filed
    Thursday, December 27, 2001
    23 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, March 30, 2004
    21 years ago
Abstract
An apparatus for applying a wafer to a polishing belt during a CMP operation includes a spindle having an upper end and a lower end. A wafer carrier is coupled to the lower end of the spindle. A linear force generator is disposed at the upper end of the spindle. A load cell is positioned between the linear force generator and the upper end of the spindle. A controller is coupled to the load cell for controlling the force applied by the linear force generator. A method for applying downward force on a wafer during CMP also is described.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




The present invention relates to chemical mechanical planarization (CMP) techniques and, more particularly, to a method for applying downward force on a wafer during CMP and an apparatus for applying a wafer to a polishing surface during a CMP operation.




In the fabrication of semiconductor devices, there is a need to perform chemical mechanical planarization (CMP) operations. Typically, integrated circuit devices are in the form of multi-level structures. At the substrate level, transistor devices having diffusion regions are formed. In subsequent levels, interconnect metallization lines are patterned and electrically connected to the transistor devices to define the desired functional device. As is well known, patterned conductive layers are insulated from other conductive layers by dielectric materials, such as silicon dioxide. As more metallization levels and associated dielectric layers are formed, the need to planarize the dielectric material grows. Without planarization, fabrication of further metallization layers becomes substantially more difficult due to the variations in the surface topography. In other applications, metallization line patterns are formed in the dielectric material, and then, metal CMP operations are performed to remove excess material.




A chemical mechanical planarization (CMP) system is typically utilized to polish a wafer as described above. A CMP system typically includes system components for handling and polishing the surface of a wafer. Such components can be, for example, an orbital polishing pad, or a linear belt polishing pad. The pad itself is typically made of a polyurethane material or polyurethane in conjunction with other materials such as, for example a stainless steel belt. In operation, the belt pad is put in motion and then a slurry material is applied and spread over the surface of the belt pad. Once the belt pad having slurry on it is moving at a desired rate, the wafer is lowered onto the surface of the belt pad. In this manner, wafer surface that is desired to be planarized is substantially smoothed, much like sandpaper may be used to sand wood. The wafer may then be cleaned in a wafer cleaning system.





FIG. 1A

shows a linear polishing apparatus


10


which is typically utilized in a CMP system. The linear polishing apparatus


10


polishes away materials on a surface of a semiconductor wafer


16


. The material being removed may be a substrate material of the wafer


16


or one or more layers formed on the wafer


16


. Such a layer typically includes one or more of any type of material formed or present during a CMP process such as, for example, dielectric materials, silicon nitride, metals (e.g., aluminum and copper), metal alloys, semiconductor materials, etc. Typically, CMP may be utilized to polish the one or more of the layers on the wafer


16


to planarize a surface layer of the wafer


16


.




The linear polishing apparatus


10


utilizes a polishing belt


12


, which moves linearly in respect to the surface of the wafer


16


. The belt


12


is a continuous belt rotating about rollers


20


. The rollers are typically driven by a motor so that the rotational motion of the rollers


20


causes the polishing belt


12


to be driven in a linear motion


22


with respect to the wafer


16


.




The wafer


16


is held by a polishing head


18


. The wafer


16


is typically held in position by mechanical retaining ring and/or by vacuum. The polishing head


18


positions the wafer atop the polishing belt


12


and moves the wafer


16


down to the polishing belt


12


. The polishing head


18


applies the wafer


16


to the polishing belt


12


with pressure so that the surface of the wafer


16


is polished by a surface of the polishing belt


12


. The polishing head


18


is typically part of a spindle drive assembly


30


(shown in

FIG. 1B

) that enables application of polishing pressure to the wafer


16


.





FIG. 1B

shows a conventional spindle drive assembly


30


that may be utilized to apply the wafer


16


to the polishing belt in the CMP apparatus


10


(as shown above in FIG.


1


A). The spindle drive assembly


30


includes the polishing head


18


connected to a spindle


42


. The spindle


42


is attached to a force magnifier


34


that in one end is connected to a hinge


40


and in the other end is connected to an air cylinder


32


. The force magnifier


34


is typically an a machined aluminum arm that acts in a similar manner to a lever so force applied by the air cylinder


32


is magnified onto the spindle


42


. The spindle


42


then pushes down the polishing head


18


which in turn applies pressure to the wafer


16


for polishing action (as shown in FIG.


1


A).




Generally, a range of 3 psi to 10 psi can be applied to the wafer


16


by the spindle drive assembly


30


. Unfortunately, at pressures lower than 3 psi, the by the spindle drive assembly


30


is unable to apply a consistent, controlled pressure. The air cylinder


32


is typically controlled with a pneumatic servo valve that uses feedback from a load cell


36


inside the polishing head


18


. Problematically the weight of the spindle, head, and other hardware is not supported by anything other than the spindle. This makes the application of downward forces lower than the weight attached to the cylinder


32


very unstable. Also, because of the force magnifier


34


, small adjustments in pressure made at the cylinder


32


cause large pressure application changes in the polishing head


18


so control of pressure is very difficult. In certain circumstances, the inability to control low force application prevents a gentle touchdown of the wafer onto the polishing pad. This often occurs because of an inherent overshoot built into the spindle drive assembly


30


for a particular pressure setting. For example, if pressure of 4 psi is desired to be applied to the wafer, a pressure of 5 psi is generally applied to break friction within individual components of the spindle drive assembly


30


and move the spindle. Therefore, low polishing pressure application to the wafer using conventional pressure application systems is very problematic.




Additionally, because of the indirect linkage of air cylinder


32


to the rest of the spindle drive assembly


30


, reduced stability of the polishing head


18


often occurs. Therefore, consistent polishing pressure on a wafer, especially at low pressure levels is often difficult to attain.




Therefore, there is a need for an apparatus that overcomes the problems of the prior art by having a downward force application apparatus that can optimize control of polishing pressure applied by a polishing head to a wafer in CMP systems.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




Broadly speaking, the present invention fills this need by enabling the optimal control of downward force application in a chemical mechanical planarization (CMP) polishing process. It should be appreciated that the present invention can be implemented in numerous ways, including as a process, an apparatus, a system, a device or a method. Several inventive embodiments of the present invention are described below.




In accordance with one aspect of the invention, an apparatus for applying a wafer to a polishing surface during a CMP operation is provided. The apparatus includes a spindle that has an upper end and a lower end. A wafer carrier is coupled to the lower end of the spindle. A linear force generator is disposed at the upper end of the spindle. A load cell is positioned between the linear force generator and the upper end of the spindle. A controller is coupled to the load cell for controlling the force applied by the linear force generator.




In one embodiment, the linear force generator includes a lower plate that is disposed on the load cell and an upper plate supported above the lower plate. The linear force generator also includes a bladder positioned between the lower plate and the upper plate. In another embodiment, a load cell plate is coupled to the upper end of the spindle, and a load cell is disposed on the load cell plate.




In accordance with another aspect of the invention, a method for applying downward force on a wafer during chemical mechanical planarization (CMP) is disclosed. In this method, a linear downward force is applied to an upper end of a spindle. The spindle has a wafer carrier coupled to a lower end thereof. The method also monitors the linear downward force applied on the upper end of the spindle.




The advantages of the present invention are numerous. Most notably, by creating an apparatus that is configured to optimally control and apply linear downward force onto a wafer, control over polishing pressures utilized in CMP may be significantly improved. Specifically, a force generation assembly may be connected to an upper end of the spindle, and the lower end of the spindle may be connected to a wafer carrier. This structure enables direct linear application of force to a wafer. In this way, the range of consistent force application may be expanded and low force application to the wafer can be enhanced. In addition, the force application apparatus described herein augments wafer carrier stability which even further optimizes wafer processing. Consequently, the force application apparatus enables highly advantageous wafer polishing pressure control and improved wafer processing efficiency.




It is to be understood that the foregoing general description and the following detailed description are exemplary and explanatory only and are not restrictive of the invention, as claimed.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




The accompanying drawings, which are incorporated in and constitute part of this specification, illustrate exemplary embodiments of the invention and together with the description serve to explain the principles of the invention.





FIG. 1A

shows a linear polishing apparatus which is typically utilized in a CMP system.





FIG. 1B

shows a conventional spindle drive assembly that may be utilized to apply the wafer to the polishing belt in the CMP apparatus (as shown above in FIG.


1


A).





FIG. 2A

shows a CMP system according to one embodiment of the present invention.





FIG. 2B

shows the force application assembly in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention.





FIG. 2C

shows a modified force generation assembly with an alternative retracting spring structure in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention.





FIG. 2D

includes a modified force generation assembly in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention.





FIG. 3

shows a block diagram illustrating an operation of the force application assembly in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION




Several exemplary embodiments of the invention will now be described in detail with reference to the accompanying drawings.

FIGS. 1A and 1B

are discussed above in the “Background of the Invention” section. It should be appreciated that although the following embodiments describe an apparatus applying downward force, the following embodiments may be inverted so upward force is applied. In the following description, numerous specific details are set forth in order to provide a thorough understanding of the present invention. It will be understood, however, by one of ordinary skill in the art, that the present invention may be practiced without some or all of these specific details. In other instances, well known process operations have not been described in detail in order not to unnecessarily obscure the present invention.





FIG. 2A

shows a chemical mechanical planarization (CMP) system


100


according to one embodiment of the present invention. A carrier head


106


that is a part of a force application assembly


118


(as shown in

FIG. 2B

) may be used to secure and hold the wafer


104


in place during wafer polishing operations. A polishing belt


102


forms a continuous loop around rotating drums


112




a


and


112




b


. It should be appreciated that the polishing belt


102


may be any suitable type of structure such as, for example, a single layer polishing pad, a polishing pad supported by a stainless steel layer, a multilayer polishing structure (e.g., a polishing pad over a cushioning layer which is in turn over a stainless steel layer). It should also be appreciated that the principles described herein also apply to non-belt CMP devices, e.g., rotary devices. The polishing belt


102


, in one embodiment, is a single layer polyurethane polishing pad utilized in linear CMP systems. The polishing belt


102


generally rotates in a direction indicated by a direction


108


at a speed of about 400 feet per minute. Although, this speed does vary depending upon the specific CMP operation.




As the belt


102


rotates, polishing slurry may be applied and spread over the surface of the polishing belt


102


. The carrier head


106


may then be used to lower the wafer


104


onto the surface of the rotating polishing belt


102


. The force application assembly


118


is discussed in further detail in reference to

FIG. 2B. A

platen


110


may support the polishing belt


102


during the polishing process. The platen


110


may utilize any suitable type of bearing such as an air bearing. In this manner, the surface of the wafer


104


that is desired to be planarized is substantially smoothed in an even manner.




In some cases, the CMP operation is used to planarize materials such as copper (or other metals), and in other cases, it may be used to remove layers of dielectric or combinations of dielectric and copper. The rate of planarization may be changed by adjusting the polishing pressure. The polishing rate is generally proportional to the amount of polishing pressure applied by the carrier head


106


with the wafer


104


to the polishing pad against the platen


110


. By effectively managing the polishing rate, the desired amount of material is removed from the surface of the wafer


104


. When the polishing is complete the carrier head


106


may be used to raise the wafer


104


off of the polishing belt


102


. The wafer


104


is then ready to proceed to a wafer cleaning system. Therefore stable and flexible application of downward force by the carrier head


106


is extremely important for efficient wafer production.





FIG. 2B

shows the force application assembly


118


in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention. In this embodiment, the force application assembly


118


includes the wafer carrier


106


that is coupled to a lower end of a spindle


126


and a force generation assembly


120


connected to the upper end of the spindle


126


. In one embodiment, the wafer carrier


106


is located below the force generation assembly


120


and the spindle


126


in a substantially direct vertical line. It should be understood that the spindle may be any suitable shape that that can couple the force generation assembly


120


to the wafer carrier


106


. In one embodiment, the spindle


126


has a substantially cylindrical shape. The lower end of the spindle


126


is connected to the wafer carrier


106


and the upper end is connected to the force generation assembly


120


. It should be appreciated that the spindle


126


may be any suitable dimension depending on the configuration desired for use within the CMP system


100


.




The force generation assembly


120


as described herein includes components of the force applicator


118


located above the spindle


126


. In one embodiment, the force generation assembly


120


may include components such as a load cell


124


and a bladder


122


and their accompanying structural components. In this embodiment, a bottom surface of a load cell plate


130


connects with the upper end of the spindle


126


. The load cell plate


130


is coupled to springs


135


which in turn is coupled to a bottom surface of a lower plate


132


. The load cell


124


is positioned between the load cell plate


130


and the lower plate


132


. The springs


135


are utilized with rods that serve to pull the lower plate


132


onto the load cell


124


. Therefore, the load cell


124


is mounted on the load cell plate


130


, under constant pressure, as part of the supported weight of the force application assembly


118


. In one embodiment, the load cell


124


detects between about 100 pounds of force to about 150 pounds of force. A top portion of the load cell


124


is coupled to a bottom surface of a lower plate


132


. Springs


134


are attached to the lower plate


132


and a upper plate


136


. The bladder


122


is located between the lower plate


132


and the upper plate


136


. The springs


134


are utilized with rods to retract the lower plate


132


onto the bladder


122


so when air is released from the bladder


122


, the springs


134


retract the lower plate


132


towards the upper plate


136


. A bladder spacer


144


enables maintenance of a minimum space between the upper plate


136


and the lower plate


132


. The structure that includes the upper plate


136


, the lower plate


132


and the bladder


122


is herein referred to as a linear force generator


121


that is disposed at the upper end of the spindle


126


, and the load cell


124


is positioned between the linear force generator


121


and the upper end of the spindle


126


. It should be understood that linear force generator


121


as described herein includes two plates, a bladder, and associated components, but could be any type of suitable device that can provide pressure or force in a controllable manner such as, for example, motors, hydraulic devices, gears, etc. Because the springs


134


and


135


keep a constant retracting pressure on the components within the force generation assembly


120


, once force is applied, the load cell


124


only detects the force of the wafer carrier


106


against the polishing belt.




It should be understood that the bladder


122


may utilize any suitable gas or fluid to apply pressure to the wafer carrier


106


. In one embodiment, clean, dry air is utilized to inflate the bladder


122


. Any references to “air” utilized herein can be substituted with any suitable gas or fluid such as, for example, nitrogen, etc. An air line


138


connects to the bladder


122


through a hole within the upper plate


136


. The air line


138


attaches to a servo valve


140


that manages air input and output to and from the bladder


122


. The air line


138


is also attached to an quick exhaust device


143


which enables a fast release of air. It should be understood that the quick exhaust device


143


may be any suitable air releasing device such as, for example, a solenoid, a quick exhaust valve, etc. The servo valve


140


is connected to an input


144


(into the servo valve) and an output


142


(out of the servo valve). The servo valve


140


may be utilized as a gatekeeper for air input and output from the bladder


122


. Optionally, a servo amplifier comparator


145


may monitor the amount of downward force detected by the load cell


124


that is utilized to control the servo valve


140


to set and/or maintain a certain amount of downward force air bladder applies on the spindle


126


. The servo amplifier comparator


145


and the servo valve


140


may also herein be referred to as a controller. Therefore, the controller may be coupled to the load cell for controlling the force applied by the linear force generator


121


. The operation of monitoring and applying downward force is further described in reference to FIG.


3


.




When air is inputted into the bladder


122


from the servo valve


140


, the bladder


122


increases in volume and expands. When the bladder


122


expands, it presses against the upper plate


136


and the lower plate


132


. In one embodiment, the upper plate


136


may be stabilized so the upper plate


136


does not move when the bladder


122


expands. The lower plate


132


pushes down on the load cell


124


which transmits the downward force to the load cell plate


130


. The load cell plate


130


transmits the downward force directly to the spindle


126


. With use of the downward force, the spindle


126


is moved downward and pushes the wafer carrier


106


with a wafer against a polishing pad for wafer polishing operations. Therefore, in one embodiment, there is a transmission of a direct linear downward force applied from the bladder


122


to the wafer carrier which implements the wafer polishing.




The air pressure within the bladder


122


may be adjusted so that the air bladder applies a desired amount of force on the spindle. When air pressure in the bladder


122


is reduced, the springs


134


(which was expanded when air was inputted into the bladder


122


) retracts thereby reducing force on the lower plate


132


. When this happens the downward force applied to the wafer carrier


106


is reduced thereby reducing polishing pressure applied to a wafer in a CMP process. Because downward force is applied in a direct line without use of a force magnifier, small adjustments applied at the bladder


122


are transmitted in a direct linear manner to the wafer carrier


106


. The force application assembly


118


enables stable application of pressure to the wafer at a greater range than conventional force application devices.





FIG. 2C

shows a modified force generation assembly


120


′ with an alternative retracting spring structure in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention. In this embodiment, the force generation assembly


120


′ has the load cell plate


130


that is connected to an upper end of the spindle


126


. Load cell springs


148


are compression springs located below the load cell plate


130


. The load cell springs


148


are connected with retracting rods which penetrate through the load cell plate


130


and are coupled to a lower plate


132


. Through use of the compression springs


148


, the retracting rods pull the lower plate


132


onto the load cell


124


located between the lower plate


132


and the load cell plate


130


. Retracting springs


146


are located below the lower plate


132


and are connected to retracting rods that penetrate the lower plate


132


and are coupled to the upper plate


136


. Through use of the compression springs


146


, the retracting rods pull the upper plate


136


onto the bladder


122


located between the lower plate


132


and the upper plate


136


. The bladder spacer


144


limits the compressibility of the bladder


122


by introducing a limit to the narrowing of the space between the upper plate


136


and the lower plate


132


.




When the bladder


122


expands, it presses against the upper plate


136


and the lower plate


132


. The lower plate


132


pushes down on the load cell


124


which applies pressure to the load cell plate


130


. The movement of the lower plate


132


downward expands the support springs


146


. The load cell plate


130


transmits pressure generated by the bladder


122


directly to the spindle


126


. The spindle


126


pushes the wafer carrier


106


with a wafer against a polishing pad for wafer polishing operations.




When the bladder


122


contracts, force applied to the upper plate


136


and the lower plate


136


is reduced so the springs


146


contract. When this occurs, the downward pressure the bladder


122


is applying is reduced which in turn reduces the downward force the spindle


126


applies to the wafer carrier


106


. The reduction of pressure on the wafer carrier


106


therefore reduces polishing pressure applied to a wafer in a CMP process. Because downward force is applied in a direct line without use of a force magnifier, small adjustments applied at the bladder


122


are transmitted directly to the wafer carrier


106


. The force application assembly enables stable application of pressure to the wafer at a greater range than conventional force application devices.





FIG. 2D

includes a modified force generation assembly


120


″ in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention. In this embodiment, the force generation assembly


120


″ has a structure and function of the force generation assembly


120


′ but has a retract flag


162


that penetrates the upper plate


136


to be coupled with the lower plate


132


. The retract flag


162


may notify a pressure control system that the mechanism is retracted. A sensor located above the retract flag senses the position of the retract flag


162


and trips to indicate full retraction of the lower plate


132


. In addition, the force generation assembly


120


″ includes a load cell amplifier output


164


which enables the servo amplifier comparator to receive an amplified load cell signal. A rotary union


126




a


may optionally be attached to the spindle


126


. The rotary union


126




a


enables the spindle


126


to spin and in one embodiment allows transfer of air and/or vacuum to the carrier head. It should be understood that spindle


126


as described in the embodiments herein (as described in reference to

FIGS. 2B through 3

) may optionally include the rotary union


126




a.







FIG. 3

shows a block diagram


200


illustrating an operation of the force application assembly


118


in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention. In diagram


200


, when air is inputted into the air bladder


122


, the bladder


122


expands and pushes down on the loadcell


124


. The loadcell


124


detects the force applied by the bladder


122


and sends a force measurement signal through the loadcell amplifier


164


to the servo amplifier comparator


145


indicating an amount of linear downward force detected at the loadcell


124


. The signal from the loadcell


124


is low voltage so the loadcell amplifier


164


amplifies the force measurement signal. The servo amplifier comparator


145


receives the signal from the loadcell


124


, which in one embodiment is an analog voltage, and utilizes a close loop monitoring of the pressure detected at the loadcell


124


. The servo amplifier comparator


145


monitors signals from the load cell


124


. Therefore, the servo amplifier


124


may receive the signal regarding the amount of linear downward force detected by the loadcell and compare that force with a force setpoint


202


(which in one embodiment is an analog voltage) and, by managing the servo valve


140


, regulate the amount of linear downward force. In, one embodiment, the servo amplifier comparator instructs the servo valve


140


(by transmitting a signal) to channel air into the bladder


122


if the detected amount of linear downward force is below the force setpoint


202


and instructs the servo valve to release air from the air bladder when the detected downward force is higher than the force setpoint


202


. An air line into the servo valve


140


may include air pressure to enable channeling of air to the bladder


122


. A valve exhaust


206


is optionally attached to the system


200


which enables quicker removal of air from the air bladder


122


.




In summary, the apparatus enables application of linear downward force onto a wafer carrier with a wafer thereby optimizing the ability to apply downward force for wafer polishing operations. In addition, the downward force is applied in a direct line so small adjustments applied at the bladder are transmitted directly to the wafer carrier.




The invention has been described herein in terms of several exemplary embodiments. Other embodiments of the invention will be apparent to those skilled in the art from consideration of the specification and practice of the invention. The embodiments and preferred features described above should be considered exemplary, with the invention being defined by the appended claims.



Claims
  • 1. An apparatus for applying a wafer to a polishing surface during a chemical mechanical planarization (CMP) operation, comprising:a spindle having an upper end and a lower end; a wafer carrier coupled to the lower end of the spindle; a linear force generator disposed at the upper end of the spindle having a bladder; a load cell positioned between the linear force generator and the upper end of the spindle; and a controller coupled to the load cell for controlling the force applied by the linear force generator.
  • 2. An apparatus for applying a wafer to a polishing surface during a CMP operation as recited in claim 1, wherein the linear force generator includes:a lower plate disposed on the load cell; an upper plate disposed above the lower plate; and the bladder positioned between the lower plate and the upper plate.
  • 3. An apparatus for applying a wafer to a polishing surface during a CMP operation as recited in claim 2, wherein the controller includes:a servo amplifier comparator that monitors signals from the load cell; and a servo valve that channels air into and releases air from the bladder.
  • 4. An apparatus for applying a wafer to a polishing surface during a CMP operation as recited in claim 1, wherein a load cell plate is disposed on the upper end of the spindle, and the load cell is mounted on the load cell plate.
  • 5. An apparatus for applying a wafer to a polishing surface during a chemical mechanical planarization (CMP) operation, comprising:a spindle having an upper end and a lower end; a wafer carrier coupled to the lower end of the spindle; a load cell plate coupled to the upper end of the spindle; a load cell disposed on the load cell plate; a lower plate disposed on the load cell; an upper plate supported above the lower plate; and a bladder positioned between the lower plate and the upper plate.
  • 6. An apparatus for applying a wafer to a polishing surface during a CMP operation as recited in claim 5, further comprising:a servo amplifier comparator that monitors signals from the load cell.
  • 7. An apparatus for applying a wafer to a polishing surface during a CMP operation as recited in claim 6, further comprising:a servo valve that channels fluid to and releases fluid from the bladder.
  • 8. An apparatus for applying a wafer to a polishing surface during a CMP operation as recited in claim 7, wherein the servo amplifier comparator and the servo valve controls a force applied by the bladder.
  • 9. An apparatus for applying a wafer to a polishing surface during a chemical mechanical planarization (CMP) operation, comprising:a spindle having an upper end and a lower end; a wafer carrier coupled to the lower end of the spindle; a linear force generator disposed at the upper end of the spindle having a motor capable of providing force in a controllable manner; a load cell positioned between the linear force generator and the upper end of the spindle; and a controller coupled to the load cell for controlling the force applied by the linear force generator.
  • 10. An apparatus for applying a wafer to a polishing surface during a chemical mechanical planarization (CMP) operation, comprising:a spindle having an upper end and a lower end; a wafer carrier coupled to the lower end of the spindle; a linear force generator disposed at the upper end of the spindle having a hydraulic device capable of providing force in a controllable manner; a load cell positioned between the linear force generator and the upper end of the spindle; and a controller coupled to the load cell for controlling the force applied by the linear force generator.
US Referenced Citations (5)
Number Name Date Kind
5613901 Weber et al. Mar 1997 A
5762536 Pant et al. Jun 1998 A
5916009 Izumi et al. Jun 1999 A
6358114 Walker et al. Mar 2002 B1
6439978 Jones et al. Aug 2002 B1