Disclosed herein is an on-line inspection process and apparatus for detection of oil and/or grease (lubricant) contamination on tobacco, tobacco products, food pharmaceuticals, packaging, and other consumer goods and products, and a light wavelength converting material for taggant applications and quantitative diagnostics.
In the processing and packaging of consumer products and products designed to provide tobacco enjoyment, oils, greases and lubricants may inadvertently come into contact with the product being produced.
In the case of products designed to provide tobacco enjoyment, tobacco leaf is processed prior to the time that it is provided as final product. For example, leaf may be contacted by machinery during harvesting, curing and transport to a stemmery. When leaf is provided in strip form at a stemmery, and cut or otherwise shredded to the desired size, it is possible for oils, greases and lubricants to inadvertently come into contact with the tobacco. Likewise, lubricants used in operating the various machines used in the processing of the tobacco can come inadvertently into contact with that tobacco. The sources of lubricant contamination can vary, such as when a particular piece of machinery or component of that piece of machinery fails to operate in an optimum fashion.
Lubricants may inadvertently come into contact with tobacco due to leakage of lubricants through gaskets or seals, from sliding mechanisms, from drum systems, from gear boxes, from pumps, from sealed rolling bearing units, from chains and belts, and the like. Lubricants are used in conditioning cylinders, threshers, separators, redryers, receivers, feeders, conveyors, cutters, blenders, tobacco presses and other such pieces of equipment that are commonly used in tobacco stemmeries, and in tobacco primary processing operations.
Lubricants of similar compositions are used throughout the various stages of tobacco treatment and cigarette manufacture. Heretofore, it has been difficult for the cigarette manufacturer to detect the presence of oil in its tobacco and/or its cigarettes and to locate the source of a particular lubricant once it has been detected.
It would be advantageous if the inspection of tobacco and tobacco products for the presence of a lubricant or the like could be conducted on-line, that is, in real time during the production process, with the capability to identify the source, once it has been detected.
In one aspect, disclosed is a process for detecting oil or lubricant contamination in a manufactured product, the process comprising adding a fluorescent taggant to oils or lubricants contained in processing machinery for said product; conveying said product past an infrared detection apparatus; irradiating said product with infrared radiation from said detection apparatus as it passes the detection apparatus; and detecting infrared radiation emitted from said irradiated product.
In another aspect, disclosed is a process for detecting oil or lubricant contamination in a tobacco product, the process comprising adding a fluorescent taggant to oils or lubricants contained in tobacco processing machinery; conveying tobacco product past an infrared detection apparatus; irradiating said tobacco product with infrared radiation of a first wavelength from said detection apparatus as it passes the detection apparatus; and detecting infrared radiation emitted from said irradiated tobacco product.
In yet another aspect, disclosed is a system for localization of oil contamination, comprising a tipping machine for tobacco rods having an infrared detection apparatus comprising a high intensity infrared light source directed at tobacco rods and a high speed NIR spectrometer sensor tuned to detect an of a second wavelength emitted signal from an Indocyanine Green (ICG) complex disposed in said oil.
In a further aspect, disclosed is a process for detecting lubricant contamination in a product produced by a manufacturing operation and/or processing operation. The process includes adding a first taggant to a lubricant of a first machine of the operation, adding a second taggant to a lubricant of a second machine of the operation, and irradiating the product and detecting radiation emitted from the product responsive thereto, the detecting step including distinguishing the first taggant from the second taggant so as to discern the source of lubricant contamination.
The irradiated product absorbs the original radiation and re-emits radiation of a different wavelength than the original radiation, which then may be detected as disclosed herein.
The forms disclosed herein are illustrated by way of example, and not by way of limitation, in the figures of the accompanying drawings and in which like reference numerals refer to similar elements and in which:
Various aspects will now be described with reference to specific forms selected for purposes of illustration. It will be appreciated that the spirit and scope of the apparatus, system and methods disclosed herein are not limited to the selected forms. Moreover, it is to be noted that the figures provided herein are not drawn to any particular proportion or scale, and that many variations can be made to the illustrated forms. Reference is now made to
Each of the following terms written in singular grammatical form: “a,” “an,” and “the,” as used herein, may also refer to, and encompass, a plurality of the stated entity or object, unless otherwise specifically defined or stated herein, or, unless the context clearly dictates otherwise. For example, the phrases “a device,” “an assembly,” “a mechanism,” “a component,” and “an element,” as used herein, may also refer to, and encompass, a plurality of devices, a plurality of assemblies, a plurality of mechanisms, a plurality of components, and a plurality of elements, respectively.
Each of the following terms: “includes,” “including,” “has,” “‘having,” “comprises,” and “comprising,” and, their linguistic or grammatical variants, derivatives, and/or conjugates, as used herein, means “including, but not limited to.”
Throughout the illustrative description, the examples, and the appended claims, a numerical value of a parameter, feature, object, or dimension, may be stated or described in terms of a numerical range format. It is to be fully understood that the stated numerical range format is provided for illustrating implementation of the forms disclosed herein, and is not to be understood or construed as inflexibly limiting the scope of the forms disclosed herein.
Moreover, for stating or describing a numerical range, the phrase “in a range of between about a first numerical value and about a second numerical value,” is considered equivalent to, and means the same as, the phrase “in a range of from about a first numerical value to about a second numerical value,” and, thus, the two equivalently meaning phrases may be used interchangeably.
It is to be understood that the various forms disclosed herein are not limited in their application to the details of the order or sequence, and number, of steps or procedures, and sub-steps or sub-procedures, of operation or implementation of forms of the method or to the details of type, composition, construction, arrangement, order and number of the system, system sub-units, devices, assemblies, sub-assemblies, mechanisms, structures, components, elements, and configurations, and, peripheral equipment, utilities, accessories, and materials of forms of the system, set forth in the following illustrative description, accompanying drawings, and examples, unless otherwise specifically stated herein. The apparatus, systems and methods disclosed herein can be practiced or implemented according to various other alternative forms and in various other alternative ways.
It is also to be understood that all technical and scientific words, terms, and/or phrases, used herein throughout the present disclosure have either the identical or similar meaning as commonly understood by one of ordinary skill in the art, unless otherwise specifically defined or stated herein. Phraseology, terminology, and, notation, employed herein throughout the present disclosure are for the purpose of description and should not be regarded as limiting.
Disclosed herein are new oil soluble, light wavelength-converting, preferably upconverting, compositions for taggant applications and quantitative diagnostics in connection with lubricants, such as by way of non-limiting example, the detection of errant lubricants on product that comes into contact with lubricated machinery. Other taggant applications are contemplated, including, but not limited to, anti-counterfeiting, brand protection, or verification that a machine contains a correct lubricant, and other possible applications. A detection system enables the development of near real time, low cost, compact, portable and highly sensitive detection, monitoring and diagnostics of modifications to manufacturing process systems in real world environments. It is the unique process (e.g. the conversion of visible light to infrared light, infrared to visible light and the up-conversion of infrared to higher energy infrared) that enables high sensitivity detection against almost any sample or environmental background.
Using the system, theoretical particle detection (10−23 mol) of molecules added to analytic mixtures can be achieved through the use of on-line verification methods and even handheld detection applications. Detection sensitivity of 10−20 mol is possible in a variety of detection schemes, and even direct visual detection of 10−14 mol sensitivity has been demonstrated using a hand held 3.0 to 9.0 volt laser diode system against backgrounds of various colors and compositions. The narrow emission bandwidths and small particle size of these materials enable the simultaneous detection of multiple analytes (i.e. multiplexed assays).
In one form, the detection system disclose herein can be used in many processes and for consumer products which are susceptible to lubricant contamination during the manufacturing process, such as for example in the growing, collection, processing and/or packaging of packaged consumer goods, such as food products, beverages, tipped and non-tipped cigars, cigarillos, snus and other smokeless tobacco products, smoking articles, electronic cigarettes, distilled products, pharmaceuticals, frozen foods and other comestibles, and the like. Further applications could include clothing, furniture, lumber or any other manufactured or packaged product wherein an absence of oil is desired.
According to the present invention, a detectable taggant compound is added to the various lubricants used in manufacturing and processing machinery, and advantageously taggant compounds having different characteristics are added into the lubricants at different processing locations, such that detection of one or more of these taggant compounds can enable rapid identification of the location of the source of lubricant contamination in the manufactured product.
Advantageously, the taggant compound is one which is detectable by fluorescence when it is exposed to particular wavelengths of light. In particular, a suitable taggant is one which absorbs energy at one wavelength and fluoresces/emits at a different wavelength. Such materials are well-known in the art as Stokes-shifting materials, and have recently found increasing use in inks for security marking of documents, such as banknotes and the like, to render such documents less susceptible to counterfeiting or copying. However, some conventional Stokes-shifting and anti-Stokes conversion materials are composed of inorganic compounds, such as doped rare earth metal particles, such as those described in U.S. Published Patent Application No. 2010/0219377, which are insoluble in lubricants. It would be advantageous if taggant compounds could be formulated to be soluble or dispersible in oils or lubricants.
In one form, the taggant may be an organic compound comprised of purified crystals from naturally occurring chlorophyll. Suitable naturally-occurring chlorophyll crystals include Chlorophyll A (CAS number 1406-65-1) and Chlorophyll B (CAS number 519-62-0). These taggants are known as being down-converting or fluorescent, and are sensitive to a particular narrow wavelength of IR light (680 nanometers). The taggant emits back this particular of light at a different wavelength (715 nanometers). A similar compound may be a benze-indolium perchlorate or a benze-indolium tosolyate. Such materials absorb around 670 nanometers and emit at a wavelength of 713 nanometers. Another material with down-conversion properties is Indocyanine Green (ICG). The chemical structure for Chlorophyll A is provided below.
Since this compound is an organic chemical, it is readily dissolved in oils and lubricants.
In another form, an oil-soluble fluorescent material has been developed based on Indocyanine Green (ICG), the chemical structure of which is provided below.
ICG is sodium 4-[2-[(1E,3E,5E,7Z)-7-[1,1-dimethyl-3-(4-sulfonatobutyl)-benzo[e]indol-2-ylidene]hepta-1,3,5-trienyl]-1,1-dimethyl-benzo[e]indol-3-ium-3-yl]butane-1-sulfonate, an infrared fluorescing compound currently used in the medical industry for imaging cells and blood flows in the human body, which in its conventional form is water-soluble.
The newly developed taggant is an ICG-complex available from Persis Science LLC, Andreas Pa. The chemical structure for a tetrabutylammonium chloride complexation of ICG is provided below and analytical structural information is provided in
The new ICG-complex is sensitive to a particular narrow absorption band of IR light between about 760 to about 810 nanometers (
The ICG complex can be added to oils or lubricants in the amounts of approximately 1 ppb to 5%, preferably a range of 1 ppm to 2000 ppm, based on the weight of the lubricant.
Additionally, the nature of the ICG complexing agent can be modified to impart one or more secondary NIR emission wavelengths adjacent to the major emission peak at 840 nanometers. By utilizing such variations in the complexing agent, and adding differently complexed ICG compounds in lubricants at differing locations in the overall process, a single detector can be located at the end of the process, and when contamination is detected, the contaminated product can be removed from the process and further analyzed for the secondary NIR emission peaks, to determine the location of the source of contamination.
In one form, the detection system of the present invention can be used in many processes and for consumer products which are susceptible to lubricant contamination during the manufacturing process, such as for example in the growing, collection, processing and/or packaging of packaged consumer goods, such as food products, beverages, tipped and non-tipped cigars, cigarillos, snus and other smokeless tobacco products, smoking articles, electronic cigarettes, distilled products, pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, foods and other consumer goods, and the like. Further applications could include clothing, furniture, finished wood or lumber or any other manufactured or packaged product wherein an absence of oil spotting is desired.
In one form, the detection system utilizes near-infrared (NIR) emission, wherein a high intensity IR light source is directed at tobacco products and emitted IR light from the taggant is gathered and analyzed using a high speed NIR spectrometer sensor tuned to detect the emission signal from the particular taggant added to the oil. Adequate measures are made to prevent the detector from being able to see the excitation wavelength. This is done through the use of proper filters placed over the detectors. The light from the laser is pulsed at a frequency of about 800 Hz and the detector is inversely pulsed to detect the taggant. NIR light can penetrate into various materials, such as tobacco rods, to a depth of several millimeters, even enabling subsurface inspection of finished cigarettes. The high speed NIR sensor can detect tagged oils/lubricants at speeds of over about 2,000 feet per minute or 4,000 feet per minute or more. In the production of cigarettes, the high speed NIR sensor can detect tagged oils/lubricants of finished cigarettes at a rate of 15,000 per minute (about 4,920 feet per minute), or even at a rate of 20,000 per minute (about 6,560 feet per minute).
The high-speed detector comprises an IR laser diode that is used to excite the taggant at its “absorption” frequency and a sensor that is tuned to receive light at the taggant's “emission” frequency. If the sensor detects the presence of the taggant, it can change the state of its output contacts. These output contacts can be used to stop the manufacturing equipment and set an alarm and/or to reject the oil contaminated product.
The taggant can be added to process machinery lubricants at concentrations between about 10 ppm and 100 ppm, typically at a concentration of about 50 ppm, based on the weight of the oil/lubricant. At these taggant concentration levels the detection system can detect as little as 10 microliters of oil, or even as little as 1 microliter of tagged oil.
However, in order to provide for easier treatment of oils or lubricants already in place within various machines, it can be more convenient to formulate a master batch of the taggant in any particular oil, wherein the taggant is mixed at higher concentrations in the base oil/lubricant, such as from about 0.1 to about 5 wt % taggant, or even from about 0.2 to about 2 wt % taggant, in a balance of the base oil/lubricant. A portion of such tagged master batch is then easily transported and added to oils/lubricants which are already in place in the machines to be treated, for example by adding a small amount of the tagged master batch to the oil sump of the machine.
When the taggant is not an oil-soluble taggant, such as when it is an inorganic particle, an optional surfactant or dispersant additive can be added in an amount effective to facilitate dispersion of the taggant particles in the base oil. Such surfactants/dispersants are well-known in the art and their identities need not be repeated herein.
The NIR emission detectors can be placed virtually anywhere along the process, such that a signal received by a detector at a known location will indicate oil contamination in the processed material almost immediately, readily indicating the location of the source of contamination directly upstream of the detector.
In an alternative form, the nature of the ICG complexing agent can be modified to impart one or more secondary NIR emission wavelengths adjacent to the major wavelength peak at 840 nanometers. By utilizing such variations in the complexing agent, and adding differently complexed ICG compounds in lubricants at differing locations in the overall process, a single detector can be located at the end of the process, and when contamination is detected, the contaminated product can be removed from the process and further analyzed for the secondary NIR emission peaks, to determine the location of the source of contamination.
Referring now to
As may be appreciated from the above description, in tobacco processing, tobacco comes into contact with machinery at many different points in the overall process, such as machinery used during the growing and harvesting operations on the farm, handling equipment at the receiving station or auction house, machinery in the stemmery, on conveyors, conditioners, cutters and silos in the primary manufacturing centers, and ultimately on makers, tippers and packers in the make/pack manufacturing centers. By utilizing a different taggant in the lubricants of the machinery at each of these locations, the discrete source and/or location of contamination can be readily determined by inspection/detection of the finished product.
In
A magazine or hopper 104 at the top of the frame of the filter tipping machine contains a supply of filter rod sections of six times unit length. The outlet of the magazine 104 admits discrete filter rod sections of six times unit length into successive axially parallel peripheral flutes of a rotary drum-shaped severing conveyor 106. The latter cooperates with two axially and circumferentially staggered rotary circular knives 107 which subdivide each oncoming filter rod section of six times unit length into groups of three coaxial filter rod sections of double unit length each.
Successive groups are delivered into the flutes of a composite rotary drum-shaped staggering conveyor 108 which moves at least two filter rod sections of each group relative to each other and relative to the third filter rod section in a circumferential direction and transfers successive filter rod sections of double unit length into successive flutes of a rotary drum-shaped shuffling conveyor 109. The latter cooperates with suitable cams or the like (not shown) to form a single row of aligned filter rod sections which are advanced sideways into successive flutes of a rotary drum-shaped combined accelerating and inserting conveyor 111. The conveyor 111 inserts discrete filter rod sections of double unit length into the aforementioned clearances between successive pairs of plain cigarettes in the oncoming flutes of the assembly conveyor 103 so that each such flute of the conveyor 103 which has advanced beyond the transfer station between the conveyors 103 and 111 contains a group of three coaxial rod-shaped articles including two axially spaced-apart tobacco rods of unit length and a filter rod section of double unit length between them. Successive groups are caused to advance between two cams or the like (not shown) which cause the tobacco rods to move axially toward each other so that their inner ends abut the respective ends of the filter rod section between them. The thus condensed or shortened groups are transferred into successive flutes of a rotary drum-shaped transfer conveyor 112.
The frame of the filter tipping machine further supports an expiring reel 114 for a supply of an elongated web or strip 113 which is convoluted onto the core of the reel 114. The web 113 is advanced lengthwise by rollers 116 which cause it to advance over the pronounced edge of a conventional curling tool 117, and a rotary drum-shaped suction conveyor 119 thereupon causes the web 113 to advance into and beyond a paster 118 serving to coat one side of the web with a film of a suitable adhesive. The adhesive-coated leader of the web 113 is severed at requisite intervals at the periphery of the suction conveyor 119 to yield a succession of adhesive coated discrete portions or uniting bands which are attached to successive groups of rod-shaped articles in the flutes of the transfer conveyor 112. Each uniting band extends along and slightly beyond both axial ends of the respective filter rod section of double unit length.
Successive groups of rod-shaped articles (each such group carries a uniting band) are transferred onto a drum-shaped rolling or wrapping conveyor 122 which cooperates with a normally stationary rolling member 123 to convolute the uniting bands around the respective filter rod sections and around the adjacent inner ends of the respective pairs of plain cigarettes C of unit length. The thus obtained filter cigarettes C of double unit length are delivered into the flutes of a rotary drum-shaped adhesive drying or setting conveyor 124 which, in turn, delivers successive filter cigarettes C of double unit length into the peripheral flutes of a rotary drum-shaped subdividing conveyor 126 cooperating with a circular knife to sever each filter cigarette C of double unit length midway across the tubular wrapper (converted or rolled uniting band) so that a conveyor 127 of a turn-around device 129 receives pairs of coaxial filter cigarettes C of unit length. The device 129 inverts one filter cigarette C of each pair end-for-end so that the single-length filter mouthpieces of all filter cigarettes C face in the same direction not later than on a further conveyor 128 of the turn-round device 129 and the inverted and non-inverted filter cigarettes C form a single row of parallel cigarettes C which are caused to move sideways.
The conveyor 128 delivers successive filter cigarettes C of the single row into successive flutes of at least one inspection drum 131 which is followed by a combined testing and reject drum 132. As may be appreciated, the present invention contemplates the case in which each flute of an inspection drum of a tipping machine receives two cigarettes. Any reference herein to a flute of an inspection drum receiving a single cigarette is meant to cover such a case as well. The inspection drum 131 can advance successive filter cigarettes C of unit length past one or more NIR testing devices 140 each which irradiates cigarettes C with IR radiation having a wavelength of about 805 nm, and detects reflected IR radiation at wavelengths at or about 840 nm (in the case where the taggant is an ICG complex). As is conventional, inspection drum 131 may also be employed to detect loose ends, air leaks around filter tips, etc. The reject drum 132 receives a signal from and cooperates with control device 140 to eject those filter cigarettes C which are detected to contain one or more of the taggants according to the present invention. A take-off conveyor (e.g., an endless belt or chain conveyor having an endless flexible element 136 trained over several pulleys, sheaves or sprocket wheels 134 of which only one is actually shown in
In one form, when the NIR detection device detects the presence of the taggant primary emission peak, the identified cigarette is rejected and ejected from the system. Subsequent to ejection, the cigarette can be re-analyzed with another NIR detection device which can identify the secondary wavelength peaks from any of the variety of differently-complexed ICG taggants, so as to determine the source of lubricant contamination throughout the system.
In another form, a process for detecting oil or lubricant contamination in a manufactured product produced from raw materials is provided. The process includes the steps of adding a first taggant to an oil or lubricant of a machine for preparing raw materials for a manufacturing operation, adding a second taggant to an oil or lubricant of a machine used in a manufacturing operation for manufacturing the product, conveying the product past a detection apparatus adapted to distinguish the first taggant from the second taggant so as to discern the source of oil or lubricant contamination (i.e., whether the source of oil is from production of a raw (or direct) material or from the production of the final product of which the raw material is a part). In one form, for example and not by way of limitation, the first taggant is added to the oil or lubricant of a machine for preparing raw materials for shipping. Further, for example and not by way of limitation, the second taggant may be added to the oil or lubricant of a packaging machine. The product may be irradiated with infrared radiation from the detection apparatus as it passes the detection apparatus and infrared radiation emitted detected from the irradiated product. It is envisioned that if a plurality of machines are involved to produce a raw material, then a plurality of taggants would be utilized individually as to each of them. Likewise, if a plurality of machines is involved to produce the final product, then a plurality of taggants would also be utilized individually as to each of them.
Specific forms will now be described further by way of example. While the following examples demonstrate certain forms of the subject matter disclosed herein, they are not to be interpreted as limiting the scope thereof, but rather as contributing to a complete description.
500 mg of complexed ICG (Product No. OT-1013, available from Persis Science LLC of Andreas Pa.) is dispersed into 1.0 kg of Klüberoil 68 using a speedmixer. Klüberoil 68 is available from Klüber Lubrication North America L.P., Londonderry, N.H. The material is mixed for 10.0 minutes at a speed of 2100 RPM. The resulting concentrate is slowly added to an additional 100.0 kg of Kluberoil 68 while stirring under high speed dispersion. A sample of the material is placed into a Shimadzu 5301 Fluorometer and the excitation and emission spectrographs are recorded. When excited at a wavelength of 785, a strong infrared emission is noted from 810 nanometers to 960 nanometers. See
The above example is modified slightly using a tetrabutylammonium bromide complexation of an Infrared dye available, IR830 available from Sigma-Aldrich of St. Louis, Mo. After mixing, it is noted that the material will produce fluorescence around 833 nanometers when excited with approximately 0.5 mW of 785 light.
Upconverting nanoparticles, MED C-19 (Yb2O3:Er3+), were obtained from Persis Science, LLC in a slurry format in DMSO. The DMSO was dialyzed from the aqueous phase leaving the particles in aqueous phase. The particles were dried and dispersed into Kluberoil 68 using a Speedmixer. The dispersion was measured optically using a Spex Fluorolog-3. The oil suspension was excited at 970 nm and the detection occurred in the visible from 400 to 700 nm to determine the presence of the tagged oil.
0.5 wt % of a europium chelate, available from Honeywell Corporation under the trade name of CD-335, was incorporated into 99.5 wt % of Lubriplate 220 oil using a horizontal media mill. Adequate detection was achieved using UV LED's at a wavelength of 363 nm and an APD detector with a 600 nm-700 nm notch filter.
1.0 wt % of an infrared absorbing dithiolene dye commercially available from Epolin, Inc—358 Adams St. Newark N.J. 07105, was dissolved via mixing with 99 parts of Kluber Oil 220 under nitrogen with a stir bar for 5 hours. The resulting mixture was analyzed for infrared absorption. The absorption occurred from 800 nm to 1200 nm with a peak at around 1060 nm. The detection was achieved by contrast imaging with a Cognex In-Sight vision system and using a Monster LED light system with a wavelength of 850 nm. A Midwest optical filter 850 bandpass was used to isolate the absorption.
As may be appreciated, other tobacco- and non-tobacco-related consumer product applications can benefit from the invention disclosed herein. Contemplated tobacco-related applications include cigars, cigarillos, MST, pouched tobacco products. dry snuff, chewing tobacco and snus. The taggants disclosed herein may be applied in accordance with these teachings to various machines and machine modules that execute various manufacturing operations at points along the manufacturing process of interest. The systems and methods disclosed herein can be modified for compatibility with such applications.
While the present invention has been described and illustrated by reference to particular forms, those of ordinary skill in the art will appreciate that the invention lends itself to variations not necessarily illustrated herein. For this reason, then, reference should be made solely to the appended claims for purposes of determining the true scope of the present invention.
This patent application is a Continuation of U.S. Ser. No. 14/994,972 filed on Jan. 13, 2016, (Attorney Docket No. 400276-20090), which is a Divisional of U.S. Ser. No. 13/482,771, filed on May 29, 2012, now U.S. Pat. No. 9,244,017 (Attorney Docket 400276-20009), which is a continuation-in-part of U.S. Ser. No. 13/338,971, filed on Dec. 28, 2011, now U.S. Pat. No. 9,080,987 (Attorney Docket 16083), and claims priority to U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 61/490,403, filed on May 26, 2011, (Attorney Docket 15785), the contents of each are hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 13482771 | May 2012 | US |
Child | 14994972 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 14994972 | Jan 2016 | US |
Child | 15653377 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 13338971 | Dec 2011 | US |
Child | 13482771 | US |