The present invention relates to the technical field of separator elements for separating a fluid medium for treatment into a filtrate and a retentate, which elements are commonly referred to as filter membranes.
More precisely, the invention relates to new porous substrate shapes enabling the area of the filter surface of the separator elements to be increased.
Separation methods using membranes are used in numerous sectors, in particular in the environment for producing potable water and treating industrial effluents, in the chemical, petrochemical, pharmaceutical, and agrifood industries, and in the field of biotechnology.
A membrane constitutes a selective barrier and, under the action of a transfer force, it enables certain components of the medium for treatment to pass through or to be stopped. Whether components pass through or are stopped is the result of their size compared with the size of the pores in the membrane, which then behaves as a filter. Depending on the size of the pores, these techniques are referred to as microfiltration, ultrafiltration, or nanofiltration.
There exist membranes of various structures and textures. In general, membranes are constituted by a porous substrate that provides the membrane with mechanical strength and that also gives it a shape, and thus determines the filter surface of the membrane. One or more layers having a thickness of a few micrometers for performing separation are deposited on the substrate, which layers can be referred to as separator layers, filter layers, separation layers, or active layers. During separation, the filtered fluid is transferred through the separator layer and the fluid then spreads out in the porous texture of the substrate in order to go towards the outside surface of the porous substrate. This portion of the fluid for treatment that has passed through the separator layer and the porous substrate is referred to as the permeate or the filtrate and it is recovered by a collector chamber surrounding the membrane. The other portion is referred to as the retentate and it is usually reinjected into the fluid for treatment upstream from the membrane via a recirculation loop.
In conventional manner, the substrate is initially fabricated with the desired shape by extrusion, and then sintered at a temperature and for a length of time that are sufficient to achieve the required strength, while nevertheless conserving in the resulting ceramic the desired open and interconnected texture of pores. That method makes it necessary to obtain one or more rectilinear channels within which the separator layers are subsequently deposited and sintered. The substrates are conventionally tubular in shape and have one or more rectilinear channels arranged in parallel with the central axis of the substrate. In patent EP 0 778 073, the inside surfaces of the channels are smooth and they do not present any irregularities, whereas in patent GB 2 223 690, the channels present a star-shaped profile. In patent application WO 96/28241, the channel presents a helical shape.
Since the inside volume of the substrate is defined and limited by its outside dimensions and since the area of the filter surface is proportional to the number of channels, it has been found that the areas of the filter surfaces of filter membranes fabricated using substrates having such shapes come up against a ceiling and, as a result, present performance that is limited in terms of flow rate.
The principle of all tangential separation making use of filter elements lies in selective transfer, which is of effectiveness that depends on the selectivity of the membrane (the active layer) and on the permeability (flux) of the filter element in question as a whole (substrate plus active layer).
In addition to the above-described effectiveness of the selective transfer, the performance of a filter element is directly proportional to the area of the filter surface involved.
The ratio S/V where S is the area of the exchange surface of the membrane and V is the volume of the separator element can be used to characterize the compactness of a membrane:
Historically and in chronological order, single-channel cylindrical tubular separator elements were the first to appear on the market, followed by multichannel tubular separator elements.
In addition to increasing the total area of the filter surface, one of the advantages of multichannel separator elements lies in obtaining channels of small hydraulic diameter without any risk of fragility for the separator elements, however the initial multichannel separator elements had channels that were exclusively of circular right section.
The following generation abandoned circular channels in order to better occupy the internal volume of the tube, to increase compactness, and to increase the possibilities of turbulence.
Thus, by way of example, a membrane having an outside diameter of 25 millimeters (mm) and a length of 1178 mm develops a filter surface having an area of 0.155 square meters (m2) when it possesses seven circular channels, each having a hydraulic diameter of 6 mm, and it develops a substrate surface having an area of 0.195 m2 when it possesses eight non-circular channels, likewise having a hydraulic diameter of 6 mm.
Compactness calculations for those two membranes give the following results:
It can be seen from these two examples that for given hydraulic diameter and for separator elements that are identical in shape and outside dimensions, going from channels of circular section to channels of non-circular section makes it possible to increase the value of the compactness by 25%.
The table in
The dimensioning of the channels inside a separator element obtained by extrusion is thus limited, not only by considerations involving mechanical strength and the flux of filtrate in the pores of the porous substrate, but also by friction forces that generate a risk of tearing and/or cracking between the ceramic paste and the die.
The compactness of separator elements obtained by extrusion thus tends towards an upper limit, and the present invention proposes remedying the drawbacks of prior solutions by providing novel separator elements for which, firstly the spaces reserved for the internal flow of the fluid for treatment form interconnected three-dimensional structures creating surfaces within said separator elements that are suitable for increasing the compactness as expressed by the above-described ratio S/V, and for which, secondly the thicknesses of the skeleton-forming structural elements can be of the order of several tenths of a millimeter.
In order to achieve these objects, the separator element is a single-piece separator element for separating a fluid medium for treatment into a filtrate and a retentate, said separator element comprising a porous rigid single-piece substrate made out of a single material and presenting firstly, at its periphery, a perimeter wall that is continuous between an inlet for the fluid medium for treatment at one end of the porous substrate and an outlet for the retentate at the other end of the porous substrate, and secondly, internally, at least one surface covered by at least one separator layer and defining an open structure made up of empty spaces for passing a flow of the fluid medium for treatment in order to recover at the periphery of the porous substrate a filtrate that has passed through the separator layer and the porous substrate.
According to the invention, the empty spaces for passing the fluid medium for treatment that are defined by the surface of the substrate covered by the separator layer are arranged in the porous substrate so as to create within the porous substrate at least a first flow network for the fluid medium for treatment, the network comprising at least two interconnected flow circuits for the fluid medium for treatment between the inlet and the outlet of the porous substrate.
In the context of the invention, the novel separator elements possess internal shapes that are modulated in such a manner that it is possible to increase the total area of the filter surface of the novel separator elements designed in this way up to compactness values of 2000 square meters per cubic meter (m2/m3) or more, with this being done firstly by establishing communication between empty spaces within a given element of shapes and dimensions that can be varied, and secondly by increasing the number of flow circuits that are formed in this way.
The separator element of the invention further includes in combination one and/or more of the following additional characteristics:
The following description given with reference to the accompanying figures enables the invention to be understood better.
As a preliminary point, definitions are given of some of the terms used in the context of the invention. The term “mean pore diameter” is used to mean the d50 value of a volume distribution at which 50% of the total volume of the pores corresponds to the volume of pores having a diameter less than this d50. The volume distribution is the curve (analytic function) representing the frequencies of pore volumes as a function of their diameters. d50 corresponds to the median separating into two equal portions the area situated under the curve of frequencies as obtained by mercury penetration for mean pore diameters greater than or equal to 4 nanometers (nm), or as obtained by adsorbing gas, in particular N2, when the mean pore diameters are less than 4 nm, these two techniques being retained as references in the context of the invention for measuring mean pore diameters.
In particular, it is possible to use the techniques described in:
The invention proposes separator elements operating by tangential flow to separate a fluid medium for treatment into a filtrate and a retentate, each element comprising a monolithic porous substrate of shape selected to define circuits inside the porous substrate for passing a flow of the fluid medium for treatment, which circuits are interconnected with one another. Such monolithic substrates, defined as being made as a single piece out of only one material that is uniform and continuous throughout, without bonds nor exogenous contributions, cannot be made by conventional extrusion techniques, but can be made, e.g. by additive techniques such as those described in patent application FR 3 006 606, for example.
The invention seeks to provide separator elements for separating a fluid medium by tangential filtering, commonly referred to filter membranes. In general manner, and as shown in
The porous texture of the substrate is open and forms a network of interconnected pores, thus enabling the fluid that has filtered through the filter separator layer to pass through the porous substrate and be recovered at its periphery. It is common practice to measure the permeability to water of the substrate in order to qualify the hydraulic resistance of the substrate, which simultaneously makes it possible to confirm that the porous texture is interconnected. Specifically, in a porous medium, the steady flow of an incompressible viscous fluid is governed by Darcy's law. The speed of the fluid is proportional to the pressure gradient and inversely proportional to the dynamic viscosity of the fluid, via a characteristic parameter known as “permeability” that may be measured, for example, in compliance with French standard NF X 45-101, of December 1996.
Usually, the porous substrate 2 is made of a non-metallic inorganic material. Preferably, the porous substrate 2 is made of a ceramic, selected from among oxides, nitrides, carbides, and other ceramic materials, and mixtures thereof, and in particular from titanium oxide, alumina, zirconia, and mixtures thereof, titanium nitride, aluminum nitride, boron nitride, and silicon carbide, possibly mixed with some other ceramic material. It should be observed that the porous substrate may also be made out of an organic material or out of an inorganic material that is purely metallic. For example, the porous substrate 2 may be made of a pure metal such as aluminum, zinc, copper, or titanium or in the form of an alloy of a plurality of these metals, or of stainless steels. For example, the porous substrate 2 may present a mean pore diameter lying in the range 1 μm to 100 μm.
Whatever the material used, the invention makes use of the method described in patent application FR 3 006 606 in which the substrate is fabricated by using an additive method.
Internally, the porous substrate 2 includes at least one open structure 3 formed by empty spaces for the flow of the fluid medium for treatment. These empty spaces 3 correspond to zones of the porous substrate that do not include porous material. These empty spaces 3 are arranged within the porous substrate 2 so that the porous substrate presents at its periphery a perimeter wall 21 that is continuous between an inlet 4 for the fluid medium situated at one end of the porous substrate and an outlet 5 for the retentate situated at the other end of the porous substrate.
In the embodiment shown in
The portion of the porous substrate 2 defining the open structure 3 presents a surface that is covered by at least one separator layer 6 that is to be in contact with the fluid medium for treatment flowing inside the open structure 3. A fraction of the fluid medium for treatment passes through the separator layer 6 and the porous substrate 2 so that this treated fraction of the fluid, referred to as the filtrate or the permeate, flows out via the perimeter wall or the outside surface 21 of the porous substrate. The filtrate is recovered on the peripheral surface of the porous substrate by any appropriate means.
The separating filter layer 6 that covers the walls of the open structure 3 serves to filter the fluid medium for treatment. In other words, the open structure 3 without porous material is surrounded between the inlet 4 and the outlet 5 by the separating filter layer 6. By definition, the separating filter layers need to have a mean pore diameter that is smaller than the mean pore diameter of the porous substrate 2. The separator layers define the surface of the tangential flow separator elements that is to come into contact with the fluid for treatment and on which the fluid for treatment flows.
The tangential flow separator element generally presents a length of 1 m to 1.5 m. The section of a tangential flow separator element usually presents an area of 0.8 cm2 to 14 cm2. The thicknesses of the separating filter layers lie typically in the range 1 μm to 100 μm. Naturally, in order to perform the separation function and serve as an active layer, the separator layers present a mean pore diameter that is less than the mean pore diameter of the substrate. Usually, the mean pore diameter of the separating filter layers is less than the mean pore diameter of the substrate by a factor of at least three, and preferably of at least five.
The concepts of separator layers for microfiltration, ultrafiltration, and nanofiltration are well known to the person skilled in the art. It is generally accepted that:
It is possible for a micro- or ultrafiltration layer to be deposited directly on the porous substrate (a single-layer separator layer), or else on an intermediate layer of smaller mean pore diameter, itself deposited directly on the porous substrate. By way of example, the separator layer may be based on or constituted exclusively by one or more metal oxides, carbides, or nitrides, or other ceramics. In particular, the separator layer is constituted by at least one separator membrane deposited continuously on the walls of the three-dimensional structures, each layer being constituted by a ceramic selected from oxides, nitrides, carbides, and other ceramic materials, and mixtures thereof, and in particular titanium oxide, alumina, zirconia, or a mixture thereof, titanium nitride, aluminum nitride, boron nitride, silicon carbide, titanium carbide, possibly mixed with some other ceramic material. Furthermore, the separator layer 6 may be constituted by at least one separator layer deposited continuously on the walls of the three-dimensional structures, each layer being constituted by a polymer suitable for the intended separation and deposited from a collodion of the polymer.
According to a essential characteristic of the invention, the empty spaces 3 for passing the fluid medium for treatment are arranged in the porous substrate 2 so as to create at least a first network R1 within the porous substrate, and more generally so as to create K networks R1, R2, . . . , RK with at least one network R1 having at least two circuits R11, R12 for passing a flow of the fluid medium for treatment, and more generally N circuits R11, R12, . . . , R12, . . . , R1N that are mutually interconnected (where N is greater than or equal to 2) between the inlet 4 and the outlet 5 of the porous substrate. Thus, the fluid medium flows in a first network R1 having at least two flow circuits R11, R12 each communicating with the inlet 4 and the outlet 5 of the porous substrate, these two flow circuits R11, R12 communicating with each other between the inlet 4 and the outlet 5 of the porous substrate. Naturally, a fraction of the fluid medium for treatment flowing in these networks and circuits passes through the separator layer and the substrate 2 so that this treated fraction, referred to as permeate or filtrate, is recovered at the peripheral surface of the substrate.
It should be observed that the fluid medium may also flow in at least a second network R2 having one flow circuit R21 or a series of flow circuits R21, R22, R23, . . . that are connected together. Each of these networks R1, R2, . . . , R2K is considered as being independent relative to the other network in the sense that the fluid medium for treatment flowing in the circuit(s) of any one network does not flow in the circuit(s) of another network.
During its passage through the porous substrate 2 via the first network R1, the fluid medium for treatment encounters either at least one bifurcation or at least one separation causing the fluid medium to split into a plurality of portions (at least two) in order to follow different paths, and/or else at least one junction leading to a plurality of portions of the fluid medium for treatment (at least two such portions) being united that come from different paths. Thus, the flow circuits R11, R12 of the network R1 communicate with each other via crossings or interconnections 9 formed within the porous substrate.
Naturally, the number of flow circuits for the fluid medium for treatment making up a network may vary in the range 2 to N, where N is an integer. Likewise, the number of interconnections 9 between the flow circuits may vary from 1 to M. These interconnections are arranged between the flow circuits constituting a flow network. Likewise, it should be observed that the flow circuits communicate with the inlet 4 and the outlet 5 of the porous substrate, in zones that are common or separated from the porous substrate.
In the embodiment shown in
Naturally, the embodiment shown in
In the embodiment shown in
From the above description, it can be seen that the empty spaces 3 arranged in the porous substrate for passing the fluid medium define one or more open structures, each corresponding to a network. According to an advantageous characteristic, each open structure is limited by a single continuous surface between the inlet and the outlet of the porous substrate, so as to be in contact everywhere with the fluid medium for treatment without presenting any blind space. In other words, the empty spaces are arranged so as to avoid creating retention zones for the fluid medium where the fluid medium for treatment might stagnate. This applies for example for a blind circuit segment having its inlet and outlet for the fluid medium situated at the same location relative to the flow direction of the fluid, with the fluid medium stagnating or reversing its travel direction between the inlet/outlet and the end of the blind circuit.
According to an advantageous characteristic, it should be considered that this open structure that is arranged for making a network of interconnected circuits defines three-dimensional structures all the way to the perimeter wall 21 of the porous substrate.
According to a characteristic of the invention, these three-dimensional structures possess an identity and a continuity of porous material and texture all the way to the outside of the perimeter wall 21. In other words, the material constituting these three-dimensional structures is identical and presents a porous texture that is constant to within the accuracy of the fabrication method.
According to an advantageous embodiment characteristic, the three-dimensional structures are formed by repeating at least one pattern 11 incorporated in a volume unit of the porous substrate forming a mesh 12 within which a morphologically predefined space 3 is left empty for passing the flow of the fluid for treatment. The pattern 11 is repeated firstly by exact or partial juxtaposition of the pattern(s) along at least one dimension of three-dimensional space, and secondly so as to obtain flow continuity for the fluid medium between the empty spaces 3 of the volume unit and porous material continuity for discharging the filtrate.
The use of such a mesh 12 in association with such a pattern 11 in the context of the invention finds a particularly advantageous application when the structure is formed by interleaving two identical flow circuits.
In order to simplify the description of this structure, it is proposed to characterize a cubic mesh 12 containing a symmetrical cruciform pattern 11 with the side of the cubic mesh 12 in which the pattern is incorporated being written c, with a being the dimension characterizing the square opening of the pattern that is flush with the frontier of the mesh, and with L being the characteristic length of each portion of the square section network, so that the filtering surface area of the pattern is given by the following formula:
Spattern=6×(4a×L)
and with
this becomes:
The volume of the mesh is Vmesh=c3, so the compactness of the separator element obtained by stacking and juxtaposing this mesh containing this pattern is obtained by the following formula:
If the resulting circuit is assumed to be a composition of interconnected square section channels, their hydraulic diameter Dh is then equal to a and it becomes possible to compare the compactness of such a structure of the invention formed by two circuits of this type with the above-described compactness for separator elements obtained by extrusion.
A separator element fabricated in this way, with a set at 3.47 mm and with c equal to 7.94 mm possesses a minimum thickness e of porous material between the two circuits that is equal to 0.5 mm and an intrinsic compactness equal to:
which corresponds to a compactness of 743.7 m2/m3 to be compared with a filter element obtained by extrusion having an outside diameter of 25 mm, a length of 1178 mm, and possessing 23 rectilinear non-circular channels of hydraulic diameter of Dh=3.47 mm by observing that there is an increase in compactness of about 30% (Table 1).
In comparison with a filter element obtained by extrusion having an outside diameter of 20 mm, a length of 1178 mm, and possessing 61 rectilinear non-circular channels of hydraulic diameter Dh=1.60 mm, the same construction of a structure having two identical circuits gives, for a hydraulic diameter Dh of 1.60 mm, an increase in compactness of 28% (Table 2):
In comparison with a filter element obtained by extrusion having an outside diameter of 25 mm, a length of 1178 mm, and possessing eight rectilinear non-circular channels of hydraulic diameter Dh=6.00 mm, the same construction of a structure having identical double circuits gives, for a hydraulic diameter Dh of 6.00 mm, an increase in compactness of 36% (Table 3):
This combination of two patterns leads to the construction of a single network for which it can be seen that the cubic elementary mesh contains a set of interconnected void spaces having a regular tetrahedral pattern.
Stacking such a pattern in the three directions of three-dimensional space, while imparting successive turns to the pattern so that the empty spaces of the edges of the tetrahedron coincide and juxtapose in repetitive and continuous manner makes it possible to obtain the following new compactness values, returning by way of example and for comparison purposes to the same extruded separator elements and the same three hydraulic diameters as used in example 1 (Table 4):
It can be seen that with such a structure, there are increases in compactness of 66%, 72%, and 123% respectively for hydraulic diameters of 6 mm, 3.47 mm, and 1.6 mm.
It is clear that it is possible to envisage using patterns 11 with a wide variety of shapes. For example, a pattern 11 and the associated mesh may present one or more symmetries selected from the following list:
Likewise, it should be observed that repeating the pattern(s) 11 may present symmetry relative to the external symmetry of the substrate. Under such circumstances, the porous substrate may have an external profile that varies, optionally presenting symmetry.
In the above examples, the open structure 3 defines three-dimensional structures formed by repeating at least one pattern 11 without variation, neither of shape nor of the dimensions of the pattern.
Naturally, it may be envisaged to make the open structure 3 defining three-dimensional surfaces by repeating at least one pattern 11 of dimensions that vary gradually in isomorphic manner in at least one direction and/or of morphology that varies gradually in isometric manner in at least one direction.
By juxtaposing such a pattern 11 in two x and y directions, and by gradually varying in isomorphic manner while adjusting stepwise the dimensions of the spaces corresponding to the rectangles 11b, the square 11a, and the trapezium 11c, it is possible to obtain a substrate as shown in
In the above-described embodiment, the open structure 3 defines three-dimensional structures with repetitive geometrical configurations.
In the above examples, the empty spaces 3 are created in the porous material so as to allow the fluid medium to flow.
The porous substrate 2 is arranged to contain internally a single flow network 3 for the fluid medium for treatment flowing between an inlet 4 and an outlet 5. In the example shown, the inlet 4 is situated at one end of the porous substrate 2 and the outlet 5 at the other end of the porous substrate 2. The porous substrate 2 includes empty spaces or passages 3 for forming flow circuits for the fluid medium for treatment. The porous substrate 2 is arranged to include over its entire periphery a perimeter wall 21 surrounding the empty spaces or passages. The perimeter wall 21, which is defined by the outside surface 22 of the porous substrate 2, extends in continuous manner between the inlet 4 and the outlet 5.
Starting from its continuous perimeter wall 6, the porous substrate 2 includes a three-dimensional arrangement of structures that are connected to one another so as to leave between them empty spaces 3 for passing the fluid medium to create a flow network comprising a series of flow circuits R1, R2, . . . , RK for the fluid medium, which circuits are interconnected between the inlet 4 and the outlet 5 of the porous substrate.
As explained, the three-dimensional structures form an integral portion of the single-piece porous substrate, i.e. they result from the very shape given to the porous substrate and are not in any way separate fitted elements. The assembly forms a porous single block without any bonding, nor any interfaces, nor any joints of any kind. There is identity and continuity of porous material and texture between the three-dimensional structures and the perimeter wall 21. Thus, the three-dimensional structures are mechanically and chemically solid and of the same strength as the perimeter wall 21.
In the embodiment shown in
The channels a to h are made in the example shown, parallel to one another over the entire length of the porous substrate. Between the inlet 4 and the section B-B, the channels a to h are independent of one another. At the section B-B, the channels a to h are interconnected in the manner shown in
In the example shown, this arrangement of three-dimensional structures and of interconnections is repeated at different sections of the porous substrate at a regular pitch, while permutating the interconnections 9 in circular manner between the channels. Thus, at a section C-C of the porous substrate following the section B-B in question in the flow direction of the fluid medium for treatment (
In the example shown, the channels a to h are interconnected between the inlet and the outlet seven times by the interconnections 9 so that the fluid medium for treatment entering via the inlet 4 can flow in each of the channels to the outlet 5. The channels a to h and the interconnections 9 together form a series of mutually interconnected circuits R1, R2, . . . , RK.
Naturally, provision may be made to make a network in the porous substrate with a number of flow circuits different from that described and with interconnections different from those selected. Similarly, it may be advantageous to make a plurality of networks of flow circuits for the fluid medium that are mutually interconnected in the porous substrate, with the circuits of any one network being independent of the circuits of the other network. For example, the separator element 1 may include a first network of mutually interconnected circuits formed by the channels a, h, e, and d that are connected to one another, with various sections via communication passages 9, a second network of mutually interconnected circuits formed by the channels b and c connected to each other with at least one and in general manner with a plurality of different sections via communication passages 9, and a third network of mutually interconnected circuits formed by the channels f and g connected to each other, with at least one and more generally with a plurality of different sections by communication passages 9. These circuits of each of these three networks are independent from one another, i.e. they do not communicate with one another.
Naturally, a network may include a greater or smaller number of mutually interconnected flow circuits that are interconnected via interconnections 9 repeated at a pitch that may be regular or irregular. Likewise, the flow circuits may present shapes and dimensions that are very diverse. In the embodiment shown in
It follows from the above description that the tangential flow separator element 1 presents a novel shape for the flow network for the fluid medium that enables the hydraulic diameters of the flow circuits to vary progressively or sequentially. This novel shape for the flow network for the fluid medium also makes it possible to implement radial and/or longitudinal interruptions in the travel direction of the fluid medium in order to increase the performance of the separator elements.
In the context of the invention, the porous substrate or indeed the tangential flow separator element as a whole is fabricated by way of example using an additive technique, such as that described by way of example in patent application FR 3 006 606.
The invention is not limited to the examples described and shown since various modifications can be made thereto without going beyond its ambit.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
15 54908 | May 2015 | FR | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/FR2016/051233 | 5/25/2016 | WO |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2016/193573 | 12/8/2016 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
5028036 | Sane | Jul 1991 | A |
5853582 | Grangeon et al. | Dec 1998 | A |
6499606 | Grangeon et al. | Dec 2002 | B1 |
20110236628 | Soukhojak | Sep 2011 | A1 |
20140065350 | Kobashi et al. | Mar 2014 | A1 |
20150008177 | Yajima | Jan 2015 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
103443053 | Dec 2013 | CN |
0 778 073 | Jun 1997 | EP |
2 832 708 | Feb 2015 | EP |
3 006 606 | Dec 2014 | FR |
2 223 690 | Apr 1990 | GB |
S6331517 | Feb 1988 | JP |
2001232163 | Aug 2001 | JP |
9628241 | Sep 1996 | WO |
Entry |
---|
International Search Report, dated Sep. 21, 2016, for PCT/FR2016/051233; French Search Report dated Apr. 13, 2016, for French Application No. 1554908. |
Japanese Office Action, dated Dec. 1, 2020, corresponding to Japanese Application No. 2017-561808. |
Chinese Office Action, dated Jun. 9, 2020, corresponding to Chinese Application No. 201680030948.9. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20180140990 A1 | May 2018 | US |