Patent Application
20170167010
The present invention relates to an apparatus and method for the manufacture of at least substantially hydrogen-free ta-C layers on substrates (workpieces) of metal or ceramic materials, and to a substrate having such a ta-C layer. Ta-C layers, also termed coatings, are defined in the VDI guideline 2840 entitled “Carbon Films, basic knowledge and film properties.
A paper entitled “Diamond-like Carbon Coatings for tribological applications on Automotive Components” by R. Tietema, D. Doerwald, R. Jacobs and T. Krug presented at the 4th World Tribology Congress, Kyoto, September 2009 discusses the manufacture of diamond-like carbon coatings from the beginning of the 1990's. As described there the first diamond-like carbon coatings (DLC-coatings) were introduced on the market for automotive components. These coatings enabled the development of HP diesel fuel injection technology.
The increasingly stringent environmental regulations applied around the world (for example Euro 4 and 5) promote the need to reduce friction in order to save fuel consumption and reduce CO2 emissions. Suitable combinations of coatings, surface structure and lubricants have recently led to minimized friction. This is reported in investigations such as, in particular, those carried out by Kano. M, Yasuda, Y et al described in their paper Ultralow friction of DLC in presence of glycerol mono-oleate (GMO), Tribology Letters, Vol. 18, No. 2 (2005) 245. They have shown that a substantial decrease in friction is possible by using a suitable combination of oil and coating type, in particular the hydrogen free DLC-coating. For an a-C:H coating (hydrogenated DLC) on the steel surface the values for the coefficient of friction are 0.13 for a dry surface, 0.12 when a 5W30 lubricant is used and 0.9 when a lubricant comprising a mixture of PAO (i.e. Polyalphaolefines'and GMO (i.e. glycerol monooleate) is used. When a hydrogen-free ta-C DLC layer is used the comparative values are 0.13 for a dry surface, 0.09 for a surface lubricated with 5W30 engine oil but only just under 0.02 when a lubricant comprising a mixture of PAO and GMO is applied.
The German standard VDI 2840 (“Carbon films: Basic knowledge, film types and properties”) provides a well-defined overview of the plurality in carbon films, which are all indicated as diamond or diamond-like coatings.
In this context the use of hydrogen-free ta-C coatings with appropriate lubricants is evidently very important. To date these coatings have been made using an arc process. A hardness in the range from 20 GPa to 90 GPa, in particular 43 GPa to 80 GPa; is considered useful (diamond has a hardness of 100 Gpa). However, the coatings are quite rough because the arc process leads to the generation of droplets. The surface has rough points due to the droplets. Thus although low friction can be obtained the wear rate of the counterpart in the tribological system is relatively high due to the surface roughness caused by droplets.
The object of the present invention is to provide an alternative apparatus and method by which (doped) hydrogen-free ta-C coatings with a hardness in the required range but with a relatively very smooth surface can be made which exhibit low wear (and lead to low wear of the sliding partner) and which can be deposited simply and relatively economically.
In order to satisfy this object there is provided an apparatus of the initially named kind which is characterized in that the apparatus includes at least the following components:
The pulse repetition frequency is preferably in the range from 1 Hz to 2 kHz, especially in the range from 1 Hz to 1.5 kHz and in particular of about 10 to 30 Hz.
The pulse pattern consists of controllable macro-pulses of a length in the range of 10 to 5000 μsec, typically in the range between 50 and 3000 μsec, and especially between 400 and 800 μsec. The macro-pulses consist of controllable micropulses in the range from 1 to 100 μsec, typically 5-50 μsec. During each micropulse the power to the cathode is switched on and off. The range for switching on is typically between 2 and 25 μsec and the range for the power to be switched off is typically between 6 and 1000 μsec. Each micro-pulse generates an oscillation that is amplified to high values if the frequency of the pulses is appropriately selected, thus generating a highly ionized plasma. This power supply is further referred to as a HIPIMS+OSC power supply.
It has surprisingly been found that with an apparatus of this kind hydrogen-free (or at least substantially hydrogen-free) ta-C coatings with a hardness of 50 GPa can readily be deposited on a metal or ceramic surface with a relatively smooth coating substantially free of droplets. Such coatings achieve low wear and a low friction of about 0.02 with the usual running partners such as valve train components (e.g. tappets), fuel injection components, engine components (e.g. piston rings) and power train components (e.g. gears). Also there is a high potential for using these coating on cutting and forming tools, especially for cutting materials where strong adhesive wear (BUE: Built-Up-Edge formation) is involved.
It can be advantageous to provide at least one other magnetron cathode, serving as a source of dopant material for the carbon based coating.
The bias power supply for applying a negative bias voltage to the substrate or substrates on the support device is preferably one of:
The achievable deposition rate is relatively high, for example a 1 micron coating can be deposited (on a rotating substrate) within a period of about two to six hours using the following scheme for the example of non-doped ta-C:
The process is usually carried out at an Ar pressure of about 0.1 to 1.8 Pa (1. 10−3-8.102 mbar. It would be possible to use other inert, non-reactive gases so long as hydrogen is not present. The total process time depends largely on the maximum time averaged DC power with which the apparatus can be operated during coating. This typically lies in the range from 10 to 50 kW but could be higher.
In the rest of this description, the expression “HIPMS” has to be read in general as HIPIMS, MPP or HIPIMS+OSC, unless otherwise specifically mentioned. When in the remainder of the description the word “pulse” is mentioned. It is to be interpreted as single pulse (in case of HIPIMS) or as a macro-pulse according to the description given above (in case of MPP or HIPIMS+OSC), unless something else has been specifically pointed out in the text.
The [possibility exists of addition of doping elements in the coating. The addition of doping elements makes it possible to modify the tribological properties of the tribosystem part-lubricant-counterpart with respect to wear resistance improvement and friction reduction. In this connection it has been that, by adding silicon in hydrogenated PECVD produced DLC (a-C:H) in PECVD/sputtered carbon or carbon arc coatings, the wettability can be improved, therefore reducing friction. A small addition of hydrogen in sputtered carbon coatings will increase the hardness to levels exceeding the hardness of a-C:H coatings produced with PECVD. An addition of N2 can also have beneficial influences. The addition of metals can be expected to improve the hardness of the coatings, or at least to make the coating better suitable for certain tribological wear phenomena, like for instance impact fatigue wear, high temperature wear, etc.
One possible coating process can be described as follow:
In a first step cleaning and etching of the substrate is carried out with Ar-ions, using an argon atmosphere in the vacuum chamber. This step is carried out for a period of 10 to 30 minutes
Another option for this step is the use of HIPIMS etching with a Cr, Ti or Si target operated in a HIPIMS magnetron etching mode with a relatively high substrate bias of −500 to −2000V as well known in the art and described in EP-B-1260603 of Sheffield Hallam University. The typical time averaged equivalent DC etching power applied to the Cr, Ti or Si cathode is in the range of 1 to 25 kW.
In a second step a bond layer of Cr, Ti or Si is deposited on the metal or ceramic surface. This is done for about 10 to 20 minutes from a target of Cr, Ti or Si operated in a sputter discharge mode or in a HIPIMS coating mode. In this connection it should be noted that, in case of using a HIPIMS mode, the maximum average power which can be dissipated by and thus effectively applied to a cathode is the power which does not lead to an undesirable temperature increase of the cathode or unwanted melting thereof. Thus in a DC sputtering operation a maximum power according to the allowable thermal load of the target/cathode combination of approximately 15 W/cm2 might be applied to a particular cathode. In HIPIMS operation a pulsed power supply is used which might typically apply power in 50 to 3000 μs wide pulses at a pulse repetition frequency of less than 1 Hz-5 kHz. In an example: if the pulse is switched on during 20 μsec and a pulse frequency of 5 kHz is applied, each pulse would then have a power associated with it of 180 kW resulting in an average power of
P=180 kW×(20 μs/(200−20)μs=20 kW
For this example the maximum pulse power that can be supplied during a HIPIMS pulse is thus 180 kW.
According to the state of the art an appropriate substrate bias of about 0 to 200V should be provided. The deposition of the bond layer can also be done with filtered arc cathodes. Also the use of unfiltered arc cathodes is a possibility, but this is less advantageous because it will lead to additional roughness of the coating because of droplet generation.
In a third step a Cr C, Ti—C or Si—C transition layer is deposited for about 1 to 5 minutes with simultaneous operation of the Cr, Ti or Si and graphite targets in a HIPIMS+OSC mode or with carbon-arc cathodes with about −50 to −2000V substrate bias.
During deposition as little hydrogen containing gas as possible shall be used (an impurity due to an initial small amount of water vapour or the hydrogen containing contamination can never be completely precluded).
In a fourth step the ta-C hydrogen-free DLC coating is deposited using the graphite cathode operated with a HIPIMS+OSC power supply designed in accordance with the principal claim, i.e. using a cathode power supply which is connectable to the at least one graphite cathode and to an associated anode and which is designed as already described earlier.-During deposition the pulses sequences of the HIPIMS+OSC power supplies can be altered to change the coating properties and to enable a multilayered structure with alternating intermediate layers.
In this process the average power of the high power pulse sequences (macro-pulses) averaged over a longer period of time and each comprising a plurality of high power pulse sequences (micro-pulses) is comparable with the power of a DC sputtering system with a constant DC power in the range between 10 and 250 kW.
Moreover, the average power of the high power pulse sequences of the HIPIMS+OSC power supply in each micro-pulse in general exceeds the power of a HIPIMS pulse power which lies, for example, in the range between 100 and 1000 kW.
Thus the apparatus of the invention typically comprises a plurality of magnetrons and associated cathodes, at least one of which comprises a bond layer material (Cr, Ti or Si). The at least one cathode for the bond layer material can also be an arc cathode (filtered, or unfiltered). The apparatus further comprises a power supply for the sputtering of bond layer material for the deposition of the bond layer material on the substrate or substrates prior to deposition of the ta-C layer. A typical example of a bond layer material is as already stated Cr, Ti or Si. Thus there will usually be a minimum of two cathodes, typically one of Cr and one of graphite. In practice it may be more convenient to use a sputtering apparatus with four or more cathodes. This makes it relatively easy to arrange the magnetrons and/or the arc cathodes so that there is an alternating pole arrangement of N, S, N; (magnetron 1) S, N, S (magnetron 2); N, S, N (magnetron 3) and S, N, S (magnetron 4) arranged around the periphery of the vacuum chamber in manner known per se to ensure stronger magnetic confinement of the plasma (closed field).
It is also possible for the apparatus to have at least one arc cathode of graphite and also an apparatus for the generation of an arc for the deposition of an arc carbon layer on the bond layer from the at least one arc cathode of graphite before depositing the ta-C layer by magnetron sputtering from a graphite cathode.
The substrates typically consist of one of the following materials: Steel, especially 100 Cr6, titanium, titanium alloys, aluminium alloys and ceramic materials such as WC. Other materials can be possible as well. Optionally nonconductive substrate materials can be used if RF-biasing or unipolar pulsed biasing is applied. In general the setup is preferable for components and tools to be coated, which require abrasive wear resistance, impact fatigue resistance and corrosion resistance.
For the expiry phase of each high frequency pulse sequence (macro-pulse), it is possible for the HIPIMS+OSC high frequency pulse source to be designed to supply unipolar power pulses (macro-pulses) with a lower pulse repetition frequency than the pulse repetition frequency of the high frequency pulses (micro-pulses) contained in the macro-pulse. This reflects the fact that less energy is then required to maintain the very high degree of ionization in the chamber at the end of each high power pulse sequence, thus leading to less heat which needs to be dissipated and reducing the working temperature of the graphite cathode(s).
The HIPIMS+OSC power supply expediently contains a capacitor that can be charged to supply the high frequency power pulses and also an LC oscillating circuit which is connected or connectable between the capacitor and the cathode or cathodes.
The cathode power supply preferably comprises an electronic switch controllable by a program and adapted to connect the capacitor to the at least one cathode at the pulse sequence repetition frequency for the generation of the desired pulse sequence.
The electronic switch or an additional electronic switch can be adapted to connect the capacitor after the build-up phase to the at least one cathode via the LC circuit to generate the high frequency DC power pulse at the desired pulse repetition frequency for the high power DC pulses of each pulse sequence.
Thus, an LC oscillating circuit is usefully provided for the generation of the high frequency DC pulse component of the pulse sequence. It may seem a little strange that an LC oscillating circuit is used to generate a DC pulse component. It appears however that the apparatus has an inherent rectifying function leading to the DC pulses.
The invention also comprises a method of manufacturing an at least substantially hydrogen-free ta-C layer on at least one substrate (workpiece) of metal or ceramic materials, the method being characterized in that the ta-C layer is deposited in a vacuum chamber, which is connectable to an inert gas source not containing hydrogen and to a vacuum pump by magnetron sputtering from at least one graphite cathode having an associated magnet arrangement forming a magnetron, the graphite cathode serving as a source of carbon material while using a bias power supply for applying a negative bias to the at least one substrate and a cathode power supply which is connectable to the at least one graphite cathode and to an associated anode and which is designed to transmit high power pulse sequences spaced at intervals of time, with each high power pulse sequence comprising a series of high frequency DC pulses adapted to be supplied, optionally after a build-up phase, to the at least one graphite cathode with the high frequency DC power pulses having a peak power in the range from 100 kW to over 2 megawatt, and a pulse repetition frequency in the range from 1 Hz to 350 kHz.
The pulse repetition frequency is preferably in the range from 1 Hz to 2 kHz, especially in the range from 1 Hz to 1.5 kHz and in particular of about 10 to 30 Hz.
The invention also comprises the use of dopants to the ta-C coating. In this respect dopants can be metals from sputter targets operated with arc, sputter or HIPIMS cathodes (Si, Cr, Ti, W, WC) or dopants which are supplied from the precursors in gas phase (hydrocarbon gases, nitrogen, oxygen, Si containing precursors like silane, HMDSO, TMS).
The invention also relates to a substrate having a ta-C layer which is made by the method of one of the present claims.
The invention will now be explained in more detail with reference to the accompanying drawings in which are shown:
In all drawings the same reference numerals have been used for the same components or features or for components having the same function and the description given for any particular component will not be repeated unnecessarily unless there is some distinction of importance. Thus a description given once for a particular component or feature will apply to any other component given the same reference numeral.
Referring first to
Biasing can also be done by pulsed biasing or RF-biasing. Pulsed biasing can be synchronized with the HIPIMS-cathode pulses (also described in WO2007/115819). Good results can be achieved with the HIPIMS-DC biasing described in connection with FIGS. 1 to 3 of WO2007/115819. For thicker coatings, HIPIMS biasing may be an issue because of more or less non-conductivity of the coating.
In this example the metallic housing of the vacuum chamber 14 is connected to ground and this is at the same time the positive terminal of the apparatus. The positive terminal(s) of the high impulse cathode power supply(ies) 18 is/are likewise connected to the housing 14 and thus to ground 36 as well as the positive terminal of the bias power supply 32.
A connection stub 40 is provided at the top of the vacuum chamber 14 (but could be at located at other locations as well) and can be connected via a valve 42 and a further line 44 to a vacuum system for the purpose of evacuating the treatment chamber 14. The vacuum system is not shown but well known in this field. A further line 50, which serves for the supply of an inert gas, especially argon to the vacuum chamber 14, is likewise connected to the top of the vacuum chamber 14 via a valve 48 and a further connection stub 46. For dopants, additional gas supply systems 43, 45, 47 can be used.
Vacuum coating apparatus of the generally described kind are known in the prior art and frequently equipped with two or more cathodes 16. For example a vacuum coating apparatus is available from the company Hauzer Techno Coating BV in which the chamber has a generally square shape in cross-section with one cathode at each of the four sides. This design has one side designed as a door permitting access to the chamber 14. In another design the chamber is approximately octagonal in cross-section with two doors which each form three sides of the chamber. Each door can carry up to three magnetrons and associated cathodes 16. A typical vacuum coating apparatus includes a plurality of further devices which are not shown in the schematic drawings of this application. Such further devices comprise items such as dark space shields, heaters for the preheating of the substrates and sometimes electron beam sources or plasma sources in diverse designs. Finally, it is also possible to provide arc cathodes with respective arc power supplies in the same chamber in addition to magnetron cathodes. When using the apparatus air is first extracted from the vacuum chamber 14 by the vacuum pumping system via the line 44, the valve 42 and the line 40 and the argon is supplied via the line 50, the valve 48 and the connection stub 50. The chamber and the workpieces are preheated during pump-down to drive out any volatile gases or compounds which adhere to the workpieces or chamber walls.
The inert gas (argon) which is supplied to the chamber is always ionized to an initial extent, for example by cosmic radiation and splits up into ions and electrons.
By generating a sufficiently high voltage on the work pieces, a glow discharge can be generated on the workpieces. The argon ions are attracted to the workpieces and collide there with the material of the workpieces, thus etching the workpieces.
Alternatively, Ar ions can be generated by a plasma source. The generated ions can be attracted to the workpieces by a negative substrate bias voltage and can then etch the workpieces.
As soon as the etching treatment has been carried out the coating mode can be switched on. For a sputter discharge, during deposition the cathodes will be activated. Ar-ions are colliding with the target and knock atoms out of the target. Electrons are ejected from the target due to sputtering and are accelerated by the dark space voltage gradient. With their energy they can collide with Ar atoms, where secondary electrons will be emitted and help to maintain the discharge. Each of the cathodes is provided with a magnet system (not shown in
In case of a HIPIMS discharge, a different discharge mode is effective. The number of ions increases dramatically and as a consequence the target material particles knocked out from the target will be ionized. This is not the case for a normal sputter discharge. As a consequence gases present in the chamber will be highly ionized as well. This is beneficial when dopants are applied.
The power supply to the cathode or cathodes causes a flux of ions of the material of the cathode to move into the space occupied by the workpieces 12 and to coat them with the material of the respective cathode. The structure of the coating is influenced by the applied negative bias voltage that influences the movement of ions towards the workpieces.
Sputtering processes are known in diverse forms. There are those that operate with a constant voltage at the cathodes and a constant negative voltage at the workpieces and this is termed DC magnetron sputtering. Pulsed DC sputtering is likewise known in which at least one of the cathodes is operated in a pulsed mode, i.e. pulsed power is applied to the cathode by a pulsed power supply.
A special form of a pulsed discharge is the HIPIMS discharge. In a HIPIMS mode the power which is supplied to each cathode during a power impulse can be much higher than the power of a DC sputtering mode because there are substantial intervals between each pulse and the average power remains the same as for DC puttering. The limiting constraint on the power is the amount of heat that can be dissipated at the cathode before this overheats.
In recent times the cathodes are no longer supplied with a constant power but rather with power impulses of much higher power but only in relatively short pulses. This leads to a higher ionization in the vacuum chamber and improved coatings. For example, in well known HIPIMS sputtering (high power impulse magnetron sputtering), each power pulse can have a duration of say 10 μs and a pulse repetition time is used of say 200 μs, (corresponding to a pulse repetition frequency of 5000 Hz, i.e. a spacing between impulses of 190 μs). These values are only given as an example and can be varied in wide limits. For example, an impulse duration can be selected between 10 μs and 4 ms and a pulse repetition time between 200 μs and 1 s. As the time during which a very high peak power is applied to the cathodes is short the average power can be kept to a moderate level equivalent to that of a DC sputtering process. It has however been found that by the application of high power impulses at the cathode these operate in a different mode in which a very high degree of ionization of the ions arises which are ejected from the cathodes, with this degree of ionization, which is material dependent, lying in the range between 40% and indeed up to 90%. As a result of this high degree of ionization, many more ions are attracted by the workpieces and arrive there with higher velocities which lead to denser coatings and make it possible to achieve completely different and better coating properties then regular sputtering or arc coating.
The fact that the power is supplied in power peaks means however that relatively high currents flow in the bias power supply during these power peaks and the current take up cannot be readily supplied by a normal power supply.
In order to overcome this difficulty WO 2007/115819 describes a solution as shown in
By way of example the discharge can take place in such a way that a bias of −50V drops during the power pulses to −40V.
As HIPIMS sputtering has developed there have been some proposals to use special high power pulse sequences instead of single power pulses. In accordance with the present invention it has surprisingly been found that with HIPIMS+OSC power supplies excellent hydrogen-free ta-C coatings can be formed from a graphite cathode when such pulse sequences are used with parameters in particular ranges.
In the simplest form of the present invention one of the cathodes 16 is a graphite cathode for supplying the carbon by magnetron sputtering and the other is a Cr, Ti or Si target for supplying a bond layer material. Possibly, other materials could also be used for a bond layer.
All the depositions of ta-C layers investigated were performed using workpieces on a table 20 of 850 mm diameter. To ensure good adhesion of the hard hydrogen-free carbon layer on the substrate, the apparatus initially used a standard ARC adhesion layer such as is used when depositing ta-C by carbon arc. It will not be described in detail because it is not the preferred solution and the arc process is in any case well known.
The two cathodes 16 labelled also C are of graphite and have magnet arrangements with centre poles of polarity “north” (N) and outside poles of polarity “south” (S) to generate the well known magnetic tunnel of a magnetron. The cathodes have the shape of elongate rectangles when viewed face on and are shown here in a cross-section perpendicular to their long axis. Instead of having SNS polarity as shown, they could have NSN polarity as shown for the magnet arrangements for the Cr cathodes at the top and bottom of
The magnet arrangements can be moved in the direction of the respective double arrows 82 towards and away from the respective cathodes 16. This is an important control parameter for the operation of the HIPIMS cathodes.
The idea is for the magnetrons to have alternating polarities going around the vacuum chamber 14. This means, with an even number of cathodes that the magnetic poles always alternate, i.e. N, S, N, S, N, S, N, S, N, S, N, S, when going around the chamber. This leads to an enhanced magnetic confinement of the plasma. A similar magnetic confinement can also be achieved if all cathodes have the same polarities, say NSN. Then it is necessary to operate with auxiliary S poles between the adjacent magnetrons to obtain a similar N, S, N, S, N arrangement around the chamber. It will be appreciated that the described arrangements only work with an even number of magnetrons. However, it is also possible to obtain a similar effect with an odd number of magnetrons either by making some poles stronger than others or by the use of auxiliary poles. Such designs to obtain a closed plasma are well known and documented in various patent applications.
What
The electronic control 88, which can be thought of as a microprocessor or microcontroller, is also able to operate a further electronic switch 90. This switch is used as a crowbar, which together with switch 86 will be switched on if an arc occurs on the cathode. This switch will preferentially be connected directly between the output terminals of cathode and anode (14 and 16) in order to dissipate as much stored energy from capacitors and inductances as possible for fastest switching off.
An LC circuit 92 is connected into the lead 84 so that the power applied during each high power pulse sequence can be modified at the resonant frequency of the LC circuit, which is preferably also a tunable LC circuit capable of operating at various resonant frequencies.
It should be noted that for reasons which are not well understood the plasma in side the vacuum chamber acts as complicated electrical load with non-linear characteristics which lead to the waveforms explained below with reference to
The most characteristic properties from a process point of view of the pulse unit used here, as described in connection with
In Table 1 some parameters are given that have been applied for the respective pulse file (column 1 in Table 1). Pulse files are the programs for the macro-pulses. In this example the macro-pulses have been built up from micro-pulses in a here called ignition part (column 2-6) and a here called highly ionized part (column 11). In column 12 is the total time of the macro-pulse mentioned. Details about the columns of table 1 are explained by the first line: the pulse file concerned here is named 35. In the ignition part of the macro-pulse, 4 repetitive pulse cycles have been programmed (column 5), where each individual cycle consists of a micro-pulse. For each micro-pulse the voltage is switched by means of switch 86 to the output for 3 μs (voltage on) followed by a period of 40 μs in which the voltage is switched off. This on/off cycle is repeated 4 times (column 5), which leads to a duration (column 2) of 172 μs (4×40+4×3). The frequency of 23 kHz indicated in column 6 is derived from the periodicity of 43 μs, determined by the sum of column 3 and 4.
After the ignition period, a highly ionized period follows. Here the micro-pulse consists of 30 μsec off (column 9) and 14 μsec on (column 10). The period of this micro-pulse is therefore 44 μsec, corresponding to 22.7 kHz (column 11). The number of micro-pulses programmed in the highly ionized part, is 11 (column 10), resulting in a duration of the highly ionized period of 484 μsec (column 8, calculated from columns 11 and the sum of column 9 and 10). The total duration of the macro-pulse in column 12 is 656 μsec, which is calculated from the sum of all micro-pulse periods. In this case it is the sum of the durations of the ignition period (column 2) and of the highly ionized period (column 7).
Table 1
Every pulse starts with an ignition pulse. After the ignition pulse, pulse file 35 generates pulses with long off times, while pulse file 42 generates pulses with short off times. Pulse file 43 has intermediate off times. This can also be seen in the oscilloscope recordings of
For pulse file 35 the cathode current has the largest oscillations and it actually drops down to zero. It is noteworthy that the bias current also has the largest oscillations, as can be expected, but the off time is still not large enough for the bias current to drop down back to zero.
In
In the enlarged oscillogram of
Process Parameters: Pulse File and Magnetic Field
In order to scan the process window the three shown pulse files were used to deposit hydrogen-free carbon layers. In addition the magnetic field was changed by putting the magnetic board, i.e. the holder of the permanent magnets, either in the front or back position, as symbolised by the arrow 82. In the front position the horizontal field strength (parallel to the carbon target surface) is approximately 600 Gauss. The back position results in a magnetic field strength of approximately 300 Gauss. One of the most interesting properties of the coating is the hardness. In Table 2 below the hardness result of the 6 deposited coatings (3 pulse files×2 magnetic field strengths) is shown. The results are also shown in the bar graph of
TABLE 2 in indicated as a table above and as a bar graph in
A stronger magnetic field results in a harder coating. For each individual pulse file this correlates with the peak bias current and the peak cathode current. It should be noted however that for different pulse files this correlation is lost. For example, pulse file 35 with magnets in back position has a peak bias current of 26 A and a coating hardness of 3400 Vickers, and pulse file 43 with magnets in back position has a peak bias current of 36 A and a hardness of only 2700 Vickers. This is possibly caused by the peak cathode current. It is known that the height of the peak cathode current is one of the dominating parameters for the ionization of the cathode material. The increase in bias current is probably related to an additional ionization of Ar gas.
From this first scan of parameters it is concluded that the best result can be obtained with the strongest magnetic field (magnets in front) and the longest off time in the pulse package (pulse file 35).
Process Parameters: Argon Flow, UBM Coil Current, and Bias Voltage
Other process parameters which can influence the coating properties are the maximum temperature, the process pressure, the UBM coil current, and the bias voltage. To investigate the effect these parameters have on the coating properties, the coating of run 7 (pulse file 35, magnets in front, 400 sccm Ar, 2 A UBM coil current, 100 V bias) was taken as the reference.
The effect on the coating hardness of these parameters is shown in Table 3 below and illustrated also in the bar graph of
Increasing the coil current from 2 A to 4 A (which increases the ionization because of the stronger unbalancing effect on the cathodes) has a positive effect on the coating hardness. Also the peak bias current, and therefore the coating temperature, goes up in this case. Under these conditions a coating hardness of almost 4900 Vickers was achieved, which is the best result obtained so far. Further investigations have to be done and will probably add more information to these coatings.
Probably it makes no sense to increase the bias voltage combined with increased coil currents. It is likely that there is an optimum for the combination off higher coil currents and higher bias voltages. The optimum is in this case probably lower than 150 V.
From the current scan of the process parameters it can be concluded that the best result is obtained by depositing with long off times of the voltage pulses within the pulse package or sequence. Depositing with higher UBM coil currents results in the deposition of a hydrogen-free carbon coating with the highest measured hardness so far (almost 4900 Vickers). Thus, the following recommendations can be given:
When an optimum coating from this parameter window has been obtained then attention should be paid to the base layer or bond layer. It seems that improvements can be made by:
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11 008 717.8 | Oct 2011 | EP | regional |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 13663596 | Oct 2012 | US |
| Child | 15443272 | US |
