Patent Grant
9559660
The invention relates to micromechanical devices and, in particular, their temperature compensation. In particular, the invention relates to MEMS resonators. The device according to the invention has the features of a micromechanical bulk acoustic wave (BAW) device.
The invention also concerns a method of manufacturing a micromechanical bulk acoustic wave (BAW) device.
Widely used quartz crystal based resonators can potentially be replaced by micromechanical, typically silicon-based resonators in many applications. Silicon resonators can be made smaller than quartz resonators and there are a plurality standard manufacturing methods for silicon resonators. However, a problem associated with silicon based resonators is that they have a high temperature drift of the resonance frequency. The drift is mainly due to the temperature dependence of the Young modulus of silicon, which causes a temperature coefficient of frequency (TCF) approx. −30 ppm/° C. This causes the resonance frequency to fluctuate due to changes in ambient temperature.
The large intrinsic temperature drift prevents silicon-based resonators from entering the quartz crystal dominated oscillator market. It is, however, known to compensate the temperature dependence in various ways. The prior art solutions include:
Passive compensation methods are discussed in not yet published Finnish patent applications 20105849 and 20105851 of the same applicant, as well as references cited therein, in particular A. K. Samarao et al, “Passive TCF Compensation in High Q Silicon Micromechanical Resonators,” IEEE International Conference on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems (MEMS 2010), 2010, pp. 116-119; US 2010/0127596 and U.S. Pat. No. 4,719,383.
An article by A. K. Samarao et al., “Intrinsic Temperature Compensation of Highly Resistive High-Q Silicon Microresonators via Charge Carrier Depletion”, Frequency Control Symposium (FCS), 2010 IEEE International, 1-4 Jun. 2010, pages: 334-339, discloses a bulk acoustic wave resonator comprising boron-doped (p-doping) silicon resonator element for reducing the temperature drift of the resonator. The boron-doped (p-doping) resonator element comprises, in addition, one or more layers of diffused phosphorus (n-doping) in order to create one or more pn-junction to the resonator element. The pn-junctions forming a depletion region with low charge carrier concentration have the effect that a TCF of −3 ppm/° C. could be achieved.
Hajjam et al. “Sub-100 ppb/° C. Temperature Stability in Thermally Actuated High Frequency Silicon Resonators via Degenerate Phosphorous Doping and Bias Current Optimization”, IEEE International Electron Device Meeting, December 2010, disclose also the possibility of n-type doping of silicon with phosphorus in order to further improve the TCF. They report a temperature drift of 0.05 ppm/° C. in a thermally diffusion doped silicon resonator. Diffusion doping, however, results in a strong concentration gradient of charge carriers in the resonator and an n-dopant concentration of about 1*1019 cm−3 or higher, which is shown later to be needed for efficient T-compensation, can be created only to a region penetrating to approximately 2 micron thickness from the surface of the device. Achieved concentration levels may be also dependent on the exact geometry of the device, which sets design constraints. Thus, there are severe limits for the design of the resonator with respect to its volume, thickness and availability of resonance modes, for example. For example, bulk acoustic wave modes are not effectively temperature compensated in diffusion doped resonators.
U.S. Pat. No. 4,358,745 discloses a surface acoustic wave (SAW) device having a substrate comprising a thin doped silicon layer carrying surface waves and being allegedly temperature compensated. Modern simulations have, however, shown that the structures described therein can carry only Rayleigh SAW waves and shear horizontal SAW waves which are not well temperature compensated in practice due to strong contribution from non-compensated elastic matrix elements of silicon. In addition, the publication does not disclose any excitation means which could in practice be used to excite a SAW mode to the structure disclosed. Introduction of such means, such as a piezoactive layer on top of the doped layer, would additionally decrease the performance of the device since the comtribution from the piezoactive layer would be very large. Due to these facts, the described structure has never been commercially exploited.
Thus, there is a need for improved and practically feasible semiconductor resonators and other devices.
It is an aim of the invention to achieve an improved temperature compensated micromechanical device, such as a resonator. In particular, an aim of the invention is to achieve a resonator design which offers more design flexibility. One aim is to provide a resonator structure which can be industrially manufactured in a simple way.
The invention also provides a set new practical designs of temperature compensated resonators for various purposes.
According to one aspect, the device according to the invention comprises an oscillating or deflecting element made of semiconductor material comprising a substantial concentration of n-type doping agent, excitation or sensing means functionally connected to said oscillating or deflecting element. Further, the oscillating or deflecting element is essentially homogeneously doped with said n-type doping agent.
According to the main aspect of the invention, the device is a bulk acoustic wave (BAW) device. Thus, it is adapted to carry bulk acoustic waves and to oscillate in acoustic BAW modes. In such a structure, the oscillating or deflecting element is homogeneously doped throughout its whole thickness.
According to one aspect, the device according to the invention comprises an oscillating or deflecting element made of semiconductor material comprising a substantial concentration of n-type doping agent, excitation or sensing means functionally connected to said oscillating or deflecting element. The oscillating or deflecting semiconductor element can be characterized as a spring or a plurality of springs which have an integral part for the functionality of the device. If the orientation of the spring(s) is such that its spring constant (which is generally a function of elastic matrix elements c11, c12, c44) is mainly dependent on the c11-c12 term, the temperature variation of the spring constant can be remarkably reduced by n-doping. As the springs are an integral part of the device functionality, the device performance variation as a function of temperature is minimized in this way.
According to one aspect, the device according to the invention comprises an oscillating or deflecting element made of semiconductor material comprising a substantial concentration of n-type doping agent, excitation or sensing means functionally connected to said oscillating or deflecting element and the crystal orientation of the semiconductor material, which is preferably silicon, with respect to the direction of resonance or deflection of the oscillating or deflecting element is chosen to deviate less than 30°, preferably less than 15° from a direction that maximizes the temperature coefficient of the device. According to one embodiment, the crystal orientation is chosen to maximize the temperature coefficient of the device. Examples of the influence of the crystal direction chosen are given later in this document.
According to one aspect, the device according to the device according to the invention comprises an n-doped resonator element and comprising transducer means for exciting a resonance mode to the resonator element. The resonance mode may be one of the following:
The present method of manufacturing a micromechanical device comprises
The abovementioned aspects can be implemented as such or in any suitable combination thereof and/or with one or more of the specific embodiments described hereinafter. Some of the embodiments are the subject of dependent claims.
Application areas of the invention comprise for example micromechanical frequency reference crystals, and micromechanical sensors comprising a resonating or deflecting element as an integral part of the sensor. The term deflecting covers movement (e.g. bending, stretching, twisting and turning) in all directions involving loading of the element through its c11-c12-dependent spring constant.
In the following discussion, we concentrate on an embodiment of the invention in which the oscillating or deflecting element is a resonator element.
According to one embodiment, the concentration of the n-type doping agent in the resonator is at least 1.0*1019 cm−3, preferably at least 1.1*1019 cm−3 and typically at least 1.2*1019 cm−3. Usually, the concentration is less than 1021 cm−3. Thus, there is a strong excess of negative electron charge carriers in the resonator. Above the abovementioned concentration limits it is possible to achieve practical resonators with close to zero TCF. Generally, the concentration limit is lowest for Lamé modes. For other modes, the zero-TCF limit is typically slightly higher.
According to one embodiment, the resonator element is essentially free from p-type doping agents.
According to one embodiment, the resonator element is essentially homogeneously doped with the n-type doping agent. Preferably, the doping concentration has local variation of no more than 10% within the resonator element.
According to one embodiment, the resonator element comprises a crystal grown by Czochralski method, in which the n-type doping agent is present already in the crystal growing stage. According to another embodiment, the resonator element comprises a crystal which is epitaxially grown with the n-type doping agent is present already in the growing stage. Both these methods result in a homogeneous doping of the crystal.
The resonator can be made of silicon and the doping agent can be phosphorus, antimony or arsenic, for example.
According to one embodiment, the resonator element comprises a homogeneously doped silicon plate or beam having a thickness of at least 4 μm and at least one lateral dimension of at least 50 μm, and the transducer element is adapted to produce a shear, square extensional, width extensional or flexural plate bulk acoustic wave mode or extensional, flexural or torsional beam bulk acoustic wave mode to the resonator element.
According to one embodiment, the minimum dimension of the resonator element is at least 5 μm, typically at least 7 μm. Relatively thick resonators like this cannot in practice be homogeneously doped by diffusion doping. In the case of plate resonators, the minimum dimension is typically the thickness.
According to one embodiment, the present device is adapted to be actuated without bias current using non-thermal actuation methods. This can be achieved with piezoelectric thin film excitation means or electrostatic excitation means, as will be described below in more detail.
Considerable advantages are obtained by means of the invention. It has been experimentally shown by the inventors that resonators practically no temperature drift and even overcompensation of resonators can be achieved with n-doped resonators according to the invention. Such behaviour has not been demonstrated with the doping levels achieved with p-doping this far. In addition, p-doped resonators exhibit temperature compensation effect only when driven in a resonance mode dependent strongly on the c44 shear stiffness term, which restricts the applicability of p-doping for temperature compensation to a relatively narrow set of resonance modes. As concerns known resonators with regions of n-type doping, the TCF is still relatively low. Although in many applications a TCF close to zero is ultimately desired, solutions are needed which can offer an even higher TCF which can then be traded off with other design parameters. The present invention responds to this need.
In the case of n-doped resonators the resonance modes whose frequency is dependent mainly on the term c11-c12, where the c11 and c12 are the elastic matrix elements, can be temperature compensated. A set of c11-c12 characterized resonance modes and geometries is presented in this document in detail. In general, the invention can be applied e.g. to shear-mode resonators such as a plate resonator in the Lamé mode and to beams oscillating in extensional flexural and torsional resonance modes, and to more general combinations thereof. Thus, the aim of improved flexibility is met with the invention.
Compared with resonators having a plurality of pn-junctions, the present design is easier to manufacture. No pn-junctions are needed in order to achieve the temperature compensation effect. In addition the temperature compensation effect is more remarkable with strong n-doping: positive or zero TCF has not been demonstrated based on pn junctions.
Compared with diffusion doped non-homogeneous resonators, the invention has also great advantages. Diffusion doped resonators which have springs that make up large (thickness >2 μm or smallest cross-sectional dimension >4 μm) continuous volumes cannot be homogeneously doped with the diffusion method. Such devices are desirable in many contexts. Examples are:
Compared with SAW resonators, such as that disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 4,358,745, the present BAW device has a completely different principle of operation and, what is most important, can be realized in practice without losing temperature compensation. It should be noted that extending the doping to deeper layers of a SAW resonator would not make sense because of surface waves used and in practice would make the device inoperative because electrical shunt coupling would increase and oscillation would not take place.
From fabrication point of view, the ability to use a homogeneously pre-doped wafer is a process simplification, because suitably doped wafers can be purchased from a wafer manufacturer and the standard MEMS process flow needs not be changed because of a separate doping step.
The present invention has been demonstrated both theoretically and experimentally. Theoretical calculations show that the temperature drift of c11-c12 characterized modes can be affected by addition of free electrons by heavy n-type doping. Experimentally have been demonstrated i.a. well temperature compensated square extensional resonator elements and even overcompensated Lamé-mode resonator elements. The term “overcompensated” means that the resonator element as such, without additional elements (e.g. layers necessary for the transducers or additional transducer blocks) coupled to it exhibits a positive temperature drift, i.e. TCF of >0, at 25° C.
It has also been found out by the inventors that compared with traditional p-doped silicon resonators, there is even stronger temperature compensation effect when silicon is strongly n-doped with phosphorus. Similar behavior can be expected with other n-dopants, too, since the theory (see the end of the description), which agrees well with experimental results, is independent of the specific element used as the n-dopant. It has been shown that by means of the invention, even the manufacture of overcompensated (thus, TCF >0) silicon resonators is practically possible. This, for its part, offers new possibilities for the development of different kinds of new resonators for various purposes, for which only quartz-based resonators have been thinkable this far.
Particularly important embodiments of the invention comprise a temperature compensated square extensional resonance mode which can readily be actuated both piezoelectrically and electrostatically and also has other desirable properties. Of importance is also purely c11-c12 characterized Lamé mode having a positive temperature drift (or TCF), which indicates that there is room to overcompensate silicon in order to design the temperature drift of a multimaterial (such as thin film piezoactuated) device to close to zero.
A close to zero TCF behavior of a beam resonator can be achieved, i.a., by
The term “temperature compensated” refers to the fact the temperature coefficient of frequency (TCF) of the resonator is higher than that of a resonator made of silicon crystal with standard doping levels, that is, higher than about −30 ppm/° C., preferably higher than −20 ppm/° C.
The term “close to zero” (TCF or temperature drift) means a TCF range of −5-+5 ppm/° C.
The expressions that the frequency of a particular resonance mode is characterized or dominated by matrix element terms (c11-c12) means that no more than 20% of frequency contribution come from other terms (e.g. the c44 term).
Crystal directions are denoted with the bracket notation, e.g. [100]. By this notation any equivalent direction is meant: e.g. [100] is equivalent to [010] or [001].
When elastic matrix elements c11, c12 and c44 are referred to in the text it is assumed that these elements are given in the [100] crystal axes. For example, with this definition the silicon elastic matrix elements are approximately (c11, c12, c44)=(166, 64, 80) Gpa.
The present invention can be utilized in various kinds of oscillator, clock and timer units which may further form part of electronic devices, such as portable electronic devices, in particular wireless devices.
In the following, embodiments and advantages of the invention are discussed in more detail with reference to the attached drawings.
According to one aspect thereof, the present in invention presents the idea and applications of heavy n-type (e.g. by phosphorous) doping of silicon for compensating for the temperature drift of resonance frequency of silicon MEMS resonators. As will be shown below, the invention can be applied for
Many specific examples of these variations are given below after a short discussion of general aspects of n-doping, applicable to several or all of the specific examples.
The temperature drift of silicon with standard doping levels, if no special measures taken, is in the order of −30 ppm/° C. According to typical embodiments of the invention, the temperature drift of the n-doped silicon resonator is −20-+20, in particular −5-+5 ppm/° C., depending i.a. on the doping concentration, crystal orientation, modeshape, geometrical design and interfering material structures of the resonator. It is common that TCF curves are determined by fitting an N-order (typically N=3) polynomial function to measured temperature drift data at the temperature of 25° C. Unless otherwise mentioned, the temperature drift (or TCF) values cited herein are given at 25° C. The values may differ from that in other temperatures due to nonlinearity of the temperature/frequency curve, which may occur, as will be discussed later in more detail.
According to one embodiment, the resonator element comprises an n-doped silicon crystal essentially free (within normal purity levels) from p-type doping agents, yielding a TCF of −3 ppm/° C. or higher.
According to one embodiment, the n-type doping is homogeneous within ordinary manufacturing tolerances throughout the resonator thickness. Thus, there are no interfaces of differently behaving materials inside the resonator element.
The experimental and theoretical investigation described in the following shows that by n-type doping the compensation of modes characterized by mainly by the c11-c12 stiffness term, in contrast to previously known modes characterized by c44 stiffness term and temperature compensated by p doping.
According to one embodiment, the resonator element comprises a silicon crystal doped with phosphorus to a relatively heavy doping concentration of 1018 . . . 1020 cm−3. Such concentration is sufficient for the manufacture of close to zero (TCF ≧−3 ppm/C) temperature drift resonators operating in the square extensional (SE) plate mode dominated by the c11 stiffness constant. Such concentration is also sufficient for manufacturing close to zero (TCF ≧−3 ppm/° C.) temperature drift resonators operating in the c11-c12 characterized Lamé mode, with the additional possibility to achieve TCF >0 ppm/C in order to account for the negative temperature drift effect of additional thin film layers such as the electrodes and the piezolayer.
The resonator element can comprise a crystal grown, for example, epitaxially or by the Czochralski method. Suitable methods are presented e.g. in Handbook of Semiconductor Silicon Technology, Edited by: O'Mara, W. C.; Herring, R. B.; Hunt, L. P. © 1990 William Andrew Publishing/Noyes.
Actuation of the Resonator
The micromechanical resonator according to the invention can be actuated with transducer means known per se. According to one embodiment the transducer means comprise a piezoelectric actuator element. According to another embodiment, the transducer means comprise electrostatic actuator means.
The present invention can generally be applied in both electrostatically and piezoelectrically actuated resonators.
Of particular importance is a temperature compensated square extensional (SE) mode resonator that can be easily excited using a piezoelectic layer and an electrode layer deposited on top of the n-doped resonator element. As shown below, it has been observed that the SE mode has a close to zero TCF (−1 ppm/° C.). The SE mode can be excited electrostatically as well.
According to one embodiment, the resonator comprises an n-doped resonator element (TCF >0) and a piezoelectric layer (for example AlN) and electrode layer so as to form a piezoactivated MEMS resonator. The piezoelectric layer and electrode layer are known to have a negative TCF. However, the overall TCF of the resonator is close to zero because of overcompensation of the TCF of the resonator element as such. This arrangement is particularly suitable for temperature compensated SE mode resonators.
With reference to
According to one embodiment the resonator comprises an array of overcompensated (TCF >0) resonator elements 50A, 50B and an undercompensated piezoelectric actuator 52 coupled to the resonator elements 50A, 50B. The overall TCF of the resonator is thus between the TCF's of its individual components and may be designed to be close to zero.
In the example of
Resonator Geometry
According to one embodiment, the resonator element is a beam. The term “beam” generally refers to resonator elements whose in-plane aspect ratio (length vs. width) is at least 5. Typically, the aspect ratio is at least 10.
According to one embodiment, the resonator element is a plate. The plate can be rectangular. For example, it may be a square plate. The plate can also be a polygonal, circular or elliptical. The aspect ratio of a plate (any lateral dimension vs. thickness) is greater than 5.
Depending on the desired resonance mode and level of temperature compensation, the crystal orientation of the resonator is varied with respect to its side orientations, anchoring points and/or actuation means. In the following, the preferred resonance geometries and resonance modes are discussed in the theoretically most optimal crystal orientation, i.e. orientation maximizing the TCF. However, as will be discussed with reference to
The following discussion is divided into paragraphs according to the geometry of the resonator element. First, resonators comprising an essentially two-dimensional plate are discussed. Then, essentially one-dimensional beam resonators are discussed. Finally, some generalizations of the resonators are introduced and more complex geometries and variations taking advantage of the invention are briefly discussed.
Anchoring of the resonators can be carried out at any suitable location allowing the desired resonance mode to emerge into the resonator element. Typically, the anchors are intended not to significantly contribute to the operation of the resonance element and are not considered to be part of the resonance element. However, as will be discussed later, there are some special designs in which the anchors are designed to be beams that have a considerable effect on the resonance properties and, in particular, TCF of the resonator. In this case, the anchors are part of the resonator element.
Plate Resonators
Shear Mode Plate Resonators
A Lamé mode excited to a square silicon plate, in which the crystal orientation in the silicon wafer is (100) and the plate sides are oriented along [100] directions, is an example of a pure shear mode resonator which can take full advantage of n-doping. In this configuration the resonance frequency of a Lamé mode is proportional to sqrt(c11-c12).
As an example, the Lamé modeshape of a plate having dimensions (length×width×height) of 320 μm*320 μm*10 μm is illustrated in
In addition to this basic Lamé modeshape, also higher-order variants of the Lamé mode are covered by the invention. The first order mode is comprised of two diagonally propagating shear waves in a square plate. In higher order modes this condition is satisfied in each square subplate the square plate is virtually divided in. Higher order Lamé modes are more extensively discussed in FI 20105849. A shear wave of similar character is excited to a plate resonator, which is rotated 45 degrees within the plane of the resonator. This mode is called the face-shear mode, and it is of almost pure shear character. The mode shape of the face-shear mode is shown in
Finite element model simulations show that when a plate is rotated within the (100) plane the mode gradually changes from Lamé mode to face-shear mode, and the resonance frequency is simultaneously decreased from 10 MHz to 9 MHz. The linear TCF for various n-dopant concentrations can be calculated using FEM simulations and stiffness matrix element temperature sensitivities from theory.
The evolution from the Lamé mode TCF to the face-shear mode TCF as the plate is rotated within (100) plane is shown in
In (110) plane modes that are similar to the above mentioned Lame/face-shear modes can be observed, but they are not as pure as in (100) plane in terms of their sqrt(c11-c12) dependency; hence we refer to these as pseudo-Lamé mode and pseudo face-shear mode in the following. This is because (110) plane is less symmetric than the (100) plane. At 0/90 degrees in-plane rotation one side of the plate is aligned along [100] while the other is oriented along [110]. In the same manner, at 45 degrees in-plane rotation angle the diagonals are oriented along [100] and [110].
The TCF values in
Following observations can be made from the data in
The Lamé mode is important because its temperature drift can be overcompensated with well realizable dopant levels. Experimentally it has been shown that a TCF of even +18 ppm/° C. can be achieved in such resonator.
The invention is not limited to simple square plate Lamé mode plate resonators, but also more complex variants which can be theoretically divided into subsquares, can be realized. The principle is the same as that more extensively discussed in the Finnish patent application No. 20105849 of the same applicant.
Square Extensional (SE) Mode Plate Resonators
SE mode excited to a square silicon plate, in which the crystal orientation in the silicon wafer is (100) and the plate sides are oriented along [100] directions, represents an example of an extensional mode resonator which can take advantage of n-doping. The SE mode at 13 MHz is illustrated in
Observations are:
Flexural Mode Plate Resonators
Flexural saddle modes that exist in square-shaped plate resonators are strongly c11-c12 characterized modes, when aligned suitably with the crystal axis. Saddle modes are characterized by the saddle surface shape of the resonance mode, which results in two intersecting nodal lines (sets of locations with no displacement) through the resonator body (for more discussion on saddle modes, see FI 20105851). Two types of saddle modes in plates of dimensions (width*length*thickness) of 320 μm*320 μm*10 μm are shown in
According to simulations, saddle mode of
Saddle mode of
As discussed in more detail in FI 20105851, saddle modes are not restricted to rectangular plates, and modes of similar character exist, e.g., in disk-shaped plates as well.
In addition to the saddle modes discussed above, other flexural (bending) resonance modes, which can be temperature compensated by n-doping, can be excited to a plate resonator. These modes can be can be characterized as being similar modes as the out-of-plane flexural modes of a beam resonator (discussed later in a separate section). A plate resonator can be described as a beam whose lateral dimensions (height, width) are close or equal to each other.
Width Extensional Plate Resonators
It turns out that when the length of one of the sides of a square plate resonator is varied, the mode shape changes gradually from the square extensional mode (
Interestingly, the WE mode is more susceptible to temperature compensation by n-doping than the SE-mode.
Beam Resonators
Approximation of the Frequency Vs. Elastic Matrix Elements Relationship of the Extensional/Flexural Resonance of a Beam Resonator
The Young's modulus for one dimensional stretching/shrinking of an element of a material is given by Y1D=T/S, where T is the stress along the stretching/shrinking direction and S is the related strain. We assume that no stresses affect the material element in the directions that are perpendicular to T. If we assume that the material has cubic crystal symmetry, the stress vs. strain relationship is given by the matrix equation [T]=[c][S], where [T] and [S] are 6×1 stress and strain matrices, respectively, and [c] is the 6×6 elastic matrix with three independent elements c11, c12 and c44. Solving Y1D for stretch along the [100] crystal axes yields a result Y1D=c11−2*c122/(c11+c12)2.
The bending stiffness and the extensional stiffness of a beam are proportional to Y1D. Therefore the resonance frequency of a flexural (bending) resonance mode or an extensional resonance mode is proportional to sqrt(Y1D).
Point labeled as “Y1D” in
Torsional beams with rectangular cross sections are discussed in more detail below. However, the invention can be generalized to beams with non-rectangular cross-sections (e.g. circle or ellipse), and to even beams, whose cross section is varied along the length of the beam (e.g. a tapering beam).
Extensional Mode Beam Resonators
A beam shaped body has a length extensional resonance where the resonance is characterized by the contraction/extension of the resonator. The resonance frequency is approximately given by f=sqrt(Y1D/φ/2L, where Y1D is the Young's modulus for 1D stretch defined above, ρ is the resonator density and L is the resonator length. As suggested above the resonance can be temperature compensated by n-doping when the resonator length dimension is aligned along the [100] crystal direction (or when the deviation from the [100] direction is small). The resonator can be fabricated on any wafer plane.
Example of a beam resonator extensional resonance mode is shown in
Following observations can be made:
In addition to the first order length extensional mode illustrated in
Flexural Mode Beam Resonators
A beam similar to as referred above in connection with length extensional modes can be excited also to a flexural mode (including in-plane flexure and out-of plane flexure). A flexural mode resonance is proportional to sqrt(Y1D), and therefore it can be temperature compensated by n-doping when it is aligned along the [100] crystal direction in the same manner as the length extensional resonator from the above discussion.
In addition to the first order flexural mode illustrated in
Torsional Mode Beam Resonators
Conditions for the torsional beam cross section aspect ratio and the needed n-doping concentration are more accurately quantified by simulation results presented in
Observations are:
Simulations were done at 5 degree steps, and the cases with 30/40 degrees tilt were inferior to the presented case. Optimal tilt direction is expected to occur between 33 and 37 degrees. Importantly, an intermediate angle producing similar aspect-ratio independence is not found for beams fabricated to the (100) plane.
In addition to the first order torsional mode illustrated in
Generalizations and Variations
The abovementioned principles and resonator structures can be applied in various ways in order to achieve more complex resonator entities. Thus, the geometry of the resonator can be designed to meet the needs of a particular application and still the temperature compensation be adjusted to the desired level. For example, additional mass-loading elements can be brought to plate or beam resonators in order to adjust the resonance frequency of the resonator. Flexural-mode mass-loaded resonators per se are more extensively discussed in the Finnish patent application No. 20105851 of the same applicant.
Any compound resonator, which can be divided into mass element(s) and spring(s) can be temperature compensated with n-doping, when the resonance mode is such that the at least some of the spring(s)
It should be noted that a compound resonator may contain of multiple springs, and the individual springs may independently experience extension, bending or torsion.
Discussion in chapter Shear mode plate resonators was restricted to (pseudo) Lamé modes and (pseudo) face-shear modes of square plate resonators. As appreciated by a skilled person, the resonator body does not have to be of square shape to be able to resonate in a shear mode whose frequency would be (c11-c12)-characterized. For example, the so called Wine glass resonance mode of a circular resonator plate is a (c11-c12)-characterized shear mode that can be temperature compensated. Even further, allowing the geometry to deviate from the perfect square or disk shapes to more asymmetric geometries gradually changes the strongly (c11-c12)-characterized shear modes to modes with weaker (c11-c12) dependence, which, however, due to the overcompensation capability with n-doping can still be temperature compensated with a suitable n-dopant concentration.
In general, although such modifications can bring non-idealities to the system and decrease the temperature compensation effect of n-doping of the resonator element with respect to simple geometries, the desired compensation level may still be well achievable due to the overcompensation capability with n-doping.
Optimization and Practical Implementations of n-Doped Resonators
As is apparent from the above discussion, many resonators designs can be overcompensated with the aid of the invention. This fact indicates that there is some “slack” to trade off when optimizing the resonator overall performance. The aim typically is to have the overall temperature compensation close to zero. This could be achieved, for example, by optimizing the frequency vs. temperature behavior by:
Special Features
As discussed in our previous patent application PCT/FI2010/050935, the effect of manufacturing tolerances of BAW resonators can be minimized by providing at least one void to the resonanor element. In FEM simulations it has been found that a central void provided to an n-doped resonator can also increase the TCF of the resonator. For example, in the case of a SE mode square plate resonator of dimensions 320×320×10 μm3, over +2 ppm/° C. increase in TCF was observed, when a central void of 100 micrometers diameter was created in the center of the plate (assuming n-dopant density of 5*1019 cm−3). Similar behaviour can be expected for other modes, too.
Consequently, according to one aspect of the invention, the n-doped resonator element comprises at least one void, typically in the form of a recess or through-hole in the resonator element. Preferably, the void is in the form of a closed-loop trench. Typically, the void is provided in the middle of the resonator element but it may also be located in non-central position or there may be an array of symmetrically or non-symmetrically arranged voids.
According to another aspect of the invention, the anchors of the resonator plate are designed to be beams that have a considerable influence on the temperature compensation properties of the resonator. In this context, the term “considerable influence” means that they affect the TCF of the resonator by at least 2 ppm/° C.
According to one still another aspect, the resonator device comprises at least two separate resonator elements which have a TCF difference, preferably of the order of 30-50 ppm/° C. At least one or both of the resonator elements may by n-doped. According to a preferred embodiment, both resonator elements are n-doped, typically with the same concentration, but their crystal orientations differ by 45°. For example, there could be two Lamé resonators, one having a TCF of −30 ppm/° C. and the other a TCF of +18 ppm/° C. Measurement of both of the two resonator elements can be used for temperature compensation utilizing the TCF difference. This kind of method is disclosed in more detail in U.S. Pat. No. 7,145,402.
Theoretical Model for TCF of a Resonator
The frequency of a resonator can be given in a generalized form by
where c is the generalized stiffness of the material (which takes into account the resonance mode, resonator geometry and its orientation with respect to crystal), ρ is the material density and L is the generalized dimension of the resonator.
When the temperature changes the resonance frequency changes due to change in material parameters and in the dimensions of the resonator. The temperature coefficient of the resonance frequency
depends on material parameters on the following way:
TCf=TCv−α,
where α is the linear coefficient of thermal expansion taking into account the elongation of the resonator and TC of acoustic velocity is
Usually the clearly dominating effect is the first term, i.e. thermal coefficient of stiffness TCc, whereas thermal expansions effect is much smaller. If one is able to modify TCc of the resonating material strongly enough, temperature stable resonators can be realised. The following experimental verification of the model shows that by heavy n-doping of silicon this can be achieved.
Theoretical Model for the Stiffness Matrix Element Temperature Sensitivities
To further demonstrate the feasibility and to understand the operation of the invention, the authors have developed a theoretical model. The model utilizes the free electron contribution to the elastic constants of silicon using the many-valley approach by Keyes (R. W. Keyes, Solid State Physics, Vol. 20, 1967). The model contains a single fitting parameter, the deformation potential. The deformation potential parameter was fitted to the data published by Hall (“Electronic Effect in the Elastic Constants of n-Type Silicon”, Physical Review, vol 161 (2), pp. 756-761, 1967) using the data points at temperature range T=100 . . . 308 K.
The theory, as applied on the present inventive structure and bulk acoustic wave modes was found to agree with experimental data at a reasonably good level (see experimental section below). When TCFs have been calculated using the theory results it has always been assumed that the thermal expansion coefficient is that of normal (non-doped or weakly doped) silicon, i.e., α=2.6 ppm/° C. in the general TCF theory above.
Definition of c11-c12 Characterized Modes
The expressions that the “frequency of a particular resonance mode is characterized or dominated by matrix element terms (c11-c12)”, or “mainly dependent on c11-c12” are clarified in the following.
The theoretical model presented in above is able to predict the elastic constant temperature sensitivities dcij/dT as a function of the n-dopant concentration. For minimizing the temperature dependence of a resonator it would be desirable that the temperature sensitivity of a constant would be zero at some dopant concentration level. This appears not to be the case for the constants c11, c12 and c44, but, when investigating the difference of the terms c11 and c12 we see that the sensitivity d(c11-c12)/dT is zero at the dopant concentration of approximately n=1.2*1019 cm−3, see
This result suggests that it is possible to temperature compensate a resonator, if the resonator geometry, its orientation with respect to the crystal, and the resonance mode in question is such that the generalized stiffness (see chapter Theoretical model for TCF of a resonator) c is proportional to c11-c12. Such a mode is, for example, the Lamé mode of a plate resonator.
By “c is proportional to c11-c12” is meant the following: Assume that the generalized stiffness c can be expressed as a linear polynomial, c=P*c11+Q′*c12+R*c44, where P, Q′ and R are constants. The polynomial may be refactored as:
c=P*(c11-c12)+Q*c12+R*c44 [eq1],
where the new constant we have Q=Q′+P.
By “generalized stiffness c proportional to c11-c12” is meant that constant P is nonzero and that Q=R=0.
However, the temperature compensation property can be applied to a wider class of resonators than to just those for which the above discussed strict condition is fulfilled. As shown in
In general, the generalized stiffness c of a resonance mode does not have to be a linear function of cij's—typically for non-pure shear modes the function is not linear (see Approximation of the frequency vs. elastic matrix elements relationship of the extensional/flexural resonance of a beam resonator). Since the relative changes of stiffness dcij/cij are always small for in the context of this invention, a linear expansion of the generalized stiffness can be used (linear expansion is done at the point [c11, c12, c44]=[166, 64, 80] Gpa, which represents the stiffness terms of ordinary (essentially non-doped) silicon, can be used since the absolute value of silicon stiffness is not greatly affected by doping). The polynomial approximation for the generalized stiffness change dc can be written as
dc=P*(dc11-dc12)+Q*dc12+R*dc44.
The frequency of a resonator is proportional to sqrt(c) (see Theoretical model for TCF of a resonator). Because of the small magnitude of the relative changes dcij/cij, and that of the generalized stiffness dc/c, we can linearize the relation for the frequency change as well and obtain
df=(constant)*(P*(dc11-dc12)Q*dc12R*dc44),
which has a factor of the same polynomial form as has been described above.
When expressed in terms of the temperature sensitivities the relation reads as
df/dT=(constant)*(P*d(c11-c12)/dT+Q*dc12/dT+R*dc44/dT).
A mode that can be temperature compensated has df/dT >=0 at some n-dopant concentration level. A condition for a resonance mode that can be temperature compensated is thus given by the linear inequality
d(c11-c12)/dT+Q/P*dc12/dT+R/P*dc44/dT≧0.
A numerical estimate can be derived: from
y≦−7.9/4.4*x+3.5/4.4 or approximately y≦−1.8*x+0.8.
Assuming an error margin of 5% to the values calculated by the (see Theoretical model for TCF of a resonator) we arrive at inequality
y≦−1.8*x+1.
Thus, all points (Q/P, R/P) that fall under the line −1.8*x+1 represent modes that can be temperature compensated.
In conclusion, a mode can be temperature compensated with n-doping, when its linearized frequency change df (as a function of the changes of matrix elements dcij), which can be written as
df=P*dc11+Q′*dc12+R*dc44,
or
df=P*(dc11-dc12)+Q*dc11+R*dc44,
where Q=Q′+P
has coefficients P, Q and R, which fulfill the inequality R/P<−1.8*Q/P+1.
Experimental Verification
The effect of homogeneous n-doping on single-crystal silicon MEMS resonator temperature coefficients has been experimentally tested. Plate resonators were fabricated on SOI wafers, whose device layer was n-doped with phosphorus to concentration of ˜5×1019 cm−3. Devices were characterized at temperature range of T=40 . . . 80° C., and the temperature vs. resonance frequency curves were extracted.
A total of four different resonance modes in two different resonator types were characterized. The tested resonator types were
For both resonator types the square extensional resonance mode and the Lamé resonance mode were characterized.
The frequency vs. temperature data from the measurements are shown in
The most important observations were:
It can be seen that the graphs are not fully linear but there is a noticeable second-order term (constant “b”) present. It is expected that the curves can be linearized by e.g. using additional dopant in the silicon crystal.
The description of embodiments, theory and experiments above and the attached drawings are for illustrative purposes only and are not intended to limit the invention, whose scope is defined in the following claims. The claims should be interpreted in their full scope taking equivalents into account.
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20115151 | Feb 2011 | FI | national |
| Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PCT/FI2012/050157 | 2/17/2012 | WO | 00 | 12/4/2013 |
| Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| WO2012/110708 | 8/23/2012 | WO | A |
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4358745 | Keyes | Nov 1982 | A |
| 6707351 | Gorrell | Mar 2004 | B2 |
| 7145402 | Mattila et al. | Dec 2006 | B2 |
| 7459329 | Ouellet | Dec 2008 | B2 |
| 20040207492 | Nguyen | Oct 2004 | A1 |
| 20070262831 | Van Beek | Nov 2007 | A1 |
| 20070296527 | Lutz | Dec 2007 | A1 |
| 20080007362 | Partridge | Jan 2008 | A1 |
| 20080143217 | Ho | Jun 2008 | A1 |
| 20090153258 | Lutz | Jun 2009 | A1 |
| 20110089785 | Ho | Apr 2011 | A1 |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| 2302792 | Mar 2011 | EP |
| Entry |
|---|
| Agache, V. et al. “High Q factor plate resonators for ultrasensitive mass sensing applications”, Solid-State Sensors, Actuators and Microsystems Conference, 2009, Transducers 2009, Denver, Jun. 21-25, 2009, pp. 1630-1633, E-ISBN: 978-1-4244-4193-8, ISBN: 978-1-4244-4190-7. |
| Hajjam A. et al. “Sub-100ppb/C temperature stability in thermally actuated high frequency silicon resonators via degenerate phosporous doping and bias current optimization” Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM), 2010 IEEE International San Fransisco, CA, Dec. 6-Dec. 8, 2010, p. 7.5.1.-7.5.4. Published on Jan. 28, 2011. |
| Hajjam A. et al. “Temperature compensated single-device electromechanical oscillators”, MEMS 2011, Cancun, Jan. 23-27, 2011, pp. 801-804. |
| Hall, John J. “Electronic Effects in the Elastic Constants of n-Type Silicon”, Physical Review, vol. 161, No. 3, Sep. 15, 1967. |
| Ho, G. K. et al. “Micromechanical IBARs: Modeling and Process Compensation”, Journal of Microelectromechanical Systems, Jun. 2010, vol. 19, Issue 3, pp. 516-525, ISSN: 1057-7157, doi: 10.1109/JMEMS.2009.2030076, XP011308240. |
| Koskenvuori, M. et al. “Temperature measurement and compensation based on two vibrating modes of a bulk acoustic mode microresonator”, MEMS 2008, Tucson, Jan. 13-17, 2008, pp. 78-81. |
| Lin, A.T.-H. et al. Electrostatically transduced face-shear mode silicon MEMS microresonator, Frequency Control Symposium (FCS), 2010 IEEE International, Jun. 1-4, 2010, p. 534-538, published on Aug. 23, 2010. |
| Samarao, A. K. “Passive TCF compensation in high Q silicon micromechanical resonators”, 2010 IEEE 23rd International Conference on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems (MEMS), Jan. 24-28, 2010, Wanchai, Hong Kong, pp. 116-119, ISSN: 1084-6999, E-ISBN: 978-1-4244-5763-2. |
| Samarao, A.K. et al. “Intrinsic Temperature Compensation of Highly Resistive High-Q Silicon Microresonators via Charge Carrier Depletion”, School of Eletrical and Computer Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, published in 2010 IEEE International Frequency Control Symposium, Jun. 1-4, 2010, pp. 334-339. |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20140077898 A1 | Mar 2014 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 61443725 | Feb 2011 | US |
