Star pinch plasma source of photons or neutrons

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6728337
  • Patent Number
    6,728,337
  • Date Filed
    Monday, June 10, 2002
    22 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, April 27, 2004
    20 years ago
  • Inventors
  • Original Assignees
  • Examiners
    • Church; Craig E
    • Kiknadze; Irakli
    Agents
    • Wolf, Greenfield & Sacks, P.C.
Abstract
A source of photons or neutrons includes a housing that defines a discharge chamber, a first group of ion beam sources directed toward a plasma discharge region in the discharge chamber, the first group of ion beam sources including a first electrode and an inner shell, and a second electrode spaced from the plasma discharge region. The source of photons or neutrons further includes a first power supply for energizing the first group of ion beam sources to electrostatically accelerate toward the plasma discharge region ion beams which are at least partially neutralized before they enter the plasma discharge region, and a second power supply coupled between the first and second electrodes for delivering a heating current to the plasma discharge region. The ion beams and the heating current form a hot plasma that radiates photons or neutrons. The source of photons or neutrons may further include a second group of ion beam sources. The photons may be in the soft X-ray or extreme ultraviolet wavelength range and, in one embodiment, have wavelengths in a range of about 10-15 nanometers.
Description




FIELD OF THE INVENTION




This invention relates to plasma sources and, more particularly, to sources of soft X-ray or extreme ultraviolet photons, or sources of neutrons, wherein high power production of photons or neutrons is achieved by electrostatic acceleration of ions toward a plasma discharge region, neutralization of the ions to avoid space charge repulsion as the discharge region is approached and the application of a heating current through the central plasma in order to raise its temperature and density.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




Soft X-ray and extreme ultraviolet photons can be generated in a hot plasma. The wavelength of the photons is determined by the mixture of ionization states present, with generally shorter wavelength photons being produced by the radiation of higher ionization states within the plasma. An example relevant to lithography is the xenon plasma that contains states Xe


10+


, Xe


11+


and Xe


12+


and radiates strongly in the 10-15 nanometer (nm) band of the spectrum. Within this band, the 13.5 nanometer wavelength is considered to be the optimum for lithography because it can be reflected with up to 70% efficiency by molybdenum-silicon multilayer mirrors in a combination that re-images the pattern of a semiconductor circuit from a mask onto a silicon wafer.




Several approaches to the generation of these energetic photons have been researched in recent years. The plasma has been heated by laser pulses in the so-called laser-produced-plasma (LPP) method. Also, the plasma has been heated directly by the passage of a pulsed electric current in a variety of discharge-produced plasma (DPP) photon sources. These include the capillary discharge, the dense plasma focus and the Z-pinch. It is believed that a viable 13.5 nm source for commercial, high throughput lithography will be required to emit approximately 100 watts of photon power into 2 steradians in a 2% fractional band at 13.5 nm, from a roughly spherical source of diameter less than 1.5 millimeters. In xenon, which is the most efficient 13.5 nm radiator (of room temperature gaseous elements), the 2% fractional band is produced at an electrical efficiency of approximately 0.5% into 2π steradians in DPP sources and up to 1% into 2π steradians in LPP sources relative to laser power absorbed. For the lithography source, a plasma power of 30-60 kilowatts (kW) is therefore required. Other requirements are for precise plasma positioning, to provide uniform illumination, and a repetition frequency greater than 6 kHz.




In the prior art, the plasma has been positioned, in the case of a laser produced plasma, by the intersection of a stabilized beam of liquid xenon with a focused laser beam. The size and positional stability of the resulting plasma are compatible with the application, but with laser efficiencies of only 4% for the pulsed lasers of interest, an electrical input power of 750 kW to 1.5 megawatts is likely to be needed in order to generate 100 watts of 13.5 nm photons, making the economics of the LPP source very unfavorable.




By supplying electrical energy directly to the plasma, the DPP source can, in principle, have a power input not much greater than the 30-60 kW plasma power. However, in prior art discharges, the plasma has, with the exception of the dense plasma focus, been too large in at least one dimension, and the dense plasma focus itself depends on a closely positioned electrode, only a few millimeters distant from the plasma, to create a small, positionally stable plasma focus. There are limits to the plasma power that can be generated in such close proximity to a solid electrode, presenting a difficult scaling challenge for the dense plasma focus source.




Pending application Ser. No. 09/815,633 filed Mar. 23, 2001 discloses a new photon source, referred to herein as the astron source, wherein energy and material are fed into a plasma at a central location via numerous energetic neutral beams. In this source, a relatively large separation has been achieved between the plasma and the nearest solid surface. The astron source also has a distributed electrode which exhibits low current density and anticipated longer life. Although this approach has enabled the generation of a hot plasma that emits extreme ultraviolet photons and is capable in principle of being scaled to 30-60 kW plasma power, it depends on a high acceleration efficiency for the neutral beam particles. To date, only 20% efficiency has been measured, and improvements in acceleration efficiency are required in order to give this photon source a good electrical efficiency.




Accordingly, there is a need for improved methods and apparatus for generating soft X-ray or extreme ultraviolet photons.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




According to a first aspect of the invention, a source of photons is provided. The source of photons comprises a housing that defines a discharge chamber, a first group of ion beam sources directed toward a plasma discharge region in the discharge chamber, the first group of ion beam sources comprising a first electrode and an inner shell that at least partially encloses the plasma discharge region, and a second electrode spaced from the plasma discharge region. The source of photons further comprises a first power supply for energizing the first group of ion beam sources to electrostatically accelerate, from the first group of ion beam sources toward the plasma discharge region, ion beams which are at least partially neutralized before they enter the plasma discharge region, and a second power supply coupled between the first and second electrodes for delivering a heating current to the plasma discharge region. The ion beams and the heating current form a hot plasma that radiates photons.




In some embodiments, the ion beams and the heating current are both pulsed, and the pulsed ion beams precede the pulsed heating current. The ion beams may be at least partially neutralized by resonant charge exchange.




The radiated photons may be in the soft X-ray or extreme ultraviolet wavelength range. In some embodiments, the ion beams comprise xenon ions and the radiated photons have wavelengths in a range of about 10-15 nanometers. The ion beams may comprise ions of a working gas selected from the group consisting of xenon, hydrogen, lithium, helium, nitrogen, oxygen, neon, argon and krypton.




In some embodiments, the first electrode comprises a first hollow ring electrode. The first power supply may be connected between the first hollow ring electrode and the inner shell. The second power supply may be connected between the first hollow ring electrode and the second electrode.




In some embodiments, the source of photons further comprises a second group of ion sources. The second group of ion sources may comprise a second hollow ring electrode and the inner shell. The first power supply may have a first terminal connected to the first and second hollow ring electrodes and a second terminal connected to the inner shell. The second power supply may be connected between the first and second hollow ring electrodes.




In some embodiments, the second electrode comprises a cup electrode. The cup electrode may be coupled to the plasma discharge region through a hole in the inner shell. In some embodiments, the source of photons may further comprise a ring electrode mounted within the cup electrode and a third power supply coupled between the ring electrode and the cup electrode.




In some embodiments, the inner shell may be divided into a first shell portion corresponding to the first hollow ring electrode and a second shell portion corresponding to the second hollow ring electrode. The first and second shell portions may be connected by a resistor having a value that is large in comparison with the impedance of the plasma during delivery of the heating current.




In some embodiments, the second electrode may comprise a structure defining an aperture for emission of a photon beam from the plasma discharge region.




According to a further aspect of the invention, a system for generating photons is provided. The system comprises a housing defining a discharge chamber, a first group of ion beam sources directed toward a plasma discharge region in the discharge chamber, the first group of ion beam sources comprising a first electrode and an inner shell that at least partially encloses the plasma discharge region, and a second electrode spaced from the plasma discharge region. The system further comprises a first power supply for energizing the first group of ion beam sources to accelerate, from the first group of ion beam sources toward the plasma discharge region, beams of ions of a working gas, wherein the ions are at least partially neutralized before they enter the plasma discharge region, a second power supply coupled between the first and second electrodes for delivering a heating current to the plasma discharge region, a gas source for supplying the working gas to the discharge chamber, and a vacuum system for controlling the pressure of the working gas in the discharge chamber.




According to another aspect of the invention, the apparatus described herein may be used for the production of neutrons.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




For a better understanding of the present invention, reference is made to the accompanying drawings, which are incorporated herein by reference and in which:





FIG. 1A

is a cross-sectional side view of an embodiment of an extreme ultraviolet source based on the acceleration of multiple ion beams to a central plasma discharge region;





FIG. 1B

is a cross-sectional top view of the extreme ultraviolet source shown in

FIG. 1A

;





FIG. 2A

is a cross-sectional side view of a first embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention;





FIG. 2B

is a cross-sectional top view of the photon source shown in

FIG. 2A

;





FIG. 3

is a cross-sectional side view of a second embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention;





FIG. 4

is a cross-sectional top view of the photon source shown in

FIG. 3

;





FIG. 5

is a schematic representation of an embodiment of a system for generating photons in accordance with the invention;





FIG. 6A

is a cross-sectional side view of a third embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention;





FIG. 6B

is a cross-sectional top view of the photon source shown in

FIG. 6A

;





FIG. 7

is a cross-sectional side view of a fourth embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention;





FIG. 8

is a cross-sectional side view of a fifth embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention;





FIG. 9

is a cross-sectional side view of a sixth embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention;





FIG. 10A

is a cross-sectional side view of a seventh embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention;





FIG. 10B

is a cross-sectional top view of the photon source shown in

FIG. 10A

;





FIG. 11A

is a cross-sectional side view of an eighth embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention;





FIG. 11B

is a cross-sectional top view of the photon source shown in

FIG. 11A

;





FIG. 12

is a cross-sectional side view of a ninth embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention;





FIG. 13

is a cross-sectional side view of a tenth embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention; and





FIG. 14

is a cross-sectional side view of an eleventh embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION




A star pinch photon source in accordance with a feature of the invention operates in two stages to produce X-ray or extreme ultraviolet radiation. In a first stage, a central plasma is formed using multiple ion beams directed at a central plasma discharge region as described below. In a second stage, a heating current pulse is passed through the central plasma in order to heat and compress the plasma, raising its temperature and density.




The astron source is a source of photons comprising a discharge chamber, a plurality of ion beam sources in the discharge chamber, each electrostatically accelerating a beam of ions of a working gas toward a plasma discharge region, and a neutralizing mechanism for at least partially neutralizing the ion beams before they enter the plasma discharge region. The neutralized beams enter the plasma discharge region and form a hot plasma that radiates photons.




The astron principle that operates in the first stage of the photon source described above is illustrated in

FIGS. 1A and 1B

. The embodiment of the source shown in

FIGS. 1A and 1B

has a two-gap ion acceleration structure


100


. Acceleration structure


100


includes concentric spherical electrode shells


112


,


113


and


114


. The electrode shells


112


,


113


and


114


have a plurality of sets of holes aligned along axes which pass through a central plasma discharge region


120


. Thus, for example, holes


122


,


123


and


124


in electrode shells


112


,


113


and


114


, respectively, are aligned along an axis


126


that passes through plasma discharge region


120


. Each set of holes, such as holes


122


,


123


and


124


, defines an acceleration column


128


. The spaces between electrode shells


112


,


113


and


114


constitute acceleration gaps for electrostatic acceleration of ion beams. Thus, each acceleration column has two gaps in the embodiment of

FIGS. 1A and 1B

. The embodiment of

FIGS. 1A and 1B

includes


36


acceleration columns


128


, arrayed in three sets of


12


. Thus, the acceleration structure directs


36


ion beams toward plasma discharge region


120


. However, different numbers of ion beams may be utilized within the scope of the invention.




The electrode shells


112


,


113


and


114


may be supported by insulating spacers


130


. A plenum


132


having ports


134


encloses acceleration structure


100


.




A working gas is introduced, either in a pulsed mode or continuously, through ports


134


into a space


144


behind the outermost electrode shell


114


. Some of the working gas flows down the acceleration columns


128


. When the appropriate gas density is present in the acceleration columns, a pulsed voltage may be applied between electrode shells


112


and


114


, with the polarity of electrode shell


114


being positive with respect to electrode shell


112


. In the configuration of

FIGS. 1A and 1B

, provided the appropriate gas density is present and provided that sufficient voltage is applied, a pseudospark discharge develops simultaneously in each of the acceleration columns


128


. The pseudospark discharge is characterized by the development of oppositely directed electron and ion beams that can have extremely high intensity. The ion beam exits from the negative polarity end of the acceleration column


128


at electrode shell


112


and progresses toward the central plasma discharge region


120


.




By correct adjustment of the working gas density at an exit region


146


of each of acceleration columns


128


, most of the ions can be neutralized by resonant charge exchange, so as to form a neutral beam that propagates without deflection to the plasma in plasma discharge region


120


. Those ions that are not neutralized contribute excess positive charge to each of the ion beams, causing electrons to be attracted from the nearby surface of electrode shell


112


, which is already primed as a cathode due to the breakdown into a pseudospark discharge. Thus, the neutral atoms are accompanied by a nearly charge-balanced beam plasma, including the remaining unneutralized ions and electrons. The slow ions resulting from resonant charge exchange define tracks that are favored for conduction of a high current heating pulse in the second stage of device operation, as described below. Additional details and embodiments of the astron photon source are described in the aforementioned application Ser. No. 09/815,633, which is hereby incorporated by reference.




In the second stage of device operation, the newly-formed plasma is heated and compressed, or pinched, by passage through the plasma of a pulse of electric current. A first embodiment of a star pinch photon source which incorporates both the first stage of operation, wherein beams of ions are electrostatically accelerated toward a plasma discharge region and are at least partially neutralized, and the second stage, wherein an electric current is passed through the plasma discharge region, is shown in

FIGS. 2A

and


2


B.

FIG. 2A

is a simplified cross-sectional side view of the photon source, and

FIG. 2B

is a cross-section defined by revolution of line A—A in

FIG. 2A

around axis


200


. In

FIGS. 2A and 2B

, a central cathode shell, corresponding to electrode shell


112


in

FIG. 1A

, is divided into two half shells


202


and


204


that are electrically connected to a pulse voltage source


205


. The anode shell of the photon source is divided into two half shells


212


and


214


which are electrically connected by a conductor


216


. The working gas is introduced at low pressure through ports


218


and flows through passages


220


to enter hollow anode volumes


222


within anode half shells


212


and


214


. Cathode half shells


202


and


204


are electrically isolated by insulator


225


. The cathode half shells are electrically isolated from the respective anode half shells by insulators


227


and


229


. A pulse voltage source


215


has one terminal connected to cathode half shells


202


and


204


(through the low impedance of voltage source


205


) and the other terminal connected to anode half shells


212


and


214


.




During the first phase of operation of the photon source shown in

FIGS. 2A and 2B

, a pulsed voltage V


1


from pulse voltage source


215


is applied between anode half shells


212


,


214


and cathode half shells


202


,


204


. In the absence of any applied voltage V


2


from pulse source


205


, the potential difference between cathode half shells


202


and


204


remains at zero. The combined cathode half shells are therefore pulsed negatively by voltage V


1


relative to the combined anode half shells, and a discharge develops as described above in connection with

FIGS. 1A and 1B

. Neutralized beams from this discharge pass through a plasma discharge region


224


to form a small spherical plasma. At the same time, the passage of ions and energetic neutral atoms forms ionized tracks


230


between cathode half shell


202


and plasma discharge region


224


, and ionized tracks


232


between cathode half shell


204


and plasma discharge region


224


. The ionized tracks


230


and


232


lie on the surfaces of two cones that have their vertices located at plasma discharge region


224


and provide conducting paths between cathode half shells


202


and


204


.




During the second phase of operation, a pulsed voltage V


2


from pulse voltage source


205


is applied between cathode half shells


202


and


204


. The circuit is completed by conduction through the conical configuration of ionized tracks connecting cathode half shells


202


and


204


. Thus, cathode half shells


202


and


204


constitute first and second electrodes, respectively, for application of a heating current to the plasma in plasma discharge region


224


. The current flows through the plasma in plasma discharge region


224


, heating and compressing it via the magnetic pinch effect. The plasma temperature and density rise to the point where the desired X-ray or extreme ultraviolet radiation is emitted copiously. The radiation is emitted from the photon source in conical beams


234


that are relayed to the point of use by collecting optical surfaces (not shown in FIGS.


2


A and


2


B).




The working gas pressure in the central part of the acceleration structure may be maintained in a range of about 1.0 to 100 millitorr to provide the appropriate gas density. As noted above, one suitable working gas is xenon. Other suitable working gases include, but are not limited to, hydrogen, lithium, helium, nitrogen, oxygen, neon, argon and krypton.




The ion beams may be pulsed or continuous, and the ion acceleration voltage V


1


may be from 2 kV to 20 kV, but is not limited to this range. Voltage V


1


may have a typical pulse duration of 0.1 to 10 microseconds, but may also be applied continuously. The heating voltage V


2


is applied typically within 100 nanoseconds to 10 microseconds of the initial application of voltage V


1


. The amplitude of voltage V


2


is typically in the range of 100 volts to 10 kV, and the width of this pulse typically ranges from 10 nanoseconds to 1 microsecond.




A second embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention is shown in

FIGS. 3 and 4

.

FIG. 3

is a simplified cross-sectional side view of the photon source, and

FIG. 4

is a cross-section defined by revolution of line A—A in

FIG. 3

around axis


200


. Like elements in

FIGS. 2A

,


2


B,


3


and


4


have the same reference numerals. The embodiment of

FIGS. 3 and 4

differs from the embodiment of

FIGS. 2A and 2B

by the addition of a transformer


211


for coupling pulsed electrical current from pulse voltage source


205


to cathode half shells


202


and


204


. Transformer


211


includes multiple primary windings


208


, a toroidal core


210


, which may be of non-magnetic or magnetic material, and an armature or secondary


206


, also having a toroidal configuration. Primary windings


208


are connected to pulse voltage source


205


, and secondary


206


, which may have a single turn, is connected between cathode half shells


202


and


204


.




During the first phase of operation, a pulsed voltage V


1


is applied by pulse source


215


between the anode half shells


212


,


214


and secondary winding


206


that is connected to cathode half shells


202


and


204


. In the absence of any applied voltage V


2


from pulse voltage source


205


to primary windings


208


, the electric potential between the cathode half shells


202


and


204


remains at zero. The combined cathode half shells are therefore pulsed negatively by voltage V


1


I relative to the combined anode half shells


212


and


214


, and a discharge develops as described above. The neutralized beams of this discharge pass through plasma discharge region


224


to form a small spherical plasma. At the same time, the passage of ions and energetic neutral atoms forms ionized tracks


230


and


232


as described above.




During the second phase of operation, a pulsed voltage V


2


is applied simultaneously and in parallel across all the primary windings


208


, with the result that a voltage is induced between cathode half shells


202


and


204


that are connected to opposite ends of transformer secondary


206


. The transformer secondary circuit is completed by a conduction through the ionized tracks


230


and


232


connecting cathode half shells


202


and


204


. As in the embodiment of

FIGS. 2A and 2B

, cathode half shells


202


and


204


constitute first and second electrodes, respectively, for application of a heating current to the plasma in plasma discharge region


224


. The secondary current flows through the plasma in plasma discharge region


224


, heating and compressing it via the magnetic pinch effect. As described above, the plasma temperature and density rise to the point where the desired X-ray or extreme ultraviolet radiation is emitted.




An embodiment of a system for generating photons in accordance with the invention is shown schematically in FIG.


5


. An acceleration structure


500


may correspond to the acceleration structure shown in

FIGS. 2A and 2B

, the acceleration structure shown in

FIGS. 3 and 4

, or any other acceleration structure within the scope of the present invention. In the system of

FIG. 5

, acceleration structure


500


is a modification of acceleration structure


100


shown in

FIGS. 1A and 1B

and described above. Like elements in

FIGS. 1A

,


1


B and


5


have the same reference numerals.




Acceleration structure


500


includes concentric spherical electrode shells


112


,


113


and


114


, each of which is divided by an insulator


503


into electrode half shells. A pulse voltage source


540


is connected between inner electrode half shells


112




a


and


112




b


. A pulse voltage source


530


is connected between outer electrode half shells


114




a


,


114




b


and inner electrode half shells


112




a


,


112




b.






Acceleration structure


500


is enclosed within a housing


502


that defines a discharge chamber


504


. A top aperture


140


of acceleration structure


500


is coupled through a screen


510


to a collection region


514


that is defined by an enclosure


516


. Enclosure


516


contains collection optics


518


for relaying a photon beam


150


to a remote point of use. Screen


510


constitutes a beam exit aperture which allows propagation of photons from discharge chamber


504


to collection region


514


but impedes flow of gas from discharge chamber


504


to collection region


514


.




A gas source


520


coupled to housing


502


supplies a working gas through inlets


522


and ports


134


in plenum


132


to acceleration structure


500


. A bottom aperture


142


of acceleration structure


500


is coupled to a vacuum pump


524


. An outlet


526


of vacuum pump


524


is connected to gas source


520


to form a gas recirculation system. The gas source


520


and the vacuum pump


524


are connected to housing


502


in a closed loop configuration that permits recirculation of the working gas through discharge chamber


504


. Gas source


520


may include elements for removing impurities and particulates from the working gas. The system may include a detector


550


located in collection region


514


, a control circuit


552


and a flow controller


554


for a feedback control of the rate of flow of the working gas into the discharge chamber


504


in response to a measured spectrum of the radiated photons.




In another embodiment of the vacuum pumping system (not shown), the vacuum pump is connected to enclosure


516


rather than to housing


502


. In this embodiment, gas is pumped from the central part of acceleration structure


500


through screen


510


or other beam exit aperture and then through enclosure


516


.




The system of

FIG. 5

operates with first and second phases as described above in connection with

FIGS. 2A and 2B

. In the first phase, pulse source


530


applies a pulsed voltage between inner electrode half shells


112




a


,


112




b


and outer electrode half shells


114




a


,


114




b


, causing neutralized beams to be directed toward plasma discharge region


120


. In the second stage, the plasma in discharge region


120


is heated and compressed by passage of a pulse of electric current. The neutralized beams form ionized tracks between cathode half shells


112




a


,


112




b


and plasma discharge region


120


. Application of a pulse to cathode half shells


112




a


and


112




b


by pulse source


540


causes electrical current to flow along the ionized tracks through plasma discharge region


120


. Thus, cathode half shells


112




a


and


112




b


constitute first and second electrodes, respectively, for application of a heating current to the plasma in plasma discharge region


120


. The current flows through the plasma in plasma discharge region


120


, heating and compressing it. The plasma temperature and density rise to the point where the desired X-ray or extreme ultraviolet radiation is emitted. The radiation is emitted from the acceleration structure


500


as conical photon beam


150


.




A third embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention is shown in

FIGS. 6A and 6B

. Like elements in

FIGS. 1A

,


1


B,


6


A and


6


B have the same reference numerals. The embodiment of

FIGS. 6A and 6B

differs from the structure of

FIGS. 1A and 1B

by the addition of an external electrode


600


for supplying an electrical heating current to plasma discharge region


120


. A pulse voltage source


601


is connected between inner electrode shell


112


and outer electrode shell


114


. A pulse voltage source


602


is connected between inner electrode shell


112


and external electrode


600


. Insulators


603


and


604


electrically isolate the connections to electrode shells


112


and


114


, respectively. External electrode


600


may have a cylindrical configuration and may be positioned in the bottom aperture of the acceleration structure in spaced relationship to plasma discharge region


120


.




During the first phase of operation, a pulse voltage V


3


from voltage source


601


is applied between electrode shells


112


and


114


. A discharge develops as described above, and the neutralized beams of the discharge pass through plasma discharge region


120


to form a plasma. At the same time, the passage of ions and energetic neutral atoms forms ionized tracks as described above.




During the second phase of operation, a pulse voltage V


4


from voltage source


602


is applied between external electrode


600


and electrode shell


112


. The circuit is completed by conduction through the ionized tracks connecting electrode shell


112


and plasma discharge region


120


and through a glow region


605


between plasma discharge region


120


and external electrode


600


. Thus, inner electrode shell


112


constitutes a first electrode and external electrode


600


constitutes a second electrode for application of a heating current to the plasma in plasma discharge region


120


. The current flows through the plasma in plasma discharge region


120


, heating and compressing it. The plasma temperature and density rise to the point where the desired X-ray or extreme ultraviolet radiation is emitted. The plasma tends to be elongated in the direction of external electrode


600


. The working gas extends to electrode


600


at approximately the same pressure as inside electrode shell


112


.




A fourth embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention is shown in FIG.


7


.

FIG. 7

is a simplified cross-sectional side view of the photon source. A chamber, or inner shell


700


, which may be spherical, has an electrically conducting wall and a hollow interior. Inner shell


700


may include an annular flange


702


for electrical connection and mechanical support. The photon source further includes ring electrodes


710


and


712


disposed around a source axis


714


outside inner shell


700


. Ring electrodes


710


and


712


may include flanges


716


and


718


, respectively, for electrical connection and mechanical support. Ring electrodes


710


and


712


are supported by insulators


720


and


722


, respectively. Each of ring electrodes


710


and


712


may comprise a hollow ring or toroid. Each of ring electrode


710


and ring electrode


712


has a plurality of holes


730


, and inner shell


700


has a hole


732


corresponding to each hole


730


to form hole pairs


730


,


732


. The holes


730


and


732


of each hole pair are aligned and define a plasma channel


734


that intersects a central plasma discharge region


740


. In one embodiment, each of ring electrodes


710


and


712


has


24


holes


730


spaced around axis


714


. The spaces between each of ring electrodes


710


and


712


and inner shell


700


constitute acceleration gaps for electrostatic acceleration of ion beams. Each hole pair


730


,


732


defines an ion beam source, thus providing


48


ion beam sources having plasma channels


734


intersecting plasma discharge region


740


.




The photon source shown in

FIG. 7

may be mounted in a housing, as described above in connection with FIG.


5


. The housing is filled with a working gas, for example xenon for 10-15 nanometer extreme ultraviolet emission, at low pressure, typically 1-100 millitorr. Inner shell


700


may be provided with a beam exit aperture, such as a honeycomb structure


742


comprising multiple, aligned, small bore holes having high optical transmission for a photon beam and low conductance for the working gas in order to provide near vacuum conditions for photon propagation. The honeycomb structure


742


may correspond to the screen


510


shown in FIG.


5


and described above. A photon beam


744


of extreme ultraviolet or soft X-ray radiation is emitted from inner shell


700


through honeycomb structure


742


.




A power supply


750


is connected between ring electrode


710


and inner shell


700


, and a power supply


752


is connected between ring electrode


710


and ring electrode


712


. Each of power supplies


750


and


752


is capable of providing high voltage pulses having pulse widths of 0.1-10 microseconds.




In a first phase of operation, power supply


750


applies a negative DC potential to inner shell


700


relative to ring electrodes


710


and


712


. Ring electrodes


710


and


712


remain at the same electrical potential during this phase of operation, connected through low impedance power supply


752


. Power supply


750


supplies a DC current, typically 1-100 milliamps, to maintain a discharge in all hole pairs


730


,


732


. The plasma channels


734


defined by hole pairs


730


,


732


intersect at plasma discharge region


740


. Power supply


750


is then pulsed, typically a 1-10 microsecond pulse, to a negative voltage, typically 1-20 kV, and drives an increased current, typically 1-100 amps, through the plasma channels


734


. Ions of the working gas are accelerated toward plasma discharge region


740


. During passage along plasma channels


734


, the ions experience neutralizing collisions in a resonant charge exchange process, so that the ion beams are at least partially neutralized before they enter plasma discharge region


740


to form a dense plasma.




During a second phase of operation, power supply


752


applies a high current pulse, typically 0.1-10 microseconds and 1-100 kiloamps, to ring electrodes


710


and


712


. The pulse from power supply


752


may be initiated during the pulse from power supply


750


or at most slightly after the end of the pulse from power supply


750


. Thus, power supply


752


is typically triggered about 0.1-10 microseconds after power supply


750


is triggered. The circuit is completed through plasma channels


734


. In particular, ring electrode


710


defines an upper conical array of plasma channels


734


, and ring electrode


712


defines a lower conical array of plasma channels


734


. In this embodiment, ring electrode


710


constitutes a first electrode and ring electrode


712


constitutes a second electrode for application of a heating current to the plasma in plasma discharge region


740


. The high current from power supply


752


compresses and heats the plasma in plasma discharge region


740


so that it emits extreme ultraviolet or soft X-ray photons which propagate from inner shell


700


through honeycomb structure


742


as photon beam


744


to be used in an application.




A fifth embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention is shown in FIG.


8


.

FIG. 8

is a simplified cross-sectional side view of the photon source. Like elements in

FIGS. 7 and 8

have the same reference numerals. In the embodiment of

FIG. 8

, an electrode


800


replaces ring electrode


712


used in the embodiment of FIG.


7


. Electrode


800


may be cup-shaped and may have a single hole


802


and a rod


804


for electrical connection and mechanical support. Cup electrode


800


functions as a hollow electrode and is supported by an insulator


810


. A hole


812


in inner shell


700


is aligned with hole


802


in cup electrode


800


to define a plasma channel


820


. Power supply


750


is connected between ring electrode


710


and inner shell


700


, and power supply


752


is connected between ring electrode


710


and cup electrode


800


.




In a first phase of operation, power supply


750


applies a negative DC potential to inner shell


700


relative to electrodes


710


and


800


. Electrode


800


and ring electrode


710


remain at the same potential during this phase of operation, connected through low impedance power supply


752


. Power supply


750


supplies a DC current, typically 1-100 milliamps, to maintain a discharge in all hole pairs


730


,


732


. Plasma channels


734


intersect at plasma discharge region


740


. Power supply


750


is pulsed, typically 1-10 microseconds, to a negative voltage, typically 1-20 kV, and drives an increased current, typically 1-100 amps, through hole pairs


730


,


732


and


802


,


812


. Ions of the working gas are accelerated toward plasma discharge region


740


. In passage along plasma channel


734


, the ions experience neutralizing collisions in a resonant charge exchange process, so that the ion beams are at least partially neutralized before they enter plasma discharge region


740


to form a dense plasma.




During a second phase of operation, power supply


752


applies a high current pulse, typically 0.1-10 microseconds and 1-100 kiloamps, to electrodes


710


and


800


. The circuit is completed through plasma channels


734


and


820


. In this embodiment, ring electrode


710


constitutes a first electrode and electrode


800


constitutes a second electrode for application of a heating current to the plasma in plasma discharge region


740


. This high current compresses and heats the plasma in plasma discharge region


740


so that it emits extreme ultraviolet or soft X-ray photons which propagate from inner shell


700


through honeycomb structure


742


as photon beam


744


to be used in an application.




A sixth embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention is shown in FIG.


9


.

FIG. 9

is a simplified cross-sectional side view of the photon source. Like elements in

FIGS. 7-9

have the same reference numerals. The embodiment of

FIG. 9

differs from the embodiment of

FIG. 8

by the addition of a ring electrode


900


within cup electrode


800


and a power supply


910


connected between ring electrode


900


and cup electrode


800


. The connection to ring electrode


900


is electrically isolated from chamber


700


and cup electrode


800


by an insulator


912


.




The DC discharge between cup electrode


800


and inner shell


700


can be modulated to have greater or lesser current by the application of a voltage from power supply


910


between ring electrode


900


and cup electrode


800


. When ring electrode


900


is positive with respect to cup electrode


800


, electrons are removed from the discharge and the cup electrode current is decreased or inhibited completely. When ring electrode


900


is made negative with respect to cup electrode


800


, the discharge is enhanced. In this way, the discharge from the cup electrode


800


may be balanced with the combined discharges from ring electrode


710


to inner shell


700


in spite of their different geometries. This configuration facilitates rapid electrical breakdown between external electrode


800


and ring electrode


710


during the high current phase when power supply


752


is energized. A rapid negative pulse to ring electrode


900


can assist in the initiation of the high current discharge when power supply


752


is energized. Operation of the sixth embodiment is otherwise similar to the operation of the fifth embodiment described above.




Any of the DC discharges can be controlled using electrodes, similar to ring electrode


900


, within the anode enclosures adjacent to holes


730


. This may apply, for example, in

FIG. 7

to balance the DC discharges from ring electrode


710


to inner shell


700


with respect to the DC discharges from ring electrode


712


to inner shell


700


.




A seventh embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention is shown in

FIGS. 10A and 10B

.

FIG. 10A

is a simplified cross-sectional side view of the photon source, and

FIG. 10B

is a cross-sectional top view of the photon source shown in FIG.


10


A. Like elements in

FIGS. 7-10B

have the same reference numerals. The embodiment of

FIGS. 10A and 10B

differs from the embodiment of

FIG. 8

with respect to the coupling between cup electrode


800


and inner shell


700


. Referring again to

FIG. 8

, cup electrode


800


is coupled to inner shell


700


through a relatively small diameter hole


812


. In the embodiment of

FIGS. 10A and 10B

, inner shell


700


has a relatively large diameter opening


1010


to cup electrode


800


. Opening


1010


may be in a range of about 40% to 100% of the diameter of inner shell


700


. Operation of the seventh embodiment is otherwise similar to the operation of the fifth embodiment described above.




As noted above, the working gas is ionized within hollow ring electrode


710


. In a preferred embodiment, the working gas is supplied to the interior of ring electrode


710


through a plurality of conduits


1020


in flange


716


to ensure relatively uniform distribution of the working gas within ring electrode


710


. It will be understood that similar conduits may be utilized in ring electrode


712


of FIG.


7


and in the cup electrode


800


of

FIGS. 8

,


9


and


10


A and


10


B. It will be further understood that different configurations may be utilized for supplying the working gas to the interior regions of the ion beam sources within the scope of the present invention.




An eighth embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention is shown in

FIGS. 11A and 11B

.

FIG. 11A

is a simplified cross-sectional side view of the photon source, and

FIG. 11B

is a cross-sectional top view of the photon source shown in FIG.


11


A. Like elements in

FIGS. 7-11B

have the same reference numerals. The embodiment of

FIGS. 11A and 11B

differs from the embodiment of

FIG. 8

with respect to the configuration of the second electrode and the inner shell.




In the embodiment of

FIGS. 11A and 11B

, an inner shell


1100


may be generally spherical in shape and has an opening


1102


for emission of photon beam


744


. Hollow ring electrode


710


has an annular configuration and is located outside inner shell


1100


in a plane perpendicular to source axis


714


. A second electrode


1110


having honeycomb structure


742


or other beam exit aperture is positioned over opening


1102


in inner shell


1100


. Second electrode


1110


is electrically isolated from inner shell


1100


by an insulator


1112


. First power supply


750


is connected between inner shell


1100


and ring electrode


710


, and second power supply


752


is connected between ring electrode


710


and second electrode


1110


. Photon beam


744


is emitted in a beam direction


1120


along source axis


714


.




In a first phase of operation, power supply


750


applies a negative DC potential to inner shell


1100


relative to ring electrode


710


. Power supply


750


supplies a DC current, typically 1-100 milliamps, to maintain a discharge in all hole pairs


730


,


732


. The plasma channels


734


defined by hole pairs


730


,


732


intersect at plasma discharge region


740


. Power supply


750


is then pulsed, typically a 1-10 microsecond pulse, to a negative voltage, typically 1-20 kV, and drives an increased current, typically 1-100 amps, through the plasma channels


734


. Ions of the working gas are accelerated toward plasma discharge region


740


. During passage along plasma channel


734


, the ions experience neutralizing collisions in a resonant charge exchange process and impinge on plasma discharge region


740


to form a dense plasma.




During a second phase of operation, power supply


752


applies a high current pulse, typically 0.1-10 microseconds and 1-100 kiloamps, between ring electrode


710


and second electrode


1110


. The pulse from power supply


752


may be initiated during the pulse from power supply


750


or at most slightly after the end of the pulse from power supply


750


. Thus, power supply


752


is typically triggered about 0.1-10 microseconds after power supply


750


is triggered. The circuit is completed through plasma channels


734


. In the embodiment of

FIGS. 11A and 11B

, hollow ring electrode


710


constitutes a first electrode and electrode


1110


constitutes a second electrode for application of a heating current to the plasma in plasma discharge region


740


. The high current from power supply


752


compresses and heats the plasma in plasma discharge region


740


so that it emits extreme ultraviolet or soft X-ray photons which propagate from inner shell


1100


through honeycomb structure


742


as photon beam


744


to be used in an application.




In the embodiment of

FIGS. 11A and 11B

, the anode and cathode are reversed during high current discharge relative to the embodiment of

FIGS. 10A and 10B

. This configuration keeps the output photon beam


744


pointing away from the cathode. This avoids a jet of ions that otherwise would accompany the photon beam. The anode is now the honeycomb structure


742


that the photon beam


744


passes through. An electron column


1130


may extend from plasma discharge region


740


to electrode


1110


.




A ninth embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention is shown in FIG.


12


.

FIG. 12

is a simplified cross-sectional side view of the photon source. Like elements in

FIGS. 7-12

have the same reference numerals. The embodiment of

FIG. 12

differs from the embodiment of

FIGS. 11A and 11B

by the addition of a receptacle


1230


at the lower end of inner shell


1100


for the accumulation of ions from plasma discharge region


40


. Receptacle


1230


may have any desired size and shape and may be coupled to a vacuum system, as shown in FIG.


5


and described above.




A tenth embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention is shown in FIG.


13


.

FIG. 13

is a simplified cross-sectional side view of the photon source. Like elements in

FIGS. 7-13

have the same reference numerals. The embodiment of

FIG. 13

differs from the embodiment of

FIG. 7

with respect to the configuration of the inner shell and the addition of a resistor. The photon source of

FIG. 13

includes a first inner shell portion


1300


associated with ring electrode


710


and a second inner shell portion


1302


associated with ring electrode


712


. Inner shell portions


1300


and


1302


are electrically isolated from each other by an insulator


1310


. Each of the shell portions


1300


and


1302


may include a hemispherical portion and a flange portion. Shell portion


1300


may be provided with honeycomb structure


742


or other beam exit aperture. The hemispherical portions may be mounted together and spaced apart by insulator


1310


to form a spherical inner shell.




A resistor


1320


may be connected between shell portions


1300


and


1302


. The value of resistor


1320


is selected to be high compared to the impedance of the plasma load on power supply


752


during the high current heating pulse. The purpose of resistor


1320


is to allow the shell portions


1300


and


1302


to float electrically with respect to each other during the high current pulse, but to prevent significant current from power supply


752


from bypassing the plasma through the inner shell walls.




An eleventh embodiment of a photon source in accordance with the invention is shown in FIG.


14


.

FIG. 14

is a simplified cross-sectional side view of the photon source. Like elements in

FIGS. 7-14

have the same reference numerals. The embodiment of

FIG. 14

differs from the embodiment of

FIG. 13

with respect to the configuration of the inner shell. The photon source of

FIG. 14

includes first inner shell portion


1300


associated with ring electrode


710


, second inner shell portion


1302


associated with ring electrode


712


and a third inner shell portion


1400


. The third inner shell portion


1400


includes honeycomb structure


742


or other beam exit aperture and is connected to a reference potential, such as ground.




The hot and dense plasma that is created in the star pinch apparatus described herein can also be used for the production of neutrons. Neutrons may be emitted with an energy of 2.45 MeV upon the collision of two energetic deuterium ions. The ion density within the heated plasma may exceed 10


20


ions cm


−3


for a period of the order of 10


−6


seconds. Although existing experimental data with xenon in the star pinch apparatus indicates that a plasma temperature of only 50 eV has been achieved, future improvements to the density and temperature using the same principle should allow the deuterium plasma temperature to be raised to more than 1 keV, at which level D—D fusion reactions producing 2.45 MeV neutrons begin to become very plentiful.




The production of net fusion energy requires even higher plasma temperature, in the range of 10 keV, and the use of fusion reactants such as deuterium plus tritium, D+T, which have the highest fusion reaction cross section. The D−T reaction produces 14MeV neutrons plus an energetic charged particle. Many different plasma configurations have been studied intensively in the quest for fusion energy, including several types of plasma pinch. To date it has been difficult to approach fusion densities and temperatures in any type of plasma pinch, and that is expected to also be true of the star pinch apparatus. However, the advantages that the star pinch apparatus would have relative to other types of pinch in the economical generation of fusion power are the large distance between the heated plasma and the nearest solid surface, to absorb the plasma blast wave after a pulsed fusion reaction, and the capability for long duration repetitive operation because of low erosion rates on the distributed electrode.




While there have been shown and described what are at present considered the preferred embodiments of the present invention, it will be obvious to those skilled in the art that various changes and modifications may be made therein without departing from the scope of the invention as defined by the appended claims.



Claims
  • 1. A source of photons comprising:a housing that defines a discharge chamber; a first group of ion beam sources directed toward a plasma discharge region in the discharge chamber, said first group of ion beam sources comprising a first electrode and an inner shell that at least partially encloses the plasma discharge region; a second electrode spaced from the plasma discharge region; a first power supply for energizing the first group of ion beam sources to electrostatically accelerate, from the first group of ion beam sources toward the plasma discharge region, ion beams which are at least partially neutralized before they enter the plasma discharge region; and a second power supply coupled between the first and second electrodes for delivering a heating current to the plasma discharge region, wherein the ion beams and the heating current form a hot plasma that radiates photons.
  • 2. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, wherein the ion beam sources of said first group of ion beam sources are distributed around the plasma discharge region.
  • 3. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, wherein the ion beams precede the heating current.
  • 4. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, wherein the heating current is pulsed and wherein the ion beams comprise pulsed ion beams that precede the pulsed heating current.
  • 5. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, wherein the ion beams are continuous and wherein the heating current is pulsed.
  • 6. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, wherein the ion beams are at least partially neutralized by resonant charge exchange.
  • 7. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, wherein the radiated photons are in the soft X-ray or extreme ultraviolet wavelength range.
  • 8. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, wherein the ion beams comprise xenon ions and wherein the radiated photons have wavelengths in a range of about 10-15 nanometers.
  • 9. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, wherein the ion beams comprise ions of a working gas selected from the group consisting of xenon, hydrogen, lithium, helium, nitrogen, oxygen, neon, argon and krypton.
  • 10. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, wherein said first electrode of ion beam sources comprises a first hollow ring electrode.
  • 11. A source of photons as defined in claim 10, wherein said first power supply is connected between said first hollow ring electrode and said inner shell.
  • 12. A source of photons as defined in claim 10, further comprising a second group of ion sources, said second group of ion sources comprising a second hollow ring electrode and said inner shell.
  • 13. A source of photons as defined in claim 12, wherein said first power supply has a first terminal connected to said first and second hollow ring electrodes and a second terminal connected to said inner shell.
  • 14. A source of photons as defined in claim 13, wherein said second power supply is connected between said first and second hollow ring electrodes.
  • 15. A source of photons as defined in claim 10, wherein said first hollow ring electrode and said inner shell have a plurality of hole pairs which define plasma channels from the first hollow ring electrode to the plasma discharge region.
  • 16. A source of photons as defined in claim 12, wherein said first hollow ring electrode and said inner shell have a plurality of hole pairs which define plasma channels from the first hollow ring electrode to the plasma discharge region and wherein said second hollow ring electrode and said inner shell have a plurality of hole pairs which define plasma channels from the second hollow ring electrode to the plasma discharge region.
  • 17. A source of photons as defined in claim 10, wherein said second electrode comprises a cup electrode.
  • 18. A source of photons as defined in claim 17, wherein said cup electrode is coupled to the plasma discharge region through a hole in said inner shell.
  • 19. A source of photons as defined in claim 17, further comprising a ring electrode mounted within said cup electrode and a third power supply coupled between said ring electrode and said cup electrode.
  • 20. A source of photons as defined in claim 17, wherein said cup electrode is coupled to the plasma discharge region through a relatively wide opening in the inner shell.
  • 21. A source of photons as defined in claim 12, wherein said inner shell is divided into a first shell portion corresponding to said first hollow ring electrode and a second shell portion corresponding to said second hollow ring electrode, wherein said first and second shell portions are connected by a resistor having a value that is large in comparison with the impedance of the plasma during delivery of the heating current.
  • 22. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, wherein said second electrode comprises a structure defining an aperture for emission of a photon beam from the plasma discharge region.
  • 23. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, wherein a photon beam is emitted from the plasma discharge region in a beam direction and wherein said first group of ion beam sources comprises an annular array of ion beam sources distributed around the plasma discharge region in a plane perpendicular to the beam direction.
  • 24. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, wherein said second power supply is triggered to deliver a heating current about 0.1 to 10 microseconds after said first power supply is triggered to energize said first group of ion beam sources.
  • 25. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, further comprising a gas source for supplying a working gas to the discharge chamber, wherein the working gas is ionized to form the ion beams.
  • 26. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, wherein said first and second electrodes are configured such that the heating current is conducted along the ion beams to the plasma discharge region.
  • 27. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, wherein a photon beam is emitted from the plasma discharge region in a beam direction and wherein said second electrode is spaced from the plasma discharge region in the beam direction.
  • 28. A source of photons as defined in claim 1, wherein said first group of ion beam sources comprises an inner shell that at least partially encloses the plasma discharge region, said inner shell including a shell portion having a beam exit aperture, wherein the shell portion is connected to a reference potential.
  • 29. A system for generating photons, comprising:a housing defining a discharge chamber; a first group of ion beam sources directed toward a plasma discharge region in the discharge chamber, said first group of ion beam sources comprising a first electrode and an inner shell that at least partially encloses the plasma discharge region; a second electrode spaced from the plasma discharge region; a first power supply for energizing the first group of ion beam sources to accelerate, from the first group of ion beam sources toward the plasma discharge region, beams of ions of a working gas, wherein the ions are at least partially neutralized before they enter the plasma discharge region; a second power supply coupled between the first and second electrodes for delivering a heating current to the plasma discharge region; a gas source for supplying the working gas to the discharge chamber; and a vacuum system for controlling the pressure of the working gas in the discharge chamber.
  • 30. A source of neutrons comprising:a housing that defines a discharge chamber; a first group of ion beam sources directed toward a plasma discharge region in the discharge chamber, wherein a component of said first group of ion beam sources constitutes a first electrode; a second electrode spaced from the plasma discharge region; a first power supply for energizing the first group of ion beam sources to electrostatically accelerate, from the first group of ion beam sources toward the plasma discharge region, ion beams which are at least partially neutralized before they enter the plasma discharge region; and a second power supply coupled between the first and second electrodes for delivering a heating current to the plasma discharge region, wherein the ion beams and the heating current form a hot plasma that radiates neutrons.
  • 31. A source of neutrons as defined in claim 30, further comprising a second group of ion beam sources directed toward the plasma discharge region, wherein a component of said second group of ion beam sources constitutes said second electrode.
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a continuation-in-part of application Ser. No. 09/876,469 filed Jun. 7, 2001 now U.S. Pat. No. 6,567,499 and claims the benefit of provisional application Ser. No. 60/361,118 filed Mar. 1, 2002, which are hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety.

US Referenced Citations (16)
Number Name Date Kind
3258402 Fansworth Jun 1966 A
3386883 Fansworth Jun 1968 A
3530497 Hirsch et al. Sep 1970 A
4401618 Salisbury Aug 1983 A
4682033 Martin et al. Jul 1987 A
4841556 Kato et al. Jun 1989 A
5126638 Dethlefsen Jun 1992 A
5315629 Jewell et al. May 1994 A
5502356 McGeoch Mar 1996 A
5504795 McGeoch Apr 1996 A
5577092 Kublak et al. Nov 1996 A
6075838 McGeoch Jun 2000 A
6188746 Miley et al. Feb 2001 B1
6324255 Kondo et al. Nov 2001 B1
6327338 Golovanivsky et al. Dec 2001 B1
6504903 Kondo et al. Jan 2003 B1
Foreign Referenced Citations (2)
Number Date Country
WO 9530235 Nov 1995 WO
WO 0191523 Nov 2001 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (4)
Entry
Malcolm W. McGeoch, “Radio Frequency Pre-ionized Xenon Z-Pinch Source for Extreme Ultraviolet Lithography”, Applied Optics, 1998, pp. 1651-1658.
B.I. Kikiani et al, “Resonance Charge Exchange of Inert-Gas Ions in the Energy Range 200-4000eV”, Amer. Inst. of Physics, Sov. Phys. Tech. Phys., vol. 20, No. 3, 1975, pp. 364-367.
K.K. Jain et al, “Repetitive High Current Density Pseudospark-Produced Ion Beams”, Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 62, No. 13, Mar. 29, 1993, pp. 1466-1468.
J. Christiansen et al, “Production of High Current Particle Beams by Low Pressure Spark Discharge”, Zeitschrift fur Physik A, 290, pp. 35-41, 1979.
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
60/361118 Mar 2002 US
Continuation in Parts (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 09/876469 Jun 2001 US
Child 10/165998 US